05/08/2013

We cant lose a democracy we never had - Opinion - Israel News | Haaretz

SUBSCRIBE T O HAARET Z DIGIT AL EDIT IONS

Haaretz.com

TheMarker

TheMarker Caf
Hel l o kjh You hav e v iewed 0 of 1 0 articles. Monday, August 05, 2013 Av 29, 5773 Search Haaretz.com

ISRAEL MINT
Pr ofile Log ou t
su bscri be n ow

National

Soap opera at Safari over newborn elephant NEWS OPINION JEWISH WORLD BUSINESS

TRAVEL IN ISRAEL

CULTURE

WEEKEND BLOGS

ARCHAEOLOGY
Like 73k Follow

ISRAEL NEWS

Mideast peace process King Dav id's Tomb Israeli culture's top 1 00 Ethiopian Aliy ah BREAKING NEWS 8:24 PM Thirty killed in heavy fighting in Syrian mountains (Reuters)
Home Opinion

Word of the Day

More Breaking News

We cant lose a democracy we never had

The illusion of democracy in Israel is just one of the many illusions that we Israelis have been educated to believe.
By Tsafi Saar | Aug. 4, 2013 | 3:41 AM |
4 Tw eet 20

HAARETZ SELECT

6
Recommend Send Angela Godfrey-Goldstein, Raymond Deane and 94 others recommend this.

Cleopatra and Marc Antony, joined for eternity on a coin found in Israel
Found in an archaeological dig in Bethsaida, this rare bronze coin tells of lov e, trade ties and globe-shaking jealousies. And what if Marc Antony had won the war? By Miriam Feinberg Vamosh | Archaeology

A three-story approach to ending the Israeli-Palestinian conflict

By Avraham Burg | Opinion

T he big bang of Israeli self-parody

By Asher Schechter | Features

T he U.S.'s critical role in subduing Sinai threat to Israel

By Rupert Sutton | Opinion

An IDF soldier with Palestinians: Abrogating rights and freedom s.

Photo by Emil Salman

Many dirges have been heard lately lamenting the death of democracy on account of the governability law that passed its first reading in the Knesset this past week. There is reason to lament; it is indeed a bad and dangerous piece of legislation. But for something to die, it must have once lived. Has there been democracy in Israel before the governability was passed? The answer is no. For Israel's entire 65-year existence it has not been a democratic state. From its founding until 1966 Israel imposed martial law on the Arab communities in its territory. Since the occupation of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip in 1967 until today, Israel has ruled over millions of Palestinian inhabitants in these territories an occupied population with its basic freedoms and rights abrogated. There has been an illusion of democracy here, or alternatively, a democracy for Jews only. This of course is a contradiction in terms. This is just one of the many illusions, which we Israelis have been educated to believe. It isn't easy to discover how much of life and education here are full of indoctrination, because lightly scratching the surface reveals what is just a cover for an entirely different reality. Some of us discover this at an early age, others later. There are also those who will never discover this, perhaps they would even prefer not to see it. Among the prominent examples are myths like "making the desert bloom," or the statement, "A land without a people for a people without a land" - basic concepts in Zionism that express a worldview that ignored the land's inhabitants. There is "Hebrew labor," the aspiration that Jews who settled the land would work with their own hands instead of managing

Tex t size Comments (6) Print Page Send to friend Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share
THIS STORY IS BY

Analysis || Oops, Israelis went and changed, and started to notice things
People hav e lost their tolerance for being abused. Now they want a say in econom ic issues. By Eytan Avriel | Business | 7

At Ramallah's first youth hostel, backpackers find solace from politics

By Roy (Chicky) Arad | Features | 2

Tsafi Saar

RELATED TAGS Knesset opinion

T his day in Jewish history / Zeev Jabotinsky, Zionist visionary, dies

By David B. Green | This Day in Jew ish History

At Jerusalem gay parade, no pomp but plenty of pride

By Nadja Rumjanceva | Opinion

O PI NI O N
A three-story approach to ending the IsraeliPalestinian conflict
By Avraham Burg | 01:26 AM

