On Package Paralleling Paralleling Solutions Selection EMCP-II+P (Larne) EMCP-II+P Cummins Generac (1) (Griffin (2) PCC (1)

C32) SDMO Kerys Basler Woodward Woodward ComAp Deep Sea Deif AGC-3 (1) EasyGen Lavado (1) DGC 2020 (1) (1) (1) EGCP-2 InteliSys 5520/5560 (1) (1) 3200

Paralleling Capability Maximum number of gensets to parallel Time from start to all units on bus (dead bus) Time from start to all units on bus (live bus) System Controls and Monitoring Features (Detailed View) Manual Paralleling Backup Dead bus arbitration - Lead Unit Select Dead bus arbitration - Random Access Load shed Load add kW sharing VAR sharing Synchronization - Frequency matching Synchronoization - Voltage matching Load sense demand (optimized fuel strategy) Single master interface Utility / mains sensing Load Control Soft loading/unloading Base load setpoint (import/export control) Mode of Operation Open transition transfer Close transition transfer - momentary (>100 ms) Close transition transfer - soft load transfer Peak shaving / load management System Control Functions ATS integration - hardwire Integrated ATS monitoring and control Redundant control network Tie breaker control Main-Tie-Main control UPS integration User Interface Color Monochrome Communications Customer Communications USB port Configuration saving / file transfer Other Functions Smart derate strategy Delayed Excitation paralleling Smart exitation Control (magnetization Capabilities Alarm/shutdown date stamp (target:20 ms) Real clock sync between units

>8

2 8-17 sec (11 sec average)

20(+)

18(+)

(3)

32

min 8 (2)

32

16

16

15 seconds

Standard Standard (1) Not Available CB Aux(2) CB Aux(2) Standard (3) cross current Standard Not Available Not Available Not Available Not available Not available Not available

Standard Standard Not Available Not Available Standard Standard CB Aux(1) Optional CB Aux(1) Optional Standard Standard (2) cross current Standard Standard Standard Not Available Standard Not Available Optional (2) Not Available Optional (2) Not available Optional (2) Not available Not available Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Optional
(2)

Not Available Not Available Standard Standard (4) Standard (4) Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Not Available Standard Not Available Standard (5) Standard
(5)

Standard

Optional (2) Optional (2) Not Available Not Available Standard Standard Optional (2) Optional (2) Standard Standard Standard Standard Optional (2) Optional (2) Standard Optional (2) Optional (2) Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Optional (2) Standard Standard Optional (3) Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available

Standard Standard Standard Standard

Optional (3) Standard (3) Optional (3) Optional (3) Optional (3) Standard Standard Standard Standard Optional Optional (3) Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard

Optional (2) Not Available Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Optional Optional (2) Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Optional

Optional (2) Not Available Standard Optional (2) Optional (2) Standard Standard Standard Standard Optional Optional Optional
(3) (3) (3)

Optional (2) Not Available Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard
(3)

Standard

Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard

Standard Standard Optional Optional Optional Optional

(3) (3) (3) (3)

Standard Standard With close With close transition ATS transition ATS Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Standard Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Standard Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available

Not Available Not Available Standard Standard Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Standard Standard

Standard Standard Optional Optional (2) (2) Optional Optional (2) Optional Standard
(2)

Standard Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available

Standard Standard Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Optional (2) (2) Not Available Optional Not Available Not Available

Standard Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Standard

Standard Not Available Standard Standard (3) (3) Standard Not Available Not Available Standard Modbus RTU / TCP Not Available Standard

Standard Standard

Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Standard Standard Standard Standard

M5X with CCM M5X with CCM Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available

LON / Modbus Not Available Not Available Not Available Standard

Modbus RTU Not Available Standard

Modbus RTU Modbus RTU Modbus RTU Modbus RTU Modbus RTU / TCP Not Available Not Available Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard

Modbus RTU Not Available Standard

Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Requires separate Master Controller

Legend Last Update: September 24, 2008

Standard

Optional

Not Available

Comments

No data found

Printed: 09/24/2008

Comments
EMCP II+P (Larne) 1. EMCP II+P from Larne provided with a timer based dead bus circuit 2. Load shed/load add via breaker aux contact only 3. kW sharing via additional load share module (standard) EMCP II+P (C32) 1. Load shed/load add via CB aux contact; 4x contacts provided 2. kW sharing via additional load share module (standard) Cummins 1. All data pulled from Cummins website (www.cumminspower.com) 2. Higher end paralleling functions accomplished via DCM 200, 300, or 1000 master control panel Generac 1. All data pulled from Generac Website (www.generac.com) 2. Generac MPS systems require a PowerManger System Controller (PM-SC) 3. Specific number of units not listed, but advertized as 100 kW - 9000 kW MPS systems 4. 6 steps max for load sequencing 5. Trasfer between generator requires Generac ATS Kohler / SDMO Kerys 1. Insufficient information exists on the web. Woodward EasyGen 3200 1. All data pulled from Woodward website (www.woodward.com) 2. Woodward provides Easygen 3200 controller only; controls provided by third party. Woodward EGCP-2 1. All data pulled from Woodward website (www.woodward.com) 2. Woodward provides EGCP-2 controller only; controls provided by third party. 3. With external kW transducer Basler DGC 2020 1. All data pulled from Basler wbsite (www.basler.com) 2. Specific number of units not specified, but load sharing performed via load share lines. 3. Basler provides DGC 2020 controller only; controls provided by third party. 4. Dead bus control via timer. ComAp InteliSys 1. All data pulled from ComAp website (www.comap.cz) 2. ComAp provides InteliSys controller only; controls provided by third party Deep Sea 1. All data pulled from Deep Sea website (www.deepseaplc.com) 2. Deep Sea provides 5520/5560 controller only; controls provided by third party. 3. With optional DSC 5560 controller Deif AGC-3 1. All data pulled from Deif website (www.deif.com) 2. Deif provides AGC-3 controller only; controls provided by third party. 3. Depending on system complexity, additional AGC-3 controller may be Lavado Controls 1. No information found.

Last Update: September 24, 2008

Printed: 09/24/2008