Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

One of the major applications of Equity Valuation is the Private companies valuation. Private companies valuation can be applied: To value a Start up operations of Public companies. To estimate a value of specific transactions i.e. acquisitions. To estimate fair value of Goodwill for the purpose of impairment testing.

Overlap of Shareholders and Management Private companies have higher managerial ownership. This benefits the companies by eliminating agency costs*. Also, management is able to focus on long-term prospects of the company instead of being pressurized from external investors to enhance short-term profitability.
*Agency costs: Issues arise from the conflicting interests of owners (principals) & managers (agents).

2. THE SCOPE OF PRIVATE COMPANY VALUATION Private company can be a small firm with a single employee or unincorporated businesses, or public companies that have been taken private in management buyouts etc.

Quality/Depth of Management Small private companies are less attractive to management due to their limited growth potential. Due to small scale of operations, there is less management depth in these companies. These factors further lead to higher risk and lower growth. Quality of Financial and Other Information There is limited availability of financial and other information for private companies. The unavailability of financial information lead to uncertainty in valuation of such companies which further increases risk. However, in cases where fairness opinions are required by firms i.e. in acquisitions, analysts are provided with unlimited access to financial information. Pressure from short-term investors Private companies do not face pressures regarding maintaining stock price performance in the short term. Private companies can take longer term investment focus. Tax Concerns Private companies are more sensitive to reduction in reported taxable income and corporate tax payments than public companies.

2.1 Private and Public Company Valuation (Similarities and Contrasts) 2.1.1) Company-Specific Factors These are the factors related to the characteristics of the firm itself. These factors have both positive and negative impact on private company valuation. These include: life cycle stage of the firm size of the fir markets in which the firm operates goals of the firm characteristics of management of the firm

Stage in Life Cycle Private companies are typically less mature than public companies. Private companies have less capital Private companies have fewer assets and employees. Private companies may also include large, stable, going concern and stable companies. Size Private companies are usually smaller in size. Private companies have higher risk due to their smaller size. The higher risk inherent in private companies increases the risk premium and the required rate of return. Smaller size also reduces growth opportunities as these companies have limited access to capital to fund investments. However, smaller companies have advantage of low compliance costs.

2.1.2) Stock-Specific Factors: These are the factors related to stock of a private company. These factors are usually negative for private company valuation. These include: Liquidity of private companys stock. Concentration of control in private companies. Marketability of private companys stock.

402

Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

Liquidity of Equity interests in business Private companys stock has low liquidity compared to public companys stock. Private companies have small number shareholders. as of

its employees. These transactions require valuations due to accounting and tax implications to the issuer and employee. Compliance-Related: It is related to law or regulation requirements i.e. o Financial Reporting: Valuations which are required in Financial Reporting include goodwill. Goodwill impairment test is performed by doing business valuation for a cash-generated unit (IFRS) of a firm or reporting unit (U.S. GAAP). Stock options grant value is also based on private company valuations. o Tax Reporting: Tax-related reasons for valuations include corporate and individual tax reporting e.g. property tax, corporate restructuring, estate and gift taxation etc.

Concentration of Control In private companies, only one or few investors have control. This concentration of control benefits the controlling shareholders at the cost of other shareholders.

Potential agreements restricting liquidity Private companies may have shareholder agreements which restrict the ability to sell shares. These restrictions on sale reduce the marketability of private companys stock. Note: There is more heterogeneity in private firm risks, discount rates and valuation methods. This creates higher uncertainty and difficulty in private company valuations.

Each of the above mentioned categories requires a specialized knowledge and skills to do valuations accurately. Transaction related valuations are performed by investment bankers. Compliance related valuations are performed by professionals with accounting or tax regulation knowledge. Litigation related valuations are performed by professionals with legal setting experience.

2.2 Reasons for Performing Valuations Reasons for performing private company valuation can be categorized into three types Transaction-Related: It includes events related to ownership, sale or financing of a business i.e. o Private Financing: Development stage companies require capital and this capital is provided by venture capital investors. Due to high risk, these investors invest through multiple rounds based on achievement of key developments called milestones. Due to high uncertainty related to expected future cash flows, valuations are often informal and based on negotiations between the company and investors. o Initial Public Offering (IPO): An IPO increases the liquidity of a private company. In such events, valuation is based on any identical public company data. o Acquisition: Acquisition can be an attractive liquidity option for development stage or mature companies. In such events, valuation is performed by management of the target and/or buyer. o Bankruptcy: In such events, valuation is performed to evaluate whether a company is more valuable as a going concern or in liquidation. o Share-based payment (compensation): These are the transactions between a company and its employees. These transactions require

