Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 9

Investment

Bill
Gross Outlook
May/June 2003

Is That All There Is – To A Fire?

Attention K-Mart We answered this


shoppers and the critical secular ques-
private sector ev- tion with a meta-
erywhere! You have phorical response
morphed into a wet in firewood termi-
log. Uncle Sam, nology: Yes, they
Uncle Alan, and as- could, but wet logs
sorted global kin are don’t burn very well.
trying to light your Sure, policy makers
fire again, but so far could keep on ap-
there’s been mainly plying the kindling
smoke and very little – low interest rates,
heat. Wet logs don’t increasing fiscal
burn very well. deficits, and perhaps even a Bernanke
blowtorch if need be – but that’s not a
OK, now that I’ve got your attention, self-sustaining fire. If anything it leads
what could that possibly mean? Well, to more bubbles and new instabilities.
PIMCO’s Secular Forum which meets For a fire to keep on burning late into
annually for three days in May to dis- the night you need the logs to catch, and
cuss the fate of the world and the global the world’s economic firewood has long
markets over the next few years, spent since been soaked by oversupply and
much of the time talking about firewood feeble demand now exacerbated by a
and the use of newspaper, kindling, or post-bubble psychology discouraging
even a blowtorch to get it burning. This risk taking. Wet logs in economic terms
was our approach to conceptualizing the imply slow growth, relatively benign in-
plight of policymakers as they confront flation, and near historically low interest
a post-bubble, debt laden, American rates in which “carry” and “roll-down”
centric/savings short, financial imbal- become fundamental to returns and out-
anced, demographically challenged performance, TIPS do especially well.
global economy. Could government, we It is a world in which stock returns do
asked, reflate the world when the private a slow burn along with everything else
sector was hung over, cranky, irritable, and institutional and individual inves-
and ill disposed to do what it used to do tors eventually resign themselves to less
best – spend money? heat, and making do with a cup of coffee
Investment Outlook

or hot chocolate. Corporations and their debt levels and its suffocating impact
investors have for several years now been on business investment and personal
making like Jim Morrison and implor- spending; because of a creeping, almost
ing policymakers to “light their fire” and imperceptible demographic muting of
restore pricing power. They will, but at consumption in aging societies such as
our secular horizon’s end, Morrison may Japan, Germany, and Italy; because of
in turn change his sex and morph into a market bubble popping and the nega-
mellow version of Peggy Lee, wailing “Is tives of receding wealth; because of the
that all there is – to a fire?” To find out dragnet of post 9/11 and now SARS, be-
why, cuddle up with any blankets you cause of all of that and more we live in
can find and listen to our following pyro- a world where we have too much rela-
technical discussion of a global economy tive to what we can afford to, or want to
whose fate is still in the balance. spend.

Historical Secular Review Current Outlook


To start at the beginning folks, let me just If you accept this PIMCO economic axi-
say that this fire starting stuff is pretty om, then certain private sector behavior
complicated. For three days, over 100 becomes more understandable. In order
Secular Forum participants along with to get out from under the 16-ton sledge-
guest presenters – economist Martin hammer of debt, companies use cash
Feldstein, PBGC’s Executive Director flow to build reserves or retire bonds
Steven Kandarian, Strategist Rob Arnott, – they don’t invest. Consumers begin
and authors William Greider and Kevin to put away money instead of spend,
Phillips – went back and forth on budget which was the pattern of the late 90s.
deficits, currency devals, various esti- And the combination induces a negative
mates of real interest rates, trade deficits, spiral or vicious cycle of even more con-
post 9/11 syndrome, SARS, Iraq, and the servative behavior including job layoffs,
appropriate value of the Renminbi. Just which leads to muted growth in person-
pronouncing Renminbi (RMB) is hard al income. In combination, this private
enough when you’re 59 like yours truly. sector response to a high debt, reduced
Thank goodness we were well stocked wealth, increased risk laden economic
with some cosmopolitan, currency-savvy environment can produce a slowdown
MBA draft picks to show a few of us or even a recession – Japan off and on
where the matches were stored. for years now, the U.S. in 2001/2002,
Europe in 2003. This sometimes volun-
In any case, let me attempt to outline as tary, sometimes imposed economic diet
simply as possible the global economy’s is graphically displayed in the chart on
primary problem: It suffers from a lack the following page.
of aggregate demand and too much sup-
ply. Because of globalization and Chi- As the U.S. private sector retrenches to
nese overproduction; because of high a more normal historic average level of

