Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

Advertise Newsletter Partners Syndication About Us Contact Us Write For Us RSS

EAST ASIA SOUTHEAST ASIA SOUTH ASIA CENTRAL ASIA OCEANIA POLITICS SECURITY ECONOMY SOCIETY ENVIRONMENT

The Diplomat Blogs PACIFIC MONEYEconomics and Business CHINA POWERA New World Order JAMES HOLMESThe Naval Diplomat FLASHPOINTSDiplomacy by Other Means ASEAN BEATInsights Into Half a Billons THE PULSEPerspectives on South Asia ASIA LIFEThe Other Asia-Pacific THE EDITORView from America TECH BIZ Asia-Pacific Tech News BLOGS ARCHIVES Sport & Culture Blog India Decade New Leaders Forum A New Japan New Emissary Tokyo notes APAC Insider Asia Scope Embassy Finder Education Author Spotlight
thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true 1/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

China, What's Next? Event Calendar Photo Essays

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy


RegionSecuritySouth AsiaTopic August 20, 2013

By Mohan Malik
Share Tw eet 22 Like 2 10 137

Subduing India, preferably without striking a blow, remains a major Chinese policy objective.

Indias Quiet Counter-China Strategy 1962s Other Crisis: India and China go to War China Needles, India Responds India-China Ties Just Got Chillier Historys Hostage: China, India and the War of 1962
Reports of more than a dozen Chinese incursions during July-August across the poorly-defined Line of Actual Control (LoAC)the de-facto border separating India and Chinahave surfaced, barely three months after a tense border face-off in mid-April when a Chinese platoon set up tents about 12 miles inside Indian Kashmir. That standoff almost derailed the first ever visit to India by Chinese Premier Li Keqiang in late May, and ended with the withdrawal of the Peoples Liberation Army (PLA) troops on May 6.

Mutual antagonism has persisted along the border ever since the 1962 China-India border war with frequent border
thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true 2/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

skirmishes and standoffs. Negotiations over drawing the official borders have dragged on for so long that they now carry the distinction of being the longest-running border negotiations in the world. This is fitting as the LoAC is the longest border in the world that has yet to be demarcated and delineated. Premier Li Keqiang expressed optimism about resolving the border issue in the near future when he finally visited India in late May. Moreover the latest incursions occurred soon after Indian Defense Minister A.K. Antony visited China in June to discuss measures to maintain peace and tranquility along the LoAC. Recently, Chinese and Indian Special Representatives also held their 16th round of boundary talks. Still, the prospects of an early border settlement are not brightindeed, the two sides have failed to even exchange maps showing each others perception of where the LoAC runs. Some had hoped the growing economic interaction between China and India would help resolve the border dispute. In fact, the opposite has proven true; namely, trade itself has become a source of friction as Indias trade deficit with China has soared from $1 billion in 2002 to $40 billion in 2013. A 2012 Pew opinion poll showed that only 23 percent Chinese and Indians hold a favorable view of each other. The failure to resolve the border row has little to do with the substance of the issue, and everything to do with the interests of some of the parties. There is indeed a fairly good understanding of where the LoAC lies. This is evident from the fact that no incursions were reported for a decade from 1988 to 1998. It was only in 1998notably, the year India tested nuclear weapons that PLA border patrols again began routinely made forays across the disputed 2,400-mile-long LoAC to try and establish new territorial claims. Indian military has recorded nearly 600 incursions over the last 3 years alone. For their part, Chinese officials deny any transgressions and accuse the Indian side of patrolling on the Chinese side of the LAC. Its therefore clear that some in China view the unresolved border dispute as working in Beijings favor. Chinas aggressive patrolling along the unsettled border keeps Indias military forces tied down on multiple fronts, tests Delhis resolve, heightens its anxiety, exposes its strategic vulnerabilities, and diverts scarce resources away from its naval modernization. Moreover, independent analysts see parallels between Chinas land forces penetrating the LoAC into Indian Territory and Chinas maritime forces attempting to expand its maritime presence eastwards. Also indicative of this trend is Chinese maritime forces harassment of Japanese, Vietnamese and Filipino forces well within their exclusive economic zones. Whether on the high seas or in the icy Himalayan ranges, the PLA does not shy away from using assertive military tactics and an implicit threat of force to seize what it claims to own. Belligerence, brinkmanship, intimidation, risk taking, and controlled escalation have long been part of Chinese diplomacy. But by engaging in simultaneous territorial disputes and coercive diplomacy China has renewed fears across Asia over its wider territorial ambitions. This has led to discussions in regional strategic circles about a Triple Entente involving Tokyo, Hanoi, New Delhi to counter the Chinese octopus spreading its tentacles all around Asian periphery. There is a growing consensus in Asian capitals that a robust regional response to the PLAs rejection of the territorial status quo may well be needed to maintain peace and stability in Asia. The net result along the LoAC is that it has heavily militarized, as tensions rise over aggressive patrolling and their military drills. Since 2000, the Chinese have put in place a sophisticated military infrastructure in Tibet: five fully operational air bases, several helipads, an extensive rail network, and 36,000 miles of roadsgiving them the ability to rapidly deploy 30 divisions (appx. 15,000 soldiers each) along the border, a 3-to-1 advantage over India. Chinas economy and military expenditure are already 3 times the size of Indias. In addition, the PLAs strategic options against India will multiply as Chinese land and rail links with Pakistani Kashmir, Nepal, Burma, and Bangladesh improve.
thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true 3/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

