Complaint Ubid V Godaddy

FILED: APRIL 6, 2009
Case 1:09-cv-02123 Document 1 Filed 04/06/2009 Page 1 of 22

09CV2123
JUDGE KOCORAS
MAGISTRATE JUDGE COX !"#$%&#'"!$&(#)$*$&)#(!)$+!,$#,-'+$#
.-+#$%&#"-+$%&+"#(!)$+!,$#-.#!//!"-!)#
BR &*)$&+"#(!0!)!-"!
!
#$%&'!%()*'! ! ! ! ! +!
! ! ! !! ! ! +! ),-.!(/*0! ! ! !
! ! ! 12,345366'! !! +! !
! ! ! ! ! ! +! !789:.0!! ! ! !
! ;*!! ! ! ! ! +!
! ! ! ! ! ! +! <,:3-5=,5.0! ! ! !
>?@!AB&C&&D!AEB#1'!%()*!,49! +! !
AB&C&&D*)B<'!%()'! ! ! +! !
! ! ! ! ! ! +! 1234#$3567#(896:;8;##
! ! ! &.6.49,45-*! ! +!
!
!
,-<=/*!"$#
! (BF! )B<@G! 5H.! 12,345366'! #$%&! %()'! IJ8$%&K+! LM! ,49! 5H=/8:H! 35-! 849.=-3:4.9!
)/84-.2! /6! E.N/=9'! N/OP2,34-! ,49! ,22.:.-'! 8P/4! 346/=O,53/4! ,49! L.23.6'! .QN.P5! ,-! 5/! 5H/-.!
P,=,:=,PH-!,PP23N,L2.!5/!35-.26'!RH3NH!,=.!L,-.9!/4!P.=-/4,2!S4/R2.9:.'!,:,34-5!&.6.49,45-!>?@!
AB&C&&D!AEB#1!%()*!,49!AB&C&&D*)B<'!%()!IN/22.N53;.2M!JA/&,99MK+!,-!6/22/R-0!
"*$'+&#-.#$%&#*,$!-"#
! "*! >H3-!3-!,4!,N53/4!849.=!C453NML.=-T8,5534:!)/4-8O.=!1=/5.N53/4!CN5!IJC)1CK!/=!
JCN5K+'!!"# $%&%'%(%#)# !!*"+,-'! ,-! ,! =.-825! /6! A/&,99MU-!322.:,2! 345.=4.5! -NH.O.!5H,5! :.4.=,5.-!
=.;.48.! 6=/O! 5H.! 84,85H/=3V.9! 5,S34:'! 8-.'! ,49! O/4.53V,53/4! /6! 8$%&U-! ;,28,L2.! O,=S-*! 8$%&!
-..S-! =.9=.--! 6/=! 9,O,:.-! N,8-.9! 5/! 35! 849.=! 5H.! C)1C! 6/=! A/&,99MU-! 8-.'! =.:3-5=,53/4'!
5=,663NS34:! 34! ,49W/=! 23N.4-34:! /6! J&.N.P53;.! &/O,34-K'! RH3NH! ,=.! 9/O,34! 4,O.-! 5H,5! ,=.!
39.453N,2!/=!N/468-34:2M!-3O32,=!5/!8$%&U-!;,28,L2.'!P=/5.N5.9'!93-534N53;.!,49!6,O/8-!O,=S-*!!
! X*! A/&,99M!322.:,22M!,NH3.;.-!O/4.5,=M!:,34!LM!S4/R34:2M!93;.=534:!345.=4.5!5=,663N!
5/! -,39! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-*! >H.! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-! 34! 5H3-! N,-.! ,=.! JP,=S.9! P,:.-K! O.,434:!
5H.M! 93-P2,M! 4/! -8L-5,453;.! N/45.45! ,49! ,=.! 8-.9! .QN28-3;.2M! 6/=! 5H.! 93-P2,M! /6! =.;.48.!
:.4.=,534:! A//:2.! C9F/=9-! ,9;.=53-.O.45-*! A/&,99M! 9.=3;.-! =.;.48.! .,NH! 53O.! ,4! 345.=4.5!
! "!
8-.=!3-!93=.N5.9!5/!5H.!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-!,49!,4!,9;.=53-.O.45!3-!JN23NS.9K*!A/&,99M!H,-!L..4!
9.=3;34:!=.;.48.!6=/O!O/=.!5H,4!/4.!H849=.9!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-!-/2.2M!R35H!5H.!345.45!5/!P=/635!
6=/O!,9;.=53-34:!/4!9/O,34!4,O.-!5H,5!,=.!N/468-34:2M!-3O32,=!5/!8$%&U-!;,28,L2.!O,=S-*!!
)'>1&,$#<*$$&+#1'+!)(!,$!-"#*"(#0&"'&#
! Y*! >H3-! 3-! ,4! ,N53/4! 6/=! NML.=-T8,5534:! 849.=! "Z! #*G*)*! [! ""XZI9+*! >H3-! )/8=5! H,-!
-8L\.N5!O,55.=!\8=3-93N53/4!/;.=!5H3-!N2,3O!P8=-8,45!5/!X]!#*G*)*![!"YY"*!
! ^*! _.48.! 3-! P=/P.=! 34! 5H3-! 7893N3,2! &3-5=3N5! P8=-8,45! 5/! X]! #*G*)*! [! "Y`"IL+! ,-! ,!
-8L-5,453,2!P,=5!/6!5H.!.;.45-!/=!/O3--3/4-!:3;34:!=3-.!5/!5H.!N2,3O!,49!5H.!,N58,2!H,=O!5/!12,345366!
/NN8==.9!34!5H3-!&3-5=3N5!LM!=.,-/4!/6!5H.!&.6.49,45-U!N/498N5!,-!,22.:.9!L.2/R*!
=*+$!&)#*"(#=&+)-"*/#1'+!)(!,$!-"#
# Z*! 12,345366! 8$%&! 3-! ,! &.2,R,=.! N/=P/=,53/4! R35H! 35-! P=34N3P,2! P2,N.! /6! L8-34.--!
2/N,5.9!,5!)H3N,:/'!%2234/3-!abaY"*!8$%&!3-!5H.!2.,934:!,--.5!=.N/;.=M!-/2853/4-!N/OP,4M!6/=!5H.!
R/=29U-!O/-5!5=8-5.9!L=,49-!H,;34:!-/29!/;.=!cX!L3223/4!/6!.QN.--!34;.45/=M!/;.=!5H.!2,-5!.2.;.4!
M.,=-*!
a*! &.6.49,45!>H.!A/&,99M!A=/8P!%4N*!3-!,4!C=3V/4,!N/=P/=,53/4!R35H!35-!P=34N3P2.!
P2,N.! /6! L8-34.--! 2/N,5.9! ,5! "^^ZZ! (*! ?,M9.4! E9*'! G835.! X"`! GN/55-9,2.'! Cd! ]ZXab*! %5-! -.26e
9.-N=3L.9!J62,:-H3P!N/OP,4MK!3-! &.6.49,45!A/&,99M*N/O!%4N*!RH3NH!P8=P/=5-!5/!L.!5H.!R/=29U-!
2.,934:!%)C((e,NN=.935.9!9/O,34!4,O.!=.:3-5=,=!6/=!*)B<'!*(@>'!*BEA'!*%(fB'!*$%d!,49!*#G!
9/O,34! .Q5.4-3/4-*! %5! N2,3O-! 5/! H,;.! /;.=! 5R.45Me434.! IX`+! O3223/4! 9/O,34! 4,O.-! 849.=! 35-!
O,4,:.O.45'! ,49!L/,-5-! 5H,5! JI,+-! ,4! %)C((e,NN=.935.9! 9/O,34! =.:3-5=,='! A/&,99M! H,-! O/=.!
4,O.-!849.=!O,4,:.O.45!5H,4!,4M!/5H.=!=.:3-5=,=!,49!H,-!,4!,==,M!/6!345.=4.5!L,-.9!-.=;3N.-*K!
H55P-0WWRRR*:/9,99M*N/OW:9-H/PW,L/85*,-PgN3hY]XY*!
! X!
i*! A/&,99M! /66.=-! 35-! -.=;3N.-! 34! 345.=-5,5.! N/OO.=N.'! 34N28934:!L85! 4/5! 23O35.9! 5/!
=.:3-5=,53/4'! N.=5363N,53/4'! H/-534:'! P,=S34:'! =.93=.N534:'! 5=,4-6.=-'! ,49! O/4.53V,53/4! 5H=/8:H! 35-!
JP,=S34:K!P=/:=,O!5H,5!O/4.53V.-!P,=53N3P,534:!9/O,34-!R35H!A//:2.!C9F/=9-!,9;.=53-.O.45-*!
A/&,99M!H,-!,!48OL.=!/6!-8L-393,=M!N/OP,43.-'!34N28934:0!F329!F.-5!&/O,34-'!%4N*'!&/O,34-!
LM!1=/QM'!G5,=63.29!>.NH4/2/:3.-'!,49!$28.!E,V/=!&/O,34-*!!
]*! >H3-! )/8=5! H,-! P.=-/4,2! \8=3-93N53/4! /;.=! &.6.49,45-! >H.! A/&,99M! A=/8P! %4N*!
,49! A/&,99M*N/O! %4N*'! L.N,8-.! 5H.M! N/498N5! -8L-5,453,2! L8-34.--! R35H34! 5H3-! 93-5=3N5'! H,;.!
.4:,:.9! 34! ,N5-! /=! /O3--3/4-! R35H34! 5H3-! 7893N3,2! &3-5=3N5! N,8-34:! 34\8=M'! H,;.! .4:,:.9! 34! ,N5-!
