Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
ARTICLES
H. Fogel,
M.D.
Stamford, Connecticut
LW DEVELOPMENT of modern
surgical techniques
cardiac
milestones
in medicine.
Its ramifications
have been wide and deep. In its wake of many curative and palliative procedures for congenital and acquired heart disease, there is a renewed interest in the signifi cance of the cardiac murmur. In former years tile murmur was merely noted. Today, it is pursued until its etiology is firmly
estal)lished
investigation
blowing in quality. They are often incon stant and vary in intensity with cilange in posture. Tile commonest is a systolic mur mur at the pulmonic area, which is usually
best heard with the patient supine and during expiration. An apical systolic mur mur is also common. Such murmurs are unaccompamed by any evidence of struc tural disease such as an enlargement of the
with
will
the
lead
hope
that
tile
final turns
on roent abnormal
O@iIl
to remedial
or pallia
It is the author's
tive surgery.
Many
times
the murmur
definition
is not spe
is
out to be a functional one. This has prompted the physician to pose questions
concerning mur, tile incidence and characteristics
of the innocent
especially
or functional
in cilildren.
systolic mur
The answer
apical
Rheumatic Fever2 states an innocent (func tional) murmur is systolic, occasionally harsh, is heard best along the left sternal border and usually changes with position and respiration. (The American Heart As
as Assisting Cardiac
Physician, Clinic.
New
Haven
Rheumatic
Fever
and
793
794
sociation has
FOGEL recommended
CARDIAC
MURMUR
in very much
by twanging
nocent murmurbe used in place offunc piece of string. Harris et al.12 took photocardiographic tional or physiologic murmur.1)
A review cal papers of the American on the incidence literature for tracings uniform contrast in children with twanging-string
systolic murmurs.
tics
of this
murmur.
that
These
the
few
murmur
papers
does
overtones in insufficiency
generally
concede
not possess a pathognomonic feature that can distinguish it from an organic murmur. No doubt, this accounts for the wide dis crepancy in studies reporting the prevalence of these murmurs in normal children. Some studies35 reveal that 8 to 20% of all children of school age present these murmurs. In
grating
the
of
latter
pattern
by the vibrations
tile pattern
of a string. duced
is pro
systolic murmurs
children
of a solid structure,
in 44 to 61% of the
examined. In the resting state, Schwartz mann7 found an incidence of 44% which
increased to 86.6% after vigorous exercise.
Reporting on the physical findings, fluor oscopy and electrocardiograms of 260 pre sumably normal infants and children ob
served during Epstein9 noted mitral the first precordial 14 years murmurs of life, in 50%
such as a tuning fork. Therefore, ile sug gested that the term vibratory be used in place of twanging-string to describe this innocent systolic murmur. In his recent comprehensive publication, Rhodes@3 found the systolic vibratory mur mur to be the most common innocent mur
mur in childhood. It may be heard in infancy
after 2 or S
from those of
attempted
Messeloff'
years of age, being most characteristic be tween S and 7 years. Its incidence gradually
to analyze the characteristics of the inno cent systolic murmur in 300 children and concluded there was no single criterion for
decreases
murmur
toward
the child
adolescence.
this innocent
differentiating the systolic murmur as func tional or organic. FOUR INNOCENT SYSTOLICMURMURS One finds that there are four innocent
systolic murmurs. It is the failure to recog
causes subject some un of the in nize this which perhaps certainty about the entire nocent murmur.
tolic murmur as groaning in quality, not harsh or blowing. Taussig15 also has re
ported
murmur
has a
of 1w
groaning quality.
The following are the characteristics the vibratory murmur, as described
Almost a half-century
ago, Still11 de
scribed an innocent systolic murmur which he labelled physiological bruit.The latter was usually heard just below the level of
the nipple in approximately the left para sternal line. It was mostly found in children between the ages of 2 and 6 years. Still de
most commonly
VI) and the intensity varies with position, tending to decrease in the erect position. 3) The pitch is medium. 4) The duration is
brief, occupying
thirds of systole.
