Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 195

14 2 2011

1998

14
2
2011

CA&CC Press

14 2 2011

,
:

?

( / )
/
(, )

XXI
, : , ( ). , 1. ,
,


,
.
,
,

,
, (, ,
, ) (2009 .)
(2010 .). ,
-

1
.: Smith D. The Dragon and the Elephant:
China, India and the New World Order. London: Profile Books, 2008; Borodina S., Shvyrkov O. Investing in
BRIC Countries: Evaluating Risk and Governance in
Brazil, Russia, India and China. New York: McGrawHill Professional, 2010.

14 2 2011


, ,
,
, .
: ,
? ,

,
, .
. , ,
,
, ,
.



. ,
. ,

.
().
.
,
.

.

- 1998
2.
3,
2005 ,

,
.
, , , ,
11
2001 , 4.
,
5
6.
2
, . 1921 , ,
(

- 1920 .).
3
1999 ,
: (), - ( ..
).
4
.: Cabestan J.-P., Colin S., Facon I., Meidan M.
La China et la Russie. Entre convergences et mfiance.
.: Stratgie et prospective. Paris: UNICOMM, 2008.
P. 137138.
5
140- , - .
6
.: Lounev S. The Prospects of Interaction in the
Triangle Russia-India-China. .: Asia-Pacific: Security,
Globalisation and Developmen / Ed. by M.L. Sondhi,
K.G. Tyagi. New Delhi: Manas, 2001; . : . .: :
: - /
. . .. . :
-, 2010.

14 2 2011

I:


, . , .

,
7, ,
, ,
8.

, 9.
, .
,
, 10. , ,
, . , ,

11. 12.
, , , , ,
, . 2011 - 7

, , .
8
.: Donaldson R.H. Boris Yeltsins Foreign Policy Legacy, Presented to the 41st Annual Meeting of the
International Studies Association. Los Angeles, California, 18 March 2000 [http://www.personal.utulsa.edu/~robert-donaldson/yeltsin.htm]; Trenin D. Russias Spheres of Interest, not Influence // The Washington Quarterly, October 2009. P. 8.
9
.: Watson R. A Yeltsin Doctrine // Newsweek, 10 October 1994 [http://www.newsweek.com/1994/10/09/
a-yeltsin-doctrine.html].
10
Rutland P. Russia as an Energy Superpower // New Political Economy, June 2008, Vol. 13, No. 2. P. 209.
11
.: Ziegler Ch.E. Russia and China in Central Asia. .: Bellacqua J. The Future of China-Russia Relations. Kentucky: The University Press Kentucky, 2010. P. 248f.
12
.: Woehrel S. Russian Energy Policy Toward Neighboring Countries. CRS Report for Congress, May
2009. P. 17.

14 2 2011

13.
,
2008 ,
. , 14.
11 2001
, , , ,
, . ,

( , ), 15. , , ,
16.
, ()
, , , , , , , . ,
, , ,
, 17.

. , 1995 2009
5 230 . 12 832 .;
206 . 1 283 .; 357 . 785 .;
272 . 1044 . 1 713 .
2 540 .18 , 4% 2008 19.
. ,
20.
13
.: Cutler R.M. South Stream May Disappear // Asia Times Online, 18 March 2011 [http://www.
atimes.com/atimes/Central_Asia/MC18Ag01.html].
14
.: Gorst I. Gazprom Escalates Turkmen Gas Price Dispute // Financial Times, 2 June 2009 [http://www.
ft.com/cms/s/0/81e86c80-4f0b-11de-8c10-00144feabdc0.html#axzz1EOZjC6h8].
15
.: Varadarajan S. China and Russia up the Ante in Central Asia // The Hindu, 7 July 2005 [http://www.
hindu.com/2005/07/07/stories/2005070714961500.htm].
16
.: Lo B. Axis of Convenience. Moscow, Beijing, and the New Geopolitics. Washington D.C.: Brookings
Institution Press, 2008. P. 9395.
17
.: Matveeva A., Giustozzi A. The SCO: A Regional Organization in the Making // Working Paper 39,
Regional and Global Axes of Conflict. London: Crisis State Research Centre, LSE, September 2008. P. 7.
18
.: Russian Federation State Statistical Service [http://www.gks.ru/bgd/regl/b10_12/IssWWW.exe/stg/
d02/26-06.htm].
19
.: EUROSTAT (Comex Regime 4) [http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2006/september/tradoc_1134
40.pdf].
20
.: Ziegler Ch.E. Op. cit. P. 252253.

10

14 2 2011


. , , 11
.
,
, . 21. , - - - , .
- , .
-, .
,
- .
, ,
. ,

22.
, - .
, ( ),
, ,
, .
50% 23,
, 80%
- , - 24.
, , , , . , ( ,
). , , 25. , . ,
, -
. 2006 - ,
Lo B. Op. cit. P. 9596.
.: Rashid A. China Forced to Expand Role in Central Asia // Institute for Afghan Studies, 19 July 2000
[http://www.institute-for-afghan-studies.org/Foreign%20Affairs/china/china_expand_role_0.htm].
23
.: China: Oil, Country Analysis Briefs. U.S. Energy Information Administration, November 2010 [http://
www.eia.doe.gov/cabs/China/Oil.html].
24
.: Ullah A. India and China Competing for Malacca Straits in Burma // SouthAsiaSpeaks, 23 June 2009
[http://southasiaspeaks.wordpress.com/2009/06/23/india-and-china-competing-for-malacca-straits-in-burma/].
25
.: Higashi N. Natural Gas in China. Market Evolution and Strategy // International Energy Agency
Working Paper Series, June 2009. P. 23 [http://www.iea.org/papers/2009/nat_gas_china.pdf].
21
22

11

14 2 2011

, , 26. 2009 , , ,
27. , , 28.
,
: 1%
.
1995- 2007 : 391 .
13 800 .; 231 . 3 780 .; 24 . 524 .; 18 . 350
. 119 . 1 130 .29
, .
, , ,
30.
.
,
31.

1991 , , 32. 2000-


,
, .
, .

, .
, , 33.
.: Ziegler Ch.E. Op. cit. P. 249250.
Unknown: China President Open Turkmenistan Gas Pipeline // BBC, 14 December 2009 [http://news.
bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8411204.stm].
28
Durdiyeva Ch. China, Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan Launch Turkmenistan-China Gas
Pipeline // CACI Analyst, 20 January 2010 [http://www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/5254].
29
.: Ziegler Ch.E. Op. cit. P. 253, Table 8.3.
30
Wong E. China Quietly Extends Footprints Into Central Asia // The New York Times, 2 January 2011
[http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/03/world/asia/03china.html].
31
.: Laruelle M., Peyrouse S. Editors Note: Central Asian Perceptions of China // The China and Eurasia
Forum Quarterly, February 2009, Vol. 7, No. 1. P. 7.
32
.: Nadkarni V. India and Central Asia. Script for presentation at the annual meeting of the International
Studies Association. Chicago, 28 February 3 March 2007. P. 1.
33
.: Sikri R. Challenge and Strategy. Rethinking Indias Foreign Policy. New Delhi: SAGE Publications,
2009. P. 164165.
26
27

12

14 2 2011

,
.
, . , , , .
, , (),
() ()
, 34. , ,
. ,
, . ,
35. , , 36. , 2002 Reliance Industries Limited (RIL)
.
2009 . 2005
. , ,
- -
( ) ,
, . , , , , ,
37. SAGE (
South Asia Gas Enterprise). 1990- : , , . ,
, , , 38.
-
. 2009/2010
291,45 ., 84,6 .,
34
.: Dadwal Sh.R. The Role of Natural Gas and Central Asia in Indian Energy Security // Journal of
Energy Security, 26 July 2010 [http://www.ensec.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=254:therole-of-natural-gas-in-indian-energy-security&catid=108:energysecuritycontent&Itemid=365].
35
.: Sikri R. Op. cit.
36
.: Jackson A. China and Central Asia // Turkish Weekly, 19 May 2009 [http://www.turkishweekly.net/
news/77297/china-and-central-asia.html].
37
Dadwal Sh.R. Op. cit.
38
.: Ibidem.

13

14 2 2011

46,15 ., 32,56 . 27,48 .39


,

.

II:

,
, . , - 2008 , .
, .
-
. ,
,
. , , , (
), , , ,
.
. , ,
,
, , ; ,
, - 40. ,
1990- , .
,
, . , .
1996 , , , .

, 39
.: Government of India, Ministry of Commerce & Industry, Department of Commerce, Export Import
Data Bank, Version 6.0 [http://commerce.nic.in/eidb/Default.asp].
40
Sikri R. Op. cit. P. 165.

14

14 2 2011

. 2001 , . , , , . ,
, , 41. 2005 2009
, 2007 2010 . .
, . .
, ,
, . , , , . .
2006
, . , 42.

( ),
, 11 2001 ,
. : 11 , , 43. , ,

. , ( 2005 .) (
). 44.
, ,
. 41
.: Matveeva A., Giustozzi A. Op. cit. P. 16; Tiara T. Power Politics in Central Asia: China and Russias Relationship. New York: International Studies Association Annual Meeting, February 2009.
42
.: . // Pravda.ru, 11 2010 [http://www.pravda.ru/
world/asia/centralasia/11-06-2010/1035767-shos-0/].
43
Varadarajan S. Six Propositions about World Order and the Role of Russia, India and China. .: Das
Kundu N. Russia-India-China. Evolution of Geo-Political Strategic Trends. New Delhi: Academic Foundation,
2010. P. 39.
44
.: . // , 12 2010 [http://www.interaffairs.ru/read.php?item=281].

15

14 2 2011

, .
. , , 45.
, , .
, , , , , ; .
, , ,
. , ,
, , , .
,
. 2006 , . .
, 2007/2008 ,
, ,
- . , 1
2011 , , , , , 1990- . 20
15 .
,
46. , , ,
. , , ,
. , .
, ,
. , ,
, ,
.
, , , ,
47.
Aris S. Russian-Chinese Relations through the Lens of the SCO. Paris: NIS Center, 2008.
.: Stone M. Siberian Nights: The East Siberia-Pacific Ocean Oil Pipeline // The Oil Drum, 27 February
2007 [http://www.theoildrum.com/node/2311].
47
Rosner K. China Scores Again in Energy: Russia & Central Asia // Journal of Energy Security, 12 February
2010
[http://www.ensec.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=230:china-scores-again-in-energyrussia-aamp-central-asia&catid=102:issuecontent&Itemid=355].
45
46

16

14 2 2011

2030 , , ,

.
, ,
48. 2005 -
. ,

.
(CNPC) (ONGC) PetroKazakhstan
. 2006
. ,
. ,
- , -
,
, Sinopec
, 49. , - .
. ,
.
, , , , . , , .
,
. , ,
, ,
,
. , ,
, . , , ,
,
50. ,
, , , .
48
.: Chandra A. Geopolitics of Central Asian Energy Resources and Indian Interest // Journal of Peace
Studies, January June 2009, Vol. 16, Issue 12. P. 14.
49
.: Tonnesson S., Kolas A. Energy Security in Asia: China, India, Oil and Peace. Report to the Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Oslo: International Peace Research Institute, April 2006. P. 5053.
50
Lo B. Op. cit. P. 111.

17

14 2 2011

, , ,
, :
, , ,
.
, ,
51. .

, , . .
,
,
. , .
, ,
, , . , , -
. , ,
, ( , ,
) ,
.
, .
.
,
( ,
)
52.

51
52

Varadarajan S. Six Propositions about World Order and the Role of Russia, India and China. P. 40.
Das Kundu N. Op. cit. P. 14.

18

14 2 2011





,

,


(, )

1990-
.
, () .

()1.



,
.
.
the Post-Cold War Era. Second Edition. Colorado:
Lynne Rienner Publishers Boulder, 1991). . e (.: Buzan B.,
Wver O., De Wilde J. Security. A New Framework for
Analysis. London: Rienner Publishers Boulder, 1998;
Buzan B., Wver O. Regions and Powers. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2003)

. , , ,
, , , ,
, .

1
. e
1983 (.: Buzan B. People, States and Fear: The
National Security Problem in International Relations.
Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf, 1983).
, (.: Buzan B. People, States and
Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in

19

14 2 2011



() .
,
,
2.
, , , . ,
, . ( . ..) ,
,
, , . , 3. ,
. ,
,
4.
,
, /. . ,
/, 5.
. 6. . . ,
, 7,
, :
; ; ,
( ) 8.
2
.: Buzan B. People, States and Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War
Era. . 190.
3
Ibid. . 191.
4
.: McSweeney B. Security, Identity and Interests: A Sociology of International Relations. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 1999. . 63.
5
Buzan B. People, States and Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War Era.
. 190.
6
Buzan B., Wver O. Op. cit. . 5561.
7
.: Ibid. . 55.
8
.: Ibidem.

20

14 2 2011

, . , ,
,
,
, ,
- .





, , .
.
- , . , , , ,
9.
. . 10.
,
, .
11.
, .
.