/85-39.! 5H3-! 7893N3,2! &3-5=3N5! N,8-34:! 34\8=M! R35H34! 5H3-! 7893N3,2! &3-5=3N5'! ,49! H,;.! .4:,:.9! 34!
N/498N5!=.2,5.9!5/!5H.!842,R682!,N53;353.-!,5!3--8.!34!5H3-!,N53/4!N,8-34:!34\8=M!,49!H,=O!34!5H3-!
7893N3,2! &3-5=3N5'! ,49W/=! H,-! /5H.=R3-.! O,9.! /=! .-5,L23-H.9! N/45,N5-! R35H! 5H3-! \893N3,2! 93-5=3N5!
-8663N3.45!5/!P.=O35!5H.!.Q.=N3-.!/6!P.=-/4,2!\8=3-93N53/4*!
=/*!"$!..?)#>')!"&))#
! `*! 8$%&!R,-!6/849.9!34!"``Z!,49!/66.=-!,49!P=/;39.-!,!6822!,==,M!/6!N/OO.=N3,2!,49!
345.=4.5eL,-.9! ,8N53/4! ,49! -,2.-! -.=;3N.-*! 8$%&! O,345,34-! ,! R.L-35.! ,5! RRR*8$%&*N/O! ,49!
E.9>,:*N/O! RH3NH! /66.=! P=/98N5-! ,49! -.=;3N.-! 34! 345.=-5,5.! N/OO.=N.'! ,49! :.4.=,5.-! =.;.48.!
6=/O0! I,+! NH,=:34:! 5H.! JO,=:34! 9366.=.4N.K! L.5R..4! P8=NH,-.! ,49! -.2234:! P=3N.! /4! 5H.! ,8N53/4!
-5M2.! ,49! 63Q.9! P=3N.! N/OP2.5.9! 5=,4-,N53/4-! /4! 35-! R.L-35.-'! ,49! IL+! 5H=/8:H! N/22.N534:! ,!
N/OO3--3/4!6=/O!).=5363.9!<.=NH,45-!I)<+'!/4!,22!35.O-!-/29!6=/O!5H.-.!O.=NH,45-!5H=/8:H!35-!
345.=4.5eL,-.9!P2,56/=O-!,5!L/5H!8$%&*N/O!,49!E.9>,:*N/O*!8$%&!8-.-!5H.3=!<,=S-'!,-!9.634.9!
L.2/R'! 34! N/44.N53/4! R35H! 35-! 345.=4.5! L,-.9! N/OP,4M'! ,49! O/=.! -P.N363N,22M! 34! P=/;3934:!
P=/98N5-!,49!-.=;3N.-!34!345.=-5,5.!N/OO.=N.*!!
"b*! 8$%&!/R4-!5H.!5=,9.O,=S-!#$%&*N/O'!E@&>CA*N/O!,49!#$%&'!,49!5=,9.!4,O.!
! Y!
#$%&!IN/22.N53;.2M!5H.!J8$%&!<,=S-K+*!>H.!8$%&!<,=S-!R.=.!P8L23N3V.9!,-!/6!"`ì!,49!H,;.!
L..4!6.,58=.9!/4!5H.!%45.=4.5'!34!;,=3/8-!6/=O-!/6!O.93,!,9;.=53-.O.45-!,49!34!-5/=3.-!P8L23-H.9!
5H=/8:H/85!5H.!#435.9!G5,5.-*!
""*! >H.! 8$%&! <,=S-! ,=.! R39.2M! S4/R4! ,49! =.N/:43V.9! ,O/4:! N/4-8O.=-'! =.5,32.=-!
,49!O,486,N58=.=-'!34N28934:!L85!4/5!23O35.9!5/'!O.OL.=-!/6!5H.!=.-,2.!N/OO8435M*!
"X*! >H.!8$%&!<,=S-!,=.!843T8.!,49!93-534N53;.!,49'!,-!-8NH'!9.-3:4,5.!,!-34:2.!-/8=N.!
/6!/=3:34*!
"Y*! 8$%&U-!%45.=4.5!R.L-35.'!RRR*8L39*N/O'!H,-!L..4!=.:3-5.=.9!,49!8-.9!-34N.!"`ì!
,49!8-.-!5H.!8$%&!<,=S-*!>H.!R.L-35.!,2-/!P=/;39.-!346/=O,53/4!/4!O,4M! /6!5H.!P=/98N5-!,49!
-.=;3N.-! /66.=.9*! 8$%&U-! /5H.=! 345.=4.5! R.L-35.'! RRR*E.9>,:*N/O! H,-! L..4! =.:3-5.=.9! -34N.!
Xbbb!,49!5H.!N8==.45!R.L-35.!34!/P.=,53/4!-34N.!G.P5.OL.=!Xbb]*!
"^*! 8$%&U-! L8-34.--! /P.=,53/4-! ,=.! H.,;32M! 345.=4.5! L,-.9'! ,49! 5H.=.6/=.! 35! 9.P.49-!
8P/4!345.=4.5!5=,663N'!,49!5H.!,--/N3,5.9!,L3235M!/6!345.=4.5!8-.=-!5/!6=..2M!,NN.--!35-!R.L-35.'!6/=!
5H.!:.4.=,53/4!/6!=.;.48.*!
"Z*! 8$%&! 85323V.-! -.;.=,2! #435.9! G5,5.-! =.:3-5.=.9! P,5.45-'! 34! N/44.N53/4! R35H! 35-!
345.=4.5! L8-34.--! /P.=,53/4-'! 34N28934:0! #*G*! 1,5.45! (/-*! Z']^Z'XaZj! a'XbX'bZ"j! a'Xaa'aZ"! ,49!
P,5*!P.4934:*!
"a*! 8$%&U-! <,=S-! ,=.! ;,239! ,49! .46/=N.,L2.! 5=,9.O,=S-*! 8$%&! /R4-! 5H.! 6/22/R34:!
#435.9!G5,5.-!5=,9.O,=S!=.:3-5=,53/4-!6/=!35-!<,=S-0!
! ,*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&! >?@! <CEk@>1lC)@! DB#! )C(! >E#G>j!
E.:3-5=,53/4!(/*!YbaZY``j!A//9-!,49!G.=;3N.-!%45U2!)2,--!bYZ*!#G!"bb!"b"!"bX*!A!m!G0!B4el34.!
>=,934:!G.=;3N.-!34!FH3NH!5H.!G.22.=!1/-5-!1=/98N5-!5/!L.!C8N53/4.9!,49!$39934:!3-!&/4.!_3,!
5H.!%45.=4.5j!B4el34.!E.5,32!G5/=.!G.=;3N.-!f.,58=34:!)/4-8O.=!@2.N5=/43N-'!)/OP85.=!1=/98N5-'!
! ^!
,49! <8253O.93,! @45.=5,34O.45! 1=/98N5-j! f3=-5! #-.0! G.P5.OL.=! X^'! Xbb^*! E.:3-5=,53/4! &,5.0!
<,=NH!i'!Xbbaj!
! L*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&*)B<! >?@! $EC(&! (C<@! <CEk@>1lC)@j!
E.:3-5=,53/4!(/*!Yb^]a]Yj!A//9-!,49!G.=;3N.-!%45U2!)2,--!bYZ*!#G!"bb!"b"!"bX*!A!m!G0!B4el34.!
>=,934:!G.=;3N.-!34!FH3NH!5H.!G.22.=!1/-5-!1=/98N5-!5/!L.!C8N53/4.9!,49!$39934:!3-!&/4.!_3,!
5H.!%45.=4.5j!B4el34.!E.5,32!G5/=.!G.=;3N.-!f.,58=34:!)/4-8O.=!@2.N5=/43N-'!)/OP85.=!1=/98N5-'!
,49! <8253O.93,! @45.=5,34O.45! 1=/98N5-j! f3=-5! #-.0! (/;.OL.=! Yb'! XbbY*! E.:3-5=,53/4! &,5.0!
7,48,=M!X^'!Xbbaj!
! N*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&*)B<j! E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! X``"]baj! A//9-! ,49!
G.=;3N.-!%45U2!)2,--!bYZ*!#G!"bb!"b"!"bX*!A!m!G0!B4el34.!>=,934:!G.=;3N.-!34!FH3NH!5H.!G.22.=!
1/-5-! 1=/98N5-! 5/! L.! C8N53/4.9! ,49! $39934:! 3-! &/4.! _3,! 5H.! %45.=4.5j! B4el34.! E.5,32! G5/=.!
G.=;3N.-! f.,58=34:! )/4-8O.=! @2.N5=/43N-'! )/OP85.=! 1=/98N5-'! ,49! <8253O.93,! @45.=5,34O.45!
1=/98N5-j!f3=-5!#-.0!(/;.OL.=!Yb'!XbbY*!E.:3-5=,53/4!&,5.0!G.P5.OL.=!a'!XbbZj!
! 9*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&*)B<j! %45.=4,53/4,2! E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! bàbZabj!
A//9-!,49!G.=;3N.-!%45U2!)2,--!bYZ*!#G!"bb!"b"!"bX*!A!m!G0!B4234.!5=,934:!-.=;3N.-!34!RH3NH!
5H.!-.22.=!P/-5-!P=/98N5-!5/!L.!,8N53/4.9!,49!L39934:!3-!9/4.!;3,!5H.!345.=4.5j!/4234.!=.5,32!-5/=.!
