Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
de Niverville 1 Barbara Safran de Niverville Jan Avgikos, Faculty Advisor 04 April 2013 Japonisme: From Edo to Rothko It is easy to be charmed by the arabesque lines, graceful color and stylized details in traditional Japanese art. The Edo period, particularly, produced opulent, yet simplified, images of nature1 on screens, scrolls and prints such as Irises at Yatsuhashi (Eight Bridges) by Ogata Krin (1658-1716) or Flowering Plants and Vegetables of the Four Seasons (early 18th century). The depiction of plants and birds rivals the finest drawings in Europe of the same period (1615 1868). Much has been written about the opening up of Japan to trade with the West in 1854 following a 200-year period of seclusion. European artists looking for ways to break with European academic tradition adopted expressive line, abstract graphic style, decorative colors and dramatic asymmetrical compositions as a response to ukiyo-i woodblock prints and Japanese applied arts. This enthusiasm also coincided with a fascination for decorative styles. From the early 1860s, Japonisme could be found in nearly all media across a variety of stylistic movements. (Floyd) Jean-Pierre Lehman summarizes that Japonisme was born from the Edo era and was concentrated on the world of the senses: Japan was extolled as a land of ascetic superiority and sensual sensitivity. (758) An impressive number of western artists fell under the spell of Japanese prints and artifacts, including James McNeill Whistler, Edouard Manet, Edgar Degas, Claude Monet, 1 Nature: that which is not directly produced by humans, and which acts independently of humanity. See Soper page 15.
Safran de Niverville 2 and Vincent Van Gogh. (Floyd) However, this enthusiasm was not without its problematic aspects. Images, and the attitudes and stereotypes which they give rise to, tend to be formed at an early stage of encounter between two societies; in other words initial impressions have a strong power of preservation. Following from this, it is clear that images rarely keep pace with reality. (Lehman 757) European artists tended to introduce external, stylistic elements of Japanese arts into their own work. For instance, James McNeill Whistler believed that borrowing Japanese motifs liberated his art from the narrative and moralistic demands of Victorian painting. Caprice in Purple and Gold: The Golden Screen (1864) is a portrait of Joanna Hiffernan costumed in a sumptuous kimono, examining prints by Hiroshige. She is seated on the floor in front of a golden Japanese screen. The composition tilts slightly, as if Whistler is viewing the scene from above. Diagonals of the carpet add visual movement to an otherwise static arrangement, but the painting remains an occidental view of exotic artifacts. Another more well known painting from the same series, La Princesses du pays de la porcelaine 1863-65, hangs in the famed Peacock Room in the Freer Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. The model, Christina Spartalli, poses as one of the elongated figures typical of Chinese porcelain and Japanese ukiyo-I prints. (Freer/Sackler) Whistler succeeded in integrating Japanese elements in more minimalist compositions in his series of Nocturnes. Nocturne: Blue and Gold Old Battersea Bridge 1872-5 seems reminiscent of Hiroshiges prints of bridges in his One Hundred Famous Views of Edo series, while it stands as a signature piece of Whistlers work.
Safran de Niverville 3 Claude Monet also posed a model in an ornate kimono, his wife Camille, in the painting La Japonaise of 1876. Holding a fan, she wears a blond wig, as if to point out her European origins. Looking back in 1918, Monet called it a fantasy. He related that he had exhibited the dark The Woman in Green at the Salon of 1866 with success and it was suggested that he try to repeat it. He was shown the gold-embroidered robe, which became the focus of the light-hearted and airy painting La Japonaise. (Gimpel qtd. in Stuckey) In 1906, Kakuzo Okaruras The Book of Tea was published in an effort to explain Japanese traditions to the West. At the time, Okakura was known as a scholar, art critic and curator of Chinese and Japanese Art at the Boston Museum of Fine Arts. In this essay, Okakura explained the peculiar orientality of the Orient and used tea as his symbol. (Bleiler qtd. in Okakura iii:xv) Teaism ia a cult founded on the adoration of the beautiful among the sordid facts of everyday existence. It inculcates purity and harmony, the mystery of mutual charity, the romanticism of the social order. It is essentially a worship of the Imperfect, as it is a tender attempt to accomplish something possible in this impossible thing we know as life. (Okakura 1) The contrasting of the opulent or the perfect with the impoverished or imperfect facilitates the appreciation of each. This Japanese notion of wabi, is a . . . quintessentially Japanese taste. . . . One of the hallmarks of the traditional Japanese design principle is harmony brought about by juxtaposing disparate, often contrasting, elements. The unity of the whole is designed to emerge spontaneously from the contribution of each element (Saito 377 - 379)
Safran de Niverville 4 Kamisaka Sekka (1866-1942) is often regarded as the father of modern Japanese design. His three woodblock-printed books A Thousand Grasses (Chigusa) produced between 1899 and 1900, are stunning samples of restraint, elegance and simplicity. They seem to form a bridge between Japanese tradition and Western modernism.2 Another key period in the exchange between East and West occurred mid-century in
the
1940s
-
50s.
