AS Bzv Aml[P

&vQmk zx u AUPP
"BzvS CUS wUPh iu @|#P.'
& ]mi BL U]P zx Azu zx v Bn[P
" @|#P HIV |h 40% AvP Bzux.'
& @|#P ]mi BL PL
{Pzv gb @u iP.

{zu, u Cv AUP zP
#uuPz u #P Azvu Bzv zx u
AUPPU @Pmk AUP }v, A Cv }v[P
UP, BPm 8, 2012 A AvzvUQx. (Bn UP Gs: 12)
hm BL U]P 22x mh }v (State of Michigan 22nd Judicial District
Court), ]mi BL U]P zxUS (University of Michigan Hospitals) BPm
8, 2012 A K Ezu zux.
(]mi BL U]P zxu Bzv, 2004 B Bsix
uUQUS @|#PUPP zx ]Qa GkzxQ.)
\mhv Au Ezu : ""2005 B Bsix 2010 ,
| Bzv, D/O/B.12/23/1973, P 3118 Village Circle, Ann Arbor,
MI 48108, Gkzu zx u AUPP zx u
iP Hux J@ Ax G {zu
UPbUS zx [P sk.''
Bzv zx u UPkP, BzvSz wUPhiu |
STD, Aux E PUPi u| Qv
|# (Genital Herpes) 2004 B Bsix CuPz uUQ.
(BzvS CUS @|#P (Bn UP Gs: 65), HIV |h
40 AvP Bzux G, P E ]mi BL PL
@|#P |hzv gb u iP uUQ).

1.BzvS CUS wUPhiu @|#P:

2004 Bsi zx Bu[P @|#P [P:

Herpes Genetalia : Feb 2, 2004
Genital Herpes : Feb 16, 2004
Herpes Genetalia in Women : Feb 16, 2004

BzvS CUS wUPhiu @|#P :

Bzv PUPmhuP x zu #:
, 2005 u uP, {zuh u xP
E PshuP Bzv Q.
Ai {Pvu {aP {zuUS Au |# uUP
@sk.
B h 2, 2012 A, {zuUS GkUPmh zx
u iP, {zuUS Gu @| C G
Q.
Cvx Bzv x mk Azx SamkP #x G
zx vP@ {nQx.

BzvS CUS @|# zx Bu[P u

uPP:
Bzv zx u iP, AUS 2004 B Bsix
E P [P Qv |# (STD Genital
Herpes) Cux G Pz uPU PmkQ. Ai AUS C|#
1996u CvUPUTk.
uk u E]@ @ :

EhvP hP Qv | Ah[P umhTh, C|#

E@k uhPPUS Cu Qv |# uUP.
AuS EhUS Pz wP #UTix Cu .
BzvS {zuUS Ch v ETh |hvUP
sh.
@|# CUS Chzv uk u E]uTh x, Qv |#
{zuUS US. B h 2, 2012 A,
{zuUS GkUPmh zx u iP, {zuUS Gu
@| C G Q.

2. {zuUS Gu @| C
& CuS C|# AUS Cuv. Cx AUS C.
- Dr. Hamta Kumari
Consultant Miro Biologist
Fortis FLT.LT. Rajan Dhall Char.E. Trust, Rajan Dhal Hospital,New Delhi - 11 00 70

h 2, 2012 A, {zuUS GkUPmh zx u

iP AUS A|# C Gu Fu #Q. Axmk, CuS
C|# AUS Cuv G uUQ. H C|#
J xmh x, Auz wUP ix.@@ umiUS u
iP, {zuUS BzvS Ch Guuzv Eh uh
Cv Gu {UQ.
Cvx h uUS 2005 & 2009 P, EhE, K U G
u[P uh CuuP Bzv ux Sami Tx zx
vP # Gx {nQx.

