Emory1 3

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 1 of 75
'.
18085
Emory University Invoice Number
126003 James J . Murtagh,.,
Jr MD - Arbitration Page 9
07/15/ 05
324703
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
-------- ---------06/13/05 JC Hill Review protective order ; draft
3 .8
acknowledgment for same ;
conference regarding status of
case and strategy
06/13/05
TD Wozniak
B-mails regarding discovery 5 .5

practice ; telephone conference
with B . Morrison reg arding same ;
meet wit h B . Morr i s on
n a nd T .
Goriczynski regarding electronic
discovery issues ; meet with
defense team regarding "to do,,
items and time tables 7
06/13/05
L..J
7'C Duffield Finalise order granting limited 9 .4

expedited disco-very and file with
court ; prepare list of search
terms for Murtagh's electronic
information ; meeting with B .
Clark-Morrisan, T . Goriczynski,
and T, wozriak regard-,ng
electronic ;
discovery
prepare
acknowledgement for independent
expert in connection with
discovery order ; tale-ohone calls
with Plaintiff's counsel
regarding coordinating delivery
of computers to independent
expert ; prepare list o f search
terms to submit to independent
expert for review of Murtagh's
computer information
06/33/0 5
DG Anderson Meet with defense team regarding 2 .0

status of projects ; update list
of action items ; draft list of
search terms and phrases
ns/a 3 lQ 5
G Johnson Conference with B .

3.0
Clark-Morrison, T . Wozniak, T .
Duffield, and T Gora .cxyriskz
regarding data collection and
electronic discovery
06/14/05 JC Hill Conference with T . Duzfield

regarding strategy and current
status of projects ; conference
with T . Wozniak regarding
discovery requests ; revise
discovery requests ; review
O r igi nal Invoices ( 17- 9 8 -08)
11 .9
EPO- 62
0-
1 eo8 .5
Emory University
226003
dames J . Murt agh,
07/15/05
Date
Jr ., MD Arbitration
Invoice Number
Page 10
Timekeeper
Hours
relevant settlement agreement
provisions to incorporate into
discovery requests ; review
Plaintiff's discovery requests ;
research factually similar
case-law for attorneys' fees and
depositing funds into court's
registry for brief
06/1a/05
1~_J
06/14/05
09/14/05
TD Wozniak Revise independent expert

acknowledgment ; review and revise
list of e-mail accounts to
search ; telephone conference with
8 . Mprrison ; telephone conference
with independent expert regarding
key word searches and cost
estimate, review and comment on
Plaintiff's document requests ;
telephone conference with B .
Morrison regarding electronic
discovery ; review and revise
interrogatories and document
requests to plaintiff
TC D u f f i e l d Revise acknowledgem ent to
.discovery order and send to
D e l oitte for execution ; forward
signed copies to 3 . Bremen ; review
_
list of e-mail accounts to search
and ;
preserve
prepare list of
search terms for e-mail ac=.ints ;
revise interrogatories and
document
review
document requests t o Mu rtagh ;
requests from
Murtagb ; prepare letter to J .
B reen regarding Emory Wheel
postings ; telephone call w i th P .
Brock ingt on regarding re fe r en ce
to FERPA issues i n di scovery
requests
DG Anderson Compile documents related to Duke
~TaipolZn ; prepare list of search
terms for electronic discovery ;
compile 2,Taipohri interview
notebook
3 .4
6 .7
6 .7
06/15/05 J C Hill Draft supplemental brief on 8 .2

motion to deposit funds with the
court ; research rescission
O r i ginal Invoice s (111-18-08)
EPO - 63
324703
18 0 8 s
Emory University
126003
James J . Murtagh, jr ., MD - Arbitration
07/15/05
Date
Invoice Number
Page 11
Hours
Timekeeper
---------caselaw with similar facts ;
conference with T . Duf=field
05/15f05 TC Duffield
06/15/05
L J
06/15105
Complete list of search terms for

Murtagh's computers ; conference
caI]l with Delcitte regarding
search terms ; prepare letter to
J . Bxeen regarding postings on
2mary's website ; telephone call
with Grady's counse3l regarding
discovery requests
T7) Wozniak Telephone conference with B . ~

Morrison and T . Grodzinski
regarding electronic discovery ;
telephone conference with G .
Johnson regarding same ; telephone
conference with plaintiff's
counsel regarding consent
protective order ; telephone
conference with GradyTs counsell
regarding discovery issues and
protective order
DG Anderson
Organize case notebooks ; review

and revise charts summarizing
reference reqeusts and e-mails ;
prepare and file Hennigar v . John
Doe valuntary,dismissal ; prepare
and serve first document requests
and first interrogatories to
plaintiff
5 .4
2 .5
6 .3
06/15/05 . G Johnson
Research regarding MSX format

conversion ; canveralon and
testing of e-mail store
4 .2
06/7.6/05 TC Duffield
Rev i se letter to Plaintiff's

counsel regard i ng removall of
postings on Emory's websit e that
reference Murtagh ; revise consent
Protect i ve Order and forward t o
J . Breen and T . E i che]. b exger for
comments ; conference call w it h
opposing course]l regarding
consent prot ec t iv e order and
other discovery issue s ; rev i ew
upcorn ing action items and
coordinate complet i on of various
i tems with j, Hill and D .
9 .2
Or i ginal Invoices ( 11 - 18 -08 )
EPO- 64
324703
10085
Emor y University
126003
James J . Muxtagh, fix . ;
07/15/05
MD
- Arb i tration
Invoice Number
Page 1 2
Date
Timekeeper
-------- ---------Anderson ; various t e lephone calls
with Delo i tte regarding
modif i cation of search t erms
be ing run on Murta g h's computers
06/16/05
06/16/05
06116105
4/17/(}5
Hours
TD Wozniak Review and revise letter to 3 .2

plaintiff's counsel regarding
Emory Wheel articles on website ;
meet with J . Hill regarding
supplemental brief in support of
motion to pay money into court
registry ; e-mars with
plaintiff's counsel regarding _
expedited discovery, computer
search terms, and hearing
schedules ; telephone conference
with plaintiff's counsel
regarding discovery and potential
mediation ; telephone conference
with independent expert regarding
further narrowing search terms
JC Hill Conference with T . Duffield
regarding to-do items ; draft
response to Plaintiff's discovery
requests ; draft supplemental
brief regarding payment of funds
into court ; conference with T_
Wozniak regarding brief
DG Anderson
7 .2
Prepare search terms list ;

3 .0
prepare list of documents to be '
included in July 14 hearing
notebook ; review Goggle subpoena
and determine when responsive
documents are due ; compile
documents for T . Dutfield's
review regarding motion to compel
arbitration
TD Wozniak Review list of search terms and

"hits" compiled by independent
expert ; telephone conferences
with expert regarding modified
searches to reduce hits ;
Morrison regarding same ;
telephone conference with D .
Anderson and T . Duftield
regarding significance of certain
Original Invoices ( 1 4- 1 8-08)
3 .9
E PO- 66
324703
18 85 Emery University Invoice Number

126003
James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 13
07/15/05
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
--------_________ search terms ; review Plaintiff's
comments on protective order ;
. e-mars with T . Eichelberger
regarding same
06f17f a5
TC D uffiel d
Telephone calls with Deloitte and

T . Wozniak regarding results of
independent experts searches of
Murtaghls computer ; review and
revise supplemental brief
regarding payment of settlement
fu nds into court registry
06/17/05
JC Hill
Telephone conference with Court - T 4 .6

clerk regarding confidentiality
orde r ; conference with D .
1 .4
Anderson regarding complaint ;

revi ew word list with T .
Duffield ; revise letter to
opp osing counsel ; revise brief
regarding deposit of funds with
court
10,
06/17/05 DO Anderson Review list of terms and

determine identity of certain
individuals for determination as
to whether they stay on the list
OGJ 1 B/D5 TC Duffiel d Review and revise supplemental
brief regarding payment of
settl ement funds into court' s
reg i stry
-
06/18/05
z.
1 .1
JC Hill Draft supplemental brief to pay 4 .4

money into court registry,
additionall research regarding
same
.
~,
06/19/05
TD waznaak Update "to do" list of action 0 .7

items ; e-mails with independent
expert regarding search hits and
further narrowing scope of review
06/19/05
JC Hill Revise supplemental brief
06/20/05
TD Wozniak
Revi ew and rev i se le t ter to

plaintiff's counsel regard i ng
Emory weh postings ; telephone
conference with independent
expert regard ing finalization of
Origin al Invoices (11-18-08)
1 .2
1.4
EPO- 66
324703
I]
18085
Emary University Invoice Number
X26003 James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 14
07/15/05
Date Timekeeper
-------- ----------
Hours
search terms and production of
responsive copy of information ;
Morrison regarding same
Q6/20/ 0 5
J C Hill
Conference with T . Duffield

regarding contract remedies
research and supplemental brief ;
2 .4
research contract remedies

06/20/05 T C Duffield
Revise letter to J . Breen

regarding Emory Wheel postings ;
review list of search term hits
on Murtagh computers ; conference
. Johnson
.calwithI}eo2,G
and T, Woaniak regarding universe
of responsive documents from hits
on Murtagh's computers ; review
research regarding payment of
settlement funds into court's
registry ; revise brief regarding
same
7 .8
06/2105 JC Hill
Review supplemental memorandum or

law in support of request to pay
funds into court's registry ;
research breach of contract
issue ; conference with T .
Duffield regarding plaintiff's
motion to strike ; review
Plaintiff's complaint and draft
document retention memoranda
8.1
Q6/2iffl5
Review Plaintiff's motion to

strike counterclaims undez
anti-&LAPP statute ; research
regarding same ; conference with
T . Wozniak and T . Eichelberger ;
revise list of search terms for
Emory e-mail ; finalize letter to
J . Breen regarding postings on
Emory's website and coordinate
service to J . Breen ; revise
supplemental brief regarding
payment of settlement funds into
court's registry ; draft temporary
restraining order papers for
possible stalking
10 .4
T C Duffield
O r iginal Invoice s (11-18-08)
EPO-67
324703
~-
18085 Emory University InvoiCe Number

126003 James J . Murtagh, jr
., MD - Arbitration Page 1 5
07/15/05
324703
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
---------06/ 21/05 DG Anderson Prepare search terms for Emoxy's 5 .3
cite check and
internaJl ;search
proof supplemental brief ; revise
chart of reference requests
06/21105
2 .5
TD Wozniak E-mails regarding electronic
discovery from Emary University
and Emory I4ealthcare ; review and
revise letter to J . Breen
regarding documents on websiue ;
review plaintiff's motion to
strike ; e-mail with P . Morrison
regarding same - -
06/22/DS
TD Wozniak Review and revise supplemental

brief to pay settlement amounts
into court registry ; review
select research regarding same ;
N,orrison and _F'mory idea? thcare IT
employees regarding electronic
discovery issues ; telephone
conference with S . Morrison
regarding arguments for response
to Plaintiff's motion to strike
counterclaims ; telephone
conference with B . Morrison and
S . Sencer regarding Plaintiff's
allegations regarding insurance
lawsuit ; telephone G . Johnson and
T . Grozcinski regarding
electronic discovery issues with
respect to Ernary University
06/22/05
TC Duffield
Review Plaintiff's motion to

strikee counterclaims ; conference
response to same ; research
regarding Georgia's anti-SLAPP
statute
; draft response themes to
motion to strike ; draft letter to
Plaintiff's counsel requesting
that Plaintiff withdraw his
Motion to Strike
a ,q
7 .1
06/22/05 DG Anderson Revise list of Emory search 2 .2

terms ; cite check and proof
supplemental brief in support of
motion to payment settlement
fines
O ri ginal Invoices ( 1 1- 18-08 )
EPO - 6 8
18085 Emory University Invoice Number

126003
07/15/05
Date
timekeeper
fours
--------------------06/22/05 JC Hill Revise brief regarding deposit of 5 .4
. funds with court ; resea~cch
anti-slapp issuers
05/ 2 3 / D $ TD Woaniak
Revise letter to J .
Breen
requesting withdrawal of motion
to strike counterclaims ; review
e-mails from IT personnel at
Emory and Emory Healthcare
regarding electronic discovery
issues ; telephone conference with
8 . Morrison regarding response to
4 .2
plaintiff's motion to strike ;

review research regarding
anti-slapp arguments
06/23/05 JC Hi ll
Research SLAPP legislative

history and caselaw
2 .2
06/23/05 TC Duffield
Research regarding select

anti-SLAPS issues and free speech
waivers ; revise letter to J .
Been requesting withdrawal of
motion to strike counterclaims ;
draft response to Plaintiff's
motion to strike counterclaims ;
revise document retention memo
7 .5
06/23/05 DG Ande-rson
Cite check supplemental brief in

support of motion to payment
settlement f4nes ; telephone
conference with Google regarding
subpoenaed documents ; conference
with T . Duffield regarding status
of items on action list
3 .8
06/23/0 .5 G Johnson
Miscellaneous telephone calls

with Deloitte regar ding progress
on the forensic capture and
analysis project
2 .2
06/24/05 TD Wozniak
Telephone conference with B .

Morrison regarding anti-slapp
verification and letter
requesting plaintiff dismiss
ration to strike ; telephone
conference with Grady's counsel
regarding same ; revise letter
2 .1
Original Invoices (11-18-08)
EPO- 69
324703

126003
07/15/05
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
w - r----- _____ ____ seeking withdrawal of motion to
strike ; revise verification
o 6 /za/o 5
TC Duffield
Draft anti-SLAPP verification to B ..2

amended counterclaims for K .
Alexander and T . Wozniak ;
research in connection with
response to Plaintiffs, motion to
strike
; draft response to motion
to strike
06/24/05 DG Anderson cite check and shepardize 3 .4

supplemental brief in support of,
motion to payment settlement
fines ; telephone conference with

Google regarding subpoenaed
documents
05f27/D5 TD Wazniak
1 .4
Morrison regarding supplemental
brief in support of motion to pay
settlement funds into court's
registry ; revise supplemental
; review B . Mozrison's
brief
comments to litigation hold memo ;
meet with T . Dtiffield regarding
response to motion to strike
o5J27/4S JC Hill Review exhibits to Plaintiff's 8 .4

motion to strike ; draft section
of response to motion to strike ;
revise document retention memo ;
researchh anti-slap cases from
other jurisdictions
05 / 27/OS
DG Anderson Prepare, file and serve motion to 6 .0

pay settlement funds into court
registry ; update July 14th
hearing notebooks
06/28/05
TD Wozniak
Review and revise response to

plaintiff's motion to strike ;
revise litigation hold
Z. 8
memorandum ; review e-mails

issues at Emory Healthcare ;
e-mails with independent expert
regarding recovery of data in
slack space
O riginal I n voi ces (1 1 -18-0 8)
E PO-7D
324703
18085
126003
o 7 / 15 fo 5
Emory
Date
06/28/05
University
Invoice
Number
324703
James J . Murtagh, Jr .,-MD Arbitration page .18
Timekeeper
Hours
JC Hill
' Research anti-slapp cases from 2 . 7
other jursidictions ; outline
memorandum regarding co ntra c t
remedies
D6/28/ 0 5 DG Anderson Locate joint defense agreement ;
review reference request letters
received from Emory and compare
to what we already have ; update
chart of same ; prepare exhibits
for response to motion to strike
7 .5
06/29/05
.7 C Hill
Review anti--s] .apg cases for

attorneys' fees issues ; research
severability of contract
provisions and substantial
compliance issues ; draft
memorandum regarding remedies for
payment of funds under settlement
agreement
06/29/05
TD Wozniak
Review and revise response to

Plaintiff's motion to s tr ike
c Q=terclaims ; r ev iew select
rese arch reg a rd ing s ame
4 .2
06/29/0 DG Andersen
Review of correspondence for

letters referencing Murtagh's
defamation claims ; cite check and
proof work on response to motion
to ;
strike
review new reference
request letters received from
Emory
3 .6
06/30/05
Revise response to plaintiff's

motion to strike ; telephone
conferences with B . Morrison
regarding response brief and
connection betweenn plaintiff and
attorney Lovern ; review and
revise proposed order denying
regarding response to motion to
strike, verification, and
strategy
3 .6
TD Wozniak
06 / 3fl/D5 DG Anderson
~.
2 .3
Cite check and sh epa r dize

response t o motion to str i ke ;
6 .2
comp i le exhibi ts to same ; locate
Orig inal Invoices (11-18-08)
EPO - 7 1
18085
126003

