5/3/13

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran | Religion at the Margins

Home About Contributors Our Books Contact Us Discussion Decalogue

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran

By Thom Stark

According to the standard interpretation of surah 4:157-159 of the Quran, Jesus was not actually crucified and killed. One major interpretation says that another person was substituted for Jesus on the cross, and the Jews only thought they had successfully crucified Jesus. The passage reads thus: [The Jews said,] We have killed the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, the Messenger of God. (They did not kill him, nor did they crucify him, though it appeared like that to them; those that disagreed about him are full of doubt, with no knowledge to follow, only supposition: they certainly did not kill himGod raised him up to Himself. God is almighty and wise. There is not one of the People of the Book who will not believe in him before his death, and on the Day of Resurrection he will be a witness against them.) (4:157-159) There are, however, several problems with this interpretation, as many Islamic commentators have noted. Several early commentators, in fact, argued against the straightforward reading of the text, asserting that in fact Jesus was crucified as the injili (Gospels) record. One reason commentators offer in opposition to a straightforward reading of surah 4:157-159 is that other suwar indicate clearly that Jesus in fact died. For instance, surah 3:55: God said, Jesus, I will take you back [mutawaffika] and raise you up to Me: I will purify you of the disbelievers. To the Day of Resurrection I will make those who follow you superior to those who disbelieved. Then you will all return to Me and I will judge between you regarding your differences. In another surah, Jesus speaks to God, saying, I told them only what You commanded me to: Worship God, my Lord and your Lord. I was a witness over them during my time among them. Ever since You took my soul [mutawaffika], You alone have been the watcher over them: You are witness to all things (5:117). Both of these suwar speak of God taking Jesus. The word here (mutawaffika) occurs over 25 times in the Quran, and in each case refers to someones death. Especially instructive is its usage in 39:42: God takes [mutawaffika] the souls of the dead and the souls of the living while they sleepHe keeps hold of those whose death He has ordained and sends the others back until their appointed timethere truly are signs in this for those who reflect. If it isnt already clear enough, what this verse articulates is that God keeps in his possession the souls of the dead, as well as the souls of those who sleep. He holds the souls of those whose death he has ordained, but returns the souls of those who sleep each time they awaken. The last remark (there truly are signs in this for those who reflect) indicates that this is likely a metaphor for (or a microcosm of) death and resurrection. Thus, when Jesus states that God took his soul, he is speaking of his death.
religionatthemargins.com/2011/07/never-say-die-the-death-of-jesus-in-the-quran/ 1/9

5/3/13

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran | Religion at the Margins