3. 2005x 2009 Bzv uUS h Eh

v E CuuP Tx zu # :
zx {n[P EsP:
19, 2005 Bsk Bzv Gkzu zx u i uUS Es
Cx:""CuU P[P Bzv ux Pnh mk@ Eh Psiu.''
(Bn UP Gs: 47)
Bzv u hUhh, uh Azu Au[P [P Qx
PsiUQ. CiUS m\zv, A {zuh uUQuuPU T
uhP J Th Sh. 60 UP[P Psh zx
u Bu zv[PP J ChzvTh A CuU Sh Gi CUP
i?
x Ci AshP P Azx Bzv Amh #PUS J
@ Cx Cx Cvx Qx.

4. {zu {Pa] { mi zx u P
mi uzu Bzv Smk Ehmhx
SzvP i\ 1, 2005 {zuh {P {PuuP
Bzv TUQ. Cx Amh # Gu Ax | 30, 2005
AUP zx u Bu zv[P {zvUQx.
1.| 30, 2005 A A zx uUPPa UQ. Av Bzv
A Sh miUS :""Bzv (C) | (i 1,2005) Cv
UQ,'' G ShmiUQx.
2. Aui@ zu AUPx Bzv i\ 1, 2005 A mh,
( H AUP i 1, 2005 G Ax Cv i\ 2, 2005
GuS) CvS A i\ 3, 2005 Au vUP i!
Bzv, i\ 1, 2005 A {zu u oral sex USU
Pmhkzv G Bzv TQ!
B AuU Smh uv, {zu, hv {zu n v
P |hzvU Psiu. AuP i Bu vP CUQ.
Cvx {zu hvu Cu Gx, Bzv
AUPu Cu Gx {nQx.
S Gi Bzv, u {zu i\ 1, 2005 A zv
Pzu G T i?
A u PUPmhuP uvP, {zu {Pa]
{ mi zxz uzvUQ. B CuU Smh {Pa] uvP
5

mkmh Gx, A UPmh uvP Cnuzv

hh Gx ShzuUPx. A Cu A .
AuP @P...
| 2005 & BzvS Au Qv @| Hmh Pmi i
{PvUQx. Au Bzv zx @un vP Ev #Qx.
{ C CUS@x A {zuh Eh zvu
{a {zuUS Au @|# u {Px Au CUP
@sk. B {zu zx v Bn[P AUS Gu
@| C G AzvUQx.
(zx u AUP UP 35 , ""31 u sn BzvS ux
x hzv @u ]u (lesion) HmiUQx. Cx AS AUS
AiUPi Eh P[P PnkQx. uh CuhP Cx
ASP Hmk, A[Sz ux u A Cu, AuU Szx A P
PkQ. A |, 4 u nP CvSa Q.
ShzuUP : Ax x hzv E lesion 5mm mh APzvS
mhP x. |k J ] \ Pmi s (pustule) CUQx.'' )
Cvx Bzv @zu, {Pa] {P Ah
Cnuzvx vi uzu P mi Pu Ehmhx.
5. Bzv, HIV vUPmh J Bqh Pz uh
Pshu u Pnh T Cux Gi?
3, 2010 A GkUPmh zx ux Bzv v
#vUS J #v: (Page 23 and 24 / page 10 and 11 of 38)...
2009 B Bsk uUS J "v xn' (Partner) QhzvuP, A J HIV
| G, u Ah # E (Oral Sex), Eh(Vaginal inter course)
zxU PshuP TUQ.
i)
""GUS J v xnQUQ Eh E |#US
BQUQ@,'' G Bzv u@ Av TUQ. A, uUS HIV
|# CUQu G 3, 2010 A zx u #vUQ. Cx, A
HIV |#Psh Au v |h Eh Pshu SUQx.
ii) 2009B Bsk, A P Eh PshuU Psn Psh
Cu, Pu, HIV |# Psh Au v xn?
PUS HIV |# Eu?
iii) Cvx... J A HIV |# Psh Ph Eh (ExtraMarital Relationship) PsiUP sk Ax HIV |# Psk J
6

|h Eh (Extra-Marital Relationship) PsiUP sk.

