Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
Transitioning from pre-service preparation to full time work as a classroom teacher presents
whether one is working in an urban, suburban or rural context or something in between, the sense
of responsibility and feelings of isolation and self-doubt can be overwhelming. New teachers are
often assigned to more challenging classes avoided by experienced teachers with seniority
privileges. Furthermore, the working conditions in schools can lack collegiality and thus seem
The frustration experienced by new teachers is a primary cause of the current teacher
retention crisis. The teacher retention crisis is not, as is often believed, primarily due to high rates
those schools categorized as lowest performing. Recent studies suggest that it is our apparent
inability to retain the most credentialed teachers in our lowest performing schools that has
fueled the crisis. According to a November 2008 report of the State Educational Technology
Directors Association (SETDA), teacher turnover in public schools nationwide costs taxpayers
$7.3 billion annually, as 40 to 50 percent of new teachers leave the profession within five years.
New York City public schools alone lose about $115 million each year to teacher turnover
(CPRE, 2007).
Teachers who leave cite serious problems with the instructional, collegial and systemic
conditions of their working environment (Futernick, 2007). Schools serving low-income student
populations are worse at providing new teachers with mentoring and support. It makes sense that
schools with fewer resources in general would also tend to have fewer resources in particular to
support the mentoring needs of new teachers. Schools with more resources also tend to present
less frustrating working conditions that mitigate the threat of attrition to some extent. This
2
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
“support gap” suffered by new teachers in high poverty schools is linked to lower measures of
job satisfaction in the short term and higher rates of new teacher attrition (Johnson, Kardos,
multi-site network, can staunch attrition to half of what it would be otherwise (Ingersoll &
Kralik, 2004). When schools commit to providing high quality comprehensive induction to new
teachers, the investment pays off, literally; for every $1 invested, schools see a payoff of $1.66
over a five year period. (Villar & Strong, 2007). However, only one percent of teachers
nationwide have access to a comprehensive induction program of the scope outlined above
(Smith & Ingersoll, 2004). Furthermore, few states provide fully funded mandated induction
programs, in large part because induction has historically been regarded as a district or school
The task facing stakeholders, particularly state departments of education, local school
districts, and university teacher education programs, is to develop innovative and paradigm-
bending systems and structures that support new teachers as they make the difficult transition
from the pre-service preparation program into full-time positions as classroom teachers across a
The existing structures that define the work that takes place in schools are relics of a
nineteenth century factory model of teaching and learning. These structures are predicated on the
approaches to employee management, and behaviorist learning theory - conditions that no longer
3
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
reflect the context and mission of our educational system. What is more, one third of the current
teacher workforce are members of the Baby Boom generation. The impending retirement of this
generation of teachers will necessitate fundamental changes in how teachers’ roles are
conceptualized inside schools if schools hope to attract and retain new teachers of the Millennial
generation (Carroll, 2009, p. 46). Coinciding with the demographic shift within the teacher
workforce is a similarly dramatic demographic shift in the student population, already underway
and already challenging previously dominant school practices premised on the notion that
teachers can address the learning needs of all students using the same strategies (Darling-
Schools, Carroll argues, must adapt to their new role as twenty-first century learning
organizations. But new teachers today are entering schools where, by in large, they will work
not just the next classroom over. Although earlier generations of teachers reported finding
independence and freedom in working alone, the majority of teachers today now are looking for
more collaborative work environments. Lortie’s (1975) landmark sociological study of teachers
reveals that in the past teachers expressed a strong preference for solitary labor performed in the
privacy of their classroom, but teachers today articulate a growing interest in workplace
experiences for students, teachers themselves still enjoy precious few opportunities to work
collaboratively and engage in generative thinking and agentive action (Johnson, Berg &
Donaldson, 2005).
4
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
According to Behrstock and Clifford (2009), the private sector excels at creating
opportunities for newer employees to learn the skills of the trade by working in teams with
colleagues at all different levels of the organization. While the prospect of a teaching career
appeals to many talented young people, particularly since the collapse of the financial sector,
teachers’ working environment leaves much to be desired from the perspective of Generation Y,
also known as the Millennials. New teachers certainly do not expect schools to remodel
themselves after dot com startups, but they are interested in working in organizations that value
their potential contributions and find ways of breaking through traditional hierarchies.
