Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 161

. .

Jl

. -

2005

87.3(0)

313
.

313

1 / . . . . .

- .: - -.
ISBN 5-288-03667-5

-,

2005. - 160

1,

rn,

,

1,


,
,
,
.

87.3(0)

Sokrates als Pythagoreer und die Anamnesis in


Platons Phaidon Theodor Ebert

Dr.-A/fred-Vinz/-Stijtung

Mainzer Akademie der


Wissenschaften, 1994

-
,

2005

. . , ,

ISBN 5-288-03667-5

2005

;\
:


Ci1,

,
, , ,
,

~IO ; ,

,
,
. ,
,

,
.

. . ,

, . . ,

.
.

(Dr.-Alfred-Vinzl-Stiftung)

ll ,

, , Jl

,
.

,
. ,
, ,
,

Jl .

(DL 3. 37)
,

,
.

-,

, ,

, , -,
, ,

, ,
. - ,
- . 1

1 I'I1l

(Riginos 1986, 180)

(Di

1987, 282)

, ' OI-1 :
'lI :\1
IIIM II ll :Qi

'HxyaOou

(<< ). llll I'rn, << ,


ll Il,

, ' l II ll
, l1I :~
ll , I vll

(I\IIT. ., 180). , , , '


,

. ,
, l1
IIl ? , II
, t\flO ll, :\lO
( ). :\1" -

,
, ,

CJI

, . .

366

1'. . .,

.
, ,

"? ,
, I'

? , ,

!'1

, l} , :lOiI , lI
lI :. ,\1

II Koopoil .
ll,

(... )

(... )

mllra,

[DL 3.37.2. -

nI. n(1-

<] Ol' illl 'n!:(Ji uii<; [


, \IIoI ll ,

, II:\IO, I-IIIl!'1 .

npII,\I. nll

]. : llllll l'
I'
.,

11:\1

2R2).

11

(Dorrie, II.
ero -

: , , :\lO

: \1 II, lI?

\1, :\1 , lI'-I

Cl" ii ~ lI,

I,

110

I1llI: II:Vl

APllcToKceHa,

l'

)"-Ix Ol1aax?

\1, lII1 ,
' , III'\1 !1,

pe'lL

'1'0:\1,

II

lI
CII :IIlI

(orat. 21,

11 :
IIbIlllllO :\lllil

245-246), II :

: . Il :

II:II l:1I

( ... )

lllllll

, ro:\l.
:Vl : lI ,
ll , IlIl:\IO,

11

(Dorrie,

: ). ' \10
II , II:, ,

Hlle

II Il1,

lI "'r
lI , II l'le -

111. Kp0:\le

, , :,

(143-),

Bpe:\leHa

IIII, , , II
. II I

11

\1 lII'l

\101'

(127c-d)

, '!

lI ( : ,

I'1'6IIaJul>>,' .

128d-e) III

\1.

nu1(

,
,
.

1

l~
)I :

(.

1)

lI ,

v\6;. (.

II-XI) -

, (72-77d5).

.
OlId ,

ll,

,
" -

111110, .

II

ll .


,

, Ha/~

I~.

.
,

: I\ (57-59)

/10.

(888-3, 1023-9)

,
J ':

, , ...

. 2

? :
, ?

2 C:VJ. DL 8.46,

, cBIlAeeAb

, :VJJ IJ ll
mf 'III Allr J

JJ

IJ

. lIro
JJ II !" llJ .

(Rowe 1993, 6):

<

, , I lI f,
IL J. :.!)' ,,
,
JJ , IJl-J,

110

:.!)' coe~lY, -IJIJ, lflCl,

Ja '
I1' : . Il I

,
l IX,

rlAa:VJeHHblM

III,

1J II . J,
rof, lIro ,
cpaHHbI:'l,
eCAII ero a lJ )'1' (ro)

rolJ. m ero, , II
l , ro COKpare.
IJa ro

, ,

11 llIIl IIYII,
Bcero
ero IJ

'l

rol".
III (.

88d)

I 'D,
, IIl

AllaAore

IJ

II l II

. II, APllcToKceHa,
, ,
, I "'D~IX

(07uOL) lI!"

(Vita Pyth. , 251). - l .


DL 2.105. ero l
. ytlll 11 (McQueen/Rowe 1989).

nl/

ry
,

,
, ,

, ,

. ",

,
IJa. ,
,

-
,

ll.

3 ,

, (

, Jl , ,

,

OI

,
.

II

I,
, -
,

" (.

Symp.

1721, 1741).

; ,

,
.

, /l,

,
,
.

(II

10

,
, :

.)
, ll

,
ll (.88-).

, ,
011

Cll

apry-

l (88c8-d),
(.88l-7). -,
,

( ,

, 88d-6).' -, ,

J -lD1!I : !

>;' f.IOl

TLtt'TtX 11QovbiboKTO (88d6).

II:\! :\I :\l,

011

II

; lI

(Fo\vler 1914): 1 mY5elf believed in that before [


(Gallop 1975): I'd formerly held
this view mY5clf [ lI
] (Zehnpfcnnig 1991): ... daB 5 auch mir 5elb5t
friihcr 5chon 50 ge5chicncn hattc [. .. :\1J :\ II
]. 11 IIOI
j,

IIII :

88d3-6,

(1) : , loll

, il

ll I :

\1010111

)':\10\1

TCIICPb,

" (!

vuv

I'ap!

,[, , ) 111111

110

lOlIIlll1

:llil

cBocil

:\fY

il :\,

(2) nll nll


llml1

l)'

I!,

I.'

II, W1 (7,18) lOl


, I\ 8il" (~'07((J

>I,

11QOL,biboKTO
011 , ro:\1 1I0

nu

11

, -
aplYMel
II

(88d6-8).

. ,
,
r :

apl)'Mel fI)',

(899-917); ,
, r

, I' (92-95);
, (95-107)

apl)'MeHTa .
,

,
,

, .
II ,

r. , , ,
,

.
, ,

, . . ry,
;

,

:1
lI llO'I)'.

(Bluck 1955)

- BeplIblll I\
(Hackforth 1955).

IOlI .) llal',tII
BPCMCHII Cl.l. , IIO II~I

(Diirric 1990, S. 20-37), l'I 38.1, 38.2,


38.4, 38.4, 38.5, 39.0, 39.1, 39.2, 39.3.

12

, I'

, , ,

, ,

, .; 3ry

3 Pythagorcan flavour, (Guthrie 1975,


325 Il. 2); ro
'U , II Ill\l (Hirzel
1895, . 1, 194 I. 1); (Bumet 1911, xli-xliv); 110I (lr 1926, 175); (Bluck 1955, 6 .);
(Hackforth 1955, 7, 15); IJO (ll 1975, 75);
(Guthrie 1962, 204); Jl (Loriaux 1969, 109-111; 1975, 164).

ll II llli

ll-lI

1972).

l1,

TO:'>I,

111111

lI:'>"~,

II:'>1 l1\1 1I:l.lI

(Ste\vart
1I:'>leeM

,IIIlI

ero

, ll

TaKo11

'lli

llroll:l.l , 1I110.tlall,

11

lI ,

lO

llII

IIlI,

:'>, l1 I1I, I1 lIll:l.l,

!\'1 ll:l.1a (. r lUl Jl'

[Long 1948, 90)).

'ly I1,

III , II

II.

(Burkcrt 1962, 108)

: :! ,\II 'Ul , ll

, l1l1 ,

11

ro , 'lllll ro

I1lIIl:l.lII
) ,

BeCb:l.la ,

fr.40

Toro,

11

ro

1I,\I

II, lIII,

2.81;

II

), llII

fr.2 ;
caMOro

lIKOIIM :l.1 ro .
II t1

I1l ::l.1 IIIll1:l.:l.1


lI

(105),

II J

, ,

ero

II :l.l II:'>1 I

ro

(106),

II. , lI (

lI :\lI )
lI r - !!

; ,
!!v, lI lIX Ka'leCBe 'Ul

Y'lellllll ;

(107).

13

l'O
, . 6

I'O

r ,

61d6-7.

I'O l'O

, -
,
,
.
, (
/l,

OL 8.46)

I,

,
l'O ,
.

l'O

Pytlzagorica

Vita

< ).

lope~I3M

Gel1io Socratis

<

),
, -

r 3

\ l'O

(582d-e),

, ,


, ,
,

(.

578,

579d-e,

586,

592 .). ,
6

l\ II:VI 11 ll

, III IIIIII,

communis opinio

Hoil : . (Burnet 1911, :\!:\!.

59 591), (Robin 1962, xix), . . (Taylor 1926,


175), . . Ilor (Long 1948, 76), (Bluck 1955),
(Burkert 1962, 192), lloPbi! (Loriaux 1969, 110), raTplI (Guthrie
1975, 325), (Dorter 1982, 9), II (Dixsaut 1991, 320)_

14

II,

,
. ,
,

DL 2.124

(l\

,11,17;

1,2,48;

).?

125;

61d6-7

kaKOM-
, IO

. . . . 8 -

IIlIO

OI1llCbIBaeT

, ,

KOTOpbIil II
(1/1 PJ1Qcd. 1, 13,2

(61d7):

O\Jvi\' [ ]

Westerink);

, , 'UI,

, I:\1

studied with.

IIII, Olll , '

II : O\Jv~B'lC; l>LtQIOL;

(//1 Phaed. 5, 6,2 Westerink ).

6 III\, ~1 ,

:\II OI
:\1 ca:\IL\1 II

11

61d6-7.

i. I -

II I"O I"O l"Oll.

II

/ - :lafIl II:\I

11

lll
IIII:

ro;!.

vEavLaOl [II1] (893),

IIX

I II .

II

(242),

11

)' , )'

399

.,

llI, IIall 8

II lIII. IJaI,
-
.. 6 l

KorAa

llII dl"O

, .
8

Grubc 1935, 294: ...

II ,

t1ll l!:\'1

OTHeCTII

II

I;1.IIIII :\l . II II
II- 3 II ,\ lI (.~> lV';:,

61d). Jler-KO

, OI ..

II ll, lI )'
1I0

ll:

I.

61d-e

,l,

:\III

15

nul{

,
- ,
,

,
, .
( )

, :
, ,

jortiori,

, .

,
OI. II

.

,

.t1 ,

ll .t1

3 . :~

(61d);

('" a.lIoQQ~OI(;;))
(62);

. (70)

.\~, I1~I :\ IIaJI , ,

110

, .

I", I" llI"


(oublv i.;). I! II ,
I! :.:>1 , 011 IIIll ,, ll" lI 110 . llll ' IX,
110, II 011, l llllIOI. , .

ll IL\.\. II II , ',
I" "ll

(fr. 502 Rosc),

, , 'Ill llO ll. - ll


\I II IIIl, II:>IC \111 Il

lII'il ( ). , , ,
\1 i

Vita Pythag""ica

, ,

II lIi. - :~ , I"
l1iI 11 II lIII, ll

11

(.

Rowe [1993] 7, 115 .).

16

; ,

, ,

(107c-115a);

(11Oc-115a)

.
,
,

, , ,

l' fIA
: l' tA6.
. I ,

lI,
,

: 9


- .t1 (58-).
(WXJ ;,

58a6),IO

,
,

, ,

(60d, 61b).

, ,

.t1, ,
(.

DL 8.57).11

,
,

(85d) -

, ,

DL 8.11

( illliI ),

8.13

( ll lI).

fl

ll

ll Il; , :vI II:vl, lI


II, :vIII 08l lIII
:IoI :Vl I1l:loI, . 11

(Burkert 1962, 179

(Dodds 1951, 17]).

.) , II ..

II fl II ,

1 , .
10 ll UXlllll 11
II, lI (fr. 41 Wchrli).

11 C:vI. :lol3 (Solmscn 1980), KOOPblIIHOk


:vl :Io1 ~II.

nuz(

17

'IO; ,
,
,

, v\6;, ti tLv.

. ti
,

(613), f.lOUaLrj,

l ,
f.lOUaLrj

. 12

f3ioc;,

Ol" ti t6:.
,

, 1111

,
:\ (63-69),
(114). ti

.
lI ,
lIO,

(Resp. , 600).I

,
ti ,
:
(
, , ),

ll,

'~ . (Burnet 1911) ad loc.: <


I/ll II:\1, CCbIAKOil ll 10. 468.
. , D Vita pythagorica , 64.
". !I0 (Loriaux1969, 109 .).

18

(. 649, 662,
674,

d8,

4, 682-3,

69d2;

822-3, 835-6, 5).

II, l1IIlI

ll. , v\i
II , , ll
,

oTTelIKoM

:IO

fr. 35 DK
, 305c-d).

(.



(.

Prot. 335d7; Resp. , 475-).

,
ll,
".l~
1. , ~:\-1 I1 I1

(.

DL 1.12),

ro :\-10

, :\-10
Ol, II.

