Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 20

www.developmentandtransition.

net


 :
  

3
2006

       ! ! #  $  &  ( (*
)  - - # # . ! ! / *  * ! * & & &

: . ! ( - = . (


,
. 
,
,
, .
"#,
- $, - $".
% 1990-
,
, ,
. , ,
1999 ,

,

.

, ,
,
. (


,
. ( ,


. (

, "# -
$, .

,

*+, 2 3 . "
(5 ")
,
, ,
(" , 8,  :,
"). % :
( ((*
12% 2004 2% 2005 .
). B
" .
(

. :

. (
*+ 23,
C 8, ,
% - ( 5,

 *, 8 

! . ! 2015 ............................................  *....................................

. : ? ............................ * ................................

( .......................................................................................... *......................

/ ....................................................................................... 8 ..........................

# ................................ ( # ......................

11

! .................................................................  =, :
$  ..................................
 : ? .......................... $.............................

12
15

* .................................. E .......................

16

:  8 ........................................................................................................  *....................................

18

 : ? .. # .......................

20

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:


! .
! 2015

 *
,

%
, -( $
$ "
15
+ ,
"""+, ,
.
,
. ( ,
B $
1992-93 ,
( "#)
1990. % "#

1998 ,
- $ C 1999
% 1999 2001 .
, 1999 ,
. H , ((*
6-7 . 
,
%, . ,
- ,
$", 1999
, "#. *
, *
", ,
- $"
.

- $
. ( 5 + ((*
5-7% ,
$" 2007 2008 . *
, % : 2002
2005 7%. "
, , 5 #,
90- . "
((* 1999
:,
( " K
5 #),
.


.
B + % (B+%)
.
 , ( 5,
,
((5,
2005). % , B+%
. C
1999 ,
, B+%
2015 ?

" ,
.
, ,
, ,
,
. 8
(#,
2004),

,

( 5 C,
: %);

& 1. &
& $$. ( )
!,
( F*
- *  (, -, -)
- E F (K, (, *, ", ")

1996-9
4%
4%

2000-5
5%
7%

0%

4%

4%

*- F* (5, Q, +, %)

-1%

-1%

4%

I  (, 5 #, :, " " K)

-5%

2%

4%

*(
- ! /

-11%
-9%
-12%
-14%

2%
-1%
-1%
6%

8%
7%
7%
9%

-9%

2%

7%

-7%

2%

6%

- I *( (5, :, )

-  (, , #)
- E (C, C, %, %, )
:

N: EIU,

1991-5
-5%
-10%

2006 | 3

*
,
;

"
1999 : (1)
(
); (2) ; (3)
+ ; (4)
. 8 -
B+%
.
 . (
,
, .
* "#
, , (+, C,
, %, C), (,
C, %),
(:, , , 5). :

1999 ;
, , , .
" "#, +,
- , +

.
5
, $" +,
5 %
, .
, 5, $
, . +

" . N

,
,
. (
1997-98 . +,
10
.
F . C $"

B $ *. % ,
$",

,

.

$",
,

. $

,


.
" - $
, ,
.
 , - $
, $,
( + 5)
$.
$ ! .
"# 2000 2005.

"#,
+ .
+
. * B 5 +,
2005 + "# 6
. +
,
, , ,
. %
"#, +, 2004 .
4 . $ 4
"#
, .
* ,
"# 1998-1999 ,
: ,
"+,
+. + + "
,
,
,
C %.
* . ( ,
5 1996, K 1997, + "#
1998-1999, % 1999 2001,
.
,
.

,
- . ( +, 5
, ,
.
C ,
. 2002
.
. (
,

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:


.
,

,
.
( ?

.

. :

( :
-

. "
:

,
. *
.
*
. ,
2005 , ,

.

+ ,
$"
. , $
1-2% ,
. C ,
,
,
$",
,
,
,
,

,
.

5
. ,
"3,
8. 5,

,
, $" "#.
$ : ?
 2002 ,
( 1990
). * ,
,
. * ,
$
( " ($("), -
$ ,
,
. 8


( ,
) .
 $",
(2)
(K, (, *),
. *
(, 2004-05 .
.
* K (,
,

.
( ,

. %, , ,
C +

. : ,
$",
,
. *

,
,
$(". ,

:
,
$(" ( ,
), ,
.
E : ?
(,
. 5
1999
- (+, C,
%),
"#. (-, +
,
"#. (-,
"#
, +
(
5).
C 2,
. " "#
2006 . "
"# , $",
( *)
.
5 ,
"# ,

. " "#
,
?

