Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 37

NSF I/UCRC since 2000

Advanced Prognostics for Smart Systems


Methodology, Tools, and Applications

Jay Lee
Ohio Eminent Scholar and L.W. Scott Alter Chair Professor Univ. of Cincinnati Jay.lee@uc.edu & Director NSF Industry/University Cooperative Research Center on Intelligent Maintenance Systems (IMS) www.imscenter.net

Outline
Business and Productivity Models Prognostics Design: Methodology and Tools Design of Prognostics Platform for Various Applications Design of Smart Service Systems

Outline
Business and Productivity Models Prognostics Design: Methodology and Tools Design of Prognostics Platform for Various Applications Design of Smart Service Systems

IMS Vision and Mission Statement


To enable products and systems to achieve and sustain near near-zero breakdown performance, performance, and ultimately transform machine condition data to useful information for improved productivity and asset utilization.

The IMS Consortium

Common Unmet Needs in Future Maintenance and Service


Intelligent Monitoring, Predict and Prevent for Guaranteed Sustainability Self-Assessment Autonomous Information Flow from Field (user) To Service/Business Systems Only Handle Information Once (OHIO)

Operations Intelligence

Predict, Prioritize, Optimize, and Plan Maintenance Scheduling For Near-Zero Downtime and All-Time Readiness

Outline
Business and Productivity Models Prognostics Design: Methodology and Tools Design of Prognostics Platform for Various Applications Design of Smart Service Systems

Service Design using System-ofSystem Approach


Closed-Loop Loop Life Cycle Design
Design for Reliability and Serviceability Health Monitoring Product or System Sensors & Embedded In Use Intelligence

Near 0 Downtime

Just-in-Time Service

Product Center

Product Redesign

Degradation Assessment
(Feature Monitoring)

Web-enabled Monitoring & Prognostics

Smart Design

Self-Maintenance Redundancy Active Passive

Communications Tether-Free (Bluetooth) Internet TCP/IP

Decision Support Tools Condition-based for Optimized Planning & Maintenance Scheduling

(CBM)
p Services Responsive Asset Optimization

Enhanced E h d Six-Sigma Design

Health Information

System Instrumentation Approach


Principal Components Performance Feature

Health Feature Radar Chart 1 Bearing


0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0

Prediction of Machine Performance Life


7.5 7 6.5 Principal Component 6

Normal Behavior

Most Recent Behavior r

5.5 5

4.5 4 3.5 3 200 210 220 230 Actual Data Prediction Actual Data Prediction Uncertainty 240 250 260 Cycle Number 270 280

Tools for Autonomic Computing

User input

Statistical Pattern Recognition


What?
Example of two dimensions space
Failure Mode #1 Safe operation Failure Mode #2

Analytical comparisons of feature distributions


Feat ture f2

When?

Features are (approximately) Gaussian Stable operation without too many impacts

Cluster displacement

Possible application: pp

0
Cluster distribution 1

Feature f1

Repeatable processes and operations

CV

Current C t time

0.5

Evaluation the overlap area yields the CV


Time

Methodology
Streamline
Sort, Filtering, Prioritize Data Reduce Sensor Data Sets & PCA Correlate and Digest Relevant Data Assess Health Degradation Predict Performance Trends Diagnose Potential Failure (Prognostics) Embedded Agent (hierarchical and distributed) Only Handle Information Once Tether-free Communication Decision Support Tools Systematic Prognostics Selection Reconfigurable Hardware Platform Toolbox Maintenance M i t Information I f ti Standardization St d di ti Embedded Self-Learning & Knowledge Mgt. Closed-Loop Life Cycle Design User-Friendly Prognostics Deployment

Smart Processing Synchronize

Standardize

Sustain

12

Data Streamlining
Streamline
Maintenance Database Data Cleaning, Filtering Fil i and d Sorting S i No Maintenance Record Expert k knowledge l d

Smart Processing Synchronize

Identify Critical Components

Data Collection

Expert Knowledge

St d di Standardize

Data Cleaning, Dimension Reduction Determine a Clean and Reduced Data Set

Sustain

IMS Methodology: 5S Approach


Streamline
Sort, Filtering, Prioritize Data Reduce Sensor Data Sets & PCA Correlate and Digest Relevant Data Assess Health Degradation g Predict Performance Trends Diagnose Potential Failure (Prognostics) Embedded Agent (hierarchical system) Tether-free Communication Only Handle Information Once (OHIO) Decision Support Tools Systematic y Prognostics g Implementation p Reconfigurable Hardware and Software Platform Maintenance Information Standardization Embedded Knowledge Mgt. for Self-Learning Closed-Loop Product Life Cycle Design User-Friendly Prognostics Deployment

