Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 96

1/2003

1991 .,

12



9 2001 . .........................................2

:


.....................................4

.................................8



19321933 .......................14


. . ...............................................20

1937 .
1 31 1937 ..................................26

................................31


................................32


............39
, ,
....43



C
............................................45



:
? .................................................50

,

....................60

....63



.....70



............................................76
,

................................................78



( . . ) ....................................83



....................86


...................................................90
..............................................................92
....................................................................94

C
: , , C
, ,
.


, .
()

3,5"; ; ,
, , ; C
.
C
8 .
C
. .
,

.
( 1602/5
.
10.05.2000) , 6
. C

C
, , 2002 , .





9 2001 .
, C
, , 60 , C
25 2002
, 9 2001 .
, , , 9 C
,
. , , , C
, , , C
,
5 . , C
, .
, C
,
, , , ,
, , , , , , C
, , , , , , C
. .
, , C
, , ,
, ,
.

:
03039, C39, . , 2.
.: (044) 490C95C19.
E"mail: personal@kievweb.com.ua
ISSN 0868C8893. 1 (84), 2003, 196.

6563 01.10.2002.
:

()
(03039, C39, . , 2).
:
C
(04080, C80, . , 47/2).
5 000 .

, 2003


1991 ., 12 .
ISSN 0868C8893. 1 (84), 2003, 196.

6563 01.10.2002.
27.01.2003.
6084/8. .
. .C. . 10,82.
.C. . 9,8. . 01_____ 5 000 .
.

()
(03039, C39, . , 2).
C
(04080, C80, . , 47/2)

1/2003
( 1 28.01.2003)

1 /2003

14 2003

, , #
. #
, ,
. ,
...
., C
, , ,
, . , C
, , , C
. , C
, . , , C
, ,
, , C .
, , C
, , C
. ,
, C
. , , C
, ,
. ,
, . C
.
.
, , #
, ,
.
. #
, #
, #
.
, , , #

. , #
? ?
, ,
, .
4

.
5. 11.
1945 . . C
C
. . C
C
C
. . .
1988 . C
(C
). 1989 . C

, C
. 1990 .
.
1991 .

. 1994 . C
, C

. 1996 . C
, C
C
1998 . 1996 . C
.
20002002 . C
.
C
IIIIV . 2002 .
C

, C

.

1/2003

,

.

, ( , ,
), , C
, C
.

, ,
, , .
C
.
C
C
, C
C.
C
, ,

.
,
.
C
.
, C
C
. , , C

,
.
,
, , C
C, , , ,
C ( ), C
. , C
, C
, , .

, , ,
, ,
...
, ,
, C
. , , ,
: C
, ,
,
, . C
, ,
, C
,
.
. C
6070
. ? , , ,

, C
, C
, . , C

C C
.
, ,
, C
. , , , C
, , C
, , ,
? ?
,
60 70 ?
C ,
,
, , C
.
,
. ,
, C
, . C
,
. , ,
. C
: , C
, , , C
C

.
, ,
, , ,
,
C
, , , ,
, C ,
C
.
,
. C
, , ...

,
, ,
, , .
, ,
,
, C
, , C
. ,
, , C
.
: C
C
, ,

. C
.

. ,
5

, C
, C
. , C
, .
,
, ,
,
, C
,
, , C C
, .
, , C
, C
( ) , C
, . ,
C
,
,
, ,
, . , C
, , C
, .
, C

,
, , C
?
, ,
, C
,
, ,
, , .

, , #
, #
, , ,
, #
: ,
? #
, #
?
, , C
,
; . .
, C
, C
, C
, ,
.

, , C
C
. , C
, C () .
, C
, , C
6

, C
C
, . C
, C
,
. , C
, C
. C
, , C
, ,
, , .
,
,
. ,
C
, .
, , #
,
,
?
C
. , , , , C
,

, .
,
, ,
?
. , , C
, . . C
,
.
, #
,

. , #
#
.

, #

. , ,
,
?
:
? ,
C ,
,
,
. , , C
. , C

, , ,
, C
. ,
.

1/2003

C C
, ,
, C
C , ,
. ,
, C
C
.
C .
, , #
,

,
, , ,
( )? #
, #
#
,
, #
.

. , , C
. ,
19981999 C
, , C C
, , C
, C
.
, , ,
. , C
, ,
.
? ,
. C
. C , C
.
, #
,
, #
. .
, , #
# ,
? , #
, , , #
, #
,
,
, ?
. C
, C
. C
C
.
, , C ,
19981999 . C
, C

. 11 C
C
,
.
. ,
, .
,
.
, C
.
C
, C
, . C

. .

, C , C
, , C
, .
. ,
, ,
,
. C
, C
C
, C
. C
? . C
, , .
, , , ,
.
, ,
.
, ,
C
. , C
? C
? , , C
,
. , C
, , C
,
, C
C
. C
, C
, . , ,
,
,
, . C
C
. C.
. ,
.

7

I
C

, CC
, I. , C
C
, C
. , C
, , C
. C
.
C
,
. C
C
, ,
I C
C
.
8

. C
, C
: , , ,
, C
. .; C
, C

,
, C
C
, , C
,
C ;
C
, , C
, , C
; , C
C

1/2003

,
,

, , C
, , .
. C
. C

: ,

. C

.
.
, C
, C
, , .
, C
,
.
.
CC
, C
C
, C
, C
, C
.
.
, C
, , C
, C
. C
I C
, , ,
, , , C
.
, C
,
, .
,
. C


I . C
.
I
.
1. C

, , C
C
, C
.


, C
C
.

2.
, ,
, C
, ,
, , ,
, .
3.
,
C
,
.
4.

, C
,
.
5.
, C

C
, C
. C

,
.


, C
, II C
C
.
. .
C
C
, C
, C
.
, C
, C

,
C
, .
C
C
. C
C
,
. ,
C

, C
. C
12C
. C

.
, .
.
.

. ,
, , C
. , C
, , ,

.
,
. C
C
. C
( C
) .
. C
. C
,
, ,

10

, C
. ,

.
, C
C
, C
C
.
, ,
, C
.
.
,
C C

.
, C
, C
, , .
, , C
, C
C
, ,
, C
,
. , C
C
, , C
C
. C
C
.
11
C
, , C
. , (
) C
, C
, C
. C
,

. ,
C

.
C

C
C
, CC
C
C
,
C

1/2003

, C
, C

. C
. C
C
.
C
,
, C
.

,
. C


,
,
, C
. C
.
,

, , C
, 12C C
, 10 . C

C
. .
. , C


. C
, C
, C
, , C
. C
I C
C
.
, ,
C
, ,
, , C
. , , C
,
C
C. , C
C
C
C
. C
.
, C
,
.

, ,
. C
, ,
C
, , C

.
1
21
. ,
C
.
. C
,
.
,

I . C
, C
, C
. , C
. C
, C
, , C
, .
, C
C
.
,
, C
.

,
C
, C
,
, ,
. , C
(homo sapiens) I C
, , .
. C

.
I C
.
, . C
, , ,
.
, , ,

, ,
.
. C
, ,
C
C ,
11

C
, .
.
1986 176 10 C
, 330. C
( ) C
12
: .
, C
, C
C
. , C
, C
, .
. , C
, C
C
, C
, C
, .
,
, ,


, C
, C
, .
,
, ,
C ,
, C
. . , C
, CC
, C C
. C
C
, C
.
I C
, . ,
C
. C
, ,
C
. , C
,
C C
.
.
, C, C
,
. C,

. C
. C, , C
,
12

,
C
. C,
, C
C

.
, C
, ,


.
, C C
.
I C

, C

, C
C
. C
C
, ,
C
. C
C
C C
, C
, ,
.
, C
. , C
, , ,
, C

.
C
,


,
, .

C
.
,
.
C
, .

, C
, C
.
, C
,
.

1/2003

C
C
.
C
.


, C
.
,


C
.


(), C
, C
, ()
()
, C
.
C

facilitator , , , C
. , C
, C
, , , C
,
,
C
C
. I C

C , C
+ C
+ .
C
.
C
C
. C
,
.

. C
:
. . C
C .
C
,
, C
C
, , C
. ,
C

, C
. C
, C
.
C
, I C
.
C
,
, C
. C

, C
, .

: C
.
C
, C
, , C
.
C C
C
C
. C
,
C
.
I , , C
, , C
: , C
, , , ,
C
, , .
C
C
,
,
, ,

.
13



19321933


. .
1937

1 31
1937




19321933

,

15 2002 .

,
, 
, 

, . 

, 



C
C
C

. ,
C
C
C
,
C
, C
, ,
, C

. C
,
,
C
.
C

:
, C

1/2003

,
C
, , ,
,

. , .

,
,
,
, C
, , , ,

C
. C
, C


, , , C
, C
, .
, 19321933
.
,
1015 . ,


19321933

.
, , ,
C
,
, ,
,

. C
, C
,
,
, , C
.
,

,
, , ,

.

