Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 30

E-cigarette : Lessons from 31 may French report Bertrand Dautzenberg,

Professor of pneumology University Pierre et Maris Curie Paris, Piti-salptire hospital and OFT (Office franais de prvention du tabagisme). bdautz@gmail.com
Mai 2013

Rapport et avis dexperts sur

le-cigarette
Avec le soutien de la Direction gnrale de la sant

No conflicts of interest on the topic

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

E-cigarettes is in 2013 a very small part of the tobacco control problem in 2013. In 2016 we may anticipate a signifiant part
Tobacco control

Tobacco
e-cigarette

We have the certitude than tobacco smoke kill 700 000 EU citizens each year e_cigarette is much less toxic than regular cigarette but need precautions.

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

First patent 1965

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Kon Lik 2006 Brevet 2006 de Hon Lik patent

Applicant(s): Classification: - international: - cooperative:

+ HON LIK [CN] +


HON LIK [CN] A24B15/16; A24D1/00; A24F47/00; A61K9/00; (IPC17): A24B15/16

A24F47/002; A61K9/007 WO2004CN00182 20040308 ; CN20031011582 20030429 EP1618803 (A4) EP1618803 (B1) US201227358 9 (A1) US2012090630 (A1) US2006196518 (A1) more

Application number: EP20040718242 20040308 Priority number(s):

Also published as:

The invention relates to a non-smokable electronic spray cigarette which only comprises nicotine without harmful tar. The cigarette includes a smoke mouth integer comprised with a shell, a cell, a high frequency ionizer, nicotine solution storage and its container, control circuit, a display screen, a human contact sensor, a piezoelectric supersound atomizer, a high temperature vaporization nozzle and attachments, an electro-thermal vaporization nozzle installed in the air suction end of the shell goes through an electric control pump or a valve with a measuring chamber and a liquid storage container which contains nicotine solution and is connected to the electric control pump or a valve with a one-way flow valve, the control circuit plate has four export ends individually connected with the high frequency ionizer, electric heater, pump or valve and the display screen,; a human resistence sensor and an air flow sensor are connected to the input end of the control circuit. The advantages of the present invention are smoking without tar, reducing the cancerogenic risk, the user still feel smoking and experiercing the excitement, the cigarette is no need to be lit and is no fire danger.
ENSP e-cigarettes 2013
www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

The market of e-cigarettes will be more important than the market of smoking cessation in 2013
US market of e-cigarettes millions $
1200 1000 800 600 400 510

1000

260
200

30
0 2008

60 2009

120

2010

2011

2012

2013*

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

According to 2012 eurobarometer, Greck population is more heavy user than other Eu citizen with 8% experimentation 1% occasionnal use 2% regular use

2013 data are expected soon

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

e-cigarette & e-liquide ?


Single use e-cigarette look like cigarettes, but where usually less attractive

cartridge

Mouth piece

atomizer

batterie

diode

New e-refilling e-cigarette dont look like cigarettes but are more attractives
ENSP e-cigarettes 2013
www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Same chemical content


E.liquide

vapor

Different chemical content Tabacco


smoke

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Formation of artificial fume


1
e.cigarette
2
e-liquide in cartridge.

Electric shock heath e-liquide produce vapor

3
4

Condensation of gaze in small liquid particules


Smoker inhale particules gaz and liquid

User air

inhalation. Half life of liquid particule is short (11 sec with PG)

Dissipation of gazes

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Aerosol characteristic are not the same with vegetal glycerin and propylene glycol
180 000 Propylne glycol CMAD Immdiate 10 secondes 40 secondes Glycrine vgtale 20 000

CMAD

Immdiate 10 secondes 40 secondes

100 000

10 000

0 10 100 1000

0 10 100 1000

E cig 78
ENSP e-cigarettes 2013
www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Vansickel AR, Cobb CO, Weaver MF, Eissenberg TE.A clinical laboratory model for evaluating the acute effects of electronic "cigarettes": nicotine delivery profile and cardiovascular and subjective effects. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev. 2010 Aug;19(8):1945-53.

2010 5 <1ng/ml
cigarette Old (2009) e-cigarette dont delivered significant amont of nicotine

E-cigarette Hydro

E-cigarette NPRO

No nicotine
ENSP e-cigarettes 2013
www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Product Electronic Cigarette


Nicotine Gum

NNN
3.87 2

NNK
1.46 ND

NAT
2.16 ND

NAB
0.69 ND

Total
8.18 2

No more NNK than in NRT medication

Nicotine Patch Swedish Snus


Canadian Mild Ultra Du Maurier Regular Export A Ultra Light King

ND

ND

ND

8 2400

445 308 794

540 523 848

552 448 752

NQ NQ 122

1537 1277 2516

Gitanes Kings
Benson & Hedges Ultra Mild Winston Newport Camel Skoal Marlboro

6369 522
2200 1100 3100 4500 4300

1477 733
580 830 1400 470 1800

2965 629
560 1900 2800 4100 4900

354 NQ
25 55 150 220 190

11165 1884
3365 3885 7450 9290 11190

http://smoke-vsvapor.webs.com/nitrosa minelevels.htm

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

12

Some chemical substances in cigarette smoke and e-cigarette aerosol


Composs 1,2-Propandiol 1-Hydroxy-2Propanone 2,3-Butandione 2,5-Dimethylfurane 2-Butanone (MEK) 2-Furaldhyde 2-Methylfurane 3-Ethenylpyridine Acide actique Actone Benzne Isoprne Limonne m,p-Xylne Phnol Pyrrole Tolune Formaldhyde b Actaldhyde b Propanal b N CAS 57-55-6 116-09-6 431-03-8 625-86-5 78-93-3 98-01-1 534-22-5 1121-55-7 64-19-7 67-64-1 71-43-2 78-79-5 5989-27-5 1330-20-7 108-95-2 109-97-7 108-88-3 50-00-0 75-07-0 123-38-6

