119

..

.., 2006

4
2006

:
. , , . , . ,
, , , .
, , . , , ,
(The
Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems, Bank for International Settlements) , .
()
.
, . .
, ,
. , .
, .
, , (A glossary of terms used in payments and
settlement systems [12]), .
(payment system) ,
, , , .
(settlement system) , (.. / ).
(transfer system) , (interbank funds transfer systems) ,
(exchange-for-value systems).

, ,

2006

120

..
(interbank funds transfer system)
, ( ) ( ).
(funds transfer system) , , , , ,
.
, , . , .
, , .


.
,
(-), -, . . , ( ), . , , , ,
.
(gross settlement) ,
.
.
- (net settlement) , .
- ,
-, .
(clearing) , , , ,
(-).
- (net position)
,
, ,

.
-, -.
- .
(real-time),
(batch).
-
.
- -
(bilateral) (multilateral) .
(hybrid system), -

, .. ()
.

2
4
2006

, .
.
(, )
, ,
, .
, ,
.
, .
,
,
.
, .
, , .
. , ,
[5].
,
. . ,
. , , .. .
, , .
, ,
1.
, . , , . , , . , ,
, .
, ,
, ,
, ,
.

121

2006

122

..
, ..
.
, : (R) , (x). , . ,
,
,
. ,
.
2005 . ,
(General guidance for
payment system development [9]),
2006 . (General guidance for national payment system development).
14 ,
, .
.
. ,
, .
, ,
,
. , ,
, .
, . , - - :
;
;
;
.

, , . .
.
, , ,
. , , :
, , , , .
, ,
, ,
.
, . . -

(1)

, , . , (A, B) = 1,
.
,
- .
,
.
- .
, - :
R

Ri ( X i , Yi ) .

(2)

i 1

: Ri (Xi, Yi) = Si Ei(Xi, Yi), i = 1, 2, ..., n , -, :

2

, .
, , .
,
.

. , , .

4
2006

R (X, Y) = SX,Y E(X, Y).

. . ( ) [14]. ,
.
-
, , , : ,
( ) .
2 - . 3,
. - , .

, - - ().
m u m, , X, , Y, , , -.
- E(X, Y), ,
, E(X, Y) = 1. ,
E(I, J) = 0 I z X J z Y.
- - .

123

124

..

S Ei ( X i , Yi ) ,
i 1 i

(3)

Si (i = 1, 2, , n).
(3) -
, :
, , .
-
( -), .
:

2006

Sx , y E ( X , Y ) ,

(4)

X ,Y

:
SX, Y (X, Y ).
(4) -
,
: ,
. (3) (4) .
R , Rc = (R)c
, , .. ,

R.
'R :
'R = R Rc.

(5)

(5) - .
'R ,
:
1. 'R . , 'R(X, Y)
X Y ,
'R(Y, X), , : 'R(X, Y) = 'R(Y, X), X, Y
, : 'R(Y, X) = R(X, Y). , 'R
.
2. ,
: 'R(X, Y) = 0,
X, Y . , .
e. r = R e R r ( ), rc = Rc e
r ( ).
r = R e.

(6)

(7)
r = Rc e.

:
(8)
'r = 'R e.

, t1t2 ,
( A, B, C, D, E),
:
;
;
;
.

R

Si E i ( X i , Yi ) ,

i 1

, , , -
4

, , (http://bankir.ru/analytics/classic/r/).

2
4
2006

(8) - . (5), (6) (7).

,
, , . - , .
,
, :
1) ;
2)
;
3)

, - 4.

. ,
. , .
, , , - . ,
, .
, .

125

126

..
(t1t2).
:
Rt1t2 = 80E(, B) + 100E(, C) + 90E(, D) + 10E(, ) + 70E(B, A) + 50E(B, C) +
+ 40E(B, D) + 100E(B, ) + 30E(C, A) + 40E(C, B) + 80E(C, D) + 20E(C, E) + 100E(D, A) +
+ 110E(D, B) + 70E(D, C) + 130E(D, E) + 190E(E, A) + 10E(E, B) + 170E(E, C) +
+ 30E(E, D) + 90E(A, B) + 70E(D, C) + 80E(B, D).
, A, D B
B, C D. ,

R

Sx , y E( X , Y )
X ,Y

2006

- :
Rt1t2 = 170E(, B) + 100E(, C) + 90E(, D) + 10E(, ) + 70E(B, A) + 50E(B, C) +
+ 120E(B, D) + 100E(B, ) + 30E(C, A) + 40E(C, B) + 80E(C, D) + 20E(C, E) +
+ 100E(D, A) + 110E(D, B) + 140E(D, C) + 130E(D, E) + 190E(E, A) + 10E(E, B) +
+ 170E(E, C) + 30E(E, D),
:

'Rt 1 t 2

B
C
D
E
/ A
A

0
170
100
90
10

B
70
0
50 120 100

.
30 40
0
80 20
C
D
100 110 140 0 130

190 10 170 30
0
E

'R = R Rc
, .
:
B
C
D
E / A
B
C
D
E
/ A
A
A

0
170
100
90
10
0
70
30
100
190

B
70
0
50 120 100 B
170 0 40 110 10
'Rt 1 t 2


30 40
0
80 20 C
100 50 0 140 170
C
D
100 110 140 0 130 D
90 120 80 0
30

190 10 170 30
0 E
10 100 20 130 0
E
A
B
C
D
E

A
0
100 70 10 180

B
100 0
10
10
90

70 10 0
60 150
C
D
10
0
100
10 60

180 90 150 100

0
E
,

'r = 'R e,

127

:
A

A
0

B
100
'rt 1 t 2
70
C
D
10

180
E

B
100
0
10

C
70
10
0

D
10
10
60

E
180 1
90 1

150 1
0
100 1
10 60

0 1
90 150 100

6
20

10

.
290
160

140

4
2006

1. : // . 2003. 64.
2. : Realtime gross settlement systems, , 1997 . // http://www.bis.org/cpss.
3. :
Clearing and settlement arrangements for retail payments in selected countries, ,
2000 . // http://www.bis.org/cpss.
4. : Report on netting schemes, , 1989 . // http://www.bis.org/cpss.
5.
() // . 2002. 1819.
6. .., .. . // . 2003. 2.
7. .. . /: , 1996.
8. .., .. (, - ). /: , 2002. (http://gaap.ru/biblio/gaap-ias/
msfo/book.pdf).
9. : General guidance for payment system development, , 2005 . // http://
www.bis.org/cpss.
10. .. // . 2005. 1.
11. . : 2 . .: , 1994.
12. , :
A glossary of terms used in payments and settlement systems, , 2003 . // http://
www.bis.org/cpss.
13. .. ( ) // . 2005. 11.
14. Sheppard D. Payment Systems. Handbooks in Central Banking / Issued by the Centre for Central
Banking Studies, Bank of England, May 1996. (http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/education/ccbs/
handbooks/ccbshb08.htm).