You are on page 1of 10

598

Stratum plus, 2, 2001-2002

..

Ya.P. Gershkovich. Paradoxes in the historiography of the Sabatinovka culture.


The studying of the Sabatinovka culture is accompanied with a long and continuous succession of contradictions.
In the 20-s years V.A. Gorodtsov marked an originality of the North Pontic antiquities and allocated here the
Cimmerian culture distinct from the Srubnaya culture. The metal artifacts of the Late Bronze Age were included in
the former. In the 30-40-s years the sites of this period including Sabatinovka settlement were referred also to it.
These conclusions were not completely taken into consideration by O.A. Krivtsova-Grakova - she has allocated
the Sabatinovka stage of the Srubnaya culture. There were not bases for such correlations, but her conclusion
was accepted. As a matter of fact such an inference have deprived the Sabatinovka culture its own historiography.
The negative results of this event are visible so far. They are reflected both in the chronological and historical
interpretations of the Sabatinovka culture as a whole as well as concern an estimation of metalworking of the Late
Bronze Age in the North Pontic area.


, , , , ,
. .. , ,
,
,

, (
1996: 44).
:
,
. ,
, ,
. , ,
,
, .

I ., .. , 2001-2002.

,
, .
.
.. ( 1908: 141), ..
, , ( 1903: 92-157).
, , , . . : ... , , , ,
,
. , , ( ..),
(Tallgren
1926: 16).

.. . ,
, -

, - ,
,
,
( 1927: 625). , ,
,
, . .. ,
,

, , , ,
,

( 1928: 50).
, , , , , , ,
,
.
..

.. ( 1976: 9).
, , ,
. , .. ,
, , . , ,
,
.
20- 30- . ..
, , , ,
.
,
( 1925: 78-79).
.
,

599

(Nestor 1933: 116-118).


, , ,
.. ,

, ,
(
1985: 4).

. .. . , -
, :
... ,
,
, , ( ..),

( 1952: 87).
(, , . . , ,
), :
( 1949:
199).
.. ( 1952).
, ,
.
, .
, ,
( 1991: 128).
: , . . ,
,
. ,
.. .
, , ,
.. -.
,

600

, (, ) .
. ,
.. -,
, .
.
.. -, , , (- 1955: 5-7 .).
,
, , .

.. , ,
- (- 1955:
131-132). -, , ,
12
( , , ,
12 .), (,
), ( ), ( ). 12 ,
.. -
, ,
(- 1955: 152-155).


, .
.
.. .. . ,

, ( ) .1 1
,

..

,
( 1961:
4). ,

, .. -
,

,
,

, , .
, .. - . ,

, .

.
,
( 1961; 1957; 1962; 1960),


. . , , -, , (Florescu
1964: 1967). ,
. , ,
: , .
60-
. .. , . ,

( 1960: 88-90). ,
, -, (Gerkovi
1999: 22-29).


.. , ( 1961). ..

( 1964: 153-169).

, .. ( 1970: 48).
..
( 1968) ,
.
, ,
.. , , .. - , ,
,
(), .
, ( 1968: 16-18).
,

.. .. -.
.. .

.. , , , ,
, (
1970: 58). , ,
.

( ).

,
. .
( 1970: 49-57),
-

601

.
.. .
,
.. ,

. .. .

,
, ( 1982: 9, 11-13). ,
, ,
,
, , . ,
.. , , .

.. . , ,


,
-, , ,
- , , , - ( 1985:
145).
, ,
, ( ), , , .
, 80- .
, .. ,
,
-
(). ,
-

602



. , ,
- ( 1985: 8). ,
:
1) ( )
? 2) , ? 3)
? 4) ? 5)
( , )?
6)
? . . ,
, ,
,
, . .
, 70-
, - .
-

,
. .. , ,
.. ( 1978: 84,85).
.
. , , ,
. ,
. , , , , , , , , .

..

,

.
, 40-
.. (
1947). , .
.
.. , , , ,
( 1967).
(Lskov
1981), .. , (Bokarev, Leskov 1980).
, , .. , : , -,
, -, , .. , ( 1976: 175). , . -
(Petrescu-Dmbovia 1977) ..
( 1975),

( !)
. . , ,
.

, .

.. . -


, .
,
(
1970: 106-116).

, , ,
.

, , , - ( 1976: 14-16).
: -
() - ; ()
; (),
(); -
() - -; - ()
, ; () ( 1976: 24-63).
, ,
,
, (, ) ( 1976: . 23; 24);
,
(
1976: . 25), , ,
.
, ..
()
, , ,

( 1976: 157).

. , , ,
, -
, ,
(Bokarev, Leskov 1980: Karte 2, 3, 5). ( 1976: . 54, 56),
- .
, ,
, ,
-
- , -

603

,
( 1976: . 26, 27, 28).
- (
.. ) (Bokarev, Leskov 1980: 68-70) ( ) ,

( 1976: 40-45), ..
, .
,
, , -
-
. .. ,
, ( 1976: 51-54),
.. , ( 1976: 180-185; 1978: 76). . 2
.. , , ..
, . , , ,
-

, .
.. , .. ,
,
, ,
, (Bokarev,
Leskov 1980: 6, 7). .
, ,
2
, ..
- , - ( 1995:
120). .