James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration page 19
324703
07/15/05
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
correspondence regarding
arbitrators ; update reference
letters notebook
482 .1
TOTAL HOURS
TIMEKEEPER T I M E SUMMARY :
Ti m e k eeoe r
------------------------Todd D . Wozniak
Todd C . 17u f field
Jennifer C . Hill
Debra G . Anderson
Sandy R, Burney
Kerrie S . Howze
Glenn Johns on
Tamera S.ha. x? ey
Hours
95
168
118
71
8
2
16
0
.7 _
.8
.7
.8
.0
.7
.2
.2
108,091 .08
CURRENT FEE S
FOR COSTS A DVANCED AND EX P ENS E S INCURRED :

06/30/05 Lon g Distance .thane 'Calls-.A TL
0 6 /30/d5 Te l ec opy/Telex-ATL
Duplicating Cos t s -ATL
06130105
06/30/05 Computer Research-Lexis/Westlaw-A
46/3 D JD5 Support Staff Over time - AT L
17 6/06/45 Bus i ness Meals T . Outf i eld .
5/28/05 At l anta, GA .-Hill, Ourada
06/29/05
Business Meals D . Hamilton,
6/27/05 ATL-Re : client
Q6/(1 1 /QS Subpoena Fees Dekalb C ounty Cou r t
House
06/24/05 Professional Fees Google, Inc . Costs incurred in processing
subpoena request
06/13/05
BellSo uth Telecommunications Inv . SBNfl510032 - Record
retrieval and reproduction for
mat t e r of xenra i gax v . John na y
06/29/ 05
T . Outfi eld . 6f19/C15 P i ttsburgh,
PA .-Fax sending fees
0
13
1 .263
2,333
660
.35 .
.25
. '70
.87
.40
41 .6(?
21 .33
1 .D0
25 .00
61 .25
25 .58
EPO- 72
1ED85 Emory University

126003 Jams J . Murtagh, Jr ., M - Arbitration
07/15/05
Invoice Number
Page 20
06/10/05 Document Delivery Georgia

Messenger Service, .
Inc
9I_30
06/10/05
11 .75
Document Del i very Georgia

Messenger Service, Inc .
06/10/05
Document Delivery Georgia
Messenger Ser vi ce, Inc .
D6/O 1 JOS
Duplicating Costs Dekal. b County
Court House
06/06/' 05 Document Delivery - UPS -Ma .
Kenya R . Nelson,-COX
COMMUNICATIONS-Atlanta-GA---06/14/05
Document Delivery - UPS -Mr . Andy
Bout z-BELLS OUTH
TELEC4N3MUN I-CA.T I ON-Atlanta -GA-___
CURR EXJT EXPENSES
324703
14 .15
1 .00
7 .32
7 .12
4,a79 .67
TOTAL AMOUNT OF THIS INVOICE
112,570 .75
.. .
O ri ginal Invoic e s (11-18-08)
EPO- 73
aew,;t rti :
KING & SPALDING LLP
P .0, Box 116133

Atlanta, GA 30358-6 153
FEDERAL I.D. NO . 39-0520153
7tleph ane : (404) 572-4600

B Y li'll
2E ; SUNTRUST BANK
ABA NO: 061 000 104
MET-. SNTRU53A
A CCT NO: 8800312475
PLEASE n M caTE Yxvotce N u ain E n ON a0 sarra Nr,E
Elizabeth R . Clark-Morrison
Office of the General Counsel
Emory University
101 Administration Building
Atlanta, GA 303 2 2
Invoice Number 331058

Invoice Date
08/31/05
Client Number
18085
Matter Number
126003
Re- games J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration

------------------- -------------------------------------------------
F4Ft PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RE14-DERED THROUGH 0-7/31/05 ;

Date Timekeeper
-------- ---------0 SfZ7/05
TC DuffieXd
0.
Hours
Research and draft brie47 in 11 .7
opposition to Plaintiff s motion
to strike counterclaims ;
conference with T . Wozniak
regarding same ; revise document
retentiorn memo ; corxespond viaa
e-mail with Deloitte regarding
status of forensic review of
Murtagh's computers
06/28/05 TC Duffield Draft response to motion to 8 .3

strike counterclaims and amended'
counterclaims ;*review exhibits to
arne ;ided counterclaims and
previous correspondence betweenn
counsel regarding issues raised
in motion to strike
t16J29/4 5
TC Duffield Revise response to Plaintiff's 8 .4

motion to strike ; research
regarding reco-,rezy of attorney's
fees under O .C .G .A . 9-11-11 .1 ;
review and comment on list of
recipients of document retention
memo
05f30/05 TC Duifield Attention to list of recipients 5 .1

of document retention memo ;
PA Y1r2ER'3 l5 DUE UPON RECEIPT OF INVOICE
ATLA N TA -HOUSTON , L ON DON NEW YORK
WASHINGTON, D . C .
EPO- 74
18085 Emory University

126043 James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration
08/31/05
Invoice Number
Page 2
Date Timekeeper
-------- -------------------
,33 1 Q58
Hours
rev i ew updated reference request
chart and correspond with B .
Clark-Morrisan
n regarding missing
information ; dra f t proposed order
denying mot i on to strike and .
granting Emory's attorney's fees ;
meet with M . L a r son regard i ng
status of forensic r evi ew of
computers
Muxka gh 's ;
meet with J .
Hill to di scuss research a nd memo
regarding rescission of
settlement agreement ; conference
outstanding action items and
preparation for upcoming h earing
06/30/05
0'
JC Hill Review internet postings for 2 .4

Murtagh references ; conference
with T . Duffield regarding action
items ; conference with D .
Anderson regarding Kuritzky file
Conference with J . Hill regarding

memo on recision of settlement
agreement ; coordinate filing and
service of response to
Plaintiff's motion to strike ;
telephone calls with M . Larson at
Deloitte regarding production of
responsive copy of Murtagh's
computer files
1 .7
07/01/05 DG Anderson
Prepare, file and serve response

to motion to strike and
verification
4 .8
07/01/05
TD Wozn-Lak Review and revise response to

conferences with K . Alexander and
B . Morrison regarding same
telephone conference with T .
Eichelberger regarding response
to motion to strike and
verifications
3 .6
07/01/05
JC Hill Research available contract

provisions to withhold payments
under the agreement
2 .8
Orig i nal Invoices (11-18-08)
A PO - 75
18085
Emory University
126003
James J . Murtagh, Jam,, MD - Arbitration
D 8/31/OS
Invoice Number
Page 3
Date Timekeeper
Hers
Q7/04/Q5 JCHill
`-- Research regarding contract

remedies ; draft memorandum
regarding contract remedies
D7/ 0 5/ 0 5 TD Wozniak
Conference with T . Duffield and
5 .9
3 .1
J . 3-i11 regarding July 14 hearing

and prepare for same ; telephone
conference with B . Morrison
regarding demonstrative exhibits
pox- hearing ; review additional
postings from new criminologist
web site ; conference with J . Hill
regarding damages research and
exhibits for argument on motion
to pay money into court's
registrar
07/QS/05 TC Duffield
Revise memory responses to

Plaintiff's first request for
production of documents ;
conference with T . Wozniak and J .
Hill regarding argument outlines
,or July 14 hearing ; review
information on potential
arbitrators previously discussed
by parties and prepare chart
regarding same ; prepare outline
for argument on motion to compel
arbitration
07/05J O5 JC Hill
Conference with T . Wozniak an d T .
12 .5
5 .9
Duffield regarding hearing outlines and other preparations

for hearing ; review supplemental
brief and -Dull principal cases ;
revise responses to Plaintiff's
request for production
07/06/05
TD Wozniak
0706/05 TC Duffield
E-mails with Plaintiff's counsel

regarding review of "responsive
copy" of computer storage
; telephone conference
devices
with B . Morrison -regarding
demonstrative exhibits ;
conference with T . Duffield
regarding arguments and exhibits
for July 14 hearing
1 .7
Draft hearing outline on motion

to compel arbitration ; review and
7 .1
EPO- 76
331058
18085
.
126003
./DS
D8/37
memory University
James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration
invoice Number
Page 4
Date Timekeeper
-------- -------------------
331058
Hours
analyze cases cited in briefs in
connect ion w i th mot io n to compel
arbitration ; conference with T .
Wozniak to discuss hearing
arguments and exhibits ; telephone
call wit h M . Larson regarding
delivery of responsive copy to J .
Sreen ; telephone conference with
judge Tusan's clerk to discuss
logistics of hearing and use or
exhibits
07/06/05
LMW Johnston Coaference with J . HxlJl regarding 0 .4

mediation notes for conract
interpretation issues
07/06/05
SR Burney Retrieve caselaw cited in briefs 2 .7

for upcoming hearing ; telephone
call to trial graphix regarding
enlargements ; conferences with T .
Duffield regarding same
~ .
07/06/05 JC Hill Dra f t hearing ou t line for mo t ion
on payment into court
4 .4
07/07/05 TD Wozniak Review principal cases cited by 2,7

parties inn pleadings on motion to
compel arbitration ; review briefs
on arbitration issues ; outline
potential demonstrative exhibits
for hearing ; prepare for hearing
07/07/05 T C Duffield
07/ 0 7J05 FTC Hill

0
'
Prepare hearing outline on motion

to compel arbitration ; review
cases cited in briefs in
connection with motion to compel ;
prepare letter to opposing
counsel regarding July 14 hearing
and discovery deadlines ;
regarding July 14 hearing
arguments ; prepare hearing
outline on motion to strike
counterclaims under anti-SLAP
statute
Draft hearing outline for motion
to pay monies into court ; update
research respondeat superior
liability defamation claims ;
Origina l I nvoices (11-18-08)
7 .8
3 ."6
EPO- 77
18085
Emery University Invoice Number
126003 .
James %.7 . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 5
08/31/05
Date
Timekeeper
-------- ----------
331 0 5 E .
Hours
revise discovery responses ;

review previous draft's and
attorneys notes from mediation
and settlement agreement
negotiations
07/08/05
TD WoZniak
Emails with Plaintiff's counsel

regarding July 14 hearing and
discovery issues ; e-mails with B .
discovery ; meet with T . Duffield
regarding demonstrative exhibits
for hearing review principal
cases relied upon by Plaintiff to
avoid arbitration
2 .5
07/08/05
TC Duffield
Prepare hearing outlines for

motion to compel arbitration and
Plaintiff's motion to strike
counterclaims ; prepare
demonstrative exhibits ; telephone
call with IRON regarding
demonstratives ; telephone calfl
with t, Eichelberger regarding
interview of Duke Naipohn
7 .5-
07j08/05 JC Hill conference w i t h S . Burney

regarding subpoenas to include in
document production responses ;
revise discovery respoizses ;
research arbitration cases for
motion to compel argument
07/09/05
TD Woz-niak Prepare for hearing on motion . to

.compel ;
arbitration
revise
proposed demonstrative exhibits ;
review research regarding statute
of limitations issues
07/fl9/OS TC Duffield Revise hearing outline for motion

to strike ; prepare demonstrative
exhibits for various motions
07/10/05
3 .5
3 .0
5 .9
TD Wozniak Prepare for hearing on motion to 8 , 6

compel arbitration, motionn to
strike counterclaims, and motion

to pay money into court registry
07/10/05
.TC Hill Research discovery rule and

continuing tort theory
2 .3
E PO- 78
85
126003
018,/031/05
Date
0.
Emory University
Invoice Number
Page 6
RQUrs
Timekeeper
07/11/05
TD Woznia% Prepare for hearing on motion to

pay settlement funds into court
registry, review cases cited in
parties, briefs ; e-mails with B .
discovery ; review and comment on
electronic screening terms ;
revise litigation hold memo ;
telephone conference with Grady's
counsel regarding strategy for
July 14 hearing
3 .3
07/11/05
TC Duffield Consider and prepare exhibits for

use at July 14, 2005 hearing ;
telephone call with T .
Bichelberger to discuss interview
of D . Naipohn ; discuss hearing
arguments and exhibits with T .
Wozniak and J . Hill ; telephone
call from Judge Tusan's clerk
regarding July 14, 2005 hearing ;
revise document retention memo
and -forward to B . Clark-Morrison ;
prioritize remaining search terms
for filtering on Emory e-mail ;
Wozniak and T . Eichelberger
regarding July 14, 2005 hearing
arguments ; correspond with
Plaintiff's counsel regarding
protective order ; draft consent
motion to continue hearing on
interlocutory injunction ; draft
letter to Plaintiff's counsel
regarding production of
Responsive Copy from Murtagh's
computer
12 .2
07 / 11 / 05 JC Hill
Conference with T . i7uftzsld and

T . Wozniak regarding hearing and
arguments ; review and select
exhibits
; review letter to Breen
(37f12jo5 TC Dufrield Meet with IKON to discuss

demonstrative exhibits for July
4,4
4 .7
14, 2005 hearing ; prepare

exhibits for hearing and discuss
with T . Wozniak ; finalize letter
to Plaintiff's counsel regarding
Original In vo ices (11-18-08)
E PO- 79
331058
~.

126003
James J . P'Iur t agh,
48J 3 1/O5
Jr, MD - Arbitration
I nvo i ce . Num-bex 33105

Page 7
Date Timekeeper
-------- ----------
Hours
production of responsive copy ;
-finalize joint motionn to re-set
hearing date on motion for
interlocutory injunction and
forward to Plaintiff's counsel
for consideration ; review
Plaintiff's counsel's mark-up of
consent protective order and
discuss with T_ Wozniak ; revise
consent protective order and
forward to Plaintiff's counsel
07/12/05
DG Mderson Meet with IX014 representative to

discuss demonstrative exhibits
for July 14 hearing ; several
telephone conferences with IKON
representative regarding carne ;
prepare documents for hearing
3 .7
07/12rDS TD Wozniak Telephone conference with B .

4,6
Morrison regarding arguments for
July 14 hearing ; revise letter to
J . Breen ; revise protective
order ; telephone conference with
B . Morrison and Emory I3ealLhcare
IS employees regarding electronic
discovery ; meet with IKON
regarding demonstrative exhibits ;
prepare for hearing on mntion to
strike
o7/13f05 J ' C Hill
07/13/05
Rev i ew pleadings ; draft

bu ll e tpn irst memo of arguments ;
reseaxch
h waiver c a selaw ;
conference with T . Du i field
regarding hearing
TC Du f field Prepare for J u ly 7.4 , 2005

hear i ng ; review and an alyz e
Plaintiff's response to Emory ' s
mot i on for interlocutory
in j unction and E mo ry's re sponse
to motion to strike ; review and
ana l yze Plaintiff's second
supplemental response - to
De fe ndan ts' motions t o compel ;
f i nalize exhibits and
demonstrat ives and discuss same
w it h vendor
Ori g in a l Invo i ces ( 11 - 18-0 8)
5,4
12 .6
E PO- 80
18085
Emory University
Invo i ce Number 331058
126003
Ja mes J . Murtagh, Jr . . , MD - Arbitration
Page 8
08/31/05
Date
Timekeeper
-------- ---------07/13J05 DG Anderson Prepare exhibits and notebooks
for hearing
07/13/05
TD Wozniak
.
~
07/13/05
Hours
5 .3
Review Plaintiff's second 1D .D

supplemental surreply to
Defendants' motion to compel
arbitration, Plaintiff's response
to Emory's motion for
interlocvtory injunction, and
Plaintiff's reply in support of
motion to strike ; review newly
cited cases by Plaintiff ;
Morrison regarding new briefs ;
review Plaintiff's affidavit of
T . Nugent ; review select exhibits
to Plaintiff's newly filed
briefs ; review Plaintiff's late
filed and served motion for
discovery protective order7
prepare for July 14 hearing ;
review and comment on
demonstrative exhibits ; telephone
regarding newly filed pleadings
and responsive arguments
MW Johnston Review pleadings regarding 2 .0

hearing and conference with T .
Wozniak regarding same ; review
Murtagh affidavit
07/14/05 TD Wozniak
attend hearing an motions to

compel arbitration, to strike
counterclaims and to pay
settlement funds into court
registry ; meet with Grady's
caunsel regarding discovery and
settlement strategy ; telephone
regarding same ; revise outline
regarding potential arbitrators ;
Duffield and J . Hill regarding
discovery to pursue
B .6
07/14/05 JC Hill
Attend hearing ; conference with

