Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Thename"HundredYears'War"ismisleading Thedatesoftheconflict(13371453)covera116yearperiod Therewasnotcontinualfightingforahundredyears.(Truces,BlackDeath) Theactualtimefighting,whenaddedup,comestomuchlessthanonehundredyears Peopleatthetimedidnotseethebattlesaspartofasinglecampaignandprobably referredtotheconflictastheFrenchWars WhatwecalltheHundredYears'Warwasaseriesofbattlesduringthelatterpartofthe MiddleAgesinwhichtheEnglishkingstriedtoasserttheirrighttotheFrenchthrone andwasresistedbytheFrench. TheHundredYearsWarisoftendividedintothreewars 1) TheEdwardianWar13371360 2) TheCarolineWar 13691389 3) TheHenricianWar14151453
1. General Introduction
Longtermcauses 1EversinceWilliamI,EnglishkingsholdinglandinFrancehadproveda concernforFrenchkings.FrancewasatraditionalenemyofEnglandwith WilliamII,HenryI,HenryII,RichardI,John,HenryII,EdwardIallgoingtowar withFranceatsometimeorother.HenryIIhadruledmoreFrenchlandsthan thekingofFrance.Thishistoryofdisputeandfrictionmadeitmorelikely thatwarwouldbreakout. Shorttermcauses Between1327and1377aseriesofeventsledEdwardIIItodeclarewaronFrance.Thiswasnota kneejerkreactionbutameasuredresponsetowhatwasseenasFrenchaggressionand provocation.
ClaimtoFrenchthroneDynastic 2:In1328,KingCharlesIVofFrancehaddiedleavingnomaleheir.EdwardIIIputforwardhis claimthroughhismother,daughterofPhilipIV.TheFrenchignoredhisclaimfirstlyasitwas throughawoman(SalicLaw)andsecondlybecausehewastheKingofEngland.TheFrenchwanted theEnglishoutofFrancenotrulingit!Edwardwasdisappointedbutnotsurprisedandchoseat thisstagetodonothing.In1337inresponsetoFrenchactionsherenewedhisclaim. WoolBlockadeEconomic/Financial 3.EnglishwoolwasthebestinEuropeandpreferredbyFlemishmerchantstoFrenchwool.Philip orderedtheCountofFlanderstobantheexportofwooltoFlanders.PhilipVIalsoencouraged piratesandFrenchnavytoattackEnglishshipscarryingwooltoFlanders.TheFrenchweretrying tostrangletheEnglishwooltrade.Woolwasthemedievalequivalenttooilintermsofwealth creation.ThiswasbadforEnglandseconomy. InvasionofGascony_Economic/Financial/territorial 4.In1337,PhilipVIofFranceinvadedGascony.Gasconywasthecentreofthevitalwineandsalt tradebetweenEnglandandthecontinent.Englishmerchantswantedtothislargepartofthewine producingmarketbecauseitmadeyouveryrich.Edwardlostmoneyastaxespaidontheimportof wineandsaltwerepaidtohim(TonnageandPoundage).Winewasanimportantpartofthe Medievaldietduetotheirhighcaloriecontentandtheirpreservativequalities.FromGascony EdwardhopedtoextendcontrolfurtherintoFranceandgainaccesstoevenrichervineyards. FrenchalliancewithScotlandPolitical 5:EdwardIIIwantedtocompletehisgrandfather'sconquestofScotland.Francehadalwaysgiven helptotheScottishintheirfightagainstEngland.FrancehasgivensanctuarytoDavidBruceafter thedefeatoftheScotsatHalidonHillin1333.In1337,theEnglishNavyinterceptedFrenchShips carryingtroopsandweaponstoScotlandsupportinganinvasionofEnglandonbehalfofDavid Bruce.Edwardviewedthisasanactofwar. AmbitionPolitical 6.EdwardIIIwasyoung,ambitiousandbraveandhelikedfighting.Hewantedthegloryand excitementofawarwithFrance.EdwardwantedtorebuildtheAngevinEmpirelostduringthe reignsofJohnandHenryIII.LikeRichardIandhisgrandfather(EdwardI)hewasexpectedto achievegreatthingsinbattle.(Criteriaforagoodking!) ProblemsinEnglandPolitical 7.AwaragainstFrancewouldunitetheEnglishbaronsandstopinternalfeuding.
5.
