Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
The Power
Of
Brand idenfication
Table of Content
1. Introduction.........................................................................................
4. Critique.................................................................................................
6. References.............................................................................................
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
Introduction
Brand identification can be considered as, when consumer aware of the brands, when
it can relate certain products or service that identify what the brands as. Most of the markets
brand is comparing national brand, multinational brands or local brands to identify the value
to consumers. From the past researches that acknowledge national’s brands are related with
consumer ethnocentric identity and value expressive influences. But the further research for
this argued that social identities are also would effect. Without brand identification, company
hardly energize the sales force. There are three articles that similar with this topic that are
Theory is a formal logical explanation of some event that includes predictions of how things relate to
one another.
Variables defined as anything that varies or changes from one distance to another and can exhibit
Researcher control of Variables is a variable which is held constant in a research by observing only
(i) Exploratory studies are usually a small scale research undertaken not defines the
(ii) Descriptive studies are typically to study the variable and are quantitative. It can
(iii) Causal Studies are with study how variable affects, or is responsible for, changes
in another variable.
(ii) Observation methods are stated as the systematic process of recording the
Research Environment can be virtual or non virtual that a process, a tool or a system interoperating
to facilitate and enhance the research process within or without an institutional boundaries.
Time Dimension
population are sampled and data are collected at a single moment in time.
times, thus allowing analysis of response continuity and changes over time.
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
Summary
Article 1
Due to the research of putting the relationship between consumer ethnocentric identity
and value expression influence with social identities, the preferences of consumer for
national’s brands will be affected largely. Therefore, the purpose of this research is to
investigate the social identities and influences through self-categorisation theory and nation
branding which trying to unpin consumer preferences for national brand. From the previous
studies that consumer ethnocentric identity (CEI) did not influences the brand preferences.
By adding the prediction of CEI, It will relate brand identity with consumers’ preferences
over local brands. Self-categorisation theory defined as the consumers’ identity with social
group that reflect consumer preferences for national brands. Yet, they also used similar
concept with social psychology concept. That is, instead of multi-items measure, they used it
only single-items measure into this study that would avoid psychometric problem and
increase predictive efficiency. There are similar variables of hypothesis that put into three
parts. In the first two hypothesis, both consumer ethnocentric identity(CEI) as independent
variable(IV) that make preference for a nation’s brand as dependent variable(DV). But
second hypothesize that strengthen the relationship in the gaining of age. Value-expressive
identity (VEI) tested as IV while preference of consumers for national brand as DV in the
third and forth hypothesise. Same as the second hypothesise that age would strengthen these
relationships as well. The last two hypothesises are important that related with social
influences as DV that effect CEI as the IV. It is positively for injunctive influence as well as
descriptive influences. There IV cannot be control as measurement but can through their
ethnocentric identity by using trained interviewers to week for potential customers to frame
down the age rage when conducting survey. This has been taken as exploratory studies that
clarify ambiguous situations such as this study using experience survey through
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
each relevant identity to another. A survey was done from the company MOZAMBIQUE
questionnaire to know their perception of social identity, preference for mobile service
provider, and social influences. This survey only conducted once in three shopping centre in
much of consumers’ VEI but it did affect to CEI. Adversely, injunctive social influence
highly in younger age than older age range of consumer. The further research for this study is
to continue exploring the role of identity of youth preferences for national brand that can be
use for developing country such as South Africa. Comparing the underdeveloped with
developed markets in area, this would able to know the strength social influences on brand
preferences in order to informed in better in these market at least access to the internet.
Besides, the researcher didn’t restrict the targeted audience that can lose sales from that.
There’s also unable to collect mass sample of citizens exerts pressure on individuals to be
pro-national and anti-foreign. Researchers less focus on youth group of audiences are
susceptibility to social pressure and didn’t identify a direct relationship with CEI and VEI in
value-expressiveness.
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
Article 2
The purpose for this research is to investigate how are the brand personality of a
sports team will be related to consumer outcomes of indemnification and retail spending.
From the previous research, the researcher suggested single-items indicators for simplicity,
easy to use and increase face validity and flexibility. Exploratory or empirical research has
not been done for brand personality and brand indemnification in consumer-brand
relationship. This research using social identity theory in a sports context to predict retail
spending and the number of games watched. Asker’s brand personality also model for
characteristic of a sports team. First and second hypothesis both have positive causal
Under team cognitive identification (TCI) of third and forth hypothesises, prestige and
distinctiveness as DV both positively causal with TCI. Besides, team cognition identification
as IV has also has positive causal relationship with the number of games and so do the team-
related retail spending influences to be DV. All hypotheses are relational to each other from
that from brand personality to prestige and distinctiveness of team been manipulated as well.