Smart Processing Synchronize

Standardize

Sustain

Watchdog Agent Toolbox


Signal Processing & Feature Extraction Time-frequency / Time-frequency moments Wavelets/Wavelet packet energies / Wavelet moments Autoregressive modeling / AR model roots Expert extracted features Fast Fourier Transform
1

Performance Assessment Logistic Regression

Performance Prediction ARMA Prediction M t h Matrix Match M ti

Statistical Pattern Recognition Feature Map Pattern Matching CMAC Network Pattern Match
CV

Elman Recurrent Neural Network Fuzzy Logic Health Diagnosis Support Vector Machine Hidden Markov Model

CV

0.5

?
Time

Bayesian Belief Network

Information Delivery
Results of Smart Prognostics Tools for Asset Health Information

1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0

Confidence Value for performance degradation assessment (0-1)

Health Radar Chart Health Map p for for multiple potential issues components and pattern degradation classification
monitoring

Risk Radar Chart to Prioritize Maintenance Decision

Information Delivery
Results of Smart PrognosticsTools for Asset Health Information

1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0

Confidence Value for performance degradation assessment (0-1)

Health Radar Chart Health Map p for for multiple potential issues components and pattern degradation classification
monitoring

Risk Radar Chart to Prioritize Maintenance Decision

Field Service Application: KONE Testbed


Equipment Elevator Door (Controller) E Encoder d
IIS web

Remote Monitoring

WAGO I/O

server

Web Browser

OPC Server

iCONICS Genesis32 (OPC client)

Business Applications

Bridge
Watchdog
Database

iCONICS GenBroker (COM over tcp/ip)

D2B

A Case Study: Elevator Door Testbed

Performance Indicators Cycle time of the elevator door Maximal speed of the elevator dooe

Normal Operation CV = 97.6%

Increased Friction CV=70.3%

Normal Operation CV=97.6%

Information Delivery
Results of Smart Prognostics Tools for Asset Health Information

1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0

Confidence Value for performance degradation assessment (0-1)

Health Radar Chart Health Map p for for multiple potential issues components and pattern degradation classification
monitoring

Risk Radar Chart to Prioritize Maintenance Decision

10

ESMD Chillers FCFT Predictive Maintenance for Hong Kong International Airport Control Tower (May 2007)

Project Background

Chiller at Control Tower of H.K. Int. Airport

11

Hardware Setup
Chiller with 6 Accelerometers
Details: IMI 623C01, high-freq., ceramic shear ICP accel, 100mV/g, 0.8 to 15k Hz, top exit, 2-pin conn. From: S&V Samford Instruments Ltd.

35m BNC Cable x 6

NI PXI Data Logging System Johnson Controls OPC Server


3m LAN cable
Details: - PXI-4472, 24 Bit, 102.4 kS/s, 8 Inputs, 110 dB Dynamic Range - 6 SMB to BNC connectors, SMB-100, SMB to BNC Female - Communicate with Data Logging Server through NI MXI-4 technology

3m copper cable

Data logging Server


Details: - Dell Dimension(TM) E520 - Data Logging System

Raw Data

Vibration signals OPC (OLE for Process Control) Data

12

Fixed Cycle Feature Test (FCFT)


How to convert raw data to information? Why FCFT? What is FCFT?
T1

T2

T3

T transition of the load change

FCFT Radar Chart

Data ---- Information EMSD vibration signals on 2007-05-21 at 16-03-54 ----------- Normal

13

FCFT Radar Chart

EMSD vibration signals on 2007-05-22 at 10-57-04 ----------- Normal

FCFT Radar Chart

Some mechanical faults happened at that time.

EMSD vibration signals on 2007-05-14 at 11-22-18 ----------- Abnormal

14

Information Delivery
Results of Smart Prognostics Tools for Asset Health Information

1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0

Confidence Value for performance degradation assessment (0-1)

Health Radar Chart Health Map p for for multiple potential issues components and pattern degradation classification
monitoring

Risk Radar Chart to Prioritize Maintenance Decision

Komatsu Earth Moving Equipment Field Services (Komatsu Engineer on UC Campus)

15

Komatsus Remote Maintenance


Komatsu Ltd. has developed the necessary infrastructure for collecting data from individual construction machines, from the place of operation via the user
Help desk

Failure History data Failure code, Occurrence date & time, Repaired date & time Trend Analysis Data Data D t f from sensors ( (as max/ / ave/ / min i every 20 operating hours) Others data Load meter, Running time of engine, etc.