or two murmur
disappear in months or years. Its character istic feature was noted as a twanging sound,
Very infrequently
ARTICLES may be transmitted to the axilla. Ausculta tion witil the patient in the left lateral posi tion will reveal that the vibratory murmur
795
configura
and of the chest (pectus excavatum)
abnormal
cardiac
position
mediastinal
(dextrocardia
displace
at the sternal
Rhodes'
levoposition,
This finding
with
has prompted
contention
that innocent
maximal
systolic
intensity
murmurs
at the
be con
ment). Discussing the diagnosis of rheuma tic fever, Cassals15 described an innocent systolic murmur in childhood as having its maximal intensity in the right and rarely
in the left supraclavicular area, radiating
murmur to describe the innocent vibratory murmur. For the sake of clarity and validity, the vibratory murmur can be designated
parasternal-precordial, troublesome murmurs ferentiated from mitral since most which must insufficiency, of the be dif on the
down the left sternal border. He believes that this innocent systolic murmur is extra cardiac and is an attenuated remnant of
a supraclavicular murmur, diminishing or
basis of acoustic quality rather than point of maximal intensity, are mid-precordial.
In stating the difference between inno
disappearing with local change of head position. The above description characteristics common systolic murmur over the area. In the experience of
more'6 and the author,
neck pressure
or
cent
and
organic believed
systolic
be
murmurs,
corrected. while
two
It is
misconceptions
should after
sometimes
mur
that an innocent
exercise
mur
an
most common innocent murmur in children. It is a short, blowing murmur which varies
in intensity from a Grade I to Grade III, usually being Grade II. It is transmitted
disappears
organic murmur becomes louder. The cx perience of Whittemorel and Rhodes5 definitely disproves this statement. It was found that most innocent systolic murmurs increased in intensity with exercise. Tile
otiler caiice misconception of murmurs is judging the signifi by their intensity. In
parasternally
second change
and
toward
sound and
the
apex.
Tile with
ex
pulmonic in position
is always with
normal.
This murmur
children a typical murmur of mitral in stiffic@encv may be Grade I, while a vibra tory murmur may be Grade III or some times even Grade IV. Taussig15 has found
that a child with a normal heart may have
an extraordinarily loud functional murmur. Whittemore@ has observed in some thin, younger children on long-term follow-up that these innocent murmurs can be trans mitted to tile infrascapular, rarely inter scapular areas. The configuration of tile body seems to play a significant role in the prevalence and/or cause of the innocent murmur. Norris and Landis17 state that this murmur is common in children and in flat-chested individuals, apparently because little lung tissue intervenes between the pulmonary conus and the sternum, so that a slight dis tortion of the vessels results. It is also
amination. It is often accentuated by ex ercise. More commonly, it is found in the teen-ager. Tile third innocent murmur is the cardio respiratory. It is infrequently encountered in children. This has been defined' as usu ally ileard at the apex or over the body of the heart at the margins of the lung. It is almost always systolic in time and varies in intensity during the phases of respiration. Inspiration sometimes decreases or abol ishes it. Norris and Landis'7 describe this murmur as an interrupted or abnormal breath sound produced by the movement of the heart upon the surrounding lung tissue. It is not accurately synchronous with the heart, but often appears in the middle of systole, being distinctly separated from the first sound. It often begins and ends sud denly and is sharply localized and seems close to the ear of the examiner as a high pitched, short squeal.
796
FOGEL
INNOCENT
CARDIAC
MURMUR
A fourth innocent systolic murmur is the so-called hemic murmur which usually re
sembies the innocent pulmonic systolic mur
mur. It is apparently due to the anemia and poor papillary muscle tonus resulting from
anoxia. This latter may also explain the in nocent apical systolic murmur seen in fe brile states not associated with cardiac
enlargement or dilatation. The hemic mur mur may also be due to the increased vel ocity of blood flow accompanying febrile and anemic states. Although the venous hum should not be
mistaken for a systolic murmur, it may be
aid in differential diagnosis. The above characteristics of the murmur of mitral in sufficiency conform to the description given in Jones Criteria (@Iodified)@ for the apical systolic murmur of rileumatic heart disease which states, A significant systolic murmur is long, filling most of systole; is heard best at the apex; is well transmitted toward the axiila as over the precordium; and does not change with position or respiration. The systolic murmur of various congenital defects can be confused with the innocent.