2006 | 3
( .

" ,

+, C,
%. Q
, , "#, $, $",
,
, "#. C
,
"#.

5 ", 8 +
*+/+5$" 5 ben.slay@undp.org

1 ( 2001 ((* : 4,5%; 2002


((* C.
2 , 2, " " $
( " ,
.
#, $. (2004), ( + # "
" +, * * , T, . 6-23.
: 5 (2005), +, 5 : ( $ 5
" ", (, .

! !
* 1999
. "
, ,

. 8
- $"
;
,
*, "
(. (
,
5 "#. "# $
. (

. *

"#,
(NK , . %
, ,

.
:
?
*
*
. 8,

,
. %

,
. (
, ,
, ..

. *
,
.  ,

& 2: : !
(2005-2006)
:: BOFIT, 5 2006,

E ( 1000 m3)
! *
I F*
- 
- *,
*
- .
- * 
*(*
-
-
- 
- 
- #
-

2006

2005

2006

()

$174

$250

44%

$200
$180
$120
$85 - $95

$120 - $125 26% - 47%

$60

$105

75%

$56

$110

96%

$60

$110

83%

$47

$47

0%

$68

$110

62%

$80

$160

100%

$50

$95

90%

*(

,
:

, ,
,
.
#
5
. ,
,

. ( 1990-,
,

(". $5++ 1998).
:
. 19 25
. K

. ( 9

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:

:
H ( *,
30 ((*,
-
1990 . %
1990- (. 1).
(
, "#
30 . C 2002
13 , , 50
((*, % 5
25 ((*. % ,


10 .
$
" (. Djankov
and Murrell, 2002) ,

,
. K ,

B ( $, "#.
* ,
. *
, . $
,
. "

,
, .. ,
. *
,
. (
,
,
. ,
, -

,
. *

"#.
(, *
K,
.
(
,

. *


. ( ,
,

,

.
" ,

,
. (

, K
+, .
$
(
. %
, Bennett, Estrin, and Urga (2005)
26 1991-2003 ,

. *
1 ((* ((* 0.18
.
! 1
. $$.
0
30

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

20

! $$.

, 6 . %
,

, . 2 ,
,
.

10
0
-10
-20
-30
-40
-50

$$.

+ 1 ((*
(GDP) ((* (PRIVSECT)
. #

,
. (

: GDP= 4.262 (1.36) + 0.115 (1.73)
PRIVSECT ( t-).
Bennett, Estrin, and Urga (2005) ,
((*
,
: , ,
. N

.
*

2006 | 3


.
,
, .
I
"
. *
80- 90-

, 10 . N
,
,
,
. *

. N
, (
, )
,

.

* ,
Adecco
 - =  (LBS). *
2006
- = .
Bennett, J., Estrin, S. and Urga, G. (2005): Privatisation and Economic Growth in Transition
Economies, forthcoming.
Djankov, S. and Murrell, P. (2002): Enterprise Restructuring in Transition: A Qualitative Survey. Journal of Economic Literature 40 (3): 739-793.
EBRD Transition Report (various years). European Bank for Reconstruction and Development,
London.

(

*

. 
,
.
C ,

.
90- ,

. 8,
. *,

& 1: $$.
F, *( 1989-94
$
$ $$.

1991 1995 2002 1991 1995 2001


24
60
75
..
74
82

..
45
70
29
49
..

..
25
60
..
43
..

7
15
25
2
7
..


..
..
45
..
..
..

17
50
75
10
41
81

25
40
60
22
48
..

17
70
80
19
57
70

18
65
80
11
..
..

..
40
60
..
..
..
#
27
30
65
25
..
..

33
60
80

71

$
12
25
65
5
..
75

..
40
65
..
69
79

..
55
70
12
60
73
-
15
65
75
16

-
..
30
50
36
..
..
#
45
60
75
51
61
72
.
24
45
65
34
51
75
!
10
55
70
5
..
..
!
*
..
..
45
..
..
..

..
60
80
13
60
75
*
16
50
65
18
48
..
*
..
25
50
..
53
63
&
..
15
25
..
..
..
&
8
45
65
..
..
..

..
30
45
..
..
..

20

44

62

EBRD Transition Report 1999, 2003


"", 5 C (1997).
*
,
,
.

,

. *

90-.
N
,

. *
? *

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:



,
. +
.
:, :

(
,

. $
,
. (


, " ".
*
. 8

,
, .
" ,
, . T
,

. %


. ,
,
.

. (

() . C
,
, .


