Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Gud mundsson, A., Fjeldskaar, I. & Gjesdal, O. 2002: Fract ure-generated permeability and groundwate r yield in
Norway. Norges qeoloqiske undersoke/se Bulle tin 439 , 6 1-69.
The t ranspor t of groundwat er in bedrock is largely determined by interconnected fractu res and t heir apert ures.The
condit ions by w hich fract ures become interconnected are t hus of primary import ance in underst andi ng permeabil-
ity and groundwater yield. This applies in part icular to t he observed linear correlatio n betwee n th e current post-
glacial up lift rate and groundwater yield in th e bedrock of sout hern Norway.We present bound ary-element models
on t he form ation of interconnected fractur e pat hways w ith applicat ion to the coast al areas of West Norway. In t he
mod els, we useexte rnal tensile st ressand internal fluid overpressure; loading cond it ions th at are likely to have been
operative in large part s of Nor way duri ng t he Holocene.The ext ernal tensile st ress result s ind icate t hat many frac-
t ure pat hways form by t he linkin g up of offset j oint s t hro ugh t ransverse shear fract ures. Ot her pathways, however,
are fo rmed by linking up of j oints and contacts t hro ug h te nsile stresses associated w it h t he t ips of propagating
hydrofractures. How th e fractu re pat hways fo rm may affect t he subsequent permeability. In part icular, t ransverse
shear fractu res are likely to have relati vely small apert ures and limit t he grou ndwater t ransport.
Agust Gudm undsson, Ingrid Fje/dskaar & Otilie Gjesda/. Geolog ica/ lnstitu te, University of Berqen, Allegoten 41, N-5007
Berqen, Nor way (e-m ail: ag ust.g udm undsson@geol.uib.no)
Extension fractures
Ext ension fractures (Fig. 2) are either tension fractures or
Fig. 2. Linking up of exten sion fractures in gnei ss on th e island of
hydrofra ctures. Tension fractures form when the minimum
0ygarden (Toft ey). View northea st; t he fracture apertu re tends to
increase when meeting w it h the hori zontal exfoliation fractur es, at the principal compressive stress (considered posit ive) is nega-
contacts wi t h the dark amph ibolite layers.The steel tape is 1 m long . tive, that is, when there is an absolute tension in the crust.
A G US T GUD MUN D SSO N, /NGRID FJ ELDSKAAR & O T/LlE GJESDAL NGU -BULL 439, 2002 - PAG E 63
They are mo stly limited to areas und ergoing acti ve exte n- In contrast to tension fractures, hydrofractures can occur
sion, such as areas of rifti ng and t hose of great postg lacial at any crusta l depth. Hyd rofractu res are opened up by a flu id
upl ift such as in t he central part of Fenno scandia (M6rner pre ssure tha t is g reate r t han t he normal stress on the frac-
1980, Gudmund sson 1999).The maximu m depth to w hich a ture plane . Mo st hyd rof ract ures are extension fract ures
tension fracture can propagate a.: from the surface (before (Gudm undsson et al. 2001), in w hich case the norma l stress
it chang es into a norm al fault) is giv en by (Gudm undsson on t he hydrofracture plane is th e min imum principal com-
1992, 1999):
dm" -R
- p,g (1)
Pr"'O", + To (2)
wh ere P, is th e t otal fluid pressure, 0", is th e minimu m corn-
pressive princi pal stress (normal to the hydrofracture),and To
is th e in situ tensile streng t h of the host rock .
Because hydr ofractures can form at any crustal depth,
t hey are likely to be generally mo re im por tan t for t he devel -
opment of fracture pathways and permeability in rocks than
ten sion fract ures. For examp le, many joi nts (Figs. 2, 4) may
form as hydrofractu res w here the fluid disappears subse-
quent to the joint for mation. In genera l, where groundwater
or gas is th e fluid that dri ves a fracture ope n, it is difficu lt to
confi rm that t he fract ure was generate d by a fl uid. Oth er
fractures, however, are generated by flui ds or magma t hat
freeze in t he fracture subseque nt to its formation . Well
kno wn exam p les are dy kes, sills, inclined sheets and mineral-
filled veins. Com monly, mineral veins form net works of
ext inct geot hermal system s that provide important infor-
mat ion on permeabi lity gene ratio n t hroug h th eir em place-
ment (Gudm undsson et al. 2001). Some veins may reach
leng th s of several hund red metres, bu t most have lengths of
several met res or less (Gudmu ndsson et al. 2001L and are
thu s individually too small to have much effe ct on ground-
water flow.