Join membership for the team been enhanced through controlled over from team cognitive
identification. After the whole research, this has been exploratory studies conducted to clarify
ambiguous situations or discover ideas that maybe potential business opportunities using
experimental design that able to control over the variable. 162 students that have interest with
the sport take into this research as their primary data collection by doing a survey in
questionnaires to capture the respondents’ evaluation of brand personality, team prestige and
distinctiveness for seven years. There’s no exact physical place for students to do in this
survey but they have been observed in a way that able to access to premier facility and long
history success. Longitudinal studies in this research that used through brand personality,
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
prestige and distinctiveness. Other than this, only second hypothesis were partially supported
and others hypothesis were fully supported as proved after the analysis. Though, there’s
negative influence to distinctiveness in success. Additional, both female and male involves
cognitive identification with teams may be useful for understanding this relationship.
Conceptual model may find different facets of brand personality that are significant
predictors of prestige and distinctiveness for different teams and different sports. The next
expectation will be similar to the relationship by developing additional studies that further
explore consumer relationship with retail brands in multiple contexts. The researcher didn’t
restrict the targeted audience that lose sales from that. Due to unable to collect mass sample
of citizens exerts pressure on individuals to be pro-national and anti-foreign. They are less
focus on youth group of audiences are susceptibility to social pressure. From the hypothesis,
Article 3
The purpose of this paper is to identify the key features of identity standards manual and
assess the differences in the rules used for applying the brand to both low- and high-context
cultures, companies selling consumer goods and those selling services, and multinational and
local companies. First hypothesis has identity standards manual history, concept and
dimensions and defined by the five dimensions in the first part of first hypothesises and
divided into core and peripheral dimensions. Setting rules for applying the brand, differences
between low- and high-context cultures as the “presentation” section will have a higher
profile in manuals of low-context cultures than in manuals of high-context cultures ever since
the first part for second hypothesis. The graphic aspects of the brand such as symbol and
logotype will have a greater presence in manuals of high-context cultures whereas the textual
aspect of the brand name will have a greater presence in manuals of low-context cultures due
context communication gives more importance to textual elements. Rules for use of the brand
referring to decorative elements such as corporate tiled pattern, and per graphic will have a
communication be the third part of this hypothesis. The manuals of low-context cultures will
include more rules and consequently will have a more rigid tone than manuals of high-
context cultures while low-context cultures tend to be more legalistic and based on written
rules. Nevertheless, low-context cultures will have less-developed manuals due to their
preference for direct language and fast messages that high-context cultures will have more
complex manuals when their preference for indirect, elaborate language and slow messages
for the last part of second hypothesises. The other rules is for applying the brand: differences
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
between companies offering consumer offering services that they have dimension
“applications of brand.” has the greatest difference in contents between the manuals of
tangible goods companies and service companies. The service providers’ manuals will also
have a more rigid normative tone than tangible goods companies’ manuals. Then, service
providers will tend to use simple manuals while product-based companies will tend to have
more complex manuals. For the last hypothesis, the different between multinational and local
companies, in the sections on “architecture” and “signage”, the contents of the identity
standards manuals of multinational companies will vary from those of local companies in the
companies will have a more rigid normative tone than those of local companies. It will tend
to be more complex than those of local companies if it’s the identity standards manuals of
multinational companies. The first hypothesise are descriptive relationship that dimension
were divided into two. Second hypothesises will be causal relationship because the greater
one side of context culture will be as independent variable (IV), greater the other side of
context culture would be dependent variable (DV) and they would compare which is higher.
As for the third hypothesises are also descriptive relationship but two variables are in contra.
Multinational companies are different from local companies that these researches hypothesise
in certain section or complexity would be varying for each other but not directly influence.
Among the companies neither the product-based company nor based on product that would
able to control. The second hypothesis will be controlled by the independent variable with
independent variable would only changes accordingly. This research take design into
exploratory to define exact nature of the problem between multinational company and local
company and to gain better understanding of the environment within which problem has
occur. At first, it start with they consulted with three different website to observe why and
how to design and came out with 341 manuals in few features for the manuals. The design
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
rules should be convey in the same coherent, reinforce he coordinated image and enhance the
company’s communication with the public. It will not be limited the verbal and graphic signs
but to lay down the rules for their use and convey the documents. The literature research
followed by experience, then through Projective technique to estimate each section in each
dimension. They are using secondary data as data collection method to estimate the entire
related variable such as context culture, product influence. It’s also due to have some
empirical research has done in the past to help for the resources to analyse more in brand
identity. The cluster analysis method was also used in hierarchical mode to distribute the 39
variables studied into those dimensions. They doing survey or 106 studio for work in the area
of visual identity, It depends on which hypothesis of research according to make use of the
research environment. When consulting the web page are not necessary to find a physical
place than just look for the person in charge of the web page and analyse with it. The survey
was conducted in the studio where the respondents work. They on take as cross-sectional
dimension that all the measurement, analysis and survey were done in once in a short period
of time due to exploratory research design. The results divide the contents of the manual into
two blocks into core and peripheral the predictions are accepted.