This is, at a certain level, all about control. It is part of reconstituting teaching as a clinical
practice profession in which teachers themselves enjoy a measure of control, and the respect
such control implies, over their work. Online communities are one way of enabling teachers to
exercise agency and to define for themselves the support they need to do their jobs effectively.
The Carnegie Corporation of New York has been the primary proponent of the idea of
teaching as a clinical practice profession through its Teachers for a New Era initiative. This
reform initiative seeks deep and fundamental change in the organization of teacher education
programs, including such areas as “allocation of resources, academic organization, criteria for
practicing schools” (TNE Prospectus, 2001). Carnegie works with selected colleges and
programs can then serve as models going forward to other institutions of higher education that
want to develop state-of-the-art teacher education programs for the standard primary route to
5
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
To speak of teaching as clinical practice “extends the conversation about the teaching
profession beyond institutions of higher education to a wider policy and practice audience”
(Alter & Coggshall, 2009, p. 2). It is a way of characterizing the nature of teachers’ work in the
classroom by referencing other broad types of work that one might engage in. For example, we
customarily categorize occupations into crafts and professions. Crafts are occupations like
plumbing or woodworking in which the majority of training occurs on the job, through practice.
Professions, such as law or architecture, on the other hand, are occupations that require a
substantial course of study before professional practice begins. But the craft-profession dialectic
fails to account for occupations in medicine, which typically require advance academic
The notion of the clinical practice profession adds nuance to the stark craft versus profession
dialectic, and if applied to teaching, can point toward a different, better approach to teacher
preparation. Alter and Coggshall identify four distinguishing characteristics of a critical practice
profession, which they draw from reviewing the literature in teacher and medical education.
These are: centrality of clients, knowledge demands, use of evidence and judgement, and
grounding in a body of academic content knowledge, but the emphasis on judgement and client
agency within clinical practice means that this academic preparation must be supplemented with
has three basic components: academic grounding; practice-based training; and ongoing learning”
(Alter & Coggshall, 2009, p. 3). This third component means that the education of a clinical
practice professional is not conceptually limited to the preparation that occurs before an
individual’s professional practice begins. Rather, the education of a clinical practice professional
6
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
is conceptualized as beginning in the preservice period, continuing in the early stages of the
individual’s professional practice, and extending throughout much of the professional career.
Online learning communities and online communities of practice for educators are related to
the notion of teaching as a clinical practice profession in two ways. First, both proceed from a
common premise that the responsibility for preparing and developing teachers must be shared
between institutions of higher education and local school districts. Second, both online
communities and conceptions of teaching as clinical practice maintain that teacher learning
should be an ongoing process, and as such must be sustained past the initial induction period and
education have handled the preservice component and local districts have focused their efforts of
opportunities to mid-career educators. Ideally, however, both the institution of higher education
and the local school district would expand the scope their involvement to encompass the
preservice period through the first few years of induction. Online communities represent an
expansion of the role of the university in the induction process insofar as they position teacher
education faculty and more experienced graduates of teacher education programs as on-demand
Dede (2006) argues that online teacher professional development (oTPD) programs represent
a more viable model for delivery of mandated professional development services than the
traditional model of school-based seminars. According to Dede, Ketelhut, Whitehouse, Breit and
McCloskey (2009),
just-in-time assistance. In addition, they often give schools access to experts and archival
7
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
resources that fiscal and logistical constraints would otherwise limit. Furthermore, online
professional development programs also are potentially more scalable than those that
Given the current, rather dismal state of in-service professional development, there is reason
to be skeptical of quick-fix solutions. Yet, it is true that schools should be getting more out of
their professional development expenditures. In the 1990s, school districts spent the equivalent
of $200 per pupil on professional development related expenditures for their teachers (Killeen,
Monk, & Plecki, 2002), figures that must be even higher now. Yet teachers still overwhelmingly
report frustration with the professional development they are offered. According to Dede et al.,
professional development programs impose costs in terms of time and resources while not
necessarily improving teaching practice. This is because many teacher professional development
programs consist of “fragmented, intellectual superficial” seminars (Borko, 2004) and do not
provide the ongoing support that might assist teachers in actually implementing new curricula or
pedagogies (Barnett, 2002). Teachers dread these sessions and may pass them by daydreaming,
doodling or grading, largely because they resent the intrusion of the farce that professional
There are many different forms of online teacher professional development and a great deal
of variation in quality among these programs. It will be essential to distinguish among different
models for online teacher professional development to ensure that programs are adopted for the
right reasons, because they help teachers to improve their teaching practice and create gains in
student learning. To the extent that online communities for new teachers promote improvement
in these areas, the model can be leveraged into online teacher professional development
programs (oTPD) for teachers in all stages of their careers. These online supplements and
8
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
alternatives boast the distinct advantages of fitting into teachers’ packed schedules and offering
For example, sometimes new teachers hesitate to ask certain questions of their assigned
mentors - questions related to classroom management, for example - for fear that the information
about teachers’ self-perceived weaknesses may find its way to the employer and be used against
them. An online forum may entail less risk to one’s professional reputation than consultation
with a mentor who shares a supervisor with the new teacher. Online communities connect
teachers of that subject area in the local schools, paid graduate students interested in community
of practice development, teacher education faculty and arts and sciences faculty can all
contribute in different ways and help new teachers successfully transition from preservice to in-
service teaching.