T . Wozniak regarding to-do list
and scheduling order ; review
notes from ;
hearing
telephone
7 .7
Origi na l I nvoice s ( 1 1-18-08)
EPO-s 1
18085 memory University Invoice Number

12600 James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 9
as/3~~os
Date
Timekeeper
-------- ----------
33iDsB
fours
conference with T . DuTfield

updating him on hearing
Prepare for and transmit exhibits

to hearing
3 .7
07/14/05 G Johnson
Discuss electronic discovery

issues with team and client
1 .2
37/].5J09 JC Hill
Draft discovery scheduling orders
4_ 1
for arbitration and for

interlocutory injunction motion ;
Duffield regarding discovery
requests and to-do items .
07/15/05 -DG Anderson
-Research regarding poLuntial

arbitrator ; review and respond to
mails regarding order on motion
to compel ; conference with T .
Wozniak regarding Upcoming
arbitratzarn and discovery
schedule ; review of action item
list
2 .5
07 /1 5/05 TD Wozniak
outline additional discovery to

pursue ; review research on
potential arbitrators ; telephone
regarding potential arbitrators,
settlement issues, and discovery
strategy
1 .9
07/15/05
G Johnson

issues with team and client
1 .4
07/17/05
TD Woznia%
Emails regarding potential

arbitrators
0 .3
o7J 17 fos
JC Hill
Review amended counterclaims,

Plaintiff's complaint, demand for
arbitration and Murtagh's
affidavit for discovery issues ;
draft written discovery requests ;
draft list of potential
deponents ; revise scheduling
orders
5 .1
Review research regarding

potential arbitrators ; telephone
4 .2
07/18/ 0 S TD Wozniak
0-
Original Invo ices ( 11 - 18 -08)
E PO-82

126003
aames .j . Murtagh, Jr . . MD - Arbitration
08/31/05

Page iQ
Dale Timekeeper
-------- -------------------
Hours
conferences with B . Morrison
regarding same ; telephone
conference with T . Richelberger
regarding arbitrators and
discovery schedule ; revise
scheduling order ; telephone
conference with Pla i nt iff's
counsel regarding settlement,
obtai n i ng compu t er discovery , and
scheduling order
07/18/ 05
JC Hill Review arbitration rules for

emergency motion to make payments
into escrow account ; conference
with T . Wozniak regarding motion
1 .3
07/18/05 DG Anderson compile information on poten t ial

; make arrangements to
-arbitrators
obtain copy of tra ns c ript o f July
14 hear i ng ; update case notebooks
S :3
outline discovery plan and 7 .1

strategy ; review arbitration
demand, complaint, counterclaims
and affidavits in connection with
same ; revise draft
requests to Murtagh
07/18/05 M Evra.t t .
Research to ret riev e b i ographi ca l

information on nine arbitrators
07/19/05
R evi ew revised sc hedul ing order 2 .0

and order on motion to strike ;
DG Psiderson
0 .8
rev i ew Emo ry web s i te set up to

capture potentially relevant
ma i ls ; discuss same w i th T .
Du = f i eld
07/19/05 J-C Fail
Re vi ew M ur ta gh 's March 200 2 an d

April 2002 at"fidavit5 ; revise
requests
OTf19fa5 TD Wozn i ak
Review end revise discovery plan ;

revi ew court's order denying .
Plaintiff's mot i on to strike ;
emails with B . Morrison regarding
same ; telephone conference w i th
Origi n al In voi ce s (11-1 8-08)
2 .7
2 .0
E PO- 83
18085
~
_.
126003
08/31/05
Emory University
James J . Mur t agh,
Jr .,
MI) - . Arbitration
Invoice Number 33105E

Page 1 1
Date Timekeeper
-------- ----------
Hou rs
electronic discovery ; revise
proposed scheduling order
47/24/D5 JC Hill
Conference with T . Wozniak

regarding motion for interim
relief ; review arbitration rules
and draft motion for interim
relief ; revise memorandum in
support of motion to make payment
into escrow account
2.6
Q7/20/05 TD Woz r_iak
Telephone conference with J .

Breen an d D elo i tte t o resolve
e-discovery issues and exped i te
production of computer
information
1 .6
Draft list o f docu m ents 't o send

to the arb i trator ; review Emory
web site for relevant e- ma ?l ;
compi le information perta i n i ng to
interrogatory and discovery
requests
2 .4
07/21/05 DG Anderson Res e a r c h Arbitrator Deane's

background and compile list and
docket sheets of all Emoryrelated cases he has worked on ;
cite check and proof brief to the
arbitrator
07/21/05 2D W o zniak
07/21/05
Conference with B . Maxra.son, T . ~

Duffield, and J' . Hill regarding
discovery strategy ; e-mails with
plaintiff's counsel and Grady's
counsel regarding arbitrators ;
telephone conference with
Plaintiff's counsel and potential
arbitrator regarding engagement
and payment of settlement funds
into escrow accauzxt : e-mails
regarding potential arbitrators ;
review Plaintiff's comments on
scheduling order ; revise same
?"C Duffield Conference with B .

Clark-Nlorrisor,, T : WQZni.ak and J .
Hill regarding discovery strategy
and notentaaJl arbitrator, revise
Emory University's motion to pay
5 .3
7-3
5 .5
EPO - 84
18085
12600 James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD- - Arbitration pages 12
08/31/05
33058
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
--------------------settlement funds into escrow
account ; prepare action items
list for written discovery and
depositions
0 7 /21/ 0 5
JC Hill Conference with B . Clark-Morrison 5 .3

regarding discovery strategy and
potential arbitrators ; conference
with T . bufrield regarding
action-items and firm escrow
account issue ; telephone
conference with T . Eichelberger
regarding payment options ; revise
memorandum in support of interim
relief
0 7/22/p5 DG Anderson
Compile documents to foi-ward to

arbitrator ; proof and cite check
brief to the arbitrator
07122/05 TD Wozniak
Revise scheduling order ; revise

order granting motion to compel
arbitration ; revise discovery
plan ; telephone conference with
arbitrator and opposing counsel
regarding arbitration schedule
and payment of settlement funds
into an escrow account ; telephone
regarding same
3 .3
07/22/,05
Revise interrogatories and

document requests to Plaintiff in
arbitration and review pleadings
in connection with same ; discuss
third party subpoenas with D .
Anderson ; prepare memo to file
regarding discovery plan
8 .6
Research to retrieve list of all

cases involving Emory University
assigned to Magistrate Richard
Deans
0 .2
0.
TC Duffield
07/22/05 M Fvrit t
.7
07/22/05 J C Hill Revise memorandum for payment of 3 .4

money into escrow account ; review
discovery plan ; conference with
T . Duffield regarding discovery
O r i ginal Invoices (11-18-08)
EPO - 85

18085
129003
James v . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 13
08/31/05
Date
07/23/05
331052
Timekeeper
Hours
DG Anderson Revise list of documents to send 0 .5
to Mr . Deane
07/24j05 DG Anderson
Locate and compile documents to

send to Arbitrator Deane
4 .0
07/24/05
J C Hill
Research equitable relief in

arbitration
1 .7
07/25/ 05
L Duarte
Prepare pleading documents to be

sent to arbitrator
1 .6
Review and revise petition to

arbitrator to pay money into
escrow account ; telephone
regarding discovery plan ;
telephone conference with
sc heduling order ; telephone
conference with Arbitrator and
plaintiff's counsel regarding
temporary payment of settlement
funds into :{&S's escrow account ;
eWmails regarding process for
same
3 .2
Q ? /25/OS TD Wozniak
.. .
07/25/05 JC Hill Conference with T . Duffield 3 .6

regarding Plaintiff's request for
appellate review of motion to
compel ; research equitable relief
remedies
~T
07/25/05 DG Anderson Proof, Drepare and serve proposed 7 .2
order granting Defendants' motion
to compel, proof consent
scheduling order ; compile
documents to send to Arbitrator
Deans and have same delivered
07/25/05
TC Duffield
Telephone conference with T .

Wozniak and B . Clark-Morrison
regarding discovery ; telephone
conference with J . Green
regarding discovery schedule ;
finalize discovery schedule and
proposed order granting motion to
compel arbitration and coordinate
filing with court ; revise memo of
law in support of petition to pay
6,2
EPO- 86

126003
James J . Murtagh, .,
Jr , MD - Arbitration
08/31/05
Invoice Number 33105$

Page 14
Dale Timekeeper
-------- -------------------
Hours
settlement funds into escrow
accou nt ; r ev iew Plaintiff's
request to certify or d er granting
motion to compel arbitration ;
discuss third party subpoenas
with D . Anderson
07/26/05
TD Wo zniak
07/26/05
,
DG Anderson
Revise petition to pay settlement

amounts into escrow account ;
review and revise second
interrogatories to Plaintiff ;
Morrison regarding document
subpoenas
2 .1
Prepare, file and serve consent

sAeduling order and petition for
immediate interim relief
2 .3
07/26/05 L7 C Hill
Rev i ew brief regarding .waiver

arguments ; research regarding
wa iver arguments ; telephone
conference wi th T . Harris,
regarding equi table remedies ;
conference with T . Duf fi. eld
regard ing response to Plaintiff's
motion to certify mot i on to
compel arb i trat i on order ;
research standard under
interlocutory appeal statute
8 .3
07/26/05 TC Dutfield
Finalize and serve petition to

--' 10 .9
pay settlement funds into escrow ;
Wozniak and B . Clark-Morrison
regarding discovery plan ; prepare
email to team regarding discovery
plan ; review research regarding
interlocutory appeal of order
granting motion to compel
arbitration and draft response to
Plaintiff's motion to certify
court's order granting motion to
compel arbitration
p7J27/Q5 TD Wozniak Conference with T . Duffield

regarding argument in response to
Plaintiff's request to certify
case for appeal ; review and
revise Emory Hea].thcare 'g
Ori ginal Invo ices (11-18-08)
1 .6
EPO- 87

1260D3 James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 15
08/31/05
331nsa
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
------------------------interrogatories and-document
rectuests to Plaintiff regarding
Plaintiff's claims
07/27/05 JC Hill
Research interlocutory appeal

cases in Georgia ; review
equitable remedies research
3 .6
Telephone call with J . Breen

regarding releases for reference
request information and medical
history ; research and draft
oppos ition to Plaintiff's request
to certify order granting motion
to compel arbitration ; revise
discovery requests to Murtagh
7 .3
07/26/ 05
Set up system for confirming

email delivery of pleadings and
other documents ; telephone
conference with Breen' s and
Eichelberger's secretaries to
confirm delivery of first
discovery requests ; update
deadlines chart
1 .4
Review and revise Bmory's

response to Plaintiff's document
requests ; telephone calls
1 .7
DG Anderson
L_.J
D"7/28/D5 TD Wozniak
07/28/05 T C I?uffield Finalize Emory Healthcare's firsts 6 .9

request to Plaintiff ; correspond
with B . Clark-Morrison regarding
same ; revise opposition to
Plaintiff's request that court
certify order compelling
arbitration
07/28/05
JC Hill Research additional counterclaims 4 .5

for us to assert ; research
whether attorneys' fees and
additional costs are available
damages ; conference with m .
Dufield regarding waiver caselaw
07/29/05
TD Wozniak Telephone conference with B .

Morrison regarding response to
Plaintiff's request to certify
Original I nvoices (11 -1 8-08)
1 .9
EPO- 88

126003
James J . Murtagh, fir . ,
08/31/05
Invoice Number
Page 16
V0 - Arbitration
331058
Hours
Date Timekeeper
-------- ---------case for appeal ; review and
revise same ; review responses to
review plaintiff's letter
being produced
07/9/05
TC :Uuffie ld
Revise Emory's responses to

Murtagka's first request for
documents and things ; telephone
call with Plaintiff's counsel
regarding status of production of
computer files ; review letter
from Plaintiff's counsel
regarding same ; revise opposition
to Plaintiff's request that court
certify oxder compelling
arbitration ; attention to
voicemails from B . Clark-Morrison
regarding Emery IT issues and
follow-un with G . Johnson
9.7
07/29/05 G Johnson

issues with T . Duffield and
client
1 .2
o7/2g/o5
Research attorneys' fees issue in

breach of contract actions
0 .9
0~
J C Hill
TOTAL HOURS
TIMEKEEPER TIME SUMMARY :

Timekeeper
------------------------Michael w, Johnston
Todd D . Wozniak
Todd C . Duffield
Jennifer C . Hill
Debra G . Anderson
Sandy R . Burney
Lisa Duarte
Maureen EVritt
Glenn Johnson
416 .0
Hours
,2_n
82,8
169 .2
96 .4
56 .1
2
1
1
3
.7
.6
.0
_8
. :
~
Original Invoices ( 1 1- 18-08)
E PO- 89
18085
Emory Un i versity
126003 James J . Murtagh, Jr . . , MD - Arbitrat i on
oal 3 a./o5
CURRENT FEES

Page 17
97,116-48
FOR COS TS ADVANCED AND 8X L'tNSSS INCURRED :
07 /,31/OS
07/31/05
07/37./05
0731/05
07/31/05
07/08/05
Long Distance Prone Calls-ATL

Telecopy/Telex-ATL
Duplicating Costs-AIL
Computer Research-Lexis/Westlaw-A
Support Staff Overtime-AIL
Business Meals T . Duffield 6/ 2 8,
7/5/05 ATL-Dinner w/Hi7.3.
07/31/05
Computer Research
07/18/05
Filing FA(~ W . C . Blathers,
RPR-SilcGing 'Lee for hearing held
on 7/14/05
07/18/05 Filing Fee W . C . Blathers,
RPR-Payment for expedited order
issued in case
05/1705 Document Delivery Georgia
Messenger 5exvice, Inc .
06/17/05
07/01/05
07/22/05
07/29/05
05/27/05
Duplicating Costs IKON Office
Solutions - Document copies
07/15/05 Duplicating Costs XXbN office
Solutions -flow-up boards for
Hearing on July 14, 2005
0,30
7 .00
459
3,933
702
32
.94
.00
.00
.63
1Q_24
66 .78
12 .50
11 .75
73 .39
51 .50
23 .50
32,25
5023
1,1a8 .D$
-----------?,D2S . 9 S
CURRENT EXPENSES
TOTAL AMOUiv'T OF 2RIS INVOICE
Origina l Invoices (11-18-08)
104,142 .43
EPO- 90
Remit 70 :
KING & S PALD I NG Up
P .4. Box 11 6 133

Aftu, GA 30361-6133
Tc16pboa et (dQ4) $3 2- 4bOp
FEDFJtAt. J_X'Y . NO, iC-D52A733
BY wazF : SUNT)WST BANK

.ADA NO-. 061 OW 104
5wFF7': SN 7'FLlT53A
AC C T NO ; 6 8D031?4 75
MBSCs INDICATE IM1YOICE NLIN!$ 6R ON RMSYTaX{9
Emory University
1 0 1 Administration Building
Atlanta, GA 30322
Invoice Numb e r
335139
Invoice Da te 10/04/05
client Numbe r
18 0 8 5
Matter Number 12600 3
Re : James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration

---------------- -------------------------------------------------------
FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES R~TDERED TH P OiTGF] 08f3 1 /05 :

Date
Tim e k ee per
-------- ---------DG
V
aa/a
os
Anderson
aQUxs
Ci t e check, pxoo t , file and serve 4 .3
Emory ' s response to . plaintiff's
request t o certify f o r immediate
appell at e review its order
granting Defendant's motion to
arbitrate ; confirm recei p t'of
same with Breen and E ichelb e xges f
review Emoxy ' s e. -mazl o from
Emory's e - ma i l filter
08 /01/05
TC Duffield Fina l ize brief in opposition to 1 .2

Plaintiff's r e q ues t to certify
order compelling arbitratio n ;
caaxdinate fi l ing and servi c e of
same ; review select e-rnails
from
Emory e-mail f .ilter

OS / d 1f Q5
TD Wozniak Revise response to plaintiff's 0 . 3

motion f or interl ocutory appeal
o8/tea/o5 iC Hill
Conf e rence with T . Du f field

regarding amending counrerclaim6 ;
revise memorandum regarding
potential remedies
08/02/05 T C Duff ie l. d Revi ew and rev i se memorandum

regarding legal theories for .
1 .6
3 .1
stopping payment und e r the

Poi FiVENT IS D VE UPON RE C.E,GPx` OF INVOICE
O riginal Invoi ces (11-18-08)
EPO- 91
1B0$5 Emory University

126003 Jam es a . Murt agh,
ID/04/05
Jr . , MD - Arbitration
Invoice Number 3~5 :1 3g

Page 2
Date Timeke e p er
-------- ----------
Houxs
settlement agreement ; correspond
with Deloitte regarding
production copy of Murtagh-s
computer files ; telephone
conference with Sreen4s office
r6gaTding status of production
copy ; prepare draft release for
reference request information and
medical information
OB/43/D5 DG Andereon
Conference w i th T . Duff i e l d
regarding action items and
subpae aa S t aomp 4 l. e document
responsive to Plaintiff,5
document requests
2,2
08/03/05
Cvxx e sporxd with Dejoitte

regarding receipt of re spon siv e
copy 'f ram 8reen ; meet w i th D .
Anderson to discuss discovery
action, items ; review Muxtagh's
response to Emory-s petition to
pay settlement payments into
escrow ; outline reply i s sue s
2 .6
Review Flailitiff,s response to

motio n to pay settlement funds
into escrow account
0 .4
48/o4/OS DG Anderson Compile documents responsive to

Plaintiff's document requestsi
keyaite and shepardize cases
cited by Plaintiff in response
brief
0 .8
TC Duff ield
08833{n5 JC Hill
08/04/05
TC Driffield
Review and distinguish cases

ei t~e d in Plaintiff's response to
R mory ' s petition to pay funds
into escrow ; discuss arguments
for reply brief with T . Wozniak ;
. draft reply t o murtagh's
response ; prepare e -mail to
Arbitrator Deane requesting oral
confernece on Emdxy' s petition
and Murtagh' s response
5 .8
08/04/05 JC Hill Conference w i th T . Du ffie ld

regarding -reply to Plaintiff is
resp onn e to motion fo r payment
into an escrow account ; research
3 .8
EPO - 92
1$OSS Emory University Invoice Number

1 260 0 3 James L7 . Murta!ah, Jr,, MD - Arbitration Page 3
lfl/i34/~5
Date Timekeeper
-------- -------------------
33513,9
Hours
elements of defamation and libel
for amended counterclaims ; draft
letter to Arbitrator outlining
additional counter claims against
Plaintiff in arbitration
os/o 4 l n5 TD Wozn i ak
Telephone conference with T .