C
.
C
.
,

, C

, ,
1917
, C ,
, C
.
: C
C

.
,
,
. C
,
C


C
. C

, C
C
, .
:
C
,
,
, .
15

, , C

C
. C
C
,

. C

, ,
, 4 1919
, : C
, ,
, ,

.
,
C
.
,
, .
, C

C
,

1/2003


,
, C
, C
, ( 70C
XX .), ( XXI .). C
C
C
. C
: ,
, C
, .
:

,
, , C
, C
C ,
C
.
C

, ,
, 90%
, C

16

C
.

,
C
19171919 C
C
, C
C
. ,
,
, C
, C
,

100 .

,

,

C
.

C
C
,
,

, .
, C
,
C
, ,
, ,
.
. , C
, C
C
,

.
,


, C
. . , . C
, . C

. ,
C ,
.
,
,
C
.


.
(,
)
C
, , C
, , , ,
.
C
, C
, C
C
.

C
1,
C
. C
1902 ,
1919
. C

17

. ,

C
C
C
.
... , C
C



, , , C
C ,
,


, C

, C
:


(, )
C
;
C
,
;

C
;
C
,
;
C

, C C


.

,
C
.
, C
,
, C
.
, C

19321933
. . . , .

, . . C
, 1926 1928
(). C
18

C
.

, C


,
, C
.

C
, C
C C
. 14 1932 .
()
, C
, C
.
C
:


;

,
C
;
()
;
C
C
.

,
, C
: C
1932 ? C
,
,
.
,
, , .
,
, C
C


,
1932 . 1 736 298 , 1933 . 1 689 790 .
, 1933
36 C
,
28 .
C

,

1/2003

1917 ., 85 % 500
. C
65
, 1918 .
16 , 371
, 265 C ,
.

C, C
(1933)
(18701953) ,
30C


,
. , ,
, 10
, C

, ,
, , C
, C
.
C
C

()
C
, .
,
10 C

, .
C
,
. C

. C
C
. C
,

.
,


19321933 . C
,
,

.

19



.

.
. 2
, 

, 
.
,
. 
, ,


.


.
, 
. ,
, 
, 
.

. 
.


. . *
,
.
,
,
. ,
.
.
, .

,
. , ,
C
, .
. , C
, C
. ,
: , C
,
, , C
. ,
, ,
.

: 50C
[...]. C
(!) .
,

,
, ,
, C
C .
, C
C, .
* : . 2000. 1. . 45; . 2000.
( ).

19 1999
C
.
. C
. , C
,
.
, ,
. C
.
,
C
: C
, ,
,
C
.
, , C
,
? , , C
C
C
, C
. C
C
, , .
C
.
. 25
1956 , 19 C

C
:
. .
, . C
: C

:
, .
20

1/2003

(
, . [
]. . 263. . 1. 38485 / . 414.
. . 133).
14 1955
C, 1929 1946 ,
. C

. 1955 C
() C
, ()
, 4
, C
() . ( .
32099 / . 217. . 102108).
,
,
. , 1956
, 23 1956
( . 44539 / . 676. . 460;
), 5 1956 C
, 7 1956 C
, 5 1956 , 6
1956 (
), 17 1956 C
( ), 8
1956 ( C
), 30 1956
C, 1957 C
(C
), 21 1957 , 23 C
1957 , 16 1957
( ), 9 C
1957 ( C
), 13 1957
( . 44539 / . 676. .
460; ), 4
1957 C, 15 1957 C
, 9 1957
C, 3 1957 C
, 20 1957 , 1957
( 20
1990
. ), 28 C
1958 , 22 1958 C
C, 28 1959
. . , 21 1961 ,
16 1961 , 13
1988 , 16 1989
, C (
20 1990

. ; . 37892 / .
390. 1. . 168), ,
, , , C
, C .

, . . C
7 1937 , , C
, C
,
C
. , C
,
,

( . 44539 / . 676. . 395).
,
. ,
,
C , C
. : C
. ., . ., . .,
C . ., . ., CC
. ., . ., . ., C
,
[...] ( . 44539 / .
676. . 406).

, , C
31 1956 C
: .. ( ),
, ,
1934 . C
, , , C
1935
C
. [...]
. . . . ,
1923
,
C
C
( . 44539 / . 676. . 404).
, , .
: [...]
, 1923
, C
[...] ( . . 419).
, . C
,
.
, ,
, C
, .
, C
, C
? . .
C
, 1958 ,
, ?

, C
21

,
. 3 1960
C
C : C
C
1934 (
1936
1937 . C
. . .)
23.V.1934 . C
. . 3 C
( . 61278 / . 1604. .
158). :
1934
C
, C
. (. . 18, 19).

, 1960 .
. C
: C
. [...]
. C
.
.
,


( ) . C
, , .
. ,
, ,

(C ).
.
, C
. 1961 C
, 1963 C
( )
. ,
, C
. .
1965 , C
,
()
, 1969 . .
1970 C
. 1984 C
. C
, ,
. , C
C
. .
, C
: [...]
,
22

: . . , . . ,
. . , . . , . . , . . C
, . . , . . , . .
. ( . . 2050C . . 50).
,
? , C
C
. C
:
,
1937 C
: !, 1987C : C
!.
C
(C
C2) . , C
. C
, .
,
(
1991C)
. C
, 19171941 .,
,
. . . C
,

. .
.
. , C
.
() 1919 , C
25 1937 C

, 16
1937 ( . 66363 / . 1916. .
13). 13

. 29
( . 62959 / . 1713. . 10).
() 19201922
( ),
1929 . , , C
. :
.
. ,
29 1937 8 1938
C
( . 64642 /
. 1813. . 1) C
C ( C
. 49866 / . 972. . 1).
26 1937 , 17 1938 .
18 1938 , C
, ,
( . . 97128),

1/2003

17 . 25 1938
C
C C
( . 60750 . . 10) C
7 1938 .
,
. , C
. C
, C
, C
.
C
, .
, C
,
, , C
. C
,
. C

.
, .
1955 , 1938
, . C
C
,
,
30 ( C
. 52850 / . 1170. 1. . 233238).
, ,
, . 544, 547
5411 ,
C .
C

, ,
()
. ,

, C
30 ( . . 234). C
, (1955)
C
. ,
,
( . .
237). ,
(1955) C
, , , C
( C
) C
: , , C
, C
,
( . . .), C
C

, (
. . 236).
.

, C
. : C
C , C
, C
, ,
, , C
, C
. 547
. 20617 . . C
541
5411 ( . 51230 / . 35.
. 378). . 14 .
. 4 . C
C
. 2. C
C
C
. ., . .
. . ( . . 237238). ,
, C
. ,
. , C
1931 . 23 1958

.
:
.
1960 

 ,
1905 .
, . .,
19371939 ., 
,
.
,
865 20 1954 .,
518 23
1960 

50 .


<>
//
17 1961
( . 56269 / . 1331. . 75).


C . ,
, C
: ,
.
,
C
, , .
23

CC
() .
, C
8 1927 , C
2 7 . C
,
, ,
.
, ,
, ,
,
. , .

.
.
.
.
. .
1893 , ..
. .
( ) 
.
() 7 1937 .
.

( ) . 541
.
23 1937 . (sic) .
. 1 
17 1991 .
. ().

<> . . .

3 1997
. , ,
, C
, .
.
19191920
, . 1921 C
( . 49711 / . 958. .
8391). ,
. C
,
, , CC
. 1993
( . 1993.
. 1).
( 9 1937
). 25 1933 C
, 1 23 , 21 1933 23
1934
( . 62089 / . 1650. 1. . 7,
1320, 4951, 5262, 7984), 1942
.
.

24

. ,
1965 :
1931 . [ . . .] C
.
, ,
,
...
,
. [...] , ,
. C
... (
, 2030C . .: , 1991. . 227).
, ,
.
, C
. C
,
, 1998 C
, C
.
?
. . : ,
,
, : , , C
, . [...] ,
C C
, , C
(
. 2. , 1999. . 21). C
. 2 C
17
1991 , : C
, C
, ,
. :
, .
!

C .
, , , C
, .

, ,
.

C
CCC,
, .
12 1999 .
,
,


252033 , . , 7, . 49.
.
. 212 54 25

1/2003

*
2

256400, ,
. , . , 36
30.04.99 140

5.10.38 .
3.. 1903 . ., . . , C
.. 7, 180, 54C10 ', C
.

12.09.1989 . .
. C
, C
, C
. ,
.
: . ., 1872 .., . .,
1879 .., . ., 1885 .., . .,
1882 .., . ., 1883 .., . .,
1879 .. , . ., 1893 ..,
. ., 1890 .., . . 10
'.
C
.

. , C
. ., ,

, .
,
. . . 206
17 . , , ... 2, 7
C
17.04.91 ., ,
.

252601, . 11, , 13/15


01.09.99 09/32273999 140
30.04.99 .



.
256400 ,
.
. , 36
,
3.. ,
..,
.., .., ..,
.., C
,
.
3.. . 54C10
. 1 C
C
,
3040C 50C 16.01.
1989 ., . 1 3 C

17.04.1991 .
.. 7 180
. 206C17 , , ,

' , C
( ,
) . ,
(.
365 ).
. 7 C

...
C

,
C
.