A knowledge of the pathology of congeni
worthwhile to draw attention to this inno cent phenomenon. It is a common occur rence in childhood and is a continuous mur mur with a diastolic accentuation. It is heard to the right of the sternum as well as the left, beneath the clavicle. Frequently, it is heard better in the supraclavicular
fossa, varying between Grades I and III;
tal heart disease is essential in interpreting the various murmurs produced. These mur murs can often be differentiated from the innocent murmur by auscultation. In many instances, even the pediatric cardiologist requires the aid of history, electrocardio gram, fluoroscopy and sometimes physio logic data such as those obtained from
cardiac catheterization. The more common
and is often high-pitched. It is louder in the erect position than in the supine. Char acteristically, the diastolic component dis appears in the supine position. The pul monic first and second sounds can be heard to have good quality above the background of tile venous hum. The cardinal feature of the venous hum is its decrease in intensity or disappearance with rotation of the head or pressure over the neck veins.
damage. In the left lateral supine position, innocent parasternal-precordial murmurs are still heard best at the sternal border or medial to the apex. This difference in loca tion of the maximal intensity of the murmur in the left lateral supine position is a great
congenital heart diseases whose murmurs can be differentiated from the innocent murmur will be discussed. The murmur of congenital heart disease which is most easily confused with an inno cent murmur is that of an interatrial septal defect. This murmur has a blowing quality and is transmitted high into the posterior thorax. This transmission is a useful point of differentiation from an innocent murmur. In this malformation the second sound over the pulmonic area is usually more widely split than in normal children. The typical electrocardiogram in patients with an in teratrial septal defect reveals incomplete right bundle branch block. Fluoroscopy usually reveals a small aorta, prominent and active pulmonary arteries, large right auricle and right ventricle. On occasion, all findings are equivocal and cardiac cathe terization must be performed. Interventricular septal defects produce murmurs which may also be confused with loud innocent murmurs. This defect usually produces a loud, harsh murmur transmitted over the entire precordium and heard best to the left of the sternum in the third inter space or lower. It is also transmitted into the mid- or low-interscapular area as com
ARTICLES pared to the high posterior chest referral of the murmur of interatrial septal defect. In young children the murmur may eXilibit also bone conduction (audible over the
acromium and olecranon). is a systolic thrill. Invariably, there
797
The murmur of pulmonic valvular steno sis SilOtil(1 cause 110 difficulty. This murmur
is usually Grade III or louder, maximal
and examines any indigent or private pa tient upon referral by a physician. The pro fessional caliber of this clinic was approved by the American and Connecticut Heart Associations in accordance with Recom mended Standards and Minimum Require ments for Cardiovascular Clinics, 1949. One hundred one patients in the pediatric
age group (less than 14 years of age) have
over the pulmonic area, and louder in the first interspace than in the third. It is transmitted along the left clavicle and may
present bone conduction. It is usually ac
companied by a systolic thrill. The second soun(l over the pulmonic area may be di minished and pure but usually it is absent. Congenital suhaortic and aortic stenosis
produce rough systolic murmurs ileard best trans
over
the
aortic
area,
upper
notch
part
with
of the
sternum,
and suprasternal
mission into tile neck. Such murmurs also exhibit bone conduction and are as sociated with thrills, felt best in or just above the suprasternal notch. Determina tions of blood pressure will reveal a narrow pulse pressure. Coarctation of the aorta may produce a systolic murmur over the base. Usually, it is best heard at the level of the fifth left rib posteriorly. There is a sudden diminution in intensity of this murmur as one descends
tile paravertebral column. In all children
with cardiac murmurs palpation of the femoral arteries should be done. If the pulsations seem diminished, blood pressure sllould be taken in one leg as well as both arms. This simple and definitive procedure makes the diagnosis of coarctation of the aorta the easiest of all the structural defects to establish. CLINICAL STUDY In seeking further clarification of the character and incidence of innocent mur murs, the author reviewed the records of all children referred to a cardiac clinic, sponsored by a privately endowed com
munity without hospital. This confirmation was a clinical by information study ob
complicated innocent murmurs studied in 54 pediatric referrals. In explanation of Table II it should be noted that the data were compiled from the first cardiac examination. Each patient was observed until the diagnosis was firmly established. In almost all cases observation was made over several years. In this interim the murmur varied between Grade I and Grade II in intensity, occasionally Grade III. Uniformly, all these murmurs, includ ing those described as of maximal intensity at the apex, at some time showed variability with positional change; i.e., the murmur
would disappear or become considerably
tained at necropsy. This community cardiac clinic serves a population of about 85,000
less intense in the erect position. On follow up examination, the few apical innocent murmurs would invariably be found to have their maximal intensity in the third or fourth left interspace. No cardiorespiratory mur
798
FOGEL TABLE I
INNOCENT
CARDIAC
MURMUR
I)IAGN0SIS
OF 101
PEDIATRIC
PATIENTS
REFERRED
FOR CARDIAC
EVALUATION
.,umberPer Cent
54 4
I 0.9 9.9 14.9
companied by a thrill nor is it transmitted into the back. However, Whittemore has found that a loud innocent murmur can be transmitted into the hack. In the New Haven, Connecticut school system Sile ex amined 1,766 children \vitil cardiac muir
murs.