May/June 2003
U.S. Private Sector Financial Balance 1947-2007, % of GDP
10

-2

-4

-6

-8
1947 Q1 1954 Q3 1962 Q1 1969 Q3 1977 Q1 1984 Q3 1992 Q1 1999 Q3 2007 Q1

Source: US Flow of Funds data, NIPA tables, LSR calculations for period 2002 Q4 to 2007 Q4
Lombard Street Research Monthly International Review 125

Chart 1

total savings, it necessarily acts as an Steven Kandarian, our guest speaker


economic drag – it throws more water from the PBGC, estimates the U.S.
on the logs. Were we to return to typi- private pension system is under water
cal peaks of the past 30 years near 4% of by over $300 billion. Public sector plan
GDP, then real growth will be reduced totals make the number much worse.
by 1% annually over our 3-5 year secu- So expect tens of billions of future cash
lar time frame, relative to what it would flow to be diverted into bonds and
otherwise have been. not productive plant and equipment
– payback time – wet logs for the next
This self-imposed, squirrel-like behav- few years, although long term, healthy
ior, which retrains the savings center in pension plans and corporate balance
our societal brains, may be exacerbated sheets are the foundations for eventual
by enforced changes in government recoveries.
re-regulation typified in the pension ac-
counting area. Britain’s new accounting Then there is the problem of our grow-
standard, FRS17, seems likely to become ing current account deficit, a mysteri-
more of a global norm, compelling ous chicken and egg conundrum that
companies to value their pension assets stirs intense debate but little common
at current market prices. In addition sense or logic. The fact is that we are
new more conservative future return overspending by nearly 6% of GDP
assumptions may flush global corporate – that’s what a trade deficit means. To a
pension funds out into the open, show- certain extent, that number is reflected
ing underfunding at levels such as the in Chart 1, but here’s the point. Moving
U.K.’s displayed on the following page, towards trade account balance/return-
or even worse. ing to a private sector savings mode can
Investment Outlook

Short On Promises
130

120

110

100

90

80

Estimated UK pension funding level for FTSE 100 companies, % 70

2001 2002 2003

Source: UBS Warburg, The Economist

Chart 2

be either voluntary or forced. If we don’t unfathomable complexity, floundering


go there on our own, eventually the financial institutions, a straightjacket
world via a depreciating dollar, a sale called the “Stability Pact,” and a cen-
of our widely foreign owned stocks and tral bank obsessed with the rear view
bonds, or both, will impose an inflation- mirror mirage called “inflation.” Japan
ary tax or a negative wealth effect that is a basket case whose only investment
will mandate the savings via reduced opportunity might be to buy its stocks
consumption. The U.S. over the next 3-5 whose prices can’t go much lower. Chi-
years may still be the strongest non- na is advanced by some as the “Great
Asian economy in the world but it will Asian Hope,” but it is still more of a
by no means be a locomotive. producer than a consumer. As noted in
last year’s review, China is a significant
That negative might be mitigated of deflationary influence. It (and India)
course if some able and willing global makes the logs in the U.S., the U.K., and
competitor would step up to the plate Euroland even wetter by hollowing out
and lead – some country or sector with our manufacturing and services indus-
dry firewood – undrenched by high tries, leaving us less and less to export
debt, slowing demographics, and over- except for our paper assets.
powering regulation. There are few
contestants. Euroland is plagued by an The entire globe of course is shrouded
aging work force, regulatory webs of by geopolitical veils emanating from 9/11.