{zu, u Pnh u # a @x, Ax uUS
P Ava]uP Cux G u P AUP TUS Bzv
US C[S sku UP. Cx, A P AUP TuS
mh J #vP CUQx.
Ci BhPh Eh P Bzv... {u
u Pnh # mh G Gsn Th u P
ukzvuP GiU Ti?
Bzv, HIV vUPmh J Bqh Pz uh Pshu u
Pnh T Cux Gi?
Cimh C, ""u J Sk s,'' G uzu P AUP,
FhP[P U PQ.

6. HIV |#UP @u #xPsh Bzv:

2009 Hmh v HIV |# xnh Eh Pshxh, uUS HIV |#
HmiUS G 3, 2010& uzu vzxUPsh Bzv.
3, 2010 A GkUPmh zx @u AUP Bn uUS
: ""HIV \u izv HIV |# @uUPP Bzv J m]
Pzvmk, AuS HIV u #mhx.'' (UP 58)
@ 3, 2010 A GkUPmh zx w ux
G..."" E u| ASP, 1 hzvS
@| Eh hz x[Qmh. AUS HIV UP B\
(counseling) PkUPmhx,'' G UQx. @ Bzvhx zx
uUP \uizv Pzx [Pmhx.
{zuh 2005 B Bsk uuP xP
Eh PshuPa Q. @ 2009 u PzuuPa
Q. Ci A x Es, {zu HIV
vUPmiUP @sk@? B {zuUS Gu @| C G
zx v Bu[P uUQx.
Cvx | 2009 B Bsk, Ph Cnx \v #x,
{zu A P zx h Gkzx, Au L[ #uS, A
BzvP u {zv Su Cu HIV@u 2010& |hux Gx
ShzuUPx.
(, 2010 A zx v uUS : "@|, u 1 hzvS
, J v xnh E PshuP, A@x PzuUP CUP
7

ukP(Condoms) kzvuP TQ. #P E

Eh Psh [P Cu @|# UPUTk G Bzv
uUQ.)
7. Bzv u # P @|#UPP GkzxU Psh xP:
{zu, a, 2009 B Bsi, C |UP
B][P uh K U zxU Psh G Bzv Q.
Cx, A #U P @| vUPmiu 5 u Pzv |huPU
TQ...
Bzv a 25, 2009 B Bsk zx uP uUS
Es, AUS P [P u | herpes (Qv
|#) Cux G uUQx. (C| [P @UPP
CnUPmk).
Qv |#s HmiUS Chzv CzuU P] Hmk Ax ux
mh Ax s HmiUS Chzv CUS u ]ux, ASv
ux mhTh, Cx EhiP AP uUP.
Bzv H 15, 2009 zx v, A 22, 2009 u #U P
@| vUPmiu G Smka Qx.
Bzv S mix, {zu Bzvh K U,
Pmi Anzx, Eumi zumk P uh Psiu, {a\P
BzvUS CUS herpes |# {zuUS US.
h 2, 2012 A Gkzu zx u iP {zUS
(STD) C|# C Gu Fu #Q.
(a 25, 2009 A BzvS GkUPmh zx @u : ""35

v Bzv, C u # P#UPmh Sv u
P @| Shz uzx, Au @vUP vu. AUS
3 [PUS , Aux A Cv 4 u[P u[Qu zvu,
Cu s Ah x Pzv @u S xP iiP
P#UPmh SvUS x...,'' ""... Ax @ CzuUP]h Duzxh
Cux...,'' ""... BzvS u J vj herpes sP
@ux, @uP iz@ux 2007 B Bsi@u UP. Aua
[P A 2 h[S A x |mPUS GkzxUPQ.)
(15 H, 2009&zx AUP : & "" Qv @| vUPmiu
35 v Bzv, u@x a US P @|
vUPmiUQ. C@|# Phu 7 [PP AUS CUQx. CuU P
@|# u AUS x Pzv Bzx, iiP P#UPmh
x. C@|# 7 [PUS , A CvS n @u
zv uh[QvUQx. a 25, 2009 A GkUPmh @uPi,
AUS Cu sP, AUS HP@ Cu Qv@| HmiUPUTk G
8

PukQx. Au A 1 zvS Valtrex 500 MG BID u,

Zovirax P kzxi Azumh... Cu @|# 7 [PPz
uhx CUQx.'')
8.