3. DEFINITIONS (STANDARDS) OF VALUE It is important to understand the context of the valuation and its requirements before estimating a value. Following are the major definitions of value: Fair market value: This term can be defined as the price at which asset would change hands: o Between a Hypothetical willing and able buyer & seller. o At arms length in an open and unrestricted market. o When neither buyer nor seller has any compulsion to buy or sell. o When both buyer and seller have reasonable knowledge. Note: Fair market value is often used for tax reporting purposes. Market Value: It is defined as estimated amount for which asset should exchange on the date of valuation. It is characterized by: o A willing buyer and seller o An arms length transaction after proper marketing. o Prudent buyer and seller. o Neither buyer nor seller has any compulsion to buy or sell. o Both buyer and seller have reasonable knowledge. Note: Market value is often used for real estate and tangible asset valuations.

403

Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

Fair value (financial reporting): It is characterized by: o An arms length transaction. o Neither buyer nor seller has any compulsion to buy or sell. o Both buyer and seller have reasonable knowledge. Fair Value in IFRS: The price that would be received for an asset or paid to transfer a liability in a current transaction between marketplace participants in the reference market for the asset or liability. Fair Value in U.S.GAAP: The price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date. Between a Hypothetical willing and able buyer & seller.

In this method, asset is valued as the PV of the discounted cash flows expected to receive from that asset. It is the same as DCF or PV models used in public companies valuation. It is a type of Absolute valuation model. This approach is most appropriate for companies growing rapidly.

2) The Market Approach In this method, value of an asset is based on price multiples from sales of assets similar to the subject asset. It is a type of Relative valuation model. This approach is most appropriate for stable and mature companies. This approach is not appropriate to apply to a small, relatively mature private firm with low growth rate. In order to use price multiples of large firms, risks and growth prospects should not be differ materially

Fair value (litigation): The definition of fair value in a litigation context is generally similar to the fair value of financial reporting. It is set forth in United States by state statutes and legal precedents in certain litigation matters. Investment value: It is a value which is specific to a particular investor i.e. based on the investors perspectives on future earnings, level of risk, potential synergies, return requirements and financing costs etc. Intrinsic value: It is a value which is based on available facts & information and it is considered to be the true or real value. This value is assumed to be same for the whole market.

3) The Asset-based Approach In this method, value of an asset is based on the values of the underlying assets of the entire firm less the value of any related liabilities. It is a type of Absolute valuation model. This approach is most appropriate for companies at their earliest stages of development because Going-concern view is uncertain. Future expected CFs are difficult to forecast.

Valuation Approaches are selected based on specific factors i.e. In this method, value of an asset is based on the values of the underlying assets of the entire firm less the value of any related liabilities. The nature of operations Stage in Lifecycle Size of the company

NOTE: Difference between Investment & Intrinsic Value: Investment value = Intrinsic value + (-) synergies According to U.S. GAAP, fair value is the exit price. Exit price is the price received to sell an asset or transfer a liability. It should be the price paid to buy that asset. IFRS does not specify an entry or exit price perspective in fair value determination. Private company valuation which is performed for a specific purpose for a particular valuation date and by using specific definition of value, can not be applied for another purpose e.g. in order to value a controlling interest, analyst should not use value used for tax reporting purposes which is from the perspective of minority shareholder.

Non-Operating Assets and Firm Value Value of Firm = Value of Operating Assets + Value of Nonoperating Assets where, Value of Operating Assets = value estimated by discounting FCFF Non-operating assets are Excess cash* Excess marketable securities Land held for investment

4. PRIVATE COMPANY VALUATION APPROACHES There are three major approaches to private company valuation: 1) The Income Approach

404

Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

4.1 Earnings Normalization and Cash-flow Estimation Issues 4.1.1) Earnings Normalization issues for Private Companies Private company valuations require significant adjustments to estimate the normalized earnings of the company. In this reading, Normalized Earnings are defined as Economic benefits adjusted for non-recurring, noneconomic, or other unusual items to eliminate anomalies and/or facilitate comparisons. In private company, earnings may reflect discretionary expenses or expenses that are not at arms length amounts due to the concentration of control. Tax and other motivations also result in over or understatement of earnings which do not represent normalized earnings i.e. above-market compensation to controlling shareholders in case of higher profits help in reducing income tax expense by reducing the taxable income. Similarly, in case of losses or low profits, expenses can be understated in order to overstate the current income. Personal-use of firms assets and excess entertainment expenses also require an adjustment by an analyst. Private Companies financial statements are not audited. Rather they are just reviewed. Reviewed Financial Statements provide an opinion letter. Compiled Financial Statements do not provide an opinion letter. Practice: Question 1 Volume 4, Reading 43, P. 681