Through a combination of trade, aid, resource extraction and infrastructure development, as well as arms sales and naval bases, Beijing has extended its strategic perimeter in South Asia and the Indian Ocean region. India has responded to the Chinese buildup by unveiling its own border infrastructure development projects, and deploying combat aircraft, cruise missiles, and mountain warfare divisions to fortify its northern borders. The Indian government also recently approved a new mountain strike corps (40,000 soldiers), apart from two infantry brigades and two armored brigades, to plug operational gaps along the border. However, New Delhis bureaucratic and economic constraints could delay force expansion plans. Still, Indias belated efforts to bolster its military position via stepped-up border patrols, and the construction or activation of new outposts, airstrips, surveillance, and roads have riled the PLA. The PLA tactics of pitching tents and flag marches to smashing bunkers and snatching surveillance cameras show strong disapproval of Indian countermeasures. On the eve of Indian Defense Minister Antonys visit to Beijing on July 4, a hawkish PLA Major General (ret) Luo Yuan warned India not to provoke new problems and stir up trouble through its plans to increase deployments along the border. To freeze the status quo, Beijing has proposed the conclusion of a new Border Defense Cooperation Agreement that would effectively reduce fortifications on both sides of the border. Not surprisingly, New Delhi has countered by proposing a broader accord designed to prevent border flare-ups, incursions, and especially the actual use of force under any condition. So far conflict has been avoided. But with the PLA expanding its presence to both the east and west, and Chinas neighbors shedding their defensive mindsets, there is a real risk of a miscalculation and a major catastrophe. The combative streak speaks to a profound shift underway in Chinese foreign policy. Specifically, China is abandoning Deng Xiaopings directive of trying to hide and bide its time in favor of seizing opportunities, taking the lead and showing off Chinas newly-acquired military capabilities and economic clout to shape others choices in Beijings favor. Of particular significance is the growing disconnect between the PLA and Foreign Ministry. Chinese diplomats often appear to be caught by surprise when the military engages in provocative actions. This was the case again during the Depsang plateau intrusion in Ladakh in mid-April 2013 that overlooks the Karakoram Pass, Chinas gateway to Pakistan. According to a member of Indias National Security Advisory Board, Chinese diplomats took several days to even determine that an intrusion had occurred and [i]t took threats from New Delhi to effectively kill two state visits and possibly a third before Chinese troops pulled out. While Chinese diplomats may be playing catch-up, Chinas new leadership appears to support the military hardliners attempts to change the territorial status quo through a provocative forward policy. My recent discussions with Chinas South Asia experts also confirm an inherently conflicted view of India. The broad divide is between the hardliners who want to nip the India challenge in the bud before it becomes a serious threat, and the pragmatists who want to partner with a rising India whenever interests converge and leverage its market and resources to strengthen relations. The first viewpoint is represented by the PLA strategists; the second by old India hands, foreign policy mandarins, and think tank community. Hardliners see India as a soft state that is hamstrung by a fractious polity, poverty, and religious and regional fault lines. They seem convinced that Chinas growing wealth and the unequal strategic equation will eventually force India (and others) to capitulate and acquiesce to Chinas primacy. Many assume that the Indian stateplagued with terrorism and insurgencies internally and under strategic pressure on multiple fronts externallywill eventually unravel. Military officers focus on Indias great power ambitions, its military spending and weapons acquisitions, and the
thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true 4/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