The
avant-garde
beat
generation
in
New
York
and
San
Francisco
developed
an
intense
interest
in
the
Buddhist
religion
as
an
antidote
for
the
paranoia
and
conformity
of
American
society
at
that
time.
Resembling
the
earlier
theosophists3,
some
Beats
were
convinced
that
eastern
religion
expressed
an
ancient
wisdom
required
for
balancing
the
excesses
of
western
technological
society.
They
envisioned
a
universal
human
community
undivided,
without
obstacles
imposed
by
ethnic
origin
or
creed.
The
Beat
poets
introduced
Buddhism
to
Americans
in
a
refreshing
way.4
(Chandler
312-13,
316)
2
On
display
in
the
Designing
Nature:
The
Rinpa
Aesthetic
in
Japanese
Art
exhibition
at
the
Metropolitan
Museum
of
Art
in
New
York,
May
26,
2012
January
13,
2013.
3
Theosophy:
the
teachings
of
a
modern
movement
originating
in
the
US
in
1875
and
following
chiefly
Buddhist
and
Brahmanic
theories
especially
of
pantheistic
evolution
and
reincarnation.
Merriam-Websters
Collegiate
Dictionary.
11th
ed.
4
Allan
Ginsberg
stumbled
upon
Zen
Buddhism
in
the
New
York
Public
Library
in
1953.
He also found books on Chinese painting. In 1954, Jack Kerouac read various Buddhist and Hindu texts. (See Chandler 314) Beat poets frequented the same bar as Abstract Expressionist artists. (See Landau)
Safran
de
Niverville
5
The
origins
of
the
word
'beat'
are
obscure
.
.
.
More
than
mere
weariness,
it
implies
the
feeling
of
having
been
used,
of
being
raw.
It
involves
a
sort
of
nakedness
of
mind,
and,
ultimately,
of
soul;
a
feeling
of
being
reduced
to
the
bedrock
of
consciousness.
(Holmes)
Of
the
same
era,
Mark
Rothkos
paintings
have
been
described
by
many
commentators
as
representations
of
nothingness.5
The
common
characteristics
of
these
writings
is
that
Rothkos
paintings,
because
of
the
reduction
of
figure,
line,
space
and
color,
are
on
the
verge
of
nothing.
Natalie
Kosoi
maintains
that
Rothkos
nothingness
is
reminiscent
of
Heideggers
slipping
away
of
the
whole.
.
.
.
It
is
a
state
in
which
we
touch
the
deepest
core
of
ourselves.
(27)
The
enveloping
effect
of
Rothkos
colored
rectangles
also
recalls
the
oneness
sought
by
practitioners
of
Zen
Buddhism,
who
through
meditation,
seek
to
empty
the
mind
and
discover
the
center
of
their
being.
Shunryu
Suzuki,
an
influential
Zen
teacher
in
America,
taught
that
it
is
necessary
to
believe
in
nothing.
This
nothing
has
nor
form
or
color,
it
exists
before
all
forms
and
colors
appear.
Something
appears
from
nothing
in
a
phenomenal
existence.
(144)6
5
Nothingness:
Non-existence,
void,
emptiness.
Merriam-Websters
Collegiate
Dictionary.
11th
ed.
In
her
essay
Nothingness
Made
Visible:
The
Case
of
Rothkos
Paintings,
Natalie
Kosoi
cites
James
E.
B.
Breslin,
Barbara
Novak
and
Brian
O
Doherty
and
Robert
Rosenblum
as
examples.