Thick sil ls can have considera ble effects on groundwa te r
flow, bu t generally t he most important 'f rozen' hydrofrac-
t ures for groundwater flow are regional dykes (Fig. 5). In
Norway, dyk es are co mmo n along th e west coast and in the Fig.6 . Ext ension fractur es link ed up through transverse shear fractures,
Oslo reg ion (Thon 1985, Sundvoll & Larsen 1993, Torsvik et modelled in Figs. 7-8.View NNE; the lengt h of the steel tap e is 0.8 m.
al. 1997, Fossen & Dunlap 1999). Many dykes are of dense
basalt or dolerite wi t h low matrix permeability and act as In lateral sect ions (Fig. 6), shear fractures (and exte nsion
barr iers to t ransverse flow of groundwater. Ot hers, par ticu - fractures ) normally grow by th e linki ng up of gradua lly
larly thick and fractured dykes, may be sources of ground wa- larger segm ents. These segm ent s may init ially be offs et
te r (Sing hal & Gupta 1999). jo ints form ed early in the evolu ti on of th e ho st rock.
Perhaps th e most important effect of dykes on gro und- Alternat ively, lat er-formed tecton ic fractu res may propagat e
water flow in Norway, however, is that the basalt ic dyke rock and link up into larger, segme nte d fract ures (Fig. 6). ln do ing
has nor mally very different mechanica l properties fro m it s so, they form an int erco nnecte d system of fractu res or seg-
host rock (Fig. 5). It fo llo ws t hat stresses tend to conce ntrate ment s that has th e potent ial of conducting g roundwater
at t he con tact between the dy ke rock and the host rock and along its entire leng t h.
generate fract ures th at may conduct groundwater. Dyke s The linking up of small-scale j oi nt s and fract ures into
form th eir pathways in a similar way to t hat in th e mo de ls of larger shear fractures or fractu re systems is,in detai l, a com -
hydrof ract ure formation belo w. It follows that groundwater ple x process th at is sti ll only part ly un derstoo d (Cox & Scho lz
condu it s at con tacts between dyke rock and host rock wi ll 1988, Gudmundsson 1992, Acocella et al. 2000, Mansfi eld &
foll ow th ese same path ways. Cartwrig ht 2001). This process, however, largel y controls
w het her or not th e perco lat ion threshold of a fract ure sys-
Fault s tem is reached and, thereby, th e bed rock perme abilit y. Some
Fault s may in itiate as small-scale shear fractu res (Fig. 3) or, ge neral aspects of linking up of fractures into segmented
perhaps more commo nly, develop during the linking up of extension fractu res and shear fractu res are illustrate d by t he
small fract ures of various types (Fig. 6). In vertical sections, fo llo w ing nu mer ical models.
shear fractures (like tension fractures ) norma lly have diffi-
culty in prop agat ing t hrou g h horizontal discontinuities such Num erical models of fracture growth
as open exfol iation fractures (Fig. 3). At such discontinu it ies, All the models are made using t he bound ary-elem ent pro -
a shear f ract ure may eit her becom e offset or arrested. gram BEASY (1991Lth e method being descr ibed in deta il by
AGUS T G U DM U N DSSON, ING RID FJEL D SKA A R & O T/ LlE GJ ESDA L N GU - BULL 439, 2002 - PA GE 65
Surface
Tension fractures
/ \'"
Fig. 9. Boundary-element mode l show ing how the ten sile st ress, in
mega-pascals, around the t ip of a vertical hydrofractu re opens up vert i- Fig. 10. Same model as in Fig. 9,except t hat a third jo int has been add ed
cal jo ints and a weak contact int o te nsion fract ures. Figs.8-12 show only (in the centre) and the weak contact is here tw ice as long as in th e pre-
tensile st ressesin th e range 1.5-10 MPa. vious (Fig. 9) mode l.
rat io of 0.25 is used and , for the first t wo models (Figs. 9-10), modulus of 5 GPa, is embedded in a layer A of 10 GPa, bo th
also a uniform Young's mo dulus of 10 GPa. In t he t hird and of w hich have a Poisson 's rat io of 0.25.There are two ver t ical
fourth models (Figs.11-12), ho w ever, th ere is a softe r layer of discon tinuit ies, each of lengt h 0.4 uni ts and present ed by
5 GPa embedded in th e stiffer layer of 10 GPa, rep resenti ng in terna l spring s of st iff ness 6 MPa/ m th at reach th e surface.
layering wi t hi n th e gneiss (Figs. 1-3).As before, the joi nt s and Fig. 11 show s tha t, even if t he diff erence in st iffn ess bet wee n
horizontal contacts in the roc k are m od elled as int ern al
spring s wit h a stiffness of 6 MPa/ m. Here, this stiffness may Surface
be ta ken as representative of a soft, but elastic , infil l in a joint
and a w eak sed imentary or soil material at a con tact. For A
comparison, sma ll-scale laborato ry samples of clay and
w eak mudsto ne have Young 's modu li so low as 3 MPa (Bell
2000). Nearly ide nt ical result s w ere obta ined in m odel run s ension fractu res
w here th e con tacts and joints w ere op en (em pt y) and th us B
wi t h zero material stiffness.
