Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Bimonthly Newsletter of the Wildlands Center for Preventing Roads. March/April 1997. Volume 2 # 2
Kalmiopsis Wild Land After the 1964 Wilderness Act, the Kalmiopsis roads
were given trail numbers and made to serve wilderness
Threatened by Roads hikers as the primary access to the Chetco River from the
east side of the Wilderness. But despite the area’s Wilder-
ness designation, the mining threat in the Kalmiopsis
by Barbara Ullian remained and the roads were often maintained by bulldozers
and driven by miners and anyone else who could get a key.
“Few completely roadless, large watersheds exist in Others vandalized or drove around the agency-placed
the Pacific Northwest, but those that remain relatively Wilderness gates.
undisturbed play critical roles in sustaining sensitive There is a long history of vandalism and destruction of
native species and important ecosystem processes.” the two gates on these roads. Often they would remain open
—Dr. Chris Frissell, A New Strategy for Watershed for weeks on end. Mining claim owners have also abused
Restoration and Recovery of Pacific Salmon in the Pa- their privileged access and passed their gate keys around to
cific Northwest, 1993.
T
he 179,000-acre Kalmiopsis Wilderness and its
adjacent roadless areas in southwest Oregon’s
Siskiyou Mountains hold the largest remaining block
of wild country on the Lower 48 States’ Pacific Coast. There
are three National Wild and Scenic Rivers—the Chetco,
Illinois, and N. Fork Smith—running through the Kalmiopsis.
Unlike typical high elevation Wilderness Areas, the
Kalmiopsis contains many miles of high quality spawning
and rearing habitat for wild salmon, steelhead, and anadro-
mous cutthroat trout. Southwest Oregon’s steelhead trout
and coho salmon, which inhabit the Kalmiopsis’ rivers, have
been proposed for listing under the federal Endangered
Species Act.
Despite their remoteness and solitude, the Kalmiopsis
Wilderness and adjacent roadless lands are now embroiled
in controversy over old bulldozed mining roads and the
impacts of their use on ancient cedar, endangered salmon, Road crossing the Chetco River. Barbara Ullian photo.
and wilderness values in general. Two roads in particular
strike to the core of the debate—and, as it so happens, others. In one case, two Forest Service employees observed
threaten to pierce the heart of the Kalmiopsis itself. a large party of individuals in 4-wheel drive vehicles open
The Kalmiopsis was designated a Wild Area in 1946 by the Onion Camp gate with a key and drive into the Wilder-
the U.S. Secretary of Agriculture, and gained Congressional ness. The Forest Service has never prosecuted known
protection with the passage of the 1964 Wilderness Act. violators of the Wilderness’ motorized vehicle prohibition.
Although there is no record of authorization for its construc- For one of the claims accessed by the second road, the
tion, the first bulldozed mining road, from Onion Camp to Forest Service has received plans for a large placer mine and
the Little Chetco River, appeared in the 1940s. The original processing plant on the banks of the Chetco River. The plan
owners of mining claims on the Little Chetco were granted calls for two cemented crossings of the Wild Chetco River
motorized ingress and egress in 1963 and made two or three and reconstruction of the fifteen-mile route through the
trips per year. The second road emerged in 1961, when the Kalmiopsis. Now the public is faced with either spending
claimant of 2,100 acres of placer mines on the Chetco River millions of dollars to purchase the mining claims or risk
took two bulldozers, a grader, a dump truck, and assorted 4- large-scale mining deep in the Wilderness.
wheel drive vehicles to blaze fifteen miles of road across The owner of sixty acres of mining claims patented in
some of the most rugged country on the West Coast. He 1988 and 100 acres of unpatented claims on the Little
neither gave notice to nor received authorization from the Chetco River, after years of being allowed by the Forest
Forest Service. Despite the Wild Area designation, the Service to access the patented land without the required
agency’s only action was to ask the miner, after the illegal special use permit or an approved plan of operation, is now
construction, to sign a Special Use Permit which required
him to maintain the Wilderness road.
see “Kalmiopsis” on page 3
From the Wildlands CPR Office...