6
I
have
quoted
a
small
element
from
Suzukis
seminal
text,
Zen
Mind,
Beginners
Mind.
See
the entire text for a better grasp of Zen concepts. Rothkos paintings have also been related to nothingness as death. See Wilkin for a full discussion.
Safran de Niverville 6 However, in 1943, Mark Rothko and Adolph Gotlieb declared in the New York Times, There is no such thing as good painting about nothing. We assert that the subject is crucial and only that subject-matter is valid which is tragic and timeless. (Gotlieb, Rothko and Newman) Perhaps these statements are indicative of the artists intention differing from the interpretations of his viewers. By 1949, Rothko had developed his classic style of floating rectangles, which have become synonymous with his style (Wilkin 28) and perhaps with nothingness, in spite of his comments to the contrary. Rothkos paintings intrigue me with their ambiguous manipulation of figure- ground relationships and their apparent simplicity of concept. The subtle colors amplify the sensation of being engulfed in a primal void. Earlier works such as No. 13, (White, Red on Yellow) 1958 seem to glow in a happier state than the dark canvases of the late 1960s such as Untitled 1967 and Untitled (White, Black, Rust or Brown) 1968. The close tonality of these later works creates an atmosphere of mystery and deepness.7 Despite their apparent simplicity, Rothkos paintings achieved a richness of color through hundreds of meticulously layered sheets of paint. He mixed his own paints, often with unusual materials. (Waters) Karen Wilkin notes that Rothko deliberately confused the conventional reading of pictorial space, creating ambiguity between distant and near forms, between depth and flatness. His paintings also blur differences between boundaries and colors, at times disappearing into dark monochromes. (28) This ambiguity approaches the Zen notion of oneness, of letting go of the duality of Western thinking. (Suzuki 2, 7)
Safran
de
Niverville
7
Although
this
concept
can
be
read
into
Rothkos
work,
he
was
known
to
be
more
influenced
by
the
nihilist8
writings
of
Nietzsche.
(Lequeux
122
and
Nehamas)
As
an
artist,
I
can
appreciate
the
splendor
of
Edo-period
works
like
Irises
at
Yatsuhashi
(Eight
Bridges)
as
well
as
the
restraint
and
elegance
of
rustic
Japanese
tea
bowls
and
water
vessels9.
What
I
admire
in
these
works
are
the
figure-ground
relationships,
simplified
line
drawing,
asymmetry
and
simplicity
in
the
use
of
natural,
rough
materials.
The
notion
of
wabi,
finding
beauty
in
the
unfinished
or
the
rough,
becomes
a
way
of
simplifying
the
tangled
and
baroque
subject
of
my
garden.
Asymmetrical
figure-ground
relationships
help
me
to
arrange
pictorial
elements
as
I
develop
a
work.
The
contrast
between
the
perfect
and
the
imperfect,
the
worn
and
the
new
can
create
visual
tension
in
a
subject
that
could
descend
into
hackneyed
sentimentality
without
it.
In
a
different
way,
Mark
Rothkos
large
canvases
inspire
me
in
awe
and
contemplation
with
their
subtlety,
drawing
me
into
their
depths.
8
Nihilism:
A
viewpoint
that
traditional
values
and
beliefs
are
unfounded
and
that
existence
is
senseless
and
useless.
Merriam-Websters
Collegiate
Dictionary,
11th
ed.
9
View
Gallery
280,
Arts
of
Japan,
Museum
of
Fine
Arts
Boston.
Safran de Niverville 8 Works Cited Chandler, Daniel Ross. "The Beat Generation And Buddhist Religion." Asia Journal Of Theology 21.2 (2007): 312-324. Academic Search Premier. Web. 21 Mar. 2013. Ann Davis. "Theosophy." Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press. Web. 28 Mar. 2013. Floyd, Phylis. "Japonisme." Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press. Web. 26 Mar. 2013. Flowering Plants and Vegetables of the Four Seasons. Early 18th century. Ink and color on gilt paper. Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. Web. 1 Apr. 2013.
