Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 4

31/07/2013

Mandela's Jewish comrades - Opinion - Israel News | Haaretz


SUBSCRIBE T O HAARET Z DIGIT AL EDIT IONS

Haaretz.com

TheMarker

TheMarker Caf
Hel l o kjh You hav e v iewed 9 of 1 0 articles. Wednesday, July 31, 2013 Av 24, 5773 Search Haaretz.com

ISRAEL MINT
Pr ofile Log ou t
su bscri be n ow

National

Go outside - meteor season in Israel is on

NEWS

OPINION JEWISH WORLD


Peace talks

BUSINESS

TRAVEL IN ISRAEL
Egy pt

CULTURE

WEEKEND BLOGS
Like 73k Follow

ISRAEL NEWS BREAKING NEWS


Home Opinion

Ethiopian Aliy ah

Maccabiah 201 3

Word of the Day

7:04 PM Kerry convenes press conference following start of peace talks in Washington (Haaretz)

More Breaking News

Mandela's Jewish comrades


All five of the white defendants at the infamous Rivonia trials were Jewish. 50 years on from the police raids that led to the trials, what motivated both these Jewish anti-apartheid activists, disowned by South Africa's Jewish community?
By Roy Isacowitz | Jul. 30, 2013 | 6:11 PM |
0 Tw eet 50

HAARETZ SELECT

2
Send 143 people recommend this. Be the first of your friends.

Recommend

Jewish-American education, political diversity and critical thinking


Sm art, v alue-based Jewish education persists in the United States despite a com m unal tendency to foster a one-sided affinity with Israel. By Benjy Cannon | Jew ish World Opinions

In dealing with ultra-Orthodox Jews, Israels 2013-14 budget is miraculous


By Meirav Arlosoroff | Business Opinion | 2

Yair Lapid's High Noon on Facebook


By Barak Ravid | Diplom ania

Looking for beauty in T el Aviv's ugliest building


By Keshet Rosenblum | Arts & Leisure

Form er South African President Nelson Mandela wav ing to the m edia as he arriv es outside 1 0 Downing Street, in central London, August 2 8, 2 007 . Photo by AFP

The predominance of Jews among the older generation of white antiapartheid activists is unmistakable. As my father once put it, there was a minyan for every political discussion in Pretoria Central Prison after the imposition of martial law in 1960 - though never for the purpose of prayer, as far as I know. Most of the old-timers were comfortable in their Jewishness, but their rituals had a lot more to do with Marx than with the Almighty. That Jewish asymmetry was on display this past week as South Africa marked the 50th anniversary of the 1963 police raid on Lilisleaf Farm, near Johannesburg, which served at the time as the headquarters of Umkonto we Sizwe, the military wing of the underground African National Congress. It doesnt take much perspicuity to notice that all five of the white defendants in the subsequent trial were Jewish. (Another two Jews one of whom, Arthur Goldreich, lived in Israel until his death in 2011 escaped from detention before the trial.) Similarly, fully half the white defendants in the earlier Treason Trial (1956) were Jewish, as was the lead counsel. The head count of white opponents of apartheid reads like a census list from one of the old shtetls in Lithuania (from where most South African Jews originated): Joe Slovo, Harold Wolpe, Ruth First, Albie Sachs, Ronald Segal, Dennis Goldberg, Rusty Bernstein, Solly Sachs, Helen Suzman, Ray Alexander,

Tex t size Comments (2) Print Page Send to friend Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share
THIS STORY IS BY

'Dead' man talking: I helped build the Iranian nuclear reactor


Jeffrey 'Shuki' Gould, an Australian v eteran of three of Israels wars, believ es he built the foundations of the Bushehr reactor during his Mossad day s. By Dan Goldberg | Features

Lessons on peace & U.S. Jews, from Florida rightist who urges Israelis to 'Bring down traitor Bibi'
By Bradley Burston | A Special Place in Hell | 12

Roy Isacowitz

Stage Animal || T here will be blood at Cameri T heater


RELATED TAGS opinion Nelson Mandela
By Michael Handelzalts | Arts & Leisure

Chief Rabbinate election || Why David Stavs campaign failed


By Hannah Kehat | Opinion

O PI NI O N
RELATED ARTICLES What Net any ahu should learn from t he fall of apart heid By Ilan Baruch | Jul. 10, 2013 | 11:08 PM | 5

Israel will nev er be a 'norm al' state


By Liam Hoare | 11:45 AM

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.538830

1/4

31/07/2013
Ronnie Kasrils, Raymond Suttner, Ray Simons, Wolfie Kodish and many others. Some, like Ruth First, paid with their lives. Others were permanently disabled (Albie Sachs) or spent years in jail. Several, including Slovo, Kasrils and Albie Sachs, went on to fill senior positions in post-apartheid South African governments.