. .

* . 2000. . 1(96). . 45.

25

1937
,
,

,

. .




 : , ,
(.: , 1997) . 
, . . .


.
( 52) 

(1993, 1)
, 45 .
,
. ,
. . 
.
,
, .
4 (. ,
. , . . 
) 183 . ,
,
, 
. , ,

, . . (
1926 . 2 1953 .; 
).
,

. , 
,
. ,
26


(), () ,
, 
.

. . 
,


19341941 (,
1999). 
,
:

, 



, ,
. 

,
.
,

:
300600 1920, 13
1930, 56 19501952
.
. ,
,
(
. ., 2001. . 423).
,


. ,
,
1997 183
, 


.

1/2003

1 31 1937

. 183
, .

1937 , 
 
.



(., 1999),
. . 
. .


[ ( 1918)
(18791951).]
[ C
( 17
1920), ( 2 1921),
(22
1922 1923) C
(18891938).

C
(). . C
.]
[ C
(25 1931 20
1933) (18921940).
: .
. . C
1961.]
(11 1934
11 1937) C
(18921937). : ,
(19121915),

(1915),
(1915). .
(14
1937 25 1938) C
(18941938). . .
(25 14
1938)
(19021940). : . C
., C
, ,
C .
.
(11 1934 7
1937) (18921938).

(1915), C
. .
(17 1936 26 C
1937) (
; 18881938).
4 5
. C
.
(15 26 1937)
(18941938).


(1907)
(1910). .
. . . ( 9 1938) "
(19051940). .
(20 1937 9 1940)
(19001940).
(1911).
.
(11 1934 29 1937) "
() (18991937).
.
()
(; ... 19371938...).
1956.
(26 23
1937) (18991938).
: (?)
(1911). .
(1 1934 21
1937) (18971937).
. C
.

1 (
)
(21 1936 4 1937)
" (19001938).

(1916). .
. . . ( 1937),
(16 1937 24 1938) "
(*1894).
(1950 ).
.
( 15
1937) (18971938).
C
(1910). .

2 ().
, ,

(21 1936 13 1937)


(19031937).
C
27

3 (; )
(16 1936 21
1937) () C
(18981937). . .
(23 3 1937) "
(19021940). C
(1914) C
. .
(19 20 1937)
(*1900). :
(). 1957 .
(20 22 1937) "
(18971937).
(1917)
C
. .
(3 13 1937)
(19011940).

(1913). .
(9 1937 6
1938) "
(19001938). C
. . C
C

(). .
(13 1937 21
1938)
(19001957). . . C
1989.
11 ( 28 1937)
(*1901).
.
1945 .
( 16 1937) "
" (19021938).
. 1958.
1 ( 2
1937) (*1903).
. 1939
.
( 8
1937) (19091948). C
28

C . C
1939, .

(*1902). .
(?
1938)
(19071941). 5 . .
.
10 (4
1936 1938) C
(*1896). . .
.

4 (; ).
,

( 31 [ ?]
1937) (18971938). C
. .
(31 20 1937)
(18991938). : C
, , C
(
1918). .
(20 25 1937) "
(19061938).
.
. 19171919 . C
( ).
.
( 11 1937)
(18961938).
. : C
. .
. . . (
1937), (7 1937 9 1938) "
(19051940). .
(8 1937 5
1938) (*1909). 1928 C
C
. 19251929 . C
.
1939, .
(8 1937 4 C
1938) (*1905).
(1941) .
(3 21
1937) (19021938).

(1915). .
. . . (1937) "
(1904 1956). C
, 1922 . C
C
,
.

1/2003

. (1916), 19171918 .
. .
.
(29 16 [ ?]
1937) (*1898).
(1913).
1939 .
(16 [ ?] 1937 19 C
1938) (19041938).

. .

( 20 1937) "
(19031940). C
.
( 4 1937) "
" (*1900).
. 1939 .
1957 . .
(8 1
1937) (*1905). 1938
.
(1937 4 1938) "
(19041940). C
.
(8 1 1937)
(*1903).
,
(1916), C
(1928). 1953
.
C
(*1905). 7 1937 .
2
(19041957).
6 ( 1935), . . .
8 ( 8 1937), C
3 (8 1937 22 1938)
[] (*1901).
. 1939 (
)
.
( 31 1937)
(*1910).
(). 1940 .

7 ( 8 1937) "
" (19001938).
.
9 (1936 23 1937)
(19051941). : C
.
. 1956.
"
(1903). 2 1938 C
.

6 ()
( 24 1937) "
(19021937).
. C
.
(1924). C
. 1957.
( 27 1937)
(*1902). C
. 1939 ( )
.

7 ().

[ C
.]

8 (, )
( 26 1937)
(*1895). . 1938
.
. . . (... 1937
5 (). 1938 ...) (*1898).

. : 5
(21 1936 7 1937) .
(19001937). : 4 1939.
. .
(23 1937 17 1938)
(18991938). C 9 ().
.
,
( 15 1934), C
( 5 1937)
[ C
(18981937). . .]
.
(11 1934 9
1937) " 10 (;
)
(19001938). .
(9 1935 26 1937) "
3 (28
22 1937), (22 (18951938). : C
1937 20 1938) " C . .
(3 1937 3 1938) "
(19021939).
, (18941938).
. . : . .
29

11 ()

[ C ( 1935) (18901938).
.]
. 1989.
12 ()
(1 1937 29 
1938) (*1905). 1938 ()
.
(20 1934 8 1937)
(18881938). :
( ). C

. .
( 29 1937) "
(23 1937 8 1938)
(18981938). .
"
(*1895). C
(1915). 1938 .

. . . ( 22 1937),
(13 3 1937)

(18941938). .
()
(15 1936 29 1937)
()
(18951937).
(*1899). : (1907).
1937 .
.
. . . (29 1937 5

1938) (*1894). :

. 1940
( 1934 17 1937)
.
(18941937). C
. .
(21 1936 23 1937)
" (18961937).
: . C
C (7 1935 13
.
1937)
() (*1900).
(17 1937 9 C
1938; 17 1937 . . . C . 1938 .
) (*1891).
:
. (1957 
).

30


(19 1937 1938) "
" (*1901).
: C . .
(1938) .
#
(27 15 1937; 15
C) C
(*1900). : C
. 1937 .

1/2003



( 1934 1 1938)
() (18961938).
: , C
(1917) C
(1917). .
(2 1936 C
1937) (*1898).
: . 1937 .
.
(28 1937 28
1938) (*1901).
1945


19321933 ,
, .

, , .
,
, , , , ,
.
,
, . , ,
,
, , , ,
,
, . ,

. .
, ,
70 3 7 ,
.
, , .
, .
, ,
. ,
.
, , ,
,
, , .
, , .
. .
, , .
, , .
.
,
, ,
.
, .
, ,
,
. .
,
,
. , , ,
. ,
, .
, ,
C.
. .
3 .
, .
.
100 ., 200 . , , ,
* . .

.
, .
, , .
,
, ,
.
, , ,
. ,
.
, . , ,
. .
, . .
,
. .
, , , ,
. . ,
, , , , ,
. ,
: , , , ,
. ,
. .
, ,
, .
, ,
. 10 . 8 ,
.
, ,
,
. ,
. .
,
. , .
.
, . .
, .
, ,
. ,
.
, , ,
. ,
, .
,
.
,
. . 1941
,
.
, .
,
. ,
(), 51, 20 2002 .

31




,
,





XIX , C
, .
C
. C
,
. C
,
.
, ,
. C
,

.
1920 , C
, C
, C
C
.
, . , 1921

; 1922

.
1920C , C
,
C
, C
:
.
192122
.
192030" C
C, C
C. 1922
C, C
C
.
C
. C
150 , C
.
C
. 1923 C
C
, , C
. C
, C
, C
.

1/2003

... C
C
.
, , C

C
1000 C
. C
, C
192122 , C
C
.


( ), C
, . . . C

. C
C

, C
, C

.
. C
,
, , , , C
. C
, C


.
1924 C
,

280
. , C

, C
(), C
C
1923 .
. C
,
1923

. C
C
C
.
1923
, 10C

C
, C
,
10 , C
500 . C
,
,
, C

, C
C
.
() 20 1924
.
, C
C
, C
29 1924
C

C
. . . ,
.

500600 . C
, C
C
,
, C
, C
C
, C
C
...
* : . //
. 1999. C. 5; C. :
// . 1999. 1.

33

1926
10
100 . C
3 18 .
() 26 C
1928 C

. C 1928
C
131 901.24 .
1921 C
.
C
,

. 200 C
C

(C
C
).
21 1926
() C
,
, C
C
C
.
C
.
. C

49 C
. C
C
. C
C

,
C
,
.

, C

, C
.

200 . C
. C
. , , ,
.

