Comparison Between Various Manu

Sr. No
Description ABB ABB
1 Model ACS 1000 ACS 5000
2 No. of Pulses 12 Pulse 12 Pulse

3 Ambient temprature 50 Deg C

Medium Voltage Component
4 Technology Based-IGCT Based
5 Fuses Fuseless
No of components 12 Nos.of IGCTs & 2 Nos.
6 in Inverter Section Capacitors.
Very High- Since number of
7 Reliability components are very less
Power factor- 0.95 across the
8 Power Factor speed range
Medium Voltage Component Based-IGCT
Based
Fuseless
12 Nos.of IGCTs & 2 Nos. Capacitors.
Very High- Since number of components
are very less
Power factor- 0.95 across the speed range

Separate transformer Indian

9 Input Transformer make. Separate transformer Indian make.
Efficiency High >98.0% at full Efficiency High 98.5% at full load and rated
10 Efficiency of Drive load and rated speed speed
Not applicable. (Not Required
Because IGCT has the very high Not applicable. (Not Required Because
11 Cell bypass feature reliability.) IGCT has the very high reliability.)
Current THD Line
12 Side As per IEEE 519-1992 Std. As per IEEE-519 Std.
Very Good presence- ABB has sold more
13 Presence in India then 300 Drives in India.
Compatibility with
14 Other Motors Yes Yes
Market share in
15 India 75%
16 Manufacturing Turgi, Switzerland Turgi, Switzerland
een Various Manufacturer

Siemens Yantra Harvest

Perfect Harmony Harsvert-A11/070 1000 KW
36 Pulse 54 Pulse

40 Deg C 45 Deg C

MultiCell- Low Voltage IGBT based MultiCell- Low Voltage IGBT based IGBT PWM
54 Fuses 54 Fuses

360-LV IGBT, 288 Capacitors 360-LV IGBT, 288 Capacitors

Less - Since number of components are very
high Less - Since number of components are very high

Power factor- 0.95 across the speed range Power factor- 0.95 across the speed range

Inbuilt Transfomer. Additional air-conditioning Inbuilt Transfomer. Additional air-conditioning is

is required for Transformer cooling. required for Transformer cooling.
Efficiency 98.0% because of Integrated High efficiency of 96% ( including input
transformer at full load and rated speed transformer )

(Optional) Mandatory otherwise reliability of (Optianal) Mandatory otherwise reliability of Drive

Drive will be very very poor. will be very very poor.

As per IEEE-519 Std. IEEE 519-1992 ( 54 Pulse rectifier system )

World wide 3000 Installation Rare presence

Yes Yes

15% 10%
China China