The same idea is expressed in surah 19:33, in which an infant Jesus speaks to Marys slanderers: Peace was on me the day I was born, and will be on me the day I die and the day I am raised to life again. Earlier in the same surah, the same language is used with respect to the executed John the Baptist: Peace was on him the day he was born, the day he died, and it will be on him the day he is raised to life again (19:15). Thus, here Jesus speaks of his death as yet to be fulfilled, whereas in 5:117 Jesus speaks of his death as an event in the past. Therefore, it is clear that a straightforward reading of 4:157-159 would be at odds with numerous other passages throughout the Quran which speak of Jesus death. Perhaps a genuine contradiction exists, although given the singular authorship of the Quran, this would be unlikely. How then should we interpret surah 4:157-159? Lets look at it again: [The Jews said,] We have killed the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, the Messenger of God. (They did not kill him, nor did they crucify him, though it appeared like that to them; those that disagreed about him are full of doubt, with no knowledge to follow, only supposition: they certainly did not kill himGod raised him up to Himself. God is almighty and wise. There is not one of the People of the Book who will not believe in him before his death, and on the Day of Resurrection he will be a witness against them.) Many have argued that the reason Jesus is said not to have been killed here is because God would not permit a prophet as holy as Jesus to suffer such an ignoble death. But Islamic scholar Mahmoud Ayoub decisively refutes this argument, pointing to numerous prophets identified in the Quran who suffer for the sake of Gods cause. Ayoub then offers this interpretation of the above passage. In light of the fact that the Quran has no reason to deny that a good prophet could suffer for God, Ayoub asks, Why then . . . does the Quran deny the crucifixion of Christ in the face of apparently overwhelming evidence? Muslim commentators were not capable of refuting the crucifixion convincingly. . . . Commentators have taken the verse as a historical statement. However, this statement, like all the other statements about Jesus in the Quran, does not belong to history, but to theology in the broadest sense. . . . The reproach of the Jews, for their saying: We have surely killed Jesus the Christ, son of Mary, the apostle of God, with which the verse starts, is not directed at the telling of an historical lie, or at the making of a false report. It is rather, as is clear from the context, directed at human arrogance and folly, at an attitude towards God and His messenger. The words identifying Jesus are especially significant. They wished to kill Jesus, the innocent man, who is also the Christ, the Word, and Gods representative among them. By identifying Christ in this context, the Quran is addressing not only the people who could have killed yet another prophet, but all of humanity is told who Jesus is. The Quran is not speaking about a man, righteous and wronged though he may be, but about the Word of God who was sent to earth and who returned to God. Thus the denial of the killing of Jesus is a denial of the power of men to vanquish and destroy the divine Word, which is forever victorious. Hence the words, they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him, go far deeper than the events of ephemeral human history; they penetrate the heart and conscience of human beings. The claim of humanity (here exemplified in the Jewish society of Christs earthly existence) to have this power against God can only be an illusion. They did not slay him . . . but it seemed so to them. They only imagined doing so. The words, wa lkin shubbiha lahum do not disclose, therefore, a long-hidden secret of divine deception; rather they constitute an accusation or judgment against the human sin of pride and ignorance. They are explained further in what follows: those who have disagreed about Christ are surely in doubt concerning the truth. They have no knowledge; they follow only conjecture, the foolish imaginings of their minds. What is the truth? It is, I think, the affirmation, once again, that God is greater than human powers and empty schemes: They did not kill him, [that is, Jesus the Christ and Gods Apostle] with certainty, rather God took him up to Himself, and God is mighty, and wise. Again, human ignorance, delusion and conjecture are all identified as a lack of certainty or firm faith. In the phrase, and God is mighty and Wise, these human limitations are contrasted with divine power and infinite wisdom.1 This reading of 4:157-159 certainly resolves the tension with the other passages which state clearly that Jesus was subject to death. But perhaps some will think Ayoubs reading fanciful. On what grounds does Ayoub take the recourse to metaphor here? Although Ayoub himself does not make this argument, I would offer another passage from the Quran which would reinforce Ayoubs reading of the passage in question. This other passage is from the second surah, and thus appears in the Quran prior to the statement that Jesus did not die: Do not say that those who are killed in Gods cause are dead; they are alive, though you do not realize it. (2:154) I would argue that this verse should function as a hermeneutical key to 4:157-159. God expressly tells the Prophet not to say that martyrs killed for Gods cause are dead. Why? Because despite their death, they continue to live in Gods care. Then, just two suwar later, the Prophet denies that Jesus was truly killed. Note the similarity: they are alive; though you do not realize it and they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him, though it appeared like that to them. I would argue, therefore, that 4:157-159 is simply putting into practice the instruction given in 2:154 about how to speak of those who have died for Gods cause. To deny that Jesus was crucified and killed is not to deny the historical event, but to deny its finality, as well as to deny the significance that Jesus executioners ascribed to the event. This does not, however, solve the problem fully. There remains the question of the interpretation of 4:159: There is not one of the
religionatthemargins.com/2011/07/never-say-die-the-death-of-jesus-in-the-quran/ 2/9

5/3/13

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran | Religion at the Margins

People of the Book who will not believe in him before his death, and on the Day of Resurrection he will be a witness against them.) The translation of this verse is very difficult; there are a number of ambiguities. First, the People of the Book can refer to Jews and Christians (and others with their own scriptures) as a collective, but here it is unlikely that it refers to all people of any book. The immediate context refers only to the Jews, thus I would argue that People of the Book in this case is restricted to Jews. Second, the above translation says, who will not believe in him before his death. But the prepositional phrase here can be translated either in him or in it. So either its talking about belief in Jesus (and his message), or belief in the fact that he was killed. This drastically affects the meaning of the verse. Third, it is not clear what the antecedent to his is meant to be in before his death. Is this referring to the death of Jesus? Or is it referring to the death of the one who will believe (either in him or in it)? This is unclear. Fourth, again, who is the he who will be a witness on the Day of Resurrection? Moreover, who is the them against whom the he will be a witness? The standard reading is that Jesus will be a witness against all the People of the Book. This is possible. But if they came to believe in him, then why would he be a witness against them? This would work if they came to believe in it (i.e., his death). Thus his witness against them at the resurrection would be that he is alive in God. So, the verse could mean, There is not one of the Jews who will not believe that Jesus died before he [the Jew] dies, and on the Day of Resurrection, Jesus will witness against them in this false belief. But this seems very strange. Another possible reading is that each Jew will come to believe in Jesus before s/he dies, and that Jew will be a witness against those who executed Jesus (them being Jesus executioners and those who rejected him in his own day, not the People of the Book in general). This may seem like a bold claimthat every Jew will come to believe in Jesus message, but if Im not mistaken, the Apostle Paul made rather a similar claim (Rom 11:26). So perhaps its not so farfetched for the Quran to hold this view. Whatever we do with this particular verse (the ambiguities are too many to solve the question definitively), these two facts remain: the Quran states that a righteous martyr is not to be spoken of as having been killed; the Quran speaks of Jesus death in indirect (yet clear) ways in numerous other suwar. These two facts mitigate against a straightforward reading of 4:157-159, which leaves us to conclude that the Quran states (1) that Jesus died a martyrs death for Gods cause; (2) that, nevertheless, his death was not final, and (3) that it did not have the significance Jesus executioners wished to ascribe to it.
1. Mahmoud Ayoub, Towards an Islamic Christology, II: The Death of Jesus, Reality or Delusion (A Study of the Death of Jesus in Tafsir Literature), The Muslim World 70/2 (April 1980), 116-17. [BACK]