0 .9
Du f f i. e l d regard i ng reply in
8 uppar t o f pe t i ti on to pay money
into escrow a ccount and request
for oral argume nt ; review a-mails
regarding same
C18/05/ a 5 DG Anderson
comp i le reference letter

materials for revie w and
d i scovery ' plan
08/05fQS TC Dufrield
Review signed orders from Fudge 8 .2

Tusan ; correspond via e-mail with
Deloitte regarding status of
responsive copy ; follow-up with
S . pfahl regarding R . Deane's
involvement in qui tam action,,
regarding arguments for reply to
Plaintiff's response to Emory's
petition to pay settlement funds
into escrow account ; drat same
08/05/05
J Q Hill Draft letter to Arbitrator and

counsel regarding additional
counterclaims asserted key Emory
in arbitration ; confexence with
T . I>uffield regarding damages
theories for Emory
06/05/US
TD Wozniak Review e-mail from B . Morrison ;

meet with T . Duffield regarding
arguments for reply brief and
discovery strategy
08/07/05 7v Wozniak
Review e-mails regarding

conference with the Arbitrator
0 .8
1 .3
4 .6
2 .9
and newly posted Now

Criminologist articlex ; review
plaintiff's r,--sponse to petition
to pay money into escrow account ;
review and revise reply to game
Origina l Invoices ( 11 -1 8-08)
E PO- 9 3
Emory University
18085
126003
3 James J . Muztagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration
3. 0/Oa/Q5
Daze Timekeeper
-------- ---------QSJ08/Q5 JC Hill
Hours
R eview and revise memora n dum
regarding remedies to stop
payment under t he settlement
a Yr e eTnerit
1.6
Revise reply in support of paying

inoney Into escrow
1 .0
Revise reply in support of

petition to p ay sett l ement f u nds
into escrow ; review prior
litigat ion pleadings in
connection with same ; telephone
call with B . Morrison regarding
same ; e - m aiZ s w i th A e 1 o i r LL
regarding pyoduction of
responsive copy and follow-tip
wi t h J . green reg arding same ;
forward releases for m edi ca l
information and employment
information to J, Breen for
execution by Murt agh ; review
-recent e-mail postings by Grady
coalition
7 .9
08/09/05 i C Hill
C onfex e nce With T . Du fflcald

regarding discovery items ; review
articles from websites
1 .1
os/09/p5 TD Wozn1 ak
Review and revise repl y in

3 .5
support Q9 pet ition to pay funds
into escrow ; review a-mails from
X . Alexander and B . Morrison
regarding discovery responses ;
review newly posted Internet
articles
4 8 JD9/o5 TC Duff ield
Review Chronicle of Higher

Education articles regard i ng
Murtagh ; con f erence with T .
wa mi ak arguments to be made in
reply to pay settlement funds
into escrow ; revise reply brief ;
conference ca l l with B . Morwi s o n
regarding Emory's discovery
; Zo 11 ow-up with J .
responses
Breen acid Deloitte r egarding
responsive copy of Murtag'h"s
computer ; conmider additional
discovery requests to Plaintiff
08/08/05
LJ
Invo i c e N umbe r 3 35 1 39
.Page 4
TD Wozniak
Original I nvoices ( 11 -1 8-08)
10 .5
E P O- 9 4
18085
0 .-
Emory University
126003 James LT . Muxtagh, Jr ., MI) - Arbitration

10/04/05

Page 5
Date
Timekeeper
-------- ----------
Hours
and discuss same with s . Hill ;
meet with B . Smith from Deloitta,
to receive responsive copy and
forward copy to T . Ezchelberger ;
discuss logistics of review of
Murtagh's computer files with G .
Johnson
L18/ 1 D/45
JC Hill Telephone conference regard"q

third-party subpoenas ; research
computer systems protection act
regarding potential claims
against Plaintiff ; telephone
conference regarding
disparagement claims ; revise
letter to arbitrator and counsel
regarding counterclaims ; review
postings on internet ; research
regarding psychiatrist/patient
privilege
08/10/05
TD O4zniak

Morrison regarding discovery
responses ; revise same ; review
,gelect documents responsive to
Plaintiff's discovery ; review
newly posted articlea on New
Criminologist websitef review
e-mails regarding electronic
discovery
n 8/1 a ffly TC Du ffie Id Finalize E maxy's reply brief i n

support of petition to pay
settlement funds into escrow ;
review additional postingig by
Murtagh off, the internet ;
conference call with s, Morrison
regarding discovery responses ;
revise discovery responses ;
review documents rece i ved from B .
Morrison ; review research
regarding disparagement claims
against Murt agh and damages
remedies ; discuss an d finalize
letter to Arbitrator amending a nd
adding claims in arbitration ;
prepare correspondence to J .
green regarding overdue discovery
and m.*dical release
3 .3
3.0
8 .?
EPO-95
18085
126003 James .T, M3lrtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 6
10/04/05
Date Timekeeper
-------- ---------0 8 /11/U5
T C DuffieJ.d
Review select computer f i les

2. 9
produced by Plain t if f ; correspond
with 37e l o i tt e regarding r e ce ipt
of addi t ional computer filles ;
forward to B . Morrison all John
Doe pleadings ; finalize e-mail t o
J . Bree n regard i ng overdue
computer d i scovery and releases
1 .1
Finalize Emory's discovery

responses
; telephone calfl with x .
Lee at Womble Carlyle regarding
possible responsive documents
from St . Paul Fire litigation ;
prepare for conference call with
Arbitrator Deaxae on Emary' s
petition to pay settlement funds
into escrow ; participate on
conference call with Arbitrator
and counsel ; conference with T .
Wozniak and T . Eichelberger
following call with Arbitrator ;
discuss logistics of computer
file review with J . Hill
8 .0
08J12/as JC H11 .1
Conference with T . Duffiela ;

review documents produced by
Plaintiff
1 .1
08/12/05
Update case notebooks
0 :3
08/12/45 TD W oz n iak
Telephone hearing with Arbitrator

Deane ; telephone conference with
Crady's counsel regarding same
~ .S
Os/13/45 TD Wozniak
Review "to do" items list
0 .4
08/14/05
JC Hill
Review documents produced by

Plaintiff
~. .1
08/15/0 5
TD Wozniak
Meet with defense team regarding

damages a~nalyses, discovery, and
computer files
~. . ~
08/15/05
J c Hill
Review insurance pleadings from

St . Paul Fire litigation at
Womble Carlyle ; meeting with
F: . 2
as/12/o5
..
Hour s
Aeva .ew select computer files

produced by murtagh
08/11/05 ic Bill
10
335139
TC Duffield
L Duarte
Original Invoices ( 11 -1 8-OS)
EP0- 96
18085
Emory University invoice Number
James J . Murtiagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 7
126003
10/04/05
335139
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
-------- ---------defense team regarding to-do
items ; conference with T .
Duffield regarding damages
issues ; review computer files
produced b y Plaintiff
08/15/05 T C D u f f ie la Telephone call w i th J . Sreen
regarding o verdue discovery ;
conference with defense team
regarding discovery action items
and additional c l aims to assert
in arbitration
3 ,3
0a/15/OS DG Arxde r son A tt end status meeting ; ]prepare 1 .8

and serve discovery responses ;
update action item list
40
06/x . 6/05 TD woz xxialc
Conference with L . Hennigar and

8 . Morrison regarding P l a .i ntift ' s
document requests ; conference
with S . Morri son regardin g
strategy
2, 2
08/16/05 cc Hill
Conference with T . Duffield

regarding discovery r e sponses ;
draft language fox r-h:L ;rd party
subpoenas f o r documents
4 .8
Review Nurtaghlu discovery

responses ; revise letter to
Arbitrator Deane regarding
EmorY's claims in arbitration,,
discuss subpoenas to third
parties with ,7 . Hill ; review
discovery plan deadlines ; review
files sent Exam Emgry' s
communications directors and
Emory Healthcare's chief
compliance officer
3 .5
Create file fax disks from

Del oi tt e
0 .2
08/17/05
JC Hill Review Plaintiff's computer files 0 .4
D8117/OS
Tr_ Duffield Telephone call to J . Breen's

office regarding overdue releases
far medical records and reference
request information
Ori g in al I n vo i ces (11-18-08)
0 .2
EPO- 97
I8085 Emory University Invoice Number

12603 James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page a
10/04/05
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
48/17/Q5 DO wAnderson Telephone conference with The

marker Group regarding serving
subpoenas in case ; review witneas
notes prepared by T . Wozniak
08/18/05
335 139
0-6
JC Hill Reseaxch regarding Plaintiff's' 4 .2

Ocommon interest," "joint
defense," and "law enforcement
assistance" objections to
discovery ; research failure to
provide medical release and
effect an emotional distress
damages claims ; conference with
T . Duff laid regarding good faith
letter discovery ; conference with
D . Andexson regarding pleadings
from St . Paul Fire litigation
OS/18/05 TC Auffield
Rev i,9e th ird . party subpoenas ;

e-mail G . Johnson regarding
review o f Plaintiff ,s computer
files ; review an d revise
t hi rd -party subpoenas ; review
discovery plan and
d deadlines
;
review Plaintiff's discovery
responses
3 .7
Wi$f 05 DG Anderson Review e-mails from Emory filter ;

. forward copies of relevant
e-mails to T . Duffa.eld ; compile
documents to be produced to
Plaintiff
1 .5
08/18/05
1 .5
TD Woznicak
L-mails regarding J . Fowler

interview and notes ; telephone
conference with S . cower
regarding obtaining discovery
from the government ; telephone
regarding same
DS /19/05
TC Duffield Revise third party subpoenas ;

discuss disc overy is s u e s and
document review i ssues w i th J .
Hill ELnd D . Anderson ; finalize
letter to Arbitrator Deane
regarding Emflry' s arbitration
c 1. a ims
Original I nvoices (11-18-fl8)
1 .3
EP O- 98
18085
126003

dames J . Muxtagh,.
.Jr
, MD - Arbitration Page 9
335139
10/04/05
Da te
a~~~~~05
Timekeeper
Hour
JC Hill E-mail correspondence with IT

team regarding electronic
discovery ; conferences with T .
Duffield regarding third party
subpoenas for document requests
08/19/OS A Whitted Review list of non-prinr-able

documents
08/19/05 DG Anderson Conference with T . Duffield
regarding document production ;
0 .3
0 .3
0 .8
compile documenta far same ; dxafCt

letter to Arbitrator and forward
same t o all parties
08/21/05 DO Anderson Pre pare
0-
form
subpoenas
0 .5
OS/22/a5 JC H i ll
Conference with A . Witted and T .

Duffield regarding review o f
electronic discovery ; e-maidl
correspondence with A . Witted
regarding review of electronic
discovery ; review murta_qh's
computer files ; conference with
D . Anderson regarding privilege
log
1 .8
08/22/45 A Whined
Review electronic documents

received
2.2
08/22/05 D G Anderson
Prepare subpoenas and commissions
2 .3
08/ z2/05 TC Duffield
Finalize third-party subpoenas

and coordinate service of same ;
telephone calfl to J . Breen
regarding discovery issues ; draft
letter to J . Breen request
supplame:ntation of discovery
responses ; conference with A .
Whitted and L7 . Hill regarding
review at Mtzxtagh'S computer
; telephones conference with
files
T . Kozniak and G . Johnson
regarding review of Murtagh,s
computer files and Emory's e-mail
files ; telephone call with T .
Nugent regarding affidavit ;
Bichel.berger regarding contacting
D . Naipohn
7 .6
EPO-99
18 0 8 5 Emory University
9~
126003
10/04/05
James J . Muz'tagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration
Invoice Number
Page 10
Date Timekeeper
-------- ----------
33 5 1 39
Hours
08/22/05 Tt7 Woz ni ak Revise subpoenas, e -malls

regarding di scove ):y requests ;
1 .1
. review and select documents for

discovery
08/22/05 G Johnson
Review electronic Toaterial

forwarded by Emory ; evaluate data
conversion options
3 .2
08/23/05
TD Wozniak
Telephone conference with S .