In th e fir st mod el (Fig. 9), a hydrofractu re t ip at a depth of
0.5 units belo w the surfac e approaches th ree discontinu -
iti es, presented by t wo vertical j oi nts and a hori zon tal con- A
tact, each w it h a length of 0.2 uni ts. Thi s m od el reflects, for
examp le, the mech anical effec t s of a verti cal hyd rofractu re
appro aching the sur face in Fig. 4. All th e th ree discontin u-
iti es ope n up, and t ensile stresses con cent rate around the
t ip s of th e cont act and th e low er t ip s of t he j oin ts. These
stress conc entrations indicate a tend enc y fo r th e j oint s and
t he con t act to link up, as is seen in the next model (Fig. 10).
w here a new centra l joint has also been added .The cont act
has the greatest open ing , followed by t hat of th e central
joint (Fig. 10) and, t hen, the joints to each side. All j oi nts have Fig. 11. Boundary-element model showing how the tensile stress, in
th e greates t open ing s in th eir deep er part s. mega -pascals, around the tip of a vert ical hydrofracture open s up verti -
cal joints into tension fractures.The joi nts are located in a soh layer B
The next t wo models (Figs. 11-12) show t he effects of
(Young's mod ulus 5 GPa) embedded in a stiffer layer A (Young's modu -
m echanical layering on discont in uiti es ope ni ng ahead of a lus 10 GPa). The soh layer reduce s the ten sile st resses associated wi t h
prop agat ing hydro fract ure. A soh layer B, w it h a Young 's the hydrofracture tip.
AGUS T GUDMUNDSSON, I NG RID FJELDSKAAR & O T/Ll E GJESDA L NGU - BULL 439 , 2002 - PAGE 67
urface
on where the margin of th e up lifted crustal plate is taken to
be (Gud mundsson 1999).Thus,th e present -day st ressfiel d in
A
Norway de pends on its late-glacial hist ory.
There is considerable evidence that th e w hole of Norw ay
became degl aciated during th e period from 8000 to 12,000
B.P. The deglaciation began in the coastal areas (Mangerud
1991, Sejrup et al. 2000) and continued to th e highl and s
w here it was essentially complete some 8000 years ago
(Mangerud 1991, Nesje & Dahl 2002). In West Norway, the
postg lacial stre ss field generated neote ct onic activity
(Anundsen et al. 2002, Helle et al. 2000). The best docu-
Hydrofracture ~ ment ed neotectonic activity in Norwa y, howev er, is from th e
Lapland prov ince in the far no rth w here several reverse and
normal faults have been active in t he Holocene, some up to
the present (Olesen 1992, Dehls et al. 2000), and give n rise t o
hyd rological changes (Olesen et al. 2000).
During deg laciation in the coastal areas, tem porary t en-
sile stresses may have followed the ini tial comp ressive
st resses associated with t he formation of the ho rizontal
exfo liat ion fractu res (Fig. 1). Because rocks are much weaker
Fig. 12. Same model as in Fig . 11 except th at t he t ip of th e hydrofra ctur e
here meets wit h th e bott om of th e soft layer B.
in tension than in compre ssion, the linking up of existing
joints and fracture s subject t o suita bly orient ed t ensile
stresses (Figs. 7, 8) is muc h more likely than for an equally
large compressive stress. Extensi on is still occur ring in some
layers A and B is only by a factor of 2, th e tensile st ress coasta l parts of West Norway (Hicks et al. 2000). Postglacial
related to th e hydrofracture is much di min ished in th e soft tensile stresses at shallo w crustal depth s are thus likely to
layer. There is a small ope ning of the vertical joints in t heir have been common, th ereby support ing the use of t ensile
deepest parts wh ile the near-surface part s remain closed. loading in some of th e nu merical models (Figs.7, 8).
When, however, the hydrofractur e has propagated an The ot her nu merical models use internal fluid overpres-
additiona l 0.1 unit towards th e surface,th at is, to the bottom sure as th e only loadin g mechan ism (Figs. 9-12).This t ype of
of the soft layer B, th ere is considerable ope ning of t he loading emphasi ses the basic conditio ns for t he propaga-
joints, the maximum being at the free surface (Fig. 12).Thus, tion of vertical hydrofra ctu res.The models in Figs. 9-12 also
for th e given loading conditions, when th e hydrofractur e is indica te th at at least some of the horizontal exfoliation frac-
at 0.4 units below th e free surface,th e geomet ry of th e verti- tures (Figs. 1-3) may have opened up dur ing flow of an over-
cal discontinuities changes from th e maxi mum opening pressured groundwater associated wit h t he hyd rof ract ure
being in their deepest parts to its being at the surface. The propagation. Similar suggestions have been made for hori -
apertu re of an extension fract ure com monly becomes much zontal fractures in Sweden, some of w hich are thoug ht to be
larger at a free surface, or at an op en, sliding di scontinuity, partl y generated by flu id overpr essure beneath the retreat-
because of th e lack of elastic constraint (Fig. 2). ing ice front during deglac iation (Talbot 1999).