2009 & {Pu Qv @|#:

EP |huPU SgmhmiUS zv BzvS

u@u @u Qvs i Hmhu :
Bzv, 22, 2009 Ax @ 12, 2009 (Bn UP Gs: 30),
@ 3, 2009 (Bn UP Gs: 27) zv # Qv
@| vUPmiu G Ah zx vP uUQ. B
Bzv@, ux P AUP, @ 13x 24 , 2009 Hg
Bzv {zu u vP zP #u G
SmiUQ.
Qv s i HmiUS zv A {zu
Pmhkzv Eh Psiu {zuUS C|# US.
B Ax zx uP AUS STD |# C Gu uUQ.
""Bzv uu |# :
... | a _ P |# uhx CUQx.
AUPmh P | (Genital Wart Suppression) CUQx.'')
""u | :
UQP, uu sk sk u Qv|# CUS Ex.''
Gynecologic care xP :
Phu @ 11,2009 u uh#... J 30 |UP uh#
4 |mPUS }iUQx. G1, P0 CUS C CuS J PUP
#vUQ. CUS Qv |# Eu, Au AhUQ uPP Valtrex G
u GkzxU PQ. Cu |# PnUS h CUP, AuP
uk (condoms) kzu ]Q.)
zx iP:
1.
, hzv Qv @| Hmh PmiP @u
#u@x Herpes simplex Type 2 Cx Evx.

9.

BPm 3, 2006 Hmh Qv i |#.

BPm 4, 2006 GkUPmh zx u AUS (Varicella Zoster)

Cu FukzxQx.
BPm 5, 2006 GkUPmh zx u AUS Qv i
Herpes |# Cu FukzxQx.
9

2006 B Bsi, BPm uzvx i\ u 2006 , A

{zu x Aua zvuP, AuU Sizu S A vkzx
[QmhuP, S Gx zux, kUP \mh A
CuuP uh S AUP TUQ.
(zx AUP : ""...32 uS C|, uUS vuP
J Qvs hzvSU RU P Sv vuP {UQ. A 5
|mPUS u Cu AhzuU PsiUQ. B hzv C
s x J CUS vux A. zx h[PP Cx x@x
CUS UPxu. Cx Qv s iP CUS@ G Bzv
PkQ...uh#a zv UPP Hk Qv s iP
CUS@ G Bzv PkQ.'')
10. 19, 2005 & @u @|#:
19, 2005 A hUh, BzvS kzu GaUP, A u P u
Pzuz ukuTh Ah | a#xk Gxu.
zx Bu zv[PT : ""Phu zv, CUS u,
zv P[P HmiUQ. Gmk |mPUS |
u , }UPzxUPsh ] \uU Pmi vuPz uUQx.''
""@| u PzuU PTh ukuz uUP @sk. Cuz umh
x, Cv i vU P] uk uUS C|# k,'' G hUh
|h GazvUQ.

11. | 15, 2007 A @u @|#:

| 15, 2007 A HSV Type 2 G |# uUQx. (|
17, 2007 A zx AUP, BzvS Herpes |# Cu Fu
#Qx.(Bn UP Gs 38)
zx u AUP : C zx uUPP u
Bzv, x 33& uh x hzv u vu HmiuUPP
zx Eu GkzxUP vu. Cu 3 Ax 4 |mPUS PshuuPa
. AUS HSV Type 2 G | CUQx. AUS J
uhx, HSV |# uQx. CUS Au v GkUPmk
uUPP (culture)Amkx. zxvP Cuh ASP
USx, Cx Herpes |P CUPUTk G uQx. Au Voltrex
u GkzxU Pi A Azv.''
B#UTh v AUP: ""Herpes |# (Qv s) u |hzuh
sk. |# v GkUPmh Ch: hSv P[P.
10

i: B, Herpes Simplex |#UP x.