Cowan regarding obtaining
discovery from U . S . AttOrney5'
office and FBI ; review select
materials culled from plaintiXf'a
; review plaintiff's
computer
discovery responses ; revise
e-maidl and letter requesting
Plaintiff produce documents and
computer information sGa .l3l owed ;
MOrx'3 .Sbn
2 .4
09/23/Oa
iC Hill Review B . MOrxxson's desk files 3 .2

for documents responaive to
draft privilege log ; review newly
produced computer files
ds/a 3 /os
A Whitted t7pda.te index of electronic

documents in dCSearah with
0-
3 .1
additional conputer files

produced by Plaintiff
Q8/23/0 $
D G Anderson
Pxapaxe subpoenas and commissions

for third party discovery
5.6
as/2 3 Jo5
TC Duffield
Research procedure for requesting

documents and ~nformaticn from
the FBI and v,S, Attorney's
Office ; finalize letter to J .
Breen regarding deficient
discovery responses ;
correspondence with J . Bremen
regarding outstanding releases ;
Eichelberger regarding D ,
Na3patn} conference with J . FIi13l
regarding preparation of
privilege log and review of
3.3
Original I nvoices (11-18-08)
EPO - 10D
18085
Er.1 oXy Univers it y
invoice
Numb e r 33S13 .9
126003 dame s J . Muxtagh, sr ., MD - Arbitration Page 11
10/04/05
Hate
Timekeeper
-------- ----------
Hours
documents and subpoenas to FBI

and U, S . Attorney
Q B/ 2/ 0 5
G Johnson
Review electronic material

forwarded by client ; evaluate
data conversion options
1 .8
08/ 24/05
UC H ill
Conference with T . Duffielc3

regarding privilege log ; xeva .ew
B . Morrisnn's desk files
0 .6
08/24/05 TI) Wozniak
Review and revise subpoena to FBI

and U .S _ Attorneys' office
0. 4
08/24/05
DG Anderson
Prepare subpoenas ; compile

dacuments for document production
4 .3
0 8 /2 4 / 45
T C D u zfiel d
Finalize subpoenas and FOIL

requests to FBI and US Attorneys
office ; telephone calls to J .
Breen regarding outstanding
discovery ; review B . Morrison'S
memorandum regarding J . Fowler
prepare affidavit for J, Fowler ;
review plaintiff's affidavits
regardingr additiana3l discovery
to pursue
.
4 .3
08/25/05
A Whitted
Create database end load data

produced by Plaintiff into
Concordance
0 .5
o8/2S/v5 TD W o zn i ak
Revisee e-mail-to J . green

regarding overdue discovery ; meet
w~.'th m . Aufield regarding
Plaintiff's claim to psychiatrist
-patient privilege ; e-mails with
B . Mox'risan regarding discovery
issues
0 .9
0e/25/o 5
Tc H111
Review documents in concordance

database
0 .6
0 S/25/ a 5
DG Andersen
Prepare documer=s to be produced ;

prepare subpoenas to Chi-rd
parties for documents
4.8
Telephone calls with Breen law

firm to coordinate exchange of
documents ; telephone call with T .
7 .3
0.
a8/25Jd5 TC Duffield
LJ
Orig i n a l Invoices (11-18-08)
E PO- 1 0 1
IS a85 Emory University

12,5003
10/04/05

Page 12
Hours
Da t e Time keep er
-------- ------- Nugent regarding deposition and
subpoena for documents ; telephone
call with T . Eichelberger to
discuss deposition dates for T .
Nugent ; conference with T .
Wozniak regarding var4ous
discovery issues and response to
J . Breen e-mail regarding
discovery ; review research
regarding waiver of
psych3.atri.9t-patent privilege :
prepare response to J . green
e-mail ; revise affidavit for J .
Fawler and forward to B . Morrison
08/26/05
L _J
JC Hill Conference wi th T . Duffia ld and

D . Anderson regarding to-do
items ; review and tag responsive
r i l es in concordance data base
08/26/05 TD Wozniak Revi ew and revise e-ma il s

regarding plai.ntiffls overdue
discovery
1.7
0 .3
DB/2 6 J5 A Whited Update Concordance database with 0 .7

additional computer files
produced by Plaintiff
08/26105
DG Anderson Conference with T . Duffield to 3 .2

discuss privilege log ; prepare
subpoenas for production of
documents ; prepare documents to
be produced
X 8 /2 6 /05 T C Duffield
Conference with J . Hill and D .

Anderson regarding discovery
issues and review o f Muxtugh
files ; review research regaraing
whether discover privilege
exists in Georgia for information
provided to law enforcement
officials ; review Murrtagh's
affidavits and discovery
responses ; telephone calls from
Breen law firm regarding exchange
of discavcry ; prepare additional
subpoenas, telephone conference
with T . Nugent regarding subpoena
for documents
4 .2
~ ~.
EPO- 102
L _J
X8085
Emory Un i v e rsit y
126003
James J . muxtagh,.,
Jr KD - Arbitration Page 13
10/04/05
Date Timekeepe :c
Hours
---------08/29105 TD Wozrii ak Review Select materials produced 0 .6
by plaintiff ; e- M a i 1s regarding
Plaintiff's contacts to
Arb i trat or , s office
08/29/05
L Duarte Create third party document 2 .4

notebook, index and files
o6 / 29j05 DG Anderson Prepare subpoenas ; coacrespoadence 1 .0

with court reporter regarding
transcript of July 14 hearing
Is
08/29f 05
TC Dukfield
Telephone calls with J . Breezyn

regarding discovery responses,
releases, an d production of
remaining computer files ;
finalize third party vubpoanas ;
prepare case status report ;
revieww and analyze Plaintiff's
document production ; forward
intorestl .Ilg e-mails to B .
Marxison
7 .4
Q8f29/ 0 5
JC Hill
Review St .
materials
documents
discovery
1 .8
08/30/05
TD Wozniak Telephone conference with

arbitrator regarding Plaintiff's
calling rzis office ; review select
ewmails produced by Plaintiff ;
Morrison regarding same
1 .1
08/30/05
A Whitted Rxepare e-mail data for document

review
0 .6
D 8 /30/05
DG Anderson
Serve third party subpoenas for

n of documents
prnduct i, on
2 .2
08/30/05
?'C Duffield

Morrison regarding conference
call with Arbitrator and
Plaintiff's docuoient production,
forward various e-mails from
Murtagh's document production to
B . Morrison ; forward Muxt&gh 1s
entire document production to T .
Eichelbergex : review Murtagh's
1 .2
Paul Fire litigation

for responsive
to plaintifl,s
requests
EPO- 103
18085
Emary University Invoice Number
126003
James J . Murtagh, %7r . . MD - Arbitration Page 14
10/04/05
33513
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
-------- ---------document production and determine
additional areas of discovery
08J30/fl5 JC Hill
Review St . Paul -Fire Litigation

pleadings for documents
respons~ve to Plaintiff's first
request far documents
1 .2
08/31/05 A Wh itted
Setup iConect database for remote

user
0 .7
08/31/05 TC Duf field
Prepare letter to T . NugenC

regarding deposition ; coordinate
remote access to concordance for
B . Morrison ; review Plaintiff's
third-party discovery requests to
reference requestors and
correspond with B . Morrison
regarding game ; review select
portions of St . Paul Fire
litigation pleadings for
potential breaches of the
settlement agreement
1.5
08/3 1 I05 JC Hill
Review pleadings from sr . Paul

Fire litigation
0.3
d$/31/05 L Du ar t e
Update third party document

notebooks
0 .3
TOTAL HOURS
TIMEKBEPE$ TIME SUMMARYTimekeeper

------------------------Todd D . Wozniak
Todd C . I7uffield
Jennifer C . Hail
Glenn Johnson
Debra G . Anderson
Lisa Duarte
Aisha Whitted
C9JRRP.NT FEES
231 .1
Hour s
26 . 7
107 .7
43 .7
5 .0
36 .9
3 .0
B,1
50,295 .15
11
Origi n al Invoices (1 1 - 1 8-08)
EPp - 1U4
18085 ftory University

12 6 003- James J, Murtagh, Jr ., NID - Arbitration
1 Df0a/45
Invoice number
Page 15
3351,39
F()R COSTS ADV ANCED AND EXPENSES INCURRED :

08/31/0S
08/31/05
08/31/U5
D S/31/ 0 5
08/31/OS
08/31/05
OS/31/05
08/31/05
OR/31/05
08/29/05
ca#2alo 5
Q8/ 0 S/fly
08/12/05
08/26/05
08/12/05
Long Distance Phone Calls-AxL

Long Distance Phone Calls-WDC
TelecopY/Te7.ex--ATi1
Te1 ecalaYlTe 1 .ex-WDC
Postage/Ex-press Maid-ATL
Duplicating Costs-ATL
Duplicating Costs-WDC
CtimpULer Research-x,exis/wesLl.aw-A
Computer Research
Court Reporter Wynette C .
Slathers, RPR - Transcript of
July 14, 2005 hearing
Outside Counsel Fees Photocopy
and shipping charges - Womble
Carlylr Sandxidge & Rice
messenger Service, Inc .
Messenger Service . Tnc_
TelephonelConference Calls T .
DuZrield, 8 / 2 /O5 Cell phone
charges
CURRENT EXPENSES
TOTAL AMOU NT OF THIS
I N VO I CE
O riginal I nvoi ces (11-18-08)
0
0
13
15
4
.80
.30
.25
.45
.88
612 .10
0 .30
1,415 .43
9 .13
160 .60
2 Q 7 .95
2 5 .25
32 .2
43 .2 1
21 .35
-----------2,525 .45
52,520 .20
EPO- 105
Reavt To :
KING & S P AL DZN GLLP
P .O . Bax 116233
Azlama, GA 3D368-6l33
Telep2ione; (4404) 572-:b00
FSDER4 L ] . D.?+ U.58-0520t53
BY WIRE: SUNTRUST BANK
"
ABA NO ; 061 000 104
sNvW r: snTra Us3A
ACCT NO : 56E 303 3 347 5

PLEA INDICATE L'~ PO1CE NUMBER U4 REMv7 ' YJiNm
Emory University
Invoice -Number
336998
Invoice Date 10/20/05
Client Number 18085
Matter dumber 1 2 600 3

Atlanta, GA 30322
Re ; James J . Murtagh, Jr . , MD - Arbitration

-----------------------------------------------------------------------FOR PRfJrE oB'ZOTvnL SERVICES 'REiQDMED THROUGH 09/3D/05 . Daze Timekeeper
-------- ---------09/01/05
TD Wozniak
o 51a1/os ?'c Duf fxe2d
09/01/QS ,7C Iii11

09/o 1 JoS
Hours
Review plas ritiT'-' s counsel ' s
e-mail regarding medical and
educational releases ; conference
call regarding review and
production of Emory electronic
?nformation ; telephone conference
With B . Morrison regarding same
0 .9
conference w i th (i . JO~51150P
n
regarding conversion and review
of Emory e-mail mailboxes ;
several telephone calls from N .
Stafford regarding releases and
amended complaint ; prepare
correspondence to J . Breen
regarding reference request
inquiries ; review and analyze fir,
Murtagh's amended complaint,
prepare e-mail to B . Morri son ;
revise letter to J . Breen
requesting supplementation of Dr .
Murtagh's discovery responses
4 .5
Review Dr . Murtsgh 's most recent

comr>uter file Droduction
?. 7
DG Anderson Prepare, file and serve notice o-F 1,2

service of Subpoenas
rArWENrls DUE UPON RECErp r oF INVOICE
ATLANTA HOUSTON . LONDON
NEW YORK . WASF31?dGT'OT', 2) .C .
Ori g i nal I nvo ices ( 11-18 -Q 8)
EPO - 1 06
18085 Emory University Invoice dumber

126003
James C . Murtagh, Jr ., NiD - Arbitration Page 2
10/20/05
Date Timekeepex
-------- ----------
R our s
09f 0 z/05 A Whitted

rega rd ing Emory e-mail data
processing .
0 .4
09/02/05 J C Fill
Review Dr . Muxtagh's computer

file production for relevan t
documents ; review amended
complaint ; create chart of St .
Paul ire litigation pleadings
responsive to Dr . Murtagh's
discovery requests potentially
relevant to claims
5 .4
prepare subpoena for deposition

c3X1C3d notice of service of subpoena
1 .2
09/02/05 A Whitted
Review sammle of processed data
0 .1
fl9/0 5 /05
j C Hill
Review Dr . Nlurtagh`s computer

f ile
2 .1
0 9 1 D5/45
DG Anderson
Prepare document subpoena for

George Anderson ; update third
party document'-files
1 .6
Letter to Dr . Murtahg's counsel

regarding deficient" discovery
responses ; review amended
complaint response discuss
response with T . Wozniak ; prepare
weekly status report for B .
Morrison ; telephone call with N .
Stafford regarding various
discovery issues and filing Dr .
Mu Ytagh's amendedd complaint ;
9 .5
draft answer to amended

complaint ; review research
regarding statute of limitations
for fraudulent inducement cla-i'm
0 9 /o6/as
336998
0-C Hill
Research regarding fraudulent

inducement claim and possibility
of . rescission in conjunction with
merger clause ; review Dr .
5 .2
Murtagh's e-mail files ; complete

chart nn 6L . Paul Fire pleaclings
with relevance to fir . I~furLagh's
amended complaint
Origi nal Invoices (11-18-08)
EPO- 107
L J
18b85
126003
lOf 2 4/05

Date Timekeeper
09/06/05 TD 'Wozniak
33699E
Fours
Review plaantii f's amended
complaint ; telephone
'
conference
with T . Duffield regarding answer
and motion to compel arbitration ;
e-mails regarding plaintiff's
1 .5
book "Blue ;
Codes"
a-mails with
independent expert regarding
problems with p l ainti f f's e-mail
production
09/07/05
Review Plaintiff's amended

complaint and amended arbitration
demand ; telephone conference with
B . Nor_r ;son regarding amended
complaint., motion to compel
arbitration 0r dismiss same, and
pe'tition to require Plaintiff to
return settlement funds ; review
additional materials produced by
plaintiff ; review end revise
letter Xec?raesting plaintiff
supplement discovery responses
3 .6
Telephone T . Wozniak regarding

Prime Paint issue and whether
rescission claims must be
arbitrated
0 .8
Schedule A, Nugent deposition ;

check on status off consent
protective order ; make
arrangements to get copy of disk
of hearing transcript from court
reporter ; compile documents f ax
J . Hill to review for privilege
log
2 .3
0 9 / 07/OS
Conference call with B . Morrison

and T . Wozniak regarding
discove :~-y issues and response to
Dr . Murtagh's amended comvlaint ;
review select pleadings from
underlying litigation that
-reference peer review process ;
follow-up with J . Breen regarding
various outstanding discovery
issues ; telephone call with N .
Stafford regarding production of
document-s ; review fir . Nurtzgh-'s
recent discovery responses ;
6 .4
09/07/05
...
TD Wozniak
ME R o s s
T C Duffield
Original Invoices (11-18-0 8 )
EPO- 108
W-
I8085 Emory University

126003
James J . Murtagh, fix ., tai. Arbitration
10/20/05
Date' Timekeeper
-------- ----------
Invoice Number
Page 4
Hours
correspond with Deloitte
regarding computer file
production
09/07/05 JC Hill
Review underlying litigation

pleadings for references to Deer
review processes
2 .3
09/07/05 -A Whitted
Convert sample of Emory e-mail

stores
0 .3
09f08/65 TD Wozniak
Telephone cor_fEerence with K .

Alexander and B . Morrison
regarding media inquiry ; review
plaintiff's response to second
discovery requests ; telephone
conference with Gxady' s counsel
regarding strategy and peer
review process issues ; review new
Grady Coalition web posting ; meet
with T . 17uffield regarding
modifications to discovery plan
3 .1
09/08/05
T C Duffield
09/08/05 jC Hill
09/08/ 05
A Whined
Draft answer to amended

complaint ; review Dr . Murtagh's
attzchments to amended complaint
and forward to B . Morrisan;
Follow-up with N . Stafford
regarding Dr . Murtagh'S second
document n?:oduction ; finalize
letter regarding deficiencies
with Dr . Murtagh's first
discovery responses ; conference
call with T . Eichelberger
regarding Dr . Murtagh's amended
complaint and discovery
responses ; review e-mails in
e-mail filter mailbox and recent
internet postings on the new
criminologist website
6 .6
Review transcripts -from

underlying litigation for terms
responsive to Dr, Murtagh's
allegations in amendedd complaint
1 , $
Prepare analysis of Emory e-mail

conversion prpj ect
0 .2
O riginal Invoi ce s (11-18-08)
EP O- 1 09
336998
0 .
?8085 Emory University invoice Number

320'00 James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 5
33695E
1 o/2ol0 5
Date
T imekeeper
---------09/08/05 DO A1der so31
0 9f0/O5 TC3uffie?d
Hours
Review Emery internal e-mails for
relevant e-mails ; contact court
to determine if Plaintiff piled
amended complaint and if the
protective order in the case had
been filled
2 .2
Telephone call from FBI regarding

subpoena ; telephone call with B .
Hinnant regarding rescheduling T .
Nugent deposition ; telephone
5 .3
calls with al`l counsel of record

to reschedule T . Nugent
deposition ; prepare letter to B .
Hi.nnar!t regarding rescheduled
.deposition and subpoena document
production ; coordinate service of
letters/releases for job
reference request information ;
review recent internet postings,
research regarding arbitrability
of claim -for fraudulent
inducement in connection with
drafting motion to compel
arbitration' of amended ca-Lnp1FIn't
09/09/05
JC Hill
D9/D9/05 DG Anderson
09/09/05 . TD tq azni ak
0 --
09/i G/ 0 5
D G Anderson
Review Dr . Murtagh's e-mail

production
3 .2
Prepare reference letter requests

for p1"OC211 CL ]. pIn of docum e nts ;
obtain articles from the New
Criminologist webs-ite ; revie w and
respond to e-mails regarding
arrangements for T . Nugent
de po si t ion ; review and respond to
,vvicemails from FBI ; co=iZc
documents for privilege re-view
6 .2
Review e-mails with indeoe-ndent

expert regarding plaintiff's
e-mail ;
production
telephone
Conference with G . Johnson
regarding review and conversion
of Emory's e-mails ; meet with T .
7ufiie?d. regarding T . -Nvgent
deposition
Pr epa r e
e,_ret _req_ru ests. = ax
O rigi n al Inv oices ( 11 - 18-O S )
i _4
0 .5
APO-110
i8o85 Emory University