-.=;3N.-! 6.,58=34:! N/4-8O.=! .2.N5=/43N-'! N/OP85.=e=.2,5.9! P=/98N5-'! H/O.! ,PP23,4N.-'! H/O.!
3OP=/;.O.45'! ,85/O/53;.'! -P/=5-! ,49! =.N=.,53/4,2'! O8253O.93,! .45.=5,34O.45'! 5/M-'! \.R.2=M'!
6=,:=,4N.-'!-S34!N,=.'!N/-O.53N-'!P8=-.-'!H,49!L,:-'!R,22.5-'!-84:2,--.-'!H,5-'!5//2-'!,=5'!68=4358=.'!
-5/=,:.'! /=:,43V,53/4'!P.5! -8PP23.-'! N=,65-'! 6//9! ,49! R34.'! :,=9.434:! ,49! P2,4534:! -8PP23.-'! ,49!
2,R4!,49!:,=9.4!9.N/=j!f3=-5!#-.0!7,48,=M!"'!"`ì*!E.:3-5=,53/4!&,5.0!G.P5.OL.=!a'!XbbZj!
! .*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&j!!E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! XZ"`bZbj! A//9-! ,49! G.=;3N.-!
%45U2! )2,--! bYZ*! #G! "bb! "b"! "bX*! A! m! G0! &3--.O34,534:! ,9;.=53-34:! O,55.=! 6/=! /5H.=-! ;3,!
! Z!
.2.N5=/43N! N/OO843N,53/4-! 4.5R/=S-! ,49! P=/O/534:! 5H.! ://9-! ,49! -.=;3N.-! /6! /5H.=-! 5H=/8:H!
L,44.=!,9;.=53-.O.45-!,49!5H=/8:H!5H.!.2.N5=/43N!P=/O/53/4!/6!,49!,8N53/434:!/6!5H.!://9-!,49!
-.=;3N.-!/6!/5H.=-!/4234.!;3,!5H.!:2/L,2!N/OP85.=!4.5R/=Sj!.2.N5=/43N!=.5,3234:!-.=;3N.-!LM!,8N53/4!
,49! /5H.=! O.,4-'! 4,O.2M'! /4234.! =.5,32! -5/=.! ,49! ,8N53/4! -.=;3N.-! 34! 5H.! 63.29-! /6! N/OP85.=e
=.2,5.9'! .2.N5=/43N'! H/O.! ,PP23,4N.'! H/O.! 3OP=/;.O.45'! ,85/O/53;.'! -P/=5-! ,49! =.N=.,53/4,2!
P=/98N5-'! /66.=.9! ;3,! 5H.! :2/L,2! N/OP85.=! 4.5R/=Sj!f3=-5! #-.0! <,M! "'! "``]*! E.:3-5=,53/4! &,5.0!
&.N.OL.=!"]'!Xbb"j!,49!
! 6*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&j! E.:3-5=,53/4!(/*! XXX`Z"Zj! A//9-! ,49! G.=;3N.-! #G!
bbX! bbZ! bXX! bXY! bX`! bYi! bY]! bZb*! A! m! G0! nN,5,2/:-! 6/=! N/OP85.=e=.2,5.9! P=/98N5-'! 4,O.2M'!
H,=9R,=.'!-/65R,=.'!P.=3PH.=,2-'!,NN.--/=3.-'!-8PP23.-'!L//S-!,49!34-5=8N53/4,2!O,5.=3,2-oj!%)!bYZ*!
#G! "bb! "b"! "bX*! A! m! G0! 93--.O34,534:! ,9;.=53-34:! 6/=! /5H.=-! ,49! P=/O/534:! 5H.! ://9-! ,49!
-.=;3N.-! /6! /5H.=-! 5H=/8:H! 5H.! 93-5=3L853/4! /6! P=345.9! P8L23N,53/4-! ,49! ;3,! /4e234.!
5.2.N/OO843N,53/4-! 4.5R/=S-j! 5.2.PH/4.! -H/Pe,5eH/O.! -.=;3N.-'! O,32e/=9.=! N,5,2/:! -.=;3N.-'!
n=.5,32! -5/=.! -.=;3N.-o! ,49! .2.N5=/43N! =.5,3234:! -.=;3N.-! ;3,! :2/L,2! N/OP85.=! 4.5R/=S'! ,22! 34! 5H.!
63.29! /6! N/OP85.=e=.2,5.9! P=/98N5-'! 4,O.2M'! H,=9R,=.'! -/65R,=.'! P.=3PH.=,2-'! ,NN.--/=3.-'!
-8PP23.-'!L//S-!,49!34-5=8N53/4,2!O,5.=3,2-j! f3=-5!#-.0!<,M!"'!"``]*!E.:3-5=,53/4!&,5.0!<,=NH!X'!
"```*!
! :*! >=,9.O,=S0! E@&>CA*)B<j! E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! XZYZbà'! A//9-! ,49!
G.=;3N.-!%)!bYZ!#G!"bb!"b"!"bX*!A!m!Gj!nN/OP85.=3V.9!/4e234.!=.5,32!-.=;3N.-!/66.=34:!,!;,=3.5M!
/6! N/4-8O.=! O.=NH,493-.o*! f3=-5! #-.0! (/;.OL.=! "b'! "``]*! E.:3-5=,53/4! &,5.0! (/;.OL.=! "b'!
"``]*!
"i*! 8$%&! /R4-! 48O.=/8-! 9/O,34! 4,O.-! RH3NH! 34N289.! L85! ,=.! 4/5! 23O35.9! 5/0!
RRR*8L39*N/O'! RRR*E.95,:*N/O'! RRR*M/8L39*N/O'! RRR*$39;322.*N/O'! RRR*8L39*/=:'!
! a!
RRR*8L39*4.5'!RRR*8L39O/5/=-*N/O'!,49!RRR*8L39*5;'!6/=!N/OO.=N3,2!8-.*!
"]*! 8$%&!H,-!;,239'!.46/=N.,L2.'!P=/5.N5.9!,49!;,28,L2.!2.:,2!=3:H5-!5/!5H.!8-.!/6!-,39!
9/O,34!4,O.-'!5=,9.O,=S-'!5,:234.-'!,49!5=,9.!4,O.-'!N/22.N53;.2M!5H.!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!
<,=S-'!,-!35!H,-!8-.9!5H.-.!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!<,=S-!34!345.=-5,5.!N/OO.=N.'!6/=!L8-34.--!
P8=P/-.-'! 34! N/44.N53/4! R35H! 5H.! -,2.! /6! ://9-'! -.=;3N.-'! ,49! 35-! =.-,2.! /P.=,53/4-'! ,-! R.22! ,-'!
H,;34:!L..4!6.,58=.9!/4!5H.!%45.=4.5!,49!8-.9!34!/5H.=!;,=3/8-!6/=O-!/6!,9;.=53-.O.45-*!
(&.!"!$!-")#
"`*! f/=!P8=P/-.-!/6!5H3-!)/OP2,345'!5H.!6/22/R34:!5.=O-!R322!L.!9..O.9!5/!H,;.!5H.!
6/22/R34:!O.,434:-0!
! "#! $%&%'()*%! $+,-)./0! ,-! 8-.9! 34! 5H3-! )/OP2,345'! O.,4-0! ,! 9/O,34! 5H,5! 3-!
5,-5.9'!=.:3-5.=.9'!23N.4-.9'!O/4.53V.9'!5=,663NS.9!34!,49W/=!/5H.=R3-.!8-.9'!6/=!N/OO.=N3,2!:,34'!
5H,5!3-!39.453N,2!5/!/=!N/468-34:2M!-3O32,=!5/!,!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!<,=S*!
! 1#! $)/().&()*%! -.2! 3-45-64%! 7-89/0! ,-! 8-.9! 34! 5H3-! )/OP2,345'! O.,4-0!
;.4.=,L2.'! ;,28,L2.'! 93-534N53;.'! 6,O/8-'! =.:3-5.=.9! /=! N/OO/4! 2,R! 5=,9.O,=S-'! 5=,9.! 4,O.-'!
2/:/-'!6,O/8-!4,O.-'!N/=P/=,5.!4,O.-'!9/O,34!4,O.-'!,49!/5H.=!-8NH!93-534N53;.W;,28,L2.!O,=S-!
/6!8$%&*!
! :#! $+,-).! ;-,%/0! ,-! 8-.9! 34! 5H3-! )/OP2,345'! O.,4-0! ,! 5.Q58,2! 39.45363.=!
=.:3-5.=.9! R35H34! 5H.! &/O,34! (,O.! GM-5.O*! C! 9/O,34! 4,O.! N/OP=3-.-! 5R/! /=! O/=.!
N/OP/4.45-'! .,NH! -.P,=,5.9! LM! ,! P.=3/9*! >H.! =3:H5eO/-5! N/OP/4.45! 3-! 5H.! 5/Pe2.;.2! 9/O,34'!
-8NH!,-!*N/O!/=!*/=:*!</-5!9/O,34!4,O.-!,=.!=.:3-5.=.9!93=.N52M!R35H34!,!5/Pe2.;.2!9/O,34'!.*:*!
://:2.*N/O*! &/O,34! 4,O.-! N/4-3-5! /6! 2.55.=-'! 48OL.=-'! P.=3/9-'! ,49! HMPH.4-'! L85! 4/! /5H.=!
NH,=,N5.=-*!
! $#! $+,-).!<-/().=0!,-!8-.9!34!5H3-!)/OP2,345'!O.,4-0!5H.!P=,N53N.!/6!9/O,34!
