PEER EVALUATION TO RESEARCH GROUP PARTICIPATION Name of Peer Evaluated:____________________________________Date: _________ Criteria 1.

Involves in group works and helps others in the group. 2. Attends to meeting on time, turns in all work when it is due. 3. Participates in synthesizing concepts or changes for the improvement of research work appropriately. 4. Stays on task all of the time without reminders. 5. Participates in group-work activities enthusiastically (e.g. encoding, editing, collecting data..etc.) 6. Completes assigned tasks and does not depend on others to do the work. 7. Shows sensitivity to needs/feelings of others during discussion. 8. Gathers information and shares useful ideas for discussions. All information fits the groups goals. 9. Meet responsibilities and accountabilities on the delegated tasks. 10. Respectfully listens, discusses, asks questions and helps direct the group in solving problems. 11. Demonstrates positive attitude about the task(s) and the work of others (without complaining and blaming) 12. Seeks Actively and suggests solutions to problems. 13. Works hard up to the final defense TOTAL SCORE: Interpretation of Level of Participation: ALWAYS (4): Particiapation is Performed and Observed at all times. SOMETIMES (3): Participation is Performed and observed frequently. SELDOM (2): Participation is Performed and Observed not often. RARELY (1): Participation is Performed and observed almost never. Always 4 Sometime s 3 Seldom 2 Rarely 1

Signature: _____________________ Peer Evaluator

RESEARCH ADVISER EVALUATION TO RESEARCH GROUP PARTICIPATION

Evaluate each members effectiveness on the following criteria. Rate each member from 1-to-4 (4 being the highest and 1 is the lowest). Give comments, if necessary for your rating. Criteria M1 M2 M3 M4 M5 M6 M7 1. Involves in group works and helps others in the group. 2. Punctual to group meetings and turns in all work when it is due. 3. Participates in synthesizing concepts or changes for the improvement of research work appropriately. 4. Stays on task all of the time without reminders. 5. Participates in group-work activities enthusiastically (e.g. encoding, editing, collecting data..etc.) 6. Completes assigned tasks and does not depend on others to do the work. 7. Gathers information and shares useful ideas for discussions. All information fits the groups goals. 8. Respectfully listens, discusses, asks questions and helps direct the group in solving problems. 9. Demonstrates positive attitude about the task(s) and the work of others (without complaining and blaming) 10. Works to complete all group goals. TOTAL SCORE:
Interpretation of Level of Participation: ALWAYS (4): Participation is Performed and Observed at all times. SOMETIMES (3): Participation is Performed and observed frequently. SELDOM (2): Participation is Performed and Observed not often. RARELY (1): Participation is Performed and observed almost never.

M8

Member 1: Name: _______________________ Comments (if any,) ______________________________________ Member 2: Name: _______________________ Comments (if any,) ______________________________________ Member 3: Name: _______________________ Comments (if any,) ______________________________________ Member 4: Name: _______________________ Comments (if any,) ______________________________________ Member 5: Name: _______________________ Comments (if any,) ______________________________________ Member 6: Name: _______________________ Comments (if any,) ______________________________________ Member 7: Name: _______________________ Comments (if any,) ______________________________________ Member 8: Name: _______________________ Comments (if any,) ______________________________________

Signature over Printed Name of Research Adviser: ______________________ Date: ______________