126003
10/20/05
Date Timekeeper
-------- -------------------
Invoice Number
Page 6
Hours
production o f documents to
reference seekers
09/11/05
JC Hill
Review interne t postings, review

file for privilege log and update
privilege log
1 .4
09/ 1 2 / 05
JC Hill
Review discovery responses from

underlying litigation ; review
exhibits to plaintiff Is amended
Complaint ; review Plaintiff's
manuscr-i'Dt for Blue codes for
violations of settlement
agreement ; outline motion far
reconsideration- brief to
arbitrator
5 .8
09/12/05
MW Johnston

regarding strategy
1.1
09/12/05
TD Wozniak
review e-mail sent by new

criminologist to ErnoYy employees ;
e-mails with B . Morrison
regarding same ; analyze options
regarding same ; meet with M .
Johnston regarding litigation
options ; telephone conference
with B . Morrison regarding
litigation and discovery options ;
review plaintiff's amended
complaint ; e-mails regarding
electronic discovery ; meet with
defense team regarding "to do"
items
a .1
09/12/05 DG Anderson Conference with defense team 2 .2

regarding actiop items list,
.
be
4 9 /12f0 5
filed
TC Duffield
336998
upcoming motions, and answer to

7 contact MLQ regarding
status of serving subpoenas ;
update subpoena chart
Conference call with B . Morrison

and T . WQzniak to discuss amended
complaint and strategy for
dealing with recent New
Criminologist postings ; research
Eleventh Circuit law regarding
arbitrability of fraudulent
inducement claims ; telephone call
Ori ginal Invoices ( 11 - 18-08)
11,E
EPO- 111
11
18085 .
Emory University
1250( } 3
James J . Murtagh, Jr ., VD - Arbitration
10/20/05
Da t e
invoice Number
Page 7
Timekeeper
Hours
to Breenn law firm regarding
outstanding discovery and draft
follow-up letter ; telephone call
from T . Nugent regarding
deposition and document
production ; draft letter to T .
Nugent's counsel regarding direct
communication with T . Nugent ;
telephone call from 3 . Skellie
regarding request for extension
of time to respond to document
subpoena T attention to discovery
plan and upcoming discovery
; follow-uD with B .
deadlines
Marrisnn and in-house IT group
regarding conversion of Fmory
e-snails
09/ 12/05
A Thh?ti ed
Prepare Emory e-ma r s for

conversion to PS T -format
2 .7
09/13/05
R 3e??rett
Conference with defense team

regarding upcoming motions and
action .items ; outline issues -for
motion to comDel discovery
1 .4
D9/13/05 LTC Hill Conference with defense te am ;

3 .7
review client documents for
pr i vi l ege log ; review E'B l ue
-- Codes" manuscript for breaches of settlement agreement
09/13/05
09/13/05
TD Wozniak

2 .3
Morrn san regarding litigation
options and potential petition
for sanctior_s ; review and revise
answer to amended complaint ; meet
with defense team regarding
answer to amended comp?a?nt,
motion to coupel arbitration,
motions to compel discovery,
petition to repay settlement
ilIS1C~5~ and other action items
IDG Anderson Conference with defense team

regarding motions to dismiss ;
prepare documents to b e dates
labeled
O riginal Invoices ( 11 - 18 -08)
4 .3
EP O- 112
3369E
18085 memory Una .lrersiLy Invoice Number

126003
James v . Murtagh, Jr ., I4D - Arbitration Page 8
10/20/05
Date Timekeeper
-------- ---------09/13fn5 TC Duffield
Hours
Review Dr . Mur t agh's second
document produ ct i on ; r e s e arch and
draft-motion to compel
arbitra ti on of amended complain ;
revise answer to amended
; attent i on to
complaint
correspondence - ~rorn opposing
counsel and R . . Marshall
?0 . 6
09/ 13/05 A Whitted
Prepare emails for conversion to

PST format
0 .1
09/14/05 TD Wozniak
Review arbitrator's decision

regarding motion to pay
settlement funds into court
registry ; telephone conference
with ?' .- El-chelbu,gex regarding
same and litigation strategy ;
Morrison regarding litigation
strategy ; e-mail regarding same ;
revise answer to amended
Complaint ; review research
regarding peer review processes
2 .7
Review underlying pleadings

regarding peer review-privilege
assertions ; draft outline for
motion for reconsideration brief
2 .2
09/14/05 DG Anderson Review pleadings regarding

underlying litigation in
connection with determining
continued confidentiality of Dr .
Murtagh's November 2000
ddeposition transcript
1 .7
09/14/05
2 .9
11
o9/s d /o s
JC Hill
A Whitted Prepare emails -for conversion to

PST format
OR/15/05 DG Anderson Proof, p rep are and f i l e ans wer to 6 .6

amended ;
complaint
trace history
of filing documents with the
court xm d er seal ; set up case on
summation
09/15/05
0
JC Hill
Review discovery pleadings from

underlying litigation regarding
peer review privilege assert-ion ;
conference with D . Anderson
O riginal Invoices ( 11 -1 8-08)
5. 6
EPO-9 13
336998 .
16D85 Emoxy University

0
126003
10/20/05
games . J .
Murtagh,
Date TimekeeDer
-------- -------------------
09115105
R Bennett
., IUD jr
arbitration
Invoice Number 33699c

Page 9
Hours
regarding pleadings from
underlying litigat?on :'raview
rescission research ; draft
rescission argument for motion to
compel arbitration or dismiss ;
"Blue Codes"
Review interrogatories and
requests for production sent to
Dr . C+iurtagh and his responses
thereto ; legal research regarding
waiver of psychiatrist/patient
privilege ; begin drafting motion
to compel discovery
8 .2
09/Z5/O5 A Whitted prepare Emory e-mails -For 5 .2

conversion to ps~ format
09/16/ .05 DG _7undc2" S ol'? RcV 2e1a pleadings regard~P_g

underlying litigation in
connection with determining
continued confidentiality of Dr .
Murtagh's November 2000
de-oasitn on transcript
09/16/05
09/16/05
TC Duf_3 eld
jC T3 ? 1 1
03/16/ 0 5 R Bennett
LJ
0 .5
Review discovery issues ;

telephone call with M . I-Tallia at
FBI regarding subpoena response ;
telephone call '-from B . Spear
regarding B . Skellie subpoena
response ; discuss strategy of
reconsideration of order denying
petition to pay funds into escrow
with T . Wozniak ; draft motion to
compel discovery
7 .7
Conference T . Duzzìeld regarding

suxspaenas, depositior_s, and
briefs ; review pleadings
regarding Internet postings and
breaches of settlement agreement ;
review Dr, Murtagh's response to
our motion for interim relief ;
draft brief for reconsideration
6 .8
Draft mncio?n to compel

psychiatric records ; research
regarding same
Orig in a l I n voices (11-18-08)
6 .4
E PO- 114
18085
126003
1Q/2n/oS
Jrnory University Invoice Number

James J . Murtagh,.,
Jr MD - Arbitration page 10
336998
Date
Timekeeper
Hours
--------------------09j16J05 A shitted Prepare mails for conversion to 1 .4
PST format
09/16 05 TD Wozniak Telephone conference with G .
Johnson regarding conversion of
'Ernory e-mails ; review subpoena
responses ; meet with T . Dufiield
regarding FBI's response to
subpoena
09/17/05 ic Hill
09/17/05
1 .0
Draft motion to camped,

arbitration and dismiss amended
complaint, conduct research
regarding waiver of fraudulent
inducement claim and rescissicni
review and edit motion for
reconsideration' of petition to
pay settlement funds into esc x ou-
12,1
Draft brief in support of mo t ion

f or reconsideration. of petition
for interim relief ; research for
dismiss amended counterclaim ;
draft section of brief regarding
peer revi ew p roce ss e s and
privil e ge
8 . .9
A Wh i ned . Convert e mai l s to PST
f ormat
0 .4
09/18/05 TD Wozniak Review and revise motion to

compe l arbitration and d i smiss
2 .5
09/18/05
TC Du-Lfzeld
8 .3
09/18/05
JC Hill ?review additional pleadings from 5 .4

underlying litigation for .peer
review references ; research
plaintiff's rescission argument
regarding tender back
amended comp l aint ; review

research regarding f raudulen t
inducement and resciss i on i ssues
F ina l ize motion to compel

discovery and to dismiss
'Plaintiff's amended complaint ;
revie w and edit motion for
reconsideration of p etition t o
pay settlement funds in t o escrow ;
conduct legal research in
connection with both motions
EPO- 115
~.
1885 Emo?-y University invoice Number

126003 Jam e s J . Nurtagh, Jr . , MD Arbitration gage ? 1
14/2Q/05
33699c
Date
Timekeeper
Rours
---------;- x'evzew and revise
requirement
brief in support of motion for
reconsideration of petition for
interim relief
09/ '?8/05 R B e nn ett
Revise motion to compel

psychiatric records
2 .0
09119105 Ì'D W ozn i ak

arbitration and/or aismiss
amended camplain~ ; review and
revise motion for reconsideration
and for order zequiririq plaintiff
to repay all settlement amounts ;
telephone conference with 8 .
Morrison regarding third party
discovery ; e-mails with
arbitrator and opposing counsel
regarding reschedtsl iz-ag hearing
5 .5
09/19/05 JC Hill Research for brief in support of

motion to compel arbitration ;
revise brief in support of motion
for reconsideration ; review
exhibits ; research fraud and lack
of reliance as a matter of
lawdversipocdngs
4 ,4
09/19/05 D G Anderson Review Emory internal e-mails 4 .4

from e-mail filter for relevant
e-mails ; cite check, check quotes
and blue book motion to compel
arbitration
09/19/ 05 R Benn e t t
09/19/05 TC
nuf L ie ? d
09/20/05 TD Wdzaiak
Revise motion to compel medical

and psychiatric records
0 .5
Review motion to compel

arbitration and dismiss
plaintiff's amended complaint ;
review motion for reconsideration
of arbitrator's denial of
petition for interim relief ;
attention to mail from third
party subpoenas ; review upcoming
deadlines ; review e-mails from
Emory e-mail filter
6 .1
Telephone conference with P .

Mprxa sson regarding motions for
O rig inal Invo ices (11-18-08)
2 .1
EPO- 116
18085
126003
1 o/zalo 5
Emory University- Invoice Number

Date Timekeeper
-------- -------------------
Hours
reconsideration and to comne!
arbitration of amended comDlaint ;
review select materials produced
by T, Nugent ; telephone
conference with S . Morrison
regarding third party-discovery,
Dlaintiff's admissions, and K .
XuritzXY e-mail
09/ 20/05
A Whitted
Prepare e-mai2s for conversion

Tax document review
0 .4
09/2p/ 0 5
DG Anderson
Prepare exhibits to motion to

compel arbitration ; revise motion
to compel
3 .4
09/20/05
R Sennett
Legal -research for motion to

compel medical records
0 .7
6 .6
09/20/05 J c Hill-
Review documents produced b y Dr .

Murtagh and Deloitte
2 .1
09/21/05

arbitration and motion for
reconsideration of immediate
relief ; review select third party
discovery
1 .7
0 9 /2 1 /os A Whitted
Prepare emails for conversion for

document review
1.8
09/21/05 D G Anderson
7. . 2
09/21/05 TC Duff? e].d
Revise motion for reconsideration

and motion to compel arbitration
pursuant to B . Morrison's
comments ; revise privilege log ;
attention to files received from
independent expert ; outline
summary of information obtained
5 .5
09/20/05 T C Du-ffj. e1, d
?' D Wozniak
335998
arbitration and motion for

reconsideration of petition for
interim relief ; review T .
Nugent's documents produced in
responses to subpoena duces
tecum ; correspond with t".eloitte
regarding production of remaining
computer riles
EPQ-1 1 7
18085
126003 James J . Muxtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration gage 13
10/20/05
Date
-------- ----
Timekeeper
33639
Hours
already to rebut Dr . Muztagh's

July 8, 2D05 affidavit
09/21/05
JC Hill
09/22/05 A
Whw t ;. ed.
Review additional documents for

privilege log ; review caselaw
regarding just-iTizble reliance in
settlement proceedings for motion
to dismiss fraudulent claims ;
review additional e-mails from
fir . Murtagh's Eudora files
2 .9
prepare emails for conversion for

document review
0 .9
09/22/05
R Bennett
Legal xeaearch regarding the

"federal claims act seal"
privilege and law enforcement
privilege
1.2
09/22/05
Th- WoaniFk
Meet with T . Duffield regarding

B . Skellie's motion to quash
subpoena ; review plaintiff's
privilege log ; revise memory's
privilege log ; telephone
conference with B . No?-rison
regarding same ; review Nugent
discovery response
1 .9
09/22/05
?'C Duffield Revise and serve privilege log ;

- review motion to quash Skellie
subpoena ; telephone call from T .
Eichelbexger regarding Dr .
Murtagh's motion to revise
amended complaint ; review Dr .
Murtagh's privilege log ; prepare
e-mail to ~ . N,pxxa.spn regarding
outstanding third party discovery
09/2/05 JC Hill Review tiles from Dr_ Murtagh's

first production fQr :,_-esponsive
documents to search on
concordance database ; search
concordance database -for
responsive documentsl review
correspondence file -for
respo:zsive documents to Drodlice ;
research joint defense/common
interest privileges 1'' 01' notion to
compel
Origina l Invo ices ( 11 - 1 8-08)
6. 2
4 .9
EPO-1i8
18085
126003 James J . Murtagh,.,
Jr MD - Arbitration Page 14
10/2dj4S
Date
Q3/22/05
Timekeeper
Hours
DG ~ Anderson Review Dr . Murtagh's first

document production ; cite check
and proof motion to compel
09/23/05 R Benne t t
33699$
draft motion to compel discovery,

research evidence required to
2,6
7 .5
prove an DIED claim ; meeting with

defense team regarding upcoming
projects including interviewing
reference requestars and drafting
affidavits
0 9 /23 / 05 TD Wozniak Meet with defense team regarding 3 .0

motions to compel discovery and
1-1
third party discovery ; review

e-mails from plaintiff Is counsel
regarding privilege logs also
third party discovery ; revise
responses to same ; review and
revise memo to B . Morrison
regarding third party disco-very
issues
09/23/05
09/23/05
T C Duffield
Finalize and file motion to 8 .8

compel arbitration and/or dismiss .
Dr . Murtagh's amended complaint
and motion for reconsideration of
petition for interim relief ;
telephone calfl with B . Morrison
regarding comments to motions ;
prepare correspondence to J .
Breen regarding privilege locig and
other discovery issues ; prepare
weekly status report to R .
Morrison and review evidence
obtained from third parties that
is inconsistent with Dr .
Murtagh's affidavit testimony ;
conference with defense team to
discuss status of discovery
JC Hill Research far'mots pn to compel ;

conference with defense team ;
5 .9
telephone conference with C .

Johnson Yegardirig file shamming
documents ; review Dr . Murtagh's
Eudora e-mail files
09/23/05 A Whiffed Prepare emails for conversion -for 1 .4

document review
O rigin a l In voices (11 - 1 8-08)
EPO- 119
19085
Emory University
Invo i ce Number
126003 J ames .7 . Murtagh, ,Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 15
10/20/05
Date Timekeeper
-------- ---------0 /2305
D G Anderson
Hours
prepare, file and serve motion to
compel arbitration and motion for
reconsideration
3 .4
09/24/05 R Bennett
Revisions to motion to compe3l

discovery
1 .3
49/2?/il5 G Johnson
Prepare e-mail material for

indexing ; index material
-_ . 2
os/2 S /o 5
G Johnson
Prepare e-mail material for
4 .4
0 9/2b/05
TD, Wozniak
Conference call with plaintiff's

counsel regarding scheduling and
discovery issues ; review and
revise good faith discovery
correspondence
'_ . 7
Q9/ 2 6/Q5 JC Hill
Review Dr .
e--mzzlS
1 .3
09/26/05
Legal research regarding proof

required to shuy; "severe
emotional distress" element of
intentional inf2iction of
emotional distress c l aim
R Bennett
09/26/05 TC D uf rie '! a
0 9/ 26 / 0 5
A whitted
indexing ; index material
Murtagh's Eudora
Revise motion to dismiss Dr .