4.1.2) Cash Flow Estimation Issues for Private Companies Assessing future cash flow estimates in private companies involve greater uncertainty. One possible solution is to project the different possible future scenarios i.e. For a privately held development stage company, the possible scenarios are: o Initial public offering o Acquisition o Continued as a private company o Bankruptcy For a larger, mature company, the possible scenarios can be based on a range of levels of growth rate and profitability. In valuing an individual scenario, discount rate is chosen for each specific scenario. The probability of occurrence of each scenario is also estimated. The overall value is then a probability-weighted-average of the companys estimated individual scenario values. The other method is based on discounting future CFs under each scenario by a single discount rate. The overall value is then estimated by the weighted average of individual scenario values. While doing valuation, appraisal should take into account the managements biases to overstate values i.e. in case of goodwill impairment and understate values i.e. in case of stock option grants. The process of estimating FCFF and FCFE is the same for both private and public companies. When a company has volatile capital structure, FCFF is preferred to FCFE.

Practice: Example 1 Volume 4, Reading 43, P. 645

In case of real estate owned by the firm the following adjustments are required: If real property is used in businesss operations o Market rental charge should be added to expenses. o Any income and depreciation expenses are removed from the income statement. Real estate value represents a non-operating asset of the entity. It has different level of risks and expected future growth rate; therefore, it should be valued separately. When real estate is leased to the private firm by a related party, the lease rate should be adjusted to a market rate.

Practice: Question 1 Volume 4, Reading 43, P. 649

Other adjustments are related to: Inventory accounting methods Depreciation assumptions Capitalization v/s expensing

The normalized Earnings for a strategic buyer incorporate acquisition synergies, whereas a financial (nonstrategic) transaction does not.

405

Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

4.2 Income Approach Valuation Methods of Private Company

There are three forms of income approach. Free Cash Flow Method (Discounted cash flow method): In this method, value of an asset is based on estimates of future expected CFs discounted to PV by using an appropriate discount rate. This approach is most appropriate for large & mature private companies. Capitalized Cash Flow Method (capitalized income method or capitalization of earnings method): In this method, value of an asset is based on an assumption of a constant growth rate of FCFF or FCFE. It is basically a single-stage model. This approach is most appropriate for smaller companies. Residual Income Method (Excess Earnings Method): It is a method in which asset is valued by estimating the value of all intangible assets of the business by capitalizing future earnings in excess of the estimated return requirements associated with working capital and fixed assets. The value of the intangible assets is then added to the values of working capital and fixed assets to arrive at the value of the business enterprise. It is sometimes categorized under asset based approach. This approach is most appropriate for smaller companies.

a private company is higher because: Private company has less access to debt financing. Due to less access to debt financing, it has to use more equity financing which is expensive than debt financing. Smaller size of private company increases the operating risk and cost of debt as well. Discount rate in acquisition context: In doing valuation in acquisition transactions, targets cost of capital and targets capital structure (not of buyer) should be used in calculating WACC. Discount rate adjustment for projection risk: Limited amount of financial information regarding private companys operations creates uncertainty in forecasting its cash flows. This uncertainty leads to a higher required rate of return. The other issue is the managerial inexperience in forecasting future financial performance. Life Cycle Stage: Discount rate is difficult to estimate for firms in their early stage of development. These firms usually have high unsystematic risks; therefore, CAPM should not be used for such companies. Also, various discount rates are used for various life-cycle stages and it is difficult to identify the accurate stage of a company.

Practice: Example 3 Volume 4, Reading 43, P. 652

4.2.2) Free Cash Flow Method For both private and public companies, free cash flow valuation is similar. For example, individual free cash flows are forecasted for a limited time horizon and their PV is found by discounting them by appropriate discount rate. At the end of initial projection period, terminal value is calculated. There are two ways of estimating terminal value i.e. by using constant-growth model or by using price multiple. However, care should be taken in using price multiple in a high growth industry because it incorporates high growth rate twice in the calculation of terminal value i.e. once in the CFs projection over the projection period and then in the market multiple used in calculating the residual enterprise value.