Mandela's Jewish comrades - Opinion - Israel News | Haaretz


Mandelas Mideast message: Choose negot iat ions, not t he bat t lefield By Heribert Adam | Jul. 8, 2013 | 2:38 PM |
3

T he EU's glaring hy pocrisy in regarding Israel


By Alan Baker | 08:52 AM | 3

What Israel wont learn from Mandelas legacy By Roy Isacowitz | Jun. 12, 2013 | 1:36 PM |
49

Frenkels honorable withdrawal


By Haaretz Editorial | 08:22 AM

Art hur Chaskalson, Jewish ant i-apart heid hero, dies at age 81 It is not only we hyper-sensitive Jews who pay By Jeremy Gordin | Dec. 11, 2012 | 9:19 AM | 6 attention to the Jewish hue of the white opposition. The apartheid regime also took note and made hay of it A deafening silence regularly. And Nelson Mandela (whose first employer, By Benjamin Pogrund | Dec. 26, 2003 | 12:00 AM at a time when few companies would employ blacks, was my neighbor Lazar Sidelsky) remarked on it in his autobiography, Long Walk to Freedom, when he wrote: I have found Jews to be more broadminded than most whites on issues of race and politics, perhaps because they themselves have historically been victims of prejudice.

A sordid defam ation of Judaism


By David Landau | 08:21 AM

MO RE FRO M THE WEB


RIP Dennis Farina, aka Cousin Avi (Jewish Journal) Mos Def undergoes Guant anamo-st y le forcefeeding (Video) Hezbollahs Cost ly Support for Sy rias Assad (World Politics Review)
Recommended by

That was certainly true of the Jews Mandela encountered during the struggle against apartheid, but it did not apply to the South African Jewish community as a whole. Nor does a legacy of prejudice adequately explain the heroism of the minority though it may well account for the apathy and quiescence of the majority. The fact is that all South African Jews benefited from apartheid and the majority tacitly supported it (while voting, in the main, against Afrikaner nationalism.) The South African Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBOD), which remains the representative body of South African Jewry to this day, was resolute in its refusal to condemn apartheid and it did nothing to support the families of community members who had been banned, jailed or exiled. The Boards first explicit condemnation of apartheid came in 1985, when South African racism was already on its last legs. Its not difficult to understand the stance of the SAJBOD, which accurately expressed the attitude of the community as a whole (excluding, of course, the many anti-apartheid activists.) By the early 1960s (the bulk of the Lithuanian immigration predated the Holocaust by several decades), most South African Jews were prosperous but insecure; the memories of the overt anti-Semitism that had characterized Afrikaner nationalism in the Thirties and much of the Forties were still vivid. At the same time, the community was passionately pro-Zionist (perhaps the most Zionist Jewish community in the diaspora), which both distanced the Jews from South African politics (their emotional involvement being with Israel) and inclined them favorably towards the regime when South Africa and Israel forged their military partnership in the Seventies. Thus, the attitude of the SAJBOD and much of the community was determined by three, interwoven factors: The economic success of the Jewish community in South Africa, the fear of anti-Semitism and the influence of Zionism. The Board saw its role as doing what was good for the Jews and, for much of the 20th century, apartheid was good for the Jews. Not for all of them, of course the Board was able to avert its collective eyes from those in jail, in exile or underground but for most. The example of the South African Jewish community does not support Mandelas assumption that being victims of prejudice in the past creates antibodies to prejudice in general. If anything, the opposite is true as we know well from our Israeli experience. Victimhood can just as easily desensitize as sensitize. The fear of reawakening the demons of the past can create its own horrors. At the very least, it can and does lead to a moral blindness. The South African Jewish community was prosperous but morally bankrupt. Those members of the community who fought against apartheid swam against the stream. They were motivated more by ideology (communism, socialism and Bundism) than they were by a legacy of prejudice and suffering. By the 1930s, Jewish laborers and artisans occupied leadership positions in the burgeoning South African trade union movement and the majority of the Jewish males who went on to oppose apartheid had joined the all-volunteer South African army to fight against fascism in World War II. My father, Jock Isacowitz, got his political toes wet as one of the founders of the Springbok Legion, an ex-servicemens organization that