*, +, +, " ,
$5++ ($ 5 +
+) 1997 , 8, :: (


. ,
,
.

,

,
. N -
. ,
( 5 1994 ,
.
8
(

(. 8
). + ,

,
:

. 


.

,
,
. +
. *
,
. (

. "
2
,
(. Handbook Of New Institutional Economics).
" ,
.
*

2006 | 3
,
.
. (

* ,
,
. :,

, .
*
. "

, ,
. H

,
. %
,
.
:
,
.
,

. C , .

/
:
8
!

( 1990-
,
. 
,
.
K ,
, .
N ,
, ,

. 5 ,
( )
(
).

$
,
: 35% ,
2002 , .
 , -

. " ,
,
. # ,
,
,
,
,
. *
( $,

.

* (Ph.D.),
.

- =

Johnson, S., McMillan, J. and Woodruff, C. (2002). Property Rights And Finance, American
Economic Review 92 (5).
Blanchard, O. and Kremer, M. (1997). Disorganization, Quarterly Journal of Economics 111.
Monard C. and Shirley, M., eds. (2005) Handbook Of New Institutional Economics, Kluwer Academic Press.


,
,
,
.
:
.
, Bekaert, Cambell, and Lundblad (2001) ,
emerging markets
2
.
(
(
, . (
+ -
;
,
.
( , ,
:

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:


, ,
,
, , ,

.
( Black et al. (1998)
,
10000

50 . 8
90
5 (Atanasov et al., 2004). +

,
.

.
 " ( ( 1998 )
.



.
%
, ,

.
,
. "

.

(-
Glaeser, Johnson, and Shleifer (2001)
, 1994

((*. (
K,
, *

. (,

C ,
(,

). ( K
:
,
.
( C

, : . (

.  ,
, ,

.
(

. C ,

. C 1998
,
1994 . %
,

1990-.

10

N
. :

,
. :
,

, , - 2. C



(., , Doidge, Karolyi and Stulz (2003)),
-
.



. Durnev
and Kim (2005) ,

. N ,


.
,
. Durnev and Kim (2005)
,
10 ( 100 )
9 .

:  .
!
+
. C ,

2006 | 3
,

. H

Atanasov, Vladimir, Conrad Ciccotello, and Stanley Gyoshev, 2004, How can law affect
finance: An empirical examination of tunneling in an emerging market, working paper,
Babson College.
Bekaert, Geert, Cambell Harvey, and Christian Lundblad (2001), Emerging equity markets
and economic development, Journal of Development Economics, 465-504.
Black, Bernard, Reinier Kraakman, and Anna Tarassova (2000), Russian privatisation and
corporate governance: What went wrong, Stanford Law Review 52, 1731-1808.
Doidge, Craig A., G. Andrew Karolyi, and Rene M. Stulz, (2003), Why are foreign firms listed
in the U.S. worth more? Journal of Financial Economics 71, 205238.

8 (Ph.D.) #
McGill (), Desautels Faculty of Management



#
( #
,
.
-

( ) . Q

,

. (
:,
30%
, 2001 ,
. *
*+
:.

.
* #
*+, , ,
2002 2004 ,
: 1% . 8
, Q 2001
4% 5%, 2 1998-1999
10%, 5 2000 7% 11%.
5 ,
: , 1998
1995-1996 . % Q,
,

( 25% 70%);
, ,
2001 .

Durnev, Art, and E. Han Kim, 2005, To Steal or not to steal: Firm attributes, legal environment,
and valuation, Journal of Finance 60, 1461-1493.
Glaeser, Edward, Simon Johnson, and Andrei Shleifer, (2001), Coase versus the Coasians,
Quarterly Journal of Economics, 853-899.

C ,
,

(
, ). ,
Q, 2001
, . ( :

( 250 ) , ,
( 250 )
, .
, -
,
. 8

( , ),
. % ,
,
, . H
,
,
.
,
,
.
*, ,
,
. (
,
. N
:
,
,
,

,

. ( ,

, ,
.

11

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:


.
* :

. H :
: 81 155
( 5 (2006). % ,
,

.
.
,

<25%

28

25-39%

33

40-55%

10

56-69%

6
__
84

>70%

% , ,
, .


. K
, . 8 2005
:
Q,
. (
. "
, , ,
,
(

). "

!