developments in Indias naval and nuclear doctrines. They opine that rising powers like India and China are likely to come into conflict as their capabilities, ambitions, and interests grow. PLA admirals and analysts similarly express indignation over Indias oil exploration in the South China Sea, its statements in support of freedom of navigation and the proliferation of its security dialogues with Japan, Vietnam, Australia and the United States. Growing angst over Indian naval forays in the Pacific Ocean led one analyst to ask: Are we all ready to accept India as a Pacific power? Aggressive patrolling along the LoAC would surely help the PLA keep Indian militarys focus on its land borders instead of widening its navys horizons in distant seas. Some fear that the Indo-U.S. cooperation in defense, space, and maritime spheres would prolong U.S. hegemony and prevent the establishment of a Sino-centric hierarchical order in Asia. As such, they believe that India and other countries that partner with the U.S. to counter China deserve Beijings wrath. A crucial means of victory without bloodshed (bing bu xue ren) in Chinese strategic tradition is to intimidate the hostile country into capitulation through provocation, brinkmanship, coercion, controlled escalation, and a shift in the balance of power. The aim is to convince the enemy, who is militarily weak and/or tied down by other security concerns, that the overall correlation of forces has shifted to his disadvantage and thus to force him to concede. In any case, some PLA hawks believe that China would prevail in a conflict with India and reap broader strategic rewards. Pragmatists, on the other hand, are optimistic about China and Indias ability to maintain peace and stability in accordance with their own self-interests. They point to burgeoning trade ties and collaboration on issues like climate change. Some Chinese pragmatists call for co-opting India in a newly scripted Look West policy to counter Americas pivot to Asia (i.e., the West of China, meaning South, West and Central Asia and beyond). The pivot to the West school favors a quick border settlement so as to reset India ties and drive a wedge between India and the U.S. and Japan. The dominant viewpoint holds that relations between Asias giants need careful management and conflict avoidance strategies. Even as they have failed to settle the border dispute, both sides have refrained from aggressive rhetoric since 2009 and no shots have been fired since 1987. Both desire a peaceful security environment to focus on economic development and avoid overt rivalry or conflict. Still, the volatile agents of nationalism, history, ambition, strength, and size produce a combustible mix. Therefore, both sides are arming for an all-out conflict. Strategic thinkers in both Beijing and New Delhi are bitten by the containment bug. Both countries aspire to the same things at the same time on the same (contested) continental landmass and its adjoining waters. Neither power is comfortable with the rise of the other. Asia has never known a time when China and India were growing strong simultaneously, in such close proximity and with disputed frontiers and overlapping spheres of influence. In the absence of a border settlement, tensions on both sides of the Himalayan divide will remain high as both militaries reinforce their strategic positions and engage in a battle of wits. Subduing India, preferably without striking a blow, remains a major Chinese policy objective. Dr. Mohan Malik is professor in Asian Security at the Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies, Honolulu and author of China and India: Great Power Rivals (Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2011). These are author's personal
views and in no way reflect the views of the Asia-Pacific Center or the U.S. Department of Defense.

Photo Credit: Wikicommons

thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true

5/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

Reddit Digg StumbleUpon Delicious Technorati Yahoo Google Sina Plurk

China, Chinese military, India, Indian Ocean, Line of Actual Control (LoAC), PLA COMMENTS 52 LEAVE A COMMENT 1. Andrew October 7, 2013 at 9:19 am This article should be required reading for any student of the evolving perilous Asian strategic situation and the new "Great Game." Sad to see the deceit on the part of Chinese military/CCPC leaders in all theatres of territorial contention, as their efforts continue to expand the nation's borders by subterfuge and, frankly, bully tactics. Surely, such game-playing would "offend" that civilization's great emperors who would have recognized by now that only the goodwill that comes from negotiating an honourable and just peace with neighbouring states best serves the traditional desire for stability and prosperity. This current game of chicken and deceit isn't worthy of China, nor its people. Reply 2. sandesh jopat August 30, 2013 at 10:36 pm There is no question of even a single inch of indian territory to be ceded to china ,India is fully prepared to meet any eventuality with China,we are not interested in any foreign country intervention,but we will not allow any power to look towards india. Reply Previous 1 2 3 LEAVE A COMMENT
thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true 6/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