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
Critique
Article 1
Although they are using communication method to conduct survey that is faster than
observation but it will rush the result as the result might not be accurate. This is also might
not have as quality survey as the proper period of time to get responds but due to the time
period can save cost. Besides, cross-sectional dimension that conduct only one time also will
be not that accurate to get the result. Yet, this research has been improved as in they put in
different ages into the variable different that some has affect the only two variable. Even
interview survey would have non sampling error as the age of respondents cannot be control
Article 2
In this research, they only explore the research as using several empirical researches into
students and observing for 7 year. It has taken too many times and cost to conduct as well as
might change the interest of sport and lifestyle would affect the perception in brand
preference. Age also can be one of the issue that change the purchasing the brand according
to standard of living. The researchers are still unable to find a direct relationship between
CEI and VEI. Most of the hypothesis were not supported that they didn’t identify whether
there’s third variable to proof that CEI and VEI is the main relationship to influence the brand
preferences. Team cognitive identity also has not been test to influence the sport sales.
Membership is a good way to hold consumers on purchasing same brand as either brand
Articles 3
Using their own concept to make this research as that they are a lot of hypothesis that are not
support as they looking at the issue for brand identification. There appear to be having non-
response error that the amount survey required were less and or not accurate to the report.
The time is also be the issue that cross-sectional dimension would not meet the accurate data
needed. The communication method is another issue that the interviewers would influence
Research Objectives Theory/Framework Hypotheses Tested Variables Included (in each hypothesis) Researcher Control of Type of Research
Used to Develop the and the nature of the variables Variables Design Used
Hypotheses
Investigating the social There is using Consumer ethnocentric identity Consumer ethnocentric The researcher Exploratory
identities and influences self-categorisation The increase level of a person’s identity(CEI) controlled over a Studies is defined
through nation branding theory to know consumer ethnocentric identity related A person’s consumer ethnocentric person’s consumer as conducted to
which unpin consumer consumers’ to the increasing level of their identity as independent variable that ethnocentric identity clarify ambiguous
preferences for national identity with preference for a national brand over make their preference for a national to make preference situations or
brand is the purpose of this social group will foreign brand positively be as the first brand over a foreign brand as the for consumer for discover ideas that
research. be reflected with hypothesis, dependant variable nation brand over maybe potential
consumer Second hypothesis use the higher age foreign brand. business
From the previous studies preferences for of consumers that strengthen the The second hypothesis exist with opportunities.
that consumer ethnocentric national brands. relationship between consumer moderating variable as the age would These variables
identity (CEI) did not ethnocentric identity and preference affect the relationship between control through their After the
influences the brand It also have its for a national brand. independent variable of consumer behaviour of their whole research,
preferences. By adding the own concept that ethnocentric identity and dependent ethnocentric identity this has been
prediction of CEI that similar with social Value-expressive identity(VEI) variable of their preference for a to manipulate the exploratory
related to brand identity to psychology Another hypothesis stated to increase national brand. results such as trained studies using
for consumers preferences concepts that preference for a national brand over a interviewers could experiences
over local brands. instead of multi- foreign brand with a higher of a Value-expressive identity(VEI) seek for potential survey in
items measure that person’s value expressive identity. A person’s value expressive consumers in certain conducting
measure with Again, the higher age of consumers identity as Independent variable effect of age rage to questionnaire for
single-items that strengthens the relationship dependent variable in preference for a strengthen the the respondents.
measure put into between value expressive identity and national brand for the third hypothesis. relationship.
this study. preference for national brand. Age also become moderating It also has had causal
variable for strengthen relationship for research that allow
This has been as Social influences(SI) independent variable of value causal inferences to
to avoid the The hypothesis predicts that expressive identity and preference for a be made and seeks to
psychometric consumer ethnocentric identity and national brand in this hypothesis. identify cause-and-
problem and injunctive influence have positive effect relationship
increase predictive relationship. Social influences(SI) that each relevant
efficiency. The last hypothesis stated consumer Under social influence that identity to another.
ethnocentric identity also has positive consumer ethnocentric identity is
relationship with descriptive independent variable that injunctive
influence. influence as dependent variable.
