Results of EuP Lot 11: Pumps and Circulators

Hugh Falkner
Motor Summit 2008 Zurich, 25 November 2008

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Definition of scope and exclusions

Clean water duty only
- End suction water pumps (ESOB, ESCC, ESCCi) - Vertical multistage water pumps Submersible multistage pumps

Pumps with special features excluded

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Basis of method mean efficiency of each decile

Cut off threshold Average of band

Band

100%

90%
80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% Ref

75% 65% 55% 45% 35% 25% 15% 5%

Basecase Model

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Results
LLCC level around C=70/80% depending on pump category, corresponding to some 6,5 TWh savings Claimed cost for industry 400 MEUR staged introduction of requirements is proposed to give time to adapt Expected savings from proposed measures = 3,4 TWh by 2020 but savings continuous = life-time of a pump is 11 years No labelling proposed as largely OEM market: best of class (C=80%) indication for benchmark level World in move: voluntary certification pump efficiency scheme in Korea + mandatory national efficiency standard in China

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Pumps efficiency assessment method

1. no pump efficiency assessment method available 2. preparatory study made pioneering work: workable solution 3. need to see requirements in long-term context (revision)

Quantity cut-off 5% C (ESOB 1450) C (ESOB 2900) C (ESCC 1450) C (ESCC 2900) C (ESCCI 1450) C (ESCCI 2900) C (MS 1450) C (MS 2900) C (MSS 2900) 134.38 137.28 134.39 137.32 138.13 141.71 134.83 139.52 137.08 10% 132.58 135.60 132.74 135.93 136.67 139.45 134.45 138.19 134.31 15% 131.70 134.54 132.07 134.86 135.40 137.73 133.89 136.95 132.89 20% 130.68 133.43 131.20 133.82 134.60 136.53 132.97 135.41 132.43 30% 129.35 131.61 129.77 132.23 133.44 134.91 132.40 134.89 130.94 40% 128.07 130.27 128.46 130.77 132.30 133.69 130.38 133.95 128.79 50% 126.97 129.18 127.38 129.86 131.00 132.65 130.04 133.43 127.27 60% 126.10 128.12 126.57 128.80 130.32 131.34 127.22 131.87 125.22 70% 124.85 127.06 125.46 127.75 128.98 129.83 125.48 130.37 123.84 80% 122.94 125.34 124.07 126.54 127.30 128.14 123.93 127.75 122.05

BOT = 11.48 x2 0.85 y2 0.38 xy + 88.59 x + 13.46 y - C

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Sample LCC analysis

LCC analysis on small ESCC (2250 hours pa)

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Anticipated realisation of the scheme

78 76
80

78

76

74
80
78

76

76

72

10

70

74

74
70

74

68

Q [m/h]

72
70
68

68 66
64

60
36

66

56

64 62

62

60

10

24
22

60
50

58

56

20

30 2628

58
42

56
54 52

54 52 50 48

50
48
1

48

46 44 4

46

72

10

10

ns [rpm]

72
2

10

66

62

40 38 36
34

64

80

72

48 46 44 42 48 46 44
42

76

58 56 54 52

70

74

78

60

50

68

62

66

64

40 38
38
32

72

76

52
50

58
60 56

70

54

74

78

68
66

62

64

72

48

52

58

46

40

54

44

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Circulators

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Methodology
H
Hmax

Q25% Q50% Q75% Q100%

Control option Continuous On/Off Thermostatic Radiator Valve (TRV) control On/Off control

Annual running hours 5,000 2,300 2,300

Flow profile Blauer Engel Blauer Engel 100% or OFF

Flow (%) 100 75 50 25

Time (%) 6 15 35 44

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Costs of improved technology

Ref Design Option Cost (%) Cost (Euros) Additional Cost (Euros)

1 2 3 4

Baseline Speed Control (induction motor) PM/Variable speed Improved design conventional technology

100 135 200 120

120 162 240 144

0 42 120 24

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Changes since the Consultation Forum

Boiler Integrated circulators also to be included Re-alignment of EEI scheme to make MEPS equally challenging for both small and large circulators

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

Efficiencies of existing circulators

EEI 20% best class 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 EEI 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 10
1 2 3

EEI =

Pavg Pref

C = 0.49

10

hydr

10 [W]

10

Date (if applicable)

Presentation Title

New efficiency levels

Now

The future..

Class
Class A B C D E F G Energy Efficiency Index (EEI)

Energy Efficiency Index (EEI) EEI < 0.20 0.20 = EEI < 0.40

A*
EEI < 0.40 0.40 = EEI < 0.60 0.60 = EEI < 0.80 0.80 = EEI < 1.00 1.00 = EEI < 1.20 1.20 = EEI < 1.40 EEI =1.40

www.ecomotors.org