Please read our new comments policy. Name:(required) Email:(required, but not published)

body p

Find us on Facebook
The Diplomat Magazine
Like 124,740

thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true

7/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

Sign up for newsletter


Your Email

1. PACIFIC MONEY Nintendo 2DS: A Budget-Friendly 3DS That Cuts Corners Will Nintendos hinge-less 3DS without 3D be a hit or miss this holiday season? 2. CHINA POWER P2P Companies: The Movers and Shakers of Chinas Shadow Banking P2P companies match shadow lenders with borrowers in China. Can Beijing manage the growing risks? 3. THE NAVAL DIPLOMAT 5 Warfare Concepts That Explain Rugby Watching rugby allows observers to see the ideas of Clausewitz, Corbett and Sun Tzu in action. 4. FLASHPOINTS Malaysia to Establish Marine Corps and South China Sea Naval Base Malaysia's Navy has announced it is creating a Marine Corps force and naval base at Bintulu. 5. ASEAN BEAT Nearly 2 Million Packs of Contraband Cigarettes Seized in Singapore Also: Myanmar bombing spree continues, 49 dead in Laos plane crash. Friday ASEAN links. 6. ASIA LIFE Modern-Day Slavery: Indias Other Shame Study: India accounts for nearly half of the worlds slaves. 7. THE PULSE Chayn: Helping Victims of Domestic Abuse

thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true

8/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

An enterprising team of volunteers create a valuable resource for victims of domestic violence. 8. THE EDITOR The US-Japan Security Relationship: Drift or Longevity? Despite concerns, with quality leadership bilateral security ties should continue to thrive. 9. TECH BIZ Samsung Galaxy Round: The Dawn of Flexible-Display Smartphones? From rumors to reality, Samsung has produced the first truly curved handset.

THE DIPLOMAT Archives East Asia


Chinas Foreign Policy Debates China: Urbanization and Hukou Reform Japans Clumsy Perception Management

Southeast Asia
Singapore and the F-35B Joint Strike Fighter Reforming the Cambodian Peoples Party Singapore: How to Stay Stable and Strong

South Asia
From Romance to Realism in U.S.-India Ties Rethinking India-Pakistan Relations The Deft Politicking of Nepals Army

Central Asia
Iran Talks: Breaking the Mosaic of Mistrust China and Iran: Destined to Clash? Kashgar on the Move

Oceania
Tony Abbott Poised to Become Australias PM Turkey Threatens to Ban Australian Politicians from Gallipoli The Deep Sea Resources Rush

Environment
The Rise of Chinese Space Junk Shark Finning: Appetite for Extinction? Mahendraparvata: Cambodias Archaeological
thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true 9/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

Rebirth

Politics
Reforming the Cambodian Peoples Party Chinas Foreign Policy Debates China: Urbanization and Hukou Reform

Security
Singapore and the F-35B Joint Strike Fighter China and Iran: Destined to Clash? The Creeping Militarization of the Arctic

Economy
Kashgar on the Move China: Urbanization and Hukou Reform Can Australia Get the G20 Back on Track?

Society
Kashgar on the Move China: Urbanization and Hukou Reform Tin Htut Paing: On The Run in Myanmar

China, What's Next?


How to Improve China-US Trust Chinas Highly Unequal Economy The Return of Smile Diplomacy George Orwells China? Avoiding US-China Military Rivalry Is Bismarck Chinas Man? Chinas Bumpy Ride Ahead Understanding Chinas Global Impact

The Diplomat Blogs


Pacific Money China Power James Holmes Flashpoints ASEAN Beat The Pulse Asia Life The Editor Sport & Culture Blog(archived) Indian Decade (archived) A New Japan (archived) New Leaders Forum (archived) New Emissary (archived) Tokyo Notes (archived) APAC Insider (archived) Asia Scope (archived)

Election Special
Australian Election 2010 (archived) Philippines Election 2010 (archived)

APAC 2020 Author Spotlight Australian Universities Country Snapshots Embassy Finder Event Calendar

thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true

10/11

10/20/13

Victory Without Bloodshed: Chinas India Strategy | The Diplomat

Photo Essays Video Gallery

Advertise Newsletter Partners Syndication About Us Contact Us Write For Us Privacy Policy 2013 The Diplomat. All Rights Reserved.

thediplomat.com/2013/08/20/victory-without-bloodshed-chinas-india-strategy/?all=true

11/11