604


,
. ,
, ,

.
.. ..

, , , (Bokarev,
Leskov 1980: 25-26).

- .
24 ,
.. .. ,
(, ) ( ).
,
I .
, , (, , ), - .
11
(, , ),
(, , , ,
.). 45 10 ,
(, , ). , ,
.. .. , ,
...
, ,
(Bokarev, Leskov 1980: 72).
.

.. ( 1997: 127), -
, .. - ,
.
, (-) -

..

,
, .
,
, ,

,
.
.. . .. ,
9

( 1977),
( 1986: 63-65). , -

,
. ,
( 1986: 81).
.. , ( 1986),
. ,
, , ( 1986: 86,
115, . 24). ..
( 1976: 160 .),
.. ,

( 1985: 145). ,
, , , ,
,
( )
. , , .. - .. .

, (, 1985: 490),

XVI . .. (Klochko
1993: 58).
,
,
. ,
,
, , , .
,

, , , ,
, . ,
( ,
III, ) ( 1985: 51-69), ,
, ,
, . , , ,
,
.
, - , .
,
.3
, , ,
, ( ,
).
. - ,
.. ,
, (
) (
1996: 44-45), - (
3
. ,
( 1998: 61), , , ..
.. , (, 1999: 111). ,
.

605

-) , .. ( ) ( 1997:
139; 1998: 66; Gerkovi 1999: 75-77).
,
- .
,
.

,
(Gerkovi
1999: 75-77; 1999: 66). , (Gershkovich 2000: 100101).4 , ,
,
.5

- --, , ,
.


- , , ,
.
.. ( 1994: 123). ,
,
,
( 1995: 118).
, ,

. ,
4
.. , ,
( 1994: 81).
5
,
, ,
( ) ( ) (Gerkovi 1999: 15-16, 46).

606


(
1997: 8, 9)
,
. ,
, -, .. - ( 1995:
122). (, 1980: 146-147). , ( - )

, -

..

( 1976: 170-171). , ,
.

, , , .
,
, , -.
, , XXI
.

i .. 1961.
ii // i 13. .
.., .. 1985. // . . I. .
.. 1996.
// -
2. .
.. 1952. ii i
i 1947-48 . // 4.
.. 1995. // - (II . ..).
.
.. 1986.
//
. .
. .
.. 1997. //
6. .
.. 1998.
( - ) // 7. .
.., .. 1999.

//

( ). .
.. 1927.
// . . 7.
.. 1928.
// . . 2.
.. 1903. . .1. .
.. 1975. III-VIII .

.. - . .
.. 1997. .
- . .
.. 1925. // . 1935. 2/3.
.. 1949. i
i // 2.
.. 1952. i // 4.
.. 1947. . .
.. 1991. . .
.. 1994. - // -
. .
., .. 1980.
// (4).
- .. 1955. // 4.
.I. 1962. i i i
i // 4.
.. 1967. //
. .
.. 1970. // . .
.. 1960. //
. .
.. 1985. -
( ) // . .
.. 1976.
// (3).
.. 1978. (2- II . ..) //
. .
.. 1960.


// (4).
.. 1961.
// .
.
.. 1908. . .
.. 1957.
. //
70.
i .. 1961. i i
i i // i 12.
.
.. 1976. . .
i .. 1977. i
ii // i 22. .
.. 1986. //
. .
.. 1970. // 172.
.. 1976. - . .
.. 1978. // (4).
.. 1985. -
II . . . .
.. 1976.
. // . .
i I.M. 1964. i //i 17. .
.. 1968.
// (3).

607
.. 1982.
. .
.. 1986. //
. .
.. 1994. :
- //

V . .. V . .. . . .
Bokarev V., Leskov A. 1980. Jung-und Sptbronzezeitliche
Gussformen im nordlichen Scwarzmeergebiet // PBF XIX.
Gerkovi J.P. 1999. Zur Studien sptbronzeitlichen
Sabatinovka-Kultur am unteren Dnepr und an der Westkste
des Azovischen Meeres // Archologie in Eurasien 7.
Gershkovich Y.P. 2000. Farmers and Pastoralists of the Black
Sea Lowland during the Late Bronze Age // Late Prehistoric
Exploitation of the Eurasien Steppe. Cambridge.
Florescu A. 1964. Contribuii la cunoaterea culturii Noua //
AM II-III.
Florescu A. 1967. Sur les problemes du bronze tardif CarpatoDanubien et nord-ouest Pontique // Dacia (N.S.) XI.
Klochko V.I. 1993. Weapons of the Tribes of the Northern
Pontic Zone in the 16th 10th centuries B.C. // BPS 1.
Leskov A.M. 1981. Jung- und sptbronzezeitliche Depotfunde
im nordliche Schwarzmeergebiet (Depots mit einheimischeu
formen) // PBF XX: 1.
Nestor I. 1933. Der Stand der Vorgeschichtsforschung in
Rumnien. Berlin.
Petrescu-Dmbovia M. 1977. Depozitele de bronzuri din
Romnia. Bucureti.
Tallgren A.M. 1926. Pontide prescythique apres lintroduction
des metaux // ESA II.