, C
C
. C
34

15
.
C

,
C
. C
. , C

. ,
C
, C
.
C
,

C
.
, C


. , C
C

, C
C
C
, C
C
,
C

. C
. C
. C
,
C

.
C
.
C
. C
C
() C
C

.
, C
C
C
.
7 1926
,

. 11 C

1/2003


C
. . C
: C

,

. :
. C

,
, C
. C
,
...



.
C
.
C C
,
C:
8000 ,
<...>
, C
C
. C
,
. C
,
C.
26 1927 C

, C


. C
C
<...>
C
C


.
C
,
. ,
, C

. C

.
, 1928

.

C
, .

63:
. C
,

.

,
C
.
C
, C
. C
C
, 19
1929 . 900
10 5% C
.
C
500 . C
1945 C
1954C (
!). C

. C
C
9 7 C
.
,

, C
. C
,
C
: , , ,
, .
5 1930
C
. 1931 ()
,
C
. C
C
, 32 C
, .
C

.
(
).
, 26 1930

35

16 , C
2530 .
C
. , 1931 C
C

, C
, C
, .
C
, .

. , C
C
, 1928 C
( C
60C70%).
1926 39 921
4 083 . 1 1930
49.100 10.140
. 1941 ,
, 70 , 86C
17
.
C
C
C
. C
, C
.

C
, C
.
,
, C
, ,
,
C
.
C
, C , C
1934 , C
,
, , 7 1934 C
C
. C

() 4 1938 .
.
30 C
.
C
C
C C
. C
36

, ,

C
().
, C
, C
,
C
() C
(). C

(), C
, C
(
).

, C
, (1) C
,
C
, (2) C
. 1943
.
,
C
, C
:

,

. .
C
. ,
:
, C
, C
.
, ,
.
,
C
(, I C
5,5
, 80C XIX
1,5 . ,
II
3 ). C
C
.
( ), C
( ), ( )
( )
, C

. ,
, . ,

1/2003

C . , C
. , . , . C
, , C
;
, ,
;
.
.

, , C
, .
C

C
.
C
500 C
, C
32 . C
,
, (
C
: C
C
, C
).
C
. C
, C
, 1943 C
. , . :
,
,
, . , C
,
, C

. C

10 .
C
:
C C
, C

,
,
C
. ,
, , C
C C
.

C
. 1944C C
,

C
, , C
, 10, C C
:
"
, "
.
5 "
"
, , ,
.
, ,
1,5 .
... "
"

,
" "
. ,
, ,
"
, "
"
,
. , "
,
"
,
"
.

.
"
"
,
.
, "
,


,

.

""
, "
, "

.
"
, "
"
.
"
"
"
37

15 1944 .,
:
C
,

.
, .
20C, 40C

. 20C, 1944C

, .

. 1944 C
C

. C
10 C
, , C
.
C
. , C

, , C
, , ,

.
1945 , C
,

. C
C
C
. CC
. C

38

C
...
30 1945 C

.
1945
,
C
, :
.
C

.
15 1948
. C
, 18
1948
.
, , C
: C
C
C
? C
C C
? C
, ?
.
.
!
. "
.
"
, "
"
, , "
.
"
.
.
, , "

"
. ,
, "
.
.
,
C
C , C
,
. C
: C
; C
.

1/2003


.
"

,
...
, :
1. "
.
2. ,
"
.
, "
,
.

.
.
.




C
C
C
C
.
C
, .
, C
C
.
,




,

, , 6

,

. C
C
, . . C
, C
.

, C
.
, C
,

, C
, C ,
C
. :
, . .
, C
, C
,
, C
, C
.

, C

,
, .

, , C
, C
.
C
,
C
, C

C
.
: ?
. , C
11% C
.
,
. , C

39

15,2
, 65%
, C
215 .
, C
.
,
,
,
. C
C
. C
C
( , , 2000 .).
, C
,
C
.
, ,
, C
, C
.
, C
. ,
,
C . C
, C
, , C
, .
, (47 )

, , ,
.
,
C
C .

(), () ().
70%,
C
. C
. C

. C
, , ,
.

. C
.

. C
, C

, C2 C
( ), ( ).
1,6 .
40


,
C
. ,
, C
, C
C
.
C
, ( )
,
. ,
$8 . 2/3 C
C
.

,
70%
CC .
,
( , )
Urals.
, C
, , C
( Kirkuk)
C
.
,
, C
,
915
3. C
, C
.

15 3 ,
.
, , , C
C C
500 ,
. ,
C
, ,
.
. C
,

C
.

, C
, ,
, , C

, C . C C
C

1/2003

, 91 (!!!) C
, C
, , C
, .
CC
, C
C
C
.
C
(),
"
.
1958
1992 .
C
.
, C
1993 .
(
, ).



1995 20 .
,
C

C
C
"
.

C
. ,
. C
, C
, , C
130 .
C
: C
C
C
C .
, C
C
. 11

, ( C
2001 ).
2002 C
C
. C

. C
C

. C C
11

.
, C
1991 ,
.
200 C

,
C ( C
, C
). , ,
.
,
C C
, , C
, C
, C
.

,
,

1996 , C
C
C.
, C


C
,
,
2001 ,
C
C
(Centcom).
,
, C
C
( 150 . ). , C
, C
( C ) C
C
. C
, ,
C, ,

. ,
. , .
, C
.
, C
C
.
,
41

C
C
, , C
, , C
. ""
( C
),
" (C
CC
),
( C
) , ,
""
( C
). C
C
, C
( ).
, C
, C

C 1988 ,
C
150 . . , C
, C
C ,
" (C
C).
,
, Human Rights
Watch .
: C

, , 6
( , 6
). 6
. ,
, .
,
,
. C
, .
, C
.
, C
, , C

,
:

( ) ,
.


, C
, C
42

C
,
C
.

C
C

.
,

C C
C
,
, C

.
C
,
C
, C
?..
C
,
. C
, C
,
. C
C
C
.
,
C
C, C
, C
C
. C

,
C
, C
,
, C
. C
C
, , C
.
, . ,
, , .

, ,

,

1/2003

, ,


, ,

Haaretz C

, C

,
.

C
. C

, C

, .

, , C

, webC Yediot Ahronot (C

) C

Prof. Zach Adam, Rehovot


Prof. Colman Altman, Haifa
Dr. Janina Altman, Haifa
Tammy Amiel"Houser, Tel Aviv
Chaya Amir, Tel Aviv
Dr. Shmuel Amir, Tel Aviv
Prof. Daniel Amit, Jerusalem/Rome
Yali Amit, Chicago
Dr. Meir Amor, Montreal, Canada
Dr. Yonathan (Jon) Anson, Beer Sheva

Prof. Shalom Baer, Jerusalem


Dan Bar"On, Beer Sheva
Dr. Avner Ben"Amos, Tel Aviv
Prof. Matania Ben"Artzi, Jerusalem
Prof. Linda Ben"Zvi, Tel Aviv
Avi Berg, Tel Aviv
Dr. Louise Bethlehem, Hod Hasharon
Prof. Anat Bilezki, Tel Aviv
Uri Bitan, Haifa
Prof. Daniel Boyarin, Berkeley
43

Boston Globe
, C C
C
C
. C
,
.

C
, C

. C
44

Prof. Micah Leshem, Haifa


Erez Levkovitz, Jerusalem
Prof. Rene Levy, Lausanne
Dr. Orly Lubin, Tel Aviv
Dr. Ruchama Marton, Tel Aviv
Dr. Anat Matar, Tel Aviv
Prof. Paul Mendes"Flohr, Jerusalem
Rabbi Jeremy Milgrom, Jerusalem
Menucha Moravitz, Ramat"Gan
Regev Nathansohn, Tel Aviv
Prof. Avraham Oz, Haifa
Dr. Ilan Pappe, Haifa
Gabriel Piterberg, UCLA
Shakhar Rahav, Berkeley
Dr. Amnon Raz"Krakotzkin, Beer Sheva
Prof. Zvi Razi, Tel Aviv
Prof. Tanya Reinhart, Tel Aviv
Prof. Fanny"Michaela Reisin, Berlin
Prof. Freddie Rokem, Tel Aviv
Prof. Henry Rosenfeld, Haifa
Dr. Maya Rosenfeld, Jerusalem
Ouzi Rotem, Philadelphia
Dr. Hannah Safran, Haifa
Tami Sarfatti, UCLA
Dr. Nita Schechet, Jerusalem
Hillel Schocken, Tel Aviv
Ruben Seroussi, Tel Aviv
Dr. Erella Shadmi, Beit Berl
Prof. Nomi Shir, Beer Sheva
Dr. Miriam Shlesinger, Tel Aviv
Aharon Shabtai, Tel Aviv
Orly Soker, Sapir"Jerusalem
Nurit Steinfeld, Jerusalem
Roman Vater, Tel Aviv
Dr. Roy Wagner, Tel"Aviv
Dr. Michael Yogev, Haifa
Kim Yuval, Tel Aviv
Prof. Moshe Zimmermann, Jerusalem

C

.
C
.
C
, .

. , C
.

.