(Gcddes 1885, 194),

,\ IIII

YC:\-1lI :\l,

II il . (

[Burkert 1960].)

ceil

ro

, ,

BCCb:l.la

, :\-1 .
II llIIll :~CHOHa ro
7[(10'; 1:OU'; u\uc; (D 2) f!81
II 3ll

IO

11 ,
(Burkert 1962, . 264 :'.I. 51),

,
,

Ol :'.IJI,

, !. lIro.
II lIIl
, 'l, , il
:\-1 :\-1 I:\-1,

:\-1 , :\-1

. , (

] 945], 22)

[Heidcl 1940, -
, 11 II:\-1II

19

" nul!

, ,

IL< II
":)

, (26-)

" (58).
,

II

II 1l,

(KC<OC<Q6.:;), (KaOC<Qat.:;)
(Kc<OC<QE\JE!\').

I ,
~IA
(. 6-69;

80d-84b;

114). <Q,

(75-d2, 80, 82b-)

I,

, II:l<llO ,

(>~~ILt"[

(Paml. 1273),

:~eHOH,

11
11 I', 1I:1<I II
ll, y(>ci:~IPH (1283, 8, 3, d3) mJyy(>a~~a
(1286) llIIlIllO:\! , , 11.1,

'

IllIil

"l,

:~eHOHY (, Parm. 1274), II\lllll I',


,

:\l, II II,

IIbI:l<l IIll \' ,


lIlOil ~ ';,
II!, l~l /n Ar, hs,
99.7-9, , \' ";/"

3lI, II:\IIIIII ~
1I/III ,

1,' , 110 IIOI xci:8a(>UIC;


i1:1.1lI (Parker 1983,


294-300),
, , :l.1 , OI :
I" :l.1 ,
,

1/I/(~dl"II . ,
"~:\lIl, Il BeCb:l.1a (Ta:l.1 298),
:~IlIO lll\ -

20

ro

,

,

30 ,
,

aOIY


ll .
l\ ,


.
,

, .il
; ,

(iJbu)>>

(60-4). .il,

.
6 .il
, I"

( 685, 8).

.il (.

fr. 8,15 DK).

lO

.il (iJbovj)
.il .il

rro .il .il

.il (60-).
, ' :l.l l

IIIO llil ll~.


I,
ilC CBoe~y ( ),

fr. 129 IOII ;


:l.l, IO ~II 011 II
~, II, -

~lI IIpaeT ~OlIB 'lIIll,


. ~ ~ : II lI ,
II II.

nll

21

~ ,
, , l [

Jl , ll
Il

(60c-d).

COKpary

Il,

11 Ol

f.1ouaLld];

OLX , ,

f.10UaL1,

- OI

Il
v .

,
ll: f.10UaL1,
[ [

. ,
Te,lb


. , ,
[ lOI .


I ,

(61clO-d2).

lI: , OI I6u:,
, , ,

(8Ef.1LTOv>
(6110), , ,
.
:, , v.

[ [

, ,

TeoiJop

22


. ,
,

(61d-62c).


,
,
:

, lI

, ,
, ? (, ,

,
, I
[. 45-].) ,
,

(6),
, ,
JI ,
(6).

,
: .

, 6ld-6d, 'I ,

,
JlI

(6-69)

, .

,
.

67c-d

1XOa.Qmc:,

23

nllZOI(

VJlI, . ,

64,
,1v

(67d),
il :\ (674-6),
(! oQOW':; Iuv'{:;),
3III

,\V

(67d6-11),

~
(i

JII l

CKoii .
II, ( )

:I<ll'

JI, , . C<Q<JLC;, 1101'0 .


peiiclLX

(. 65, 66)

(64d),

(64e9-65;

65cl1-d2),

, II

(f.1E'(cX OEWV, 69c-d).

Il ,l

(69d).

,

:\

,
: , 66-672.

II , ,

, ,

(662-, 67-4), ,

llll

(662,

24
. 674).

mt Il
d. ,



: II . ,

, . .

,
, ,

conjessio Pythagorica.

Jl

,
. ,
lIO

(. 40-)
; (220)

(61clO)

, ,

MopaAblIbIx

.
, lO

.
A JI
, (.

DL 2.45),

25

" nI//\

I . ()

,
,16

. ,
nim ntllrlitr

Pytllagorica,

I;


I', -
!' , ,
,

366

!' ( ): ,

, , ,
,

, ,

, (
, , . 59)

, , , ,
, ,
; , ,
,

Il, (59),
-

Jl
.

, ,

(XI 131,

505)

, ll ,
!' ,
.

'6

. I1 (Dorrie 1990) l':vI 38.10, lil

ll.

,'

lI , ll l'

( 235 :l.1ll) ll Vita Plftha~, :vl8 ll IIllI


II - HeOKp~T, ' llO:l.1Il:vIO
Il3.

26

, , ?

: ,
l6G:? ,
, I1A


, ,
.

, ,

,
,
:
.tlI ,
, , ,
.

-
,

, (91-92, 95-).18

18

, :\~, , ' II ll

ll

113 II IIl1ru IlO

> llaIlOla. Ie :\oIll, i

lli .
l

Ca:\olOM

, -I :\ol lll

1I:l ll1 COOTBeTCBlle IIrollOl-1

,II , llll (96-l03), ll

ollllcbIKaeT 'Dl :ll /" TalI~1 30~1,


01111 ~/"Il II~lIIII IIl1liJCil lI61l.
IIrepec Ill L'<.,~ i'QiL, (968)
llll:\ol, epelI tDJCII

(96b-d)

11:\01

lJlla)' Il ll,

lllll :lallllil /"il ~lbICIlI1: II:\lII

Ka'Iece

opl'alIa ~IlllI (96) ~


fr.l05 D), xapaKTeplICIIKa :\lJIll
I il (965-6) - AIlI<.'l.leOHa (. test. 10 11 13 D).
I IWII 3 (97d8-el) :\0101"110
(.

,I. JII~1 ll, OlKO ~1


l I1'Il1 I (. Il

[Guthrie1962] 293-95). , Il IIill:\oI


:\oIeCle, l II 3:-, 11 I/"G
i:\olll

V-

,, . . l

IV

V ,

, :\oIII

- 06:\

:\I:\ol,

'

Ili'!II

I\l, lI :-\:\IiI I!AOCKoit.

:\oIOf

:-"I

Il,

'

27

nll

, ,
II ry
I1\I'O II lI

(89d-91a),

, l'O


(81-82),

l'O (84-85).
,

\"

IO

l, l" \"
,
.

-,

, "

: :ll

lIJ , II
I

rlllil ~III ll
~I, : "

ero

JJ

:'vlI.

Jl, II:'>1

u: ,Illll. lla:'>! "JI


IIII lIil II
n.IIIIO ll ll, iil,:

011

, - 'I1

( lIllil

(97b8f.).

al",

llO , 6 OI',\ :,>1


, :'>!III:

<1,\ :'>! l
11 ~,
, I1II II. lIII
\l"I u 11 II~I ;\III~fC "ocoKpaTOBCKJI:\1 Il
\(, : ,l ,

:l lIlI1I Jli,
IIJI II
pllal1l1cTY. il , ,
II: :ll, KaKII:\1 AHaKcal'op

II lr IIII ", IIIO

_ :I1 llOl
OllOil, , , ,
lIl\, ,
,I I:\1 ll (, 60 5),

RIl/, 11 R :\ IlOl'lll!
II":lII IIll lll,

28

apIYMellTa

Jl

Jl3

II()>>. , II, lI

Jl , Jl (

Jl,

aplY-

lI lIJlllO),
Jl , ,

(72d9-el).

Jl Jl ,
, Jl , ii
Jl Jl l1Jl

JlIIOI

, Jl Jl ,
,
Jl , -

Jl , JlI1 Jl
Jl (87-88).
Jl
Jl ,

. ,

(aQpovia)

: ,

, (85-86).

Jl

11

ilIO

apryMeHTOB

Jl3

. Jl
Jl
, Jl

Jl,

11

. JlI

:, IOJl. Jl :l Jl
, , Jl,

! , . . Jl
Jl , Jl
Jl ,.

nllzo

29


11<1 ,

,
011

<l

Il

apIYMeHToB,

. , tIO

ll,

Te:HIC,

1I~,IIlIO, , .\tn

,' (.

86b-d).

(. 862-5),

. ll ,

,
m

(.\lepmHocmH

. ,
ii:, ,
.

, lI
,

I - ,
(

");
ii .

,

.
:,

apIYMeHTaM,
, ,

011

: .

'll ll

, \ ,

'l, , ,

, '/ Il \' ,
ll ,

011 :380 <l


)( IlI .

30

11
l
I\
ll.

l"O

apIYMellT,

/\

60II0

(72-). Jl llll :~
(771-) 6 (771-5): Il

,

ll, lI

. (
) l"O

apIYMeHTa,

.I

(85-88).

ll , :~a

ll

l,

I\

aplY-

. /\
II.
II:

ll

, "?
,

(.724-S, 7l0-2)?

HaKOHel{,

"

?
l"O,
, Cl,

TOAI,KO

, ll (72S-6);
, ,

, ,

(726-7),

, -

31

nu

. JJ

Kpary
,

JJJI JI

~ - (732-3).

I'i1eT

MeIIOH

3JJ

, '! :

(.

81d4-S).

JJ

, I, ,

poii : , JJ JJ
I'I J10-l1

, , ,
i1;I CJ

JJ~l

~' ~
i1: JJJJJJ
!( , ,

- ,
:1"0,

19

Eb('rt ]974, 96-100.

JJ

JJIIO

II ('IIII II, ('

(' \lII, ~1 [ n. 767.;

e\l)'

6 II

,(' (,l'O

~llI ,

81('3-4.

II(' Jt:ldIIlI ('IIII, il II

(BW), IJlO

lcctio !acilior,

('IIII(,:'v1 lI;

11

lliJ Il

,IOI\I. OI' I1llil,


IIlI: \1 II (,'t~, 7((~";: i;:

'0\)'0), II 11 , \1

IO:/II~\I, ,i\lll? " ,

' ? (~3-5).

BTOpOil

II, '1\1 iI 6,\ r , J'


I1:~l[,

\lbI lI1I BW \1 lcctio difficilim':


oC:J (.:' ~'tl1(~";: i<;: ,L'),
\I II\I, , I\I,
IIJIII\IIIII.1ll? rbl lI , ?

II :

IIIO\lIIl1III \1 110 (60

01;

(' \II!('), , lI
OI'lll , ,
,

6, ,110601"0 VJ 113 :Iol'lllltl 'I.J" IIll


'< I"CO~ICTplI"lI _ 'u, ll 110I"'l (, 823-4),

32

, - ,
,

, : ;
(.

Mell.

84-).

, ,
,

I (922-5),

, ,

. ,


()
.
. ,

aplYMeHT ad J/Ominem,

. 2 \

aplYMeHTa

,
.

.
,

.
I

,22

129

( ,

20 .

Ebert 1974, 87 .
1975, 156.
22 . DL 8.4-5 ( II'
lII), 8.14; :VIII, D Vita Pythllgoricll xiv, 63.
111I (N Pllaed. 11 20, 1 Westerink) ll ai
21 ll

ULt6QCI'" vflV~(l(;, ll II
IIIIllllllll ".

nul!

33

lI :.

06 lIl1 1133 ,

06 ~B - .
l1 1I, (,
6 ,
)

I1

I1 ,
IIIIl\I ,

6 f.!L<iJf (.
. 34),

Met. 1 5,

f.!lf.!jmc;

98527,

(Met. 1 6,

9871) . or ,
lllll ,

,
lI,

l1 (.

Met. 1 5, 98534-36).

cl, , ,
(ELbj,

iblaL),

L: [
II .

i1

EOLV, ,

. ,

,
;

011

v. 23

, ,;

-
-

V. Cousin, Proeli Philosophi Platonid Opcra Incdita pars tcrtia.


Pafls
' 729 () I!:\1II
, IIl1. '164,l..
I:\1 III! (. /n Phaed. 5 6,2 Westcrink).
2J

34

: l1.
,
, ,
Cil

Cil 0/1
,

BepllO

, ,

,
: ,

,
,

I,.
, (73)
- ,


. , ,
.

, ?

, -

,
,

, ,

- ,

Cil, .

, I I
,
. () ,
-

GIO , .

. ll" . . ll, II:vllllI


IIll"ll II lIllll:vl lIIII

(n.\!. nlt).

35

nuzz(

:,) ,

il,

: ,

,
.
, ,

:, ?

, - ,

: .

, :

.
,

.
,
.

()

? ,

, , ,

- ,
: .

OIl.

, , ,
:,

, ,
,

: 24 ,
- , ,

- ,
:,),

, ,

pa:~Be ,

(d)

, ?

- ?
- . 31
- : ?
- .
- , , , - , ,

lI (Verdenius 1958)
735-6 v tQOi[O\' \', J10 (ll
1975), (Vicaire 1983) (Rowe 1993).

24

6m

36

: ,
,
.
. ,
, .
.

, 3, !

()

, -

, ,
,

,
. , -?

? , 2:; ,

? ,

,
?

, -

?
(74)

,
Ol ,

?
-.

-,
,

25 735-, 110 BCe:l<IY,

(73d5-8):

II

lll IICII;
)"

L71710V
11

if.1ciLOV. , I

(5)

ACI"O , . 73. lI
il , ~I

. KOIbeKTypa,
8, .