26 th August 1346
1) Edwardchosehisgroundcarefullyonaslopeofahillwithhisflanksprotectedbyriver,marshand
woodland.(Reducedthreatofknightsandbeingsurrounded/outflanked) 2) Frenchforcesnumberedapproximately36,000. 3) Englishforcesnumberedapprox.12,000,including7,000archers 4) Edwardorderedmostofhismenatarmsto dismount.Hethenarrangedthreegroupsof menatarmsandspearmen,witharchers placedontheirsides.Thearchersformedranks A resemblinganoutwardV.Smallpitsweredug infrontofthemtotripuphorses. 5) Edwardheldareservedivisionofmenat armsandarcherstopluganyholesandallow B foranescapeifnecessary. 6) Thebattlelinewas2,000metreswide. Ridge 7) TheFrenchwereextremelyconfidentwiththeFrenchnoblesdiscussingwhomthey weregoingtotakeasprisoners.TheKingofMajorcahadalreadynamedEdwardIIIas hisprisoner!TheFrenchkingPhilipVIorderedtheraisingofthebannerofStDenis.Thissignifiedthat therewastobenomercyshowntotheEnglishandthatnoprisonerswouldbetaken.EdwardIIIreplied byraisinghisDragonbannerstatingthatnoquarterwouldbeshowntotheFrench.Themindgames hadstarted!
8) EdwardwaitedfortheFrenchtoattack. 9)At4pmTheFrenchking,PhilipVIsentforwardhisGenoesecrossbowmen,whilehisknightswere preparingforachargetoannihilate"ThecontemptiblelittleEnglisharmy."Astheyadvanced,asudden rainstormswirledaroundthetwoarmies.TheEnglisharchersremovedtheirbowstringstocoverinside theirjacketsandhats;thecrossbowmencouldtakenosuchprecautionswiththeircumbersomeweapons. 10)TheChroniclerFroissartdescribestheGenoeseaswhoopingandshouting.OncetheEnglish formationwaswithincrossbowrangetheGenoesefiredtheirbolts;buttherainhadloosenedthestrings oftheircrossbowsandtheirshotsfellshort.TheintentionwasfortheGenoesetocreateaholeinthe Englishlines,whichcouldthenbeenteredbyFrenchknightswhowouldthenattacktheEnglishfromthe rearwhilstanotherdivisionofFrenchknightsattackedfromthefront. 11)Froissartthensays:TheEnglisharcherseachsteppedforthonepace,drewthebowstringtohisear, andlettheirarrowsfly;sowhollyandsothickthatitseemedassnow.TheGenoesecrossbowmenwere nomatchfortheEnglisharcherswhooutrangedthemandhadaquickerfirerate.(16permin3permin)
(EachEnglisharchercarriedtwosheavesofarrows(48)intobattle.Resupplywasaccomplishedbygoingbackthroughthe linesorhavingmorearrowsbroughtforward.)15)Arrows,dependingontypeandweight,couldbeshot250to300metres. TheEnglisharcherscouldshootanaverageof10arrowsperminute.
12)ThebarrageinflictedsignificantcasualtiesontheGenoeseandforcedthemtoretreat. 13)TheFrenchknightsbecameimpatientandbegantheirattackridingdownmanyoftheunfortunate Genoeseastheywent.AstheFrenchknightscharged,theyhadtoridetotheirrighttoavoidaridge, whichsquashedtheFrenchknightsintoacompactunit!TheEnglisharchersshotablanketvolleyofarrows rightintothechargingknights.Theirhorsesswerved,plungedandreared.SoontheFrenchknightswere intotaldisorder. 14)TheFrenchknightsintherearmistooktheagonisingcriesofthecrushedGenoeseasthoseofthe Englishandchargedforward,eagernottomissoutonanopportunitytograbtheirprisoners.Repeatedly theFrenchknightstriedtochargebuteachtimetheyweremetwithahailofdeadlyarrows. 15)Thetotalnumberofarrowsshotduringthebattleisestimatedatmillion 16)Fromthestartofthebattleat4:00pmuntiltheendatmidnight,therewere14to16chargesmade againsttheEnglishlines. 17)Casualtieswereestimatedfrom5,000(low)to10,000ormore(high)fortheFrenchKnightsand Genoesecrossbowmen.Englishcasualtieswereseveralhundred.(700) 18)Edward,thesixteenyearoldBlackPrincewonhisspurs. 19)Asmall,trainedprofessionalarmyhaddefeatedalargedisorderlyfeudalarmy.
Knights
Crossbowmen
Longbowmen
EdwardIIIsInfantry
Artillery
8. Why did Edward III win the Battle of Crcy?
BattlePosition
Hechosehisbattlepositionwell.Hewasoutnumbered.Hissideswereprotectedby woodsandriverwhichwouldpreventtheFrenchfromsurroundinghimorattackinghis armyfrombehind.WoodsdidnotsuitFrenchknightsonhorseback.Therewasaslight slopeupwardstotheEnglisharmy.Thiswouldfavourhisarchersandmakeahorse chargemoredifficult.Slopedisadvantagedcrossbowfirebutaidedlongbowmen.Slope alsogaveEdwardbetterview.Philipsviewwasnotasgood.