Murtagh's defamation and
emotional distress claims and to .
compel discovery ; review e-mails
from J . Breen regarding
outstanding discovery matters and
respond to same ; conference call
with T . Wozniak, T . Eichelberger
and j , Breen regarding upcoming
status conference and discovery
schedule ; review request from A .
Whitted regarding search terms
for Emory e-mail files ;
correspond with LT . Breen
regarding outstanding protective
order ; prepare letters to J .
BreEn regarding motion to compel
issues and subpoenas nd releasers
Prepare emails for conversion for
document review
Orig i n al Invoices ( 11 - 18 -08 )
1.2
10 .2
C) . ='
EPO- 120
33699E
18085
126003
James j . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - arbitration Page 16
10/20/05
Date
TimekeeDer
-------- ----------
Hours
09/26j45 DG Anderson Prepare list of subpoenas served 1 .2

on third parties
09/27/05
TD Wozniak
09/27/05
DG p-ndexson
09/27/05 Tc Duffield
Review e-mails regarding Emory's

third party subpoenas ; conference
call with Arbitrator regarding
scheduling and motion for
reconsideration of order
regarding settlement payments ;
message to B . Morrison regarding
same ; meet with T . Duzfield
regarding FOIA request to FB I and
motion to compel discovery from
plaintiff
Prepare set of all third p art y
document requests and responses
to , same t o send t o J . Breen and
T . r.ic h e I herge r
2 .7
-3 .4
Conference call with ,Arbitrator

Deane regarding discovery
schedule and status of case ;
telephone call with M . Hallie at
the FBI regarding subpoena ; draft
release of FBI information for
_Dr . Murtagh ; review federal
regulations regarding information
requests to FBI and prepare
letter to FBI regarding subpoena
and release ; telephone call with
B . Spears regarding Ske1lie
motion to quash subpoena ;
attention to Dr . Nlurtagh's motion
for leave to correct his amended
complaint
3 .9
09/27/05
A Whitted
Prepare e- mails .f or conversion

for document review
1. 1
09/28/05
DG Anderson
Update file and index of third

party documents
2 .3
09/28/05
R Bennett
' -
Meeting wi th T . Duffield
regarding reference request
aff id av it s ; telephone con'Lerence
with Humana Military Hospital
regarding reference release and
requested information
1. 2
Original Invoices ( 11 -1 8-0 8)
EPO-1 2 7
336998
18085 memory University invoice Number

226003 _ James .i . Mur4 agh , J r ., ND - Arbitration Page 17
20/20/05
Hours
date Timekeeper
-------- ----------
is.
09/28/05 TC DuEf?eid
Review and -finalize product i on o f

subpoena and release responses to
Dr . Murtagh
0 .5
Distribute documents rece ived in

response to releases ; update
i ndex of third party documents
0.4
09/29/05 11 Bennett
Legal research reg ar d i ng

consultants privilege and law
enforcement privilege
2 .8
as / zs/o 5
TC Duffield
Review Dr- Mv.?'zagh' s document

oroduction -for deposition
exh i b it s and references t o his
book
1 .0
0 /2/D5
j C Hill
Rev i ew Dr, Mux tagkx ' s eudora

e--mails
4 .4
09/29/45
A Whitted
prepare emails for conversion for

document review
0 .7
09/30/05 TC Dui~ield
Prepare e-mail to J . 3Xeen

regarding deadline to provide
medical release and legall
authority for privileges
asserted ; finalize motion to
compel discovery
? .B
09/20/ 05
Draft responsive pa r a graphs to

plaintiff's privilege arguments
1 .0
Review Plaintiff's letter
0 .9
R Bennett
DS/30/05 TD Wozniak
providing legal support for

alleged privileges ; e-mails with
T . Du~:field regarding same
TOTAL HOURS
386 .1
EPO- 122
3369E
18085
126003
1/20/05

James J . Murtagh, Jr ., MD - Arbitration Page 1$
TIMEKEEPER TIME SUMMARY :

Timekeeper
------------------------Michael W . Johnston
Michael E . Ross
Todd D . ado zni ak
Rehekah Bennett
Todd C . Duffield
Jennifer C . Hill
Debra G . Anderson
Glenn Johnson
Aisha Whitted
CURRENT FEES
33695a.
Hours
I .1
0 .8
42
35
135
68
.6
.3
.1
.a
sz .a
8 .6
20 .4
81 , 3?6 .SQ
FOR COSTS ADVANCED AhTD EXPENSES INCURRED :

09/30/05
09/30/05
09/30/05
09/30/05
fl9/3Q/05
09/30/05
09/14/05
09119105
o -9 f2a/os
09/20/05
09/29/05
09/08/05
09~09/OS
Long Distance Phone Calls-ATL

sêlecopyJTelex-ASS,
Postage/Express Mail-AiY,
Litigation Support Electronic
Document Scanning
Duplicating Casts-ATE
Computer Research-Lexi s/Westlaw-A
Support Staff Overtime-ATL
Business Meals Jennifer Hill,
9/12, ATL, working dinner with
Todd-Dufiield
business Meals Todd Duffield,
9/13, ATL, meal for Todd Duxfa.eld
Business Meals Lenora Shealy,
9/18, ATL, working dinner
(Shealy, Hill, Duffie1d)
Business Meals Backout seq
5928080 - Void check 487163 .
BACIZOUT 1
Business Meals Jennifer Hill,
9 11 8, ATL, overtime meals-Hill
and Duffield
Court Reporter Wynette C .
Blathers, RPR - Disk of
transcript of hearing held on
July 14, 2005
Subpoena Fees 14LQ Attorney
Services - Se2nrice of Process on
?Var_ .Page
0 .35
3 . 15
? .6S
1,503 .00
473 .10
2,503 .50
379 .60
31 .22
8 .95
41 .96
-X3. .95
24 .74
30 .00
17 0 .Op
EPO- 123
18085 Emory Univers ity

12 003 James J . Murt a g h ,
10/2D/05
09/09/05
09/09/05
09/09/05
09/30/05
D9/02/OS
09/02/05
09/02/05
q 9 Jo2/ 05
09/0 / D5
os/ 1 6 1 a S
09/23/05
09/23/05
09/23/05
09/23/05
09/26/05
Invoice Number
it ., ICJ - Arbitration t ake 1 9
Subpoena Fees MLQ Attorney

services Service of Process on
Albert Skellie
Services - Service of Process on
New Grady Coalition by serving
Ronald Marshall
Services - service of Process on
Ronald Marshall
??rba .trafiion/Nediatzgn Fees Jones
Day - One Third of Arbitrator
gees
Document Delivery FedEx Q8/3(l/OS
Document Deliverv Georgia
messenger Service, Inc .
Messenger Service, Inc_
Bocument Delivery Georgia
I)ocumert Delivery Georgia
Messenger Service, inc .
Document Delivery Backau` Seq No
X935074 . Modification to Invoice .
21fib38 . Georgia Messenger
Service, Inc .
Document Delivery Backout Seq No

5936075 . Modification to Invoice
26638 . Georgia Messenger
Service, Inc .
Duplicating Costs Lex Business
Solutions - CD duplication andd
electronic data discovery
CURRENT EXPENSES
TOTAL AMOUNT OF THIS i-1,TV01CE
Original Invoices ( 11-18 -08)
59 .00
is . 00
74 .00
B, 399 . 16
12 .01
32 .92
69 .50
71 .70
4.1 .ea
23 . 0
23 .90
11 .95
-23 .0
-11 .95
437,40
-----------14,366 .65
95,715 .15
EPO- 124
336998
Remi: To :
KING & SPA L D IN G UP
P .O. Box I76133
Adznm, GA 3036E-6 133

: (404) 5i2-46pQ
Telephone
FEDERAL I.D . NO . 5845W253
PY v17RE: SUNTRUST BANK

RB A NO r 06 1 000 2 04
St4'TFT': SNTRUS3A
ACCT NO: 880031 2475
ms.tiss
2lizabeth fit . Clark-Moxrison

Emory University
Atlanta, GA
30322
LNIN
cA-TE u.'V o) a N1sMnen
ON
x"i]z-rwiucE

1 2 / 01/05
Invoice Date
Client Number
18085
Matter Number
126003
Re, James J . Mux4agh, Jr . , MID - Arbitration

-----------------------------------------------------------------------~7OR ? P r.}FESSI ONPS, SERVICES REN-DR-RED THROUGH 10/3! /0-5
Da ~. e
Timekeeper
-------- ---------09/03. /05 L buar t e
D9/la/4S
T Ha wk
09/15/05
T Hawk
10/03/05 R Bennett
10/03/05
iD Wozniak
Hours
Update case and document

notebooks
0 .7

regarding peer review issues
associated with case ; legal
research regarding same
1 .2
Review brief in support of

?laintif"i's motion regarding peer
review issues
1.b
Resear ch regarding the joint

defense/common i nteres t
privilege ; revis e ' motion -to
compel t o respond to ne w
contentions made i n Pla i rk.ir f's
September 30, 2005 letter
3 .9
Revi ew cases cited by Plaintiff

for alleged law enforcement,
co m mon interest, and false cla i ms .
privi leges ; meet w i th T . _n u Tlf eld
regarding Pla i nt if f 's privilege
assertions ; t el ephone con f ere nce
with S . Morrison regarding
th i rd-pa rt y discovery
1 .9
AA YN.IENT IS D UE UPON RECEIPT 0.F 3"A'VoICE

ATLANTA HOUSTON
LONDON . ?SEW YORK
WASHINGTON, D .C .
EP O - 125
Greenberg
~ . Tra uri g
Page
5
Invoice No . 1996998
File No . 10209 1 .010100
counsel regarding witness availability for

depositions; prepare correspondence to C .
Culotta notifying him of same; outline initial
objections to 30(b)(6) deposition topics ;
confer with IT . experts regarding
GeorgiansOpenGavt@yahoo .caznm account ;
draft subpoena to Yahoo
TDW Telephone conference with Emary's in-house

counsel regarding depositions ordered by
arbitrator ; review and revise subpoena to
Yahoo; meet with L. Dietrich regarding
motion for protective order regarding
President Wagner`s deposition ; review
deposition preparation notebooks previously
compiled for witness preparation sessions ;
meet with L. Edeltnann regarding updates to
same
4.10 hrs 335 .00 1,373 .54
09/12/07 LAD Review and revise motion for protective

order ; research on quashing deposition notice
of high ranking official
1 .60 hrs 250.04 400 .00
09/121.07
9.70 brs
09/11/0?
LCE Finalize Yahoo! subpoena ; prepare

correspondence to opposing counsel
regarding same ; review and update
deposition notebook for Dr . Fowler; review
and update deposition notebook for L .
Snead ; revise correspondence to C . Culotta
regarding availability of certain Emory
witnesses for deposition and Emory`s
objection to President Warner and Rule
30(b)(6) depositions; exchange emails with
C. Culotta regarding St . Paul production,
Emory privilege log, and Murtagh's tax
issues ; review Eznory's current privilege log ;
prepare deposition notebook for N .
McDonald; confer with T. Wozniak
regarding objections to Rule 30(b)(6)
250.00
2,425 .00
TDW:JB
Tax II) : 13-3b13083
Greenberg Traurig, LLP I Attorneys at Lbw I The Forum 1$294 Northside Parkway I Sub 400 1 Atl anta , Georgia 30327
.goaw. Om
Tel 678.55QA% 11
EPO - 37 6
G ree n be rg
i.. Traurig
deposition topics
Page 6
Invoice No . : 1996998
File No . 10209 1 .010100
TDW Review e-mails from C . Culottes regarding

documents produced from St . Paul litigation
and privilege logs ; respond to same ; review
C. Culotta's request for Emory's position on
MU1rtSgh!5 tax issues ; meet with L, Edelmann
regarding deposition preparation sessions
and privilege logs
2.10 hrs
335 .00
703 .50
DAB Review and comparisonn of documents to be

produced in- supplemental production to
Plaintiff Murtagh
2.60 ors
185 .00
481 .00
09/13/07
LAD Revise motion for protective order of James

Wagner deposition and 30(b)(6) deposition;
draft affidavit of K . Alexander for same
5 .801rs 250 A0
1,450 .00
09!13/07
LCE Revise Ernory's motion for protective order

regarding President Wagner and affidavit of
K. Alexander in support of same ; review
relevant orders regarding expert witness
testimony; confer with T . Wozniak regarding
Murtagh's failure to comply with same and
decision as to whether to seek IME ; examine
deposition transcript from August 30, 2007
deposition of Murtagh ; prepare
correspondence to K. Lee regarding
additional documents needed ; outline
contempt hearing argument
9.70 firs 250 .00 2,425 .04
09/13IQ7
TDW Review and comment on rule 3 0(b)(6)