nosed diagnosis detection
Among
was of
these,
based a left
169 cases
septai primarily
were
defect. upon Grade
diag
This tile Il-Ill
as interventricular
10 15
parasternal
systolic murmur,
(5) (1) transmitted scapular to the regions.
(@)
16 9
these
scoped
169 children
and had
were re-exammeci,
repeat electrocardiograms.
fluoro
It was found
(1)
(3)
that approximately
the murmur had
75% had
in many
an innocent
In this
murmur
group
(@)
(1) (1) and coarcta (1)
cases
with where
disappeared
position the and murmur
was
In
variability
most cases re
posterior
ferral
where referred remaining (1) (1)
block,
were
having
physical examina
interventricular
septal
defects
had
systolic
thrills.
It was
thought
that
tile
data, no murmur
TABLE II
MURMIRS IX 54 PEnIATIII( FOR (aiwrar E VAIL ATION
murmurs.
(en!Site
.VumherPer
murs were encountered in this group of patients. The innocent systolic murmur over the pulmonic area was found to be blowing in quality. It was observed in seven children at the ages of 6, 6, 8, 9, 11, 13 and 14 years. This innocent pulmonic murmur comprised
12.9% of all the innocent murmurs.
intensityApex611.1Pulmonic of maximal area71@2 .9Left space16@9.7Left third intercostal space@546.3I'ransmissionFrom fourth intercostal
transm,mittedalong apexall border61(X)Frons left sternal arealocalized571.4down pulmonic .6Left left sternal border@228
In the author's series there were three cases where a loud (Grade III) innocent systolic parasternal-precordial murmur was transmitted into the back. These murmurs were not accompanied by thrills. In his comprehensive article, Rhodes13 does not mention this phenomenon. Taussig'5 states than an innocent murmur is seldom ac
third
intercostal
space
ARTICLES
majority as having of these patients initially septal diagnosed defects
799 CONCLUSIONS
interventricular
children between
Subsequent
the
growth
of tile child altered some of the characteris tics of the murmur. It is interesting to note that Whittemorel6 found the incidence of innocent murmurs to be 60.8% in those 1,766 school children diagnosed as having cardiac murmurs by the private or school physician. DISCUSSION The most prevalent cardiac sign in chil dren, tile innocent systolic murmur, has
been the focus of many varying opinions.
The most common murmur in childhood is the innocent systolic murmur. There are four types of innocent sys tolic murmurs; the vibratory parasternal precordial, the blowing pulmonic, the car diorespiratory, and the hemic. The vibratory parasternal-precordial
systolic murmur is the most common in
childhood. The blowing pulmonic systolic murmur is next in frequency and tends to
become more prevalent in tile teen-age
Because of renewed interest, more informa tive ol)servations are now finding their way
into the literature. As a result, there are ob
group as the vibratory parasternal-pre cordial murmur decreases in incidence. In the author's series of 101 children referred with suspected organic heart dis ease, the incidence of innocent systolic mur
murs was 60.4% which included seven cases in which there was a history of rheumatic
criteria
of this
fever. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The author wishes to express appreciation to Drs. Ruth Whittemore, Richard J. Waters and Harold M. Marvin for their suggestions and comments.
One deduces from the available studies that there are four types of innocent systolic murmurs; viz., tile parasternal-precordial, the pulmonic, the cardiorespiratory and the hemic. The latter two are infrequent in
childhood.