37

tl3 ,
, ,

III .

. ,
, ,

, ,
Mellb

TOl\'IY

, -

, ,

. ,

, ?
()

:, il 3, !-

3l1, ?

, ?
,
II, -, II
, .
0110 lI , ?

3I : ,

II
,

II,

?2

~6 "l .
lI lliI I"lIaCIIT "to"t[ f.1i-v [: :iVtlXL, "to"t[ ' Ol1 (wv
ltI mar,,\iIJc), )I - "[(~ ... "[~ ... (, ll
ce~leilcTBY, 11 W in marginc: I1

). lI II
, , (BIIKep ).

,IIII (Verdenius 1958,

209 .) II 060l\X ~IOI[L lI ll


,\: IIII lI,;\eTb IIa~IeK L llll (
IIO~IY '" ... ), TaKO~1 ll ll

\ IIO\' "II iIIIX 1111-

, TOla ~ II

CIIMMHII.

)il "l, 1I1I lI, ' II pe.1


eI~ (, III"O ,\IIlI<l ... II I"I" lI), 1111 II,\/l lll~1 ll

38

()

, .
, <5(. -

>

', ,

, !

, ,
,

: -

, l".

, I-I

, ?

' .

, lI?
, ,

.- ,27

I"OiI,

~lO.

KpoYle

f.!(V ...

, '[(

(d)

,[0,[( I

II - llII
...

'

iVLOH:

I II

(iVLOH), I1."Ih, lI BOKpyr lI KaYlOHII )!..'1 yII,' II:\1II (,[0,[[ f.![V ... ,[0,[[

), lI lX , , II ll
II L", aKJIX llII

IL"X

rnII

(Verdenius 1958, 209).

ll :\1 ll, , LV!''[ ,\


OIII1 IOYI . :\I)' u

748 (. LVfU :\I Yl

4 11 l

(747, 1, 6)

YlYl Yl ,
YlII. Or YlYllI Yl ,
, lD11 Yl UOL
l ,llII Yl l . I
,

Yloe IJYliUD1 11 m IIl.


11 '111(~,~ iav BYleCO ,,~ av. (Hackforth 1955,

193),

:\II,

27 7413 ll

IJ

(Gallop 1975, 229). (Rowe 1993) 11 II


(Zehnpfennig 1991), IIIllIO:\I ,
, , , n II1 ll .

39

nr/I\

, ,

, lIll.

_ , - , -

11

, II,

?
,

paBllo,28

Ill'?
, ,

, ,
-II , : ,
,

-
, ()

, .
,

ll ll ,

011 II

ll OJ'.

II.
,
, ?

- II !
- , II
(75)
, ,

, OII
, ,
I ! II ?

-, .

283
.

(I{ 1926), v (Verden-

1958), lI (Vicaire 193) 11 (Rowe 1993) v


II IJ lJ 74d6 C<UTO [uv iuov, - ~
(Bumet 19{){) I1 ;\ (ll 1975).

ItlS

40

, KOlle'Io, ,

,

?~9 , ,
.

, , . ,
,
.

, ()
lll ,

, , ?
-?
-, .

, , -

, -

,
, :

,30

, ,
?

, ,

, ,

, .

?
-.

29

(, , ,

lI

ll

1'0)

:l.I.

:1.1

, , , II
I

v ,

Kai 6

f.lUf.ltV (755) ,; {II ~IOl'~IV 74d9.


, , " , II
II I\I :l.1.
)0

757 :l.1

(Vahlen)

aVOLaHV

ai iwo~aHV, ':l<I), III'IO:I.1

IIYCT

II, Ol' :l<'" ll

i\lll ll.

"C:l<1

41

nuI(

()

- ?

-.

, ,

I!?

- , .
_
IIIIM Jl , , 11 , CJI -
, ,

?

,

, ,
, -

(d) Jl

CJlO-

, aJI, ,

, ,
ll ,

CJlOB

.!

:Jll , ?

BepllO.

, : , -

ei\'I,

:. ?

.
, ,
, :.
()

- , , Bepllo, - ,1
I\I.

- , , ,
, I,

alla ,
, -, :

JI ll, -

" R 75d2

1I\'1CCC (Rowe 1993) 'lI TOl'TO, TiJ, () (I.


195, ad loc. ll III (t1900), I'O()l'll

Cpll .. Vcrdcnius

1926) 11 lI (Vicaire 19).

42

Jl. , lI:~ ll

IIIleM, , Jl,
blloe Jl.
(76)

Jl

Jl.
, , Jl,

, ,

Jl, , Jl Jl
, Jl

- , ,

Jl lI

. , ,

OAIIO

: Jl ,
, :
, Jl , ,
:, Jl
, Jl

, .
, ?

, ll, () Jl
:~

MOIY

: Jl

- ,

:I1 Jl Jl ?

, ,

Jl

Jl ,

, Jl?
,

o'IeHb ,

:~Jl

, Jl,
Jl Jl -.
()

II, lI , ,

Il ?

;;mll ;;;; nul'

_ II,

43

, -

311 OI-?

- II .
_ OI

:lIIIl?

TOIO,

, !

, ?

-.

, ,

10,

;\0 -

l .

,
ll , ,

: ,
II .

(d)

- -, ,
?
,

I. ,
,

?
?

, , . ,

TOI/~a, I1, :

IId

, , l

,
,

, () Il,
II,

,

, lI

II, ,
,

?
, -

44

? , ,

,
, , , ,

IleT
-

-, ,
,

CII
, (77)
,

, !

, ,
I"O: ,

, ,
. ,
!

, ,
,

II

. ,
, ,

TOIO,

l,. ()
, ,

, ,

. l
,

. ,

:.t1 : -
,

,
,

TOlO

, :~ ,

45

nu

()

- zl, , - . -
: :
, ,
, .

HJOO , ,

ll,l .
.

:,
,

: ,

1\~leC

l"O,

.1ll,

(d) ,

cry ,


, /l.

. , ,
, .

(72-77d5)

KuK

, /

l,

011

, .

,
/ \1,

llM (724),

0110

l"O -
,J1I. llll /\,

clle/~yeT, , l' ll,


, , - ,
, 0, ,

. Toi)TOV (Sc. TCJ\I


I\(JYOV,

726)

l"ilUll! : 72-4 (' EKEt':O"

46

6v)

MOryT

. , 1
I

ll ,
. ,

,

. -

, :
.

, ,
, , , ,
(734-6) ,

COKpary

Cil,

. 6
Jl,

:~

(737-2),
Jl

I, l
Cil ,
l .~2

Jl ,
Jlil ,
Jl Jl
:, ,
Jl ,
~L'( l Jl."

32

92d,

II~~I, II : l aHa~lIIe

, II~ll l'~l

, 8l llu lII,

ll. :VI~ :.r


II u ~ ~ ~eCTe?

33

Iu ll UlI TO~, I

:VllI Ill

( ~ lIlII:'III) ~IIll, , ll
I, ll~II: l .<\.

nul!

47

III
rylII\ lIlI lI
l lI lIlI . 34

lI

ll (731-3):
III !, , lI .

(16XOcJllJ~lblX .
Cl, '! ,

lIaM

, II.

'I , /I
. -

11

:
IlII ,

II.
,

II

.";

POIIY

, , Cl, <1-

,
Il
,

l.

\!\ (73-74)
'Ii\lllI1 il

(Ackrill1973).

" /lIl~IlIl (1n Phaed. 11 8, 6-9 Wcstcrink) ,


'1> IIpll ,,~\ll:\1 Ill:l! ~lbI I
OC031e~1 llrl lllrn,

011

II

\ ( ll II II l): l\

IIiIl\~1 lI rn J m , '

CO:II\dC 1, ' '- , ,


IOI. II. II petitio principii. - a~
I!I , ~I~

IIIII~1\rn llCSI II Ul "TOIU

I\L'cca (111 P/mcd. 11 19, 1-2IWesterink): " II J


I Isc. I wrn lllrIL'( m:)
111.' :il, ' I1 l\, 111'( ~~, II1CS\ \Iilrn?). 11
HOllpUC \'1 \u 1 ceCIIHa .

48

734-4 ll

, '

Ct\CtflV11':; .:;,

mm/{/

73el)

(.

- .

: , ,

, , :

(i) ,
(ii) ,
(iii)
, .

, ,
,

: l ,
(
,

MOIY,

, ,

, ).

(ii) I

: ,
(,

, , ),

, ,
.~6

, ,

.
,
: ,
, n.~(L\ . ,

16

, ,

'" . 06 ~ II (Aekrill1973) 182 l1.

nllzol(

16.

49

i\I , . ,

IIJ , .
flJa, ,
Il,I .

/~ , lI. ll ,

pJ:lYMeBaeMbIX

3IIJ ll.~7

ll

73c4-d1

nJ\l
ll

ll, ll 73l-3,
Jll ll
.

'leM,

lI

ll

73l-3 ll ll
lI ll
: ll,

' ll

, ,

.'7

11.1

maKOdoe

. 36

ll II llI llll, ro ll
ll, C~I.

AckriII 1973, 186,

ll, I1

II('tlI, IIOlll ~Illllll II

, 11I0llll ll: " lI, Dorter 1982,


47, Scott 1987, 353, , 73-74,
IOIII' 06 II llOII l\lO,
Ile llI lI06II~l IIII. ,
:1<1\IC'leHHMI ~I, I lI:
1., :,)/I (Ackrill 1973), ~, l

'JO~IY ll II; ,

: II

00 ,lllllll II.
73c4-dl, l1l11: ",
\)<1('I'lIl1'l , eCAII II II Toro,
;. II (186), : 1011, 'IO , Mor ~ 11
ICHlle , II ,
' ,\ (186).

lIIlIIlO ll , apIYMeHT,
I>IOPOM II II J

50

74-dl


, :

, ,
IIO, , IIa
, , , :\

l l (75-748)
,

, II

(5-8). .
,


, :
, ,

?
(79-10)
I
, , 011-

011 .

, II

(iii),

II " -

111111

, lIII

~lO: II I aha:-'IIIlI

TO~I, II llI ,
II llII

11

(),

U1HAIIbI

II,

II

!I

, ro II

, U.m/>,

(186 .).

'rro 1/
.

51

m/1(


. J9 U;J"ll

, ,
,
,

.
:
,

, l-
, , .
.U. tm,

,
, (. . )

, -,
,

CaMOJo.

, ,

. ,
, l\l, ,

.1 - ,

J, .

- ,

. , ,
.

rnent

./I

recognition require-

lO

(ii), -

, (,
)

.
. ,

, ,
-

39

Ackrill 1973,

15.

52

.-I[]
,

: ,
.

.
, ,

; ,

, . ,


. , ,
, JIa,

: (737, .

(ii),

d7),


, :
:} ,
,

.
(742-4)

J, ,

(a",af.lv11u1c:

':,

73el),

. ,
,

? llO
, .

,
- -

.0

Ackrill 1973, 182.

1:

,1,.'vI

~ 'l~ lll aJ\


TO~ , Kora III

IX ;

lcr~

l ,'vI , ,
, III
;

<pillar-box)

", IIOKPTO~ ll~.

nu

53

, ,

. , ,

n.,

(j

, 3IIa.

MOJYT

. ,
, ,

, , ?

l1 MOJY ,

.
:~,

. ,
,

,

. , ,

7d5-l
,

,
,
.

74-dl, r
,

, MOry

(. 746-7:

- ,

- ... ).
, - ,41

. ,

Ackrill 1973, 188.

54

, ,


,
, ,

Ill~

I\ .
ry

--> , --> .

,iI.

, :

-,
,

, ,
, .lll

.
(745-8)

, ,

. ,

1130ll

-->

)
I

lll/L .
. II
IJlll\
, /lOl,

:l, llI

55

, ,
,

ry

. 42 I1 , , .
I

. ,

,
,

(iii)

,
,

- .

, ll

IJ\.

(iii), ,

.

ry

1130J\1

(lIe - ),

.
,
. ll

:/ll
, ll

lI :
,

II ,
, . ro:l<l

Ackrill 1973, 190.

56

(71QOELblVa.t, 743, 9)
(74d4-75a4). .ilI

.il :
, .il nlln./lL
.il1,
.il

.il I'

.il

.
C.il, ,

.il.il .

IV
, ,

apIYMeH-

.il ,
.il . .il

, .ilIIII
,

ll.lIfJ .il .il,

lILllI..
.il
.il .il .

.il

.il

C.il.il,

.il

.il . .il

.il ?
, . .il
, ,
lI .il, ll

ll
, ll II

. \lll
MOIY .

m/l(

57

Jl ilJlI
Jl Jl
' ,

11

JlIO Jlll OIIOJl JlI

JlI

(<<
,

JlJlI ,
,

66bl-67b5).

,
, Jl, J1 JlI

Jl

Jl;
Jl Jl.
Jl Jl

Jl

Jl ;

TOJlbKO

CJ1 Jl,43

Jl Jl
Jl CJ1
() , CJ1

, , I,
(;),
Jl,

-, llll. Jl
NI

CJ1IO, ,

ll..
(. III

"'

1,

1554-7)

rII ll, il II

llro llll, .

