CRIM PRO list of digested cases available in LA transcription

CASE TITLE:
ABAY, SR. VS. GARCIA ABUBAKAR VS. ABUBAKAR AGUIRRE VS. JUDGE BELMONTE ALEGRE VS. REYES ALFREDO CHING VS. CA ALISANGCO VS. TABILIRAN, JR. ALVIZO VS. SB AMARGA VS. FISCAL AMATAN VS. JUDGE AUJERO APOLINARIO GONZALES VS. CA AURILLO VS. FRANCISCO AZARCON VS. SANDIGANBAYAN BALAYON, JR. VS. OCAMPO BANAL VS. TADEO, JR. BAARES VS. BALISING BASCO VS. RAPATALO BAYAS VS. SB BELTRAN VS. SAMSON AND JOSE BERNARDO VS. CA BERNARDO VS. CA BERNARDO VS. PEOPLE BINAY VS. SB BOBIS VS. BOBIS BOGO-MEDELIN CO. VS. JUDGE PEDRO SON BONDOC VS. SANDIGANBAYAN BORJAL, SOLIVEN VS. CA BRAVO, JR. VS. BORJA BROCKA VS. ENRILE BUHAT VS. COURT OF APPEALS BURGOS, SR. VS. CHIEF OF STAFF CABALLES VS. CA CABARLES VS. HON. MACEDA CALME VS. CA CANCIO VS. ISIP CAOS VS. PERALTA CARREDO VS. PEOPLE CASUPANAN VS. LAROYA CESAR VS. SB CHUA VS. CA AND WILFRED

CITATION:
162 SCRA 665

DATE OF PROMULGATIO N:
October 22, 1999 October 27, 1994

PAG E:
236 208 135 232 77 171 165 93 173 242 134 13 274 60 214 135 209 162 228 270 248; 276 85; 167; 193 75 223 13 43 136 101 51 283 299 232 59 63 67 156 63 266 248

161 SCRA 226 April 27, 2000 224 SCRA 1 220 SCRA 55 98 Phil 739 A.M. No. RTJ-93956 235 260 218 156 SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA 283 747 13 325

September 27, 1995 May 31, 1994 February 26, 1997 March 31, 2000 March 5, 1997 November 12, 2002 1929 April 3, 2007 October 1, 1999 July 31, 2000 May 27, 1992 November 9, 1990 January 14, 1999

53 Phil 570 278 SCRA 782 190 SCRA 63 520 SCRA 332 G.R. Nos. 120681-83 209 SCRA 329

134 192 265 134

SCRA 466 SCRA 83 SCRA 701 SCRA

December 17, 1996 December 26, 1984 January 15, 2002 February 20, 2007 August 30, 1996 November 12, 2002

115 SCRA 843 183 SCRA 273 August 26, 2002 134 SCRA 105 520 SCRA 729 April 12, 2007

CHIOK CHUA VS. PADILLO CHUA-BURCE VS. CA CINCO VS. SB COJUANGCO VS. SB COJUANGCO, JR. VS. CA CONSTANTINO VS. SB CORPUZ V. TANODBAYAN CRESPO VS. MOGUL CRUZ VS. JUDGE PASCUAL CRUZ VS. MINA CUDIA VS. CA CUENCA VS. CA CUSTODIO VS. SB DADO VS. PEOPLE DANGUILAN-VITUG VS. CA DAVID VS. ARROYO DE JOYA VS. MARQUEZ DMPI VS. VELEZ DOMALANTA VS. COMELEC ENRILE VS. AMIN ESTODILLO VS. BALUMA FORALAN VS. CA FULE VS. CA GABIONZA VS. CA GALLEGO VS. SANDIGANBAYAN GALVEZ VS. CA GARCIA VS. PEOPLE GIMENEZ VS. NAZARENO GO VS. CA GO VS. JUDGE BONGOLAN GO VS. LOOYUKO GOMEZ VS. IAC GONZALES VS. HON. SALVADOR AND GLEN DALE GORREON VS. RTC OF CEBU GOVT OF HONG KONG VS. OLALIA JR. AND MUOZ GOVT VS. PURGANAN GUILLERMA DELOS SANTOSREYES VS. JUDGE CAMILO MONTESA GUILLERMO VS. JUDGE REYES, JR. HO VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILS. HUN HYUNG PARK VS. EUNG WON CHOI KWAN VS. CA LACSON VS. EXECUTIVE SECRETARY LADLAD VS. SENIOR STATE