4.2.1) Required Rate of Return: Models and Estimation Issues Challenges in estimating required rate of return for a private company are as follows: Application of Size Premiums: Size premiums are frequently added to the required rate of return of private company due to its smaller size. Size premiums are usually based on small size public companies. But it also includes premium for distress which may not be relevant for every private company. Use of CAPM: CAPM is not appropriate to use for private companies because they have less chances of going public or being acquired by a public company. Therefore, they are not comparable to the public companies for which market-data-based beta estimates are available. Also, high-levels of company specific risk is not incorporated in CAPM which only takes care of systematic risks. Expanded CAPM: It adds to the CAPM a premium for small size and company-specific risk. Elements of the build-up approach: This method is appropriate to when Guideline public companies (comparable public companies) are not available. Beta is assumed to be 1 in this method and industry risk premium is added to Expanded CAPM. Relative debt availability and cost of debt: WACC for a private company is higher because:

4.2.3) Capitalized Cash Flow Method Capitalized Cash Flow Method is basically a single-stage (constant-growth) free cash flow method. It is most appropriate to use: For valuing a private company in which it is difficult to make future projections. For valuing a private company which can be expected to have stable (constant) future operations. When market pricing and transactions related to public companies are limited.
406

Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

At the Firm level, the formula for the capitalized cash flow to the firm is: = Where, Vf FCFF1 WACC gf

= = = =

Value of the firm Free cash flow to the firm for next 12 months Weighted average cost of capital Sustainable growth rate of FCFF

Assumption in using WACC: Constant capital structure at market values in the future exists. Value of Equity = Value of Firm Market Value of Debt = Vf Market Value of Debt To value Equity directly, formula becomes: = Where, r = g = required rate of return on equity sustainable growth rate of FCFE

1. Values of working capital and fixed assets are estimated. Suppose these are $200,000 and $800,000 respectively. 2. Suppose the normalized earnings estimated are $100,000. 3. Discount rate is estimated for working capital & fixed assets i.e. a. Working capital (WC) is the most liquid and has the lowest risk. Thus, it has low discount rate. Suppose 5% b. Fixed assets are assumed to be less liquid. Thus, they have higher discount rate. Suppose 11% c. Intangible assets are assumed to be least liquid and most risky. Thus, they require highest discount rate. Suppose 12% 4. Residual income (RI) or Excess Earnings is estimated as follows: Excess Earnings or Residual Income = Normalized earnings [(required return on WC value of WC) + (required return on fixed assets value of fixed assets)] Excess Earnings or Residual Income = $100,000 [(0.05 $200,000) + (0.11 $800,000)] = $2000

Practice Example 4 on page 657, Reading 43, Curriculum, Volume 4.

4.2.4) Excess Earnings Method This method is most appropriate to use to value: Intangible assets Very small businesses

5. Total value of intangible assets is calculated follows: Value of intangible assets =

(!) !

as

The method is based on following steps:

Where, RI = Residual income calculated in step 4 r = required return on intangible assets g = growth rate Suppose, g = 3% Value of intangible assets =
$"###!.!" !.!"!!.!"

= $22,889

6. Total value of a business is estimated as follows: Total value of business = Value of WC + value of fixed assets + value of intangible assets Total Value of business = $300,000 + $100,000 + $22,889 = $1,022,889

407

Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

4.3 Market Approach Valuation Methods of Private Company

For certain industries, non-financial metrics can be used for valuation e.g. price per subscriber in cable, price per bed for hospital etc.

Market approach has three major variations: The Guideline Public Company method (GPCM) The Guideline Transaction method (GTM) The Prior Transaction Method (PTM)