Ebcrt 1978 11, ,


Fredc 1992 11 l I TO~I
~ OlIIIIIILl Oxford Studies in Ancicnt Philosophy.

. .

Stokes 1986,1-35;

58

'J
ii

,
, ,

mZIl ~(mm!lll(.
: 3
, JllIl

11 Jl

l,

apry-

ll (6;) JI,
l,
JlJ ,
.

(. III

4,

15918-20)

, , J
, ,

,

, ,

, Jl, ,
,

J
, .
(. III

4,

15920-24)

llJl Jl,
Jl, ,

,
, Jl

3J ( IIaJl ),

Jl IIaJ
( ,
)
( '),

I7.ll3 nlt ll3 nllm I'311.

nll1(

59

,
, , ,

(l, )
,

II

60 .

I(

:
6 ,

, .'\3 CtnPOlltnb

J\.,\'lll AtHeHllII (
). ,

, II


, .

II ,

.
, ,

II ", IIll III

llllllII ,\,
l1ll

110

II ll [

[Hamblin 1970]),

1931] 11 XCMlIlIHa

:I ll[' . II

IIII:\1

(Moraux 1961\)

ll,

lI (:\

8III~1

IIllllllll

ll lII1II "IIIIIIIIIII I1

TC,I fllII

"lIOII08

I . ,

.,

IIIl 11 .

Kacael'CH ll, ,
O;l.IIaKO, [llll ([\[.

VIII

292),

, II II

IJ IIll

III[

JII[,

ll II [lOIl[III.
! IIll II"i[ .

IIIII,

(Patcr 1965)

60

l "

, :

, J
(

), i . VI

1,

155-5,

Jl
Jl ", 170-171;
: I

Jl (. VI

2,

15711-14),

(. ",

75d);

, Jl Jl,

Jl (. VI

9,

16021), ,

, r ,,[

(Gorg.469b-c).4:;
Jl,

Jl Jl

Jl
Jl Jl

eI'o

. ,
Jl Jl ,
Jl

(lI)

1
(-11) ,

Jl .
Jl

1:

- :
,

Or, , .

(Alc. Mai.

.,'

. I'

1I)

(Diiring 1968, 211-229) II


11 ll

l1 :w

lIiI,
lI ,

nuZ1(

61

Or
, ,
lI ,
(. 112)

()
(.

112dlO).

,
.


,
- ?

:
. ,

ll .
,

, ,

, ,
, ,

.46
, ,
'l . ,
,

,
, , , ,
t1 , ,
.
,

t1
,

,
: , -

Toro, l , 'l lI
IIIII\III MHeHlle 110

""

II IIHOMY
.

11

62

-
, 11 ,
- .

Fl

F2.

,
,

lIO

, , lI

Fl

, .
:
( ) , ,l /l,

F2 ..


, .

. : , >,
>, , ,
,47 ,
, lC,


, .

,
. , ,

'la

'7

l ,

(82-85), lI :
lIO 1 , '
IIII/ "R~L II:

aopO~I. lI IlIIl

(83bi!-cl),

(]11 t;); / ,

CTOPOHOi/

ro, (835-7), II

III: > (LV['[)

- ,

lll/l II:III .

nllzo

63

, CJl ,

, ,

I"O,

!/ 8

- .

v


"I!,

\ ,
\
. ,

(.

737-2),

-:

(:! 7:] ! G710.lV4J).


(733-4)

.8

lIYl:l.1 , II

, Yl III
lI1I
,

l1fl

Resp.

IIpaBllllaM

II,

, 477-,

, 1I:\1

Yl

,\ ll IIlI lYl.

IIIIIBaeT

(4775), ,l

1111 YlHelllle

, 'il

, l , Ylllll

lI.

:la

I1

YleCTOYl

, :l.1 lll

Yl llI I (.

477b7-11),

, (477l,'

' OlIl I1

(477b11-d5),

:\1 Yl ll ,

IIll

(477d7-e3) 11
,

1111

'l

CHOCOOHOCTeil

illlll

IIII r .

Yl

ll

ll

lIYl llllII (:\l

lIIYl I1 llll:~ 'lI

Mllpax), IIallll

lVYllYl II "IIYl :I ,,('

l/lOYl. (. 110 ro 1I0 Ebert 1974, 122 .)

64

Il:

II> >

(nq mJ

LQ'lU ').
:

? (qb' ).
(79-1)
, ,

IlI. ,
, ,

(VHI 1,

1554-7) : ,

011

.~9

.
I (74)
:

IlI, (n~<;)

, lI ,
ll?

(7-5)

, .

1)' llO

. , , ,

, .

'9

, ' :. Cl ,

cr II l'O

11

11

[[lQV,

lliJ llOtlh.1, J

llII: tl

('tl

Apllcro-

termini technici ll .

65

nu

JlerKo ,
71-4

F1

(. flUflV, 71, ; olcOa , 7d5).


71-

F1-

, Olcf)a ,
TOLOUOV (71),

. 7d

F1,

, ,

(75-748),


i (735),

F2.

(, )
, <,

,
.
,

Ile

lI

.

,

74a9-d ,
,
,

(749-12)

.
. (

65d4-5,

.) : ,

?. (742-).

:l . -

66

, lI

, Jl Jl
, , lIII

Jl , I?
lI lI,
, Jl -, II
, Jll II.

(744-6)

,
,

73c6-dl,

Jl

Jl


CJI Jl Jl :

ib({)v (736) JI ib6\,'TEC: (744), E'rEQO\"


- EKELVO EVE\'0I1CC<flEV, E'rEQOV ()\,'
'rou'rUJv (746). Jl II,
EV\'O~m~ (738)

Jl

Jl

Jl
Jl. JlII

apIYMeHTa-

Jl; ,
, Jl
Jl Jl
Jl:

lIe

II, Jl

? JlII : ,

Jl lI
, II

, - ?
- , .
- , - lIe JlJl

Jl, Jl ,
Jl

- , !

nll

, ,

67

JI

, JI.

(74-)

JI ,

7-dl CJI
JI. 3l1

, JIl
. , 7411

JI CJI 71aQCt 'u 71

tTEQOV .

eI1 ,

JI l1
JI , JI
JI,

749- CJI

74d4 ff.

JI ,
, JII JI
,
, JI

. :
,

JI

EVVEV6'lwc;

(aUT()U

'1V 71t]fl'lV

! I'l)

, ?
(747-9)

JI

744-

(f36V;, EVEvo~aaflEV)
, JI

JI

JI; JI

68

(II,
), lI IO
.

lIlI, lI 3,

,
,

I,

73c4-dl.

(71]fl)

(.
71]fl)

71QiyvL

'lQ()714J

'lLOU,

O'lav

734-5).

, ,
lI, . .

IO
( ) ,
(
)

lO

IO ,

, , .

Evvo{i,,' 'c~Y
i',,'voLav ("'~) flf3VELV (. 73c8-dl).

(71]~l)

744

(7100 f36V'l~

[Sc.
atJ'lou ~Y 71lG]fl)V;)

]?

,
, . . ;
lO I-I,)

,) ,'

. .

03IIII

. 742 (.\(. n)).

nuzl(

69

. ( u'1 ,
n>

73c4-dl

[198d),

, lI,

744 ,
II. ll
[197]

Ki]m<; Emm:~fl'l<; [
)' :]

n;L<;

71r1fl'l<; [

ry, ].)

l,
: 73l-748

, rnU3aL!ll

lIO .
744
llrnIl ' I ,

.
flr3\'ELV ( ).

744-6

,

Evvo{iv

'l ,

738: : (

) rn.\llaL!ll uml
,

ll LL\uml

llrnllll Il.
,
747-9,

flr3"'IV

EV"'OELV -

(aUTOU

) 71lfl'lV EvvEvo'la<;

! L'l;, 748-9), ,

.
,
rnLLll;

: i\,

70

r5m

nllll, Jl

. , tfO
, Jl Jll

, Jl JI 74-dl Jl
ryJl

eJl . Or CJl
Jl : . CJl
: Jl Jl. Or ,
Jl

Jl ,

:'

Jl

74-dl, , 744-6
747-9 , ,
CJI Jl

Jl () .
, JlI

(7d) Jl Jl
. Jll,

74-dl (.

74c13-d2,

76l-), Jl Jl

. JlI :
Jl. Jl 1Jl
Jl CJI Jl
,

Jl , ,

, Jl'
Jll , ,

:
, Jl

. Jl, ,
,

,
(
) .

; IIII,

gcn.

nOYllI:l<1O

, :l<I\

11II1II\lIaTOpa

IIllIIYllllll

110

II (74, l, 762-), . gcn. I :lllIIIl


II'llI (744, 5, 7, 756, 7, ll, 6).

nll

71

,
(ij:).

(iii),

, ,


.10 l\'1 ,

74-d1.
'i!

,
.
,
lI ,

(74l1-12).

.
, , -

.
:

, , ,

, ,

, .

, ,

.- ,

,
, ,
?

, .

(741-d)

, 74-d1 742-.
, -

'1

3 ,

73c13-d2

OI , lI II:\I:\III :l,
: :o.t- !

y:o.teCTHblM,

72

, ,
,

.
,
.tlO


( )
,

~~

6 I'

,
!


74a9-d

,
. (749-12),
,

Fl:

-, , ,

,
,
.
, ,

, ,

.'2

52 (Ackrill 1973, 191 .) II ,


3l1a'lellllC : 742,
, MeCTOlI:l<leHIIC IllJ OlbICA :I<lbI,
II. lII ,

742 ":\lbI lIII IIOBO~I :-;III,

nu

73

, ,

F2.

:I

, l1

( ) ,
. , ,
,

, ,
74I-d.
l

,
.

VI

74d4-75c6

II

.
,

, lI ll

Cl1; , ll 747,
: l\
Cl1:

ll

74d4-7

. I1 ,

II 1l,\lI , l/ll
lI

(7411-12), l1

Ca:vlOM

CI

'II

:vlllll:vl llII

lI lI:l,lI~ lII
) :vI,

IIlI<1II~1

:vIbJ

:vlIl

311a1ll1(' 11 (II:
TaKlle II :'l('lIlIiJ 11('

I)'MeHTaTIIBHoil II ,.

74

(74d9-e7)

/
:
, .

m.llllll
(744-

6),

,
, ,

, {/J dll
n_: ,

(74d9-e4)

(. a\,'aya"io\', 2)
,
II)' .II :

, ,
- , : ,

'/-
,

, .
,

: ,
,

II?

(74d9-e4)
, "-
- onpe(k\eHHOlO ,

:\Jpallee

Ol II.

nu

75

,
II

apry-

l:

II

,
, lI?
(746-7)

!
,

, 3 ,

lI ll

(744-1) ,

II

. , 06

ry

(i:V'\'OEl'\')

(lXf.lr~VELV). , ,
,

(. 755-7),

60-

II , ,
:, :

(754-6).

aplYMellT .

757,
3 OI' ,

06 . .t
'r ,

cXQlX (<<: 749, 754,


75c4).:;~ pa:~:

5) (, , ,

ro) II II

II I1llIlIl llI II!\

IIII, 11 u 1JOllII 10 10 11:\ II (754-5) I'll (I{obin 1926)

6m

76

.. , lIO


, lI ll ,

( lQTOV

ib6','TEC

[(

EVEVOrj-

m1V),

, ,
?

110

, .

(74e9-75)

, ll
. ,
,

... ,

. ,
,

patmble,

. . -

.t1

. ,

6-

Hble. , ,

,
: .;
,

, , ,

.

11 BIIKep (Vicaire 1983)

lI .

ll ,

I":\!:\llil )'lII . I"

CKO:\'I,

HC:\IClIKO:\I,

IIlO

'lllO IIO IIl\II,


3. Il

(Ackrill 1958, 1(8);

(I{owe 1993) ad

" ,
,

11,111

lI ll

ll II . "ll II

:\! , ..11I
II OI' "IIJ(,

rlll

77

.;:;

, , .
:

, , ,

(EvVEvol1KEVat)

(~l1:

EIvat V"\rlat)

buvaTov

? , ,
.

, ,

. , ,

.

(75a5-10)

(747-9), l,

744-6
:
,

, ?
(747-9)


:
/,
II ,
,
nll6 -

;.< . Dist,

1934,346

394 .

78

Teo(lop 6m

II ..'" -

ll

l10

ll

0311

llll , lI I10
ll 3l1. ,

, ("

I10 ll lI .
lI II
II , .

l1

cry

,
I1,
/l, ,

, , l1?
I1 -?
(75ll-2)
l\I I1

1lO

l1ll.

,J !\,
lI 3 , /l,I1
; , llll il
'(~l l1 II

;"

(,

. . ( lIO:\1

:'j 755 :\I

IlIIcblle) II :\
caMo:\IY , II

751-.
II lIII it (747-9) ll II

:\IOCTII.

I:\I\I , Moil

,I, :

II

KOTOpbIil

II

IIllJIIII

(1)

ll II

,\il

751-: ,
, lI
.

(2)

llII,
.