April 24, 2007 April 27, 2000 202 300 203 533 SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA 726 367 629 205

G.R. No. 159785 250 SCRA 485 453 SCRA 24 232 SCRA 460 G.R. No. 171396 G.R. No. 162416

September 13, 2007 April 15, 1987 June 30, 1987 May 12, 1995 April 27, 2007 January 16, 1998 2005 1994 January 31, 2006 November 29, 2001 June 29, 2000 September 13, 1990 March 23, 2004 February 7, 1995 March 30, 2001 July 30, 1982 October 24, 1994 1999 1988 1992 July 26, 1999 October 26, 2007 April 9, 1985 December 5, 2006

162 SCRA 446

318 SCRA 434 160 SCRA 1 206 SCRA 138 537 SCRA 445

22 209 181 149 70 269 12 49, 89 246 63 187 280 256 238 189 116 96 71 79 202 20 278 208 49 47 51 261 157 112 137 23, 73 254 191 198 150 150 125 134 92 230 235 10 98

213 SCRA 138 G.R. No. 153675 389 SCRA 623 A.M. No. RTJ-93983 280 SCRA 365

April 19, 2007 2002 August 7, 1995 January 18, 1995 October 9, 1997 February 12, 2007 November 23, 2000 1999 June 1, 2007

301 SCRA 298 G.R. No. 175013

PROSECUTOR LARRANAGA VS. CA LIM VS. DUMLAO LIM, SR. VS. FELIX LLENES VS. DICDICAN LOPEZ VS. SB LUBRICA VS. PEOPLE MADRID VS. CA MALACAT VS. CA vis--vis MANALILI VS. CA MALALOAN VS. CA MALALOAN VS. CA MALLARI VS. CA MALLARI VS. PEOPLE MANIGBAS VS. LUNA; NECITO HILARIO VS. JULIAN OCAMPO III MANOTOC VS. CA MANUEL VS. ALFECHE, JR. MAPA VS. SB MARCOS VS. SB MERCADO VS. CA MONDEJAR VS. BUBAN MUSTANG LUMBER, INC. VS. CA NAGUIAT VS. IAC NARCISO VS. STA. ROMANACRUZ NATIVIDAD VS. FELIX NAZARENO VS. STATION COMMANDER NEPLUM VS. ORBESO NIERRAS VS. DACUYCUY NUEZ VS. SB OBUGAN VS. PEOPLE OLAES VS. PEOPLE OMOSA VS. CA PADERANGA VS. CA PANGANDAMAN VS. CASAR PAREDES VS. MANALO PARUNGAO VS. SB PECHO VS. SB PEOPLE OF THE PHIL. VS. CAMILO PILOTIN, et al PEOPLE OF THE PHILS. VS. YPARRAGUIRE PEOPLE VS. ABUNGAN

287 SCRA 581 A.M. No. NTJ-041556 194 SCRA 292 516 SCRA 674 G.R. No. 123595 234 SCRA 249 232 SCRA 249

March 13, 1998 March 31, 2005 1991 July 31, 1996 October 13, 1995 February 26, 2007 May 31, 2000 December 12, 1997; October 9, 1997 December 9, 1996

115; 170 145 91 26 186 269 235 297 104 281 118 193; 202 124 147 263

168 SCRA 422 98 Phil 466; ADM. CASE No. 3066 142 SCRA 149 259 SCRA 475 231 SCRA 783 247 SCRA 361 SCRA 119 257 SCRA 430 164 SCRA 505 1956, December 3, 2001

August 9, 1995 July 5, 1995 July 12, 2001 1996 March 17, 2000 February 4, 1994

163 148 87 150 287 67 135 83 109 71 201 265 267 284 129 124, 125 103 247 240 242 2 27 72

187 SCRA 312 July 11, 2002 181 SCRA 1 111 SCRA 433 May 22, 1995 155 266 247 247 159 SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA 486 281 741; 417 599 1987 January 16, 1997 1995 May 10, 1995 197 SCRA 173 238 SCRA 116 G.R. Nos. L35377-78 July 31 1975 July 5, 2000 September 28, 2000