1/2003

Prof. Victoria Buch, Jerusalem


Smadar Carmon, Toronto
Dr. Nicole Cohen"Addad, Tel Aviv
Dr. Uri Davis, Sakhnin
Athena Elizabeth DeRasmo, Haifa
Prof. Aharon Eviatar, Tel Aviv
Dr. Ovadia Ezra, Tel Aviv
Prof. Emmanuel Farjoun, Jerusalem
Pnina Firestone, Jerusalem
Elizabeth Freund, Jerusalem
Gadi Geiger, Cambridge, MA, USA
Dr. Amira Gelblum, Tel Aviv
Prof. Rachel Giora, Tel Aviv
Dr. Anat Goldrat"First, Netanya
Dr. Ofra Goldstein"Gidoni, Tel Aviv
Dr. Neve Gordon, Beer Sheva
Dr. Yerah Gover, New York
Prof. Charles W. Greenbaum, Jerusalem
Dr. Lev Grinberg, Beer Sheva
Ran HaCohen, Tel Aviv
Prof. Uri Hadar, Tel Aviv
Prof. Galit Hasan"Rokem, Jerusalem
Dr. Sara Helman, Beer Sheva
Prof. Hanna Herzog, Tel Aviv
Prof. Ze'ev Herzog, Tel Aviv
Prof. Hannan Hever, Jerusalem
Dr. Tikva Honig"Parnass, Jerusalem
Shirly Houser, Tel Aviv
Tal Itzhaki, Haifa
Prof. Eva Jablonka, Tel Aviv
Andrea Jacobs, Austin, Texas
Dr. Devorah Kalekin"Fishman, Haifa
Aya Kaniuk, Jerusalem
Prof. Jacob Katriel, Haifa
Prof. Tamar Katriel, Haifa
Prof. Baruch Kimmerling, Jerusalem
Dr. Haggai Kupermintz, Boulder, Colorado
Dr. Ron Kuzar, Haifa
Dr. Ariela Lazar, Evanston



D
,

C
C
, .

C C
, C
C
.
C
. : C
C
, , , CC
, C C
, C


, , C
[5].

:
;
C
C
;
;
() ,
[10].
XX ,

. C
. C
,

. C

,
. ,
,
, C
, C
. C

. C
C
, C

. . , C
XXI C
, CC
C

[9].
C
: C

,
.
C
C
, C
.
C
4C C
. C
5060% C
, , ,
3% . , C
C

45

.
,

C
C C
. C
C C
, C

.
C
, C
,

.
C
C
C

C
, ,
. C
C
C

, C
, C
, , C
,
C
.
C
C
,

,
C
C
, C
, C
. C
C
/ C
. , , C
, C
,
,
.
C

, CC
.
C
C
, C
C
46

.
.., . [1].

C
,
. C
C
. C

C
. , C
C
, C

.
C
C
,

.

, C
C
.

, C
C
.
C
, , C
C

C
.


C
,
C
.
,
, C
, . C
, , C
,
. C
,
C
.
C
.


C
C
.

1/2003

. , C
C
:
, (C
, CC
, C
C
) C
( C
,
) [3].

, C
,
.
C

.
. C
, C
, C
, . C
, C

, ,
C
C
. ,

. ,

, , , C
. , C
C

, , C
.
C
,
C
. . C
, . .
:
C
, , C
, ;
C
, ;

(, C
, C
, C
, , , . .);
,
, ,
[4].

XX C
C
:
C
,
.
C
/
/C
, C
. , C
. C
,
.

C
,
.
C
. C

C
.
, C
,
C
. , C
, , C
, C

C
. C
, C
: C
, C
.
, C
C
C

.
. , ,
C
, C C
C
. . "
"
:
1) C
;
2) ;
3) ;
4) C
;
5)
;
47

6) C ,
() [12].
, , C
, C


.
, C
C
, C
, . C
C
. C

C
. C
,
. C

, C
. , C
C
,
.
. , , C
, C

, C
[2].

C
,
, . ,
C
C
. C
, C
, , C
C C
, C
,
,
. [7]. C

.

C C
C
, . C
, C
, C
. C

,
(, ,
). C
48

C
, C
; C
C
C ,
.
C

. C
C
,
.

, C
C
, .
C
. ,
, C
, C

. C
, C
C
. C
:
,
,
. C
C
: C
; C
, C
. C
C
. . ,
. C


C

.
. "
.
1. , C
.
2. , C
, C

.
3.
.
, C
C
, ,
.

1/2003

, .
, , , C

, .
4. .
, C
,
, [6].
, C
C
,
, , C
, C
, .
C
, C
C
C
. C
: C
, ,
, C
,
, C
, C
C
. C
, C
( C
) ( C
, C
, , C
C
). C
,
. C

, 120 C
C
, 50%
[11].
,
C
, C
,
. C
,
.

.
C ( C
)
.
C
. , C
XXI , C

, , , C
[8].
XXI ,

.

1. . //
. 2001. 6. . 70.
2. .  :
// . 1999.
12. .105.
3. . .
//
 . 2000. 1. . 104105.
4. . . 108109.
5. . .
// 
:
/ . . , . . . .: 
 , 1999. . 15.
. 575, 581.
6. . . 
// . 1999.
4. . 6869.
7. . .
// 
. 12. 
. 1995. 5. . 11.
8. . . : 
//. 2002. 1.
. 87, 96.
9. . XXI 
// . 1992. 2. . 115116.
10. . .
// . 2002. 4. . 64.
11. . . . . 65.
12 . .
// 
. 2001. 8. . 5261.

49

:
?

:
,
, ,


, ,
. , 
(
), 
,

,
.

. ,
. ,
, 
.

. , , 
, .


XX . C
C ,
. 11 , ,
C

.
C
. , C
,
.

? ,
, ?
? C
.
. C
C
, C
. ,
C C
, C
, .

1/2003

?
C
C
, C
, C
, C
, .
, C
C
, . C
: C

;
();
;
C
, ,
(), C
;
, C
.
C
,
C
, . ,


(: . .: , 2000),
...
, ,
C
.
, C
C
,
, , C
, C
,
,
.
C
, C
, , , C
. C

.
. C
, , C
. C
,
C
, , C
C
C
.

, C
( C
) , , C
C
, , .
, C
, ?
C C
.
7
2000 C



. C


C
, C
. . C
: , C
,
. C
,
, ,
C
C
. C
C
, C
C
.
51

C
. C
(80%),
, , ?
C
. , , C

C
. , C
, C
C
. C
, C
C
, , C
.
?

C
. C
C
,
C

. ,
,

, C

1/2003

CC
C
. , C
, .


II:
C
, C
. , , C
C
, , ,
,
, C
, C
....
( . .: C,
1999).
C
? C
, C
.
. C
, C
CC
C
,
.

52

. C
,
,
24 (. .
).
?
.
() C
.
, C
, C
.
, ,
, C

C
( C
). C



, , , C
.
C
.
C
. C
.

:
C
C . C
C
1990C C

, C
60C70C .
,
C
....
C
, ,
, , .

C
( , 1 ), C
( 1 ) C
,
C

( ).


.
C
, C

, , , C

, C
.

, 1974 ,
: , C
,
: C
,
. :
C
.

, C


C
. C
C
. C

C
. ,
C
C

C

. (

.)
C


,
.
, , C
, C

.
, C
.

, , C
, .
. C
C
,
.
. C

. C
, C
, C
.
53

C
C
,
C
. C
, C
, ,
,
. C
, C
, C
. C
, , C
,
, C
, .
.
. C

, C
,
C
, C
, . C

, C
, .
,
C
,
.
, , C
.
C
, C
: C
, C
, ; C
,
,
,
; C
C
, C
, , C
,
C
;
, C
; C

, C
, C


.
54

C
, , C
, . C
, C
,

. , ,
, .
C
,
CC
,
, . , ... C
C
, C
C
C .
C ,
C
. C
. C
C
.
,
, C
, C
.
( ) C
.
C
C
.
C
. C

,
. C

.
C
. , C

C
( ).
, C
, C
.
C
,
.
,
.

, C
. C
. C

1/2003


, C
,
, C
.
: . C
C
C
C
. 80C

11 .
,
, C
, ,
C
. 173
80C ,
20 C
. <...>

105 112.
:
. ,
, ,
C
, C
85C 102 (
, C
).
120
C
C
. C
: 2002 C

200 . .

, C
. , C
120 .
1 2002 C
48,15 C
.
C
1990
2000 . , C
C
26,3 ,
28,6; 65,3;
21,3; C
26,9; 2,1; C
45,9 .

C
, C

C
. ,
C
, C
,

. C
, 14
. C
.


, C
.
C
, C
C
.
.
C C
,
. C
C
, ,
. C

, .
, C
C
, C
. C
C
, C
,
, C
. C
C
, ,
. C

C

,
C
C
C
.
.
, 15 C
, , C
,
, C
.

C
C
55

C C
. , C
C
(, . .),
, C
,
C
.
C

. C
C

. ,
45% C
358
, C
.
.
( C
2000 , 2000 )
57% 6% C
( 30
). C
C
.

C
,
. , C
C
. C
C

C
, , .
C
,
50 ,
.
C
,

C
.