12. BPm 8, 2006 Herpes |# Fu #kQx
zx u #u Au hUh TQ: ""|, | US
Ah |U Szx J #v AUQ@. A P uUS
s u Ga] Hmhx A. Ax Herpes simplex G |.''

11

Bzv v @si zx P UQ PP:

1. C Gzxn STD |#PU Psh@ Cu Bzv?
E P 3 STD |#PU Psh Bzv, u
{zu PUPmhuPU T P zu #.
Sux 2004 B Bsiux, BzvS #Qv (Oral Herpes),
Qv (Genital Herpes) , u|# Qv (Herpes Gladiatorum) G 3 STD |#P
CuuP zx Bn Bu[P E. (CUS C Gzxn
@|#P CUQ@u u?)
i)
Bzv @|# Szu zx Buzvzv uu u
u Qv | (Genital Herpes) A vUPmiu G v
#mkx.
ii)

J u Csk uzvPPx uhx CUS # Qv s

(Oral Herpes) | Bzv vUPmiu G Au zx
Buzvzv Ex.
iii) Bzv u {zu Ix h[PP 40 P Pzu
G SzvP TQ.
, 2005 u uP, {zuh u xP
E PshuP Bzv Q. Ai {Pvu {aP
{zuUS BzvS CUS [P Qv |# uUP
@sk. B {zuUS Gu @| C G
Ah zx Bu[P Q. Cvx Bzv x mk
Azxn SamkP #x G zx vP@ {nQx.
CiUS m\zv, @|#P E Bzv Gu Aih
u {zu Ix h[PP 40 P Pzu G TQ?
Cu Ax SamkP Azx # Gx {nQx.

2. PnUS Cu @|#P BzvS @ Gu

Bohx G@x ux?
h 2, 2012 A GkUPmh zx ui
{zuUS E (Sexually Transmitted Disease ) STD G
|# C.
12, 2009 A Bzv PnUS GkUPmh zx
12

ui A PnUS C|# C. H u Pnh

xP (PshP kzv) E zxUPuP zx @
u uzvUQ. S G[Qx, hx C|# BzvS
ux?

3. BzvS Cu STD |# 1996 B Bsix

CUQu?

BzvS STD herpes |# 2004B Bsku uu Ax AUS A|#

1996 B Bsix CUQu?
BzvS 2004 B Bsix GkUPmh zx Bu AUPP mk
QhzvUQ. Aui AUS HSV 1, HSV 2 |#P Cu G,
A|#PU SuPP Valtrex, Valacyclovir zvP, Zovirax P
EPkzv G Bu[P Qhzx. B 2004 B BsiS u
Bu[P QhUP.
, Bzv BPm 3, 2006 A zx Bu zv[P TQx:
""C@|# AS J CUS vuPz uu, Phu 10 h[PP
AUS hzv PmiP u x UP.''
Ai AUS E STD herpes G |# 1996x
CUQu?

4. Pnu @ J Bqh uh zvu

Bzv, Giz u J nU Skzvx u
UP s G TU PQ?
u HP@ 3 STD | vUPmhuk mk, HIV |#Psh
J v xnh 2009 B Bsk E zxU PshuPz u zxh
TUQ Bzv.
Pnu @ J Bqh uh zvu Bzv, SzvP
FhP[P, Giz u J nU Skzvx u UP s
G TU PQ?

BzvS Cu PzuhP?
i) 19, 2005 A u Pnh mk@ E PshuP Bzv zxh
TQ. B Cu Bzv 2004@u @|#UP xP Gkzx
uuP zx {n[P CUQ. PnUS Cu @|# CUS Gi
ux?
ii) 2005x {zuh u Eh K U (#
P E) G uhPshuPU S zvP
Bzv TQ.
B {zuUS A|# A@x C, C@x C
GuP zx {n Bu[P E.
13

Cvx Bzv u Pnh mk Eh zvUP.