/.
, -
. , (
)12.
.: Buzan B., Wver O., De Wilde J. Op. cit. . 12.
. (.: Waltz K.N. Theory of International Politics.
Boston: McGraw-Hill, 1979. . 88).
11
Buzan B. People, States and Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War Era.
. 218219.
12
. ,
, .
9

10

21

14 2 2011

,
.
.
, -,
-, .
, . . , . - - , - , ,
- . , , 1980- 1990- . ,
, .
. -
,
13
, - 14. . . ,
, 15.
, , , , , ; , , ; , , , , .
, ,
, , , ( ),
. .

, . , , , . , ,
,
.
13
.: Buzan B. People, States and Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War
Era. . 188, 189, 191, 195.
14
Buzan B., Wver O. Op. cit. . 55.
15
Ibid. P. 55, 62, 343.

22

14 2 2011

().

. ,
, ,
- , , .

, -, 1990-
, , , , ,
. -, (, , ; , , ; , , ; , , ,
, ).

, . .
, :
, ?
16,
-
. . : , , , , . 17. . : ,
:
.
(, . ..),
16
.: Coppieters B. Conclusions: The Caucasus as a Security Complex. .: Contested Borders in the
Caucasus / Ed. by B. Coppieters. Brussels: Vubpress, 1996. P. 193204; Cornell S.E. Small Nations and Great
Powers. A Study of Ethnopolitical Conflict in the Caucasus. Surrey: Curzon Press, 2001; Buzan B., Wver O.
Op. cit.
17
Coppieters B. Op. cit. P. 195.

23

14 2 2011

,
18.
, , , , , . , 19,
, 1915 ,
?
, 20. , ,
, ,
.
(, ,
), , , , .
, - . , , .
,
,
, , ( ), , , . , ( , ,
) ( ).
-, , . 21:
. ,
, (), .
22.
Cornell S.E. Op. cit. P. 391.
,
. : , , , , , , , , , , , , , (.: , / . . / . . . 1. : , 2006. . 87).
20
1828
.
21
Buzan B., Wver O. Op. cit. . 48.
22
Ibid. P. 49.
18
19

24

14 2 2011

, ,
, . ,
,
, , 23.
24. , . , ,
, . , , - .
, , , .
, , - ,

/, ? , , .
, . , , ,
, . , . , ,
.
, , . ?
, . - ; ,
-, 25,
. , , .
, () .
.
23
24

. 193.

.: Ibid. P. 4748.
Buzan B. People, States and Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War Era.

25
.: Buzan B. People, States and Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War
Era. . 193; Buzan B., Wver O. Op. cit. . 41.

25

14 2 2011

.
, , .
-
.
, . , 26. ,
,
, ,
.

, , ,
, .
. , , . , 27, , .

, , . ,
, , , , .

, .
( ), , , , . . , , . , , , , .
, , . , ,
, 26

. 197.

27

Buzan B. People, States and Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War Era.
.: Ibid. P. 193.

26

14 2 2011

. , , .
, , -.
, , , , ,
, .
, , . , , .



, ,
, , .
,
. .
,
, . ,
.
, , ,
, . .
?!
, .
: ,
, , ,
28.
-
. , ,
,
. :
28

Buzan B., Wver O. Op. cit. P. 44.

27

14 2 2011

. -: , 29
, ,
, ,
. , , ,
. .
, ,
. ,
, , .

1990- , .
, .
(,
, ; , , ; , , ; , , , , ).

. (,
, ) ,
,

.
, ,
, .

29

Buzan B., Wver O. Op. cit. P. 87.

28

14 2 2011

-





,

(, )


.
, ,



. ,
, .
-
,
. , XXI ,
, 1.
-
.
,
.

, -

( ).
-,
2. (, , ,
.) ,
. , 3.

() , , 2
Kohen M.G. International Law is the Most Appropriate Moral Answer to Territorial Conflicts // Geopolitics (London), 2001, Vol. 6, No. 2. P. 169.
3
.: Jennings R.Y. The Acquisition of Territory
in International Law. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1963. P. 2 (. : Hurrell A. Op. cit. P. 279).

Hurrell A. International Law and the Making and


Unmaking of Boundaries. .: States, Nations and Borders: Ethics of Making Boundaries / Ed. by A. Buchanan,
M. Moore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
2003. P. 287.
1

29

14 2 2011


, .
, , (19992000 .).
, , , - .
,

, .

- ,
,
- ,
, .
, ,
, .
,
().

uti possidetis

uti possidetis ( )
.
, ,
- uti possidetis4,
, , 5. ( ), 6.
uti possidetis ,
, ;
. , 7.
, , , (, ) uti possidetis8.
, uti possidetis

.: Polat N. Boundary Issues in Central Asia. New York: Transnational Publishers, 2002. P. 46.
International Court of Justice. Reports, 1986. P. 565.
6
.: Ibid. P. 568.
7
.: . uti possidetis juris // , 2009, 6 (66).
8
.
4
5

30

14 2 2011

: - 9, , ,
.
(1975 .). () .

:
10.
uti possidetis, .
, .
.
1. .
2. - .
3. ,
11.
; , , ,
.





- , () . ()

. .
9

. 90.

.., .. . .: , 1985.

, - [http://www.
cis.minsk.by/main.aspx?uid=178]; 22 1993 [http://
www.cis.minsk.by/main.aspx?uid=176].
11
.: .., .. . . . 90; .
. ., 1990. . 155.
10

31

14 2 2011

()12, ()13
()14. , XIX ,

15. - , , , , .
-
. .
1960- 1980-
. 16,
17.
.

. 1992 .
;
, , 18. 19 34000 . 19.
: 12

2 000 . 156 , 744 1 206 .
13
(. 1 000 )
.
14
3 150 .
1 782 , 1 072 , 450 // , 26 1996 (. : . . .: , 2007. . 135; .,
. - // , 2002,
5 [23]).
15
, , -
, . - , (.: .
- . ., 1975; . . .; Raczka W. Xinjiang and its Central Asian
Borderlands // Central Asian Survey (London), September 1998, Vol. 17, No. 3; .
: // .
. Law (), 2000, 4 (20); .).
16
. ,
(.: . : .., ..
. . . 266).
17
.: . // , 16 2002.
18
6 1992 , 11 1993
(.: Guangcheng Xing. Security Issues in Chinas Relations with Central Asian States. .: Ethnic Challenges beyond Border: Chinese and Russian Perspectives of the Central Asian Conundrum / Ed. by Y. Zhang, R. Azizian.
London: Macmillan, 1998. P. 208 . : Polat N. Op. cit. . 3839).
19
SWB FE/1666 A 1/5, 15 April 1993 (. : Polat N. Op. cit. . 39).

32

14 2 2011

- ,
( ),
. , , .
.
n

-, , . , ( , .), .

-, , ,
20.


. 1993 . ,
1992
, , .

; 1999 21.
:
1996 () 1999 . 2001

. 10 2002 22.
2011 ;
, . , 300 23; 28 . 34. .
. , (
20
. , - , , , , 1 300 , ,
( , 16 2002).
21
26 1994 , , 1996 , 1997
1998 // , 11 1999.
22
.: . . . . 140.
23
.: . . , 30 2009
[http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=1241090940].

33

14 2 2011

). - (1999 .) (2002 .).


12 2011 , 28 . . 3% 24;
.

- ; ( ).
- 1921
1940 ,
.
(, , , ), . 1996 ; , ( ) ,
25.
- , - 1982 . ,
(
), 1982
; 1991 .
, , ( ) .
(.. 20% )26, .
(), , , ,
- .

7,5 . ; - 27. 24
.: . [http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.
php?st=1294994040]; . 1 . . [http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.
php?st=1295129040].
25
1998 2002 . (2001 .)
(2003 .) . 14 2003 ,
(.: 7080% [http://
xronika.az/sng/print:page,1,3423-tekst-konvencii-o-pravovom-statuse-kaspijskogo.html]).
26
.: Iran Wants Equal Caspian Division of Waters, Seabed [http://www.upi.com/Science_News/ResourceWars/2009/10/09/Iran-wants-equal-Caspian-division-of-waters-seabed/UPI-10581255113679/].
27
14. .
7 590 , 2 376 , 1 782 , 1 241 ,

34

14 2 2011

-
18 2005 . 2007 -
28.
- .
- () .


29. - : , .
, , 30. . , .
, .
. 22 2000

31.
, 16 1996
. 426 , 600 (.: . // (. . ), 2000, 1. . 101; [http://portal.mfa.kz/portal/page/portal/mfa/ru/content/policy/
issues/delimitation]).
28
[http://
www.rosgranitsa.ru/about/international/countries/delimitation].
29
7 000 :
2 376 , 1 878 , 1 283 ,
1 295 156 .
. .
30
:
(1946), -
(1958), , (1978)
- (1982)
. (c.: ..
: . . . . . .: , 1997. . 1617).
31
.: 176-II 15
2000 // (), 2000, 11. . 167.

35

14 2 2011

.
1.
-
.
2. -
, 32.
,
.
, -
, 33.

34.
- - , ,
35, .
.
-
. , 1999 ,
1999- 2001 2001- 2002 ;
.
16 2001 96% . ,
( 4% ); -
(9 2002 .).
. ( ) .
-
32
.: . . 1, 3 // .
33
.:
. . 1 // .
34
.:
. . 4 // .
35
, .
.

36

14 2 2011

, ;
36.
, ( ).
.
2003 - , 2004
.
2000
, 1961
.
- .
2002
- ; .
- 24 2009 ;
.


- 37.
, - 60 38.
, - .
, - .
n

-, - , 19201930- ,
.
, ..
.

-, , -

36
.: ( President.kz)
[http://missions.itu.int/~kazaks/rus/archive/0209/n0209a.htm].
37
.: - [http://mfa.uz/rus/
pressa_i_media_servis/news/250309r_1.mgr].
38
.: [http://www.mfa.tj/
index.php?node=article&id=498].

37

14 2 2011

. , - ;
,
39.
n

-, -
- .
, ,
, ,
; ,
. -
, , , .

-, -
,
, , .

-, ,
(8) : ()
, (, , ) ( ) , () .

,
, , .
, ,
, : , , .

; .
39
1955 ,
30 1961 . , (.: . . [http: www.cvi.kz/text/Safety/Etnic/html];
1 400 290 [www.kabar.kz]).

38

14 2 2011

, .
, -
, .
-
. ,
, , ;
.

.


2008





(, )


(TODAIE)
(, )

. , ,
-



, , . 39

14 2 2011

. ,
, , 1.
, , .
,
- . .
,
,
.
,
2003 ,

2. ,

.

. 2004


EUJUST Themis,
. , 3.
2004
.
. .
,
. ,
, 4.

, ,
.
,
,
.
. .

1
,
, .
,
2004 , . , .
. 18 2004
, . , 5
2004

.
, , 6 2004
.
2
.: Kirchner E.J., Sperling J. EU Security
Governance. Manchester: Manchester University Press,
2007. P. 51.

.: Ibid. P. 58.
.: Mirwaldt K., Ivanov V.I. Russia: Struggling for Dignity. .: Global Security Governance /
Ed. by E.J. Kirchner, J. Sperling. London: Routledge,
2007. P. 240.
3
4

40

14 2 2011



, 5. ,
: ,
6. , ,
, . .
n

-, ()
.

-,
( ) .

-, ,
.

, , - , , - , . . . , ,
7. , , . . , , , , . .

, , 8. ,
.
. , . .
, .
5
.: Kirchner E.J. Regional and Global Security: Changing Threats and Institutional Responses. .:
Global Security Governance. P. 3.
6
.: Webber M. Security Governance and the Excluded States of Postcommunist Europe. .: New
Security Challenges in Postcommunist Europe: Securing Europes East / Ed. by D. Averre, A. Cottey. Manchester:
Manchester University Press, 2002. P. 44.
7
.: Keohane R.O., Martin L.L. The Promise of Institutionalist Theory // International Security, 1995,
No. 20 (1). P. 39.
8
.: Keohane R.O. Neoliberal Institutionalism: A Perspective on World Politics. .: International Institutions and State Power: Essays in International Relations Theory / Ed. by R.O. Keohane. London: Westview
Press, 1989. P. 3.

41

14 2 2011

, ,
, ,
. . ,
, , , .
, , . ,
; , ,
,
. , -
( ), ( ) , - .
, , ,
9. .
- : .
. , , , , , . , . , , .
, ,
. , , , , , .
:
, - ,
. , .
, .
10.
,
, . . , . ,
9
.: Mearsheimer J.J. The False Promise of International Institutions // International Security, 1994/95,
No. 19 (3). P. 1012.
10
.: Keohane R.O., Nye J.S. Power and Interdependence. New York: Longman, 2001. P. 131.