, .
,
, , C
, ,
, C
C
.
C

C , C
56

.

, C
. C

, . C
, C
, , C
.
,
C
. , C
,
, C
.
, C
,
C
, C
.
C
, C
C
, C
.

.
C
. C


C
. C

, C, C
.
, C
60% C
. , C
. C
.
,
XIX , C
C
.
?
C
? .
C
, C

. C

, C
. C

1/2003

C
.
C
C
.

( ), C

(
. . ). C
C
.
. C
,
,
XIX . C
C
, C
.
C
,
.
,

. C
, .
C
, , ,
, C
. C
C
, ,
.
, C

,
.
,
,
, , ,
C
.
, C

? C
: C

?
, C

.
.
. C

.
:

:
C
.

. C
. C
,
C
. , C
, C
. , C
, . , C
, , C C
, C
.
C C
C
,
,

, .
,
C
.
C
: C
, C
, ,
, C
, 1765 .
II ,
.
,
. ,
, ,

, C
.
.
C
( ), C

? , ,


C
? . C
: ,
C
,

.
,
,
,
, .
57

C
, C
, C
,
. , C

. C
C
, C
C , C
, C
. C
, C
,
, C
.

,
.

, ,
,
.
, C
,
: C
, C
C
. , C
, C

( . C
).
, .
. , C
,
,
C
, ,
. ,
58

,
, C
, C
.
C
C
, C
,
,
.


. C
, C
. C
, C
C
C
,
C
. C
,
,
. .
,
1917C , C
.
,

. ,
C
, C
,

.

, C

.
1920C
. C
C
, .
,
( C
C . ), C
: C
C
, C

.

2002 .
,

. , C

1/2003


. , C
, C
, , , , C
. C
C
:
, C
C
.
C
. , C
, C
. C

,
C
. ,
, ,
. , C
,
C
.
C
C
, C
C
.
,
,
.
, C
1917 C
.
, 1990C C
, C
.
?! ,
, C
.
C
?

:
C
,
, ,

. , C
. C
,
, C
.
C
C
: C

, , ,
, . C


, , ,
.

. C
C
,
C
,
C
.
C
.

C
. C
C
,
, C
C
C
.
?


, C
C
,
C
C
, , C
C
.
, C
C ,
CC
. ,
C
, C
C
.

C

,
C
. , C
C
, C
, ,
, C
C
.
59


. , ,
,
.
1993 
, 1995
, 1999
.
, ...

23 50 C
700 .

. ? : . C
, C
, . , , . ,

, . C
,
, .
,
. . ,

C, , C
.
200 ,
, . ,
C
, C
.

1/2003

,
, C
.

, C
, C
, . , C
? C
. C
, ,
, ,
,

: 1999
C
C
C
,
C
,
C
C

,
. . .

. ! C

.
, . C
, C
,
.
, C
C
. C
.
, ,

,
.
.


,
. C
, C
: , , ; C
, , C
,
, .
, , C
.
, , ,
. ,
,
, C
.

C C
C
C
,
. . C
.
, .



C
: C
.

, C
.
C
, , C
(),
, C
. C
, !
C
. , C
. .
24 C

C
,
. , C

,
61

. 8 2002 C
60C
. C
. C
, C
16:20 4 C
, C
, 48C
. , C
C
. ,
, ,
,
.
C
,
C C
C
, C
,
,

. C
C

, C , , .
. , ,
12 C , C
15C C
,
25 . .
,
C
. C
,
.
.
,
( . 31.10.2002).
, 1 ,
C


, 1971 . C
20:30 C ,
, 1974 .
,

. C , C
, C
. .
, .
, C
,
,

C
C

. C

.
().
62

1/2003

, C
,

C
.
,
, C
C
1
, C
,

, :
, .
, C
.
.
C C

:
,
1999 .



, C
, C

.
( C
, C
) C
C

, .
C C
,
, C

, 

.

,
, ,
C
. , C
C
.

C
,
( C
, ),
() C

,
, , C

.

.


,
C
C
.
, () C
C
() C
, , C
. C
: , , C
. . . C
. C
, , C

,
, .
, C
, C
C
. C
(CC
),
( )
( C

).
,
C
63

64

C

.
C
?


, C
C
. ,
,
, C
C

. ,
, C

,
.
,
( )
. C

, C
C
.

.
, , ,
,
C , , ,
.
,
,
,
. C
, : C
C
( C
).
,

. , . .
. , , . .
C C
C
,
C
,
, .
:
C
, .
, C
,
. C

1/2003

,
,
, ,
C
. C
, , ,
,

.
C
, , , C
.
,


.

, Lebenskraft
C
. C
C
C
. C
:
.

,
C
. ( ) C
C
, ,

.
, C
, ,
C
.
:
, ;
; C
C
C
. , , ,
,
, (,
;
, ,
, ; , C
, , ,
, .
[2].
, C
,

, ,
, C

, , , C
C .
C
C
, C

, C
,
C
() . ( C
, ,


,
,
).


,
, , ,
. C
, , C
C
, , C
.

. , C

alter ego . ,
, , C
,
. C
C
. ,
,
; , C
, C
, C
,
, C
.

,
,
, C
.

,
, C
. ,
(. . ) C
, C
,
. C
, C
, C


C
. , . ,
, , C
.
,
, C
, C
C
,
, ,
, C
.



,
, C
C
. : C
, (. 5:17). C
, . .
.
,

, . ,
C
.
()
C
.
C
, C
, . .
,
.

. C
. :

C
, C
, C
, C
, ;
,
, C
, . . [1].

,
, C
.
,
, C
. C
,
65

,
() ,
.
,
, , C
. C
, .

.
: C
C
, C
, , ,
,
. C
, C
(. 2: 19C20)
: C
,
. ,
,
,
, , C
.
,
,
. , C
, C
, .
, C
.
, , C
, , C
. ,
, C
.
: C

, C
C
.
,
, C
: C
.
. C
, C
, .
, C
. C
, C
, C
, , ,
.
, C
, C
66

, , . C
, , C
, C
, ,
( 9:25). ( . C
, ,
, CC
, ,
C
, ).
, , C
C
.
C , ,
C
, C
. C
C
,

, C
C
.
( , C
) , C

. ,
, , .
, ,

,
C
. ,
, , . ,
:
, C
[3].
C
,
C
, , C
. C
, .
. C
.

, C
, . . ,
. :
,
.
C
, .
( ) ,
, C
C

1/2003

, C
.
, , , C
.
C.
,
, C
, . C
: , C
, C
. C
, . ,
: , C
,
: C
, C
[4].
,
, C

,
C
.
, , C
, .
,
, C
(. 1:9). ,
, C
,
.

.
, , ,
.
, ,
, , C
.

( ,
. .). ,
C
, C
.
,
, C
:
, (.
23:38). ,
, , C
, C
, . C
: , C
, .
status quo,
, ,

, ,
.
C
, C
,
C
.


C
,
. C
C
, . , C
,
, , ,
,

, C
. : C
, ( C
)
, ; ,
, ,
.
C
C
C
.
C C
C
:
C
,
C
.

,
, C
,
. . . ,
,
,
, C
( , ,
. .),
, C
.
, C
C
, , ,
C

( C
). C

67

C
: C
,
,
, C
?
C

. C
,
, C
, C

.
, (. 10: 34),
C
C
, C
.
C
, ,
,
,
: C
. C
, C
. C
, . C
C
.
: , C
, (. 21: 8).
. C
, C
, C
,
, C
.

. C
, C

, .
, ,
( , , C
), , C
C
,
,


C
, .
C
. C, C
C
68

C

. C
C
,
, , , ,
. , , C
C
,

.
C
, C
, . C
, C
CC
. C
, ,
, C
C
,
, ,
.
, , ,

, , C
,
C
.
, , C

C
,

C
.
:
C
? C

C

, ,
, ?
,
C
, ,

, C
.


,
, C
, , C
.

1/2003

,
, , ,
. C
, C
, , , C
. C
. C
C
,
, C
,
. C
, . . ,
C
,
. , ,
C
.


. C

, .

C . C
C
,
Filioque .
, C
, , C
C
, C
,
, , ,
. C
, ,
, C
. , C
,
C
, , C
, , C
.
Filioque C
,
:

.
, XI C
, C
C
C
, , C
C
. XVII , C
,

C
. C

CC
, C
C
.
,
, C
. ,
C
. C
C
.
, C
.
C
C
. C
, C
,

C
, C
C
.
,
, C
C
, C

. C
,
() C
,

,
: .
, C
, C
, C
, C

1. . . ., 1986. . 6.
2. . 
// . ., 1991.
. 178.
3. . . 309.
4. . . 307.

69

.
, 

,
, ,
,



.
,

,


.

,

, 


,
,

.

1/2003



( . . )

, 


XIXXX

C
: . (17721823), .
(18181883), . C (18511914) . C
(18511926).
. C
: C
, C

; ,
, C
,
,
[1, . 9799].
. C
, C
, C

. , C
C

, C

[1, . 231].
. C , C

.
,
[1, . 482].
. , C
,
, ,
,
C
. ,
,
C
, [1, . 509, 512].