 =
:
$ 


(
),
(
18 ). N
,
,
, ( 5 (2005),
- $.
+
. ,

:
(
$"-15). : :
65% , "
24%, " 33%. (
:
, 5, +,
. (
:
.
% - (
, )
,

. " ,

,
,
. ( :
*+ ,
2001 ,

. 8 ,

,
, , .
( # I , .!( F
*(, 


, %,
2005- ,
, - $ 2006-
. 
+, 26 2006
.

2000 2004
2005- . + ((*
2,4% 12% 2004-. H

12

C 1, 2004-
2005-
.

2006 | 3

,
2000-2003- ,
3 - 4% ((* 2004- 2005- .
* , 2000 2003 ,
2,4% ((* 2004- ,
, 3,2% ((* 2005-. $
,
,
1998- +.

* 2004
.

. "

2005-
.

H
,
,

.
2004- ,
.

+
,
. 8
((* 25% 2003- 21% 2004- .

. %


.
!
" : .
" (
((*) 10%
2006- . (
,
, ,
,
. %

 (5). "

.

,
. (

, 2006-
$.
# : .
* , ((*,

,
. C
,
,
.
K
((*,
. :
, . N

,
. * , ,
C
2005- :
20% ((* 2004- 16 % 2005 .
% . 8

2006-
, ,
. :
, ,
((* ,

(,
),
.

. *
,
,

.
"

,
.
:

* . $

.
+. Q
,
.
'
. "
- .$ ,
,
. %
, +
.
* ,
;

13

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:


& 1. # (2000 2005 ..)
:: *
2000
5.9
 $$. (%)
28.2
 (%)
0.6
! (% $$.)
* 2005- . ** .

.

+

. ( ,

.
,
T .
(
.

2005-

. % ,
,
.
,
"H, .
' .
+ 9 . ,
(. 2005- ,
4 . . C
,

. % ,

,

,
.
*
, Q

.


C , 2005-
, -
. *

, ,

. ( :

5 , ,

.

14

2001
9.2
12
-0.3

2002
5.2
0.8
0.7

2003
9.6
5.2
-0.2

2004
12.1
9
-3.2

2005
2.4*
10.3
-2.9**

 -
:

.

5

.
. 2006 2007
( ,
.
. 5 2006-
,
2004-2005 . "
, , . (

. (
+ ,

. *

. *
2007-
,

.
" ,
2006- ,

. "

. 3

,
+
.

=,
.

: ,
Blue Ribbon, UNDP,
$ ,
Blue Ribbon,
UNDP,
#  (2005), !, : $ F
* *, # : $, 

2006 | 3


:
?
$
+ 1990


- . (,
-
, +
"""+,

.
(

,
. "

, ,
. (,
,
. :

,
$,

((, 1991).  (
$ """+
(C, 1996). 

. % ,


.
(
? C
. %, ,
1992
:(T. " ,
( $ "#
. ( ,

. 

, ,
,
. ( ,
- $",
,

. ( ,

,
, .
( # (Global Development Network, #"+) : (Bridging Research
and Policy)

. N
,
:
, 5,

*.
,
,

. ( H $
NN,
. C , #
(Deutsches Institut fr Wirtschaftsforschung, DIW) 5
, N N
(Economic and Social Research Institute)
. ( ,

. *
, ,
, . ( ,
NN ,
( ,
).

. % ,
B.
( ,
#"+,
. Q
,
. :

,

. +
,
* (
") N
(N$8) ( #
TRANSFORM). %

. ,
*
, NC+,
, N$8

.
5

,
, :
,
, .

15

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:


3 #"+

. : ,
, ,
. (,
$",
,

. ( ,
, ,

2,
,
.
N #"+ 5 ,

( ). %,

1999 ( 5
,
2002
N$8, USAID.
*
*+. (

,



*
E
( 1990- " 1
,
(. % 1). +
((* C % (
)
: 2004 ((*
C 20% , % 31%
, 1989 . "
, ((*
,
% #. " , 1990- "
. (
2004 ((* 7%,
.
N
, (
(( , 2005).

16

- : 2. (
5, 2000-2003
: 5 USAID. N
, 5 ,
,
- ,
.
+, ,
#"+,
, ,

;
. (, ,

:
,
$ .
$ (Alf Vanags) 

, !, -.
# #
http://gdn.eerc.ru
Richard N Cooper (1996) Currency Convertibility in Transforming Economies: Was It a Mistake?, Weatherhead Center for International Affairs, Harvard University, mimeo.
John Williamson (1991), Currency Convertibility in Eastern Europe

%. % , ,
- (C
%) 1999
.
, ,
,
. *
"
,
, ,

.  , (
5 ,
7
.
*

"
, ,
. " "
. (

2006 | 3
,
. Q
" ,
,

.