May/June 2003
Consumer and business confidence is Similarly, the ECB is at 21⁄2% nominal
periodically exposed to terrorist shocks, or about 0% in real terms. The Japanese
or unilateral U.S. decisions as to current central bank is, of course, nominally if
or future “evil doer” national behavior not absolutely UNREAL. Add to all of
and our self-imposed remedies. Preludes this the vow by the Fed’s Bernanke and
to war seem to be far more confidence now Greenspan to defeat deflation at
inhibiting than the short afterglow of any cost with any means and you get
their conclusion. One significant ter- a sense as to the “fire” power at their
rorist attack in future months or years command.
could be economically calamitous. And
airline travel/tourism, already affected Fiscal policy is proactive too, although
for 20 months by fear and security held back in Euroland by the (3% max
measures surrounding the World Trade deficit) Stability Pact and in the U.S. by
Center attacks is now doubly vulnerable Clintonian advocacy of a decade past,
to the perceived plague of SARS. This which ascribed the miracle of the New
is not the normal world we once knew Age Economy to balanced budgets.
and believed in at the turn of the mil- Japan has its limits as well, less they
lennium. Drying these logs will take an risk a rating agency downgrade close to
extended period of sunshine or perhaps junk bond status. But we expect more
government sector kindling of bonfire fiscal gasoline in future years from each
magnitude. of these burdened economic societies.
$500 billion+ will be the U.S. standard; a
That bonfire, of course, has been burn- “see no evil” fudge of the Stability Pact
ing for some time now. Last year’s will be Europe’s. For Japan, changes are
Secular Outlook, and summaries (en- always out there – “somewhere.”
treaties) by PIMCO’s Paul McCulley in
the past 12 months have aptly described So government is fighting back, and
the transition of influence (and power) before we morph from Jim Morrison to
that takes place during periods of pri- Peggy Lee, we must critically ask – what
vate sector malaise. Budget surpluses kind of fire will this be a few years
are turned into deficits with the tap of a hence? Standard cyclical economists
legislative wand. Short-term real inter- and firestarters answer that it will be
est rates drop to 0% levels or below. a pretty hot one – Greenspan certainly
While all central banks are not created talks that way as he points to a New
or conceived equally, it’s fair to say that Age Economic revival. We are less op-
monetary gasoline is being poured on timistic for all of the reasons cited that
the global economy’s wet logs in signifi- have provided and will maintain wet
cant quantities. Greenspan has pegged logs. We see 2-3% inflation in the U.S.
the Fed Funds rate at 11⁄4%. That is a and 2-3% max real growth over the next
nominal rate, which when adjusted for 3-5 years; 1-2% inflation in Euroland
current inflation of about 21⁄4% converts and 1-2% max real growth, – barely
to a negative real fed funds rate of -1%. above the line in Japan. Not much of
Investment Outlook

a fire. Some emerging market econo- days are over – no more capital gains
mies may do relatively better as lower – but that a bear market may be years
real interest rates and more aggressive away. As critical a question to ask in ad-
reforms lead to increased reserves and dition to “Is that all there is – to a fire?”
a greater sense of stability. Nonethe- is, “How long does the Fed (and the ECB)
less, it will be a Peggy Lee world, but stay low and what is a sustainable real
the mellowness of the inflation and real interest rate in this new environment?”
growth will mask the potential vola- Answer that and you have a big piece
tility engendered by a levered world of the future’s investment puzzle. Our
dependent upon finance for it’s warmth. current supposition is that they stay low
A system built on the basis of a free for several years at least and that a real
flow of capital can be severely damaged interest rate of 1% after that, instead of
by volatility within the system itself. the historic 2-3% level, may become the
Peggy Lee never lived in Butler Creek standard. A debt laden, levered global
– (PIMCO’s phrase in the mid-90s for economy cannot stand much in the way
a placid economy and financial mar- of interest rate hikes. The past few years’
kets). Our perceived economy may at reductions have barely kept us above
the average appear to be an eddy, but water – mortgage refis and all. Just think
there are rapids on either side. This will of what happens to housing and hous-
be a global economy fraught with risk. ing equalization when the cycle reverses.
Unregulated hedge funds, collateralized Economy GONZO.
debt obligations, and poorly structured
derivatives of all kinds that redistribute Bond investors should not be shocked by
risk but do not eliminate it portend the this 1% real rate assumption. The chart
likelihood of another LTCM debacle on the following page points out that it
at some point. Greenspan is clearly off was only during the post-1980 period that
base in his support of derivatives and short-term real interest rates were abnor-
their medicinal “hedging” qualities. mally high on a global basis. Periods of
Leverage cannot ultimately be hedged disinflation (and certainly deflation) tend
in a finance dominated global economy to produce high real rates because central
when interest rates rise. There will be a banks are squeezing inflation out of the
piper to pay when the firestarters run system. All other periods including refla-
out of fuel. tionary ones have much lower real rates,
averaging – believe it or not – a negative
Investment Policy .7% globally for the first 80 years of the
20th century.
So where should you put, how might
we invest your money in this global
This 1% real rate assumption in the U.S.,
economy with insufficient heat, but more
and even lower elsewhere, is critical
than enough volatility? With government
because if true, it allows bond portfolio
yields at near record lows, we remain
managers to profit not only from the
convinced that Treasury bond’s salad
carry of higher yields of longer duration