II

l\allllOC

aUTO

llII

ll

nllI(

79

, ll,

OJlIIll ):

, ,

ClIbIIllaTb

'IYBCTBO-

, II II -

, II
, I' :
, ll

, ,
?

, ,

ll , .

(754-9)
ll llll l'O
ll , II

, lI

(749-753),

O II ,
,

l'O ,
, II,
. ll lI
, .
ll, , lI
III - ll
,

II,

110

ll

lI (
II lI ) ,

0110 lI
ponens ll'

modus ponendo

IIII'

pallee

Il

(75ll-2) lI ll
l ll.

80

II ,
:IO

,

(754-6). ,

74-12
,
ll.

:l

74d4-75c6

, ,

lI . -,

lI

l ,

. -, l
,


, IlI
,
,

() ,

, . ,

74d8-e4,

I\

II\

755-8,

Fl:


ll

II .
6UV:

nu1!

81

, ... . , , ,

F2.

;~
.
, ,

, . .
.

74d4-7,

-7 75ll-2,

n, n

-
.

, , ,

14,

1128-

protasis

problema

('t:Q07tOC;):


?. ,
, : '

, '
?; : '

, '
, (~

ou;)?

(. .

1 4,

101-).

, 03l 'I -

82

, II

II
lI ll ll (1014-6). II ,
, ll, ll
I ,
II

, I-Ja II,

l
.

,
.

1 10-11

ll


(.

1 10, 1044-5);

- ,

prima jacie

he- (. 1048-11);
, ,
caA>>::

,
,
(. .

1 11,

104-5, 29-6).;;7

, I
, ,
,

cBoelo

746-7,

. ,
()[()

TEXVfJ

),
, ,

57

II

10434-36,

IIIlI1I II

, .

IIII

p/"{Jtasis 11

m .

- llllI
Hadgopoulos 1976.

r/(

83

(\"[t71( ),
ry .
( ,

),
, .

:~- ,

?,

75al1-b2,

746-7,

. ,

74d4-7,

6-7 75ll-2,

. ~ ;

3.110



; , ry
( )

(I ),
.

746-7, ,


. , 75ll-2
(746-7)
,

, '
,

cr

cTaryce

84

: ,
, , .
,

-
.

(100d),

'

(naQouaia)

(KOlVUJvia), -

,
,

11

flE1:EXEIV)

( ,

1005,


-.

,
ll
, ?
,

(.

12d-13).

Parm.

tritos mltlzropos,

,
. ,
,
. ,

Ol .

,
,

. -

nllaz/!

85

.1mll: ( :
), :
,
-

lI ,
. '!

(74d8,

5, 8)

ll .
, ,
748, ,
II

,
, .

(Fl-)

, ,

(755-8),
,

110

,
, :
, ,

[Sc.

].
, ,
.

(759-10)
,

,
, -

86

. ,

"

(. V

4,

15918-24):

(I), ,

6:),
,

xO'IeT

II .

, ,
.
.

,
,

, ,

(.

754),

-,


(. 7410).
,

IIl ,

,
,

'IYBcTBeH-

,
,

.
, 0-

:m

: IIII -

nllazl(

87

Jl

Jl ?
Jl ,

, .

Jl,

Jl

, JI'
Jl

(7Sal1-b2),

MOAeJlb

: ,

].

[Sc.

, ,

Jl , Jl
JI JIll
,

Jl


, Jl Jl Jl

>EL

710U iA'l'[ E71Lcmlfl'lV at)'[ou


'[ou LaOU, 75bS-6), :
, ,
.

Jl n

.\, () Jl
, Jl

Jl

CAeJlaHHbIX

. ,

I1 ,

TOJlbKO

I. ,

', Jl JIJl

rJlarOJla EWOEiV (74d9,

2,

7Sal, a4-S, a1l),


-

, Jl ,

(7SbS,

1lI JlJl :ktVElV


: Jl 76).

, nuJ\ (EI'l;,
Jl ) :ll -

88

nllll_,

_\tblX

npeclJ\femoti,

7410; , .ll
nllll (I"]6:, )
n/i.,\ll u . ,

: :~

( .ll ry
, . 755-10),

; ,
.

.II

(752, 3, 6) lI
, .

.II ,
.II

,
).

.ll

(na,,'u

. ,
, , ,

,
,

(lV),
.
,

, .


,
Jl

(744-756)

ll
, 1,

89

nu

06

; ,

, ,

-06. , :

, ,
, ,

.
?
,
II, IJa
, lIO

. ,

Fl

JI

F2

,
, ,
,

, 'Ja,


FI- 755-8 . : ,

[Sc.

] (EVVE\'0'lKE\'lXL)

(I-l'lbl bU\'lX'l"OV Elv'aL


~) ,
.

-:
,

? IO. :J
,
, II-

Lm

90

.

I

.
?
II

I, lIe

O,lUblKO

, ,

, \l Mory :\,
. 8
ll

i(To't11';;

l\139 - .tl


. ,

"

, Mory
, ll\1
Il.

Oll,


;
,

747-9. ,
,
ll ?
, IO',

Oll
. , :
: (I1
), :\

mlll

'. 3I. ~ICCTO , ~101YT ,111 II.lC<l,II


I\<l lIye~1 .. :Ill\l ,ll\IlII. TeoplIlI ..

ClpaKI\I1II . llll ~!IllI ll (Geach


;9 . ~1 II.tl,

Cat. 6,6<125 ..35:

1957, 11 .. 45).

, ' lI

~1 iUO"l! L1i L''''l(OV, I~


CBoiI II. K0I/\d pl"lb ' K<1'1CCllIaX, ()IIIt.'IlII~llIl~
IIlI IIlpe'leCO~1 i)POL(N (1IIIC~Il'I(KO'1 'IIIO l' IICIIO,II ...

:\ ,o,:lcicll, 11 lIlll "'IIL'I III 1010 .IIIl'IIII<I).

rlu

91

oO-
,

,
:

,
hl !1l
.

:J

u_

JOJO

, llf, ,
f, ( ,
,

f,

).
, ,

(:

). , ,
,

, lI ,

, ,

, , , , ',

II'l , 6

, il ,

'leM.

ClJ

, 'IJ lI

n.\! mllOtmu

JJ

lI, .

l'lll

92

:, Jl lO

yr,

Jl

,
, Jl

0110
01\-

Jl ,

III
. ,
I OlI
, :I

1 ,

II /J. 1

. Jl ,
Jl lI IJl:?
Jl Jl , ,

Jl ?
Jl , Jl

(75c7-d5)

II,
Jl

(<< ...

Jl

, Jl , lO
... );
JI,

OlI <lO,
,

JI,

).

Jl

~I .
::JII,

Il Jl

I"O,

Jlll

(Jl), ,
Jl Jl ( >

Jl Jl, ( >.
, :l
, Jl .
,

lXQf.lOvlCl.,

Jl

JlII :

nlll!

93

:,


, , ,

I' ,
, ,
, ?

I' ,
.,l 11
, ?

,
lO I'
, -

, ?

(9dl-11)
CJl ,
(

CJl ,

tXQf.IOvia) ,

, - l'O
, - ,

, ,


il ,

)l'O ,60 CJI

,

, , , -

(,()

,] dOI',

11

,,[)

11

11

~Il('['

""IIIll,

(11,111
161d,

lI ~ ~IO ll
ll: ,

11

~, ], , ". ~

IIllI\

OlPdHII<[CIIIIC
HCIlPII"ICIIII"la
IJa ll/\~,Il'IIII "il / il),

(Mct,

5,

105620-22,

:lI! IIII [' "vll,

ro

94

(10

:, lI ,


,
/.I,.

VIII

(7611-13),

MOI

'I

(75c7-76d6),

, l\

.tl :
,

(769-10),
(- )

,lIII

(754-6). .tl

- lI
,

l\

.
, , lI lI,

(75c7-76d6)?

, III II :
[I1

apIYMeHT -

lI lI,

, 754-6, . .

lI, ,

lIlI

(.

766-13).61

,
(\:

lI ,

lI

. 

Gallop 1975, 129 JI.

nlll(

95


( ii -
> , 7414-15),

llll, ,
,

1J1O (. 71-,

74I-d2) ...

:
,


,
'I

[]

eIo

.
(76-12).62
[, ,
,

OKa:~aTeACT

, :

KPYIY,

, . ,

( )
,

,
dII. 7l-, ,

II, (I-.1('r)

. , 0,
,

II

7d5-10, ,
- .

, -

62

H.owe 1993, 174

96

. , ,
'l

? ,

lll

76-12 "
ll (
?),

,

.110 .

,'

75c7-76d6

:\
,

IOI'

71]f.]

(.

744, 8, 755-6, 1, 4),

U]fl] ,

(75d4,

4, 76, 6, 15,

d1, d2).

' :
, :


I II.

, :\
I'
,

(75c7-d6).

nu

97

(),

\'0

, \' ,

I' ( )

, ',

'

(75dl-2),

(.

75d2-). \' , ,
,

, .
, ,
,

, ,
;
; ,

, ,
,

(75d7-76c5)

.
:

aplYMell-

modus tollendo ponens.

v -),

- --+

R,

--+

Q,

Q vR

(= ) (75d7-76a8)
Q v R, - Io Q (= modus tol-

lendo ponens)

(769-5)

98

= ,
,

Q =

,
, !{ = :,
. '

-R

", ,

',

modus tollendo tollens:

R --> 5, -5,
tollens)

(765-3),

-R (= modus tollendo

5 =

(
,
, '

).

,
( )
,

tertillm datllr

.
(- -->

75d7-8,

R)

( -->

Q) -
(Q v R),

752-7;

WGTE,

764-7.

apryMeJa (769-2).

(R

-->

5) apry-

-',

avrJQ

(765-6),

apryMeHTa (-5)

768-9 ( 76-12);
apryMeJa

(-R),

II

MTP-Ill,

I~

aQa

nuI!

99

76l-3. Jl
,

aQa,

: 764-5.


?
,

- l
Jl.
. ,
,

BJlaBaeM

.
Jl ,

l Jl
. Jl
-,


: , OI

, Jl

, .

,
764-7, ,

Jl

: :

(buoiv

Q, ~,[Ol ...

1) ... ). ,

...


. 3 ( , -

:\1 II, lI

63

~1l , ".

Il (ll

1975, 131

II

ll:l.f

II.) l
II

IllOLl

lI, , r-, , tl

II, 764-7 IItl


II ,

II. ,
II II, ,

ll' , , ,

:\Iax r.

aKclIO-

100

IO IO).

aprYMeHToB.

() ,

75d7-12,

- , ,
, ,
,

. ?
.
, , ,

.
,

, ,

(75d7-12)
,
,

).
,

.
,
- , !I

. , ,

, Il ,
, ,

75c7-d5,

, , -

nu

101

. ll I1,

Jl

75dl0-1l

lIII

l160 . ll

Jl

7d-.
:,

.
Jl, Jl ,
,

'Jl

15711-14).

Jl

Jl

(VIII 2,

Jl

Jl Ol1, , Jl

Jl

Jl

Jl

Jl , Jl
JlII Jl Jl JlJl
Jl Jl .

,
: Jl

- Jl .
, - Jl ,

Jl , Jl
Jl Jl.

Jl
(2-),
'
Il

:.

J\ .

YCJlOBIIoe

,
,
Jl Jl :

, , ,
JlJl ,
,

102

(10

, -, IIa

,
. ,

, , ,
lI .

lO.
, , , -

, , -,

,
,

- ,
,
.

(... )
(752-764)

(a.vaAa~lr~a.VElv)

timti.\ll

:.

,
, OI

II ,
.
,


,
.

lO

I ry :
,

(oiK{ia

lO

J.t

Jf..l.fJ).

,
md .
, -

nuzo

103

- Jl,

ll

Jl

, I .

ll
,

, Jl,
, (.

47),

CJl

, 73-74
,

YMaJl-

Jl

. Jl

Jl

ll, Jl
lI;

:Jl . ll

, :,

011

- Jl.

, CII (76l-4)

Jl

Jl

Jl

(753)

CJI Jl

73c6-d1;

Jl , Jl'Jl v] (<<
Jl) Jl Jl
. Jl, (

Jl

73c6-dl)

Jl ()

, CJI,

Jl

Jl

. Jl, Jl

, Jl Jl

, CJIlI
Jlll, Jl

(/) Jll
. Jl Jl
Jl ,

Jl ,

Jll' , Jl 06

paBellCTBa


JlJl,

104

?
, ,

, ,
.

OI

(768)

(764-7) ll ,


:},

IIecKoAbKO

(769-).
?

apIYMeHTe,

(76b4-),
l ,

ofi-

, ,
}"IHeHUII:

bOK{iv 11

(. 764, 8, 1);

b<1~a.

(lI) . ,
, /

, I .

, -

, '
, IlI
, . .

, 'l

75c9-d2.