Mo de m Bank

Mo de m Bank

Mo de m Bank

Focus on Smart Asset Business


Failure prediction & diagnosis failures
to reduce down time, maintenance & support costs
by detecting incipient degradations of all components by identifying and isolating failure critical components

Degradation monitoring of engine and transmission systems


to estimate lifetime with higher accuracy to t prevent t or delay d l failures f il to expand components overall life
using appropriate and key data using features for key performance index

16

Komatsu Approach
to increase quality of data in Komatsu database to enable more advanced predictive maintenance decision making base on analytical reliability models to achieve intelligent maintenance excellence and to implement knowledge based decision making approach

Sensors

IMS Watchdog TM

KOMATSU On Board Computer


Monitoring & Aid View to Decision

Engine DT09XXN Engine DT09XYH Engine DT43XZA Engine DT77YVP

Replacement, High priority Replacement, High priority Maintenance required Plan replacement in 1500 h Good, 5000 h remaining

Engine Comp.A,C Comp.D No change

IMS Embedded Smart Software Tools


ENGINEERING KNOWLEDGE AND DATA ACQUISITION FROM THE SYSTEM

Customer Appliance

Komatsu WebCARE

Komatsu Engineers

Signal Processing & Feature Extraction

Data Preparing (Filtering Outlier estimation)

B Group Methods
Autoregressive Modeling Data Handling Based Feature Extraction

Health Assessment & Prediction

C
Bayesian Belief Network (BBN)

D
Fuzzy Logic (FL) Based Decision Making

E
Match Matrix & ARMA Modeling

F Human Machine Interface

AUTOMATIC AID TO DIAGNOSIS DECISION MAKING

AUTOMATIC AID TO PROGNOSIS DECISION MAKING

Remaining Lifetime Prediction Comparison and Predictive Maintenance Planning

17

Decision Support Tools for Smart Service Recommendation


FL or Reliability based Prognostics
P C S Prognostic

Failure Mode Effects & Risk Assessment Tools


System ref. Engine ref. Failure Mode Causes Effect on the Component D system

Wear Cracking FM 2 Cable disc. Sensor fails Injector Machine B Transmit. BY Derailment Wear of the cabin Cracking Sensor fails D: Detectability C: Cost P: Probability S: Severity

Machines Machine A Engine AX FM 1

Fall of the cabin

Fall of the cabin

Cylinder Inlet Valve R Inlet Valve L Injector Shaft Gears Bearing

0.6

2 H Change engine

0.9

1 M Change Bearing

BBN output

Decision Aid

Autonomic Service Logistics


1 0.8 0.6 04 0.4 0.2 0
Bearing

Logistic Information
Engine/Asset Location Components Availability Review Previous Maintenance Actions Recommend and Assign Right Technician Estimate Maintenance cost

Valve

Cylinder

18

Information Delivery
Results of Smart Prognostics Tools for Asset Health Information

1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0

Confidence Value for performance degradation assessment (0-1)

Health Radar Chart Health Map p for for multiple potential issues components and pattern degradation classification
monitoring

Risk Radar Chart to Prioritize Maintenance Decision

Bearing Fault Background


Normal Roller Inner-race Outer-race

Outer + inner Outer-race Outer + inner Outer race +roller + roller + roller

z Normal condition z Outer-race failure z Roller failure z Inner-race failure


Drawing courtesy of Wikipedia

19

Feature Extraction

FFT (Fast Fourier Transform)


Overall acceleration, velocity, or displacement, amplitude peaks at 1X RPM, 2X RPM, 3X RPM, BPFO, BPFI, FTF and BSF Harmonics and sidebands, RMS and kurtosis

Health Assessment - Multi-fault Data

Normal Condition

Inner- race + Roller

Outerrace Outer + Inner Race SOM accomplishes two things: reduces dimensions Roller Outer + Inner + Roller and displays similarities. Inner- race Outer Race + Roller

20

IMS Methodology: 5S Approach


Streamline
Sort, Filtering, Prioritize Data Reduce Sensor Data Sets & PCA Correlate and Digest Relevant Data Assess Health Degradation g Predict Performance Trends Diagnose Potential Failure (Prognostics) Embedded Agent (hierarchical system) Tether-free Communication Only Handle Information Once (OHIO) Decision Support Tools Systematic y Prognostics g Implementation p Reconfigurable Hardware and Software Platform Maintenance Information Standardization Embedded Knowledge Mgt. for Self-Learning Closed-Loop Product Life Cycle Design User-Friendly Prognostics Deployment

Smart Processing Synchronize

Standardize

Sustain

Synchronization System Structure


Data flow Health Information Internet

Embedded side

Remote side

......