4.3.1) The Guideline Public Company method (GPCM) In this method, value is estimated on the basis of observed multiples from trade data of public companies which are comparable to subject private company. These multiples, however, are adjusted for the risks and growth prospects of the subject private company. The process of valuation is same for both public and private companies i.e. Step a: A group of Comparable public companies is identified. Step b: The relevant price multiples of comparable public companies are estimated. Step c: These multiples are adjusted to reflect the risks and growth prospects of subject private company. Step d: A control premium is estimated and then this premium is added to the value derived in step c for the valuation of controlling interest because trading of interests in public companies generally show small blocks without control of the entity. Control Premium: It is a premium or amount paid for a controlling ownership interest in a business. It is added when the comparable company values are for public shares or minority interests and the target company valuation is being done for a controlling interest. Factors which affect Control Premium include: Type of Transaction: In a Strategic Transaction (in which a buyer benefits from certain synergies by owning target firm e.g. enhanced revenues, cost savings etc), large acquisition premiums are paid because of the expected synergies. In a Financial Transaction (in which a buyer has no synergies with the target firm i.e. when any unrelated business is acquired), acquisition premiums paid are usually smaller than in strategic transaction. Industry Factors: When there is high level of acquisition activities going on in the industry, it leads to rise in share prices of public companies (which reflects control premium). Hence, adding a control premium to such prices may overstate the premium for control. Form of consideration: Stock based transactions are not relevant for estimating control premiums when companys shares are overvalued in the market.

Advantage of Market Approach: Market approach is based on data which is generated from actual market transactions unlike income and asset based approaches where data is based on forecasted values. Assumption of Market Approach: Transactions through which price multiples are derived, are comparable to subject private company. Challenges in using Market Approach: Comparable public companies are difficult to find. Company-specific factors of private companies lead to different risk and growth rates. The stock-specific factors also create uncertainties in determining appropriate comparable public company. Private companies have limited liquidity and marketability.

Guideline Companies are chosen on the basis of following factors: Industry membership Form of operations Trends in business life cycle Size differences

IMPORTANT: Larger Mature Private Companies: Price multiple based on EBITDA and/or EBIT should be used. EBITDA is best compared with Market value of Invested Capital (MIC). MIC = Market value of Debt + Market value of Equity NOTE: - Face value of debt can be used when a firm has small fraction of debt financing and its operations are stable. - Market value of debt should be used when a firm is highly leveraged and its operations are highly volatile. Very small private companies (with limited asset base): Price multiple based on net income should be used. Extremely small companies: Price multiple based on revenue should be used.

Practice: Example 5 Volume 4, Reading 43, P. 663

408

Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

4.3.2) The Guideline Transaction method (GTM) In this method, value is estimated based on pricing multiples which are derived from the acquisition of control of entire private company or private company previously acquired. NOTE: Since value is estimated based on the transactions related to entire firm, there is no need to add control premium separately to the value in this method. Following factors should be considered in assessing transaction-based pricing multiples: Synergies: Strategic transactions may already include payments for expected synergies. If the subject transaction is non-strategic while a prior transaction is strategic transaction, the analyst is required to adjust the historical multiple. Contingent Consideration: It represents future payments to the seller which are contingent on the achievement of certain things i.e. obtaining regulatory approval, achieving target level of EBITDA. These contingencies create uncertainty in the valuation of a company. Noncash Consideration: When transaction is based on stock instead of cash payments, transaction price is uncertain. Comparing cash based transaction with the transaction based on shares leads to inappropriate valuation. Availability of Transactions: Comparable and relevant transactions for a specific private company are limited. Also, most of the time the relevant transactions are far in the past and can not be used to value a company currently. Changes between transaction date and valuation date: GTM is based on transactions at different points in the past. Value based on these transactions need to be adjusted for the changes in risk and growth expectations in the marketplace i.e. (due to the changes in macroeconomic and industrial conditions). Practice: Question 13 Volume 4, Reading 43, P. 687

4.4 Asset-Based Approach to Private Company Valuation This approach is also known as Cost Approach. This method is not commonly used in the valuation of private companies. Of the three approaches, the asset-based approach generally results in the lowest valuation. In this approach value is estimated as follows: Value = Fair value of Assets Fair Value of Liabilities

This approach is most appropriate to use for valuing: A liquidating company because value as a going concern will be less than its value in liquidation Natural Resource Firms Financial and Investment companies i.e. banks largely consist of loan and securities portfolios that can be priced based on market data Holding Investment Companies i.e. Real estate investment trusts (REITs) and closed end investment companies (CEICs). Very small businesses with limited intangible assets Recently formed companies or companies in their early stages, which have limited operating histories.

This approach is least appropriate to use for valuing an on going Business due to the following reasons: For on-going businesses, it is difficult to value intangible assets Certain tangible assets i.e. special plant & machinery are difficult to value. There is limited information available to value ongoing businesses on asset-by-asset basis.