Online learning communities also liberate teachers from any need to wait for a scheduled
face-to-face meeting with their assigned mentor to address their issues and concerns. Instead,
teachers are empowered to seek out solutions strategies and resources for addressing their
problems at their convenience. Ultimately, it seems likely that the online learning community
will evolve into a space where teachers seek support related to certain domains of their practice
There are indications that states have already begun to re-conceptualize professional
development for teachers. A recent report of the State Educational Technology Directors
Collaborative Approach (2008), asserts the need to “shift the focus from continuing
9
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
education credits and stand alone courses to a comprehensive approach to professional learning”
(p. 3). SETDA recommends three methods that states can take advantage of to enhance their
capacity to provide ongoing, relevant and continuous learning opportunities for teachers: online
learning communities, education portals, and mentoring. SETDA characterizes online learning
communities as spaces for teachers to exchange resources, and education portals as one-stop sites
for diverse users like teachers, parents and administrators to access needed resources related to
classroom instruction. Perhaps the ideal online teacher community would find ways of
Profile of Tapped In
National Commission for Teaching and America’s Future (NCTAF). One of the project’s central
goals is to encourage and enable university teacher education programs to participate with local
school districts in the work of supporting and socializing new teachers as they transition from
TLINC connects preservice teachers and new classroom teachers to university faculty, peers
and colleagues, and accomplished educators in an online learning community using the Tapped
In platform. Facilitating reflective practice and resource sharing, Tapped In aims to accelerate the
development of professional proficiency and improve the retention rates of early career educators
by supplementing the support new teachers already receive in face-to-face mentoring situations.
Tapped In has existed in its current form since 2002 when it was rereleased after an extensive
redesign. Before the redesign, from 1996 to 2002, the community took the form of a MUD
whose user interface is entirely textual” (Curtis, 1992). By way of further description,
10
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
A MUD is a software program that accepts “connections” from multiple users across
some kind of network (e.g., telephone lines or the Internet) and provides to each user
access to a shared database of “rooms,” “exits,” and other objects. Each user browses and
manipulates this database from “inside” one of those rooms, seeing only those objects
that are in the same room and moving from room to room mostly via the exits that
implement a redesigned system that would be robust, versatile and scalable” (Farooq, Schank,
Harris, Fusco & Schlager, 2007, p. 9), even the new iteration of Tapped In continues to rely
heavily on a spatial metaphor, substituting a college campus for the dungeon. Figure 1 is a
screenshot of the schematic Tapped In uses to represent itself which illustrates this metaphor in
action.
11
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
One of the salient challenges that NCTAF has identified through its TLINC project is the
community computing (Farooq et al., 2007). Community computing refers to the as “socio-
technical interventions and infrastructures that support community interactions and civic
Problems arise in community computing when the technological infrastructure does not meet
the requirements of end users. For example, imagine that a user comes across a forum in which
teachers are discussing ways of using video in the social studies classroom. Ideally, teachers
would be able to embed videos from Vimeo or TeacherTube in the forum, just as they might
embed videos in a personal blog. But perhaps the forum is not a rich media environment with
embedding capabilities. In this case, users cannot view the video inside the site. They will
instead have to cut and paste the URL of the recommended video into a different browser
window. This limitation of the technological infrastructure detracts from the viability of the
community because it directs traffic outside of the site rather than generating traffic within the
site. High traffic environments have a way of generating more traffic still.