Battleformation
Englishoutnumbered31.Edwardhadtoensurethatheusedallhissoldiers.He arrangedarchersinoutwardVshape.Thismeantthatallhisarcherscouldfireatthe sametimeandhitadeeperandlargerareaofFrenchtroops.Knightsdismounted, armedthemselveswithpolearms,togiveprotectiontoarcherswhowerealsoplaced behindwoodenstakesandpits.
BattleTactics
Edwardsuseofarcherswasdecisive.Archersfiringdiagonallyensuredgreaterhits. TheycouldpickofftheFrenchfromadistance.Edwardrealisedthatalthoughthedays oftheknight(heavycavalry)werenearlyover,his5,000knightswerenomatchforthe 20,000French.
Mentalattitude
Despitebeingoutnumbered,theEnglishwereorganised,hadaclearplanofactionand werepositiveintheirminds.EdwardcounteredFrenchmindgames.
Battletactics
Knightswerenolongerthethreatorforcethattheyhadbeenovertheprevious150 years.Countertacticstotheknighthadbeendeveloped(pits,pikes,longbow).French hadnotadaptedtoevolution(change)ofwarfare.Crossbowlimiteduseagainst longbow(firerate,distance,reliability).LimitedwidthofbattlefieldmeantthatFrench couldnotdeployalltheirtroopsatthesametime.
Lackofcommand
Frencharmywasfeudal(Englishwasprofessional).Menfromdifferentregionswould notcooperatewitheachotherortakecommands.UnitsofFrencharmywereworking independentlyofeachotherwithnocentralcoordinationorcommand. 10. The Siege of Calais (Sept4th1346toAug.4th1347 ) 2 n d Campaign
AfterCrcy,Edwardrealisedthathisarmywasnotbigenoughtofollowalengthy campaign.HemarchedtothecoastandlaidsiegetoCalais.Calaiswasanimportant portandhadbeenhometomanyofthepirateswhowereharassingEnglishshipsinthe Channel. ThesiegelastedfromSept4th1346toAug.4th1347duringwhichtimeEdward hadsuppliesandreinforcementsshippedinfromEngland.PhilipVItriedtocausea diversionbysupportingarebellioninScotland,butDavidBrucewascapturedatthe BattleofNeville'sCrossandtheplanfailed.PhilipfailedinhisattemptstohelpCalais andtheinhabitantswerereducedtoeatingcatsanddogs. TheEnglishtroopsweregettingrestlessandthefleetwasthreateningtomutiny. FinallyCalaisstarvedintosurrenderonthe4thAugust,1347.Apparentlyatthefinish, sixoftheleadingcitizenscametoEdwardwithropesaroundtheirnecksreadyfor execution.Theybroughtwiththemthekeystothetown.Edwardwasabouttoexecute themwhenQueenPhillippaintervenedandEdwardreluctantlysparedtheirlives. ThecaptureofCalaisgavetheEnglishcontroloftheChannelStraitsandmade CalaisthecentralmarketforEnglishwool.EnglishpeoplewereinvitedtoliveinCalais byEdwardanditremainedinEnglishhandsuntil1558. TiredandwiththethreatoftheBlackDeathlooming,Edwardmadeatrucewith PhilipVIandreturnedtoEnglandtoenjoyhistriumph.
Despitethetruceof1347,therewerestillbandsofmercenarysoldierswho
remainedinFrance.Thebandsweremadeupofmanynationalities,English,French, SwissGenoeseandSpanish.Oneachsidetheseruthlessmercenariesmadealivingby robberyandviolence.Theystolefood,raidedhousesforvaluables,attackedcastles, townsandvillagesandheldhostagesforransom.Theywerequitehappytokillanyone whoopposedthem.These'freecompanies'operatedthroughoutthewarevenwhen thereweretruces.Theywerenotmerelyhooliganbands,butwereoftenledby respectablebaronswhofoughtnotonlyforlootbutadventureandforwhomwarwasa sport.Theyweresoldiersoffortune.AmongthefamousleaderswasBertranddu Guesclin.Evenwhenwarwasgoingonthesemercenariessoldtheirservicestovarious princesanddukes.Thesehiredsoldiers,oftengreedy,brutal,andundisciplined,were capableofdesertingontheeveofbattle,betrayingtheirpatrons,andplundering civilians.Muchoftheirmutinousbehaviourwastheresultoftheiremployer's unwillingnessorinabilitytopayfortheirservices.Whenrigiddiscipline,sustainedby promptpayment,wasenforced(asinthearmyofMauriceofNassau),mercenariescould provetobeeffectivesoldiers.