42

14 2 2011

,
, .
. , , 11.
. ,
. ,
, .
: ,
12.
, , ,
, , , 13.
. .
, , , , , ,
14.
.
, . , . , .
.
, , . , , , : , ,
15.
.
, .
, . , .
11
.: Powell R. Absolute and Relative Gains in International Relations. .: Neorealism and Neoliberalism: The Contemporary Debate / Ed. by D.A. Baldwin. New York: Columbia University Press, 1993. P. 209233.
12
.: Keohane R.O. Governance in a Partially Globalized World // The American Political Science Review,
2001, No. 95 (1). P. 13.
13
.: Ideas and Foreign Policy: Beliefs, Institutions and Political Change / Ed. by J. Goldstein, R.O. Keohane. London: Cornell University Press, 1993.
14
.: Weldes J. et al. Introduction: Constructing Insecurity. .: Cultures of Insecurity: States, Communities and the Production of Danger / Ed. by J. Weldes et al. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1999.
P. 1017.
15
.: Risse-Kappen T. Identity in a Democratic Security Community: The Case of NATO. .: The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics / Ed. by P.J. Katzenstein. New York: Columbia
University Press, 1996. P. 357399.

43

14 2 2011

, , , . , .
,
. , ,

.
, , . ,
, . , ,
, . , , .
, , ,
.
, - :
,
. ,
, , , .
.
:
2008 ? ,
: - .
. ,
;
, , : , , , ;
, ,
. 2008
, ,
.




, ,
. 44

14 2 2011

1917 .
, ,
, .
1922
, 1925 . 1936 . , ,
. 1989 ,
. 1990
- . ,
1991 . , . 1992 , .
, 1990 , ,
, . -
, 2 1992 16.
, , , ,
. , , 17 .
(). , ,
, , ,
. ,
,
, . 18. , ,
, .
- , ,
, ,
16
.: Cornell S. Georgia: From Unitary Dreams to an Asymmetric Federation. .: Small Nations and
Great Powers: A Study of Ethno-Political Conflict in the Caucasus / Ed. by S. Cornell. Richmond: Curzon Press,
2000. P. 143196.
17
.:
Anchabadze Y. Georgia and Abkhazia: The Hard Road to Agreement // Caucasian Regional Studies, Special Issue,
1998, No. 3 (2&3). P. 412.
18
.: Rondeli A. Regional Security Prospects in the Caucasus. .: Crossroads and Conflict: Security and
Foreign Policy in the Caucasus and Central Asia / Ed. by G. Bertsch et al. London: Routledge, 2000. P. 49.

45

14 2 2011

19. . 1996
, ,
.
1999
2001 . 11 2001

.
,
2004 , 96% .
, ,
, 20. 2004
,

21.
. , . , ,
, , ,
, 22.
2008 .




1930 , 1921 1930 , 19
.: Corley F. South Ossetia between Gamsakhurdia and Gorbachev: Three Documents // Central Asian
Survey, 1997, No. 16 (2). P. 270.
20
Transparency International, , 133 (.: Transparency
International. The 2002 Corruption Perceptions Index [http://www.transparency.org.html], 22 June 2010). , 1999 , 20%
(.: U.N. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs.
Early Warning Assessment, November 2003). 51% , 23,6%
. 1989
(.: Philips D.L. Stability, Security and Sovereignty in the Republic of Georgia. .: Rapid
Response Conflict Prevention Assessment. Center for Preventive Action, 2004 [http://www.ciaonet.org/wps/phd01]).
21
.: Kasm K. Souk Sava Sonras Kafkasya ( ).
Ankara: USAK, 2009. P. 71.
22
.: zkan G. Grcistanda Yeni Ynetim, Etnik Ayrlk Blgeler ve Gvenlik ( .
). .: Orta Asya ve Kafkasyada G Politikas / Ed. by M.T. Demirtepe. Ankara:
USAK Yaynlar, 2008.

46

14 2 2011

.
1978
.
23. ,
18 1989 , , . 1990
,
. ,
. , . 1992 1925 , .
, 1993
24. 22 1993
, . 1 1993 - , , , . ,
, . 1994
- .
, , ,
, , .
, ,
25. , , ,
, 26. ,
, , ,
. , 14
1997 ,
. , , , . , , , .
, , 23 1998
. . ,
2325 1998 , 23
, .: Lynch D. Separatist States
and Post-Soviet Conflicts // International Affairs, 2002, No. 78 (4). P. 831848; Coppieters B. The Politicisation
and Securitisation of Ethnicity: The Case of the Southern Caucasus // Civil Wars, 2001, No. 4 (4). P. 7394.
24
.: Kasm K. Op. cit. P. 67.
25
.: Chirikba V.A. Georgian-Abkhazian Conflict and Its Aftermath. .: Caucasus: War and Peace /
Ed. by M. Ttnc. Haarlem, Netherlands: SOTA, 1998. P. 79.
26
.: Darchiashvili D. The Russian Military Presence in Georgia: The Parties Attitudes and Prospects //
Caucasian Regional Studies, 1997, No. 2 (1) [http://poli.vub.ac.be/publi/crs/eng/0201-04.htm], 10 June 2010.

47

14 2 2011

1997 .
. .
3 1999 . 97%
. ,
, .
. ,
, 2006
. , 2008 , ,
-, ,
. , 2008 , .




, , ,
. cordon
sanitaire ( ), 27. , .
,
. , 28. , 27
.: Bazolu-Sezer D. Russia and the South: Central Asia and the Southern Caucasus // European Security,
1995, No. 5 (2). P. 303323.
28
1990 , , .
, , , .
,
. , , . , ,
.
, , ( .: Amineh M.P., Houweling H. Caspian Energy: Oil and
Gas Resources and the Global Market // Perspectives on Global Development and Technology, 2003, No. 2 (3&4).
P. 391406; Bahgat G. Pipeline Diplomacy: The Geopolitics of the Caspian Sea Region // International Studies
Perspectives, 2002, No. 3 (3). P. 310327).

48

14 2 2011

, . 1991 , . , . ,
, . ,
, ,
, .
-
, - .
1993 ,
,
1994 , ,
, - . 1996 ,
,
. , , , 29. , , ,
.
() .
. 9 2001

,
. , .
,
.
.
,
. . 17 2001 , [ ] ,
.
- , , , , 30.
29
.: Cohen A. U.S. Policy in the Caucasus and Central Asia: Building a New Silk Road to Economic
Prosperity, 1997 [http://www.heritage.org/Research/Reports/1997/07/BG1132], 10 June 2010.
30
Klare M.T. Global Petro-Politics: The Foreign Policy Implications of the Bush Administrations Energy
Plan // Current History, March 2002. P. 102.

49

14 2 2011


, ,
. , :
, , .
,
, (.. , ) .
, , .
, . ,
, , 4 2008
, ,

. , , , . , : ,
31.
: , ,
, , . .
2008 ,
,
.
. ,
. ,
, .
, 1993 ,
,
. 2008
, ,
, . ,
31
, , , . , , , ,
,
. ( 2007 .),
, , .

50

14 2 2011

, .
.
, 70 000
.
, .
, . 32.
. , ; , , , , ,
33.
34.
, , , 56 , 35. , ,
,
, .



, , , ,
, , 7
(. 52) , .
.
, , : . , , ,
. , , . , , , .
.
32
.: North Atlantic Council Discusses Situation in Georgia // NATO, 12 August 2008 [http://www.nato.
int/cps/en/SID-0745DD58-902BDC72/natolive/news_43416.htm], 20 August 2008.
33
.: West Voices Dismay at Russias Unacceptable Move // Spiegel, 26 August 2008 [http://www.spiegel.
de/international/world/0,1518,574537,00.html], 6 April 2011.
34
.: Sarkozy Calls Special EU Meeting on Georgia/Russia // Euronews, 24 August 2008 [http://www.euronews.
net/2008/08/24/sarkozy-calls-special-eu-meeting-on-georgiarussia], 6 April 2011.
35
.: Press Conference on Georgia by Heikki Talvitie // OSCE, 14 August 2008 [http://www.osce.org/cio/
12323], 23 August 2008.

51

14 2 2011


()

1992 ( 1997
- ). 1994 . 1999
() ,
.
(). 2003 , , 2004 . 2006
. 2008 , .
12 2008 , , - -
- , 36.

12 2008 .
. , ,
.

.
. 19 2008
- .

, .
.
,
, .
,
.
, ,
,
36
.: Visit to NATO by Minister of Foreign Affairs and Deputy Minister of the Interior of Georgia // Press
Release, 12 August 2008.

52

14 2 2011

. . , ,
. , ,
. 20 23 .
. 27 2008 .
2008
, , . 2008 , ,
, .
.
2009 . , .

;
; ;
- . 2008

. - -
.
19992008
; ,
, .
.
.
(-T), ,
.
. , ,
. .
.
. .
-
53

14 2 2011

(EADRCC). 2008 EADRCC 37.



, . 2003 ,
,
.
(), 1 1999 . , , , , 38. , , , . , (, ,
, , ) , .
,
14 2006 , , ,
39.
,
37
2005 ,
, 2006 , .
38
(). , ,
, , . 19992006 505 . , . TACIS (TRACECA, INOGATE, ).
39

. 2 2005
,
. ,
.
. 20072013
, , . , 2007- 2010 . 120 .
, , ().

54

14 2 2011

, 40.
2008 -
.
41.
, .
1 2008 . , , , . , . , , , .
, 42. .
15 2008 27 , ,

12 8 2008
.
1 2008 43.
200 22 .
. 2010
26 .

,
. 44.
, , , , ,
, . ,
, ,
, . ,
, 40
,
, - , , , , , , ,
, .
41
1997- 2006 33 .
42
[http://eeas.europa.eu/georgia/eu_georgia_summary/index_en.htm], 6 2010.
43
[http://eeas.europa.eu/georgia/index_en.htm], 6 2010.
44
[http://www.eumm.eu/en/about_eumm/mandate], 6 2010.

55

14 2 2011

, ().
: ,
. , ,
.
,
. , , ,
, , , , 45.

.
2008
, .
, ,
46. , , . -
: , 5+2,
(EUBAM),
47. , , 48.

, , , . .
, . , , , , , , 49. ,
,
. 2003 , 50.
.
(, , , , ) 51.
[http://eumm.eu/en/intro], 6 2010.
6 . 22 2008

.
47
.: Report on the Implementation of the European Security Strategy. Brussels, 11 December 2008. P. 6
[http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/en/reports/104630.pdf].
48
.: Ibid. P. 9.
49
.: Ibid. P. 10.
50
.: Ibid. P. 11.
51
.: Parmentier F. Normative Power, EU Preferences and Russia: Lessons from the Russian-Georgian
War // European Political Economy Review, 2009, No. 9. P. 4961.
45
46

56

14 2 2011



13 1992 . :
. . . ,
- . 1994
,
, . 2006
,
, ,
- .
, , ,
.
.

. , ,
: ;

;
; .

1373
, 13 , 2006 .
. 2006
. .
, 57

14 2 2011

, . 2006
,
,
.
, .

() , ,

. 2007 -
, .
()
, 2007 .
2009 , 22 2008
, ,
16- . , 56 . : , , 2009 52. , .
. , , .
1992 . , ,
. 200 . 20 2009 .
2008
,
- . 2008 . ,
, , 28 . 12 2009
30 2009 ,
. , 30 2009 ,
, .
52
OSCE Chairman Regrets Disagreement on OSCE Future in Georgia // OSCE, 21 August 2008 [http://
www.osce.org/cio/50525], 23 December 2008.

58

14 2 2011

,
, , . ,

. - 2008
, , , , , 53.
. , , , .
, , .
2008 .
, . ,
- , ,
, .
,

. - , , . , , , 8
(. 52)
, , ,
. ,
, .
, - ,
, , . , . , , ,
. 2008
.

, , ,
53
.: elikpala M. Security in the Black Sea Region // Commission on the Black Sea Policy Report II, 2010
[http://www.blackseacom.eu/uploads/media/Black_Sea_Policy_Report_II_Security.pdf], 19 June 2010.

59

14 2 2011

, . ,
,
.
, .
2008 . : ,
, , , ,
, . ,
,
, . .
,
. ,
27 -, ,
.
, , , . , , . , , . , , .
, , ,

, , ,
. - , . , 1992
, , .
. , , , ,
- . , , , 2008
, ,
, .
, ,
. , .
, , ;
. , , , ,
60

14 2 2011

. 2008 . .
,
, , , , .
, ,
.
,
.

61

14 2 2011



:
, ,

,
,
(, )

, ,

2.

1
.: Fulle R. Political Competition in India.
Virginia: Sweet Briar College, 1969. 120 pp.; Kap Yun
Lee. Political Competition and the Party System in Japan. Yale: Yale University, 1984. 139 .; Bernholz P.,

Vaubel R. Political Competition, Innovation and


Growth in the History of Asian Civilizations. Cheltenham Camberley Northampton: Edward Elgar
Publishing, 2004. 225 .
2
. ( 1998 .) //
, 1999, 1 (2); . //
, 1999, 1 (2); .
// ,
1999, 5 (6); .


,
.
,
, ,
,
, 1; -

62

14 2 2011
. ,
.

. ,
19932001 ; ( )
(, ,
)
4.