! i!
=.:3-5=,45-! =.:3-5.=34:! ,! 9/O,34! 4,O.! 5/! ,--.--! 35-! P=/635,L3235M! 6/=! 5H.! 93-P2,M! /6! /4234.!
,9;.=53-34:*! _3,! 5H.! 5,-534:! P=/N.98=.'! ,! =.:3-5=,45! O,M! =.58=4! ,! 9/O,34! 4,O.! R35H34! 63;.! IZ+!
9,M-! 6/=! ,! 6822! =.6849*! &/O,34! 5,-5.=-! 5MP3N,22M! 9.2.5.! 9/O,34! 4,O.-! 5H,5! 5H.M! P=/\.N5! 5/! L.!
84P=/635,L2.'!/=!9.2.5.!9/O,34!4,O.-!5/!,;/39!5H.!=.:3-5=,53/4!6..!,-!P,=5!/6!5H.!J&/O,34!k3534:K!
P=/N.--*!!
! >#! 7+.%()?%!@!,+.%()?-()+.0!,-!8-.9!34!5H3-!)/OP2,345'!O.,4-0!5H.!P=,N53N.!/6!
8-34:! ,! 9/O,34WR.L-35.! 6/=! N/OO.=N3,2! :,34! LM! :.4.=,534:! =.;.48.! 6=/O! 345.=4.5! ,9;.=53-34:!
P2,N.9W93-P2,M.9W,--/N3,5.9!R35H!-,39!9/O,34WR.L-35.*!
! A#! B-89%2! $+,-)./0! ,-! 8-.9! 34! 5H3-! )/OP2,345'! O.,4-0! ,! 9/O,34! RH3NH! 3-!
849.;.2/P.9!,49!N/45,34-!23552.!/=!4/!N/45.45'!.QN.P5!6/=!=.;.48.!:.4.=,534:!,9;.=53-.O.45-*!
@-(*((A?)#>')!"&))#
# Xb*! A/&,99M! ,9;.=53-.-! ,49! P=/N8=.-! N8-5/O.=-! LM! /66.=34:! J6=..! P,=S34:K! /6! ,!
=.:3-5=,45-! 9/O,34! 4,O.*! #49.=! A/&,99MU-! J1,=S.9! 1,:.! G.=;3N.K'! A/&,99M! R322! P,=S! 5H.!
=.:3-5=,45-! P,:.! ,49! P2,N.! ,9;.=53-.O.45-! /4! R.L! P,:.! RH32.! A/&,99M! 3-! :=,45.9! 5H.! =3:H5! 5/!
N/22.N5!,49!=.5,34!,22!=.;.48.!/L5,34.9!6=/O!5H.!,9;.=53-34:*!
X"*! 18=-8,45!5/!5H.!&/O,34!(,O.!E.:3-5=,53/4!C:=..O.45!L.5R..4!A/&,99M!,49!35-!
N8-5/O.=-'! A/&,99M! 3-! 5H.! ,85H/=3V.9! 23N.4-..! /6! 5H.! =.:3-5=,45! 6/=! 5H.! P8=P/-.! /6! P2,N34:!
,9;.=53-.O.45-! 6/=! N/OO.=N3,2! :,34! /4! 5H.! =.:3-5=,45! R.LP,:.*! 1,=,:=,PH! ]! /6! A/&,99MU-!
&/O,34!(,O.!E.:3-5=,53/4!C:=..O.45!P=/;39.-0!
BC# =63D8;#=6E8#)83F5G8##
>H.! 1,=S.9! 1,:.! G.=;3N.'! 34N289.-'! L85! 3-! 4/5! 23O35.9! 5/'! 5H.!
P,=S34:! /6! P,:.-! /4! A/! &,99M! 4,O.-.=;.=-'! ,49! G5,=5.=Wf/=! G,2.!
R.L!P,:.-!I,22!P,=S.9!P,:.-'!N/22.N53;.2M'!5H.!p1,=S.9!1,:.p+*!f/=!
.;.=M!9/O,34!4,O.!=.:3-5.=.9'!A/!&,99M!R322!P=/;39.!5H.!1,=S.9!
1,:.! -.=;3N.! 6=..! 5/! 35-! N8-5/O.=-*! A/! &,99M! R322! P=/;39.! D/8!
R35H! 5H.-.! -.=;3N.-! ,-! 2/4:! ,-! D/8! ,L39.! LM! 5H.! 5.=O-! ,49!
! ]!
N/49353/4-!-.5!6/=5H!H.=.34!,49!34!.,NH!/6!A/!&,99Mq-!P/23N3.-!,49!
P=/N.98=.-!6/849!H.=.*!!
%6!D/8!,=.!8-34:!A/!&,99Mq-!1,=S.9!1,:.!-.=;3N.-'!D/8!,:=..!5H,5!
A/! &,99M! O,M! P/345! 5H.! 9/O,34! 4,O.! /=! &(G! 5/! /4.! /6! A/!
&,99Mq-! /=! A/! &,99Mq-! ,66323,5.-! R.L! P,:.-'! ,49! 5H,5! 5H.M! O,M!
P2,N.! ,9;.=53-34:! /4! D/8=! R.L! P,:.! ,49! A/! &,99M! -P.N363N,22M!
=.-.=;.-!5H3-!=3:H5*!A/!&,99M!,2-/!=.-.=;.-!5H.!=3:H5!5/!N/22.N5!,49!
=.5,34! ,22! =.;.48.! /L5,34.9! 6=/O! -8NH! ,9;.=53-34:*! D/8! O,M!
5.=O34,5.!D/8=!8-.!/6!5H.!1,=S.9!1,:.!-.=;3N.!,5!,4M!53O.!5H=/8:H!
D/8=!/4234.!,NN/845!O,4,:.=*!!
%6! D/8! ,=.! 8-34:! A/! &,99Mq-! 1,=S.9! 1,:.! -.=;3N.'! D/8! ,=.!
=.-P/4-3L2.! 6/=! .4-8=34:! 5H,5! ,4M! N/45.45! P2,N.9! /4! D/8=! 1,=S.9!
1,:.!LM!D/8!/=!,4M/4.!/4!D/8=!L.H,26!N/46/=O-!5/!,22!2/N,2'!-5,5.'!
6.9.=,2'! ,49! 345.=4,53/4,2! 2,R-*! f8=5H.='! D/8! ,=.! =.-P/4-3L2.! 6/=!
.4-8=34:!5H.!2.:,2!N/PM=3:H5!5/!,4M!3O,:.-'!5.Q5'!/=!/5H.=!R.L!-35.!
.2.O.45-! 4/5! P=/;39.9! LM! A/! &,99M*! %4! /=9.=! 5/! 8-.! A/! &,99Mq-!
1,=S.9! 1,:.! -.=;3N.'! D/8! O8-5! H,;.! ,! 9/O,34! 4,O.! =.:3-5.=.9!
R35H!A/!&,99M*!A/!&,99M!3-!4/5!=.-P/4-3L2.!6/=!O,S34:!L,NSe8P!
N/P3.-! /6! D/8=! R.L! -35.j! 5H3-! 3-! -/2.2M! D/8=! =.-P/4-3L3235M*! D/8!
,:=..!5H,5!A/!&,99M!O,M!P2,N.!,9;.=53-34:!/4!D/8=!1,=S.9!1,:.!
,49! A/! &,99M! -P.N363N,22M! =.-.=;.-! 5H3-! =3:H5*! A/! &,99M! ,2-/!
=.-.=;.-! 5H.! =3:H5! 5/! N/22.N5! ,49! =.5,34! ,22! =.;.48.! /L5,34.9! 6=/O!
-8NH!,9;.=53-34:*!!
XX*! A/&,99M'!,-!5H.!,85H/=3V.9!23N.4-..!/6!5H.!=.:3-5=,45-'!H,-!8-.9!,49!5=,663NS.9!34!
5H.!9/O,34!4,O.-!23-5.9!L.2/R'!R35H!L,9!R35H!345.45!5/!P=/635!6=/O!5H.!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!
<,=S-!/6!8$%&*!GN=..4!-H/5-!/6!5H.!9/O,34!,=.!,55,NH.9!H.=.5/!,49!34N/=P/=,5.9!H.=.34!,-!./012#
3456768#(9#:;/8<#!=>*!
! `!
"#$"%&'()*!
"#+)$"%&'()*!
"$+,-&./0'()*!
&%&+)$"%&'()*!
-$$"%&'()*!
1-23$"%&'()*!
%/$(.%)4$"%&'()*!
%/$(.%)4+)$"%&'()*!
%4--&$"%&'()*!
*-,(-,$"%&'()*!
*+5.$66$"%&'()*!
3$"%&'()*!
$"%&7,-4.'()*!
$"%&75/8-'()*!
$"%&#'()*!
$"%&#"$+-,'()*!
$"%&#"$+-,5'()*!
$"%&#1)*-5'()*!
$"%&#2)/45'()*!
$"%&#*-'()*!
$"%&#*-&%/'()*!
$"%&#,-/2.+'()*!
$"%&/4&"$%2&'()*!
$"%&/4-5.1-5%/'()*!
! "b!
$"%&/4.%9$-/$(.%)45'()*!
$"%&/51'()*!
$"%&/$(.%)45/2-'()*!
$"%&/$(.%)45/2-5'()*!
$"%&/:'()*!
$"%&"'()*!
$"%&"/%2'()*!
$"%&"-&5'()*!
$"%&()2),/&)'()*!
$"%&()45.,$(.%)4'()*!
$"%&(,%*%4/22/;+-,5'()*!
$"%&&'()*!
$"%&&/'()*!
$"%&&%/*)4&5'()*!
$"%&&%,-(.'()*!
$"%&-"/+'()*!
$"%&-(/,-4)2'()*!
$"%&-4.%.+'()*!
$"%&-8%(-'()*!
$"%&-8%(-5'()*!
$"%&-<(1/40-'()*!
$"%&62'()*!
$"%&62%01.5'()*!
$"%&6),=)"5'()*!
! ""!
$"%&6),2)/45'()*!
$"%&6),,-/2.+'()*!