In the author's series, of the 101 patients less than 14 years of age, 54 (53.5%) children had uncomplicated innocent systolic muir murs. Seven children with a history of rheu matic fever also had an innocent systolic murmur which would make the murmur's total incidence 60.4%. Of the uncomplicated innocent systolic murmurs, the site of maximal intensity was at the apex in 6 cases (11.1%), at the pul monic area in 7 (12.9%), and in the third and fourth intercostal spaces at the left sternal border in 41 cases (76%). No cardiorespira tory murmurs were noted. To discharge a patient with an innocent systolic murmur from further cardiac follow-up, the following criteria are used: Negative clinical history. Typical characteristics of an innocent
systolic murmur. Normal cardiac
roentgenogram and/or
REFERENCES
1. Nomenclature
of Diseases
in
L. W.:
Cardiac
murmurs
in chil
of
fever in
climatically
different California communities. Am. HeartJ., 29:178, 1945. 5. Wilson, May G.: Rheumatic Fever. New York, Commonwealth Fund, 1940, p. 390. 6. Davison, W. C.: The Complete Pedi
atrician: Practical, Diagnostic, Thera
Students,
and
Internes,
Gen
6th
Pediatricians,
fluoroscopy.
Normal electrocardiogram.
800
FOGEL
J. : Cardiac Robie, sounds
1949.
INNOCENT
status and of ado Harris, PE
CARDIAC
MURMUR
in childhood.
u'aria inter
9. Epstein, N.: Heart in normal infants and children; incidence of precordial systolic murmurs and fluoroscopic and electro cardiographic studies. J. Pediat., 32:39, 1948. 10. Messeloff, C. R.: Functional systolic mur
murs in children. Am. J. M. Sc., 217:71,
Crado II es le plus usual. Le intensitate varia con le position del subjecto. Illo tende a de crescer in position erecte. Le duration es breve,
le altor medie.
camente ill
Iste murmure
Su
se trova sporadi
charac
infantes.
occurrentia
Disorders
and Dis
eases of Childhood,
Oxford, 1918, p. 495. 12. Harris, T. N., Friedman, tion of murmur
C. F.: Phonocardiographic
of mitral sounds in childhood.
differentia
insufficiency
1949.
13. Rhodes, P.: Diagnosis of innocent heart murmurs in children. Bull. Denver
Rheumat.
Fever
Diagnostic
Service,
cavate)
trocardia
Feb. 1955. 14. Lvnxwiler, C. P., and Donahoe, J. L.: Evaluation of innocent heart murmurs.
mediastinal) Le murmure cardiorespiratori es trovate in frequentemente in juveniles. JIb es audite usualmente al apice o supra Ic corpore del corde al margines del pulmon. Jib es quasi
semper systolic e varia in intensitate con le
respiration. Ilbo pare esser locate proxime al aure del auscultator e ha be appareiltia de Ufl breve e altisonante crito. Le si-appellate murmure hemic resimila usualmente le innocente murmure systolic puil
monic. Illo es apparentemente causate per le anemia e be inadequate tono del muscubo papil
lan que es le effectos de anoxia. Jib pote etiam resultar del accelerate fluxo de sanguine ill
statos febril e anemic.
SUMMARIO Murmures
A causa effectuate cardiac, ii res cardiac. systolic es confuse
(Functional) in Juveniles
del successos de palliation e cura per moderne technicas de chirurgia existe un nove interesse in murmu In juveniles le innocente murmure le plus frequente forma de murmure. il es non semper recognoscite
In be serie
patieilteS
del autor,
consistente
(i.e.
de
101
ill le gruppo
pediatric
de etates
de minus que 14 annos de etate), 54 (53,5%) habeva noncomplicate innocente murmures systolic. Septe patientes con un historia de febre rheumatic etiam habeva un innocente murmure systolic. Isto augmentarea le inciden tia del murmure a 60,4%.
que quatro typos de innocente murmure sys tolic debe esser distinguite. Le murmure parasternal-precordial es le plus commun murmure in juveniles. Illo es un
murmure non-sufflante. Illo es describite usual
Inter be noncomplicate
inriocente murmures
maximal esseva be