.
- ( , ) :


()
();

. , 2009 .
1975 -
. , 19741977 ,
:
,
3.

, , .
,

,
. -
. ,
19771981 ,
. .

.
( , . )
, 1978 -

1) ;
2) ;
3) ;
4)
;
5) .5
, 2009 ,


6 ( , ,

-

. ,
. - //
, 2000, 1 (7); . :
// , 2004, 5 (35); .
//
, 2005, 2 (38); .
: //
, 2006, 1 (43) .
3
Ford G. Address in Helsinki before the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe, 1 August
1975 [www.usa-presidents.info/speeches/helsinki.html].

4
.: .. .. , 30 1997 // , 20 2010 [www.globalaffairs.ru].
5
.: 2009 Human Rights Report: Russia; 2009
Human Rights Report: Uzbekistan [http://www.state.gov].
6
.: bama B. Remarks to the Turkish Parliament. Turkish Grand National Assembly Complex, Ankara, Turkey, 6 April 2009 [www.whitehouse.gov].

63

14 2 2011


7. , ,

.



).
2009 ,
, .
, -

7
. , 4 2009 [www.america.gov].

I.
:
, ,



. , , , . ?
10

. ,
( )
. ; - (1997 .) (19982008 .) . , 8.
( , 2010 , . . , , ,
, 9; , 10. , , ,
, 11.)
,

. , , , .
8

2012 , 7 2011 // [mediamax.am].
9
Sargsyan S. Statement on the Occasion of the 20th Anniversary of the Republican Party of Armenia
[president.am].
10
.: , , 18 2010 [newsarmenia.ru].
11
., : . , . , 15 2010 [www.liberty.ru].

64

14 2 2011

, 2000 . 12. , 2001 13 .


, , 2004 . , ,
. (,
14. , , , . . , ,
.)
,
( , )
;
, ( 2003 .)
( 2004 .).
: , . ( , , . , . , ; , , 15.)
, , -, , -, , , -, , , .
2005 . ,
, , ,
.
- . . , , , , , , , , 16.
12
. (), 8 2000 [www.
kremlin.ru].
13
. , 1 2001 [www.kremlin.ru].
14
. , 26 2004 [www.kremlin.ru].
15
. , 4 2007 [www.president.gov.ua].
16
Mesquita B., Downs G. An Open Economy, a Closed Society // The New York Times, 17 August 2005.

65

14 2 2011

( . 1995 . , , ,
17.
, 1999 ., 1999 . . 2001 .18 2002 . ).
2005 , (, ..),
. ; , .
.

, . . , ;
45:25:3019. ,
, , .

,
,
- .
.
, ,
- 20.
. , . 2006 : , ,
( , . ).
. ,
, 21.
, , 19992000 .
17
.. XXI : , ,
1997 [www.press-service.uz].
18
.: .. .
, 27 2002 [www.press-service.uz].
19
.: Almond G., Powell G., Dalton R., Strom K. Comparative Politics Today: A World View. Boston, 1974.
20
.: . , 31 2006 [russian.kazakhstan.usembassy.gov].
21
.. VII , 10 2006 [www.
akorda.kz].

66

14 2 2011

( ) , , ;
,
22.

, , , , .

II.
.

?
,
, . , , (.. ),
, ,
. ( , , 23.)

(, , , ..).
, (, ), , (
, ..). , ,
() , , , .
: .
()
() , 24
; .
. , (),
, , ,
. , 12 2011 [www.kremlin.ru].
.: .. // , 2001, 3.
24
.: .. , 4 2001;
, 25 2005;
, 12 2011 [www.press-service.uz].
22
23

67

14 2 2011

. , 25.
() ( , ) , .
, , , , . ,
,
, , , , .
, ,
(
, ), .
, 20062008

. ( , ) .
,
, .
, ,
(.. 2008 .) ; 2006
. , . .
2008
. . ,
( , )
, , 26.
- , . , (, , ) ,
;
.
,
, ; , , 1999 1930 .
. - () 2008
( ). , , 25
.: .. , 21 1999; , 24 2006; -, 7 2010 [www.akorda.kz].
26
. , 6 2008 [ww.a
korda.kz].

68

14 2 2011

, ,
27. .
28.
-
, , : ; .
, ,

,
,
29. - .
,
, , , . . 2006 , , 30.
,
. (, ,
: = +
; .)

III.

?
. , , -
:
. , 31.
27
.. , 17
2008 [www.akorda.kz].
28
.: . , 6 2008.
29
.: . , 22 2011 [vlasti.net].
30
North D., Wallis J., Weingast . A Conceptual Framework for Interpreting Recorded Human History //
National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper Series [www.nber.org].
31
, , 23 2010 . , ,
, ; , .

69

14 2 2011


.
,
.
.
1. .
2. .
3. 32.
,
. : ? , , , ,
.
2011
; . ,
. , - 33.
2010 34.
, ,
, , 35.
.

, . , , 30
2010 . .
.
. , , , , 36.
28 2011
, , 37.
32
.: .. - // . : , 2009, 3.
C. 317. , , , (19931995 .).
33
.: . - , 25 2011 // [www.rian.ru].
34
.: . , 29
2010 [www.president.az].
35
.: . , 16 2009
[turkmenistan.usembassy.gov].
36
, , 11 2010 [www.president.gov.ge].
37
, 28 2011 [www.president.gov.ge].

70

14 2 2011

, ,
.

.
1. .
2.
, .
3. .
4. (, ).
5. .
( ); , .
38
; , , , .
, ,
. , :
1) (
);
2) ;
3)
( );
4) ,
, ..
;
. , , (), ( , ,
) :
, .
, , .
, ( , ), ,
, (.. ), , 39.
38
. . , 26 2011 //
[www.russ.ru].
39
.: . ? 11 2011 . // [megapolis.kz].

71

14 2 2011

(, )

. (,
40 .)

; , 41 .
:
- ,
,
, ( ), .
, 19942005 , , (
),
.
, , , , , ( )
.

:

, ,

, , (
) . ,
, 42, . ,
.
40
. , 9 2011
[www.president.az].
41
., : Babaoglu H. Logical End of Political Radicalism or Democracy Game of Anarchists
Completed, 8 April 2011 // Yeni Azdrbaycan Partiyas [www.yap.org.az]; .
.
42
Coalson R. The Gun is Hanging on the Wall // The Moscow Times, 10 January 2008.
.

72

14 2 2011

, ; , ,
, .. ,
, .
- , .
1. .
2. ,
.
3.
.
4. .
5. .
; .
, , , , , ,
.
, , , , , , , .. ,
.
. ,
, 43.
,
. , .

43
. , 14 2009 [www.
state.gov].

73

14 2 2011





,


(, )

20 ,


. ,
.
, ;
.

20 ,
.
;
.

, , .





. (XII .) , .
. , : ,
, ,
. .
;
19181921 .
. 74

14 2 2011

,
.
1990 (
)
1978 .
, 14
1990 .
9 1991 ,
. , 21 1921 . .
. , . ,
: , . , 19181921 .
: , 21 1921 , , , 1;
,
2. . .
. , 1918
1921 , , : ,
.
. (1992 .)
; 1995 , . 15 ( )
23 .
1999 ( 2007 .) ;
. .
,
20 1999 , , ,
7% ( 5%- )3.
, .
. 2003- 2010
17 . 6 2004
. , , 15 2010 .

; , . , ;
1
2
3

.: 1921 . . 70.
.: . . 67.
.: 1995 . . 50, 2. 1999 .

75

14 2 2011

, . , , , 2013 .
. , .
1995
, (
).
, . , ,
, , , . .

:

1995 ,
, .
, .
, 6 2004 , , 4. (
) . , . , .
, 15 2010 , 2013
,
. 2013
, , 200000 ( ), . , , - , .
2004 , . ,
2010 , 2013
. 2013
- ( ), ( ).
4

.: . 4, . 69, 1.

76

14 2 2011

2013 2/5 ( 1/3 ).


, 2013 ,
, ;
-.
,
: 2012 , 2013 .
, , 2010 , , , , . , 2012 , , -; , 150
. , ( ) .
-, , . . 1995 ,
.
, 2013 , ,
, - .
, , .
.
, , - . . ,
.
- ,
; . , .
, .
, . , , , ; , ,
( -). , , , ,
, ( ,
). , ,
: -, ?
, , - . ( 2012 .),
, , , , .
, ,
, , .
77

14 2 2011

, , , ,

.
, . .
( 2007 .), , . .
, .
, , .
, 2012 .
-,
,
.



; 1995 . , , ( );
. , , .
1995 , - 5. , - ( ).
. . - ( , . .):
(404,5), (499,9), (310,6), -
(108,8), (700,4), - (211,3), -
(47,6), - (474,1), (139,8). , (386,9) ,
(1152,5)6.
, .
, , - . . , .
, , .
5
6

.: , , 1995. 1, . 2, 3.
[http://www.geostat.ge/?action=page&p_id=472&lang=geo].

78

14 2 2011

, , , ,
.
, 1995 ,
. ; 20 2000 , . , 10 2002
, , , ( ).
. 2004 - ; ,
, . 75 25, .
, , : , , .
11 2008 , .
,
,
,
.
, .
, , , - .
,
. - ;
81- , , .
-
, 2013 , . , , 2013 -.
.
, 1995 ,
: 7.
.
, , ,
, .
7

.: , . 1, . 4, 1.

79

14 2 2011

235 150
, 85 . 2004 : 100 150 , 50
. , ,
, .
, , 12 2008
.
, 8.

, .



20 , ,
; . ,
. .
; , . , ,
2009 , 2012 ( ) . 2009 , , 9.
: 17 2011
, , .
, 2012 ,
-, ,
, 2013 , . .
, .
, , .
15 2010 - II , , . , 1 152 000 ,
150000. ,
,
8
9

.: 1995 . . 49, 1. 12 2008 .


.: . . 48, 1. 24 2009 .

80

14 2 2011

. , , 80 .
, ,
.
,
.
-
; , , . , 2012
.
( -), . , .
, , ,
.




.
, . ,
.
( ,
)
.

, 15 2010 :
.
.
, (
)10 . . ,
; , ,
, .
10
.: . // Journal of Democracy, 1999, No. 3 (.
. : CIPDD, 2000. . 13).

81

14 2 2011

, , ,
, :
, ,
11. :
, ;
, . , , . -
, .
. .
: , . . : , .
: , , , , .
, . , ;
,
(, ).
, ,

.
, ,
: , .

; 2013 .
:
. : ? ,
, ?
,
,
, ,
12. , 2004 . ,
, 2004 .
, , 1999 , ,
.
11
12

. // (), 26 2 , 2010. . 13.


. . 12.

82

14 2 2011

, 15 2010 ,
,
. ,
.

-

( )



(, )


,
.

; ,
,

.


.

,
-
. ,
, -


, .

1530 ,

. , ,
, ,
,
.
()
, ( )
. (
), ,
, .
83

14 2 2011


.
(,
) ,

.

( ,
).


;
, , .
,
78 , 25%
. ,
.
.
.


. , , ,
- . .
, , , - . , , ,
, .
,



.
, - .
, -

1. ,
,
. -
,
, , , ..


.
,
, . 20 , .
2.
,
84

14 2 2011
18 .
, ,
30 ( ).
,
18 29

30% ( ).
500
1 600 (. . 1).
, -
.

20092010 .
1 600 ;
,
( ), , (
).
14 ( 23 )
( )
.

, , -

1
-
1) :

2) :

52,9

14,5

47,1

58,6

26,9

3) :
,

44,6

4) :
/
37,4


3,5

23,7

3,5

28,2


2,0
/
56,6

/
0,4


, ,
85

14 2 2011

(, ).
. , ,
,
. , ,
, ,
, ; .
25%. 34%,
37% (. . 2).
2


( 2010 .)
100%
90%
80%

5,1
19,8

70%

8,7

7,3

7,2

25,4

29,5

24,7

60%
50%
40%

53,0
49,3

30%

49,9

47,0

20%
10%
0%

20,7
1829

13,3

13,0

15,6

3049

50+

, ,
. ,
, .
29% ,
21
16% (. . 3).
: ,
, 55% ,
42%.
, , ?
, ,
.
, 1829
86

14 2 2011
3



( 2010 .)
100%
90%

7,9

10,8

10,4

12,9

80%

70%
60%

59,1

50%

63,7

63,3

67,7

40%
30%
20%
10%
0%

28,9

20,8

16,4

3,3

2,8

1,0

2,5

1829

3049

50+

22,3

58400 ( 400 .), 56000 3049 53300


50 . , .
,
:
- , . , 53,5%
. ,
, . (. . 1).
1
-

( %, 2010 .)
1829

3049

50+

2,4

7,5

3,8

4,9

1,6

2,2

1,0

1,7

5,9

7,4

3,8

6,0


(, )

6,3

13,8

7,3

9,7

10,6

10,8

4,5

9,1

87

14 2 2011


1 ()
1829

3049

50+

1,2

3,8

3,0

2,8

5,9

10,1

6,3

7,7

9,6

12,9

5,3

9,8

(
)

0,4

1,3

51,5

14,2

28,4

9,1

13,7

12,7

7,5

11,7

11,4

13,1

4,8

10,4

2,4

4,4

1,5

3,0

,
, - . ,
:
18 22 .
4


( 2010 .)

