Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
No. 1 Operational Deviations Overpressure Failure Scenarios Liquid overfill resulting in back pressure or excessive static head Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Emergency relief device Level device interlocked to prevent overfill Vessels (3) Procedural Instructions to monitor level during transfer Verify tank has sufficient free board prior to transfer High level alarm with instructions to intervene to prevent overfilling
Overpressure
pressure rating of vessel Incompatible utility couplings to prevent connections of high pressure utilities Mechanical flow restriction (e.g., restriction orifice) of utility with open vent on vessel Vessel design accommodating maximum utility pressure
No. 3 4(T)
Inherently Safer/Passive
fixed roof (see procedural) Ignition source controls (e.g., lightning protection, permanent grounding/bonding, nonsplash filling including dip pipe, fill line flow restriction, or bottom inlet) Vessel design accommodating deflagration pressure Store below flash point (if not heating) Use non-intrusive instrumentation (e.g., radar level detection)
Oxygen analyzer with alarm Instructions to feed empty tanks frangible roof for fixed roof at low rate until fill line tank) submerged, avoiding splash Store material at temperature filling below its flash point (cooling) No transfers during electrical Vapor space combustible storms concentration control Low feed rate until floating roof Vapor space inerting is afloat Flame arrester in vent path Emergency purge and/or isolation activated by detection of flammable atmosphere
Overpressure
diameter larger than fill line for short vent lines) Flow restriction orifice in fill line Vessel design accommodating maximum supply pressure
Flow shutdown interlock activated by high pressure or high flow Automated flow control loop on fill line with high flow alarm Emergency relief device
Operating instructions to limit flow to a maximum safe value Operating instructions to monitor filling rate and intervene to prevent excessive fill rate
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-2
3
No. 6 Operational Deviations Overpressure Failure Scenarios External fire Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Emergency response plan Manual activation of fixed fire protection water spray (deluge) and/or foam systems
Buried (underground or
bermed) tank (consider environmental issues) Fireproof insulation (limits heat input) Slope-away diking with remote impounding of spills Locate outside fire affected zone Provide recommended tank-totank separation
spray(deluge) and/or foam systems activated by flammable gas, flame, and/or smoke detection devices Emergency relief device
Overpressure
Inadequate or obstructed vent path, resulting in high vapor space pressure during filling
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Periodic sampling/ analysis of contents for leakage Emergency action plan to transfer contents to safe location if adverse reaction can occur
No. 8
Inherently Safer/Passive
(panel coil) Use of heating/cooling medium which is not reactive with vessel contents Vessel design accommodating maximum heating/cooling medium pressure Use electrical heating Use lower pressure/temperature heating or cooling medium Vessel design accomodating maximum stored material vapor pressure at maximum heating medium temperature
High pressure interlock that activates utility closure Back pressure control with external heating/cooling circulation to avoid leak into vessel
Overpressure
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-4
5
No. 10 Operational Deviations Overpressure Failure Scenarios Excessive heat input resulting in high vapor pressure Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural High temperature or pressure alarm with operator activation of heating medium isolation
maximum expected pressure Limit the temperature or flow of the heating medium (e.g., use hot water instead of steam)
High temperature or pressure alarm and interlock which isolates the heating medium
11 12( T)
Overpressure
maximum expected pressure Limit or avoid the storage or unintended accumulation of reactive materials Consume reactive intermediate process materials as soon as they are produced
Operating instructions to periodically test for inhibitor High temperature and/or concentration or activity pressure alarm and automatic High temperature and/or addition of quench/diluent pressure alarm and manual fluid or inhibitor addition of quench, diluent or Automatic activation of inhibitor emergency cooling system Manual activation of quench or cooling system Periodic draining of accumulation points (i.e., knock-out pots)
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Operator startup of spare compressor on high pressure indication
No. 13
Failure Scenarios Control or equipment failure in vapor recovery system on refrigerated/chilled storage