Community computing projects can also struggle to generate sufficient social capital to
support significant contributions by members of the community. Imagine, for instance, that one
user is debating whether to join in a conversation taking place in a forum. The forum
conversation surrounds a new teacher who has appealed to the community for strategies and
systems that will help her maintain a degree of order and focus when she brings her classes of 30
eighth graders to the computer lab. She does not have access to a projector and only 23 of the
computers are operational. The first user might have useful experiences and ideas to relate, but
12
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
she may also be a prolific blogger who participates in various online communities and aggregates
her distributed participation using a blog. She would like to extract content from the site, the
record of her participation, using an RSS feed. If this feature is not offered, she may be dissuaded
from spending too much time in this community and may elect instead to focus her participation
It will be difficult to sustain a critical mass of users over time if conditions like these are
present. If a given infrastructure fails to support the types of activities users are interested in
engaging in or fails to provide meaningful support within a reasonable frame of time, then users
will abandon the community and find another, more active and better supported, community of
users.
These conditions - of a mismatch between end user applications and the technological
infrastructure of a community computer initiative - are most likely to prevail when “community
activities and practices are supplied hierarchically, such as by formal institutions, instead of
developing organically and being maintained by the community” (Farooq et al., p. 3). According
to Rheingold (1993), this can create an impression among users that the environment does not
belong to the users but instead to the institution, which tends to depress participation rates.
Underutilization limits the vibrancy of the community and ultimately portends its erasure.
Schlager and Fusco (2004) discuss general principles which they believe should be used to
guide technological design and development of online communities of practice for teacher
social capital to maintain feedback loops between community end users and designers;
providing multiple online gathering places for engagement with a range of community
end users; and reinforcing leadership roles organically from within the community.
13
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
Farooq et al. (2007) adopt a participatory approach to engaging users in the design of a
their successful approach to facilitating communicating between end users and developers. They
implement four channels of communication including contact and bug forms, a needed features
group, a task list and a help desk staffed by community volunteers and leaders.
Recommendations
States can take measures to support the development of online communities of practice and
online teacher professional development programs. They can, for instance, provide grants to
teaching practice, retain qualified teachers, and promote student achievement. States can also
work in collaboration with teacher education faculty to reexamine the state-mandated preparation
can also provide incentives to individual schools that tend to hire graduates of a particular
teacher education program to deepen their involvement with the institution of higher education
by agreeing to provide a clinical setting for preservice teachers. The additional opportunity for
relationship between institutions of higher education and local school districts. Finally, states can
activities grounded in practice, including online learning communities and online communities of
States, districts and schools can take certain steps to help teachers capitalize on their online
professional development activities, and to translate these experiences into their teaching
practice. They might, for instance, create instructional technology mentor positions that are
14
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
designed to support teachers in incorporating new practices and resources into their instruction,
as recommended by SETDA. They might also link education portals to online communities.
Education portals are powerful engines promoting equity of access to all teachers regardless of
the supports offered or withheld by their home district. Developed using federal funds in
combination with state funding sources, education portals represent a rich resource repository
which could become even more useful as databases of practice linked to online
communities in which teachers discuss ways of making best use of the curricular and
instructional resources. States should also allocate funds alongside the federal government for
research into the effectiveness of job-embedded professional development for improving the
retention rates of new teachers and linking new teacher practices with enhanced student learning
outcomes.
School district professional development leaders should work to cultivate relationships with
higher education institutions. Insofar as they identify ongoing learning and the integration of
development leaders should advocate for folding these aims into the mission statements and
programs and ongoing professional development programs when states and school districts fail
to appropriate sufficient funds for these purposes. Administrators should consider applying a
portion of their technology budgets to teacher professional development, especially in light of the
fact that vast increases in technology expenditures in recent years have gone underutilized in
schools, because insufficient resources have been set aside to help teachers develop the capacity
to make use of these new tools. Furthermore, administrators should seek more input from
15
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
teachers about their professional development needs and interests before deciding upon the shape
and scope of professional learning opportunities they will make available to teachers. They
should then back up their professional development programs with an authentic commitment to
sustainable professional development expressed through their firm support of teachers’ efforts to
teacher education programs. They should supply this support online because these new teachers
work in geographically disparate areas and have many competing claims on their time. But they
should adopt existing platforms aligned to their needs rather than developing infrastructure in-
house, which requires ongoing investment of significant financial and human capital resources.