. (18831950) .
(18631941).

CC
.

C
. C
(18651919). C
C
C C
. , C
C
. ,
C
, . C
, C
, :
, [3].

5070 . C
. C
C
, C
, , C C
. (. , .
)
,
. , ,
C
(. )
.

. . C
,
,
. , 60C
.
C
.
8090 . C

(. ),
(. , . ).
90C C
C
.
8090 . . C
C
. C
C
. , CC
. C
71

C
C . C
C
[2].





, C

. C
C
C
, C
. C
, C
, C
:
. C
C

.
C
C
. C

,
C
. 90C . C
200 C
,
100 .

. C
, C
C
,
. ,
, C
, C
C
.

C
(
12 10 C
). , C

,
(C),
.


. C, C
C
72

. C, C

C
,
C
. C, C
C
, C

.
, C
C
, C
57 . C
20%
, 60%
20% C
. 3/4 C
1 . .
C
: 1)
; 2) C
. C
, C

: , ,
.
C
C
.

.

()
. C
C
C
C
.
C

80C .
,

.
, C
C
,
. C
, C

.
C
.
C

1/2003

. ,
: C
. ,
C CC
C
(),
, C
.
C
. , , C

, C
C

.





. C
,
.

C
C
.
C
19911992 .

C
C
. C

C
, C
.
C

, C
C
.
C C
,

,
: C
(), C
, C C
, .
, C
, C
, C
, C
, .
C
C
. C
.
73

, C
;

.
,
C
. C
.

,
, ,
, C
, ,
,
. C
CC
C
, . .
, C
.
"
, , "
"
:
1. C
,
C.
2. C
,
C
, .
3. C
C

,
CC
. C
: , C
, ,
, C
.
C
C
C ,
.
C
.

, C
.
C

C C
,

.
74

, C
C
.
(84%),
27%
.
C
,
(50%),
(19%). C
C
, C
.

C
C C
, C
, , C
, C
.
C

CC
C
C
. , ,
C C
C
.

,
C
, C
, .
, ,
, C
. C

, ()
. C
,
.
C
,
,
C
C . C
C
, C
C
, C
, , C
. C

(C
),

1/2003


C
. C
C
, C
.
. ,
C, C
, TACIS C
. C
C
,
.

.
(C
C
), ,
C
,

.
C
C
,


Western NIS Enterprise Fund.
1992 .
1% C
( :
, , ,
) 2000 . ( C
C
,
2001 .).
,
, C
. 26 C
, , C
, ,
, C
, .
:
C C
. C
, (
,
C
; C
).
C
.


CC

,


.
,
, C
, ,

, C
.
C
C
. ,
C

.
.
C
, C

C

.
C
C
C ,

C
C
.
C

C
C , ,
, . C
CC
C
.
,
, C
,
, C
.

1. . .
.: , 1994.
2. . ., . . .
 . .: 
, 1989.
3.  . . :
. .:
. . , 1990.
4. . .
.: , 1982.
5. .
.: , 1976.

75

C

C
C
,
,
. .
,
, C
C
,

,
 .

 C C
 ,
,
C
,
,

,
.

,
, ,
. C
C
C


.
,
. C

.
(1941 .). C

C
, C
, C
,
[1]. C

C .

.

76

C
, C
, . C
.

C
, C
. , 1990C
C
C
.
C
,
C
,
[2].
:
C
, C
, C
C
. . [3].
(C
)
, ,
.
1998 , C
, , C
C
.
C
, C
C C
. C
C
C

. , C
(1963 .), (1973 .) [4], ,
, 1995
.
.
, C

1/2003

, C
. C
, C
.
C
,
, C
,
. . C
.
CC
, 1973 C

.

. , . C
C

(1997 .)
[5]. C
, ,
. (, C
C
) , C
, C
[6].
1970C
C C
, , C
, , CC
.
C
C
, C
.
C
, C
, C
, C
.
, C
C
.
C
, C,
, C
. , C
60% (C
, ) , 12% C
, [7].
C
C

(C
).
, C

, ,
. , C

( ),
[8]. ,
, C
.

1. Lasswell H. The garrison state and specialists on vio


lence // The American Journal of Sociology. 1941.
46. P. 455468.
2. Bacevich A. Tradition Abandoned: America's Military
in a New Era // The National Interest. Summer 1997.
48. P. 1625.
3. Soeters J. and Recht R. Culture and Discipline in
Military Academies: An International Comparison //
Journal of Political and Military Sociology. Winter 1998.
Vol. 26, 2. P. 169190.
4. Hauser W. America's Army in Crisis. Baltimore, Md.:
Johns Hopkins University Press, 1973; Keeley J. (Ed.). The All
Volunteer Force and American Society. Charlottesville,
Va.: University Press of Virginia, 1978; Gabriel R. and
Savage P. Crisis in Command. New York: Hill and Wang,
1978.
5. Moskos C. Toward a Postmodern Military: The United
States as a Paradigm. In The Postmodern Military: Armed
Forces After the Cold War. Charles C. Moskos, John Allen
Williams, David R. Segal. (Ed.). New York, Oxford.:
Oxford University Press, 2000. P.19.
6. . , // .
2002. 4 .
7. Nuciary M. Italy: Military for What? In The Postmodern
Military: Armed Forces After the Cold War. Charles C.
Moskos, John Allen Williams, David R. Segal. (Ed.). New
York, Oxford.: Oxford University Press, 2000. P. 145148.
8. Rumsfeld D. Transforming the Military // Foreign Affairs.
May/June 2002. Vol. 81, 3. P. 27.

77

,

, , . 

, .

,
,

, .

10 C
, C
, C
.
,
, C
( ),

. [5, . 257].
,
C
, C
C
C
78

, , ,
C
.
C
, ,

C
C
C
.
,
. ,
C
.
,

, '
<...>, C
, C
' . <>
C
, C
.
C
[5, . 268].
, C
, C
, C

1/2003

: :
[2, . 4].
,

? , , C
C
,
. .? ,
,
.
,
. C

, , C
. C

, , C
C .
.
C
C
C
.
C C
C
, , , , C
.,
( ) C

. C
,
(,
),
, C
,
.
,
C
. C
, CC
[1; 3; 4] C
()
.
:

"
, "
,
(
)
, "
"
"
.
C

,
C
,
.
,
. ., , ,
,
, C
.
, , : ,
C
, C
C

.

C
, , .
C
C .
C
C

. C
,
.
. C
, C
. ,
, C
.

C
. C

, C
.
, C
C
, C
C
.
,
1 (, , ), 0,8,
0,6 . .
26 C
,
(. . 1).
.
C
.
, C
C
.
,
( ) C
79

(
1. .
) 2. , 7 .
3. 14 .
4. 21 .
5. 28 .
6. 28 ,

. C
C
, C
C
C
.
, C

(
) : ; C
; ; ; ; [4].
C
, C

(. . 2).
.
C
, C
( C
, C . ).

, C
C
,
.
C
,

1,0
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
0,1

,
C
C C
[3].
C
, . C
, C
, C
.
C
, C
.
1. () .
2. ().
3. ().
4. ().
5. ().
6. C ().
7. ().

C
, C
, C
.
, C
,

. , C

80

1. #
.
2. , .
3. ,
.
4. ,
.
5.

1,0
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2

1/2003


(, C
).

C
, C
C C
C ,
. ,

C

, C
C
. C
C
. C
,
.
() C
,
.
C

:

:

I

(
)

1. .
2. 7 .
3. 14 .
4. 21 .
5. 28 .
6. 28

1,0
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
0,1

II

III

(
,
)

1. #
.
2.
.
3. #
, .
4. #
, .
5. #

1,0
0,8
0,6
0,3
0,1

1. .
2. .
3. #
#
.

4. ##

.
#
5. #

.
6. #
.
7. #

. 1. 

81

, ,

(
)
()



IIIIV

III

, , ,

( )

. 2. 
.

82

C
C
( ) C
,
.

1. . .
// .
1998. 12. . 4143.
2. . ., . . 
. .: , 2000, 240 .
3. . . 
. .: , 1999.
4. . . : 
. .: ,
2002.
5. . ., . ., . ., 
. .
' . .: 
: . .: , 2002.
456 .

1/2003


C

.

C
(. . 1).
, ,
C
, C C
,
( ).
, C
(C
) ,
C
.
. 2 C
C
: ( C
), ( ), C
.
C
C


*
( . . )

14 , C
. 8 (, , , , , ,
, ),
: + , = , C , , ? . C
, ;
1 14, , . 20 .

_________ _________ ____ ____________
, , _________________________________________

10

11

12

13

14

*. . , . . . .
: C , 2002. . 108115.

83


1. "
:
) . C
;
) .
;
) ;
) ;
) , C
;
) ,
;
) , C
,
;
) C , C
, .
2. "
:
) C
;
) ;
) C
, ;
) C
;
) ;
)
;
) ,
, ;
) ,
.
3.