This post was written by

Thom Stark who has written 99 posts on Religion at the Margins. Thom Stark is the writer/director of several films, including Who Art in Heaven, Revolution, Dear Whiskey, and the award-winning Note to Self. He is the author of The Human Faces of God: What Scripture Reveals When It Gets God Wrong (and Why Inerrancy Tries To Hide It). Thom was a Fig Tree and Ledbetter scholar at Emmanuel School of Religion, A Graduate Seminary. Thom has lectured on Second Temple Jewish apocalypticism, Christian origins, the Parables of Jesus, and early Christological controversies. He has also been the recipient of numerous lectures on tact. Send an Email

31 31 31 31 11 Like 31 31 31 Subscribe 31 to this author's posts feed. This entry was posted on July 20, 2011 at 2:11 PM and is filed under Religion. 31
religionatthemargins.com/2011/07/never-say-die-the-death-of-jesus-in-the-quran/ 3/9

5/3/13

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran | Religion at the Margins
0

10 comments Leave a message...

Share
2 years ago

Oldest

Community Daniel K aris t ai

Interesting article. I remember having a lively conversation with a local Imam back in California over the death of Jesus and his position was something similar to the one you're refuting here. He said the Quran taught that God made it look like Jesus died but in reality Jesus didn't. It was a strange form of docetism. I have a tangental question about the Quran in general. You wrote, "Perhaps a genuine contradiction exists, although given the singular authorship of the Quran, this would be unlikely." Why does the singularity of authorship make contradiction unlikely?
Reply Thom S t ark
Mod

Share
2 years ago

Yes, the position I'm arguing against is by far the most accepted view. That God made it look like Jesus died is the standard interpretation. Because it's far less likely that someone would contradict him or herself (especially on the question of whether or not Jesus died!), than it is that two different authors would have contradictory views.
Reply Felipe Ramos Share
2 years ago

Hello Thom, I want to check you about Mutawaffika(or mutawaffeeka). I did see it in 3:55. Although, I did not see the two words, which is portray Mutawaffika(or Mutawaffeeka), in 5:117 and 39:42. I give you an Islamic website link for translation, arabic language, roman transliteration 5:117- http://www.islamawakened.com/q... 39:42 - http://www.islamawakened.com/q... Please give me your feedback.. Thank you Jesus bless you
Reply Thom S t ark
Mod

Share
2 years ago

The word appears in both passages in different forms: tawaffaytanee and yatawaffa respectively. The root, tawaffa, carries different prefixes and suffixes according to its tense, subject, gender, etc.
Reply Felipe Ramos Share
2 years ago

Wow, Arabic language must be complex than what I think. I am curious, are you know Arabic language very well? have you read all collections of Hadith? One more thing... thank you for respond me ! Jesus bless you
Reply Marc Share

2 years ago

I think you're point about Islamic evidence for Jesus dying is moot: of course he died according to Muslims, just not on the cross.
Reply Thom S t ark
Mod

Share
2 years ago

Actually, Marc, that's incorrect. The standard Islamic tradition is that Jesus did not die at all, but was translated to heaven, where he remains alive to this day. But some early Muslim commentators pointed to the verses I have pointed to here and noted that they stand in contradiction to those who claim Jesus did not die.
Reply Felipe Ramos Reply Share
2 years ago

Hey, You cant mind I can show this article to my Muslim friends ??
Share
Mod

Thom S t ark

Felipe Ramos 2 years ago

Of course. It's on the internet after all. Obviously I don't know your friends, but statistically it's doubtful they'll respond very religionatthemargins.com/2011/07/never-say-die-the-death-of-jesus-in-the-quran/

4/9

5/3/13

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran | Religion at the Margins Of course. It's on the internet after all. Obviously I don't know your friends, but statistically it's doubtful they'll respond very positively. Most Muslims accept the later ahadith as authoritative interpretations of Qur'an, thus rendering my arguments here irrelevant.
Reply Mus
a year ago