Raw data Industrial Field

Health Information Display ATC Status Display User Discrete Event Interf Display ace Algorithm Modification Error Log Database Data Format

21

IMS Methodology: 5S Approach


Streamline
Sort, Filtering, Prioritize Data Reduce Sensor Data Sets & PCA Correlate and Digest Relevant Data Assess Health Degradation g Predict Performance Trends Diagnose Potential Failure (Prognostics) Embedded Agent (hierarchical system) Tether-free Communication Only Handle Information Once (OHIO) Decision Support Tools Systematic y Prognostics g Implementation p Reconfigurable Hardware and Software Platform Maintenance Information Standardization Embedded Knowledge Mgt. for Self-Learning Closed-Loop Product Life Cycle Design User-Friendly Prognostics Deployment

Smart Processing Synchronize

Standardize

Sustain

Watchdog Agent Software Platform


Executive Agent
Task Scheduler

Engine
Algorithm Selector Health Diagnosis Performance Assessment Database Agent

ISO 13374 / Processing Task OSA-CBM Feature Selection

Algorithm Toolbox Communications Toolbox

Performance Prediction Services External Devices

44

22

Reconfigurable Prognostics Platform


D2B Machine Level Connectivity
Sensor Fusion Feature Extraction Performance Assessment Autonomous Learning Prediction and Prognostics

Decision Support Tools D2B Business Level Connectivity

IMS Prognostics Platform

IMS Methodology: 5S Approach


Streamline
Sort, Filtering, Prioritize Data Reduce Sensor Data Sets & PCA Correlate and Digest Relevant Data Assess Health Degradation g Predict Performance Trends Diagnose Potential Failure (Prognostics) Embedded Agent (hierarchical system) Tether-free Communication Only Handle Information Once (OHIO) Decision Support Tools Systematic y Prognostics g Implementation p Reconfigurable Hardware and Software Platform Maintenance Information Standardization Embedded Knowledge Mgt. for Self-Learning Closed-Loop Product Life Cycle Design User-Friendly Prognostics Deployment

Smart Processing Synchronize

Standardize

Sustain

23

Next Step Close the Loop


Closed-Loop Loop Life Cycle Design
Design for Reliability and Serviceability Health Monitoring Product or System Sensors & Embedded In Use Intelligence

Just-in-Time Service

Product Center

Product Redesign

Watchdog Agent Degradation Assessment


(Feature Monitoring)

Web-enabled Monitoring & Prognostics

Smart Design

Self-Maintenance Redundancy Active Passive

Communications Tether-Free (Bluetooth) Internet TCP/IP

Decision Support Tools Condition-based for Maintenance Schedule

Maintenance
(CBM) Synchronization Service Asset Optimization

Enhanced E h d Six-Sigma Design

Health Information

Watchdog Agent is Trademarks of IMS Center

Int. IMS Project PROMISE (Product Embedded Information System for Service and EOL)
1. Initial product info is written in the product embedded device

Product delivery

Producers KPDM

Embedded device 3. Wireless bluetooth connection between mobile device and product embedded device

Bluetooth ?

3. Wireless Internet connection between mobile device and producers KPDM

Internet
2. A certified agent for service or EOL operations

4. Update information in the embedded device and in the producers KPDM

Service & maintenance

EOL

24

Outline
Business and Productivity Models Prognostics Design: Methodology and Tools Design of Prognostics Platform for Various Applications Design of Smart Service Systems

Prognostics Design ad Development


Streamline

Smart Processing Synchronize

Standardize

Sustain

5 0

25

Commercial Hardware -1
High Performance and Rugged
UNO-2160 Watchdog Agent System

Fanless Celeron 400MHz CPU 256/512MB SDRAM 9 30VDC power input i t 9-30VDC -10 to 50C operating temp HardwareStorage Watchdog Timer Non-volatile Media CompactFlash 2.5 HDD Battery Backed RAM

Built-in Comm. Interfaces


2x Ethernet ports 4x Serial ports 2x USB ports 1x Printer port

Robust Embedded OS
Windows CE.NET Windows XP embedded

Expansion Capability
1x PC Card slot (PCMCIA) 2x PC/104 slots

Commercial Hardware -2
I/O
CompactRIO reconfigurable embedded system Analog Input/Output, Digital Input/Output (Low / high speed, simultaneous / multiplexed) 200 MHz Pentium Class 64 MB or 512 MB Flash 4-slot or 8-slot 1 M Gate or 3M Gate FPGA Standard connector depends on the module Options: Strain Relief Connector Block, Custom Cable, etc.

