2012

/ . ., . .,
. ., . .: WWF , 2006. 16 .
:
. ., ...,
. ., ..'.., WWF
. ., ...,
. ., ..., " ",

,
. ,
.

. ,
.
2012 . ( ).

.
EC DG Environment ( )

: ,
:

WWF , 2006

XXI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4
" " (TECH Plus) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6
2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .7

? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .12

20132020 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .14
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15

2006

4
XXI .
,
,
,
2005 . "

(Gleneagles, 2005), "
() 2
. "
: "
2, 20 "
20% .

,

.
2006 . "
"
2050 . (IEA, 2006):
(Baseline):
.
(Accelerated
Technology scenarios, ACT): , "
, 2,
2050 . "
2000 .
" " (TECH Plus), "

.
,
, 2030 . "
3,2% 20032030 . 2,6% 20302050 .
.
, , "
.
"
, 1,1% ,
.
76%
2003 . 83% 2050 .

, 1000
. "
"
"

.
"
"
.
"
.

"
2
2050 . 2 .

"
, 2 ,
.
2003 . 2050 . 3 , "
, "
. 138%,
65%, .

(60 ./ 2050 .).
(,
) , "

.
" "
,
. , 2 137%
24,5 2003 . 58 2050 ., "
.

Accelerated Technology scenarios (ACT) "
" 70%
2050 . "
"

:
"
();
;
;
CO2 (Carbon Capture and Storage,
CCS).
ACT
. "
.
, , ,

CO2.
, ,
ACT, . "
""
(), "
(Research, Development and Demonstration, RD&D)
, "
2,

(, ,
.).
.
ACT ,
, "
"
, . , ,
,
"
2 25 . .

5
2

. CO2
20 000

60 000
2050 .

40 000
30 000

+6%

+10%

+9%

+21%

+27%

16%

20 000
10 000

18 000

50 000

16 000
14 000
12 000
10 000
8 000
6 000
4 000
2 000

2003

Baseline Baseline
2030
2050
(WEO 2005)

Map

Low
Low
No
Nuclear Renewables CSS

( .)

AST map
2050

AST no
CCS 2050

TECH Plus
2050

: IEA, 2006

( 2
)
.

TECH
plus

Low
efficiency

Now
CSS

Low
renewables

Low
nuclear

Map

Baseline
2050

2003

: IEA, 2006

. CO2

Low
TECH
Efficiency Plus
2050

5 000
10 000
15 000
20 000
25 000

1,5%
1,0%
1,5%
1,0%
0,5%
1,0%
1,5%
2,0%
2,5%
3,0%

30 000

3,5%

35 000

19731990

Baseline

19902003

ACT Low
Efficiency

ACT Map

: IEA, 2006

: IEA, 2006

2 Map

45%

6%


7%
CCS
5%

: IEA, 2006

34%

CCS

3%

5%

6%


1%
2 (CCS)
12%

2%

2%

6%

6
2

ACT
Map
No CSS

2050 (%)

2003
(Mt CO2)

2050
(Mt CO2)

Map
(Mt CO2)

No CSS
(Mt CO2)

12 696

21 949

8 772

9 943

60

55

2 543

3 953

2 283

2 734

42

31

9 020

32 120

12 913

17 021

54

47

24 532

58 022

25 968

29 698

55

49

: IEA, 2006

Map, "
,
* .
, "

. ACT Low Nuclear "
,

, , "
. ACT Low Renewables "
,
Map. ACT No CCS
2 . ACT Low
Efficiency
, Map.
0,3% "
, Map, "
.
Map 2050 .
58% , 2003", 24% , "
.
ACT ,
ACT
Low Efficiency, 14,6% , Map.

Map 45%
; "

16%, CCS 20%.
6%,
CCS
. , 2050 .
3 , "
2003 . 2027%, "
1630% , .
" " (TECH Plus)
,
, "

Map.
2050 .
2842%, TECH Plus 46% , "
, "
.
TECH Plus 36%, 65%
, . ,
" ""

. "
, , , 2050 . "
1341% , 2003 .