Inherently Safer/Passive
14 (T)
Overpressure
maximum expected pressure Use of in-line mixer external to vessel to premix feeds Provide tank filling system design that avoids tank stratification (e.g., top splash filling)
Mechanically agitate or
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-6
7
No. 15 Operational Deviations Overpressure Failure Scenarios Failure of upstream process controls, resulting in vapor or flashing liquid feed Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Operator activation of flow isolation on high pressure indication
16
Overpressure
maximum expected pressure Use of buried (underground or aboveground) tank Insulate tank Open vent on fixed roof tanks Place tank under a roof Use reflective coating on vessel
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Procedures for securing valves open via seals or locks
No. 17
Inherently Safer/Passive
Vessel design accommodating Emergency relief device maximum upstream pressure Interlock to isolate vessel inlet Eliminate unnecessary outlet or trip feed pump on high block valves pressure Outlet sized to eliminate or reduce likelihood of plugging
18
Overpressure
maximum expected temperature and pressure Use of external recirculation heating system Maintain submergence of heating surface by locating liquid withdrawal connection above the heating element Limit temperature of heating medium Selection of materials to avoid rust (i.e., eliminate potential catalytic effects)
low level alarm and shutdown of liquid withdrawal system to ensure liquid is above heating surface at all times Vapor space inerting
Operating instructions to
maintain liquid level above heating surface at all times Manual response to low level indication
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-8
9
No. 19 Operational Deviations Overpressure Failure Scenarios Heating and thermal expansion of liquid Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural
Temperature controls on Operating instructions on heating medium to prevent control of temperature below overheating a certain limit, or restrictions High level shutoff preventing on the length of time that liquid from rising above level heat can be applied where expansion would cause Instructions on limiting the overfill maximum liquid level Thermal expansion relief valve Manual shutoff on detection of high level Instructions on draining vessel or isolating source of heat input before blocking in
20 21
Electrostatic spark discharge and ignition of vapors during charging of solids through an open manhole or charging chute resulting in deflagration or flash fire
Eliminate addition of materials as solids (e.g., use slurry) Charging of solids through a nozzle by means of a closed system (e.g., hopper and rotary airlock, screw feeder, double-dump valve system, etc.)
Automatic inerting of vessel Manual inerting of vessel prior prior to solids addition to solids addition Ground indicator with interlock Procedures for manual to prevent manhole opening grounding and bonding of if ground connection to solids solids container and funnel to container is faulty vessel Ground operator Avoid use of non-conductive plastic containers Verify acceptable oxygen concentration before charging
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Periodic inspection of roof seals Periodic testing for combustibles in tank vapor space
No. 22 23( T)
Failure Scenarios Ignition of flammable atmosphere in tank vapor space following seal failure on internal floating roof
Inherently Safer/Passive Provide double roof seal Provide adequate natural ventilation between fixed roof and floating deck Eliminate fixed roof provided over the floating deck Ignition source controls (e.g., lightning protection, permanent grounding/bonding)
inerting Provide inerting between fixed roof and floating deck End-of-line flame arrester
24 (T)
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-10
11
No. 25 (T) Operational Failure Scenarios Deviations Underpressure or Obstructed vent path Vacuum Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural
26 (T)
No. 27 (T)
Operational Failure Scenarios Deviations Underpressure or Excessive liquid withdrawal Vacuum rate
Inherently Safer/Passive
28 (T)
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-12
13
No. 29 (T) Operational Failure Scenarios Deviations Underpressure or Control or equipment failure Vacuum in vapor recovery system on refrigerated/chilled storage Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Manual shutdown of compressor/blower on low pressure alarm
control system to minimize vacuum Air vacuum breaker device Interlock to shutdown compressor/blower on low pressure
30
High external pressure on vessel walls from water level in dike or vault resulting in dislodging tank or external collapse of tank wall
Operating instructions to