65,5

28,7

3,6

50+

65,9

27,60

4,0

3049

65,7

29,7

2,7

1829

64,8

28,3

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

88

4,5
90%

100%

14 2 2011


: ,
4% (. . 4).
, :
,
.
, . , ,
, ,
(. . 2).
2


( %, 2010 .)
1829

3049

50+

54,4

60,8

62,6

59,2

47,5

49,5

55,7

50,5

37,7

41,7

31,2

37,7

30,8

32,8

25,5

30,2

24,0

26,6

33,2

27,5

33,8

21,3

21,8

25,4

21,8

22,0

18,1

20,9

25,5

17,3

7,7

17,4

8,6

8,3

34,9

15,4

14,9

15,0

11,4

14,0

10,4

15,6

11,6

12,9

13,6

14,8

8,7

12,8

7,3

11,9

20,0

12,6

13,0

11,9

12,1

12,3

12,8

11,7

9,2

11,4

8,4

12,5

9,4

10,4

12,4

9,4

6,4

9,6

89

14 2 2011


2 ()
1829

3049

50+

8,8

10,2

9,4

9,5

6,7

3,4

2,7

4,3

2,0

1,7

0,7

1,6

0,6

1,1

2,0

1,2

0,4

0,2

0,2

0,3

,
,
. ,
60% ( 54%, 48%);
, . , , , .
. ,
-
(63%) ;
3
:
-
, ?
( %, 2010 .)
1829

3049

50+

62,7

56,0

44,2

55,0

21,9

27,1

45,4

30,3

4,1

3,7

2,0

3,4

2,3

3,9

2,5

3,0

2,3

1,6

0,7

1,6

0,2

0,2

0,1

6,6

7,5

5,2

6,6

90

14 2 2011

(45%).
,
- , ( ) .
: 5% . (. . 3).


,
.
, : , , 20
- ,
. , .
.
: , .
, , .
,
, 22%
.
5,
.

. , 54%
, (
).
.
.
, (68% ),
(66%).
, ,
, 91

14 2 2011



( 2010 .)
100%
21,9

90%

14,9

13,3

16,5

80%

70%
60%
57,2

50%

46,5

58,0

54,8

40%

30%

20%

20,0

10%
0%

1829

38,1

27,3
3049

27,6

50+

; , ,
(. . 6).
6
( )

( 2010 .)

58,7


50+

64,8

3049

31,1

53,6
20%

10,7

26,1

59,1

1829
0%

30,6

33,5
40%

60%

92

9,1
9,9

12,9
80%

100%

14 2 2011

,
: 82% , 60%, 54%.
, , , ; , - .
33% , 44% .
, ()
( 41%, 39%). ,
, .
, , ,
.
, (. . 7).
7


( 2009 .)
0%

20%

40%

22,4

54,2

25,4

48,5

32,9

40,8

39,1

34,7

43,6

19,3

49,5

100%
8,3

60,1

80%

82,0

60%

9,6
17,4

20,4
18,6
20,0
21,7
31,2

, ; , 4%

, 6% ( 3% 5%
).
93

14 2 2011

, , ; , 25% , ,
(28%). (27%).

:
( 50 15%) (. . 8).
8
:
( )

(, ) ,
?
( 2009 .)
100%
90%

9,8

11,9

8,5

10,3

80%
70%

37,5

60%

38,4

52,3

41,6

50%
40%

28,0

30%
20%
10%
0%


29,0
24,1

27,4

16,7

13,9

7,8

6,7

11,0
4,1

14,1

1829

3049

50+

6,4


. , ,
,
, . ;
, .
?
?
94

14 2 2011

,
- .
, .
, , . , , .

. , , , 30% .

, ,
.
,
- .
, (
23% ),
, .
, : - , , .
,
(. . 4).
4
:
?
( %, 3 )
1829

3049

50+

29,8

30,4

29,7

30,0

29,6

29,6

31,7

30,2

23,1

19,9

18,9

20,6

22,9

19,6

13,8

19,1

21,3

24,5

24,1

23,4

21,1

24,2

26,4

23,8

21,1

22,2

26,4

23,0

13,2

8,8

7,6

9,9

12,8

14,6

13,3

13,7

11,5

14,9

16,3

14,2

95

14 2 2011


4 ()
1829

3049

50+

11,5

16,3

12,6

13,8

9,3

9,3

11,7

9,9

8,1

8,8

10,3

9,0

5,1

5,3

5,3

5,3

4,9

4,0

6,0

4,8

3,8

4,0

4,8

4,1

0,4

0,1

7,5

7,6

5,1

6,9

,
, ; ,
( ).
,
.
,
, : . , ,
, , , . , ; ,
. , ,
(50%) (25%).
,
( ) ,
;
, ( ) .
, -
( 36%); 16% 1829 ,
3 .
, 16% 50 8%
(. . 5).
. , . 96

14 2 2011
5

:
,
?
( %, 2009 .)
1829

3049

50+


( )

15,5

8,8

5,9

10,2

,
,

17,0

19,1

20,4

18,7


( )

15,1

16,7

15,6

15,9

8,0

10,8

15,6

11,1

37,0

35,5

34,7

35,8

7,4

9,1

7,9

8,2


(15 )

-

;
, - - .
2009 ( . [eurasiamonitor.org])
14 ,
, ( ).
6 ,
(
XX .).
n

-, ,
;
. , 1829 22% ( 50 9%), 13% 2%.

-, ( 19371938 .),
, : (
45% 54%), (35%).
97

14 2 2011


XX ( %)

6. 1991

7.
1991

98

5.
1945
(

19411945 .)

4.
19371938 ,
,

3. 1922

2.

( 1917 .)

1. 1917

( )

1829

21,9

12,4

20,7

27,1

17,9

3049

9,8

12,7

24,1

35,0

18,3

50+

9,1

11,5

23,3

40,9

15,2

1829

14,4

9,8

25,6

38,0

12,1

3049

5,8

15,0

21,0

49,1

9,2

50+

5,4

10,5

17,2

58,8

8,1

1829

13,0

5,2

20,5

52,4

8,9

3049

6,0

6,0

16,5

60,7

10,7

50+

4,7

4,4

13,9

68,6

8,4

1829

15,0

65,4

8,9

4,0

6,6

3049

6,3

74,6

7,6

5,1

6,5

50+

5,4

73,6

7,4

5,7

7,8

1829

1,7

4,6

2,9

87,3

3,5

3049

1,1

3,6

2,2

91,3

1,8

50+

0,7

5,1

4,4

88,5

1,4

1829

4,9

31,7

14,4 35,45

13,5

3049

1,6

45,1

16,7

27,0

9,6

50+

0,7

49,0

16,2

25,7

8,4

1829

1,2

2,3

7,2

85,6

3,7

3049

0,9

2,7

6,7

86,6

3,1

50+

0,7

1,0

6,8

89,2

2,4

14 2 2011

-, , . ,
.

,
, . , , ,
.

:

?
, :
?
, , ?
.. 1,
,
(,
, ), , , , - . (),
( , )
.
- .
( , ..)
(, ).
- , - .
XX ,
( 1960- . , , 1986 . ..).

;
(, ),
() (, 1

.: .. . ., 2007.

99

14 2 2011

, ),
, ().
, ,
. ,
.

, , , , . , , ,
, , .
,
,
. , , 20

.

( ). , .
, (, , ), (
) .. , ,
, . ,
, .
- . , ,
. .

100

14 2 2011




,
,
,

(, )

()
: .

.
,
.


- .
(), , ,

, . .
. , , , .
, ,

1.
1
. .
.: , 1998. . 149.

113

14 2 2011


;
,
1980- 1990- . ,
.
,
, -

: .
:
I.
.
II. .
III. .

I.




, , , .
, (. . 1),
.
, . , ,
(
); ; ,
, ,
. ,
, .
, , . , , , . : () 23 2,

.
2
.: .. ? [http://zpolk.ucoz.org/news/kuda_plyvet_vmf_rossii/
2009-11-03-23], 20 2011.

114

14 2 2011
1

1991 100 .
60 . 835 , 28 , 2 , 6
I , 20 II ,
II , 40 , 30 , 70 , 50 , 400 . , 2 ( ), 1 , 2 (
), 1 ,
, , , , 3.
2011 50 ,
;
. , 1015 4.
3
.: . . // . net, 12 2010 [http://korrespondent.
net/worldabus/1075441-ria-novosti-chernomorskij-flot-cena-sily],19 2011.
4
.: .

115

14 2 2011

, , : 30% .
. , ( , )5 , , 6.
(, ,
) ; 3040- ,
- .
, ,
.

.
. (- ),
. :
, , , , , ,
7. . . 2 2010 , .

II.

, ,
.
; .
(. . 1 )
, ,
.

, .
,
, , , ,
.
5
.: ., . // ( ), 2 2009 [http://kp.ua/daily/211109/203234/], 21 2011.
6
.: . . 1 [http://flot.com/nowadays/structure/black/
bsfisdying.htm], 12 2011.
7
: // . net, 2 2010
[http://korrespondent.net/ukraine/politics/1145019-kuchma-rossijskij-flot-v-podmetki-ne-goditsya-tureckomu], 28
2011.

116

14 2 2011

, 2001 , ,

,

, 8.
.
, ,
, 9.
, , ,
. ,
; ,
. ,
, , , 10.
, , ,
;
, .
20 , ,
XVIII ,
. ,
XVIII . ( ,
) ;
.
,
, , , ,
,
. , , - , , , , , .
, , , , 11.
8
.: The Caucasus and Caspian Region: Understanding U.S. Interests and Policy. Hearing before the
Subcommittee on Europe of the Committee on International Relations House of Representatives. One Hundred
Seventh Congress. First Session, 10 October 2001. P. 1 [http://commdocs.house.gov/committees/intlrel/hfa75632.
000/hfa75632_0.html], 22 March 2011.
9
Remarks of President George Bush to the Capital City Partnership. St. Paul, Minnesota, 17 May 2001
[http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2001/05/20010517-2.html], 18 March 2011.
10
.: Shaffer B. U.S. Policy toward the Caspian Region: Recommendations for the Bush Administration
[http://belfercenter.ksg.harvard.edu/files/brenda_shaffer_policy_recommendations.doc], 27 March 2011.
11
. [http://www.from-ua.com/politics/415036e46b590/], 29 2011.

117

14 2 2011

.
, , 3 10012. 2011 ,

, , , , , , , 13.
;
,
,
.
, .
( . ,

, , :
14) ( . ,
15), ()
.
, , .
,
, , . : ,
, , ,
, , , , 16.
, 2010 ,
, 49% 30 ,
.
17. , ,
.

- ; .
,
.
, ,
.
12
.: [http://www.rada.crimea.ua/structure/factions/5],
22 2011.
13
.: . . //
, 2011, 04 (254) [http://www.sobytiya.com.ua/public/9075], 27 2011.
14
. . .: , 1996. C. 155157.
15
.. . .: -, 2006. . 499.
16
. . . . 243.
17
.: 49% // - , 11 2011[http://poglyad.te.ua/2011/03/49-molodi-zahidnoji-ukrajinyhochut-vyjihaty-z-krajiny-na-postijno/], 22 2011 ( . .).

118

14 2 2011

,
, , ( 1952 .).
, ( ),
: ,
. ,
; , .
, ,
-,
, . , .
, . 1990- . , 1999
, . ,
.
18.
, , , .
,
. ,
, , , ,
19.
( ).
, ,
. ,
. . , , - .
.
The Caucasus and Caspian Region: Understanding U.S. Interests and Policy.
.: Cohen A., Conway I. U.S. Strategy in the Black Sea Region // Backgrounder, 13 December 2006,
No. 1990. Published by The Heritage Foundation [www.heritage.org/research/RussiaandEurasia/bg1990.cfm],
14 March 2011.
18
19

119

14 2 2011

,
20.
, ,
.
, 70% 21.
( - 2008 .). , ;
.
,
: , , .
, 1990- 22.
, ( ), ,
(. ..): ,
. , ,
, 23.
,
( , ), , . , .
.
, , , ,
, , .
, , , , , , , , , ,
24 ( ).
( ) () ,
.
20
. , . , 26 2011
[http://www.kavkaz-uzel.ru/articles/180157/], 26 2011.
21
.: Fiona H., Omer T. Turkey and Russia: Axis of the Excluded? // Survival, Spring 2006, Vol. 48, No. 1
[www.brookings.edu/views/articles/fhill/2006_survival.pdf], 20 2011.
22
.: The Caucasus and Caspian Region: Understanding U.S. Interests and Policy.
23
Ibidem.
24
. , . , , . , ( .. . . . 497).