topics; e-mails with Emory's in-house
counsel regarding same; revise letter to C .
Culottes regarding depositions and Murtagh's
tax issues; telephone conferences with
Emory's in-house counsel regarding efforts to
prove plaintiff is continuing to violate
contempt order; review and comment on
4.80 hrs
09/12/07
335.00 1,608.00
TDW :JB
Tax ID: 13-3613 0 83
Greenberg Traurig , LLP I Attorneys at Law The Forum 1 3290 Norttzs ide P arkway I Suite 400 I Aflenta , Georgia 30327
Tel B78.a5~ i
~~~~ ,2~~$~~www gtlaw. cam
EPO- 3 77
Greenberg
~ Traur~g
draft motion for protective order; e-mails
with C . Colutta regarding privilege logs and
plaintiffs request regarding plaintiff's tax
issues
Page 7
Invoice No . : 1996998
File No .
102091 .010100
09/14/07
DAB Review and compare electronic data ftom

Emory's server ; review and compare
documents for use in witness binders of K .
Alexander and N. McDonald for upcoming
depositions ; identify additional search terms
for future electronic document reviews
7.80 hrs
185 .00
1,443 .00
09/14/07
LAD
Research Georgia law for standards of

protective order and quashing deposition of
high ranking executives; review and revise
K. Alexander's affidavit and motion for
protective order to quash President Wagner's
deposition
0.90 hrs
250 .00
225 .00
09/14f07
LCE Telephone conference with K. Lee regarding

St. Paul production and plaintiffs allegations
of limited waiver of peer review privilege;
confer with T. Wozniak regarding same ;
prepare list of key witnesses and
relationships ; revise and finalize Emory's
deposition of President Wagner and
memorandum of law in support of same ;
revise affidavit of K. Alexander; finalize
correspondence to C . Culotta regarding
availability of Emory witnesses for
deposition; telephone conference with T.
Eichelberger regarding Senator Shafer's open
records request and Grady's proposed
response and questions regarding same ;
telephone conference with Emory's in-house
counsel regarding same, Emory's motion for
protective order regarding deposition of
President Wagner, and affidavit of K .
12.30 hrs
250 .00
3,075 .00
TDW :JB
Tax ID : 13-36 1 3083
Greenberg Trau ri g , L LP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 13290 Northside Parkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel 678 .5511 G,}M) www. g#law.com
EPO- 378
Greenberg
Traurig
.
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
Alexander; case strategy meeting with T.

Wozniak, H . Pace, and D . Burger; review
new St. Paul documents identified by
Womble for possible production to opposing
counsel ; finalize list of objections to
Murtagh's 30(b)(6) deposition not ice
LJ
8
1996998
102091A1.0100
09/14/07 BEM Compile select pleadings for use inn case
2.00 hr s 125.00
09/14/07 HRP Conferences with L . Edeltnann and T .

Wozniak regarding Murtagh's canfempiuous
conduct ; review of civil contempt order,
pending motion to enforce, and related
documents ; review Georgia authority in
support of expedited hearing ; prepare motion
for expedited hearing on contempt motion
and supporting brief
7.40 bra 315 .00 2,331 .00
U9/14/p7 DLS Cite check motion for protective order

regarding Dr . Wagner
0.70 hrs
185 .00
129 .50
09/14/07
9.00 hrs 335 . 00
3,0 1 5.00
Tnw:JB
TDW Review continuing contemptuous conduct by

Murtaa ; telephone conference with Emory's
in-house counsel regarding options for
proving Murtagh continues to violate
contempt order ; review and revise motion for
protective order regarding President Wagner ;
review and revise affidavit for K . Alexander;
review and revise "to do" list ; revise letter to
plaintiffs counsel and arbitrator regarding
depositions ; meet with H . Pace regarding
emergency motion to hold contempt hearing ;
select pleadings related to motion; telephone
conference with T. Eichelberger regarding
settlement agreement and seal order ;
telephone conference with Emory's in-house
counsel regarding motion for protective
order, K . Alexander affidavit, and letter to
arbitrator ; revise same ; meet with L . Dietrich
250 .00
Tax ID : 13-3613 0 83
Green be rg Tra urig, LLP I Attor n eys at Law I The Foru m 1 3290 Nor thsi de Pa rkway J S pite 400 1 Atlanta, Geor gia 30327
Tel 678.5!8JJRql
www . gflaw.com
EP O- 379
G een erg
Traurig
IrJ
regarding motion for protective order and

rule 30(b)(6) topics; review and revise
Emory webmail account search terms
~,
!
Page 9
Invoice No . 1996998
102091 .010100
File No.
09/16/07
LAD Revise motion for protective order limiting

Murtagh's 3 0(b)(6) deposition notice ;
research Georgia law regarding limiting
30(b)(6) depositions
09/17/07
DAB Review select documents related to

continuing contemptuous conduct ; review
documents for use in witness binders of K.
Alexander and N . McDonald for upcoming
depositions ; identify additional documents to
use in preparation sessions
a 91 I7I07 LAD Review and revise obj ection to 30(b)(6)

deposition notice ; draft letter to C . Culotta
regarding 30(b)(6) deposit ion notice
0.6 4 hrs 250 .00 1 50.00
10 .50 hrs 185 .00
0.50brs 250 .00 125 .00
09/17/07 LCE Revise Emery's motion for expedited hearing 11 .10 his
and memorandum of law in support of same ; .
'I 'Dw:] B
.1,942 .50
250 . 0 0 2,775.00
revise list of key witnesses and relationships ;

revise list of search terms per Emory's inhouse counsel ; exchange correspondence
with Emory's in-house counsel regarding Dr .
Fowler's deposition and other Emery
depositions; research Georgia's open records
act ; telephone conference with T .
Eichelberger regarding Grady response to
Murtagh's open records act request and/or
agreement to unseal record ; prepare letter
regarding Emory's position on open records
request ; telephone conference with Emory's
in-house counsel regarding Grady's request
for Emory's position on open record request ;
draft correspondence to C . Culotta regarding
designated representatives for certain
30(b)(6) depositions and Emory's objections
Tax ID : 13-3613083
Greenberg Trau rig , LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Nnrth side Parkway I Suite 400 1 At lanta , Georgia 30327
Tel 678.SS' .0(3 / ax fi78
.~~ '~] www. gUaw. com
n g~nal nvoices ( ~ EP O- 38 0
Greenberg
Traurig
to remaining topics
09/17/07
1-1
Page
10
Invoice No. ' 1996998
File No.
HRP Prepare draft motion for expedited hearing

and brief in support; conference with L.
Edelmann regarding motion strategy
102 091. ,410 100
1 .20 hrs 315 .00 378 .00
09!1'7107 TDW Review and revise motion for protective

order ; revise letter to C. Cu lotta regarding
rule 30(b)(6) deposition; telephone
conferences and e-mails with L . Edelmann,
T. Eichelherger and Emory's in-house
counsel regarding request for settlement
agreement; telephone conference with L .
Dietrich regarding motion to unseal record ;
review and revise draft motion for
emergency hearing on motion to enforce
contempt order
3 .50 hrs 335 .00 1,1 72.54
09/18/07
DAB Review and compare electronic data ;

continue review of documents for use in
witness binders; review and organization of
witness binder for K . Alexander
830 hrs 185 .00
1,535 .50
09/ 18107
LAD Review and revise motion for protective

order to limit plaintiffs 30(b)(6) deposition ;
review of Emory's discovery requests and
responses to determine whether any 30(b)(6)
areas of examination are duplicative of
discovery already conducted
1 .40 hrs 250 .0 0
350.00
09/18/07
LCE Telephone conference with Emory's in-house

counsel regarding possible motion to unseal
record and Emory depositions ; revise
correspondence to C . Culotta regarding
Emory's designations for Rule 30(b)(6)
deposition topics and topics Emory objects
to; draft correspondence to arbitrator
regarding C . Culotta's failure to select dates
for Emory depositions as required by
11 .40 hrs 250 .00
2,850 .00
raw:
Tax ID ; 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 Northsirfe Parkway I Suite 400 1 AUan#a, Georgia 30327
Tat Si8 .55NM Frft!9"3-8)www .gdaw.com APO- 381
Greenberg
Traurig
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
. ~~
1996998
102491. .4101 00
September 10, 2007 decision; review Grady's

response to open records act request ; prepare
updated "to-do" list based on conference
with Emory's in-house counsel ; review new
documents provided by Womble from St .
Paul litigation for privilege ; finalize chart of
key witnesses
09/18/07
HRP Research Georgia authority regarding proper

procedure for sealing court record ; review
court pleadings concerning Murtaugh's
motions to seal; develop strategy for
unsealing record; conference with T .
Wozniak regarding same ; review open
records request
09/18/07
TDW
Telephone, conference with Emory's in-house

counsel regarding plaintiffs most recent ;
review open records request to Grady
regarding settlement agreement and
correspondence with Murtagh regarding
same ; review exceptions to open records act;
str ategy and telephone conference with
Emory's i n-house counsel ; review Kuritzky
order; e-mail to arbitrator and plaintiff s
counsel regarding Kuritzky order a nd related
discovery sought by plaintiff; revise witness
chart ; review correspondence regarding
privilege logs ; revi se letter to C . Culotta
regarding depositions and bas is for
obj ections to select 3 0(b)(6) deposition
topi cs ; review PACER entry regarding
j ustice departments dec i si on not to intervene
in qui tam lawsu it ; review and revise "to do"
list; e-mai ls with arbitrator and-opposing
counsel ; outline motion to unseal record ;
telephone conference with H . Pace reg arding
same
3.10 hrs
315 . 00
976 .50
7.50 hrs
335 .00
2,512 .50
TDW :JB
Tax 11D : 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig , LLP I Attorneys at Law I The For um 1 3290 Norths ide Parkway } Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel s'ra,s8KffidffmiU.(PMbl}www .stiaw.com
EPO-
382
Greenberg
raurig
l
09/19/07
Page
- 12
Invoice No .
1996998
102091 .0 1010 0
File No .
9.40 hrs
185.00 1,73 9 . 00
DAB Review and compare electronic data from

Emory's server ; review documents selected
for K . Alexander's deposition ; prepare binder
identifiug pertinent references ; review,
compare and identify affiliations of
witnesses; identify documents for use as
exhibits
09/19/07 LAD Strategy meeting with L . Edehnnnann and T .

Wozniak regarding preparations for
completing discovery and contempt hea ring;
review and revise motion for protective order
to limit plaintiffs 30(b)(6) deposition
1 .80 hrs 250 .0 450 .00
09/19107 LCE Strategy meeting with T . Wozniak and

Murtagh team; prepare for and participate in
lengthy Rule 30(b)(6) good faith discovery
conference with C . Culotta ; finalize K .
Alexander's deposition prepaxation notebook
and enclosures for same ; conference with
Emory's in-house counsel; review witness
charts and files ; review Internet postings ;
prepare correspondence to C . Culotta
regarding Emory witness deposition
schedules ; review correspondence with
Emory's in-house counsel regarding same;
draft letter to C . Culotta regarding his
concessions on Rule 30(b)(6) deposition
topics and develop -argument for outstanding
items
8.50 hrs 250 .00 2, 125.00
09/19/07
HRP
Prepare contingent motion to unseal court

record
3.60 brs
315 .6
09/19/07
DLS
Pull docket reports from Pacer
0.50 ors
185 .00
92.50
09/19/07
TDW Discovery conference with plaintiffs counsel

regarding Emory depositions, privilege logs,
7.10 hrs
335 .00
2,378 .50
. 1 ,134.00
TDW:3B
Tax ID: 13-3613083
Greenberg Traurig, LLP I Atto rneys at Law I The Forum 13290 Northside Parkway I Suite 40a I Atlanta, Georgia 30327
Tel 6T6. 55
A@Ij
V+'VW .9tiaW.Com
EPO- 383
Greenberg
Tra rig
u
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
President Wagner and alleged attorney-client
privilege waiver b y Emory; review and email to Emory additional materials regarding
R. Marshall and Murtagh ; review and
comment on K . Alexander and J. Fowler
deposition preparation notebooks ; draft
outline o fissues for K. Alexander and J.
Fowler depositions; review and revise
motion to quash rule 30(b)(6) depositions ;
meet with H . Pace regarding motion to
unseal record; telephone conferences with
Emory's in-house counsel regarding litigation
strategy
09/20/07
DAB Review webmail; review and compare

electronic data from Emory's servers ; create
N . McDonald's deposition preparation
binder; review and identify documents for
use as exhibits to upcoming depositions ;
review reference requests and updates to
chart regarding same ; review and prepare Dr.
Wayne Alexander preparation documents
7 .40 hrs
09/20/07
LCE Review emails from Dr . Fowler's laptop ;

prepare W . Alexander's deposition notebook ;
prepare Rule 30(b)(6) and expert witness
correspondence to C . Culotta ; examine
correspondence and document production for
information regarding Murtagh's potential
expert witnesses; prepare correspondence to
T. Wozniak and L . Dietrich regarding
Murtag~Ws expert witnesses ; prepare
correspondence to arbitrator regarding
Emory deposition schedule as required by
September 10, 2007 decision ; review
correspondence from C . Culotta regarding
Emory's motion for protective order for
President Wagner ; prepare correspondence to
J. Turner regarding status of A. Rollin
11 .50 hrs
13
1996998
10249 1 .010100
185 .00 1,369 .00
250 .00
2,875 .00
TDW :7B
Tax ID : 13-3 6 13083
Greenberg Traurig, LLP I Attorneys at Law I The Forum 1 3290 hfosfhside Pa rkway I Suite 400 1 Atlanta, Georgi a 30327
Tel 678.55$ 0iaat (Md@s5fO2MZ$Wm-gtiaw. carn
EPO- 384
reenber
Traurig
affidavit for use in contempt hearing ; select
potential exhibits for contempt hearing
Page
Invoice No .
File No .
14
1996998
102091 .01 010 0
09/20/07
BEM Organize and compile exhibits for Oct . 3

contempt hearing binder
09120!07
TDW Review and revise L . Hennigar and W .

Alexander deposition preparation notebooks ;
e-mails regarding parties' agreement
regarding President Wagner's deposition;
review and revise letters confirming
deposition schedules and discovery ; e-mails
with Emory's in-house counsel
2 . 40 hrs 335 .00 90 4. 00
09/21/07
DAB Compile documents referring to Dr . Fowler;

update witness affiliation charts ; analyze and
cross reference Murtage reference request
information; review and identify
designations for Dr . Wayne Alexander in
Murtagh's prior deposition testimony ;
review, comparison and analysis of
electronic data from Emory's server.
8.00 hrs 1 8 5.00 1,480 .00
09/21/07
LCE Exchange correspondence with T.

Eichelbezger regarding the open records act
request ; confer with T . Wozniak regarding
arguments for contempt hearing ; finalize
Rule 30(30(6} correspondence to C. Culotta;
draft correspondence to C . Culotta regarding
supplemental St . Paul production; review
documents from Emory web mail account ;
prepare memorandum to Emory's in-house
counsel ; telephone conference with N.
McDonald regarding depositions ; revise
reference request chart ; identify documents
relating to President Wagner's discussion of
SOX and documents relating to Emory's
ethics policies ; draft Emory's argument for
hearing on motion to enforce civil contempt
12 .I0 hrs 250 .00 3, 025.00
Tnw:JB
0.50 hrs
125 .00
62.50
Tax ID: 1 3-36 1 3 083

Greenbarc3 "rraurig , LLP I Attorneys at Law The Forum 1 3290 NOrkhside Parkway I Sui te 440 j Atlanta , Geo rgia 30327
Tel 67B .552&TURJ IFME&5" ~ irjwuv. gtl aw. eam
EPO- 385
Greenberg
Traurig
Page 15
Invoice No. 1996998
File 1Vo. 102091 .010100
order ; review arbitrator's September 21, 2007
decision regarding Emory's motion for
protective order for President Wager ;
review C. Culotta response to Emory's Rule
30(b)(6) letter; draft response to same
09/21!07
TDW Review and comment on deposition

preparation notebooks for Dr . Fowler, W .
Alexander, and L . Hennigar ; review
plaintiffs correspondence regarding rule
34(b)(6) depositions and privilege log ;
review additional select documents to be
produced related to St . Paul litigation ; review
and comment on emergency motion to enjoin
additional breaches of settlement agreement
by Murtagh; e-mails with EmorVs in-house
counsel regarding President Wagner's
deposition and contempt hearing strategy
6.20 hrs 335 .00
2,077 .00
09f221U'7 DAB Review webmail ; review and compare

articles of interest pertaining to M=agh,
Marshall, Loughrey, and others
0.50 hrs 185 .00
92 .50
09/22/07
TDW Prepare for Dr. Fowler deposition

preparation session ; review and revise
motion to unseal record; review e-mails
regarding status of open records request ;
review and revise correspondence to C.
Cullotta regarding additional St . Paul
documents being produced; begin preparing
for contempt hearing
6,30 bra 335 .00
2, 1 10.50
09123107
LCE Prepare for contempt hearing ; review

correspondence from Emory's in-house
counsel regarding media issues and R .
Sander deposition preparation ; exchange
emails with T. Wozniak regarding same ;
review T . Wozniak revisions to motion to
unseal record
5,40 hrs
1,350 .00
250 .00
Tvw:Js
Tax U 1 3-3613 083
Greenberg Traurl g , LLP I Attorneys at Law . The Forum 13290 No rths ide Parkway I Suite 400 1 AUarda , Georg ia 30327
Tat 67&553.~9~F~~~~~~~~,~pn r~ugtlaw. com
E PO- 386

Emory1 3

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Исходное описание:

Оригинальное название

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Emory1 3

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 1 of 75

B-mails regarding discovery 5 .5

7'C Duffield Finalise order granting limited 9 .4

DG Anderson Meet with defense team regarding 2 .0

G Johnson Conference with B .

06/14/05 JC Hill Conference with T . Duzfield

O r igi nal Invoices ( 17- 9 8 -08)

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 2 of 75

TD Wozniak Revise independent expert

06/15/05 J C Hill Draft supplemental brief on 8 .2

O r i ginal Invoice s (111-18-08)

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 3 of 75

Complete list of search terms for

T7) Wozniak Telephone conference with B . ~

Organize case notebooks ; review

Research regarding MSX format

Rev i se letter to Plaintiff's

Or i ginal Invoices ( 11 - 18 -08 )

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 4 of 75

TD Wozniak Review and revise letter to 3 .2

Prepare search terms list ;

TD Wozniak Review list of search terms and

Original Invoices ( 1 4- 1 8-08)

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 5 of 75

18 85 Emery University Invoice Number

Telephone calls with Deloitte and

Telephone conference with Court - T 4 .6

Anderson regarding complaint ;

06/17/05 DO Anderson Review list of terms and

JC Hill Draft supplemental brief to pay 4 .4

TD waznaak Update "to do" list of action 0 .7

JC Hill Revise supplemental brief

Revi ew and rev i se le t ter to

Origin al Invoices (11-18-08)

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 6 of 75

Conference with T . Duffield

research contract remedies

Revise letter to J . Breen

Review supplemental memorandum or

Review Plaintiff's motion to

O r iginal Invoice s (11-18-08)

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 7 of 75

18085 Emory University InvoiCe Number

TD Wozniak Review and revise supplemental

Review Plaintiff's motion to

06/22/05 DG Anderson Revise list of Emory search 2 .2

O ri ginal Invoices ( 1 1- 18-08 )

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 8 of 75

18085 Emory University Invoice Number

8 . Morrison regarding response to

plaintiff's motion to strike ;

Research SLAPP legislative

Research regarding select

Cite check supplemental brief in

Miscellaneous telephone calls

Telephone conference with B .

Original Invoices (11-18-08)

Case 1:09-cv-01186-HTW Document 1-3 Filed 05/04/09 Page 9 of 75

18085 Emory University Invoice Number

Draft anti-SLAPP verification to B ..2

06/24/05 DG Anderson cite check and shepardize 3 .4

fines ; telephone conference with