While consumer ethnocentric
All hypothesis above are relational identity remaining as independent
that for each influences influent one variable that affects descriptive
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
satisfaction with
ethnocentric or
value-
expressiveness.
Research Objectives Theory/Framework Used Hypotheses Tested Variables Included (in each Researcher Control of Type of Research Design Used
to Develop the hypothesis) and the nature of the Variables
Hypotheses variables
The purpose for this Social Identity theory in There are six hypothesises this Brand personality from Brand personalities Exploratory Studies is
research is to investigate a sports context to research. the first hypothesis is manipulated as defined as conducted to
how are the brand predict retail spending Brand personality independent variable (IV) that controlled variable to clarify ambiguous
personality of a sports and the number of The first hypothesis is positive would affect prestige as enhance prestige and situations or discover ideas
team will be related to games watched. causal relationship between dependent variable (DV). distinctiveness, that maybe potential
consumer outcomes of brand personality and business opportunities.
indemnification and retail Aaker’s brand prestige. Same for second In order to create
spending. personality model for It also hypothesize that brand hypothesis that brand awareness to customer After the whole
characteristic of a personality and distinctiveness personality as IV that affect in stronger identification research, this has been
From the previous
sports team. have positive causal distinctiveness of the team as that from brand exploratory studies using
research, the researcher
relationship. DV. personality to prestige experimental design that
suggested single-items
and distinctiveness of able to control over the
indicators for simplicity,
Team cognitive identification Another hypothesis team been manipulated variable.
easy to use and increase
Prestige and team cognitive stated that prestige then be as well.
facia validity and
identification will be third IV when team cognition
flexibility.
hypothesis that will be identification as the DV. Join membership for the
positive causal relationship. team been enhanced
This is research has not
Team cognitive identification Distinctiveness for the through controlled over
done any exploratory or
positively affected by fourth hypothesis as IV that from team cognitive
empirical research yet for
distinctiveness in forth affect team cognitive identification.
brand personality and
hypothesis. identification as DV.
brand indemnification in
The fifth hypothesis stated to
consumer-brand
use the number of games According to the fifth
relationship.
positively affected by team hypothesis for team cognitive
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
Data Collection Method Research Environment Time Dimension Findings Future Research Directions Limitations of the Study
Through observation There’s no exact Longitudinal studies in this Only second hypothesis Antecedents of The researcher didn’t
method, there’s a sample physical place for research that used through were partially supported and cognitive identification restrict the targeted
of students that related respondents to do in brand personality, prestige others hypothesis were fully with teams may be audience that loose sales
interest with the sport this survey but they and distinctiveness. supported as proved after the useful for understanding from that.
take into this research as have been observed analysis, this relationship.
their primary data in a way that able to They also unable to
collection by doing a access to premier Both team prestige and Conceptual model collect mass sample of
survey in questionnaires facility and a long distinctiveness influences may find different facets citizens exerts pressure on
to capture the history success. brand personality. of brand personality individuals to be pro-
respondents’ evaluation of that are significant national and anti-foreign.
brand personality, team predictors of prestige
prestige and Although, there’s negative and distinctiveness for They are less focus
distinctiveness for seven influence to distinctiveness in different teams and on youth group of
years success. different sports. audiences are
susceptibility to social
Additional that both The next pressure.
prestige and distinctiveness expectation will be
influenced by non-significant similar to the From the hypothesis,
of charm as from both female relationship by it didn’t identify a direct
and male. developing additional relationship with CEI and
studies that further VEI.
explore consumer
relationship with retail
brands in multiple
contexts.
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
Research Objectives Theory/Framework Hypotheses Tested Variables Included (in each Researcher Control Type of Research
Used to Develop the hypothesis) and the nature of of Variables Design Used
Hypotheses the variables
The purpose of There is no theory or First hypothesise: The first hypothesise are Among the This research take
this paper is to concept in this Identity standards manual history, concept and descriptive relationship that companies design into
identify the key research to study for dimensions dimension were divided into neither the exploratory to
features of identity the hypothesis. The content s of an identity standard manual defined two. product-based define exact nature
standards manual by the five dimensions in the first part of first company nor of the problem
and assess the hypothesises. Second hypothesises will be based on between
differences in the The second part for this hypothesises is divided the causal relationship because product that multinational
rules used for five dimensions into core and peripheral dimensions. the greater one side of would able to company and local
context culture will be as control. company and to
applying the brand
Second hypothesises: independent variable (IV), gain better
to both low- and
Rules for applying the brand : differences between low- greater the other side of The second understanding of
high-context context culture would be
and high-context cultures hypothesis will the environment
cultures, companies dependent variable (DV) within which
The “presentation” section will have a higher profile in be controlled by
selling consumer and they would compare the independent problem has occur.
goods and those manuals of low-context cultures than in manuals of
high-context cultures ever since low-context which is higher. variable with
selling services, and independent At first, it start with
communication is reinforced by preliminaries to
multinational and As for the third hypothesises variable would they consulted with
contextualise the receiver.
local companies.