76-12 , ,
,

nll

105

(:

). ,
( )
. .
( )

,
HbIl\,l 742- , ,

. ii

, :
el'o IllIOI

, ,
. 64 , -

6. llll1 :vI 742-3 11 761-3 II ~l


II

ii lI, I"O, IIl\JlOlO

I, II

11 l"O (. Hackforth
Ackrill 1973, 191 ., 1975, 120 133,
uffm 1981). l 11
.,

1955, 75
,

\1Iit, :},\lOl' TO~'I, Il II

:\III1 I, II II

~-Ia\lI'lJ(JI /

- " i\ f II:\/
1975, 133), II ,

75c10-d2

II IIil

I. illlOl1 vll "1


"lII II HpaBcTBeIlHbI~l, lI II IIII

(Huffmann 1981, 105)


1I"leeT 8 811 8

76-12 IIIl: ~IIIII ,lO

/ ll, , II , ,

' ,

CIIOCOOIIOI'O , lIO
u 11 IIlI lI TCKCTO~I f8l1,
IOpOC II-: IIII lO lll i\I
.

ll

lllllil

80ll

II :\ OI',IIIIII II ,I, f

il (lv v 11EQl

1:0VH,'\,' ';'V vuvbl1

i),V, 768-9), :"I 'I1lIO, :} 1I0"I


lIll

"lbI

742-3

75cl0-d2 IIPCII\ICTbl. I'aJIIIII


00 I OI

"I IIlIII II

:"lO

I180'II

76-12, OJ II:"III11
,,
80I

11,

;\,l,

3HilIIIICM

'IO"I;

:'>I "I :\I , 8


I1l\,

1aKO\IY

:lIIlll1

IIC ,\llJ.

r5rpnt

106

, II

il .

011,

, 749 I
,

011

ll.

764-5 ll,
ll
ll ,

ll

ll,

. ll

ll

ll,

lIa

76c6-d6

, (.! u.L

~PWV,

766)

(76l1-12). II'
,

lIe

, . .

. 766 .
II

1ii ,

. ,
, ,
ll,

I"O,

?,

II

C)'I.l. 757 tl.,



(754-6).
766-7
,

lIac

I'

754-6. , ,

(ll

aprYMelITa

1975, 130

134),

:h ll , ,

ll Ill
ll, !I.

nll

107

(.94)
, f1lI,

,
. 7
.

f1lI

"
),l\,

. , , ,

. V l

,
l

.
, ,

(.

1,

1558-24,

156-1575),

aplyelrra

.
, '/

l' ll

, ,
/ , ,

.
(.

VIII 1,

1571-)

.
, ,

OI" 759-6

1'13

: ,

011

ll ,

l ;~l :

(. 86), II:,
ll II

108

(754-5),

7410 , ii
: 3

. 759, 3, 6
OI , corAallJaeOl .
, ,

. . OI, >,
76ll-13.
,

LI .

:,

aprYMeHTa

11,

, ( )


:.

.
76ll-12: ,

, .

I 1I

. , ,
, ,
:~ec

ll,

t!..\! .
, , 1
,

'

; ,
pe:~YATaTe
:

(76c14-d6).

I
I (

cAY'lae

I). 11-

m/z{

109

:l,

76clO

756). :l,
II
. , ,
.6.;

,
,
:l, ,

: (. iiQ' W~LOl1.I-IV,

76d2-3),bl;

, .

YKa:lbIBaeT

:
I .
, /'

. ad10c.: ll COL(~'

6:;

lIl

66

kaKOI"O-II

TLVL:

IIIlI, llII IIlIII.

IIJIO 1I:\lllO :'.I

rAaroAa

f.\V,

:\I :\Iece ,

,
'

11:\11.'.010 , II J:\lI ll
modus tollendo ponens (769-3), rAaJUAY

I II ll , :\Ill 1"0 :\1O

IIAII

:\1

lI

(.

1(4) :\Ibl

ll

:\lll:\l

BToporo

II:\I:\III

e:\lY ll.
.lfIlell!lII,

BeCL:\la II:\JlO
JAaI"OAa lLV :\I :\ICCTO-

l ro 'III. ,

II

~LV

:\l , :'.1
lIIllil
il

II

II,

dI

:\1

, ll lI OlI1,

lllII

lI:\l

II:\l

ll . lI:\l (

IO II :\l (~'f.\o~f.\V)

rOBoplIT

77 lI1I lIO ll lll<JlOI )


II) II :\ll, I,

II I

Kpyrc

llil.
-

11

II

II , ,
[IO:\I ll, II J"() :

:I' lI , II:\1 fil :\Iepe


, , [ "II ", .

110

ryMeHT

769-3

I'

modus toIlendo ponens

,
(764-5), , ,

(76a9-bl),67

IX
, I' 73

76d7-77d5,


, ,

.\Illl.\t , ,

75c7-76d7,

F1-,
Il

(764-7)
,

.7 ;>

(Gallop 1975, 134),

.. ,,

lI :

II, , II , ' J
CIIM:I-I cr<ll II II
ro 11 , ,\lil ,:l-1

II~! lO:\! ,

KOTOPOro

, IDl II llllll, , :l-I)'

' :\1 ll (753

11 765), II IDl~!

J!, , ' n
lItt

11

1) CI!:\I:\lIIil J!~I)':vIII

J1 IIIlIll ,,!

r)':l-! , "I)' ' ,\iIIIO

1 lI ,,! ,\ llllll,,!

JI;

2)

:\I

IIAeT

n(!,

,
cr' 113 .... 11

11 748 I!'!, II "'l)'


011 II
:\!llllO I, 110 011, , 11 l1"la '('OI' ,
II ,

nul(

]]]

lI , ll IIall
ll , , ,

lI ll, ,

."8 ll
ll

Ol'

lI

ll,

lI

apIYMeHmodus tolIendo ponens


aplYMeHTY modus tolIendo tolIens,
ll ,

, -I
ll },[u .

ll

lI

ll

ll

lIeI'Ko

1 ,

t, ll ,
, aJIIO llI:

, lI ,

ll -?

llIIO .

(764-5)
llJa

n03zo. ll

CKOl'O

(. 725, 755-7, 766-7).

ll
, -

68

llIl, : II Il

IJ II lI1, ,
- IIII

cBoero ~
:ltICIICC, II 110 illl :It1epe
011 Ild II ,\, "

lI. II
:lt10lI, '

el'o

112

lIII: )}1O
lI -, lI

, l ,,

'l, l, ... ?
,
, , :-

nlll,
Jl

: ,

Jl

Jl

Jl

, Jl

JlJl JlJl ~lr3VEl\' (744, 755,


2, 4, 7,

d5, d7,

2, 76, 6, 14, d).69

Jl'IaI,
,

. ,
,

, ,
Jl,

Jl

' , II
Jl ,

(. III

:~

15918-20).

4,

,
,

Jl

. Jl
Jl,

. 76

Jl JllI.9 Iil : ll311 lIlt

:\1 llllII ,
II
,

(726-7) - ,

"1

II

[ ll III:'llIIll],
.

11

C01i:pam "" nuI!


,

113

. , , ,

, / U 7614-15

lI

. ,

;

(768, l0). ,

,
.

< ,
ll)

, ,

,
, 756.
, , ,

, ,
,


.
,

II

70 11 TOI'O,
~' l~1

II

:,

: II, OI - lI,

:,

011

,\

11

011

3 ,

l' ,

~' , ~I nlln".l!Il11m

. .?

- . -, l
:\ILI ~1 "080PIIl, IIIllJOlIIII. , . - 3 r, ~1 R
IIII. - .

114

I, I,l
, ,

, :

, I
,

75d7-

( )

74-dl

,

) (76l-4).
, ( )
,

(76blO-12),

, ' ()
(742-).

I
,

(764). ,


(7611-13),

.
, 1
,

.

apIYMeHT

.
.

115

n!lz!

cr,

73c1-76d6,

J ,

i\.

(76d7-77d5)

IO l1lcr
: .

,
J,

lO .

12;

10

, ,

,

,
,

; ,

lO ,

9 (

cr).

,

76d7-e7;

: ,

AOBJIO
,

(77-9). ,

, 732-3,

, ,

:. ,

,
,

(77l-5).
,

apJY-

116

(77c6-d5).

73c-76d

IIa ,


, , ,
IIa ,
,

.
, ?
?


, :
, , :
()

(1)

CJI, ,

(2)

,
,

(3)

l;,0I-lV),

('[av'[a.

LV .El

, ()

, ,
,

?71 7} , ,

76d7-e4

, . , ro

II llll1 ,\
III

o'lepeAb,

(76d7),

ll

. ll

76d7-e4

IIaI ' OVl"';: ,

, IIIII ,
II

BOllpOC.

117

nu

-? , , (')
II
II,
II, , ,

IIeT

?72

(76d7-e7)

CII lO
.
.

()
(').

(, .)
.
: ''
. ,

'5'

,
(<<
, ):


; '(-+5)

&

(--+-5)'

' ...... 5'.

alleee ,

:
. ,

(2)

(1)

lO, .

,
, ,

(3)

. (2)

70

1I0 .

(3)

'Q' ',

Heitsch 1979;

cBoeil

ll

<1I\1II1}[ I1III,: el'O lI 76d7-77a5,

118

./10I ,
./1

:
(

& Q & R) -> (P......S)

./1 '' ,

./1 ./1, . .

'S' (=

./1 ),
.t1./1

'Q'

'R'.

:, ,


, ./1. ,
76l1-13 .t1 ,
,

''

'S',

. ry

, ./1
./1 ./10, ,

'P->S'.

'S->P'

. ./1 C.t10

'P->S'

C.t10

'p...... S'

:~

.t1

./1,

./1

, .

, ./1 ,
./10 ( , ,
, .t10./1 )

:, ./1 , IJa
, , ./1 ::
-, .

,

l1l nuaz

119

, !

, ,
: , I
II mlm

, ,
. ,
!
(768-775)

,
() 3
,

011

, ll

011

.
:

. , "
,

,
l,,73

(92d6-9)
llll, , 768-775


ll

011

'', . . ,

. ,
ll I
1'0 (I{owc 1993)
(Mtldgc) 11 11 dR aT~ IIII

7' B:v!CCTC

au,f]c,
.

II II:\lii ll,

120

ll, .

apl'YMeHT,

:
, II

P...... S,

- ,
110 .

Il, -

3-

ll , ,
, ,

011

:,

110

(. 779-1).
, , ,


92: 3
l


:,

01llO

I ,
. . .

,

.,
, AlIO
,

)"<. a.ll ,
, ,
1)', 1

MOIY,

(1)

, 749- (

, I

75c7-d5).

(3)

, 01l

(
,

75c7-d5)

Il

nlll(

-,

121

746-8, II

lIe

(2)

. ,

lI I Ia (755).7 4
(.
l

103),
lIe l

lI

lI,
. :!
l

,<\.

(.

118),


(2) (3):

l
(

& Q & R)

-+

(P<-+S)

lIe

'Q'

'R',

'' (

). ,

''
,

0110

'Q'

'R',

I lI

lI

lI:

''

(2)

(3),

. ll ,
:

.. lI,

lI

1975, 134

.) lI :IIIeel, II 11<1

,1IIlI lllllI

31IIII : "<1!

74 IIII (ll

I'OBOPIIT '!C~I-TO, ''! lIa~1 IIllllilIIil II


(l-2)', IIil~I8, '! 01111 illlll,1II IIPC~1CT 11<1III) 31lI I.

122

. . ,il,

IO

, lI
.

,


. (),
,

F2:

03
. .
, ,

I, ,

, ~l 1\!

IIO HeOOXOUll.\Cble nOCbL\Kll

OKa:~aTeACTBa,

: ,
,
. lO ,
,
ClI

,
(. . III

1, 155b29-156a3).

l
eI",

II ll :~
IblX
ll,

.
.

, . . '<l1,
,

nl/zo

ry.

123

II
lI ,


, , I1
( cr
), . (>
ll

92d.)

J--cr lIeocra

Il

apIYMeHTa,

, cr cr

. cr iicr,

11

(l f.lOl, Ol !, 768,

77(5)?

, cr

, bO~a.
,

110 G-I

XI
, OlI

. ,
cr, cr

' ,

. cr
,
cr

, , .
- cr

IIa

II

06

ll? ll, , ll
Il, IIl,

apIYMellTbl,

124

:, ,

,

(1074-9). ' , ' ,

ll

apryMellTbI,

1\l:
[ ''] II,

lI

(1075-6),

92d6-9

, , ,

ll

[''], II,

ll ./1

11

II

, :,

./1IO G

, ./1< ?
:3 , ./1

ll ,

.t1

I ./1II (. 762). ./1


lI,

COI./1aCHO

OI" ,

./10 (.
.tll,(;111

33),

./1

) . ./1 Cn
6~IOLc{)~laTa

(Met. 15, 98527,

. 4), ./1

, : llO

- ,

ll

flLfll1U1':;;

(Met. 1 6,

98711 ).1'; ,

MhILIb

31JaI1, lO ,

,; :~II II lIarlO:l-Il, OlIlI fl[fl'1al~

'la I

(>,\II

II llll08

llilIi

(!l. 31\, 39, 41\

Y'leIIOCII1.

lllII,

11 passim),

:m nll

125

aJI : (,

anfflU ):
,

f.!Lf.!'l;: l.
011
IllIO

.
, :

lI
I - .