President Clinton cuts funding for forest road construction...The Grand Canyon
proposes banning all private autos by the year 2000...Yosemite National Park closes
because of flooding and road failures...Yellowstone bison are threatened by groomed
snowmobile trails...Congress targets road construction in a campaign to cut corporate Wildlands
welfare. C
Center for
These are just a few of the ways roads made it into the national news in the past
P
Preventing
few months, and we look at them all in further detail in this issue of the Road- R
Roads
RIPorter. We’ve combined the legal and bibliography notes in this issue by compil-
ing a detailed report on the bison in Yellowstone. We know the issue is quite P.O. Box 7516
Missoula, MT 59807
specific, but also think that this highlights the incredible scope of impacts motorized (406) 543-9551
recreation can cause. Bibliography notes in the next issue will be more general, wildlandsCPR@wildrockies.org
with a focus on the spread of non-native species via roads. www.wildrockies.org/ROADRIP
Muchas Gracias
Thanks to both the Turner Foundation Wildlands Center for Preventing
and the Konsgaard-Goldman Foundation
In this Issue Roads is a national coalition of
grassroots groups and individuals
for generously supporting our work for the Kalmiopsis Threatened, p. 1 working to reverse the severe
next year. And thanks too, to all of you Barbara Ullian ecological impacts of wildland roads.
who have sent in donations in the past few We seek to protect native ecosystems
months—they are much appreciated. We Odes to Roads, p. 4 and biodiversity by recreating an
are also grateful to authors of articles and Kraig Klungness interconnected network of roadless
public wildlands.
essays for this newsletter. Your words and
work are worth their weight in road- Legislative Update, p. 5
ripping machinery! Director
Legal/Bibliography Notes, Bethanie Walder
p. 6
Welkommen James Barnes Office Assistant
Wildlands CPR welcomes John Dillon Aaron Jones
and Scott Bagley for two special projects. Regional Reports, pp. 8-9
John will be presenting a slide show tour in Interns & Volunteers
Outreach & Workshops, p. 10 Chuck Cottrell
April in the Southern Rockies, Utah and
Scott Bagley
Wyoming. Check the outreach section on Video Review, p. 11
page 10 for more information. Newsletter
Dave Havlick, Jim Coefield
Scott is working on our new Road-Ripper’s Guide to Road Removal and Restora-
tion, due out in December 1997. We know lots of you are trying to gain a better Steering Committee
Katie Alvord
understanding of effective and ineffective methods of road removal and this guide Kraig Klungness
will help you do just that. It will include information on prioritizing roads, assessing Sidney Maddock
road removal/decommissioning proposals, understanding different techniques, and Rod Mondt
implementing road removal in different ecological regions, including tundra, desert, Cara Nelson
mountain and wetland. If you have any information you want to pass on to Scott, Mary O'Brien
Tom Skeele
please give us a call or send it to the office.
Advisory Committee
Beaux Arts Jasper Carlton
Libby Ellis
Thanks to office assistant and le bon artiste Aaron Jones for his drawing in this Dave Foreman
issue of the Road-RIPorter. Thanks, too, to Elizabeth O’Leary and John Jonik for Keith Hammer
their line drawings. We are looking for additional drawings and graphics to use in Timothy Hermach
our newsletter. Please contact us if you would like to share your artistic talents. Marion Hourdequin
Lorin Lindner
Andy Mahler
Say It Ain’t So! Robert McConnell
We made two mistakes in the last issue of the RIPorter. The quote by Aldo Stephanie Mills
Leopold on the back cover and in the essay “Driven Wild” should read, “recreational Reed Noss
Michael Soulé
development is a job not of building roads into lovely country, but of building Dan Stotter
receptivity into the still unlovely human mind.” Steve Trombulak
We also neglected one citation from Bibliography Notes: Louisa Willcox
Burkey, T.V. 1993. Edge effect in seed and egg predation at two neotropical rainforest Bill Willers
sites. Ecological Conservation, 66:139-143. Howie Wolke
Barbara Ullian
going New World Mine buyout near Yellowstone National Park.