inspect dike periodically and drain as necessary Operating instructions to drain storm water collected in the dike after heavy rainfall Keep tanks filled to a minimum liquid level
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Instructions to cool or shut off feed when temperature rises above a certain level
No. 31
Inherently Safer/Passive
32
High Temperature
High temperature alarm and shutdown interlock Auxiliary cooling/quench or heat transfer system Emergency relief device
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-14
15
No. 33 Operational Deviations High Temperature Failure Scenarios Chemical reaction (also see Chapter 4) Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural
Emergency relief device High temperature alarm and maximum expected interlock shutdown temperature and pressure of a possible exothermic reaction Automatic addition of reaction inhibitor and/or quench fluid Substitute less-reactive material Automatic activation of emergency cooling system
34
High Temperature
aboveground) tank (consider environmental issues) Insulate with fireproof insulation Provide remote impounding of flammable liquid spills Locate vessel to minimize exposure Provide recommended tank-totank spacing
spray (deluge) and/or foam systems activated by flammable gas, flame, and/or smoke detection devices Emergency relief device Fire detectors
Emergency response procedures Manual activation of fixed fire protection water spray (deluge) and/or foam systems Monitoring of vessel wall temperature with thermocouples or optical devices
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active Agitator shutdown on high temperature detection Vessels (3) Procedural Instructions to turn off agitator on high temperature indication
No. 35
Inherently Safer/Passive
36
Low Temperature
minimum expected (ambient) temperature Use of buried (underground or aboveground) tank Insulate tank Locate equipment indoors
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-16
17
No. 37 Operational Deviations Low Temperature Failure Scenarios Control failure of heating/cooling system Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Low temperature alarm and shutdown interlock Auxiliary heating system Vessels (3) Procedural Operate system manually or activate back-up heating/cooling system
38
Low Temperature
Low temperature alarm and feed isolation interlock Low temperature alarm activates external heating
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active Low temperature alarm and refrigerant system shutdown and/or isolation interlock Vessels (3) Procedural Manual system shutdown on low temperature indication
No. 39
Inherently Safer/Passive
40
Low Temperature
Instructions to deinventory liquid before depressuring Instructions to warm-up vessel before repressuring
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-18
19
No. 41 Operational Deviations Over-fill Failure Scenarios Level control failure causing spill Inherently Safer/Passive Install open overflow nozzle to containment system Closed loop filling Diking or drainage to remote impounding Potential Design Solutions Active feed cutoff/isolation Vessels (3) Procedural level reaches a certain point
42
Over-fill
correct or permitted crossconnections between tanks and vessels Operating/maintenance instructions to isolate tanks via blinding and disconnection Manual isolation on high level
No. 43
Inherently Safer/Passive
High level alarm and automatic containment system heating/cooling medium External heating/cooling system cutoff/isolation Operation of heating/cooling Electrical bonding of floating system at pressures below roof to tank process pressure Double tubesheet heat exchanger Intermediate heat transfer fluid at a pressure below process pressure
44
Over-fill
Leak or excessive fill from liquid utility system (e.g., utility water)
Operator isolation (e.g., disconnection, blinding, double block and vent) of utilities Leak detection devices (e.g., pH, conductivity, capacitance) and manual isolation
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-20
21
No. 45 Operational Deviations Low Level Failure Scenarios Level control failure Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Manual shutoff on low level indication
preventing further liquid withdrawal from vessel via either pump shutdown or closure of block valve
46
Low Level
maintain a minimum liquid level in the vessel Eliminate all unnecessary crossconnections Use incompatible couplings to avoid improper crossconnections where hoses are used
preventing further liquid withdrawal from vessel via either pump shutdown or closure of block valve
Operating instructions on the correct or permitted crossconnections between tanks and vessels Operating/maintenance instructions to isolate tanks via blinding and disconnection Manual outflow isolation on low level indication