2 ,
, 2003 . ( Map
6%). TECH Plus 16%
2003 .
Map TECH Plus 2 "
( 40%
2003 .) 22 49% "
, "
3 .
( 20%
2003 .) TECH
Plus
.
, "
"

.
+
2

" " (top"down) ,
.
,
,
.
, , "
60% 2 20032050 . "
ACT,
, .
,
, ,
, "
, ACT No CCS (
, CCS).
2050 . 2
2003 . ( 10%)
"
, . "
"
2,5% , , ACT
. "
"
( ACT
Low Efficiency ACT Map).

7


,
.
"
.
, XXI . "
"
, .
, "
, "
, . . "
:
. "
(natural gas combined"cycle, NGCC) "
.
,
, . "
60%
, . "
: , "
.
. "
"
(USC) ( 700 37,5
)
50%. "
(
"", ),
, " ( 50%)
.
,
.

() "

, "
.
100300 C
, .
(,
. .) , , "
, .
25%. "" , 15 ,
" "
.
, . "

"
"
, , "
"
.
" ".
"
" "
/.
(, ,
) , "
"
). "
,
75%.
, , 95%
"

1
2 CO2

3
a) b)
4 CO2

510%

1525%

100%

70%

* ,
,

: , 2005

CO2
CO2

8
, 40% "
"
".
. ()
"
. "
100% (85%) "
. ,
, "
. "
"
.
. "
, "
. "
, 25 ,

.

.
,
.
, , "
(6501000 ),
70%.
(). "
"
: " , "
,
, .
.
: ("
) , "
, "
. 2050 . ACT Map
2 1,3 /.,
0,5 / ( , "
"
1,6 /). , "
.
, , "

. ACT Map
2050 . 15% , "
"
. "
10% .

(biomass integrated gasifier/gas turbine BIG/Gt)

" ,
"
.
.

, "
( III IV ).
"
. "
. "

. "

.
2. "
2 (CO2 capture
and storage, CCS "2)
2,
(, 2005).
, CCS "
,
.
2; "
.
"
, "
.
( 2 )
"
. "

, , 600 . "
CCS
, .
, CCS ,
2 ,
.
CCS,
.
2 ,
.
CCS
2 . ,
2,
. , 2 "
"
.
"
.

9

?

1
, "
, . "
5 ,
.
, 50%

2 . "
, "
. 3 :
; "
""
" ,
, , ,
,
, . ., . .
+
,
2
450
CO2 ,

, 50 , "

. , "
.
? ,
? "

?
,
"
(, 2001).
"
:
, , "
"
2 . "
2007 .,
.


. , "
Nature
(17 2005 .) Science (24 2006 .). "
, , :
2
, " ;
;
.
"
.
(Avoiding, 2006),

14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
1990

2000

2010

2020

2030

2040

2050

: Den Elzen, M. and M. Meinshausen, 2006

, , 2080 .
3 500

300

3 000

250

2 500

200

2 000

150

1 500

100

1 000

50
0

1,0 C
1,5 C
2,0 C
2,5 C
3,0 C
3,5 C
.

: Parry et.al., 2001

500
0

. .
( )

. .
(, , )

350

10
2
2 ? "
Meinshausen, 2006,
.
400450 ppm ( ) 2"
50%, 550 ppm "
80%. 2 80% "
, 20% . "
, 21
, 2.
450 ppm 2 "" "
550 ppm .
2005 . 2 381 ppm (150 "
285 ppm), , "
500 000 ( "
"", UK..., 2005).
, , "
, .
, , 1020 "
.
, "
2 2025 . "
. ,
, , ,
2030 . 2050 .
50% , 1990 .
"
"
2 450 .
" 2 "
?
, ,
Pacala and R. Socolow, 2004; Azar et.al., 2006; Den Elzen et.al.,
2005; Den Elzen and Meinshausen, 2006. "
"
.
.
, 50
. "

2020 . 2050
25 . "
.
, "
2030 . 2030 .
.
2050 .
, . , 4050 "
.
.
"
" 2 " ,
.
" "
.
, , "
.