, 1990-. 
,
. %
. (,
%,
, %
C. 
, B .

,

. " , +
,
% ,
.

"
( %
C .

? 
*+ 8 "
(2005)
, , .
(
,
,
.
,
,
.

( ,
"
.
,

, ,
.

,

. %

,
. #

,
. *
,
.

+
, ,

" ,
((* 50 100
10 . 2
50 2002
C C ((* 2015
20 C 55
C. + 13
C 66 C. (
, ,

.

* "
- C +. +
+ T " :
, +

8 ,

& 1 & $$. (%)


1990


1992

1994

:: $ 

1996

1998

'99

'00

'01

'02

'03

'04

'04-'08*

-4.6

-5.3

-12.6

0.5

-1.9

2.7

9.8

13.5

9.8

9.2

8.1

8.2

3.2

-13.9

-20.1

7.1

2.1

3.7

5.4

5.3

6.7

4.5

&

-0.6

-29

-21.3

-16.7

5.3

3.7

8.3

10.2

9.1

10.2

8.5

6.1

&**

0.7

-5.3

-17.3

-6.7

6.7

16.5

18.6

20.4

19.8

16.9

7.5

7.5

***

1.6

-11.2

-5.2

1.7

4.3

4.3

3.8

4.2

4.2

4.4

2.5

2.7

* . .
** . F , , 2001 ., . . ,
$$. 2002-2003 . 8% .

*** . ( 1997 ., #$/; ,


( 1.5% 2003 ).

17

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:



. (
(%

. K (%

. ( C
(%
"3 $",
71 . " 8
" ,
((* 6 %, 3
%.

:  8
  *
( " (

, (
. C
*+  ?
( 20-
, ( .
+

,
. 
 , 60
. *
,
,
21- .  ,

.
C
?
C
?

 # 
,
. C ,
. 
, ,
, B + %. (

18

*
, , ,

. N
,
, ,
.
E
E ! &, .!(,

1 , , &, &

, -, ,
,
. (-,
, .
:
B ,

2006 | 3

2015- . (

.
K ,
"#, 5 B $,
, *+? K
?
H , "#, 5
B $, ,
.
(
, .
C
,
,
.

,
.
,
*+, .
( ,
B $, $", ( -(. 8 *+
$ ", .
(
: ( T ( 5
. ( $" ,

,
.
:(T ( , 510 ,
:, , %,
+, ,
C.
,
(%,

. (
, *+
 ?

( (

),

. ( -


. 

, ,
.
*+


. C , ,
2 ,

. 8 - ,
,
.
H 10 *+ . C
? C ( *+
 ?
K 10 B +
%. 8
. :
, ,
,
. :
,
,
. ,
B + %
. + ,
, ,
. , 2015
,
21- .

* .

 8 .!(

$ . : :





F F



! . F , ,
www.developmentandtransition.net

19

.F!F8(GH .F!:8: $.!*G !I$:&:



:

?
$ 2001-2005 .
$$. 12%.

(*/.). F
, */. 8%,
,
E
$ F. # */.
-
?
$ ,


. $-, 90- .


.
.


,
, , ,

. $-,


. &
, ,
, ,

.

#
UNDP F
. hhtp://www.undp.am/econbriefs/productivity

5 * :
2
* .

www.developmentandtransition.net
! .!( 

.!F8*&:F (/F!F(E::
11- F
"(
"
((
$/5
"""+),
C , -, 23-25 2006 .
8 : http://www.nationalities.org/Events.asp


- , C
T, C, 1-3 2006 . 8
: http://www.basees.org.uk/~conference/

F: 5
, %, ,
5-6

2006
.
8
:
http://ec.ut.ee/conf06/

#-
E , 5, 17-18 2006
. * *
 InWent Capacity Building International,
:
#. H : Christina
Carlson, Programme Specialist, Central Asia Cluster, Regional Bureau
for Europe and the CIS. christina.carlson@undp.org

12- F  INFORUM *, 23-25


2006 . % -
, ,

.
* ,
.
8 :
http://www.inforum.cz/inforum2006/english/
!: 8 Q j.hughes@lse.ac.uk
: 5 " I : # ",
" $ : # :
 :  5, ( 5
(), " #, : C, 8
2, : 2, C :

Grosslingova 35
Bratislava 81109
Slovakia
Tel: +421 2 59337 111
Fax: +421 2 59337 450
www.undp.org/europeandcis

Houghton Street, London WC2A 2AE, UK


www.lse.ac.uk