In 1994, the owner of the patented claims wrote the Forest
Service offering to sell the claims back to the public for
$850,000. He paid $150 for the claims in 1988.
P
lanted firmly in the midst of the Kalmiopsis controversy
is a water-loving conifer endemic to southwest Oregon Mention road closures in southwest Oregon and northern
and northern California called the Port Orford cedar. California and the foul stench of fear and loathing chokes any
Port Orford cedar grows principally in riparian areas and rational debate. While road-induced threats to Port Orford
wetlands where it shades streams, stabilizes streambanks and cedar and the wild land, rivers and species of the Kalmiopsis
floodplains, and provides significant habitat for aquatic, would dictate that the USFS deny motorized access in the
terrestrial, and avian species. In 1995, researchers confirmed Wilderness and adjacent roadless areas, and permanently
that a virulent non-native root disease, Phytophthora lateralis, close eroding mining roads, the agency instead points to the
had been introduced to the Kalmiopsis Wilderness (RIPorter terms of the 1872 Mining Law and promotes 4-wheel drive
vol. I, no. 4). recreational opportunities in the press and on the Internet.
For approximately eight miles of the Little Chetco, the Port The roads in the Kalmiopsis wild lands were and are the
Orford cedar is the dominant vegetation. Cedars here, and on construct of those who claim the 1872 Mining Law gives them
the mainstem Chetco below, are infected with root disease. rank and privilege over the rest of the public and the nation’s
Loss of streamside cedar from the disease is expected to laws including the Wilderness, Clean Water, and Endangered
increase water temperatures and accelerate erosion. Species Acts. These miners and land speculators have taken
Once introduced into a watershed, there is no effective and done what they want to these precious public lands and
means to eradicate the root disease, which is spread primarily rivers, often on only their own authority. These supposed
by the transport of its spores trapped in the mud on the icons of rugged individualism and western independence,
bottom of vehicles and equipment. The disease can spread further demand that the public subsidize their pursuit of
rapidly downstream and kill entire stands of Port Orford cedar. monetary wealth, whether it be for gold or real estate specula-
According to the Siskiyou National Forest, the introduction of tion on prime riverfront National Forest Wilderness lands.
this non-native pathogen into the Kalmiopsis Wilderness was
not likely the result of roads or vehicles, is not “significant,” at Barbara Ullian is the Conservation Director for the Siskiyou
the most only 1,000 acres of the Wilderness will be affected, Regional Educational Project, (541) 474-2265.
and the presence of the root disease in the Wilderness is not of
concern because it surfaced in a remote area. In fact, the root What You Can Do -
disease is found all along the Little Chetco River and the area The Kalmiopsis needs your help. The Siskiyou National
of the mining claims. Not coincidentally, these are accessed by Forest is preparing an environmental impact statement (EIS)
a road—a road that has been subject to increasing and unau- for the Alleman Special Use Permit (Little Chetco mining
thorized 4-wheel drive motorized travel, and heavy equipment claims). The Draft EIS is due for release in late April, 1997.
operation; a road which can facilitate mining, resort develop- Contact Mary Zuschlag, Illinois Valley RD, 26568 Redwood
ment, and logging. Highway, Cave Junction, OR 97523; (541)-592-2166; and
As irreparable as the loss of ancient riparian cedar and request a copy of the DEIS. Insist on full protection of the Port
the introduction of this root disease into the Wilderness is, it Orford cedar, Chetco and Little Chetco Rivers, and strictly-
would be even more tragic if continued motorized traffic enforced closures for all motorized use on trails # 1102, 1124,
spread the disease into the upper watershed of the Kalmiopsis. 1129, and road #087.
The Two-Track and the and implications of what I felt that day. But I knew in my gut
that what had happened was part of a much larger form of
Beer Can disregard that was not good for me, those woods, or any other
wild place. Now, after thirty more years marked with similar
experiences, much thought about them, and much reading, I
What Ripping a Road Affirms have more to say.