Just as online communities can fail to take root if they are not grounded in the needs of the
community, they can also fall prey to budget shortfalls. Unless funded initiatives achieve
sustainability, the loss of financial and human capital resources to maintain the infrastructure will
Implementation
Basically, I am suggesting that institutions of higher education should redirect their attention
from the development of in-house platforms (Farooq et al., 2007; Schlager & Fusco, 2004) to the
extension of widely used platforms. But perhaps these robust efforts at making a community
computing infrastructure responsive to the needs and desires of the community are misplaced. To
elaborate, when the development process for Tapped In was beginning, there was a dearth of
viable models of online communities. Thirteen years later, online platforms for social
networking, resource sharing and collaboration continue to proliferate. Despite the significant
investment of time and resources that has already been devoted to Tapped In, it no longer makes
16
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
sense to devote limited financial and human capital resources to the maintenance of the
One peculiarity of the online teacher communities explored in the existing literature is their
reliance on metaphors for virtual space. Tapped In presents itself as a metaphorical campus, as
Establishing Successful Teachers, an online community of practice for common branch teachers.
This project of the Faculty of Education at the University of Wollongong in Australia, relies on
the metaphor of an internet cafe for its backstory (Herrington, Herrington, Kervin & Ferry,
2006).
Both of these projects fail to appreciate that users are by now sufficiently familiar with the
premise of virtual environments that it is no longer necessary to liken them to physical spaces.
Prospective teachers entering through the primary traditional pathway of undergraduate study are
members of the Millennial generation. The idea of online spaces is practically mundane to this
17
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
audience. No conceptual leap is required, and so the campus metaphor adds little to their
experience. In fact, the metaphorical overlay may depress participation rates among the
Millennial demographic because it suggests that the community is not attuned to current
Institutions of higher education that want to expand their role in the induction of new
teachers will extract maximum benefit from their investment by selecting an existing platform
with a vibrant critical mass of existing users and a robust and supportive community. More
specifically, I would recommend: 1) LinkedIn with Huddle; 2) Ning; 3) Learn Central. These
may prove to be equally if not more viable platforms. For example, LinkedIn, when integrated
with a Huddle workspace, offer the same range of functionality as Tapped In.
It offers opportunities for communication with individuals and whole networks through the
LinkedIn interface, as well as opportunities for resource sharing and collaboration similar to the
LinkedIn is already a popular site for professional social networking. Aesthetically, it is cleaner
18
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
Ning offers a dynamic environment for user created social networks, and it boasts a
particularly large following in education-related fields. But the most promising alternative may
be Learn Central, a nascent social learning network for education, now in beta release. Users will
have to decide on the appropriate platform by assessing the goals of the project and then testing
out various options. As the needs of the community evolve, project managers can simply move
According to Lenhart (2009), 75% of adults 18-24 currently use social network websites like
Facebook and LinkedIn. Use of social network websites is also rising among adults in general.
For example, the share of adult internet users who have a profile on an online social network site
has more than quadrupled in the past four years -- from 8% in 2005 to 35% now, according to the
Pew Internet & American Life Project's December 2008 tracking survey. Many other users may
be considering creating a profile on a social network site, but may need some encouragement to
actually do so. Also, it can be very time consuming proposition to maintain engagement with
multiple online communities. Communities of practice are more likely to develop into robust,
vibrant and expansive communities when they are not positioned in competition with services
which new teachers are already making use of in their personal and professional lives. Given the
time constraints facing teachers, online teacher communities can maximize traffic by adopting
platforms which many teachers already use for personal and professional purposes, or platforms
19
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
Bibliography
Anderson, J. Q., & Rainie, H. (2008). The future of the internet III. Washington, D.C.:
Pew Internet & American Life Project. Retrieved May 30, 2009 from http://pewinter-
net.org/pdfs/PIP_FutureInternet3.pdf.
Barab, S. A., Kling, R., & Gray, J. H. (2004). Designing for virtual communities in the
service of learning. Learning in doing. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Retrieved May 25, 2009 from
http://www.cambridge.org/catalogue/catalogue.asp?isbn=0521817552.