:
) , ;
) ;
) ;
) ;
) ;
) , C
;
) ;
) .
4. "
:
) (, ,
. .);
) ( , C
);
) ;
) , , C
;
) ;
84

) , C
( , );
) ,
;
) , , .
5. "
, , ,
, :
) ;
) ;
) ;
) ;
) , ;
) ;
) , C
;
) , .
6. "
" ,
, , :
) , ;
) (, C
);
) (,
);
) ;
) , , C
;
) ;
) , C
;
) ,
.
7. "
:
) ,
;
) ;
) , ;
) ;
) ;
) ();
) ;
) , , , .
8. , :
)
;
) , ;
) ;
) ;
) C
;
) ;
) C
;
) .

1/2003

9.
, :
) , ;
) C
;
) , ;
) , C
;
) ;
) ;
) ;
) .
10.
:
) ;
) ;
) ;
) ;
) C C
;
) C
;
)
;
) C
.
11. "
:
) ;
) ;
) ;
) ;
) C
;
) , ;
) ;
) C , .
12. , ,
:
) , ;
) ;
) , C
;
) ;
) ;
) ;
) ;
) .
13. , :
) ;
) , ;
) , ;
) ;
) , ;
)
;

) ;
) .
14. , "
, :
) ;
) C ,
;
) , ;
) , ;
) ;
) , ,
, ;
) , ;
)
.

( )
: + 2 , = 1 ,
C ? 0 .
: (),
(), (), C
(), (),
(),
().

()
: 1,; 2; 3; 4;
5; 6; 8; 10; 11; 12; ()
2,; 3; 4; 5,; 7; 9; 11,; 12; C
() 1; 2; 7,; 9,,; 10 ; 11;
12,; () 1; 2; 3; 4; 7,;
8,; 9,; 10; 11 ; 12; C
() 1,; 4,; 5; 6,,; 7; 9; 10; 12;
() 1 ,; 3;
4; 5,; 6; 7,; 8,; 11; 12 C
() 1; 2; 3,; 4 ,; 5,; 6;
8; 9; 10,; 11 ,; 12.
,,, C
C
, , , C
.
( C
),
, .

C
, , C
C
. (
) , , , ,
C
.
85


,
C
C
, C
. C
C
, C
C
C
,
C .


C

C
,
,

, ,
.
, ,
C
C
.

.
.
, ,
, , C
, , C

1/2003


:

'


, ,
,
.
C
C
,
. ,
C

. C


.
C
,
, .

C

.
C

. C
, C
C
: ,
, C
, , ,
.
C

, C
.
C
,

,
.
, C
,
. 60% C

. C

.
,
, C
C

,
C
,

. C
C
, , C
, C
.



. C
,
, C
C
.
,
, , , , ,
, C
, C
.
90C95% , 5060%
.
50%
. C
C
, C
, C
30C50
.
:
1000 ( C
) 90C
. 2,7, 22,5 ,
(45), 37 , (74,2).
,

,
. C
C

.

. ,
, , C
: C
, C
87

'

C
, C
. C
2000 , C
, 2626
.


:

;
, C
;
.
C
,

, , . C
C
, , , . C

C
,
C
, ,
.
, C
:

1/2003

, ,
.
, C
, , C
,
C

.

90C C
9 9,5. C

, :
60%, 10%, 65%,
51%. C
C
. C
, ,
, 60% .
, C
C
40C50%. C
C
, C
. C
, 1996 281,6 . C
, 91,6 .,
(32,6%).

88

'

1.
C
.
2. C
, C
.
3. C
.
4. .
5. C
, , C
.
6. .
7. C
.
, , C

, C
. 90C ,
C
, .
1992
C

C
. C
1992 . C
C C
. C

01.01.1995 . C
C
.
C
C
,

, C
CC
, C
,
. .

,
,
, C
, C
,
.
C
C
, C
,
. , , C

, C
, C
. C
,
C C
, ,
,
.

1. . .
//
. 1998. 9. . 122.
2. / . . . 
. .: , 1997. . 501; 781.
(864 .)
3. . ., . .
( 
). .:  , 1998.
. 5. (63 .)
4. . . 
// . 1998. 9.
. 110113.
5. . . .,
1991. . 6. (99 .)
6. . . .
.: , 1987. . 2943. (175 .)
7. . .
// 
. 1995. 12. . 6.
(. 7681)
8. .
// . 1995. 27
28. . 28. (. 2832)
9. . , . . 
: . . : , 1997. . 664.
(671 .)
10. . . 
. .: 
, 1997. . 9. (304 .)
11. . .
( 
): . . . .: 08.01.01./
. I. . ,
1999. . 2223.
12. :
/ . . . . .:
,
1997. . 63. (142 .)
13. // 
. 1995. 7. . 36. (. 3339)
14. .
( ) // 
. 1995. 10. . 59. (5662).
15. . : ? //
. 1997. 1. .18.
16. Aksyonov I. How to Improve the Regulatory
Conditions for Small Business // The Ukrainian Legal and
Economic Bulletin. 1997. No 4. P. 10. (P. 917.)
17. Problems of Small Business in Ukraine // The
Ukrainian Legal and Economic Bulletin. 1997. 12.
P. 10. (P. 1215)
18. Storey D. Understanding the Small Business Sector.
London: Boutledge, 1995. . 13.

89

'

90

. C
,
.

,

1.
C
. C
,
:
;
;
.
,
:
C
;
, ;
CC
C
.
C

, , , C
. C
. C
.
C
:
, C
, .
2.


. C
: ,
C
.
, , ,

1/2003



,
C
(. ,
. , . , . ,
. ) : C
C
C
, C
,
.


, 

CC
, . , C
, C
C
. , C
, , C
(. ) C
C
.
.
,
, C
. ,
C

C
.
C
,
. C
C
. , C
,
, C
C
.
C
C

'

.

:
, C
.
3.
C
C

C
. C
:
, C
.
.
4.
,
.

: ,
, C

. C
,
.

.
C
.
C
.
C
, C
, .
C

C .



! C
C. C
C
. ,
, C
C
. , . : C
,
.
.
C
.



.
, ,
C
. : C
, , .
C
. , ,
:
;
;
C
.

, C
.

, C
,
, C
.

. .
, C
C
.
C
C
. C

, :
, C

,

C .
.
, , , C
, , 6
, C , C 6
, , , 6
. C
. , ,
. , C ,
C , , 6
. C , , .
91

92

,

, C
,

.



C
C
C
. 1997
C
()
,
C
Internet, C
. C
C
.
18 69 C
C
: , C
, C

1/2003





C
C
,
C
(), .
, C
C
1972 C C
C
1992 .
C
C
, C


C
.
,

,
C
C
, C
C
. ,



,
C
C


,


250 C
C
C

. C

, C
. C
, C
, C
, .
C
:

. C
C,
C
, C
.
1 2003
C
(C
) C
.

C


C
. C
C

C


.
, 2004


,

C
C
C
C


,
.

C
C
C
C

.
C
C

C
C
Edusat, C
Internet C
.
C
C
. 2728 C

, ,
C
,
.

93

NNOTATIONS



19321933

C
C 30C .
. ,

, C

,
'
.

Igor HYZHNYAK
The national measuring in premises
of 19321933s Golodomor origin
in Ukraine
The article is dedicated to the analysis of the Great
Famine genocide of 193233. Based on hypothesis
that the Soviet Russia governance in its ideological
orientation held Zionist postulates, being transformed
later in peculiar ideology of the Bolshevist Zionism,
the author reveals essential correlation of the given
ideology with Great Famine actions in Volga region
and Ukraine.






. C
, C
,

,
, ,
C
.



C

. ,
, C

. , C

C
,
.
94

Vladimir MANDRAGELYA
Some aspects of military
and civil education integration
in the context of world experience
The author researches the problems of military and
civil education integration in the modern conditions.
Having analyzed the tendencies of the last decades,
which are characterized by information technologies
development, interosculation of military and civil
spheres of life, transformation of armed forces funcC
tion, the author comes to the conclusion, that more
close organizational and contansive interaction in the
sphere of military and civil education is necessary.
Victor SHPAK
The formation and development
of the small business in the transition
economy stage
The importance of small and medium entrepreneurC
ship in the conditions of the transition economy is
revealed in the article. Starting from the world experiC
ence one may state that the weak development of small
business is the one of the main reasons of economical
stagnation. From the author's viewpoint, the largest
obstacles for small entrepreneurship formation in
Ukraine are passive state policy in process of small
business motivation, unreasoned legislative base, and
tax pressure.

1/2003




C
,
. C
( ), C
C
. , C
, ,
,
.

Rustem DZHANGUZHYN
The Iraqi campaign as a new phase
of global policy development
The situation, which has developed around the
expected military actions against Iraq, is analyzed in
the article. Having spread out the given problem on
two basic components (economical and political),
the author offers his vision of probable consequences
of the antiCIraq campaign. From his view point, the
main complexities of this conflict are concerned, on
the one hand, with especially Western conception of
the Arab fundamentalism, and, on the other hand,
with restructuring of the region.

95

1/2003

96

Оценить