$"%&6$26%22*-4.5-,8%(-'()*!
$"%&1&'()*!
$"%&1-/2.1(/,-'()*!
$"%&1)/'()*!
$"%&1)2%&/+'()*!
$"%&>1)*-5'()*!
$"%&1)*-5*&'()*!
$"%&1)$5-5'()*!
$"%&%.$"$+%.'()*!
$"%&%.$5/'()*!
$"%&2-0/2'()*!
$"%&2-4&%40'()*!
$"%&2%*)'()*!
$"%&2%9$%&/.),5'()*!
$"%&2)(/2*/,?-.'()*!
$"%&2)(/2*/,?-.32/(-'()*!
$"%&*/,?-.32/(-'()*!
$"%&*/..,-55'()*!
$"%&*&'()*!
$"%&*),.0/0-'()*!
$"%&*),.0/0-,/.-5'()*!
$"%&*),.0/0-5'()*!
! "X!
$"%&*+"/%2'()*!
$"%&*+(/5-'()*!
$"%&>4);'()*!
$"%&4);,-/2.+'()*!
$"%&)42%4-'()*!
$"%&)4*/%2%40'()*!
$"%&)43)5.(/,&5'()*!
$"%&)43,%4.'()*!
$"%&).'()*!
$"%&3/'()*!
$"%&301'()*!
$"%&,'()*!
$"%&,/.-5'()*!
$"%&,-*)&-2'()*!
$"%&,-*)&-2%40'()*!
$"%&,-4.'()*!
$"%&,-4./25'()*!
$"%&5-22'()*!
$"%&5%&-;),?'()*!
$"%&5)2&'()*!
$"%&5.+2-'()*!
$"%&./'()*!
$"%&.))25'()*!
$"%&.,/453),.'()*!
! "Y!
$"%&$62+'()*!
$"%&8%&-)'()*!
$"%&8%22/5'()*!
$"%&;),?'()*!
$"%&+/,&5/2-'()*!
$0"%&'()*!
$;/4.$"%&'()*!
+/5$"%&'()*!
+)$"%&#1)*-5'()*!
+)$"%&#*-&%/'()*!
+)$"%&/4-5.1-5%/'()*!
+)$"%&/..),4-+'()*!
+)$"%&"/%2'()*!
+)$"%&"-&5'()*!
+)$"%&",/45)4'()*!
+)$"%&&%40'()*!
+)$"%&>-$,)3-'()*!
+)$"%&6),1)*-'()*!
+)$"%&6),1)*-5'()*!
+)$"%&6),=)"5'()*!
+)$"%&6),*+(/,'()*!
+)$"%&6),,-/2.+'()*!
+)$"%&6$,4%.$,-'()*!
+)$"%&%5-22'()*!
! "^!
+)$"%&%./22'()*!
+)$"%&2/;+-,'()*!
+)$"%&*/%2%405-,8%(-'()*!
+)$"%&*/..,-55'()*!
+)$"%&*-&%/'()*!
+)$"%&*+"/%2'()*!
+)$"%&*+(/5-'()*!
+)$"%&4);'()*!
+)$"%&4);,-/2.+'()*!
+)$"%&)4*/%2%40'()*!
+)$"%&)43)5.(/,&5'()*!
+)$"%&)43,%4.'()*!
+)$"%&))'()*!
+)$"%&3)5.(/,&5'()*!
+)$"%&,<'()*!
@ABB,-&./0'"%:!
@ABB,-&./0'()*!
@ABB,-&./0'%46)!
@ABB,-&./0'4-.!
@ABB,-&./0'),0!
!
#
# XY*! C-!P,=5!/6!35-!-.=;3N.-'!A/&,99M!,2-/!/66.=-!35-!N8-5/O.=-!,!JN,-H!P,=S34:K!-.=;3N.!
RH.=.LM! 5H.! 9/O,34! =.:3-5=,45! P,M-! ,! 6..! 5/! ,22/R! A/&,99M'! 5H=/8:H! 35-! ,9;.=53-34:! P,=54.='!
A//:2.'! 5/! P2,N.! ,9-! /4! 5H.! =.:3-5=,45U-! R.L! P,:.*! >H.! =.;.48.! :.4.=,5.9! 5H=/8:H! 5H3-!
! "Z!
,9;.=53-34:! 3-! 5H.4! -P235! L.5R..4! 5H.! =.:3-5=,45'! A/&,99M'! ,49! A/&,99MU-! ,9;.=53-34:! P,=54.='!
A//:2.*!!
! X^*! >H.!J),-H1,=S34:K!P=/;3-3/4!/6!5H.!A/&,99MU-!&/O,34!E.:3-5=,53/4!C:=..O.45!
P=/;39.-!,-!6/22/R-0!
),-H1,=S34:! 3-! ,! -.=;3N.! 5H,5! .4,L2.-! M/8! 5/! .,=4! O/4.M! /4! M/8=!
P,=S.9! 9/O,34-*! %6! M/8! ,--/N3,5.! M/8=! 9/O,34-! R35H! M/8=!
),-H1,=S34:! ,NN/845'! /8=! ,9;.=53-34:! P,=54.=! P2,N.-! N/45.Q5e
=.2.;,45!,9;.=53-.O.45-!/4!M/8=!P,:.*!@,NH!53O.!,!;3-35/=!N23NS-!,!
93-P2,M.9! ,9;.=53-.O.45'! M/8! =.N.3;.! ,! -H,=.! /6! 5H.! :.4.=,5.9!
N23NSe5H=/8:H! =.;.48.! L,-.9! /4! M/8=! ),-H1,=S34:! P2,4! Iabr! 5/!
]br! /6! 5H.! :.4.=,5.9! =.;.48.+*! >H.! ,O/845! M/8! =.N.3;.! ,49! 5H.!
P=3N.!M/8!P,M!6/=!5H.!),-H1,=S34:!-.=;3N.!9.P.49-!/4!5H.!P2,4!M/8!
-.2.N5*! D/8! N,4! ,99! ,4! 8423O35.9! 48OL.=! /6! 9/O,34-! 5/! M/8=!
),-H1,=S34:!,NN/845*!
!
XZ*! A/&,99M'! ,-! 5H.! ,85H/=3V.9! 23N.4-..! /6! 5H.! =.:3-5=,45-! 849.=! 5H.! ),-H1,=S34:!
-.=;3N.'!H,-!8-.9!,49W/=!5=,663NS.9!34!5H.!6/22/R34:!9/O,34!4,O.-'!R35H!L,9!R35H!345.45!5/!P=/635!
6=/O! 5H.! &3-534N53;.! ,49! _,28,L2.! <,=S-! /6! 8$%&0! 8L399V*N/O'! M/8L3939/35*N/O'!
M/8L3939/*N/O'! 8L39O/5/=*N/O! 8L3939/*N/O! 8L3939/35*N/O! GN=..4! -H/5-! /6! 5H.! 9/O,34! ,=.!
,55,NH.9!H.=.5/!,49!34N/=P/=,5.9!H.=.34!,-!./012#3456768#?*!
Xa*! C-!P,=5!/6!35-!-.=;3N.-!A/&,99M!,2-/!/66.=-!,4!,8N53/4!-.=;3N.!5/!-.22!,49W5=,4-6.=!
,!9/O,34!4,O.-!6/=!,!6..*!B4!f.L=8,=M!`'!Xbb`!A/&,99M!5=,663NS.9!34!5H.!346=34:34:!&.N.P53;.!
&/O,34-! R35H! L,9! 6,35H! 345.45! 5/! P=/635! 6=/O! 8$%&U-! &3-534N53;.! ,49! _,28,L2.! <,=S-0!
8L3993,O/49-*L3V'! 8L39P.-5-*L3V'! 8L3968O.*N/O'! 8L39P.-5-*346/'! 8L39P.-5-*4.5'! 8L395.=O35.*L3V'!
8L39/=L8M35*N/O'! 8L3968O.*346/'! 8L3968O.*4.5'! 8L3968O.*/=:'! 8L395.=O35.*346/'! 8L395.=O35.*4.5'!
8L395.=O35.*/=:'! 8L393=.N5*N/O'! 8L3935P=/\.N5*N/O'! 8L3935P=/\.N5-*N/O'! 8L39^*O.'!
8L39,8N53/4-,2.*N/O'! 8L39,8N53/4-,2.-*N/O'! 8L39-/29*N/O'! 8L39e/4234.*N/O'! 8L392.--*N/O'!
8L39*R-'!8L39*346/'!,49!8L39*4,O.*!
!
! "a!
,-'"$#!#
$%&#*"$!,A>&+)H'*$$!"@#,-")'<&+#=+-$&,$!-"#*,$#
! Xi*! 12,345366!H.=.LM!=.P.,5-!,49!=.e,22.:.-!,22!/6!5H.!P=.N.934:!P,=,:=,PH-!,-!5H/8:H5!
6822M!-.5!6/=5H!H.=.34*!
! X]*! %4! "```'! )/4:=.--! P,--.9! 5H.! C453NML.=-T8,5534:! )/4-8O.=! 1=/5.N53/4! CN5!
IJC)1CK!/=!JCN5K+'!!"# $%&%'%(%#)#!!*"+,-'!5/!P=/5.N5! N/4-8O.=-! ,49!CO.=3N,4!L8-34.--.-'!5/!
P=/O/5.!5H.!:=/R5H!/6!/4234.!N/OO.=N.'!,49!5/!P=/;39.!N2,=35M!34!5H.!2,R!6/=!5=,9.O,=S!/R4.=-*!!
! X`*! "Z!#*G*)*!""XZI9+!P=/;39.-0!
I9+!,4I83J536G4#J38F8:K5L:##
I"+IC+!C!P.=-/4!-H,22!L.!23,L2.!34!,!N3;32!,N53/4!LM!5H.!/R4.=!/6!,!O,=S'!34N28934:!
,!P.=-/4,2!4,O.!RH3NH!3-!P=/5.N5.9!,-!,!O,=S!849.=!5H3-!-.N53/4'!36'!R35H/85!=.:,=9!
5/!5H.!://9-!/=!-.=;3N.-!/6!5H.!P,=53.-'!5H,5!P.=-/4s!!
!