Freer/Sackler Gallery. Caprice in Purple and Gold: The Golden Screen. Slideshow: Whistler. Web. 1 Apr. 2013. <https://www.asia.si.edu/explore/american/Whistler_slideshow.asp> Gotlieb, Adolph, Mark Rothko and Barnett Newman. Statement. New York Times. 13 June 1943. Art in Theory. Ed. by Charles Harrison & Paul Wood. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing. 2003. Print. Holmes, John Clellon "This is the Beat Generation". The New York Times Sunday Magazine. 19 November 1952. Web. 26 March 2013. <http://websupport1.citytech.cuny.edu/Faculty/pcatapano/US2/ US%20Documents/beatgeneration.html> Landau, Ellen G. "Beat Movement." Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press. Web. 3 Apr. 2013. Krin, Ogata. Irises at Yatsuhashi (Eight Bridges) Ogata Krin (1658-1716 ) Date-
Safran de Niverville 9 after 1709 Edo period 1615 1868 six-panel folding screens. Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. Web. 1 Apr. 2013. Kosoi, Natalie. "Nothingness Made Visible: The Case Of Rothko's Paintings." Art Journal 64.2 (2005): 21-31. Art Full Text (H.W. Wilson). Web. 15 Mar. 2013.
Issue:
Edo
Culture
and
Its
Modern
Legacy
(1984),
pp.
757-768
JStor.
Web.12
March
2013.
Lequeux,
Emmanuelle.
"Mark
Rothko:
La
Lumire
Noire.
(French)."
Beaux
Arts
Magazine
292
(2008):
120-127.
Art
Full
Text
(H.W.
Wilson).
Web.
15
Mar.
2013.
Monet,
Claude.
La
Japonaise.
Oil
on
canvas.
1876.
Museum
of
Fine
Arts,
Boston.
Monet:
A
Retrospective.
New
York:
Beaux
Arts
Editions.
1985.
Page
84.Print.
---. The Woman in the Green Dress. 1866. Oil on canvas. Kuntshalle, Bremen.
Monet: A Retrospective. New York: Beaux Arts Editions. 1985. Page 24. Print.
Nehamas, Alexander. "Nietzsche, Friedrich." Grove Art Online. Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press. Web. 29 Mar. 2013.
Okakura,
Kakuzo.
The
Book
of
Tea.
New
York:
Dover
Publications,
Inc.
1964.
Print.
Rothko, Mark. No. 13 ( Red, White on Yellow). 1958. Oil on canvas. Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. ---. Untitled. 1967. Oil on canvas. Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. ---. Untitled
(White,
Black,
Rust
or
Brown)
1968.
Oil on canvas. Metropolitan
Safran de Niverville 10 Museum of Art, New York. Saito, Yuriko . The Japanese Aesthetics of Imperfection and Insufficiency. Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 55.4 (Fall 1997): 377385. Art Full Text (H.W. Wilson). Web. 14 Nov. 2012 Sekka, Kamisaka. A Thousand Grasses (Chigusa). Three woodblock-printed books. Private collection. Designing Nature: The Rinpa Aesthetic in Japanese Art. Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. 26 May 2012 13 Jan. 2013. Soper, Kate. What is Nature? Culture, Politics and the non-Human. Oxford, UK: Blackwell Publishers Ltd., 1995. Print. Stuckey, Charles F. Ed. Diary of an Art Dealer 1918-1923. Ren Gimpel in Monet: A Retrospective. New York: Beaux Arts Editions. 1985. Pages 306-7. Print. Suzuki, Shunryu. Zen Mind, Beginners Mind. Boston: Shambhala Library. 2006. Print. Waters, Florence. Vandalised Mark Rothko Could Take 18 Months to Restore. The Telegraph. 21 Nov. 2012. Web. 29 Mar. 2013. Whistler, James McNeill. Caprice in Purple and Gold: The Golden Screen. 1864. Oil on wood panel. Freer/Sackler Galleries, Smithsonians Museums of Asian Art. ---. La princesse du pays de la porcelaine. 1863-65. Oil on canvas. Freer/Sackler Galleries, Smithsonians Museums of Asian Art. ---. Nocturne: Blue and Gold Old Battersea Bridge 1872-5. Oil on canvas. Tate Britain. Wilkin, Karen. "Mark Rothko: The Decisive Decade." New Criterion 31.3 (2012): 42-46. Art Full Text (H.W. Wilson). Web. 15 Mar. 2013.