120

14 2 2011
2

,
, ,
. , , , . ,
.

III.


. , : (, )

121

14 2 2011

( ) 25 . .
. , , , ( . )26.

; , , ( ).
, :
, . , - .
( ), , , ,
, ,
27.
, . (, ) . ,
, , . , 2011 ,
(. ,
)28 , , , .
,
(, -
- , 4 .), :
,
- . ?29
, , ( . ).
,
(
). 2000- . , , 25
( .-. , ;
) , , .
26
.: . . . . 119.
27
.. .
.: : .
.: . , 2006. . 46.
28
// .Ua, 24 2011 [http://www.
segodnya.ua/news/14235042.html], 29 2011.
29
. [http://www.mgimo.ru/news/experts/document183886.phtml],
4 2011.

122

14 2 2011

. :
, , 30.

, , ,
( - ). , , . ,
( ).
XXI ,
, .
,
, XX .
,
, ( , ),
.
, ,
, .

: , , , , ,
, ,
, . , : ,
. ,
.
, 2011
,
. ,
, -
.

( ): .
, ,
,
.
, , ,
2012 ... -
, 2011 4 , 3 ,
5 , 3 , 30
.. : // ( ), 2004, . 9, 2. . 4145 ( . .).

123

14 2 2011

. 1,5
. 1 , 700 . 1937 200 . ,
, . 2006 96 175 . 3,8 , 1,9. ,
. -
1945 . 750 . 678
, .
, 3742 . 20 23 . .
7 . , ,
(13%), , , ( 57%),
(61%) (66%). 1,5% 50% 31.
, . ,
. .
, 17 2011 ; , , : . , : 32.
,

, . ,
: , .
, , , . - : ,
, , , , 33.



, . . : 6
, . : ,
, . 34.
31
. : , , // , [http://www.inosmi.ru/
politic/20110207/166314712.html], 25 2011.
32
.. .. , 17 2011[http://
www.kprf.org/showthread.php?t=9757], 27 2011.
33
. : . [http://www.ushistory.ru/essay/278-donald-genriramsfeld.html], 29 2011.
34
. : . .: - -; : - ,
2001. 656 . ( ). . 128129.

124

14 2 2011


, () ,
35 .
(. : )36, - ; ,
(
) , , .
,
( , )
, , , .
, ,
, , .
35
36

.
.. . . . 513.


PAX IRANICA:


,


(, )


() ,

, .
,
-

125

14 2 2011

,
2000- ,
,
, .
,
,
, , ,
. , ()

. ,
,
.
, ,

Pax Iranica. .
:
,

. .

, ,
. , , :
, ,

.
,
:
, , , , , . , ,
,
,
, , .

Pax Iranica
( ) , , , , , ,
.

.
,
1990- . 1990- 2000-
.
.
- . , 126

14 2 2011

. ,
- .
:
,
; .
. ,
.
, 20042005
, . , , ,
. ,

.
. , . - .
. , , ,
, .
, , .

- .
(, , , , ), , - .
,
. , : , , , ,
. : , . . , .
, , , , , . . , 127

14 2 2011

, , . , .
,
, , .

. , . 1990-
.
,
. ,
,
. .
,
. . , . , , .
, .
:

,
.
, , ,
. - , , , .
-
, , ,
. -

. , , , .
, . 128

14 2 2011

, . , - . .
, ,
,
, , ,
. , .
,
.
, .
, .
.
. . , () , , , . , , .
- ,
. . -, .
, , ,
. , 2010 . , ,
. .

.
;
, .
: , , , .

. ; ; 129

14 2 2011


.
, .

, . .
, , . , .

- , ,
()
.
,
, :
.
. , , .
2007
, , .
. -
. - .
,
,
.
1, , , , , 20% .
,
. 2001 , : ,
.
1
19982003 ,
.

130

14 2 2011

: , . ,

, .
, :
, , . , , .

, , .
. . ,
. , , .

. .
, : ,

. , , .
,
, -. , :
, , , .
, ; .
, , , .
, . , . , . , ,
.
,
, : .
, .
, ,
.
:

.
; 131

14 2 2011


.

:
() . ,
.
: ,
, , .
, .

.
. ,

. .
()
. ,
.

.
, , .
,
- , , .
, .
( )
. ,
.
. . , , .
.

, , , , . 15

.
,
132

14 2 2011

. ,
. : ,
.
-
, . ,
,
.
, . , .
1996 ,
, . ,
90% .
1990- ,
-. 2003
- ,

. 10 .
140 . , , , , . 2 1 .
1997 6 .
- -,
5% . - .
.
.
2009
14 . . 30 42 . .
,
2009 . 8 . - . 2009 20 . .

. , .
.
( , ) ,
133

14 2 2011

.
, ,
. ,
, , ,
.
,
, , . .



. - , , XXI . ,
. , , , , .
, . ,
( ) . ,
, -
, .
2003 (, ), 2001
. , ,

.
, , . , , , ,

,
.
, , (), . ,
, , ,
. -
. ( ).
134

14 2 2011

,
. ,
. .
.
,
( ), , ,
,
. , , ,
. .
2014 .

.
-
. ,
,
: .
, ,
.

150 . , , ,
900 . . 2010 . . ,
.
, - .
,
, .
,
.

, ( , ) .
, . .
, .
. , , ,
, 2011 ,
.
135

14 2 2011

,
.
, , ,
, .
.
2008 1,15 .
5 .
, , . 217 , - . 180 .
. .
, , , , , .
, 10 . ( ).
; , ,
-
. . - , .
-
. 2010 .
. , ,
. .
, . , , , .
, : , , , , .
. -,
. 2006 (
) 500 . ( , ) , 1 . 400 500 .
, .
. , 2002
136

14 2 2011

560 . . 2005
132 .
10- .
122 68 .,
- , , .
.
.
, , .
1 .
( . ).
( ),
. .
, , 1979 3 . . 800 . .
, , , .
, . . 2010 , .
, .

, .

,
,
.
, ,
.
. ,
. , ,
.
, : 2011
, , , .
, .
-
. , , .
, , . - .
137

14 2 2011

,
, .
, , .
, .
, .
(,
, ) . :
;
( ).
( -) .

. 2008 .
/ . 2009 .
:
1. . .
2.
( ). , ,
,
, ..
3. , .
6+2 , 19992001 , ,
, , .

. -, . -, , ,
. -,
, , , , ..
. , , .
138

14 2 2011

,
, .
.
. 2006
,
, - , , .
20092011 1,5 .
. 2008 2,4 .
. 50 .
. 20062010 ,
, (, , , , ) .
, . .
, .
( ),
, , .
, ( ) ,
, . , 30 50 . ., - . ,
(, , ), , , .


?

. , . , , , , , .
.
, , 139

14 2 2011

.

().
. . ,
. .
.
, (
) , , .
.
.
.
, , , , ,
, . (, ).
.

, , , ,
, .
( ), , ,
.
.
,
. . 2004
. ,
-1 .
.
.
20062008 , (, ,
, , ).
. , ,
, -
.
- .
: ,
, , . , . ,
. , ,
.
.

, 140

14 2 2011

. 2010 65,5 . , .
201,7 .
2011 -2 ; : 350 (170 ) .
,
.

, , , ,
. - , , 2008 . -, , .
. , 13% . ,
-
.
. 2011 .
.
, .

.
2001 2004
.
. , 1999 . -
.
, ,

. ,
,
. ,
, ,
, - .
2007 ,

. , ,
141

14 2 2011

.
.
2008 -
. , ,
.
, , , ,
. ( - , ,
..)
.
2004 , ,
3,6. . , ,
.
2009 . , ; . ; 2010 , . ,
-
. , ,
. , .
. , . , , - . ,
.
,
. . ,
. - ,
. .
: . , , . , , . ,
142

14 2 2011

, ,
.
. 2010 . : , ,
-. , , .
. , ,
, .
, - ,
( ) . ,
, 2. 2004 , . -25, ,
.
, ,
. , ,
.
,
- 3 200 , .
. , , 2014 .
,
. , , , , , .
: 170 . .
. ,
.
, .
, , 2010 . , , .
. -, 2010 (
, ) .
2
70 . .
19,5 . ,
201- , .

143

14 2 2011

-
. , ,
3. . 2010 -
-2010 .
, , . 2010 - , , ,
, 4.
, ( 2010 . ,
), ,
. . , , . .
, 1 200 ,
. 2002 - .
. ,
- , .
.
, ,
. , , , .
. ,
, .
, . ,
,
, (
).
3
10 2010
- . ,
, ,
.
4
6 . , 1 108
. 1,3 , 52 , 50 , , 400 .

144

14 2 2011

,
(
), . , , .
,
. ,
, .
.
2009 . - , ,
- , , , .
,

, , .

,
. 1 ., .
2010 .
: - ,
- , .

.
,
.
: ,
.
,
. ,
.
- ,
, , (, ,
). .
2010 , 10 .
- . 2011 . ,
, .
145

14 2 2011

, , , , .
, , . , , , 35% .
, , , .
.
, .

:
; ; ; ;
; ; ;
.
, .
, - .
, - , . , ,
- .
, , - . () ()
, .
2002 ,
20 . 150 ,
. 12 - -29.
, ,
, , , , .
: .
.
.
, , .
,
(, ) ,
, .
146

14 2 2011

,
.
, (
- ),
- .
.
. , , ; .
: 10 10 .
.
1 .
250 .
.
:
1) ( 20 .);
2) ;
3) ;
4) .
.
,
, ,
.
- . -. .
. (13 17 720
86,3 ). , ,
.
. .
. , 2010 -
.
.
. , . , ,

.
, 147

14 2 2011

. . ,
, , . ,
.
, , ,
, , , .

, .
Pax Turkica .
, ,
.
, , , -,
.
, , . (
).
, ( ). ,
.
?
. , ,
,
. ( ) , , .
.
,
. . , -
. , .
( ),
.
,
, . ,
-
( ), ( )
( ).

148

14 2 2011


:




(, )


()

. ,
.


:


(), ;

;

;

;
.

, 1.
, , ,
, ,
.
1
., : . : // , 2007, 3 (51).
. 59.



, ( 1996 .
, , , ), 2001 .
: ,
.
149

14 2 2011

(), 2004 , , ,
.

, ,
.
(2009 .)
, 20102012 . , (
).
,
,
.
, - ,
.

. 2007 .
( )
2. . , 2009 , .
, , .
.
, ( ).
, , : ,
( ), ,
. , , .
, , ,
.
, . 2
.: .. // - 27 2007 .
[http://www.kyrgyz.mid.ru/press_rel/07_03.html].

150

14 2 2011

. . . , , . , , .
. , , , ,
3. , , ,
,
.
. , ,
4 ( ).
, .
2010 . ,
; ,
.
; . , 2009 - .
2002 , , .
2004 , . , . .
. 2007 , ; 2009
,
, , 5.

, 27 2009
.
3
.: - // , 16 2009 . [http://news.kremlin.ru/
transcripts/4465].
4
.: .
5
.: .. () // .. , 14 2009 [http://www.premier.gov.ru/pda/visits/world/136/3886.html].

151

14 2 2011

,
. ,
. .
, -
- .
2009
. ,

,
.



(
, 2006 .); , , , .
2004 .
, 2006 .
- . ,
, , .
, . , , , . 2004 , 2005-.
?
(
), .
, , , ,
. , - , 6.
6
.: . . .:
: , . IV (7 2006 .). : ,
2006. . 212228.

152

14 2 2011

, , , , .
34 ,
. - ,
, .
- , ,
.
, ; .
, ,
, . 7
; ,
,
-. , , , .
; , .
(, ,
),
, ,
.
,
. 2007 ,
( , ).
- : ( ) ,
.
, - , --.
,
, .
, , ; . 2006
.
,
.
, .
,
7

2006 .

153

14 2 2011

. ,

.
, ,
(, )
.
- (,
+ ) , 8.
,

. , .

,
.
,
. , .


,
, .
1. , , , .
2. .
3. ,
.
4. , .
, 2005 ,
(, , )9. , ,
, .
2009 .
. . ,
8
.: .. : . : , 2006. . 227.
9
.: . // - - , 7 2007 [www.ia-centr.ru].

154

14 2 2011

. ( )
. . .
, , , . ,
. ,
.
, , 10.
, .
- ;
.



. ,
, ;
.
, - ,
, , 11.
, , ,
, 20 , 8
- . , , . 120 , 11 ; 900 ., .
, , 2005 .
() () ;

.
Weitz R. Renewing Central Asian Partnerships // NATO Review, Issue 3, Autumn 2006.
.: // -, 3 2007 [http://www.
asiastrategy.ru/?tm&mat_id=492&PHPSESSID=f5da72f00d421c981680781da6cacf32].
10
11

155

14 2 2011

-
( ), .
. 2009
-
. . , 35 6 . ,
,
-,
.
( )
,
. .

10 .
; .
,
, , . , ,
. . , , .. , 12. , . .
2006 .
,
,
, , .

, . , , .
, .