PEOPLE VS. ABUYEN PEOPLE VS. AGBULOS PEOPLE VS. AGUDEZ PEOPLE VS. AGUSTIN PEOPLE VS. ALBA PEOPLE VS. ALBERT PEOPLE VS. ALICANDO PEOPLE VS. ALVAREZ PEOPLE VS. AMINUDIN PEOPLE VS. ANCHETA PEOPLE VS. AQUINO PEOPLE VS. ARAGON PEOPLE VS. ARNEL ALICANDO; PP. VS. MELCHOR ESTOMACA PEOPLE VS. BADAJOS PEOPLE VS. BAGISTA PEOPLE VS. BALISACAN PEOPLE VS. BENEMERITO PEOPLE VS. BENJAMIN ORTEGA PEOPLE VS. BERMAS PEOPLE VS. BESONIA PEOPLE VS. BOCAR reiterated in PANGAN VS. PEOPLE PEOPLE VS. BRIONES PEOPLE VS. BUENVIAJE PEOPLE VS. BUGARIN PEOPLE VS. BURGOS PEOPLE VS. BURGOS PEOPLE VS. CA PEOPLE VS. CA PEOPLE VS. CA AND INSPECTOR JOE PRING PEOPLE VS. CABALE PEOPLE VS. CACHOLA PEOPLE VS. CALAYCA PEOPLE VS. CALO PEOPLE VS. CAPT. LLANTO PEOPLE VS. CATAN PEOPLE VS. CAYAGO PEOPLE VS. CENDAA PEOPLE VS. CENDAA PEOPLE VS. CFI OF QUEZON PEOPLE VS. CFI OF QUEZON BR. 5 PEOPLE VS. CFI OF QUEZON, BR. 10 PEOPLE VS. CLAMOR PEOPLE VS. CONSING PEOPLE VS. CONTINENTE PEOPLE VS. CRISPIN

213 222 428 240 251 251 201 163

SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA

569 196 692 541 136 293 364 402

1992 1993 May 20, 2004 1995 January 29, 2002

January 14, 2004 August 6, 2002 94 Phil 357 December 12, 1995; April 22, 1996 January 15, 2004 214 SCRA 53 August 31, 1966 264 SCRA 677 July 24, 1997 306 SCRA 135 February 5, 2004 138 SCRA 166; 155 SCRA 45 202 SCRA 708 47 Phil 536 273 SCRA 384 144 SCRA 1 144 SCRA 1 301 SCRA 475 216 SCRA 101 223 SCRA 475

34 156 32 115 33 176 177 110 299 209 33 75 169 38 298 259 152 243 154 177 193 110 47 234 108 302 78 286 222 170 228 153 137 38 292 234 109 291 43 42 245

1997 January 21, 1999

May 8, 1990 January 21, 2004 301 SCRA 192 186 SCRA 620 205 SCRA 235 312 SCRA 623 190 SCRA 538 G.R. No. L-41903 209 SCRA 704 227 SCRA 457 July 1, 1991 339 SCRA 1 327 SCRA 167 January 16, 2003 2000 1990 January 20, 2003 1999 October 17, 1990 June 10, 1992

256 76 160 161

PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE et. al PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE

VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS.

CUTAMORA, et al DE ASIS DE LOS SANTOS DELMENDO DICHOSO DONATO DORIA DUCAY ELPEDES ENCISO ESCORDIAL ESPARAS ESTOMACA EUTIQUIA CARMEN, EVARISTO EVARISTO EXALA FERNANDEZ

296 SCRA 371 223 SCRA 174 198 SCRA 130 225 SCRA 1 160 SCRA 728 260 SCRA 539 256 SCRA 421 G.R. No. 137268 261 SCRA 431

October 6, 2000 December 7, 1993 March 27, 2001 1998 January 22, 1999 August 2, 1993 January 31, 2001 January 16, 2002 1996 1996 March 26, 2001 December 11, 1992

28 169 44 161 285 128 107 46 30 263 107 278 177 243 106 296 299 269 239 244 264 59 163 255 292 104 56 208 50 56 25 32 153 292 40 45 259 113 11 118 298 28 48 30 115 31

221 SCRA 494 186 SCRA 830 December 27, 2000 December 27, 2002 January 31, 2006 October 19, 1994 February 17, 2000 1998 January 18, 2001 January 20, 1988 July 30, 1996 July 22, 2003 October 5, 1993 January 16, 2002 214 SCRA 431 1992 January 24, 2003 November 15, 2000 January 16, 2001 October 17, 1995 February 1, 1999 198 SCRA 401 533 SCRA 643 231 SCRA 701 September 21, 2007 August 18, 1998 May 20, 1998 1994 February 28, 2001