T he U.S.'s critical role in subduing Sinai

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.539584

1/3

05/08/2013

We cant lose a democracy we never had - Opinion - Israel News | Haaretz

threat to Israel
By Rupert Sutton | 05:54 PM

others, which is perceived to be something positive until we understand that it means excluding native Arabs from work. Another phenomenon placed on a pedestal is the revival of the Hebrew language. While it was a blessed miracle, it also was enabled by the pushing aside of many other languages as well as other cultures, not infrequently with violence and this already sounds less heartwarming. There are also clichs like "our hand is outstretched in peace," as our politicians are wont to say while they are still polishing up ruins. In other versions, still in use today, there are mantras like "no partner for peace." And who can forget "the world's most moral army"? The same army that just recently detained a 5-year-old Palestinian child for investigation, and the state that plans to evict 1,300 Palestinians from their homes in the south Hebron hills to save time and resources, just to mention two examples among countless others. These are bothersome thoughts. Is it possible that everything we were raised on, or at least most of it, is mistaken? What is the significance of this? And does asking these questions undermine the fact of our existence of here? If our existence here must be based on a strong fist, on pushing out others, on nationalism, chauvinism and militarism, then the answer is yes. But is this really the case? In the history of Zionism there were other options besides that of BenGurion-style force. For example, the path shown by professors Zvi BenDor Benite and Moshe Behar in their recently published book "Modern Middle Eastern Jewish Thought: Writings on Identity, Politics, and Culture." Jewish intellectuals of Middle Eastern origin at the beginning of the 20th century warned against adopting a European arrogance to the land's inhabitants and called for respectful dialogue with them. But their words fell on deaf ears. The Brit Shalom faction of Hugo Bergmann and Gershom Scholem also proposed another way in the 1930s that was not accepted. The state established here was not, despite its pretensions, "the sole democracy in the Middle East." It appears that the first condition for really fixing this situation, if that is still possible, is the recognition that we did not lose democracy now. It never resided here.

At Jerusalem gay parade, no pom p but plenty of pride

By Nadja Rumjanceva | 11:28 AM

We cant lose a dem ocracy we nev er had

By Tsafi Saar | 03:41 AM | 6

MO RE FRO M THE WEB

HumaneWat ch | HSUS Doc Exposed as Schlock (Humane Watch) End Israel Apart heid advert isement s go up in New Y ork (Your Jewish News) How t o Get St art ed in Healt hcare (Straighter Line)
Recommended by

FACEBO O K
ACTIV ITY
Recent Activity Ezyo Ezygual Quemasda recommends Bil'in protesters dismantle section of West Bank separation barrier.
about 2 w eeks ago

RECOMMENDATIONS

Joe Bauers recommends Israel Police losing public trust and support, U.S. study shows - National.
about a month ago

MORE FROM HAARETZ.COM

Israel's new Jewish ident it y init iat ive based on fascist values
(Haaretz - New s)

FROM AROUND THE WEB

What Would George Orwell Say Today About t he Fut ure of Government ?
(Business Value Exchange)

Sylvia Posadas recommends Mohammed ElBaradei named Egypt's interim prime minister - Middle East.
about a month ago

Elena Libia recommends Israel's top defense establishment earners: Scientists at nuclear research sites - National.
about 2 months ago F acebook social plugin

A Palest inian village reaches t he end of t he road

(Weekend)

Turkey and Israel, St ill No Happy Ending

(World Politics Review )

What makes Jews so smart ?

(Weekend)

Promot ing peace in t he Middle East : The case of Orphaned Land. By

(The New Political Centre)

Look! An Arab speaking Hebrew

(Weekend)

The Window is Closing on Middle East Peace. Here's Why it Won't

(The New Republic)
Recommended by

COMMENTS
Name Subject Comment
Your comment here

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.539584

2/3

05/08/2013
By adding a comment i agree to this sites Terms of use

We cant lose a democracy we never had - Opinion - Israel News | Haaretz

LATEST

MOST VIEWED

HIGHEST RATED

Open All
6 8

Democracy 03 By Nils 04 Aug 2013

05:32PM

Gibberish 02 By C. Bendavid

4 04 Aug 2013 03:00PM

41

01

If Israel isn't a democracy , no count ry is a democracy .

By David Plane, Geneva, Sw itzerland 04 Aug 2013 11:51AM

30

y eah t hat s why y ou live in swit z

By lie to yourself much? 04 Aug 2013 01:15PM

28

Well, I've lived in Swit zerland for 49 y ears and I st ill don;t have t he right t o vot e.
By David Plane 04 Aug 2013 01:24PM

24

Different laws for different et hnicit ies and religion, mult i-t iered legal sy st em,
By Melissa 04 Aug 2013 02:39PM

35

NEWS: Diplomacy and Defense | National | World | Middle East | Features | Opinion | Israel weather | Maccabiah 2013 JEWISH WORLD: News | Rabbis' Round Table | The Jewish Thinker CULTURE: Books | Food and Wine | Arts & Leisure HAARETZ.COM BLOGS: A Special Place in Hell | West of Eden | Diplomania | Routine Emergencies | Eyes Wide Open | Jerusalem Vivendi The Axis | East Side Story | Strenger than Fiction | Modern Manna | The Fifth Question HAARETZ.CO.IL: | | | | | | | | | FAQ | Contact us | Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Management | Editorial | Employment Opportunities | Advertise on Haaretz.com | Haaretz News Widget

Design by Roni Arie | Accelerated by cotendo Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora. Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd. All Rights Reserved

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.539584

3/3