(wages)
(business"as"usual), Socolov, 2006.
, "
, "
2 "
(CCS). , ,

. ,
CCS 3040
, ,
.
,
.
23 , " " 10%.

,
XXI .
,
, ,
.
.

45 000

(25 )

. 2

40 000
35 000
30 000
25 000
20 000
15 000
10 000
5 000
2100

2090

2080

2070

2060

2050

2040

2030

2020

2010

2000

1990

: WWF Energy Task Force : Pacala and Socolow, 2004; Azar et.al., 2006; Den Elzen et.al., 2005;
Den Elzen and Meinshausen, 2006

11


20052050 .

" 2 " "

, 450 EJ, 2100 . "
( ) 600700 EJ.
6,5 9 .
,
2 ., , .
.
2 700
450 ,
, 450 350 .

,
7

, , " 2 "
"
, "
. , "
2, ,
""
2 3 ,
550 2""
. ,
2 , ,
2 350 , .
2. "

" ", "
.

. , 2020 ., "
. "
"
,
. ,
,
, 2020 . .
, " 2 "
"
. , , "
.

1
0
2010

2020

2030

2040

2050

CO2

: WWF Energy Task Force, 2006 Socolov, 2006

14

CO2,
,

6 GtC/

CO2
450 ppm
0

1950

2005

14 GtC/

2050

: WWF Energy Task Force : Pacala and Socolow, 2004; Azar et.al., 2006; Den Elzen et.al., 2005;
Den Elzen and Meinshausen, 2006

2100

12


,

: 1) 
(), 2)
, 3) , 4) 
, 5) 
, 
.
1999 .

. 
, 

, . 1998
2005 . 
( 5% ). 
7,5% 2000 .

. 
,

 ,
, 2020 . 
1990 . 2015 .,
, 2
85% 1990 . 
2015 . 
80%.

. , 2006 .



.

, 


, 

.

5%,
20062015 . ( ) 1,601,66 .


2,5% .
C 

. 
2015 .
.
20062015 .
1,851,90 . 
6,36,5% .

2010 . 73% 1990 .,
2015 78%, 2020 . 83%.
2 2010 . 77%, 2015 .
85%, 2020 . 94%. 4, N2O F
(, , SF6) 


, % 1990 .

: , , 2006

: . .,

13
2020 .

1990*

2000**

2004**

2010***

2015***

2020***

1 798
73 %

1909
78%

2028
83%

2
% 1990 .

2450
100%

1 578
64%

1 673
68%

2
% 1990 .

2450
100%

1578
64%

1673
68%

1885
77%

2084
85%

2304
94%

2.
% 1990 .

406
100%

275
68%

292
72 %

319
79%

344
85%

371
91 %

N2O

2.
% 1990 .

233
100%

116
50%

118
51%

133
57%

147
63%

162
70%

F

2.
% 1990 .

38
100%

44
116%

48
126%

56
146%

63
166 %

71
188%

2.
% 1990 .

3050
100%

2013
64%

2131
68%

2393
77 %

2638
84 %

2908
93%

*
**
***
:

, .

, 2020 .
717% , 1990 .
2050 .
. "
(, 2006), "
,
, 1020 . "
,
. "
50 , "
.

"
2050 . 2
1990 ., "
.
, "
. "
, , , ,
. ,
, "
, "

.

2 2050 .
200%
180%

1990 . = 100%

160%
140%
120%
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%

2
.

: , 2006

2
.

2050

2045

2040

2035

2030

2025

2020

2015

2010

2006

2000

1995

1990

0%

14

20132020 .
"
, ,
"
, ,
.
,
2007 . "
. :
, "

, .

"
. ,
2050 . "
. "
"40%,
"
.