Practice: Example 6 Volume 4, Reading 43, P. 666

Practice: Example 7 Volume 4, Reading 43, P. 669

4.3.3) The Prior Transaction Method (PTM) In this method, value is estimated on the basis of actual transactions in the stock of the subject private company or on the basis of multiples implied from the transaction. PTM is most relevant to use to value minority equity interest in a company. However, when relevant transactions are limited and when these transactions are at different points in time, PTM based valuation is less reliable. 4.5 Valuation Discounts and Premiums Some of the Factors which affect the lack of control & marketability discounts: Importance of size of shareholding. Distribution of shares. Relationships of parties. State law affecting minority shareholder rights.

409

Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

4.5.1) Lack of Control Discounts (DLOC) Lack of control discount is the amount or percentage deducted from the value of an equity interest in a company to reflect the absence of control. DLOC is applied when the comparable values are for the sale of an entire company (public/private) i.e. controlling interest basis and the valuation is being done for a minority interest in the target company. Lack of control negatively affects investor as he/she is unable to control the operations of an entity i.e. selecting directors. Discount is lower when: A private company is seeking an IPO. A private company is a strategic sale.

Factors affecting Marketability Factors which decrease DLOM include: High Prospects for liquidity. Payments of dividends. Large Pool of potential buyers. Duration of asset i.e. earlier higher payments (shorter duration).

Factors which increase DLOM include: Agreements regarding restriction on sale of shares. Restrictions on transferability. Higher Risk or volatility. Greater Uncertainty of value. Concentration of ownership.

Discount is higher when: A private company has not paid dividends. A private company has no probability of going public.

Methods used to quantify lack of marketability discounts Restricted Stock Transactions: In this method, lack of marketability discount is estimated as the difference between the price of a restricted stock and a price of freely traded stock. Initial Public Offerings (IPO): In this method, lack of marketability discount is estimated based on private sales of stock in companies prior to a subsequent IPO i.e. the difference between the price of a preIPO stock and a price of a post-IPO stock. Drawback: This method has a drawback because post-IPO price may reflects the increase in value due to decline in risks & decline in uncertainty of cash flows as the company progresses rather than only reflecting the impact of an IPO. Put options: In this method, DLOM is estimated as follows: DLOM =
!!

Calculation of Lack of Control Discount (DLOC): DLOC =

+

Example: If Control premium = 20%, then DLOC = 1 [ 1/ (1 + 0.20) ] = 16.7% Scenar io 1 2 Comparable Data Controlling Interest Controlling Interest Noncontrolling interest Noncontrolling interest Subject Valuation Controllin g Interest Noncontrollin g interest Controllin g Interest Noncontrollin g interest DLOC Expected ? None DLOC Control Premium None Method CCM/FC F GTM

GPCM

GPCM

4.5.2) Lack of Marketability Discount (DLOM) Lack of marketability discount is the amount or percentage deducted from the value of an ownership interest to reflect the relative absence of marketability.

Assumptions: - The time to maturity of Put option and the time to the IPO is the same. - Volatility used can be estimated using the historical volatility of publicly traded stock or implied volatility of publicly traded options. Advantage of the Method: Risk of the private company can be directly incorporated through the volatility estimate of the put option. Disadvantage of the Method: Put option only provides price protection. It does not increase liquidity of the asset. Other types of Discount include: Key person discounts. Portfolio discounts i.e. for non-homogenous assets. Non-voting shares discounts.

410

Reading 43

Private Company Valuation

FinQuiz.com

IMPORTANT: When both lack of discount and lack of marketability discounts are present, then total discount is not the summation of DLOC & DLOM, rather it is estimated as follows: Total Discount = [ 1 ( 1 DLOC in % ) (1 DLOM in % ) ] Example: Assume DLOC = 10% DLOM = 20% Total discount = [ 1 ( 1 10% ) ( 1 20%) ] = 28% Practice: All Questions at the end of Reading 43

Practice: Example 8 Volume 4, Reading 43, P. 674

NOTE: When a business has high probability of liquidation then it is recommended to add the value of nonoperating assets to the total value of a firm. When a business is expected to continue its operations as a private company, then it is better to exclude the value of non-operating assets from total valuation.

4.6 Business Valuation Standards and Practices Business valuation standards are developed to protect investors and users of valuations. These standards typically cover the development and reporting of the valuation. Various valuation standards exist for the valuation of private companies. The challenges include: involved with Valuation Standards

There are many different valuation standards. Compliance is not mandatory. There is no way to ensure compliance to the standards. Standards provide very limited technical guidance on how to use them. Valuation is dependent on the definition of value used. This can result in different conclusions of value.

411