I3+! H,-! ,! L,9! 6,35H! 345.45! 5/! P=/635! 6=/O! 5H,5! O,=S'! 34N28934:! ,! P.=-/4,2!
4,O.!RH3NH!3-!P=/5.N5.9!,-!,!O,=S!849.=!5H3-!-.N53/4j!,49!!
!
I33+!=.:3-5.=-'!5=,663N-!34'!/=!8-.-!,!9/O,34!4,O.!5H,5s!!
!
I%+!34!5H.!N,-.!/6!,!O,=S!5H,5!3-!93-534N53;.!,5!5H.!53O.!/6!=.:3-5=,53/4!
/6! 5H.! 9/O,34! 4,O.'! 3-! 39.453N,2! /=! N/468-34:2M! -3O32,=! 5/! 5H,5!
O,=Sj!!
!
I%%+! 34! 5H.! N,-.! /6! ,! 6,O/8-! O,=S! 5H,5! 3-! 6,O/8-! ,5! 5H.! 53O.! /6!
=.:3-5=,53/4!/6!5H.!9/O,34!4,O.'!3-!39.453N,2!/=!N/468-34:2M!-3O32,=!
5/!/=!932853;.!/6!5H,5!O,=Sj!/=!!
!
I%%%+!3-!,!5=,9.O,=S'!R/=9'!/=!4,O.!P=/5.N5.9!LM!=.,-/4!/6!-.N53/4!
iba!/6!5352.!"]!/=!-.N53/4!XXbZba!/6!5352.!Ya*!
!
! Yb*! "Z!#*G*)*!""XZ!I9+I@+!P=/;39.-0!
C-!8-.9!34!5H3-!P,=,:=,PH'!5H.!5.=O!J5=,663N-!34K!=.6.=-!5/!5=,4-,N53/4-!5H,5!
34N289.'! L85! ,=.! 4/5! 23O35.9! 5/'! -,2.-'! P8=NH,-.-'! 2/,4-'! P2.9:.-'! 23N.4-.-'!
.QNH,4:.-!/6!N8==.4NM'!,49!,4M!/5H.=!5=,4-6.=!6/=!N/4-39.=,53/4!/=!=.N.3P5!
34!.QNH,4:.!6/=!N/4-39.=,53/4*!
! "i!
Y"*! CNN/=934:2M'! )/4:=.--! .4,N5.9! 5H.! C)1C! 5/! 34N289.! 4/5! /42M! 3493;398,2-! ,49!
N/OP,43.-! RH/! =.:3-5.=! 9/O,34! 4,O.-'! L85! =,5H.='! 5/! ,PP2M! .T8,22M! 5/! 5H=..! N2,--.-! /6!
P.=-/4-W.45353.-0! I"+! =.:3-5=,45-! /6! 5H.! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-j! IX+! ,4M/4.! RH/! p8-.-p! 5H.! 9/O,34!
4,O.! RH3NH! 3-! 9.634.9! ,-! 5H.! =.:3-5=,45! /=! 5H.! J,85H/=3V.9! 23N.4-..K! /6! 5H.! =.:3-5=,45-! /6! 5H.!
&.N.P53;.! &/O,34-j! ,49! IY+! ,4M/4.! RH/! J5=,663N-! 34K! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-'! RH3NH! =.6.=-! 5/!
,4M/4.!34;/2;.9!34!,4M!5=,4-,N53/4-!5H,5!34N289.'!L85!,=.!4/5!23O35.9!5/'!-,2.-'!P8=NH,-.-'!2/,4-'!
P2.9:.-'! 23N.4-.-'! .QNH,4:.-! /6! N8==.4NM'! ,49! ,4M! /5H.=! 5=,4-6.=! 6/=! N/4-39.=,53/4! /=! =.N.3P5! 34!
.QNH,4:.!6/=!N/4-39.=,53/4'!RH.5H.=!/=!4/5!5H.!P.=-/4!3-!5H.!=.:3-5=,45!/6!5H.!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34*!!
! YX*! )/4:=.--!9=,65.9!5H.!C)1C!5/!P=.;.45!5H.!8-.'!23N.4-34:'!P2.9:34:'!5=,663NS34:!34'!
/=!,4M!/5H.=!.QNH,4:.!/6!N/4-39.=,53/4!6/=!5H.!8-.!/6!5H.!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34!(,O.-*!A/&,99MU-!
N/498N5! 34! O/4.53V34:! 5H.! 346=34:34:! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-! 3-! 5H.! ;.=M! N/498N5! RH3NH! )/4:=.--!
9.N2,=.9!5/!L.!322.:,2*!
! YY*! C-! ,22.:.9! H.=.34'! A/&,99MU-! ,N5.9! ,-! 5H.! ,85H/=3V.9! 23N.4-..! /6! 5H.! =.:3-5=,45-!
,49! 8-.9! 5H.! 346=34:34:! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-! 34! ;3/2,53/4! /6! 5H.! C)1C'! R35H! L,9! 6,35H! 345.45! 5/!
P=/635!6=/O!8$%&U-!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!<,=S-*!
! Y^*! A/&,99MU-! ,N5-! ,-! ,22.:.9! H.=.34! N/4-53585.! 5H.! 8-.! /6! ,49! 5=,663NS34:! 34!
346=34:34:! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-'! 34! ;3/2,53/4! /6! 5H.! C)1C! R35H! L,9! 6,35H! 345.45! 5/! P=/635! 6=/O!
8$%&U-!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!<,=S-*!!
YZ*! A/&,99MU-! ,N5-! ,-! ,22.:.9! H.=.34! N/4-53585.! NML.=P3=,NM'! NML.=-T8,5534:'! ,49W/=!
5MP/-T8,5534:'!34!;3/2,53/4!/6!5H.!C)1C*!!
! Ya*! 8$%&U-! &3-534N53;.! ,49! _,28,L2.! <,=S-! ,=.! 93-534N53;.'! 6,O/8-'! ;.4.=,L2.'!
;,28,L2.'!,49!/=!6.9.=,22M!=.:3-5.=.9!,5!5H.!#G1>B!,5!5H.!53O.!A/&,99M'!=.:3-5.=.9'!5=,663NS.9!34!
! "]!
/=!,N5.9!,-!5H.!,85H/=3V.9!23N.4-..!/6!,!=.:3-5=,45!,49!8-.9!5H.!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-*!!
! Yi*! >H.!346=34:34:!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-!,-!39.45363.9!34!P,=,:=,PH-!XZ'!X]'!,49!X`!,=.!
39.453N,2!/=!N/468-34:2M!-3O32,=!5/!8$%&U-!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!<,=S-*!!
! Y]*! A/&,99M! 9/.-! 4/5! H,;.! ,4M! 345.22.N58,2! P=/P.=5M! =3:H5-! /=! ,4M! /5H.=! =3:H5-! 34!
8$%&U-!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!<,=S-*!!
Y`*! (/4.!/6!5H.!346=34:34:!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-!N/4-3-5!/6!5H.!2.:,2!4,O.!/6!A/&,99M'!
/=!,!4,O.!5H,5!3-!/5H.=R3-.!N/OO/42M!8-.9!5/!39.4536M!A/&,99M*!!
! ^b*! A/&,99M! H,-! 4.;.=! O,9.! ,4M! P=3/=! 8-.! /6! ,4M! /6! 5H.! 346=34:34:! &.N.P53;.!
&/O,34-!34!N/44.N53/4!R35H!5H.!70@;#A6,B!/66.=34:!/6!,4M!://9-!/=!-.=;3N.-*!!
! ^"*! A/&,99M! 5=,663NS.9! 34! ,49! 8-.9! 5H.! 346=34:34:! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-! 5/! 93;.=5!
N/4-8O.=-!6=/O!8$%&U-!R.L-35.-!5/!R.L-35.-!,NN.--3L2.!6=/O!5H.!346=34:34:!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-*!
A/&,99M!5H.=.LM!N=.,5.9!,!23S.23H//9!/6!N/468-3/4!,-!5/!5H.!-/8=N.'!-P/4-/=-H3P'!,66323,53/4'!/=!
.49/=-.O.45!/6!5H.!346=34:34:!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34!R.L-35.-*!!
! ^X*! A/&,99M! /66.=.9! 5/! 5=,4-6.='! -.22'! /=! /5H.=R3-.! ,--3:4! 5H.! 346=34:34:! &.N.P53;.!