Real-time controller

Reconfigurable Chassis Connectivity


26

Watchdog Agent Tools on LabVIEW

IMS Watchdog Agent in LabVIEW

Performance Assessment

Logistic Regression

Feature Map

CMAC Pattern Match

Performance Prediction

Match Matrix Bayesian Networks

Neural Network

Health Diagnosis

Hidden Markov Model

27

IMS Plug-n-Prognose System


+ Watchdog Agent Hardware Platform Toolbox Robust Health Information

Radar Chart for Components Health Monitoring

Data

Confidence Value for Performance Degradation Monitoring

Watchdog Agent Platform

Risk Radar Chart to Prioritize Maintenance Decision

Health Map for Pattern Classification

55

Embed Prognostics in Controller

28

Validated Hardware
Allen-Bradley ControlLogix/1756 Rack with Logix 5550 Special Application Module for ControlLogix Intel Pentium 266MHz CPU, 128MB of RAM and Windows XP Professional as operating system Communication between 56SAM module and processor is realized over the backplane of the rack

5 7

Smart Machine Testbed (IMS/TechSolve in Cincinnati, OH)

29

Smart Self-Maintenance Machines


MTHI MTHI

0. 925

0. 560
MTHI

0. 690
MTHI

0. 751

MTHI
M1 M6 M2

MFPI
Product Quality Energy Downtime

Constraints
1. 2. 3. 4. Schedule Budget Quality Tolerances Etc.

MFHI

0.745

M5

M3

Readiness Flexibility

Maintenance

M4

Prognostics Tools for Vehicle Telematics


Oil pressure and Oil levels Fuel level Odometer Od t reading di Vibration and Acoustic data Air Pressure in tire and Flat tire Condition of air bags Box itself Different points on engine and transmission Anti brake system

30

Smart Bridge Health Prognostics


Feature extraction Obtain data from the critical locations
Historical Data Working Condition

Features

Embedded Sensors

Health assessment
In feature space Normal Behavior
Beam 1 Beam 2

Most Recent B h i Behavior

Support 2 Support 1

1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0

Truss 1 Truss 2

Visualization by performance chart

Future Combat Systems (FCS) and Needs


IMS Smart Watchdog Agent Prognostics Maintenance Remote diagnostics Platform L i ti Synchronization Logistics S h i ti

Condition-based Needs

31

Self-Maintenance Systems
Performance Degradation Model Expert Knowledge

Assessment Sensors

IMS Watchdog Agent

Prognostics Diagnostics Decision Support Tool

Degradation Information

Near-Zero-Downtime Service Autonomous Service Request for Spare Parts Asset Optimization

Monitoring of Standard Components, e.g.,

Components, e.g.,

32

Outline
Business and Productivity Models Prognostics Design: Methodology and Tools Design of Prognostics Platform for Various Applications Design of Smart Service Systems

Service Needs for Tomorrow:

Service is a Customer-Intensive System Service using a System Instrumentation (Smart Agent) Service through Smart Operation Analytics Service for Knowledge Management Business Service to Avoid Potential Issues for Customers.

J. Lee, NSF Symposium on Technology Management in the Service Sector Portland, OR, August 5, 2007 (Co-Sponsored by IBM Service Science)

33

Transformation of Service Intelligence

Infotronics Technologies

Synchronized Value Chain Flow (Cash Flow)

Conclusions

34

Our Approach Value Flow


Risk

Watchdog Agent IMS Platform Decision Support Tools


Validation Research Tools (Shared Tools & Knowledge) Company p y Designated Projects and Implementations

IMS Projects Value

Testbeds

Membership

Contracts

Membership Value through Leveraged Partnerships

Company Members

Membership and Partnerships

Testbeds Testbeds and and Projects Projects

25:1

IMS Methodologies and Enabling Technologies

35

IMS Value Proposition


Rapid Prognostics Design and Deployment
RISK & COST

Today

Value

TIME

RISK & COST

Saving

Risk and Cost Reduction Strategy

TIME

IMS Global Research Partnerships


Lulea Univ Sweden TU-Berlin Germany

EPFL Switzerland

Beijing Univ of Chemical S&T (BUCT) Univ. of Tokyo Japan Shanghai Jiao Tong Univ., China Cranfield Univ UK SIMTech Singapore UTT France CRC Integrated Asset Eng. QUT, Australia ITRI & PMC Taiwan H.K. PolyU

Univ. of Toronto, Canada

SENAI/UFRGS Brazil

36

Thank You !
For More Information Please visit: www.imscenter.net & www.dominantinnovation.com

37

Вам также может понравиться