FACEBO O K
ACTIV ITY
Recent Activity Ezyo Ezygual Quemasda recommends Bil'in protesters dismantle section of West Bank separation barrier
about 2 w eeks ago

RECOMMENDATIONS

Sylvia Posadas recommends Israel must facilitate travel for Palestinian players, says FIFA president - Sports .
about 3 w eeks ago

Joe Bauers recommends Israel Police losing public trust and support, U.S. study shows - National
about 3 w eeks ago

Sylvia Posadas recommends Mohammed ElBaradei named Egypt's interim prime minister - Middle East
F acebook . social plugin about a month ago

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.538830

2/4

31/07/2013

Mandela's Jewish comrades - Opinion - Israel News | Haaretz

fought for the rights of all former soldiers, irrespective of race. The Haskalah (Jewish Enlightenment), was strongly rooted in late 19th century Lithuania and its ideological offshoots, primarily socialism and Zionism, were imported ready-made into South Africa by the immigrants. These ideologies flourished in the African soil, resulting in a strong cadre of dedicated socialists, on the one hand, and a dynamic Zionist movement on the other. My father was one of the few who managed to combine the two. Arthur Goldreich, who fought with the Palmach in 1948 before returning to South Africa and joining the armed underground (he was the official lessee of Liliesleaf Farm) was another. But most of their colleagues regarded Zionism as a colonial enterprise. How sad that Israel should be following the blinkered and indifferent example of the South African Jewish community and proving their critics right. Roy Isacowitz is a writer and marketer living in Tel Aviv. He spent many years working for the Israeli and foreign media.

MORE FROM HAARETZ.COM


Why a 'Palest inian Gandhi' has never emerged - and probably never will
(Haaretz - New s)

FROM AROUND THE WEB


Why t here may not be peace in Israel
(The New Republic)

U.S. ult ra-Ort hodox group calls on Rabbi Sacks t o apologize for
(Haaretz - Jew ish World)

Promot ing peace in t he Middle East : The case of Orphaned Land. By


(The New Political Centre)

Wearing silver-laced kippah, new Dut ch king visit s Amst erdam Jews
(Haaretz - Jew ish World)

The Rise of t he Awesome Nerd


(The Financialist)

ADL defends Palest inianAmerican New Y ork Jet s lineman: Being


(Haaretz - New s)

7 ,000 Ort hodox Jews flee Rio de Janeiro Brazil aft er immodest women
(Your Jew ish New s)
Recommended by

COMMENTS
Name Subject Comment
Your comment here

By adding a comment i agree to this sites Terms of use

LATEST

MOST VIEWED

HIGHEST RATED

Open All
0 0

MANDELAS JEWISH COMRADES 02 By SELMA 31 Jul 2013 11:52AM

01

i?*
By sh 31 Jul 2013 08:36AM

NEWS: Diplomacy and Defense | National | World | Middle East | Features | Opinion | Israel weather | Maccabiah 2013 JEWISH WORLD: News | Rabbis' Round Table | The Jewish Thinker CULTURE: Books | Food and Wine | Arts & Leisure

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.538830

3/4

31/07/2013

Mandela's Jewish comrades - Opinion - Israel News | Haaretz


HAARETZ.COM BLOGS: A Special Place in Hell | West of Eden | Diplomania | Routine Emergencies | Eyes Wide Open | Jerusalem Vivendi The Axis | East Side Story | Strenger than Fiction | Modern Manna | The Fifth Question HAARETZ.CO.IL: | | | | | | | | |

FAQ | Contact us | Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Management | Editorial | Employment Opportunities | Advertise on Haaretz.com | Haaretz News Widget

Design by Roni Arie | Accelerated by cotendo Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora. Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd. All Rights Reserved

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.538830

4/4

Вам также может понравиться