Borko, H. (2004). Professional development and teacher learning: Mapping the terrain. Educa-
tional Researcher, 33 (8), 3-15.
Britton, E., Raizen, S., Paine, L., & Huntley, M. A. (2000). More swimming, less sinking:
Perspectives on teacher induction in the U.S. and abroad. Paper prepared
for the March 6-7 meeting of the National Commission on Mathematics and Science
Teaching for the 21st Century. Washington, DC: WestEd. Retrieved May 27, 2009 from
http://www.wested.org/online_pubs/teacherinduction/
Carroll, T. G. (2009). Teaching for the Future. In B.S. Wehling & C. Schneider (Eds.), Building
20
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
Consortium for Policy Research in Education (CPRE). (2007). New York: Preparing Teachers for
a New Era. In Teachers for a New Era: Designing Policy Environments to
Support High-Quality Teacher Preparation. Philadelphia, PA.
Curtis, P. (1992). Mudding: Social phenomena in text-based virtual realities. Technical re-
port, Xerox PARC, 1992. Retrieved May 27, 2009 from http://w2.eff.org/Net_cul-
ture/MOO_MUD_IRC/curtis_mudding.article.
Dede, C., Ketelhut, D. J., Whitehouse, P., Breit, L., & McCloskey, E. M. (2009). A Research
Agenda for Online Teacher Professional Development. Journal of Teacher Educa-
tion, 60 (1), 8-19. Retrieved May 26, 2009 from http://jte.sagepub.com/cgi/content/ab-
stract/60/1/8.
Farooq, U., Schank, P., Harris, A., Fusco, J., & Schlager, M. (2007). Sustaining a Community
Computing Infrastructure for Online Teacher Professional Development: A Case Study of
Designing Tapped In. Computer Supported Cooperative Work, 16 (4-5), 397-
429. Retrieved May 26, 2009 from
http://www.springerlink.com.ezproxy.gc.cuny.edu/content/r541656187358884/.
Herrington, A., Herrington, J., Kervin, L., & Ferry, B. (2006). The Design of an Online Com-
munity of Practice for Beginning Teachers. Contemporary Issues in Technology
and Teacher Education, 6 (1). Retrieved May 27, 2009 from http://www.citejourn-
al.org/vol6/iss1/general/article1.cfm.
Ingersoll, R. M. & Kralik, J. M. (2004). The Impact of Mentoring on Teacher Retention: What
the Research Says. ECS Research Review.
Johnson, S. M., Berg, J. H. & Donaldson, M. L. (2005). Who stays in teaching and why:
21
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
Johnson, S. M., Kardos, S. M., Kauffman, D., Liu, E. & Donaldson, M. L. (2004). The Support
Gap: New Teachers’ Early Experiences in High-Income and Low-Income Schools. Edu-
cation Policy Analysis Archives, 12 (61). Retrieved May 25, 2009 from
http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v12n61/.
Killeen, K. M., Monk, D. H., & Plecki, M. L. (2002). School District Spending on Professional
Development: Insights Available from National Data (1992-1998). Journal of Educa-
tion Finance, 28 (1), 25-50.
Lenhart, A. (2009, January). Adults and Social Network Websites. Washington, D.C.:
Pew Internet & American Life Project. Retrieved May 30, 2009 from http://pewinter-
net.org/Reports/2009/Adults-and-Social-Network-Websites.aspx
Smith, T. M., & Ingersoll, R. M. (2004). What Are the Effects of Induction and Mentoring on
Beginning Teacher Turnover? Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 26
(3), 681-714.
22
Claire M. Fontaine May 31, 2009
TNE Prospectus. (2001). Teachers for a new era: A national initiative to improve
the quality of teaching. New York: Carnegie Corporation of New York. Retrieved
May 29, 2009 from http://www.teachersforanewera.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=home.pro-
spectus.
Villar, A., & Strong, M. (2007). Is Mentoring Worth the Money? A Benefit-Cost Analysis and
Five-Year Rate of Return of a Comprehensive Mentoring Program for Beginning Teach-
ers. ERS Spectrum, 25 (3), 1-17. Retrieved May 25, 2009 from http://www.ment-
oringeducators.org/images/Research/Spectrum_Villar_Strong2.pdf.
23