May/June 2003
Real Interest Rates Internationally Pre- and Post- 1980
8 7.2
Percent Per Year

6
4.6 4.9 4.5 4.5 4.8 4.7
4.1
4 3.7 3.7
3.1 3.2
2.6 2.8
2.1
2 1.5 1.3 1.7
1.1 0.9 0.9
0.1 0.2 0.4 0.4
0
-0.1
-0.7 -0.7 -0.6
-2 -1.6 -1.5

-3.1 Before 1980


-4
1980 - 2000
-4.8
-6 -5.4

-8
Ita Fra Jap Bel Ger AVG Aus Spa Neth UK SAf US Ire Can Swi Swe Den

Source: Triumph of the Optimists, Princeton University Press

Chart 3

instruments but from what is known as rates staying close to existing levels yet
“roll-down” – the mild appreciation of they guard against inflationary excess.
price as a 5-year note matures into a 4-
year note at lower yields – rising in price The “roll down” of risk assets can be cap-
simply by surviving for 12 more months. tured as well of course, but their wider
This little trick of alchemy that requires bid-ask spreads and reduced liquidity
of course a rebalancing and reextension force an analysis of their attractiveness
of maturities at the appropriate period’s more on a yield standard as well as their
end, essentially adds 1% to total Treasury ability to narrow the “basis” spread to
returns. In combination with appropriate Treasuries. The past few month’s remark-
slightly longer than market durations, an able rally in credit product, including
annual return of nearly 5% from Treasur- high yield and emerging market debt
ies is not out of the question as long as make us more cautious in this area than
the Fed stays low and 1% “real” becomes we were 12 months ago when opportunity
the norm. So 5-15 year Treasuries with was just opening up. Besides, if another
yield and roll downs are not as bad as LTCM or terrorist attack is out there
they appear on their yield surface. The somewhere in our future, risk assets will
days of eating salad may be over, but 5% have a good chance of living up to their
is ample sustenance in a low inflation- name. U.S. stocks in our opinion remain
ary environment. This secular horizon more than fully valued using dividend
should also be an attractive relative yield, Tobin’s Q, and price to book stan-
period for holding TIPS. Their current dards of more rational periods. European
prices depend upon low real interest markets where dividend yields nearly
match 10-year bond rates (U.K., France) important, but a broad list of existing
are far more appealing as are many of publicly traded funds can be viewed in
those in Asia including that of Japan! Barron’s, The Wall Street Journal or The New
York Times on a weekly basis. PIMCO, of
Non-U.S. bond markets may still have a course, has numerous municipal bond
little salad left on the table. The ECB has funds that are listed on the NYSE.
lagged the Fed and will undoubtedly
have more firewood to chop in order Farewell
to hold their economies above the 0%
Well we’ve gone on long enough now
growth rate line, especially in light of the
– talking about fires and pop-singers as
super strong Euro which is a deflationary
if we know a lot about both. We know
influence on the continent. We are not
some things though. We know that a
significant currency investors but despite
look at the secular investment horizon
the dollar’s weakness in recent months,
eliminates some emotion and induces
there may be more ahead in future years
at least a modicum of critical analysis
in order to redress our current account
on the valuation of fixed income and
balance. In addition, Euroland and Asia
other securities. We know that we’re not
may not always support our lifestyle and
perfect at it, that we make mistakes and
military supremacy that is reflected in
that in the process there are opportunity
the trade deficit. A further dollar debacle
costs and a few absolute black hole losses.
from here based on politics and the sale
We know that we have a responsibility,
of U.S. financial assets is a possibility.
to our clients in the primary instance
What that implies about an uncom-
but to economic society as well in order
petitive European manufacturing base
to distribute capital rationally and pro-
is a chapter for Alice in Wonderland – it
ductively over time. We are not firestart-
probably means the ECB will come closer
ers, nor even fire extinguishers, but fire
to mimicking Japanese interest rates than
marshals in the investment world. There
we will – but only the monetary firestart-
will be much to marshal and monitor in
ers can determine the timing.
the years ahead.
Individual investors who read this Outlook
William H. Gross
and have stuck with this lengthy sum-
Managing Director
mary to this point can take advantage of
these low short term interest rate trends/
forecasts by purchasing municipal closed-
end bond funds that take advantage of
mild leverage and borrowing costs near
1% to offer yields in excess of 6% in the
case of tax-free municipals. Research is
840 Newport Center Drive
Newport Beach, CA 92660
949.720.6000
This material is not intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any financial instrument. References to specific securities and
their issuers are for illustrative purposes only and are not intended to be, and should not be interpreted as, recommendations to purchase or sell
such securities. For more information on the investment strategies described please consult your financial advisor.