Just as that two-track was part of a much larger monster,
By Kraig Klungness working for the prevention, removal, and revegetation of
roads—road-ripping for short—is part of a much larger
I
clearly remember my first anger at a road. It was a crisp configuration of ecological acts and values. It symbolizes their
November morning in 1967, not far from my grandfather’s enlivenment just as those boorishly tossed beer cans symbol-
cabin near the Michigamme River in Michigan’s Upper ized their defacement. The strength I feel in opposition to this
Peninsula. I was fourteen and ecstatic over the newfound defacement lies not in the opposition itself, but in what it
independence of finally being allowed to venture into the affirms.
woods alone to hunt whitetail deer. First, the work of road-ripping affirms the inviolate
After sitting perfectly still for three early-morning hours identity of a wild place you know and love. Most of us have
by an old white pine overlooking a deer run, I got antsy and had experiences similar to mine with similar feelings. Those
decided to stalk eastward onto adjacent state lands and feelings tell you something, that something is wrong, and you
unfamiliar ground. I wanted deeper woods and greater can use the energy they give to respond. It’s personal sweat-
distance from the other hunters I knew were around, to and-tears work to remedy an injury to a place that, when it
experience a more wild hunt. hurts, you hurt.
I meandered through mixed hardwoods, teetered atop the
springy sphagnum moss of a spruce bog, and traversed a rise
of birch. Emerging from a dense grouping of spruce and fir, I
pulled some dry bracken fern from my boot laces, and found
myself on the edge of a two-track logging road. Startled, I
heard an engine just around the bend, coming my way. I
wanted to duck behind a spruce and hide as the vehicle
passed, but it was too late for that. So I stood there, awk-
wardly, as a large four-wheel-drive wagon with three hunters
pulled up and stopped.
The driver asked if I’d seen any deer and I gave what from
then on became my standard answer for such questions: NO.
He grunted a response and threw an empty Hamms beer can—
you know, the land of sky blue waters—into the woods. In
A. Jones
perfect mimicry, his red-capped buddy in the back seat did the
same. I stood there, angry and dismayed, as I watched the
vehicle move on, waddling from side to side through puddles
and pot holes. Second, road-ripping affirms tolerance: tolerance for
Though only fourteen, I had been coming to my natural diversity in all its varied forms. It helps create the
grandfather’s cabin and joyfully immersing myself in the space for manifold wild beings, including humans, to thrive
surrounding woods for ten years. The older I got, the more I and evolve and celebrate their own call of the wild. At the
explored on my own. By the time of this incident, I felt a same time we learn what cannot be tolerated in order to
budding knowledge and love of the ways and beings of this conserve a collective good that includes the nonhuman.
place—the old-growth we called “the pines,” the tag alder Third, road-ripping affirms quietude. A place without
swamp and a chunk of upland in its middle we called “the roads and motors is a much softer, quieter, more welcoming
island,” the gray jays we called “whiskey jacks,” the river, the place, for people and wild things. Engine noise clutters the air
red squirrels, the weasels, the woodchuck, the bobcat, the with mechanical uncleanliness, shrinking spaciousness down
black bear, the Canada lynx that held my grandfather and me to the bark of internal combustion. Getting engines off the
spellbound as it passed through fresh snow within one- land takes us a long way toward hearing nature, toward
hundred feet of us on one year’s trek to get a Christmas tree. solitude and silence, toward a practice of quietude.
It was always exciting to expand my range of travel, to go Fourth, road-ripping affirms the intrinsic value of wild
farther out and discover more. But that one incident, those nature—wilderness for its own sake and not for what it can
beer cans, their ill-mannered tossing, the power wagon, the become to the human enterprise. By preventing the intrusions
goddamn road, changed my whole world right there. The that accompany roads we allow the land community to
place seemed smaller, less enchanted, less wild, more threat- flourish independent of commercial, recreational, and scenic
ened. values.