&/O,34-! 6/=! 634,4N3,2! :,34! R35H/85! H,;34:! 8-.9'! /=! H,;34:! 5H.! 345.45! 5/! 8-.'! 5H.! 346=34:34:!
&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-!34!5H.!70@;#A6,B!/66.=34:!/6!,4M!://9-!/=!-.=;3N.-*!!
! ^Y*! A/&,99M!H,-!8-.9'!5=,663NS.9!34'!,49!,N5.9!,-!=.:3-5=,45U-!,85H/=3V.9!23N.4-..!34!
5H.! 346=34:34:! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-! RH3NH! 35! S4.R! R.=.! 39.453N,2! /=! N/468-34:2M! -3O32,=! 5/! 5H.!
P=/5.N5.9!,49!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!<,=S-!/6!8$%&U-'!RH3NH!R.=.!93-534N53;.!,5!5H.!53O.!/6!
5H.!=.:3-5=,53/4!,49!N/45348.!5/!L.!93-534N53;.*!
! ^^*! A/&,99MU-!5=,663NS34:!34'!,49W/=!8-.'!,-!5H.!,85H/=3V.9!23N.4-..!/6!5H.!=.:3-5=,45'!
/6! 5H.! 346=34:34:! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34-! N/4-53585.-! NML.=-T8,5534:! 34! ;3/2,53/4! /6! !"# $%&%'%# )#
! "`!
!!*"+,-%!
! ^Z*! $M! =.,-/4! /6! &.6.49,45-U! ,N5-! ,22.:.9! H.=.34'! =.O.9M! ,5! 2,R! 3-! 4/5! ,9.T8,5.! 5/!
N/OP.4-,5.! 5H.O! 6/=! 5H.! 34\8=3.-! 34623N5.9! LM! A/&,99M*! CNN/=934:2M'! 8$%&! 3-! .45352.9! 5/!
P=.23O34,=M!,49!P.=O,4.45!34\84N53;.!=.23.6!P8=-8,45!5/!!"#$%&%'%#)#!!!C%#!
â*! $M! =.,-/4! /6! A/&,99MU-! ,N5-! ,22.:.9! H.=.34'! 8$%&! 3-! .45352.9! 5/! =.N/;.=!
A/&,99MU-!P=/635-'!,N58,2!9,O,:.-!,49!5H.!N/-5-!/6!5H.!,N53/4'!/='!/4!8$%&U-!.2.N53/4'!-5,585/=M!
9,O,:.-!849.=!!"#$%&%'%#)#!!!>'!34!,4!,O/845!8P!5/!B4.!?849=.9!>H/8-,49!&/22,=-!Ic"bb'bbb+!
P.=! &.N.P53;.! &/O,34! 4,O.! 346=34:.O.45*! f8=5H.='! 5H3-! 3-! ,4! .QN.P53/4,2! N,-.! O,S34:! 8$%&!
.23:3L2.!6/=!,4!,R,=9!/6!,55/=4.M-U!6..-!849.=!!"#$%&%'%#)#!!!>%#! !
+&H'&)$#.-+#+&/!&.#
F?@E@fBE@'!12,345366!=.-P.N56822M!=.T8.-5-!\89:O.45!,-!6/22/R-0!
! %*! >H,5!5H.!)/8=5!.45.=-!,!\89:O.45!5H,5!&.6.49,45-!H,;.!;3/2,5.9!5H.!=3:H5-!
/6!12,345366!34!5H.!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!<,=S-*!
%%*! >H.! )/8=5! ,9\89:.! ,49! 9.N=..! 5H,5! &.6.49,45-'! 5H.3=! ,:.45-'!
=.P=.-.45,53;.-'!.OP2/M..-'!,--3:4-!,49!-8PP23.=-'!,49!,22!P.=-/4-!,N534:!34!
N/4N.=5! /=! P=3;35M! R35H! 5H.O'! L.! P=.23O34,=32M! ,49! P.=O,4.452M! .4\/34.9!
6=/O!5H.!6/22/R34:!,N53;353.-0!!
,*! E.:3-5.=34:'! 8-34:'! /=! 5=,663NS34:! 34! ,4M! O,44.='! 34! ,4M! 9/O,34!
4,O.! 5H,5! 34N/=P/=,5.-'! 34! RH/2.! /=! 34! P,=5'! 5H.! &3-534N53;.! ,49!
_,28,L2.! <,=S-! /=! ,4M! 4,O.'! O,=S! /=! 9.-3:4,53/4! N/468-34:2M!
-3O32,=!5H.=.5/!IJ&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-K+j!!
L*! #-34:! 12,345366U-! &3-534N53;.! ,49! _,28,L2.! <,=S-'! /=! ,4M! /5H.=!
! Xb!
4,O.'!O,=S'!9.-3:4,53/4!/=!9.P3N53/4!34!,!O,44.=!5H,5!3-!23S.2M!5/!
N,8-.! N/468-3/4! IJ&.N.P53;.! &/O,34-K+! =.:,=934:! RH.5H.=!
&.6.49,45-! ,=.! ,66323,5.9! /=! ,--/N3,5.9! R35H! /=! -P/4-/=.9! LM!
12,345366j!
N*! E.:3-5.=34:! ,4M! 9/O,34! 4,O.! 8-34:! ,4! ,85/O,5.9! P=/N.--! 5H,5! 3-!
345.49.9! 5/! N=.,5.! I/=! RH3NH! N/829! =.-825! 34! 5H.! N=.,53/4! /6+'!
&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-j!!
9*! @4:,:34:!34!5MP/-T8,5534:j!
.*! @4:,:34:!34!NML.=-T8,5534:j!
6*! @4:,:34:!34!NML.=P3=,NMj!
:*! @4:,:34:!34!9/O,34!5,-534:!L,-.9!/4!5H.!&3-534N53;.!,49!_,28,L2.!
<,=S-j!,49!
3*!! C--3-534:'!,3934:!/=!,L.5534:!,4M!/5H.=!P.=-/4!/=!L8-34.--!.4535M!34!
.4:,:34:!34!/=!P.=6/=O34:!,4M!/6!5H.!,N53;353.-!=.6.==.9!5/!,L/;.*!
%%%*! >H.!)/8=5!,9\89:.!,49!9.N=..!5H,5!&.6.49,45-!L.!/=9.=.9!5/!P,M!-5,585/=M!
9,O,:.-!849.=!"Z!#*G*)*![!"""iI9+'!/4!.2.N53/4!/6!12,345366'!34!,4!,O/845!
/6! B4.! ?849=.9! >H/8-,49! &/22,=-! Ic"bb'bbb+! P.=! 9/O,34! 4,O.!
346=34:.O.45j! /=! ,25.=4,53;.2M! 5H.! )/8=5! ,9\89:.! ,49! 9.N=..! 5H,5!
&.6.49,45-!L.!/=9.=.9!5/!,NN/845!5/!12,345366!,49!93-:/=:.'!,22!P=/635-!5H.M!
H,;.!9.=3;.9!LM!=.,-/4!/6!5H.!346=34:34:!&.N.P53;.!&/O,34-j!,49!
%_*! >H.! )/8=5! ,9\89:.! ,49! 9.N=..! 5H,5! &.6.49,45-! L.! /=9.=.9! 5/! P,M!
12,345366U-!=.,-/4,L2.!,55/=4.M!6..-'!P=.\89:O.45!345.=.-5'!,49!N/-5-!/6!5H3-!
,N53/4j!
! X"!
1'+A#$+!*/#(&<*"(#
! 18=-8,45!5/!f.9.=,2!E82.!/6!)3;32!1=/N.98=.!Y]IL+'!12,345366!9.O,49-!,!5=3,2!LM!\8=M!/6!,22!
/6!5H.!N2,3O-!,--.=5.9!34!5H3-!)/OP2,345!-/!5=3,L2.*!!
!
&,5.90!CP=32!Y'!Xbb`! !! ! ! E.-P.N56822M!-8LO355.9'!
!
! ! ! ! ! ! W-WE/L.=5!<*!f//5.!! ! ! ! !
E/L.=5!<*!f//5.'!@-T*!ItbY"X^YXZ+!
<,55H.R!7*!?.=O,4'!@-T*!ItbaXYiXì+!
G5.PH.4!F*!f84:'!@-T*!ItbaX]`ZXX+!
fBB>@'!<@D@EG'!<%@lk@!m!flBF@EG'!ll)!
X]!(*!f3=-5!G5*!
G835.!X!
A.4.;,'!%2234/3-!ab"Y^!
>.2.PH/4.0!IaYb+!XYXeaYYY!
f,N-3O32.0!!IaYb+!]^Ze]`]X!
!
k,5H2..4!)*!)H,;.V!ItbaXZZiYZ+!
)?C_@d!lCF!f%E<'!1*)*!
X]!(*!f3=-5!G5*!
G835.!X!
A.4.;,'!%2234/3-!ab"Y^!
!
1.5.=!l*!)8==3.'!@-T*!ItbaX]"i""+!
>?@!lCF!f%E<!Bf!1@>@E!l*!)#EE%@'!1*)*!
ZYa!F34:!l,4.!!
G,345!)H,=2.-'!%2234/3-!ab"i^!
!
"((+8.%C/!D+8!B4-).()DD!
!
! XX!