PEOPLE VS. FLORES PEOPLE VS. FLORES PEOPLE VS. FLORES PEOPLE VS. FRANCISCO ZAFRA PEOPLE VS. GALLARDE PEOPLE VS. GARCIA PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. GUZMAN PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE VS. PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. GERENTE GIVERA GOROSPE HERNANDEZ HIPOL HON. JOSE C. DE ILARDE LAB-EO LARENA LI WAY CHUNG LIZADA LOPEZ MADALI MADRIAGA MAGALLANES, et al MAHINAY MALMSTEDT MALTO MANALILI MANHUYOD, JR. MANLULU MAURICIO

481 SCRA 451

288 SCRA 382 219 SCRA 756 260 SCRA 25 G.R. No. 77368 125 SCRA 11

211 SCRA 698

PEOPLE VS. MENDOZA PEOPLE VS. MENDOZA PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. MENGOTE MOGOL MOLINA MONDA, JR. MONTEJO MONTILLA MORENO NADERA NAVARRO NITAFAN OCIMAR ORILLA PANGANIBAN

231 SCRA 264 74 Phil 119 210 SCRA 174 131 SCRA 296 228 SCRA 115 108 Phil 652 285 SCRA 703 270 SCRA 393 February 19, 2001 1993 1998 January 25, 2002 February 2, 2000 March 25, 1997 February 1, 1999 August 17, 1992 February 13, 2004

179 258 295 197 105 114 9 115 31 235 100 185 221 38 262

125 SCRA 595

PEOPLE VS. PAULINO SEVILLENO PEOPLE VS. PEDRO SANTIAGO reiterated in PALU-AY VS. CA PEOPLE VS. PINEDA PEOPLE VS. PRADES PEOPLE VS. PUZON PEOPLE VS. QUITLONG PEOPLE VS. QUIZON PEOPLE VS. RAMOS PEOPLE VS. RAMOS PEOPLE VS. RAPISORA PEOPLE VS. RAYRAY PEOPLE VS. RELOVA PEOPLE VS. REYES PEOPLE VS. RIO PEOPLE VS. ROCHA PEOPLE VS. RODAS PEOPLE VS. RUGAY PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. VS. SALVATIERRA SAYABOC SEQUERRA SERZO, JR. SUBING-SUBING SUELA TABACO TIGLE TONOG, JR. TURINGAN UBA VELASQUEZ VENUS VERGARA VERZOSA

219 SCRA 1 292 256 207 186 SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA 260 325 144 184

148 SCRA 292 201 SCRA 702 531 SCRA 761 531 SCRA 554 291 SCRA 692 276 SCRA 55

March 29, 1999 178 June 20, 1989; July 30, 250 1998 195 July 30, 1998 246 August 29, 2000 43 35 1996 293 21 1990 108 January 25, 2001 238 February 1, 1995 114 192; 203 October 23, 1981 52 272 August 31, 2007 264 August 28, 2007 July 24, 1997 January 15, 2004 October 12, 1987 June 20, 1997 January 15, 2002 March 19, 1997 January 21, 2004 39 269 103 158 152 180 241 31 47 34 111 228 42 241 36 196 243

228 SCRA 168 373 SCRA 163 270 SCRA 32 205 SCRA 772 282 SCRA 424 99 Phil 134 205 Phil 741 63 Phil 435 221 SCRA 960 294 SCRA 466