e-cigarette e-cigarette e-cigarette background 1 2 3 cigarette <1 <1 <1 <1 112
<1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 8 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <0.2 <1 <1 <1 2 <1 <1 <1 11 17 <1 6 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 8 2 <0.2 <1 <1 <1 2 <1 <1 <1 13 18 <1 7 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 11 2 <0.2 <1 <1 <1 2 <1 <1 <1 14 25 <1 10 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 16 3 <0.2 62 21 5 19 21 19 24 68 64 22 135 21 18 15 61 44 86 119 12
13

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Cancerogen in e-liquide and in cigarette smoke


Substance Anthracne Phnanthrne 1-Mthyl phnanthrne Pyrne Benz(a) anthracne Chrysne Benzo(b) fluoranthne Benzo(k) fluoranthne Benzo(a) pyrne Benzo(e) pyrne Perylne Indeno(1,2,3-cd)pyrne Dibenz(ah) anthracne UK ecigarette 7 48 5 36 Under limit Under limit Under limit Under limit Under limit Under limit Under limit Under limit Under limit Groupe IARC UK cigarette cancrognes 130 350 30 130 45 50 30 9 35 16 4 12 4 3 3 3 3 2A 3 2B 2B 2A 3 3 2B 2A % (e.cig/20 cig) 0,27% 0,69% 0,83% 1,38% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

Benzo(ghi) prylne

Under limit

60

0%

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

14

tar

Cancer

tar

CO

cardio vascular risk COPD


Upper airway

CO

PM

PM

irritants

irritants

nicotine
ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

addiction

nicotine

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

In 2013 Electronic cigarettes: effective nicotine delivery after acute administration.

5 11ng/ml

Vansickel AR, Eissenberg T. ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

Nicotine Tob Res. 2013 Jan;15(1):267-70 www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

New devices are good delivery system

nicotine ng/ml
20 15
10

5
0 2010 2010 2012 2013 pic cigarette

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Cotinine in serum (ng/ml) in active and passive user of e-cigarette and cigarette
70 60 50 40 60,6 61,3

e.cigarette cigarette

30 20 10 0
Actif Passif 2,4 2,6

http://informahealthcare.com/doi/abs/10.3109/08958378.2012.758197 Flouris 2013


ENSP e-cigarettes 2013
www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Effect on cigarette and e-cigarette on lung mesured by FEV(1)


decrease FEV1/VC
8% 7% 6% 5% 4% 3% 2% 1% 0% e-cigarette cigarette

7,20%

3% 2,30%

3,40%

Actif

Passif

http://informahealthcare.com/doi/abs/10.3109/08958378.2012.758197
ENSP e-cigarettes 2013
www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

19

Time to decrease desir to smoke

E-cig 0 mg
14 E-cig 16 mg

25

inhaleur

Cigarette

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

e-cigarette to go in and out nicotine dependence


Tabacco

e.cigarette
Persistance addiction

Nicotine dependance

?
Decrease of addiction

E.cigarette
E-cigarette : Product of initiation of Tobacco dependance

tobacco

Nicotine depedance

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

What we want to see in France


1- A product to help smokers to quit tobacco risk reduction : cigarettee-cigarette out of tobacco and nicotine

2- NOT a product for non smokers Risk of initiation to nicotine dependence Use to re-normalize-cigarette (non smoking place) Use as promotion as cigarette
ENSP e-cigarettes 2013
www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

22

Yes

Decrease of tobacco market (and use)

Official datas
-8%

extrapolation
1M e-cig

Sail of cigarettes

Sail of cigarettes

13,5M

12,5M ?

13,5 millions user

14/ 2012

14/ 2013

2012

2013
23

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Yes

First page of a French new paper 31 may 2013

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

24

No

First page of a French new paper early 2013

Promotion of use e-cigarette every where including non smoking place

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

Some advertising is clearly for teenagers

No

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

26

No

Placement of e-cigarette in fim : Johnny Depp explain to Angelina Jollie how to use e-cigarette
http://www.wat.tv/embedframe/198477chuPP3r5586959

27

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

No A product to dont stop to smoke

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

28

Rapport et avis dexperts sur

le-cigarette
Avec le soutien de la Direction gnrale de la sant

Use by non smoke increase


Mai 2013

No

Non-fumeurs exprimentant l'e-cigarette


9,0% 8,0% 7,0% 6,0% 5,0% 4,0%

8,40%

3,0%
2,0% 3,2% 0,8% 1,1% 3,8%

6,0%

4,0%

1,0%
0,0%

1,4%
France PST France OFT France 12-14 ans Mdecine W PST12-19ans (2012) (2013)

USA Pearson Core jeunes Pologne 15- Pologne 15- USA Regan (2012) (2012) 19 ans filles 19 ans (2013) (2011) garons (2011) ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

29

To achieve the end tobacco, the first preventable cause of death, e-cigarette may play a positive and a negative role
+ How to facilitate access to e-cigarette to all smoker who dont plane to quit by usual way for cessation or reduction ?

- How to prevent :
Use by non smokers and adolescents tobacco industry lobbying and indirect promotion Renormalization of tobacco use

ENSP e-cigarettes 2013

www.ofta-asso.fr/docatel/Rapport_e-cigarette_VF_1.pdf

30

Вам также может понравиться