, 2001 , ,
. 12
.: // 26 2006 .
[http://council.gov.ru/files/journalsf/item/20070725100417.pdf].

156

14 2 2011

2005 .
,
; ,
, .
2009 . ;
.

. (),
, 13.
,
.
( ), , ,
, - 14.
,
, .
,
.

.
2009
, ( ).
, , ,
.
.

;
,
.
, , .
,
,
, .
; . .

()
. , , .
13
: , , , .
14
.: .. : // , 2009, 9.

157

14 2 2011

; , , ,
.
,
.
. , 15.
2009
.
. , : , 16. .
.
, ( ) ,
, .
, , ( ).
- [www.infoshos.ru], .
,
, , , ,
.


. - , , .
,
17.
15
.: //
, 18 2009 [http://infoshos.ru/ru/?idn=4996].
16
.: // , 23 2009 [http://
www.infoshos.ru/ru/?idn=4490].
17
.: : //
, 26 2009 [http://www.infoshos.ru/ru/?idn=4449].

158

14 2 2011

, ,
:
, - ,
, - .
: , . ,
; . .

,
.
, , , . - .
.
, ,
,
.
, , .
,
. / , .

, .
.
,

, .
. .
,
, .
.
,
, .

159

14 2 2011







(, )

(), 2001
, .

,
, .


.


.

,
, ().
,

( ),
, .



. ,
( , ). .

(2001 .) .
,
,
. 160

14 2 2011

, , - . , .
, - , ,
.
, . - , .
, - .
. , ,
.
, , , , -1.
.
n

-, , ,
,
. , ,
.
,
2.

-, ,
3. :
( ) , . ,
,

.

1

(., : . : , 6 2007 [http://www.infoshos.ru/ru/?idn=330]).
2
, ,
.

.
3
.: , 18 2007 [http://www.fergananews.
com/article.php?id=5292].

161

14 2 2011

-, ( , ). , ,
(
), - ().
,
2005 4: .
, , .
, , ,
, 5.

-,
. ,
2010
2010. . , , . -

.
, ; .


- .
,
(, , , ). , , , - ,
.
, .
1. , ( ). , , , . , ,
4
.: , 6 2005 [http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.
php?st=1120666800].
5
.: .. //
, 2007, 6.

162

14 2 2011

, . , ,
.
,
.
2.
;
.
. :
. , .
. , , , .
3. ,

. ; , , . ,
, 2010
, .
4. , , , .
. , -
, ,
,
, 6.
5. . ,

. .
6
: ( :
), 24 2010 [http://news.163.com/10/1124/17/
6M97CJE900014JB6.html].

163

14 2 2011

, - ,
, .
, ,
, .
.. , ,
-, . , , , ,
7.
, ,
, ().
, , ,
.




, , . ,
( ) , .

,
, .
,
. , ,
- - , .
. . 2009 , 7
.. : ? // ,
2007, 3. . 47.

164

14 2 2011

:
6,4 ., - , Google,
- ..

. ,
, , 40%;
2010
.
, , , 8.
, , . , .
.
, .
.
, ; . , ,
.

, .
- .
, .
1112 2010 , .
, .
,
, ,
. , , .
- ( ).
, , ,
; ,
8
.: : ( :
) //
[http://www.coscos.org.cn/200806022.htm].

165

14 2 2011

(
).

, - ,
- , . , , ?
, , , .
, .
,
.
.

. ,
; .
. ,
, 9.
, , - , , , .
, ; . , . / , ,
.
,
. , .
.

cat/94/].

: [http://www.newsland.ru/News/Detail/id/457728/

166

14 2 2011


,


(, )


. , ,
, .

(). :
n

,

;

-,
- ;

(, , , .).

,


.

,

, .

( - ),
. ,
, .

1991
, .

167

14 2 2011



19911993 . , 1. ,
.
,
2.
,

, 3; .
, -,
:
,
.
,
.
19941997 . ,
.
, .
1990- ; ,
- .

().
( ) ( ),
.
.
, .
, -
, ; - . , 1
2
3

.: . . .: ; , 2004.
.: Ray J.L. Democracy and International Conflict. Columbus: University of South Carolina Press, 1995.
. . .: , 2000. . 235.

168

14 2 2011

,
, .

, . 1997
.
, (). ,
, .
1990-
,

.
.

. - : , ,
.
,
; , , : 4.
, .
.

,
- . , ,
- , .
1990- 2005 , -, , , - , .
19982000 . .
2001
; ( , ) .

. , 4
.: Lane Ch. Germanys New Ostpolitik: Changing Iran // Foreign Affairs, November/December 1995,
Vol. 74, No. 6. P. 7789.

169

14 2 2011

Mobil
. ,
, - -.
, , - , .
,
, .
, 1994 , .





20012005 . 2001
; - -
. , 5.
2002
, ,
, ,
- ,
.

;
n


ad hoc ;

( ), 2002 ;

, (. . 1);

5

, ,
.

.

170

14 2 2011

, .
1
,
, ,

20022005 ( .)

2002

2003

2004

2005

90

92

74,2

53,2

95

56,6

50,8

50,4

18,1

11,1

10,4

16,3

220

86,1

50,6

91,6

160

49

50,7

59,9

:
[www.usinfo.state.gov].


,
, ( ).
-
, .
- ,
.
, ,
( ), .
, , , -
9,4 . , , , 40%6.
-
7.
.
,
. , // , 28 2004.
., . // (), 2003, 6. . 202.
6
7

171

14 2 2011

, . ,

, ,
-
, . , 60%
-8;
9 2005
19,2% (151,9% 9 2004 .) 6,8% (125,6%
9 2004 .)9.
()
.
.
, , : ,
10. , ,
,
2009 .
20062008 . . ; , , 79% (
72% 2005 .) , 58% (45% 2005 .) ( , , , )11.
, ,
.
, , ;
, . ,

.
-

.
,
;
,
() .
8

47, 49.

.: . // (), 2005, 10 (73). . 45,

9
.: . - , 2005 //
, , 2006, 11. . 55.
10
.: [www.usinfo.state.
gov/russian], 21 2005.
11
.: Polls: Americans, Europeans Share Increased Fears of Terrorism, Islamic Fundamentalism // Transatlantic Trends. Washington, D.C., & Brussels [www.transatlantictrends.org], 6 September 2006.

172

14 2 2011

,
.
; ,

2009 ,
.
2006
.
, , .
.
, ,
- .



2009
. 2009
. ,
, , , , ;
.
.
2009
;
, , , , .
,
; .
,
, .
, 12,
6+3 , 12
.: . :
[www.ia-centr-ru], 2010.

173

14 2 2011

. , ,
. ,
.
,
.
(), , (, , ),
.

. ,
; - .
, (
, ,
-
). , 13, .
14, 7 :
1.
, -
.
2. ,
. , , .
3. -, , , - .
4. , ,
, , , , .
5. .
6.
,
, , , .
13
C., : //
America.gov, 14 2011.
14
.: Feigenbaum E. Seven Critical Guidelines for U.S. Foreign Policy in Central Asia // Council on
Foreign Relations [www.businessinsider.com/seven-guidelines-for-us-central-asia-policy], 23 February 2011.

174

14 2 2011

7. ,
.
, .
-, - , .
.
- :
;
;

15.

.
, , ;
. , ( ) .
, , .
, ,
, , . 16,
.
,
2010 Rasmussen Reports:
. CNN
: 58% 17.
,
; - 18. ,
,
; 2009 . . -

.
, , , (
15
.: Rozoff R. Washington Intensifies Push into Central Asia [www.scoop.co.nz/stories/HL1101/S00127/
washington-intensifies-push-into-central-asia.htm].
16
.: . . // , 8 2010, 49 [www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=
1292015400].
17
.: U.S. State Department. USA Forum on Facebook [www.america.gov].
18
- 15 2011 [www.america.gov/st/eur-russian/
2011/March/20110315105450x0.7276226.html], / -, 10 2011.

175

14 2 2011

) , 19.
, ,
,
- .
. , ;
, , . , I , , 1990- 20.
, ,
. -
. ,
21.
,
, .
, ,
.


, , ,
, .
, , , , .

;
.
-
, ,
.

. ,
.
,
, , . 19
.: .
// REGNUM [www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=1295472840], 19 2011.
20
. // REGNUM [www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=12
92143920], 12 2010.
21
.: . [svpressa.ru/society/article/40433/].

176

14 2 2011

, , , .
, , ,

. , , ( ).
, - :
(
, , ).
,
( , ), .

, .
, , , .
, ,
, :
n


, ;

-

;

177

14 2 2011




,

(, )


().
,
.

. ? ,
,
. 1 2010

.
,

, .

50 . ,
, - .
,
2010 28,1%
20% 1. 1
.: [www.kazinform.kz].

178

14 2 2011


() 1 31 2010 91,2 , 1,2 , 2009-.

1 2010- 31
3,7 ,
1,3 ,

2009-2 . 1 2011
, .
2
.:
95 [www.zakon.kz].



. , . ,
-. ,
- . : .
? ,
, , , . .

. 3.
?
-, ,
. -
, , ,
, 9 ( 1959- 1968 .). . - .
,
. ,
, ,
4.
-, . , , , 1020%. . 6,2%, ()
10,6%.
, , . , I
2011 3,7% ( 2010 . 2,9%). 3
. // Silk Way.
. - , 2011, 2. . 13.
4
.: . . 16.

179

14 2 2011

3 2011 , 6,0% (
2010 . 3,7%).
0,9% ( 2010
1,1%), 3,6% ( I 2010 3,7%) (. . 1)5 .
, , .
,
.
6.
1

I 2010 2011 ( %)
6
6
5
3,7

3,7

3,7

3,6

2,9
3
2

1,1

0,9

1
0

: .

, , ,
20%. , .
,
, .
, ( , ) . , , , ,
, - . 7.
5
.: - 8 6 2011 . [www.nationalbank.kz].
6
.: . , // , 4 2011.
7
.: .

180

14 2 2011

- .
, ,
8. 2011 , . , 1 2011 ,
. , ,
, :
( )
.
. (, ).
. , ,
,
, , . . , , . ,
. 1 20 9.
-
, 58 ,
. , 15 , .


.
. , ,
. ,
.
: , .
, . ,
.
205 ;
- ,
8
. // Silk Way. . - , 2011, 2. . 17.
9
. . 18.

181

14 2 2011

.
- .

. . .
, , 20112015
.
.
,
. .
, . , -
,
-, . , .
, 10.

.
, , .
, , 11. . ,
. ,
, 400 1
( 60% 1
2011 .). :
1 200 .
, .
, 10
() (1 = 1 273 , 10 = 12 730 ). 1 000 () (1 = 4 330 .,
1 000 = 4 330 000 . = 902 083 ), 15 000 . , 1
. 2 .: . . . . 14.
.: // , 5 2010.
10
11

182

14 2 2011

. 10%
.
, 1 2010 ,
. 1 2011 ,
, .
.

-. ,
(). ,
, .



. , ,
. 2,5 , .
- . -
: 1 2010
. ,
. , . .
-, ,
, , , . , ,
.
C, . , , 1 2010 ()
18% . 20 2010 , , . 183

14 2 2011

, 12. ,
. , , , , 13.

, . C , ,
-,
, .
, (, ), C .
C
. ,
, , . , , , C. () . , 4,4% (. . 1).
1


( %)

6,2

10,6

10,6

4,6

9,4

8,5

12,1

15,1

16,7

:
.

.
, , .
. . 12
.: . : // Silk Way. . - , 2011, 2. . 20.
13
. . 21.

184

14 2 2011

, 7 , (, , ) ( :
70).
. .
.
. , 90% , 14.
,
.
. , 10 2011 , 331 1 015 . ,
,
.

. . ,
, .
: ,
.
, , , .

:
:
1 000 ? , - , . (IFC)
Doing Business 2010, 63 , . .
. ,
,
20%. ,
. , , 25%. :
14
.: . // Silk Way.
. - , 2011, 2. . 15.

185

14 2 2011

5080% . .
, . , . ,
.
. .
,
.
.
- 20102014 , 2010
2014 . ,
. , .
, , ().
- .
9 2010 . , , , (, , ), . ( : , , , ).
,
. (, ),
.
, , -. , , , .
. , .
.
,
.
9 2010
. ,
,
,
. , 2
, ,
, , ,
. 5 , 186

14 2 2011

. 6 , 1 , , , .
15 2010
67 .

- () .


. . , .
9 2010
, . . ,
. -
, . , ,
.
, . - .
: 20062010
, 250%.

1 2011 13,2 160%15.
-
390 . -1, , , 1 680 ,
673 16.

, . ,
15
.: .
[www.kazinform.kz].
16
.: .

187

14 2 2011

, , ,
, .
.
, -
, - , .
, .
,
, . - , .


,
()
()
(, )


,
.

, , -

, 1.
,
,
.
1
..
. ., 2005. . 3.

188

14 2 2011


,
,
2. , .
, . , , ,
.
, .
1930- , .
. ,
. .