1998

PEOPLE VS. VIERNES y ILDEFONSO PEOPLE VS. VILLANUEVA PEOPLE VS. VILLARAMA, JR. PEOPLE VS. ZASPA PEREZ VS. CA PHIL. RABBIT BUS LINES, INC VS. PEOPLE PRUDENTE VS. DAYRIT QUINTERO VS. NBI RAMISCAL, JR. VS. SANDIGANBAYAN REODICA VS. COURT OF APPEALS RICAFORTE VS. JURADO RICARDO MANOTOC, JR. VS CA; RICARDO SILVERIO VS. CA; IMELDA MARCOS VS. SB RIGOR VS. PEOPLE ROBERTS VS. CA ROQUE VS. OFFICE OF THE OMBUDSMAN ROSALES VS. CA RUFO MAURICIO CONSTRUCTION VS. IAC RUGAS VS. PEOPLE SALAO VS. CA SALAZAR VS. PEOPLE SANCHEZ VS. DEMETRIOU SANCHEZ VS. DEMETRIOU SANCIANGCO, JR. VS. PEOPLE; DOROMAL VS. SB; as cited in PILAPIL VS. SB SANTIAGO VS. GARCHITORENA SAPIERA VS. CA SAVELLA VS. JUDGE INES, MTC SINAIT, ILOCOS SUR SAYSON VS. PEOPLE SCHROEDER VS. SALDEVAR SERVANTES VS. SB SILVERIO VS. CA SOCRATES VS. SB SOLID TRIANGLE SALES CORP. VS. THE SHERIFF OF RTC QC SONY COMPUTER ENTERTAINMENT, INC. VS. BRIGHT FUTURE TECHNOLOGIES, INC. STATE PROS. AND SPECIAL PROS. IN REGION V, TOLENTINO VS.

December 13, 2001 October 15, 2003 210 SCRA 226 September 21, 2000 168 SCRA 236 April 14, 2004 180 SCRA 69 162 SCRA 467 292 532 142 195 247 SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA SCRA 87 317 149; 760; 127 1989 December 13, 2004 September 5, 2007 May 30, 1986; 1991; 1995 November 17, 2004 March 5, 1996 1999 November 27, 1987 284 SCRA 493 207 SCRA 627 227 SCRA 627 149 SCRA 1; 177 SCRA 354; 221 SCRA 349 228 SCRA 214 January 14, 2004 January 22, 1998 September 23, 2003 November 9, 1993 1993

249 39 174 103 200 249 285 286 61 17 79 127 58 92 166 222 69 31 68 237 10, 80 114 79 45; 84; 148; 203 68 145 44 89 86 148 85 303 287

307 SCRA 104 215 SCRA 102

December 2, 1993 September 14, 1999 April 19, 2007 October 28, 1988 April 27, 2007 May 18, 1999 April 8, 1991 February 20, 1996 November 23, 2001 February 15, 2007

A.M. No. MTJ-071673 522 SCRA 624 307 SCRA 149 253 SCRA 773 516 SCRA 62

June 7, 2007

187

HON. PAQUERO SUERO VS. PEOPLE TABAO VS. BARATAMAN TALAG VS. REYES TATAD VS. SB TEEHANKEE JR. VS. MADAYAG TEODORO VS. CA TORRES VS. GARCHITORENA TUCAY VS. JUDGE DOMAGAS TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX VS. CA U.S. VS. LAHOYLAHOY U.S. VS. POMPEYA U.S. VS. POMPEYA U.S. VS. TICZON U.S. VS. YAO SIM UMIL VS. RAMOS UMIL VS. RAMOS UY KHEY TENG VS. VILLAREAL UY VS. BIR UY, ROSA VS. CA VALERIO VS. DELA TORREYADAO VEGA VS. PANIS VEROY VS. LAYAGUE VICTORY LINER VS. BELLOSILLO VINO VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILS. WASHINGTON DISTILLERS INC. VS. CA WEBB VS. DE LEON YAKULT PHILS. VS. COURT OF APPEALS YAP, JR. VS. CA ZALDIVIA VS. REYES, SR.

A.M No. MTJ-011384 A.M. No. RTJ-041852 159 SCRA 70 207 SCRA 134 258 SCRA 643 A.M. No. RTJ-951286 164 SCRA 655 38 Phil 330 31 Phil 245 25 Phil 67 31 Phil 301 187 SCRA 311 202 SCRA 251 42 Phil 886

January 31, 2005 April 11, 2002 June 3, 2004 March 21, 1988 March 6, 1992 December 27, 2002 March 2, 1995

201 142 146 84 53, 81 271 76 134 285

July 15, 1918 August 6, 1915

October 20, 2000 July 28, 1997 October 10, 2007 117 SCRA 267 210 SCRA 97 178 SCRA 626 260 SCRA 821 247 SCRA 190 SCRA 357 211 SCRA 277 September 30, 1982 March 10, 2004 1996 August 23, 1995 1990 June 6, 2001

43 37 120 29 37 106 107 291 282 57 133 50 302 139 240 288; 289 182; 224 64 132 17