AN ANALYTICAL STUDY OF THE
CONE PENETRATION TEST
by
cee-Ing Te!
A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of
Doctor of Philosophy
at the
University of Oxtord
Hertford College
inity Term, 1987ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First and foremost, I like to thank Dr Guy Houlsby who has been an
extremely able and conscientious supervisor of my work. His guidance
and thoughtful suggestions have been invaluable throughout the course of
this study. His advice and comments during the preparation of this thesis
are also very much appreciated.
I am indebted to Dr Harvey Burd for the many helpful discussions on
the various aspects of large displacement finite element analysis, and for
the use of his frontal solving routine. T am grateful to Professor Cesar
Sagaseta of the University of Cantabria, Santander, vho provided me with
detailed explanations of his solutions to the cavity expansion and cone tip
problems referred to in this thesis. I must also thank my friend Tack Weng
vho painstakingly proof read the final draft of this thesis.
It is a privilege to be a member of the Oxford University Soil
Mechanics Group under the able leadership of Professor Peter Wroth. The
friendly atmosphere he engenders in the group has made it a particularly
stimulating place to work in. And to all fellow members in the group vho
have contributed in variou:
ways tovards this vork, I vould like to express
my thanks.
I am particularly grateful to Kuok Foundation, Malaysia, for the
scholarship and the generous financial support, without which all these
would not have been possible. Above everything else, it is the kindness of
everyone at the Foundation that I shall alvays remember.
Last but not the least, I vould like to express my sincere gratitude
to my parents, brothers and sisters for their continuing support and
encouragement, and to Meei Fang vhose love and understanding have been a
constant source of motivation.ABSTRACT
An Analytical Study of the Cone Penetration Test
Teh, Cee Ing
Hertford College, University of Oxford
A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy
Trinity Term, 1987
The quasi-static penetration of a cone penetrometer into clay cait be
formilated as a steady state problen by considering a steady flow of soil
past a stationary cone. The soil velocities are estimated from the flow
field of an inviscid fluid, and the inconpressibility condition is achieved
by adopting a strean fonction formulation. Emphasis is placed on obtaining
an acclirate velocity estinate and this is accomplished by a solution of the
Navier-Stokes equations.
The strain rates are evaluated from the flow field using a finite
difference scheme. The clay is modelled as a homogeneous incompressible
elastic-perfectly plastic material and the soil stresses are computed by
integrating along streanlines from some initial stress state in the upstream
region, These stresses do not in general obey the equilibrium equations,
although one of the two equations can be satisfied by an appropriate choice
of the mean stress. Several attempts have been made to use the remaining
equilibrium equation to vitain an improved velocity estimate and three
plausible iterative methods are detailed in this thesis
In a second study, a series of finite clement calculations on the cone
penetration ptoblen is performed. In modelling the penetration process, the
cone is introduced in a pte-formed hole and some initial stresses assumed in
the soil, incremental displacements are then applied to the cone until a
failure condition is reached. Although the equilibrium condition is
satisfied very closely in the finite element calculations, it is extremely
difficult to achieve a steady state solution.
Th a third series of computations, the stresses evaluated by the
strain path method are used as the starting condition for the finite element
analysis. This is believed to give the most realistic solution of the cone
penetration problem because both the steady state and equilibrium conditions
are approximately satisfied. Numerically derived cone factors are presented
and these are found to depend on the rigidity index of the soil and the in
situ stresses.
The pore pressure distribution in the soil around the penetrometer is
estimated using Henkel’s empivical equation. The dissipation analysis is
based on Terzaghi’s uncoupled consolidation theory. The governing equation
is formulated in the Alternating-Direction-Implicit finite difference
schene. This formulation is unconditionally stable and variable time steps
are used to optimise the solution procedure. The dissipation curves are
found to be significantly affected by the rigidity index of the soil and a
dimensionless time factor is proposed to account for this effect.