,

: ,

,
(Cll)

(65d4-8), -

(65d12-I).

J"O, ,
KoreKcTe

paBelICTBa

(75cll-dl).

:
,

I ,

(),

. ,

,
I

'I J6
, ,

. ,

-.
76 . all lld (\
1972) lI cOBpeMellllbIe II :\!~!8.

126

Cll
'

caMol'o

(747-6).7 7
I,

<sc.

>

. :~
Cll:

S,

S,

,
,
.

,

l , Cll

Cl,
.7 8


CIl

CIlOB:

, - C.II
, ,

?

, !
(74l-)

77

Il l, il ,

:l>I IIll :

Geach 1956, Vlastos 1956,


Blt1Ck 1957, Mills 1957 1958, Wcdin 1977, Whitc 1987.
8 Mills 1957, 128,

nu

/l

TOI'O,

127

), ,
:~ ,

lI

apryMeHTa.

( , ),

ro
. :
-

.
-I

:

,
.

, 74l-

, 3 ,

,
.

1
,

apIYMeHTa.

: .

, l',

l'

128
,

IllIO

, ,

,
( l~ )
,
.

:~ ,

,
,
,

, ,


I"O, ,

.i 9

74cl-2,

. ,
,

I"O

(74cll-12)

(74d9-e8),

C.tl

l"O

:~
.

79 lI II
III, :\, 11 I10II~I,
i[ 'I 11 lllIl\lI , ,[
8 OI8 III, . Par/ll. 132-133.

nuzo

129

!
Il
. ,

II

{I

cr

Il 10-

Il .

(.

90).

lO

I : -
,

paBIIO

TaKOI'o ,
,

.
, ,
l-l,

: lO

, )),

, ,
.
. ,
. :,
, :

,
( ),

I
.
,
. ,

:3

(74d9-e4),

, (. ''

oQw,

74dl0),

6 VUV EYW

1, ll. Rll

80 \1 \10 l1 II:V, IlC BO:~


lIO v/\II:V1 JI, JI

l1I1:~; \1l1 IIII ;1.

11

IIlil l10, ;\1 \lbI -: >-lI IIO\III11I1.

130

lC

- JI
.

CJl

, ry .
() CJl
,
. JI
,

, IO
.

CJI :
, , 11

, ;
,

. (

74dl0-e4)

lI ,

-
,

.
, , .

CJl
,

.

CJI.
,

,
, .

, ,
, .

(65d9-10).

, ,
:

, , -

nulO

131

, ) I

(. 78d 794, 80).


,

f1iIaToHa

. f1iIaTO))

,
:~ , ,
i!,

)' ,

, ,

f1iIaToHa
. ,
-,
,

. i13

l)

, ,

.
.
, :

Jl

)I;


; ,

, .
il- (
-) .
0111 , l,

, , ,
,

011 I )l ) Ja,

) '

132

Q LlI
( penlI'O)

: :.

,
.

. , 754, . .

,

, , ,

l n
: 735, 9, 7413,

d9.

dll-

.\1 : . 745, 75l.


ll

.

749-759:
, ,
,

,
, ,
.

110

, .
(749-754)

, ll ll
dllOll.-bl ll .
ll :
, , ,
IlI

. ,
,

nll

133

, , .

, ,
.

(755-10)

: II
IIll.

,
I ,

, , ?

-l?
-, .

, ,
, ,
-
II - ,

, :

, ,

0110,

, ,

I'O, .

(75all-b9)
lO,

:I ,

011

:I

IL .
lI


. , ,

110-

134

Jl Jl. Jl
Jl,

Jl
Jl

Jl

Jl

Jl

Jl,
Jl,

(89dl-91b7).

Jl

, Jl

,
,,
- ,

Jl . ()
Jl Jl

, Jl,

(Met. 1 6,

Jl

9872-);

'Jl

Jl

: Jl!

Jl Jl,
Jl ,

()
JlI<

IIa Jl
.
Jl, Jl
,

Jl,

Jl Jl Jl

, Jl Jl l":
JllI. Jl JlI

nlll(

135

, Jo

, ,
,

;
Ol',

,l

81

II ,

'loru ; 110- II

il, ,

, J' l'I', -II 1l0J


, IIO-lll'II - (), KO,JY:l.l611ileKoM -, l II

ll ( lI) IIII il
Ha:l.III0rO il 6l,

'11':1.1

311 II:l.lIII, lm ,
3I I1 llm:

, ll , :l.l

11

, aJ ll

11

:\.II1

lI, 'l)'

u u:l.l,

01' Bceil

II ::)lI ,

311 IIII UII lllll;

1'1'0

: II!' 03:1.IOlI lI6IIII

!',

C,IIII11KO:l.1

111 11 ) il CTaTblI
8 :l.lIl11 ai,

IIIII OI' I1l,

ll

n\ l!1lll 113ll:

Bumet, J.: Platonis Opera.

5- .

ll ll " II

Oxford 1900-1907

KOAfAfeHmapllll (61G\

ll lIll ) ;:

Archer-Hind, R. .: lle Plzaelto of Plato, ed. with introduction, notes and appendices. 2London
1894
luck, R. 5.: Plato's Plzaedo, translated with introduction, notes and appendices. London 1955
!3urnet, ].: Plato's PlzaeLto, ed. with introduction and
noted. Oxford 1911
[)ixsaut, .: Platon, PlzCdon. Traduction nouvelle,
mtroduction et notes. Paris 1991
fowlu, . N .. Plato: Elltllyplzro, Ap%gy, Crito, Plzaedo,
Plu.edYlfS, ed. with an English translation. (Loeb
Ubrar ) Cambridge (Mass. )/London 1914
Gall.,p, D. Plato, PlmeLto. Translated with Notes.
ford 1975
Geddes, W D.: The Plzaedo of Plato. London 1863
Hackforth, R.: Plato's Phaedo, transl. with introduction
and commentary. Cambridge 1955
Lu.\(, R.: Le Pi1edon de Platon. Commentaire et
traduction. Bd. 1 (57-84) Namur 1969, Bd. II
(84-118) Namur 1975
Robin, L.: Platon, PlzMon. Paris 1926
Rowe, .: Plato, PlzaeLio. Cambridge (Cambridge University Press) 1993
Vicaire, .: Platon, Pi1edon. Paris ] 983
Zehnpfennig, .: Platon: Phaidon, ilbersetzt und herausgegeben von . Z. Hamburg 1990

137

lI:

Ackrill, J. L.: Review of P/ato's PlmcLto. Translated with


Introduction and Commentary R. Hackforth. - In: Philos. Review 67 (1958) 106-110
-"-: Anamncsis in the Plmcdo, Remarks 73-75. - In:
. N. Lee/A. . D. Mourelatos/R. . Rorty
(.): Exegesis and Argument (.ll
. .II [. Vlastos]). Assen 1973,
177-195
Bluck, R. 5.: Forms as 5tandards. - ': Phronesis 2
(1957) 115-127
-"-: Plato's Form of Equal. - In: Phronesis 4 (1959) 5-11
Bostock, .: Plato's Plmcdo. Oxford 1986
Brown, .: he Idea of Equality in the Phacdo. - ':
Archiv f. Geschichte der Philosophie 54 (1972)
24-36
Burkert, W.: Platon oder Pythagoras? Zum Ursprung
des Wortes "Philosophie". - In: Hermes 88
(1960) 159-177
-"-: Weisheit und Wissenschaft. 5tudien zu Pythagoras, PhiJolaos und Platon. Nilrnberg 1962
Cousin, . (.): Procli Commentarium in Platonis
Parmenidem. Paris 1864
Dalfen, J.: Kenneth Dorter's Interpretation of the
PhacLfo. - In: . L. Griswold (.): Platonic
Writings - Platonic Readings. London/New
York 1988, 215-244
Denniston, J. .: he Greek Particles. Oxford 1934
954

Dodds, . : he Greeks and the Irrational. London


1951
Dorrie, .: Der Platonismus in der Antike. Bd. 1: Die
geschlichtlichen Wurzeln des Platonismus.
Obersetzung, Kommentar . Drri. Aus dem
NachlaI3 hg. Annemarie DOrrie. 5tuttgartBad Cannstatt 1987

138

ll

-"-: Der Platonismus in der Antike. Bd. 11: Der hellenistische Rahmen des kaiserzeit1ichen Platonismus. Obersetzung, Kommentar . Drri.
Aus dem Nachlal3 hg. und bearb. . Baltes.
Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt 1990
Dorter, .: Plato's
1982

/m.

Interpretation. Toronto

Diiring, J.: Aristotle's Use of Examples in the Topics.In: . . L. Owen (113;\.): Aristot]e Dialectic.
The Topics. Proceedings of the Third Symposium Aristotelicum. Oxford 1968, 202-229
Ebert, Th.: Meinung und Wissen in der Philosophie
Platons. Untersuchungen zum 'Charmides',
'' und 'Staat'. Berlin 1974
-"-: Platon - ein Verachter der 'Vielen'? - In: J. Mittelstral3/M. Riedel (.): Verniinftiges Denken:
Studien zur praktischen Phi!osophie und Wissenschaftstheorie. Ber!in 1978, 124-147
Frede,

Fritz,

.: P]atos Arguments and the Dialogue


Form. - In: J. . 1gg/N. . Smith (.):
Methods of Interpreting Plato and his Dialogues (Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy,
Suppl. ]. 1992),201-219

. .:

P/mirton. - In: Rea!encyc!opadie der


A!tertllffiSwissenschaften, Bd. XIX, 2
(Stllttgart 1938) 1538-1542
1ss.

Geach,

Th.: Mental Acts. London 1957

-"-: The Third Again. - In: Philosophica! ReYiew


65 (1965) 72-82
Gosling, J.: Similarity in Plato's
10 (1965) 151-161
Grube,

. . .:

/m.

- In: Phronesis

P!ato's Thought. London 1935

Guthrie, W. . : History of Greek Philosophy.


Cambridge 1962

1.

-"-: History of Greek Philosophy. . IV. Cambridge


1975

I111mm

139

Hadgopoulos, D. J.: Protasis and Problema in the


Topics. - In: Phronesis 21 (1976) 266-276
Hamblin, L.: Fallacies. London 1970
Haynes, R. .: The Form Equality, as Set of Equals:
Phaedo 74-. - In: Phronesis 9 (1964) 17-26
Heidel, W.: The Pythagoreans and Greek Mathematics. - In: American Journ. of Philology 61 (1940)
1-33
Heitsch, .: Finden, Wiederfinden, Erfinden. Oberlegungen zu Platons Phaidon 764-5 (Abh. d.
Mainzer Akademie der Wissenschaften . Literatur, geistes- und sozialwissenschaftliche
lasse) Wiesbaden 1979
Hirzel, R.: Der Dialog. Leipzig 1895
Huffman, : nowledge of Equality itself at Plznedo
74. - In: Discorsi 1 (1981) 103-108
, .: Art. Syllogistik. - In: Pauly/Wissowa, RealEncyclopadie Bd. IV . (Stuttgart 1931)
Sp.1046-1067
Long, . S.: Study of the Doctrine of Metempsychosis in Greece from Pythagoras to Plato. Princeton 1948
McQueen, . I./Rowe, }.: Phaedo, Socrates, and the
Chronology of the Spartan War with Elis. - In:
Methexis 2 (1989) 1-18
Mills, . W.: Plato's PI1l1e,to, 747-6. - In: Phronesis 2
(1957) 128-147; Phronesis 3 (1958) 40-58
Moraux, .: La joute dialectique d'apres l viii< livre
des TopiqllCS. - In: . . L. Owen (.):
Aristotle Dialectic. The Topics. Proceedings
of the Third Symposillm AristoteliCl1m. Oxford
1968, 277-311
Morgan, . L.: Sense-Perception and Recollection in
the Phaedo. - In: Phronesis 29 (1984) 237-251
Nehamas, .: Plato the Imperfection of the Sensible
World. - In: American PhilosophicaI Quarterly
12 (1975) 105-117

140

lllll

Parker, R.: Miasma. Pollution and Purification in Early


Greek Religion. Oxford 1983
Pater, W. de: Les Topiques d' Aristote et ' dialectique
platonicienne. La methodologie de ' definition.
Fribourg 1965
Riginos, . 5.: Platonica. The Anecdotes conceming
the Life and Writings of Plato. Leiden 1976
Rist, J. .: Equals and lntermediates in Plato. - In:
Phronesis 9 (1964) 27-37
5, .: Platonic Anamnesis Revisited. - In: Classical
Quarterly 37 (1987) 346-66
50lmsen, F.: Empedocles' Hymn to . - ln:
Phronesis 25 (1980) 219-227
5tewart, D. J.: 50crates' Last Bath. - ln: Journ. of the
History of Philos. 10 (1972) 253-259
5tokes, . .: Plato's Socratic Conversations. Drama
and Dialectic in Three Dialogues. London 1986
Taylor, . .: Plato. The Man and his Work. London
1926
Verdenius, W. J.: Notes Plato's Plzaedo. - ':
Mnemosyne lV 11 (1958) 193-243
\tlastos, G.: Reply to Geach. - In: Philosophical Review 65 (1965) 83-94
Wedin, . V.: aulX [ and the argument at
ld 747-5. - In: Phronesis 22 (1977)
191-205
Westerink, L. G. (.): The Greek Commentaries
Plato's Plzaedo. . 1: Olympiodorus. Amsterdam
1976
-"-: The Greek Commentaries Plato's PJlt1CLtO. . :
Damascius. Amsterdam 1977
White, N. .: Forms and 5ensibIes: 1Lt 74-. - ':
Philosophical Topics15 (1987) 197-214

1l

1.