(UNFCCC, 2006;
., 2004), "
( "
, ) "
.
1000 "
1 2,
, (UNFCC,
2006). "
, , "
"
.
2012 .,
2005 . "
. ,

20082012 .
: 10 20% "
1990 . 2020 .
"
, , "
(, 2006).

: 1) "

2)
"
. , "
, ,
(), "
. .
"
, ( "
) ,
, "

. , "
, , "
,
,

, .

.
" "
"
.
, "
"
. "
, ,
", "
, , .
, "
,
, "
. "
, ,
. " ", "
, 15% 1990 . "

.
"
, ,
, , , .
, ,
. "
,
(,
), "
. , "
"
.
, , "
,

.
"
"
15% 1990 .
, "

, "
, . .


20%. , "
, ,
,
.

15

. ., 2006.

.
, 2829 2006 ., www.ncsf.ru
. ., . , . ., 2004,

. ., WWF", 64 .
www.wwf.ru.
, 2001 (IPCC): 2001.

(IPCC). ,
. 1: , 109 . .
2: , , 107 . . 3:
, 103 . www.ipcc.ch.
, 2005 (IPCC):
(Carbon dioxide Capture and Storage CCS).

. 443 . www.ipcc.ch
, 2006.
.


2012 . ( 3.9
). www.economy.gov.ru.
,
4 12

, 2002.
., 123 .
www.unfccc.int.
. ., 2006.

.
2006 , 34 2006 .
Avoiding Dangerous Climate Change, 2006 H. J. Schellnhuber,
W. Cramer, N. Nakicenovic, T. Wigley, G. Yohe (eds.).
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. 392 pp.
Azar C., Lindgren K., Larson E., and Ollersten K. M., 2006.
Carbon capture and storage from fossil fuels and biomass
costs and potential role in stabilizing the atmosphere. Climate
Change v. 74. Pp. 4779.

Den Elzen, M. G. J., Lucas, P. and van Vuuren, D. P., 2005;

Abatement cost for post"Kyoto climate regime. Energy Policy v.
33. Pp. 21382151.
Den Elzen, M. and M. Meinshausen., 2006. Multi"Gas Emission
Pathways for Meeting the EU 2 degrees C Climate Target. In:
Avoiding Dangerous Climate Change. Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge. Pp. 299310.
Gleneagles, 2005, G8 Summit, ,

(Climate Change, Clean Energy and Sustainable Development)
www.g8russia.ru.
IEA, 2006. International Energy Agency. Energy Technology
Perspectives 2006, 479 pp. www.iea.org.
Nature, 2005, Climate Change. Regional Health Impact. Special
issue 17 November 2005.
Pacala, S. and R. Socolow, 2004. Stabilisation wedges: Solving
the climate problem for the next 50 years with current technolo"
gies. Science, v. 305, pp. 968972. www.princeton.edu/~cmi.
Parry M. L., Arnell N. W., McMichael T., Nicolls R., Martens W.
J. M., Kovats S., Livermore M., Rosenzweig C., Iglesias A., and
Fischer G., 2001. Millions at risk: defending critical climate
change threats and targets. Global Environmental Change v. 11,
Pp. 181183.
Science, 2006, Climate Change. Breaking the Ice. Special issue
24 March 2006.
Socolow R., 2006. Stabilisation Wedges: An Elaboration of the
Concept. In: Avoiding Dangerous Climate Change. Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge. Pp. 347354.
WWF Energy Task Force, 2006, Information from web"site
www.panda.org.
UK Meteorological Office, 2005. Information from web"site
www.stabilisation2005.com/day1/Izrael.pdf
UNFCCC, 2006; Secretariat of the Framework convention on cli"
mate change. Information from web"site www.unfccc.int.

 (WWF)
, 5
100 .
WWF
.
WWF :
;
;

.

(WWF)
109240, , . , 19, . 3
. +7 495 727 09 39
+7 495 727 09 38
'mail: russia@wwf.ru