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active Low level alarm with interlock to automatically shutdown the transfer pump Electrical bonding of floating roof to tank Vessels (3) Procedural Operating instructions to monitor tank level periodically
No. 47
Failure Scenarios Ignition of flammable atmosphere in tank vapor space following low level that results in floating roof sitting on its internal legs
Inherently Safer/Passive
48
Loss of Containment
Incompletely submerged agitator impeller causes excessive forces on vessel wall and heads
maintain a minimum liquid level in the vessel Agitator designed to run stably during filling and emptying (e.g., stiffer shaft, foot bearing)
further liquid withdrawal from vessel Low level alarm with interlock to automatically shutdown the agitator
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-22
23
No. 49 Operational Deviations Loss of Containment Failure Scenarios Corrosion from process fluid Inherently Safer/Passive Use corrosion resistant materials of construction Protective coatings and paints Double walled tank design Potential Design Solutions Active Automatic addition of corrosion inhibitor Vessels (3) Procedural
periodic withdrawal and analysis Regular thickness measurements (i.e., nondestructive testing) at key points On-line corrosion analysis with alarm
50
Loss of Containment
No. 51 (T)
Inherently Safer/Passive
Design and construction of tank Foundation heating system foundation (elevated pedestal) Insulation between tank and foundation
52
Loss of Containment
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-24
25
No. 53 Operational Deviations Loss of Containment Failure Scenarios Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Operators to visually check reservoir levels on regular basis Seal liquid reservoir to have low level sensor and alarm Flammable and/or toxic vapor sensors Operator emergency response to indications of a seal leak
Loss of sealing fluid to vessel Circulate vessel contents via agitator resulting in seal external, seal-less pump failure and emission of Use of double or tandem flammable or toxic vapors mechanical seal Alternative design which does not use a sealed agitator (i.e., continuous reactor with static mixer)
54
Floating roof sinks from snow or water on top of roof or corrosion of roof/pontoons
Provide fixed roof to protect the floating roof Double deck or pontoon floating roof Corrosion-resistant material selection for floating roof
Operating procedures for periodic draining of roof Periodic inspection and repair of pontoons Emergency response procedures
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Fire fighting foam system
No. 55
Inherently Safer/Passive Use fixed roof tank Double roof seal Electrical bonding/grounding of roof and shell
56
Corrosion from contaminated earth moisture trapped between insulation and vessel walls chemical contamination aggressive environment
Protective coatings and paints Use above-ground construction Do not insulate tank Locate below-ground vessel in secondary containment Install weatherproof jackets to protect insulation from moisture especially where chlorides may also be present
Cathodic protection
periodic withdrawal and analysis Regular thickness measurements at key points Periodic leak detection
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-26
27
No. 57 Operational Deviations Wrong Composition Failure Scenarios Incorrect or unanticipated cross-connection Inherently Safer/Passive Use of dedicated connections Use of incompatible couplings Physically separate points of connection of incompatible materials Potential Design Solutions Active certain addition combinations Vessels (3) Procedural correct or permitted crossconnections between tanks and vessels Isolate tanks and vessels via blinding and disconnection Sample/analyze prior to transfer Color coding and labeling of lines
58
Wrong Composition
Indoor location (shielded from rain) External heating/cooling with leak protection Electrical heating instead of steam
Periodic analysis to detect the presence of water or other coil fluid in the stored material Periodic draining of floating roof
Table 3: FailureScenariosforVessels Potential Design Solutions Active On-line analyzer with alarms and interlock Vessels (3) Procedural Intermittent sampling and analysis with instructions to cut-off feed
No. 59
60
Wrong Composition
9/15/2012
Chapter 3
3-28
29
No. 61 Operational Deviations Less Agitation Failure Scenarios Failure of agitator causing stratification of immiscible layers Inherently Safer/Passive Potential Design Solutions Active Vessels (3) Procedural Manual activation of back-up pump around system Manual shut off of feed on detection of loss of agitation
External, inline mixing of feeds Agitator monitor interlocked to before entering tank stop feed stream Use of compatible/mutually Automatic backup pump soluble materials around system