AAK~eoll

2618
2618

test. 10
test. 13
(.

\-Vehrli)

1610

fr.41
lIlll,

l~I (.

Rose)

fr.502
II

90"9

6,625-35

5,985

27
34

34-36

6,987

1
32-33

5,1056 20-22

33, 124
33, 124
33
33, 124
134
9360

lI

4, 101

28-36
30-33

34-36
10,1044-5
8-11

11,1043-5
29-36
34-36
III

1, 155

4-7
8-24

81
81
82
82
82
82
82
82"7
57,64
107

142

1l

29-1563
30-35
1563-1575
1571-3

2,15711-14

4,

15918-20

18-24
20-24

9,16021

122
60
107
107
60, 101
58,112
86
58
60

tcst. 5

2718

ii

XI 131, 505

25

fr. 35 D
fr. 40 D

18
12'

2.81

12'

:l-f

/n Pllaedoncm
Westerink)
1I19,1-2
II 20, 1
(lI3.

Jl

1.12
2.45
2.105
2.124
2.125
3.37
8.4-5
8.11
8.13

1814
24
82
14
14
6
3222
16"
169

/l

143
3222
82, 13
16

8.14
8.46
8.57

181~

test. 2 DK
II

fr.2

12"

Memorabilia
1,2,48
111,11,17

14
14

/n Pllaedonem

(.

Westerink)
1, 13,2
5, 6,2
11, 8, 6-9

147
147,332,
473"

61
61
60

112 d10

113

IIOI

40

24

469

60

475
477

18

6~8

6~8

7-11

6~8

144

l13m~\ll

600

63

bl1-d5
d7-e3

638
63-18
17

305 c-d

18

IIII

45

22

767I1.

81

82
83
84

311~

3-5

3119
3110

d4-5

31

-85

62

3-4

3119

3-4

8-l

62

5-7

627

32

il

127

c-d
3

d3
128

3
6

8
3

d-e
d3
132 d-133 0
-133 0

161d

1914
61
1914
1914
191.
191-1
191-1
1914
61
19

84
12879
93(,[\

ll
172l

145

.m\ll

1741

2200

9
24

YII,326a-
,358

19
19

3303-3311

335d7

60
18

143-

61

197

69
69

198d

12475
12475
12475

380
39
48

II
57-59

7
16
16
25
25

136

20
20
21
16
17
16
21,24
21
148, 15
148

58

59

60

3-4

c-d

61

10

c10-d2

d-c
d-62c

22

146
d-63d
d6-7
d7
62
63

-69

64

D
9-653

65

c11-d2
d4-5
d4-8
d9-10
d12-13
66

1-675

-3
3-672

67

3-4
4

c-d
c5-d2
D
d6-11
d8
4
4-6

68

-3
5

69

c-d
D
d2

70

72

d9-e1

22
13, 14, 147
147
15
22
22
17,19,22
18
23
23
23
23
23
65
125
130
125
23
57
18,23
23
23
23
18,24
22
19
23
23
18
18
23
18
20
20
23
23
18
15
28

ll

3-4

e3-77d5
4
4-5
5
5-6

6
6-7

73-74
73 2-3
7-2
4-6

10-2
3-4
4-5

6
9-1

IIII.

-74

c-76d
1
1-3

1-4
1-748

c1-76d6
3
4-5

c4-d1
4-4

5-6
6

c6-d1
7

c8-d1
d-e
d3

147
45
7,34-45
45
30
111
30
45
30, 11269
4734
30,31,115
46,63
46
30
63,64
64
362.'
64
110
107
49'7, 103
116
65
47,49
65
69
115
65
68
49, 4938, 50, 53, 68, 69,
70,71,114
48
3524
66
66,67,103
52
66,69
68
101
65, 70

m,\U

148
d5
d5-8
d5-e10
d7
1
l-3
5
5-6

5-8
5-748
9
9-10

74

2-3

2-4
3
5-8
9-12

9-1
9-6

a9-d3
2
2-3
4
4-6
4-10
4-756
5

6-6
7
7-9
7-6

8
9
10-12
1

l-3
l-2
4-6

65
36:'0
53,95
52
48,52,65
65,95
3620, 65, 132
3620
50
50,65
132
50
71
52
70"0
54
65,72
120
67
65, 72
7202
65,10564,114
66, 68, 69, 7(, 96, 112
66, 67, 69, 70, 77
75
88
70;0, 132
67
3826,73
90
126
3826
106
80
3826
126, 127
128
74
3826

149

6-7
7

7-9
8
8-9

10
11-12
13

c13-d2
c13-d3
d4 .
d4-7
d4-75a4
d4-75c6
d6
d8
d8-e4
d9
d9-e4
d9-e7
d9-e8
dlO
2
3

6-7
6-8
8
9
9-753
9-754

9-759

75

1
1-3

4
4-5
5
5-7

5-8
5-10

53
70:;0
67, 69, 70, 77, 78:;6
96
69
86,88,108
71,73,128
3827, 70:;0, 132
70,71"1,95
71,73
67
73,81,83
56
73,80
3928
85
80
4029,87
74, 129
74
128
129
87
56
75,82,83
121
11067,85
56,75
76,79
132
132
87,132
78:;6
86,132
87
4029,78:;6
75
80,85,89
77,88,133

150

m~\lI

70 0

7000

9-10

85
7000

ll

ll-
l1-9

4
4-5
4-9
5

5-6

78,80,81,83,87
133
75
108
79
87, 112
87,96

70 0

40:10

108
107
88
96
112
88, 108, 110bi
75,112
7503

9-6
2
l
2
3

4
4-5

4-6

6
7

7 iliI.

c7-d5
c7-76d6
c7-76d7
c9-d2
cl0-d2
cll-dl

dl-2
d2
d5
d7
d7-8
d7-12
d7-76a8

75,80,94, 106
88, 96, 109, 113
75,112
106
92,100, 120
94,96
110
104
10564
125
60
97
41'1
112
112
98,114
100
97

m_\U

d7-76c5
d10-11

4-5

97
101
101
98
102
103
96
121
111
70
103,114
70SQ
110
98,9963, 104, 110
111
104
110
98
104
109"", 110
97
87
96
112
112
104
104
98
98
104
98, 10564
95, 96, 98, 104, 105&-1,
114
104
99, 10564
114
99, 106, 111

1)67

96, 106, 112

2-3
2-7

2-764
3
4
5
5-7

76

151

1-3
1-4
2-3
4-5
4-7

6-7
8

9-
9-2
9-
9-3

9-5

4
b4-
5-6

b5-
8
8-9
-12

1
1-3

152

)'mll

6 .
6-7

c6-d6
6-13

8
9-10

10
11-12
11-13
14
14-15

c14-d6
15

d1
d2
d2-3
d3
d7
d7-e4
d7-e7
d7-77a5
d7-77d5
1-2
2

8
8-77 0 5

77

9-1
1-3

115,117
11772
110, 115
12]74
124
123
119
123
120
30

1-9

115

1-5

30, 115
116
10966
131
131
131
19
19
27

c6-d5
8

78
79
80

106
106
106
94
113
94
109, 113
106,108
94,108, 114, 118
112
113
108
96
96
96
109
112
11671
11671

d3
4

d-81d

81-82

}'.mIl,\lI

82

-
-3

83

5-6
5

84

-85
-86
-88

86

b-d
2-5

87 -88
88 -
1-7

c8-d3
8-3

D
d3-6
d6
d6-d8
89

3
9-917

d-91
d1-91b7
91
92

-92
-95 0
2-5

93
95

D
d6-9
d8
d1-11
-l7
-

96

-103

b-d
4

5-6

97

8l1.

d8-c1
100

153
19
18
18
18
27
28
30
29
29
28
10
10
10
8
82
10, 10'
103
11
147
11
27
134
26
11
32
46:12,123
119, 124
1197:1
93
11
26
2618
2618
2618
2618
2618
2618
2618
84

154

)'mJ\II

100 d
102 3-9
107 -115
114

84
8
16
17,19

242

147

:v

170-171

60

Dc Genio Socratis
578

579d-e
582d-e
5860
592.

13
13
13
13
13

il (.

Cousin)
In Parmenidem

Sp.729

3323

llIil

In Aristotelis Physicam
(.

Die1s)
99.7-9

10.468

1712

lll

Orationes
21,245-246

II

7.18

103

155

)'lI.3llm.

~l

fr.8
fr. 15
fr. 105
fr. 129

20
20
2618
201'',32

Dc Vitll Pytllllgoricll
xiv,63
xv,64
xxxv,251

.
)

(
.
,l ,

, , )

ro

I1

II Olf

Il
~l

OI" J1

l1lI
ll

l1

24,61
2718

9
12', 16, 169, 16,20,21,27
51,82, 13
5, 59, 59, 84
24
181',3222
6348
148,3J19
147
2718
61,25
82
12'
181-1
13
9

156

m.\11

II

9
23,24
148,3119,32'
2517

//I
MCIIOH

12"
13, 12", 169, 17,
3119,3222,33
1914
82

ll

II

181~,

191',

18
33

"I1I1II

19

2718

72
5,61
82

t10l1

82, 12", 147, 148, 15,22


2516
996,

XpllCl11II1
II

21
82

lll'
/l

21
16,191",31'9,34

~11l

/l~III//1I\

13
8,82, 10, 10', 11, 13
13, 158, 2517

/lI/

COBpeMeHllbIe

( I

11

, ,

/1 'l1 (

/J

, " I1I,

))

Ackrill, J. L.
B1uck, R. S.
BrO\vn, .

4734, 48'6, 49'7, 51, 52, 5240, 54,


72'2, 76"', 10564
11',12",13",12677
12576

ll

Burkert, W.
Burnet, J.

Denniston, J. .
Dixsaut, .
Dodds, . R.
Dorric, .
Dorter, .
DLiring, 1.
Ebcrt, Th.
Fo\vlcr, . N.
Frede, .
l!, .

Geach, . Th.
Geddes, W. .
Grube, . . .
Guthrie, W. . .
Hackforth, R.
Hadgopoulos, . J.
in, .

L.

Heidel, W.
Hcindorf, L. F.
Heitsch, .
Hirsch, .
Hirzel, R.
Huffman, .
, .

Long, . S.
Loriaux, R.
Mansfcld. J.
McQuecn, .
Mills, . W.
Moraux, .
Parker,
Patcr, W. de
Riginos, . S.

157

12", 136, 169, 1814


12", 13", 1712, 362", 37"(', 3928,
4029,41'1,75-'3, 109"', 115, 11671,
11973
775"
13"
169
51, 1 , 2510
13(',49'7
6045
3119, 3220, 574-', 63 4R
10-',755'
5843
10', 12-',32,3524,3827,3928,
95 /I., 99"-', 105'''', 106, 11067,
12]74
9058, 12677
1814
14, 14R

12", 136, 2618


11',125,3827,10564
8257
5944
1814
3827
111'2,13581
13581
12"
10564
5944
125, "
12", ", 171-'
13581
82
12677, 12678
5944
1915
5944
51

158

)'m.\lI

Robin, L.
Rowc,C.

Seott, .
Solmsen, F.
Stcwart, . J.
Stokes, . .
Strohm, .
Szlczak, . .
lor, . .

Vahlen, J.
Verdenius, W. J.
Vieaire, .
Vlastos, G.
Wedin, . .
White, N. .
Zehnpfennig,

136, 372(" 3928, 4029, 41-'1, 7533,


11671, 11973
82, 158, 352-1, 3/-", 3827, 3928, 4029,
41-'1, 75-'3, 763.j, 95 Il., 11671,
11973
4937
1611
12;
57.j3
13581
7836, 13581
123, 136
4030
3524, 3726, 3928, 41
3524, 3726, 3928, 4020, 41, 76-'3,
11671, 11973
12677
12677
12677
103,3827

...

...............................

1............................................................

...........................................................

30

I..........................................................

47
56

IV.........................................................
V...........................................................
VI.........................................................
V........................................................
VI.......................................................

63
73
80
94

XI..........................................................

110
115
123

............................................

136

...............................................

141

IX..........................................................
...........................................................

Jl

. . .
. .

- . .
. . .

.t1

NQ 05679 24.08.2001

11.07.2005.

84 100/32. . .
. . .

7,8.

137

199034, -, ., 7/9
. (812) 328-96-17; (812) 328-44-22
E-mail: editor@unipress.ru
www.unipress.ru
:

-, 6- . ., .

11/21, . 21
328-77-63, 325-31-76
E-mail: post@unipress.ru

rp .

199061, -,

.,

41