Share

Great article! However, what about the "Swoon theory? There are many Muslims that believe that Jesus was nailed to the cross but that he did not die, but rather passed out. Joseph of Arimathea removed his body from the cross, the roman soldiers thinking that he was dead, and some time later, he recovered (3 days and 3 nights if you like), hence the belief in the resurrection. This would be compatible with the quranic passage that he was not crucified
Reply Share

C o m m e n t fe e d

Su b s cri b e vi a e m a i l

Search & Hit Enter

Archives
Select Month

Recent Posts
Who Art in Heaven To Win Award at 46th WorldFest-Houston Transdimensional Autophilic Middle-Aged College Professors for Marriage Equality A Revolution at WorldFest-Houston Chris Rollston Secures Visiting Professorship at George Washington University Dr. Kyle McCarter Speaks Out for Dr. Rollston Dr. Athalya Brenner Lends Her Support to Christopher Rollston God is Transgendered (And So Can You!) Paul Ryan, Thomas Aquinas, Ayn Rand, and Honey Boo Boo An Unauthorized Official Statement from President Michael Sweeney of Emmanuel Christian Seminary Regarding Dr. Christopher Rollston Letters to Emmanuel from the Students of Christopher Rollston An Open Letter From a Student in Support of Dr. Rollston The Money and The Master: Rollston, Sweeney, Blowers, Weedman Nathaniel E. Greene Responds to Paul Blowers' Newest Attack on Chris Rollston Paul Blowers Shovels More Nonsense at the Feet of a Straw Man Christopher Rollston
religionatthemargins.com/2011/07/never-say-die-the-death-of-jesus-in-the-quran/ 5/9

5/3/13

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran | Religion at the Margins

Rollston Roundup: Open Letters to Emmanuel, etc. (Updated) Obama: The Most Partisan President in U.S. History The Affair of Dr. Blowers and the Blog of the Three Young Men: A Response to Christopher Rollstons Cultured Despisers The Last Temptation: "Muslim Rage," Cultural Amnesia, and Christian Hypocrisy I Walk the Line Ecce Homo?

Recent Comments
Cat
March 29, 2013 (6:36) God is Transgendered (And So Can You!) Hope I wasn't too rude with my initial post! I don't believe in the gender binary per se. Its pr...

Anonymous
March 29, 2013 (3:52) God is Transgendered (And So Can You!) Also, in this essay, when i critique the binary I am mainly critiquing the binary of gender norms...

Anonymous
March 29, 2013 (3:40) God is Transgendered (And So Can You!) First off, my aim was not to apropriate anything. Only to listen to the many voices of different ...

Cat
March 29, 2013 (12:32) God is Transgendered (And So Can You!) As a transsexual woman I think i can say pretty confidently that you are misappropriating our exp...

mountainguy
March 23, 2013 (11:18) the (non)violence of holy week 2 years later, and still loving it. Thanks David!

Subscribe to Email Notifications

Enter your email address:

Subscribe

Followers (222)

Follow this blog

religionatthemargins.com/2011/07/never-say-die-the-death-of-jesus-in-the-quran/

6/9

5/3/13

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran | Religion at the Margins

Religion at the Margins

Like 362 people like Religion at the Margins.

F acebook social plugin

Who Art in Heaven

Like 70 people like Who Art in Heaven.

Revolution - a film by Thom Stark

Like 67 people like Revolution - a film by Thom Stark.

Note to Self
Like 110 people like Note to Self.

F acebook social plugin

The Human Faces of God

Like 309 people like The Human Faces of God.

F acebook social plugin

Thom Stark
Like 401 people like Thom Stark.

F acebook social plugin

religionatthemargins.com/2011/07/never-say-die-the-death-of-jesus-in-the-quran/

7/9

5/3/13
Crystal S. Lewis
Like 449 people like Crystal S. Lewis.

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran | Religion at the Margins

F acebook social plugin

Who Art in Heaven To Win Award at 46th WorldFest-Houston

Transdimensional Autophilic MiddleAged College Professors for Marriage Equality

A Revolution at WorldFest-Houston

Chris Rollston Secures Visiting Professorship at George Washington University

religionatthemargins.com/2011/07/never-say-die-the-death-of-jesus-in-the-quran/

8/9

5/3/13

Never Say Die: The Death of Jesus in the Quran | Religion at the Margins

Dr. Kyle McCarter Speaks Out for Dr. Rollston

Marginally Significant Other Websites

Back Forward

Login | Logout Copyright 2011 Religion at the Margins. All Rights Reserved.

religionatthemargins.com/2011/07/never-say-die-the-death-of-jesus-in-the-quran/

9/9