It wasn't just the two-track and the littering, but the Nature’s intrinsic worth is so important. It’s fundamental.
attitude they symbolized. It was the same attitude that It’s not just intellectual. Breathe it, feel it, walk it. It’s inherent
resulted in the clearcuts I later found down that same road, the in the domain of the more-than-human, of goshawk, river
S
ince that crisp November day in 1967, I’ve had my Roads also fragment wildlife habitat and dump sediment into
favorite route up Lookout Mountain severed by a forty- streams.
foot-wide road corridor. Ditto for East Bluff. The woods 2) Wildland roads are an economic drain on the Ameri-
surrounding a favorite trout stream were roaded and clearcut can taxpayer—in 1996, $95 million was appropriated to the
to within twenty feet of the stream’s banks. Now there’s a Forest Service for the construction and reconstruction of
movement to open the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilder- wildland roads. An additional $81 million was appropriated
ness to trucks and jeeps. Last week, I read that large portions for road maintenance - a critical funding source to continue.
of Alaska’s wildlands, our last great wilderness, are spotted 3) The President’s proposed budget cuts for road pur-
with yellow metal pipes signifying road easements. chaser credits and reducing timber sales in roadless areas are
In The Practice of the Wild, Gary Snyder laments the a good first step toward better road policies. Funding should
“slow-motion explosion of expanding world economies” and continue for road maintenance and decommisioning.
pleads:
If the lad or lass is among us who knows where the What You Can Do -
secret heart of this Growth-Monster is hidden, let them Write President Clinton, Secretary of Agriculture
please tell us where to shoot the arrow that will slow it Glickman and your Congressional representatives:
down. And if the secret heart stays secret and our work •President Clinton, The White House, 1600 Pennsylvania
is made no easier, I for one will keep working for wil- Ave., Washington, D.C. 20050.
derness day by day. •Secretary Glickman, USDA, 200 A Whitten Bldg., 1400
It’s an apt metaphor for the situation with roads, the monster’s Independence Ave. SW, Washinton, D.C. 20250.
tentacles. •U.S. Senate/House, Washington, D.C. 20515.
A
lthough this report focuses on the impacts of motor-
ized winter use on bison, not just big animals are
affected by snowmachine use (RIPorter vol. I, no. 4).
Activists can and should incorporate many of the impacts
described here, since they are pertinent to contexts extending
well beyond the boundaries of Yellowstone National Park or
the American bison.
Snowmobiles and snow coaches impact many types of
“subnivean” animal life—that is, creatures which live below
the snow. In one study, for example, researchers reported a
marked increase in mammal mortality beneath compacted
snow. They concluded that, “Mortality of subnivean mammals
in the area packed by snowmobiles was probably due to a Yellowstone to Old Faithful and back (McMillion, 1994). For
combination of factors that increased winter stress to the point comparison, according to EPA statistics, a modern 150-
where survival was impossible. Mechanical compaction of horsepower automobile engine emits about one pound of the
snowfields will: same emissions. Yellowstone endured 26 million pounds of
•destroy subnivean air spaces pollution in the 1995-96 season. It seems clear that this
•reduce snow depth amount of pollution results in detrimental impacts to Park
•increase density, thermal conductivity, thermal flora, wildlife, and users. The Park Service, however, has largely
diffusivity and shear strength of snow. skirted the issue. For example, after complaints from park
These effects would in turn be inhibitory to mammal employees at the West Yellowstone entrance of headaches,
movement beneath the snow and at the same time subject nausea, and throat and eye irritation, the park’s response was
subnivean organisms to greater temperature stress. There is to renovate the tollbooths “to permit clean oxygen to be piped
also the possibility that air beneath packed snow may become into the toll booths.”
Glossy PR!
Check out the May 1997 issue of Backpacker Magazine for
a brief report on Wildlands CPR and the T-12 Campaign.
Call Wildlands CPR at (406) 543-9551 for more information—dates and times may change
BULK RATE
US POSTAGE
PAID
MISSOULA, MT 59801
PERMIT NO. 569