You are on page 1of 4

Journal of Global Change and Governance ● Volume II, Number 2 ● Summer 2009 ● ISSN: 1941-8760

MUCH ADO ABOUT BORAT

Review of: Robert A. Saunders, The Many Faces of Sacha Baron Cohen: Politics,
Parody, and the Battle Over Borat (Lexington Books, 2008).

Pablo Castillo Díaz


Division of Global Affairs, Rutgers University

KEYWORDS:
Media, Identity Politics, Kazakhstan

© JOURNAL OF GLOBAL CHANGE AND GOVERNANCE ● DIVISION OF GLOBAL AFFAIRS ● RUTGERS UNIVERSITY
http://www.jgcg.org
MUCH ADO ABOUT BORAT ▪2

A thorough survey of the short but But in that journey, the author takes his
prolific academic career of Robert A. readers through polished disquisitions on
Saunders exposes the three axes of his British identity, the contemporary
intellectual passions: media, identity landscape of humor and hoax TV,
politics, and the global East, a region debates over multiculturalism, the
that stretches from the Near East to the origins of American neo-conservatism,
confines of China, occupying both post- the emergent media trends in a
Soviet spaces and the Muslim world. A postmodern and globalized world, and a
random slice of Dr. Saunders’s work concise history and political culture of
thus far includes subjects as diverse as Kazakhstan that rivals any of the new
Russian counter-terrorism, the European publications on this Central Asian
branding of Transylvania, the contours republic. All of this peppered with
of Ukrainian identity post-Orange pertinent references to popular culture
revolution, the politics of international and a welcome ability to shift from
adoption, China’s soft power, Albanian lowbrow jokes to highbrow erudition.
nationalism in cyberspace, the
nationalist overtones of the Muslim A great deal of the book describes
ummah, and the impact of the Internet on Kazakhstan’s six-year struggle against
minority Russians and Romania’s this media phenomenon and the trials
Hungarians. They all deal with at least and tribulations of Ali G (“a wannabe
one – though in most cases all three – of gangster from a middle-class London
the abovementioned axes, as does The suburb”), Borat (“an anti-Semitic,
Many Faces of Sacha Baron Cohen: Gypsy-baiting journalist from
Politics, Parody, and the Battle Over Kazakhstan”), and Bruno (“a gay
Borat. Austrian fashionista with a Nazi fetish”).
But the highlight of the book is the well-
I am perhaps ill-suited to write this researched profile of the very private
review. I am at once too appreciative of Sacha Baron Cohen himself. The
Robert Saunders’s academic writings author’s investigation reveals an
and too dismissive of Baron Cohen’s extremely brilliant – and, interestingly,
comedic project. The author displays devoutly Jewish – student of history. In
razor-sharp analysis, masterful use of the an exquisite exchange with Niall
English language, and encyclopedic Ferguson, a former professor of Cohen’s
knowledge all the way through the at the University of Cambridge, the
endnotes. The book is, at its core, a author asked him if he knew back then
cultural and political analysis of the that his pupil was destined for greatness.
three characters that elevated Sacha Ferguson’s rebuke is both amusing and
Baron Cohen to world fame and the profound: “That you call greatness? If
multiple reactions that they have elicited. only he had followed my advice, he

http://www.JGCG.org
PABLO CASTILLO DÍAZ ▪3

could have been a serious historian.” Dr. Saunders, who can easily answer that
Cohen even travelled to the United question, has had similar misgivings. On
States to conduct field research for his one hand, Cohen’s commercial success
thesis, which he completed in 1993 has broken all records. His first movie
under the title “The Black-Jewish made a quarter of a billion dollars, and
Alliance – A Case of Mistaking his second movie also promises to be a
Identities.” His first incursion into blockbuster. On the other, an outsize
American territory coincided with the number of serious journalists,
Crown Heights riots, supporting Cohen’s academics, political analysts and actual
controversial conclusion that the Black- politicians have opined on Borat,
Jewish Alliance is a “misnomer.” And confirming that Cohen’s character had
yet, his intellectual abilities were all too broken the normal boundaries of simple
evident well before that, when he pantomime. And finally, the sole fact
published an essay to the Times Literary that the ninth-largest country of the
Supplement as a very precocious eight- world took such pains to confront a fake
year old. The excerpt of the essay chosen persona represents a ripe case study for
by Saunders is so shockingly insightful those students of global affairs interested
for someone of that age that it deserves in the asymmetric relations between
reproducing it here: nation-states and individuals that fall
outside of the traditional edges of
All sorts of things may have international relations. But Cohen’s
happened over the weekend. endeavor is also part of an intellectual
Russia may have invaded
Afghanistan, England may have project to unmask bigotry and mock
lost against the West Indies at political correctness, and has been
cricket, and the price of Smarties recognized as such by most of his
has jumped up 5p. But in our reviewers. For many, Borat: Cultural
maths lesson nothing has changed. Learnings of America for Make Benefit
One plus one still equals two.
After Monday morning’s maths Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan, was
lesson, the world does seem a bit horribly revelatory of the ugliness of
more reliable and less insane that American society and its prejudices. One
it did on Sunday night. commentator even called it the most
And therein lies my frustration with anti-American movie that he had ever
Cohen’s comedy. Though political seen.
analysis of popular culture is an ever-
growing and very necessary field of And here is where I depart from the
study, I sometimes wonder if Baron generalized consensus. Cohen’s movies
Cohen’s avatars deserve such a weighty are indisputably funny, but they are
and nuanced monograph. I suspect that because Cohen himself is suitably gifted,
and his comedy has enough boldness and

http://www.JGCG.org
MUCH ADO ABOUT BORAT ▪4

recklessness to separate him from the


pack. I do not find anything especially
revelatory in his interactions with
unsuspecting victims all over the world.
Borat, for example, finds bigotry and
ignorance in the expected places, though
nothing that is out of the ordinary. And
yet, far more often, his outrageous
behavior is met with natural shyness and
even excessive politeness. Anyone that
is familiar with the fake interviews
conducted by Stephen Colbert, the
“investigative reporting” pieces of The
Daily Show with Jon Stewart, the work
of Bill Maher, or the documentaries of
Michael Moore, is already used to this
face of America. Cohen’s ruse, in that
regard, comes across as less effective,
and dare I say it, less smart. In that
sense, I am glad that Saunders put his
emphasis on the politicized reactions to
Cohen rather than focusing on Cohen’s
ruse as a valid sociological experiment.
For all we know, the puppeteer behind
Ali G, Borat, and Bruno might only be
interested in making money through
senseless entertainment, but that puts
him closer to the creators of Jackass
than to Jonathan Swift.

Nevertheless, that only means that the


book is highly enjoyable even for
readers that are less than fascinated with
the subject matter itself, and that is cause
for celebration. This is, by all measures,
a superb first book by a very promising
writer, and one can only hope that it is
followed by many more.

http://www.JGCG.org

Related Interests