Complaint Ubid V Godaddy

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Исходное описание:

Оригинальное название

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Complaint Ubid V Godaddy

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

FILED: APRIL 6, 2009

Case 1:09-cv-02123 Document 1 Filed 04/06/2009 Page 1 of 22

! ,*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&! >?@! <CEk@>1lC)@! DB#! )C(! >E#G>j!

! L*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&*)B<! >?@! $EC(&! (C<@! <CEk@>1lC)@j!

! N*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&*)B<j! E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! X``"]baj! A//9-! ,49!

G.=;3N.-! f.,58=34:! )/4-8O.=! @2.N5=/43N-'! )/OP85.=! 1=/98N5-'! ,49! <8253O.93,! @45.=5,34O.45!

! 9*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&*)B<j! %45.=4,53/4,2! E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! b`abZabj!

-.=;3N.-! 6.,58=34:! N/4-8O.=! .2.N5=/43N-'! N/OP85.=e=.2,5.9! P=/98N5-'! H/O.! ,PP23,4N.-'! H/O.!

3OP=/;.O.45'! ,85/O/53;.'! -P/=5-! ,49! =.N=.,53/4,2'! O8253O.93,! .45.=5,34O.45'! 5/M-'! \.R.2=M'!

! .*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&j!!E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! XZ"`bZbj! A//9-! ,49! G.=;3N.-!

! 6*! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&j! E.:3-5=,53/4!(/*! XXX`Z"Zj! A//9-! ,49! G.=;3N.-! #G!

5.2.N/OO843N,53/4-! 4.5R/=S-j! 5.2.PH/4.! -H/Pe,5eH/O.! -.=;3N.-'! O,32e/=9.=! N,5,2/:! -.=;3N.-'!

63.29! /6! N/OP85.=e=.2,5.9! P=/98N5-'! 4,O.2M'! H,=9R,=.'! -/65R,=.'! P.=3PH.=,2-'! ,NN.--/=3.-'!

! :*! >=,9.O,=S0! E@&>CA*)B<j! E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! XZYZb`a'! A//9-! ,49!

RRR*8L39*N/O'! RRR*E.95,:*N/O'! RRR*M/8L39*N/O'! RRR*$39;322.*N/O'! RRR*8L39*/=:'!

8L3993,O/49-*L3V'! 8L39P.-5-*L3V'! 8L3968O.*N/O'! 8L39P.-5-*346/'! 8L39P.-5-*4.5'! 8L395.=O35.*L3V'!

8L39/=L8M35*N/O'! 8L3968O.*346/'! 8L3968O.*4.5'! 8L3968O.*/=:'! 8L395.=O35.*346/'! 8L395.=O35.*4.5'!

8L395.=O35.*/=:'! 8L393=.N5*N/O'! 8L3935P=/\.N5*N/O'! 8L3935P=/\.N5-*N/O'! 8L39^*O.'!

8L39,8N53/4-,2.*N/O'! 8L39,8N53/4-,2.-*N/O'! 8L39-/29*N/O'! 8L39e/4234.*N/O'! 8L392.--*N/O'!

IJC)1CK!/=!JCN5K+'!!"# $%&%'%(%#)#!!*"+,-'!5/!P=/5.N5! N/4-8O.=-! ,49!CO.=3N,4!L8-34.--.-'!5/!

_,28,L2.! <,=S-! /=! ,4M! 4,O.'! O,=S! /=! 9.-3:4,53/4! N/468-34:2M!

N,8-.! N/468-3/4! IJ&.N.P53;.! &/O,34-K+! =.:,=934:! RH.5H.=!

&.6.49,45-! ,=.! ,66323,5.9! /=! ,--/N3,5.9! R35H! /=! -P/4-/=.9! LM!

/6! B4.! ?849=.9! >H/8-,49! &/22,=-! Ic"bb'bbb+! P.=! 9/O,34! 4,O.!

346=34:.O.45j! /=! ,25.=4,53;.2M! 5H.! )/8=5! ,9\89:.! ,49! 9.N=..! 5H,5!

Вам также может понравиться

! L! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&)B<! >?@! $EC(&! (C<@! <CEk@>1lC)@j!

! N! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&)B<j! E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! X``"]baj! A//9-! ,49!

! 9! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&)B<j! %45.=4,53/4,2! E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! b`abZabj!

! .! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&j!!E.:3-5=,53/4! (/! XZ"`bZbj! A//9-! ,49! G.=;3N.-!

! 6! >=,9.O,=S0! #$%&j! E.:3-5=,53/4!(/! XXX`Z"Zj! A//9-! ,49! G.=;3N.-! #G!

! :! >=,9.O,=S0! E@&>CA)B<j! E.:3-5=,53/4! (/*! XZYZb`a'! A//9-! ,49!

RRR8L39N/O'! RRRE.95,:N/O'! RRRM/8L39N/O'! RRR$39;322.N/O'! RRR8L39/=:'!

8L3993,O/49-L3V'! 8L39P.-5-L3V'! 8L3968O.N/O'! 8L39P.-5-346/'! 8L39P.-5-4.5'! 8L395.=O35.L3V'!

8L39/=L8M35N/O'! 8L3968O.346/'! 8L3968O.4.5'! 8L3968O./=:'! 8L395.=O35.346/'! 8L395.=O35.4.5'!

8L395.=O35./=:'! 8L393=.N5N/O'! 8L3935P=/\.N5N/O'! 8L3935P=/\.N5-N/O'! 8L39^*O.'!

8L39,8N53/4-,2.N/O'! 8L39,8N53/4-,2.-N/O'! 8L39-/29N/O'! 8L39e/4234.N/O'! 8L392.--*N/O'!