BzvS Sux 2004 x E Qv |# CUQx
Gx mh aP {nQu AUS BsPh Cu
Pz uh {nQx.

5. 2009 B Bsk Bzv zxU Psh Au v HIV

xn ? P?
Bzv Ph Eh PshuU Psn Psh m] Cu
Bzv, Ah \mhu EUP, HIV | vUPmhPa
\uQUPkQ P x Tmka \v #xu
{zu ]zuUPmh iz uzx. HIV |#Psh J@k
@|#P E Bzv E zxU Pshx H? nzvPP?
Ax EzvPP?

6. Bzv, {zu uh
hUhh uUPux H?
Bzv, uh G Au[P [P, ux "v xn'
Au "v xn'US CUS HIV Emh... G Au[P [P
hUhh Qx PsiUQ!
AiUSx, uUS {zuUS Ch 2005x
EP {PvuPU T Bzv, Av J {Px hUhh T
Cux Gi?

7. Bzv H zx uUS Emkzu?

Ah @|# uxk Gu?
P vUPmhuPU Tk Bzv, A PUPmh C
G zx uUS H Emkzu?
A sn, C GuU Psh Eh u |# |h (medical diagnosis) mk #ux H?
-

8. {zu x P S mhkuS
SgmkP # si
i)
ii)

Bzv PzuuP Bu[Pa \UP sk.

{zu Bsu? A U |hiUPP Dkhi?
14

G Ehua #@sk.
CuP P Bzv u Ehu #u x, AUS
STD |# Cx mha\Qk.

9. 1996 B Bsiu BzvS CUS

Qv |# (STD) ?
Bzv 2006 zx u iP uUS Es,
A Cu | Phu 10 h[Px (Sux) vUPmhP CUPUTk
Gxu. Ai, 1996 B Bsiu AUS Qv |#
(STD) CUS@ G @P GQx.

10. Cx P G J@ |h GuP
UQ Bu.

i\ 1, 2005 A u {zu zv zxU Pzu G

Bzv TQ. B Ah zx @u Bu zv[PP, A
A uv AUP Cuu Fu #Q. {zu
i vP, A hv {zu n {ua] Cuu Fu
#Q.
{zu hv, Bzv AUP! S Gi Bzv, u
{zu i\ 1, 2005 A zv Pzu G T i?
Bzv uh S zvP TUS #v G,
{zu {Pa] { Psh zxzu, u
{zu Pzu uvU Pshu....! Aizu P G J@
|h!

15

UPzvS U |hiUPP, Suz xzv #

# z, {zu x # SamkP.
1.
Su PU Pl xzvUPP (Child Molestation)
hmh 4 USP, # z S[P }UPmhu,
AUS ]mh CUS Q[Psi ][h }v 4 BskP 9
u[PUS ]zush vzvUQx.
2.
# z, AUP {zvhx, uUSa si uPP
U Psk (u mh Juzu izxUPsk), BPm 10, 2009 B Bsh
{zu mk mh. Cu zuz uPUT Pmk
CUQ.
3.
3, 2011 A A AUP {zvPvP J # ] P
mk vvu. Aux n \umh P mk vvu. Cv
v P Gx v #.
4.
B AuS S, "UPb Ai' 2011, A uh u
P vzu #x Psh. Aux CPUS n P u
{zu EUS {vzu G J # Pa zu.
AT Samk G, u {zvhx S
Juzv Pzvh Gxu. B, A Pmh (BPm 10,
2009 A) Bn[P, AUP }vzv uUP #mk.

5.
2008 & 2009 B BskP A Suz u P
kzvUPP hmh UQ, AUP }vzu A S
Sgmhmh P, A {zu x # SamhU T
# UP Bu zv[P # ] #vUQ.
6.
# z C AUP }vzu Sgmhmh S |mPUS
P, Aux AUh 2011 Bsku, {zu u wPz
uP kzvuP, P|hP CID h J #PU PkzvUQ.

16