. , , , , , ,
.
36 , .
36 . 46 ., 50,2%
1940 67,5% 1945 3.
( . )4.
. , , , , ..
20 ,
. 1950 1940 4,2 .

( , , , . , , ..);
( , , , - );
( , -
).
2
.: .. ( ). . . . . . -, 2003.
3
.: .. 19411945 . ,
1985; Allworth E. Central Asia. A Century of Russian Rule. New York: Columbia University Press, 1990. P. 57.
4
.: . . 2. , 1968. . 101.

189

14 2 2011

, 200 , , , , . , , ,
, , . . , .
: -, , .. .
1979 39%5.
.
. -
.
. .
,
.
6.
500
7.
. . -.
2/3 , , , , , . - 1/3 ,
, , ( ) .
- , ,
, -
, 1990 .
, - .
: , ,
,
. . - . , , ., ( ,
5
.: .. . : . . : ii,
2001. . 579.
6
.: . (19461955). , 1975.
. 7780.
7
.: : XX . . , 1998.

190

14 2 2011

..). () .
, . - .
. -, , : ,
, . , , , , ,
, . ,
, , 8.

,
, . , . : ,
,

,
.
,
, , ; . .
, 87% , 74% -, 76% , 88% . , , , . (
19781984 .).

,
: . ,
5 , .
, , - .
58%.
1977 15,5%9.
1970 43,8%,
14% .
. 8
9

. : . // , 25 2009.
.: . , 1999.

191

14 2 2011

, , ,
. - .
. , , , . ,
- 10.

. -
.
1980-
. ,
, .
.
1990- ,

11, . ,
12.
(), , () - . ,
, .



1992 27% 1989 , , . - .
, , 20 1991 13. ,
14.
67 1,1 , ! , - : ,
.. 1,3 ,
2 ! , .: . [http://www.postsoviet.ru/print.php?pid#179].
.: .. . , 1999.
12
.: .., .. ( ).
, 2002. . 474.
13
.: . : . , 1996. . 8387.
14
.: , // , 2010, 38.
10
11

192

14 2 2011

,
, 15.
( , , 24 .) . , 14 .
0,3 .
.
, . , .
, , 1990 48 . , 2000
74 , 1 263 26 . 1980
55,6% ,
2008 14%.
16. ,
,
.
,
, .
17. ,
.
. : ,
, , . .
, , 18.
,
, 40% .

. - 19.
19,6 , 10,6 , 55,8%,
. ( ) 12,3% ,
0,1%, 0,4%,
1,7%; 85,6%20.
1990- , .
.: ? // , 5 2004.
.: .
17
.: . //
, 2005, 2.
18
// , 23 2008.
19
.: [http://www.centralasia-biz.com/cabiz/
kirgizstan/agrarny/abt_agrarny_kg.htm].
20
.: [http://www.kazakh-zerno.kz/index.php?option=com_
content&view=article&id=27647:2010-12-04-04-12].
15
16

193

14 2 2011


. , ,
, ,
. 300 . , .
- .
, , .
2007 , . : , ?, : . , ,

. , , , , , , .
.
. . ? .
21. - 22.

,

, 2005 , .
.
, 2005
23. . ,
, . . ,
. , , , .
3
( , 200 ). .
. . ,
, 4060%.
, , ,
, .
21
. [http://www.centrasia.
ru/newsA.php?st=1186519620], 8 2007.
22
.: / . .. , .. . : . ,
2006. . 432.
23
.: // , 2009.

194

14 2 2011

,
. ,
100 . . ,
, 24.
, , .
,
. 5% , 10%.
.
, .
, , . ,
. , , . 25. . ,
- ,
. , : , . 26. , , : , 27
, ,
.
n

-, ,
.

-, .
,
.

-, .

-, , , .

- ,
, .
,
,
. . . :
. // D-, 28 2009.
.: . , //
-, 15 2009, 16. . 4.
26
.
27
.
24
25

195

14 2 2011

. ,
. : . , 1990- 2005 .
.
. , , 1998
, .
,
, 28.
2009 .
. ,
, . , .
- . :
, ,
. (2009 .)
,
. , . , , . 29. , ,
50% - .
, , :
n

- ,
, , ;

,
;


, , , - ..;

, ;

. .
- , , , 28
, 30 2010 [http://diesel.elcat.kg/lofiversion/
index.php?t3884618.html].
29
.: . ,
// , 29 2009.

196

14 2 2011

-
19982000 , 30.

, , , , . , .
. . 8% , . , , , 10 . ,
. 2009
12 .
. . . ( )
. , ,
45%, 2 . .
80%. 15 2009 , .
31. . , - , ,
30% , , , 40 . 32. . 2010 :
, , 33.
, : . , . ( 500 )
,
34. ,
4% 2020
220
500 .
. 78 . 4
.: [http://municipalg.narod.ru/cc.htm].
.: // , 17 2009, 16 (089).
32
[http://www.rursor.ru/article.aspx?id=8281].
33
? // , 29 2010.
34
.: . // , 2010, 5.
30
31

197

14 2 2011

( , ). 1,3 .
400 . .
( 1 ) .



- .
, ,
. , , .
7,5 , 75% . 500600,
1 000 1 . .
, . ( ) .
.
. :
, XX XXI , , 35.
,
, , .
. 36. , . , , ,
, 37.
. .
, , 700 .
18% . , , ,
.
( ) ,
. . 18 2005 :
,
. ,
35
36
37

. // , 1992, 7. . 142.
.: // , 17 1994.
. // , 2010, 11.

198

14 2 2011

, - . , , ,
, , - , 38.
( ). ,
, (). . , ,
. , ,
39.
,
, 1999- 2009 40.
, , . 20% . . ,
, (
. ..) , 41. . , . , .
, . ,
,
. , ,
- ,
42.
22,4%, 46,3%,
67,2% ( 2007 .).
80%. , , . ,
. 2008
5 .
, 857 , - 1 434 ,
725 , - 629 , 2 700 .
, 43. 2006 : 1 023,8 (11%) - 1 932,9
(20%) . ,
809,1 (9%) , - . ,
24 .
38
. // Kyrgyz Weekly, 19 2005.
39
. // , 2127 2010, 16. . 7.
40
.: // D-, 22 2009.
41
. . .: , 2000. . 156.
42
. ? // - , 9 2010.
43
.: . 2008. .: . , 2008.

199

14 2 2011

- 27 ., 51 . 1 417,3
, 37 .44
- - . , - , , 99% : , .
. , 2010
, .
- , ,
17,4% . , , . 34 .
.
.
, , - , . 51%
.
.
2007 , 0,650 , .
(0,828)45. . ,
. ,
(90%
). 2007 1,5 .46
,
500 . . 1,5 ., . (20042009) 100 . .
,
, .
2008 ,
. . ,
, 2009
4,5 . , . ,
, .
,
. , , , , 47.
,
. , :
44
.: .. //
. 6. , 2010, 3. . 66.
45
.: , 2010.
46
.: .. //
, 20 2009.
47
, // , 4 2009.

200

14 2 2011

[ ] . , , 48. ,
, .
-
2009 630 .
. , , .
2010 .
, ,
, , 49.
. : . . , , ,
.
. .
. , , , 50.
. . . , , 2005 , . ,
, ,
, . - . , ,
, , 51.
2010 , -.
, , , ,
, .
, 11 2010 , - .
52. ,
, , , . ,
.
[http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=1239680820].
.: // , 9 2010. . 3.
50
// , 14 2010.
51
. 24 2005 . , 2007. . 161.
52
.: . ? // , 21 2010, 24.
48
49

201

14 2 2011

.
, , , , ,
.
,
53. . -
. : , () -
, , , ,
, ,
, 54.
:
. , - . : 55. - . 24 2011 : .
, . , , ,
, , ,
, , .
, .
. , , . , , 56.

, , , , .
, .

,
. , , , ,
, .

. : , - . , , : , - , . , . , ,
, ,
53

324.py].
54
55
56

.: [http://www.zpress.kg/news/news_only/7/21543/
, 26 2010.
[http://kara-balta.ru/forum/archive/index.php/t-1004.html].
[http://www.kginfo.org/index.php?newsid=1909].

202

14 2 2011

, .

:
2010

,

, -

(, )

2010 -
- ,
10 , . 1. ,
. , 2001

. , 2010 120 .
48 ,
100 . 33 . , - 1
- 2010 ;
2000 2010 ;
2010
;
2010 ..

.

,
,
.
2008

, -
, .
. ,
, , .
,
,
, -

203

14 2 2011


- , . , , , .


,
. , ,
, .
-, - ,

; -,
.

, :
, .
( . , . )
, . ,


.
,
.

( )

,
.

2010 , ,
(), , , 9,2%. , . , , .
. 0,1%. .
. ,
. , , 40%, 10%, , , 60% , 2.
2

.: [http://www.regnum.ru/news/polit/1348500.html#ixzz15yiuI145].

204

14 2 2011


2010 8,1%. ,
,
.
16% .
, ,
.
. , . - .
, . . .

2010

, %


, %

109,2


( 2010 . 2009 .), %

104,77

28 465,3

114,1

, .

17 882,8

97,6

9 679,2

103,8

8 203,6

91,2

, .

1 475,6

,

2010

707,5


112,1

125,1

92,2

: .

2010
(),
(20092010 .), 7 052 .
, ( 87 , 89, ,
205

14 2 2011

:
61, 65 69 , 64 )3.
- . , , , , , . ,
, 10 .
( 120 ) , ( ), , . , , ,
(, , ) .
,
1991 . 2010
1,4 ( 1,6 ) 1,3 ; , . ,
.
,
: , , .
.
, 2 ,
- .
,
. , 1 .,
300 ( ) . 2020 2 .
, - 2010 1,3863 . ( 3 049 . ).
1 598 (. 205 .),
120 532 (50180 .). , .



. 2008
.
, 2010
10 . 30 . , , , . , 2010
4045 . 10 4. , .
3
4

.: [www.undp.org/publications/hdr2010/en/HDR_2010_EN_Complete.pdf].
.: [www.oilnews.com.ua/news/article6630.html].

206

14 2 2011

, . , 4 (8,1 . )5. , , 24,6 . . .


.
2009 :

. . 2010
5 . ; . ,
. ,
, ,
6080 . .
, : , , . ;
. . ,

,
40 . .
,
.
-2010 ()
. ,
.
, , , .
, , . ,
. , 1

.
. ,
-. ,
,
, , , , , , .
5

.: Statistical Review, 2010.

207

14 2 2011

17 19 15- 2010, , , , ,
,
, 160 ,
Petronas, Dragon Oil, Wintershall, Bentec, ,
, , , , Komatsu LTD, Technip .


: , , 700 , , , .
,
. . , ,
, . ,
.
- . , - , ,
40 . ( ,
)6. , ,
. . , ,
.
, , .
, , : ,
, .
, ,
, , ,
7.
, , , ,
. , 6
7

.: [http://www.regnum.ru/news/polit/1355719.html].
.: [http://www.k2kapital.com/news/421280/].

208

14 2 2011

, ,
.
, 2010
30 . . (,
5 )

, .
- , 2010 ,
, 8.
, - : 2011
,
, 9.
2010
,
(). , , , , .

,
.
10%-
.
,
. ,
.
, 2005
, 7,6 .
1 730 ( ) . 33 .
, 14 , 5
. 2011 ,
2015 .
13 , , , (). 8
.: [http://belarus.regnum.ru/news/1356421.html]; : 2010
[http://kavkaz.ge/2010/12/21/regnum-rossiya-na-postsovetskom-prostranstve-itogi-2010-goda/], 21 2010.
9
.: [http://www.regnum.ru/news/polit/1355719.html].

209

14 2 2011

, ,
. , 2011
. , ,
.
, : . ,
, :
, ,
. , , ,
.
.

,
.
, .
, . , 10.
,
,
. . ,
.
,
.
. - ,
, ,
, .
, ,
, , 11.
. 28 -
,
. , 2010 .
, .
( -) 1996 .
20 . . 2010
, 2010 32 . 40 . 12.
10
11
12

.: [http://www.rosbalt.ru/2010/12/13/800006.html].
.: [http://www.turkmenistan.ru/ru/articles/35358.html].
.: [http://www.capital.trendaz.com], 27 2010.

210

14 2 2011


2010 , , - . 9
, , , 10 . ,
34 , . , 200250 . .
- , , - .
, .
. , -
- , - - . 2010 - .
- , .
2010 120
1 .,
, , , , .
138 . 2 - ,
-
13. . .
. 2010 275 317 , .
, , , .
,
-,
, . , ,
( ),
,
.
.
21 , .
. , ,
13

.: [http://./docs/12817/].

211

14 2 2011

(51% ) .
-BCTI (Barash Communications),
.
, , 3040%.
,

.
, .
.
sms- , sms- . :
.


, .
. ,
. .
, , , .
,
- , 171 179 14.
2010 , XXI ,
. - , .
, .
14

.: [http://gtmarket.ru/news/state/2010/01/21/2487].

212