Past performance is no guarantee of future results. There is no guarantee that these investment strategies will work under all market
conditions and each investor should evaluate their ability to invest for a long-term especially during periods of downturn in the market.
This article contains the current opinions of the manager and does not represent a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or
investment product and is for educational purposes only. Such opinions are subject to change without notice. No part of this publication may
be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without express written permission.

Each sector of the bond market entails risk. The guarantee on Treasuries & Government Bonds is to the timely repayment of principal and
interest. Shares of mutual funds are not guaranteed. Mortgage-backed securities & Corporate Bonds may be sensitive to interest rates. When
interest rates rise the value of fixed income securities generally declines. There is no assurance that private guarantors or insurers will meet
their obligations. An investment in high-yield securities generally involves greater risk to principal than an investment in higher-rated bonds.
Investing in foreign securities may entail risk due to foreign economic and political developments and may be enhanced when investing in
emerging markets. The credit quality of the investment in the portfolio does not apply to the stability or safety of the investment. A derivative
instrument is a contract whose value is based on the performance of an underlying financial asset, index or other investment. An investment
in derivatives, investors could lose more than the principal amount of their investment and is subject to the risk of the issuer’s ability to meet
payments on obligations. Municipals may realize gains and shareholders will incur a tax liability from time to time. Income from the funds
that invest in them are subject to state and local taxes & may at times be subject to the alternative minimum tax. It’s important to note that a
fund concentrating in a single state is subject to greater risk of adverse economic conditions and regulatory changes than a fund with broader
geographical diversification. Diversification does not ensure against loss. Duration is a measure of price sensitivity expressed in years. Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) is a measure of output from U.S. factories and related consumption in the United States. It does not include products
made by U.S. companies in foreign markets.

Closed-end exchange traded management investment companies. Closed-end funds, unlike open-end funds, are not continuously offered.
There is a one-time public offering and once issued, shares of closed-end funds are sold in the open market through a stock exchange. For
additional information on the closed-end funds, contact your financial advisor. ©2003, Pacific Investment Management Company LLC.

Вам также может понравиться