The graphic aspects of the brand (symbol and are also descriptive only changes three different
logotype) will have a greater presence in manuals of relationship but two accordingly. website to observe
high-context cultures whereas the textual aspect of the variables are in contra. why and how to
brand (name) will have a greater presence in manuals design and came
of low-context cultures due to high-context Multinational companies are out with 341
communication gives more importance to non-verbal different from local manuals in few
elements whereas low-context communication gives companies that these features for the
more importance to textual elements. researches hypothesise in manuals.
Rules for use of the brand referring to decorative certain section or
elements (e.g. secondary typefaces, secondary colours, complexity would be The literature
corporate tiled pattern, and per graphic) will have a varying for each other but research then with
higher profile in manuals of high-context cultures than not directly influence. experience survey.
in manuals of low-context cultures when ambiguous, It also proof
indirect, and elaborate messages are characteristic of through Projective
high-context communication. technique to
The manuals of low-context cultures will include more estimate each
rules and consequently will have a more rigid tone section in each
than manuals of high-context cultures while low- dimension.
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
Third Hypothesise:
Rules for applying the brand : differences between
companies offering consumer offering services
The dimension “applications of brand.” has the
greatest difference in contents between the manuals of
tangible goods companies and service companies.
Service providers’ manuals will have a more rigid
normative tone than tangible goods companies’
manuals.
Service providers will tend to use simple manuals
while product-based companies will tend to have more
complex manuals.
Forth Hypothesise:
Rules for applying the brand different between
multinational and local companies.
In the sections on “architecture” and “signage”, the
contents of the identity standards manuals of
multinational companies will vary from those of local
companies in the dimension “applications of brand”.
The identity standards manuals of multinational
companies will have a more rigid normative tone than
those of local companies.
It will tend to be more complex than those of local
companies if it’s the identity standards manuals of
multinational companies.
Data Collection Method Research Environment Time Dimension Findings Future Research Limitations of the
Directions Study
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
They are using It depends on which They on take as cross-sectional dimension that all The results divide the The design rules The number of tests
secondary data as hypothesis of the measurement, analysis and survey were done in once contents of the manual into should be we undertook that
data collection research according to in a short period of time due to exploratory research two blocks into core and convey in the would have had
method to estimate make use of the design. peripheral the predictions same coherent, error. Limitation of
the entire related research are accepted. reinforce he study to a
variable such as environment. coordinated description of
context culture, Although, there are image and manuals and to
product influence. When consulting the differences between the enhance the collating opinions
web page are not manuals of high- and low- company’s from experts in the
It‘s also due to necessary to find a context cultures in term with communication sector.
have some empirical physical place than language and rigid tine was with the public.
research has done in just look for the not identified. It will not be
the past to help for person in charge of limited the
the resources to the web page and Companies that sell verbal and
analyse more in analyse with it. consumer goods and those graphic signs
brand identity. The selling services, and but to lay down
cluster analysis The survey was multinational and local the rules for
method was also conducted in the companies were no their use and
used in hierarchical studio where the significant different or convey the
mode to distribute respondents work. changes toward another. documents.
the 39 variables By measuring
studied into those coherence in use
dimensions. to improve and
enhance a
They doing consistent
survey or 106 studio application of
for work in the area the brand. ,
of visual identity, Therefore, we
should
Observed some
statistical
differences
when there were
none.
Rbus 2900 business research method assignment 1
References
Lee, J. & Thorson, E. 2008, "Energising the Reseller's Sales Force: The Power of Brand
Identification," Journal of Marketing, 74(4), 81-96.
Lee, Richard; Klobas, Jane; Tezinde, Tito; Murphy, Jamie, 2010, International Marketing
Review, 2010, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p450-465, 16 (Article 1: The underlying social identities
Of a nation’s brand)
Carlson, Brad D.; Donavan, D. Todd; Cumiskey, Kevin J. 2009, International Journal of
Retail & Distribution Management, , Vol. 37 Issue 4, p370-384, 15p( Article 2 : Consumer-
brand relationships in sport: brand personality and identification)