Ombudsman: Inviting Napoles to Senate not advisable | Inquir...

http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/494053/ombudsman-inviting-napole...

Logo

Aluminum Composite Panel

www.Alibaba.com

Find Quality Products from Verified Suppliers. Get a Live Quote Now!

Latest Stories

Ginebra survives Talk N Text, makes quarternals

5 Signs of Alzheimer's
Doctor: 5 Warning Signs You're About to Get Alzheimer's Disease
Ads by Google

Home > Newsinfo > Latest News Stories > Nation >

Ombudsman: Inviting Napoles to Senate not advisable

By Maila Ager INQUIRER.net

2:19 pm | Tuesday, September 24th, 2013

0 21 825 453 Recommend 459

Ombudsman Conchita Carpio-Morales INQUIRER file photo MANILA, Philippines The Office of the Ombudsman has advised the Senate against inviting Janet Lim-Napoles to the chambers ongoing investigation into P10-billion pork barrel scam. Even as I recognize the Senates power to conduct inquiries in aid of legislation, I submit that it would not be advisable, at this time for Ms. Napoles to testify before the said committee on what she knows about the alleged scam Ombudsman Conchita Carpio-Morales said in her letter to Senate President Franklin Drilon dated Sept. 23, 2013. The committee referred to in the letter was the Senate blue ribbon committee, which is investigating the scam. Among the reasons cited by the Ombudsman for advising Napoles against appearing in the Senate were the filing of plunder and other offenses at her office against some legislators, Napoles and others last September 16. There are also other PDAF-related cases involving other government officials in conspiracy with other private

Feedback

1 of 4

9/24/13 10:09 PM

Ombudsman: Inviting Napoles to Senate not advisable | Inquir...

http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/494053/ombudsman-inviting-napole...

persons which are pending investigation by the office, the letter said. PDAF is the priority development assistance fund known as pork barrel funds. Summoning Napoles, the Ombudsman said, would not produce at this stage complete, nay reliable information that legislation intends to affect or change. Parenthetically, even if Ms. Napoles appears before the Senate to testify on what she knows given that she has publicly, consistently professed that she is now involved in any PDAF-related transaction, the objective of the Senate in summoning her to testify would be an exercise in futility, the Ombudsman said. Morales also invoked Section 15 of the Ombudsman Act of 1989 which authorizes the Ombudsman to publicize matters covered by its investigation of the matters mentioned in paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4 hereof, when circumstances so warrant and with due prudence. Provided, that the Ombudsman under its rules and regulations may determine what cases may not be made public. Provided further, that any publicity issued by the Ombudsman shall be balanced, fair, and true, the law further said. The Ombudsman also invoked Section 2 of her own offices rules of procedure against public disclosure on charges filed before her office. It cannot be gainsaid that the publicity that may be spawned by the testimony of Ms. Napoles, would among other things, adversely affect public interest, prejudice the safety of witnesses or the disposition of cases against her and/or her co-respondents pending before this office, or unduly expose them to ridicule or public censure, Morales added in her letter. Drilon, in a press conference, said he would defer to the opinion of the Ombudsman out of respect for her office. Lets not forget that the Ombudsman is not an ordinary government functionary. She is an independent constitutional official and the office of the Ombudsman is a constitutional office. Out of prudence and out of respect for her office, we must defer to the judgment of the Ombudsman as she has acquired primary jurisdiction over the case, Drilon said. The Ombudsman, he said, was in the best position to determine whether or not the prosecution of the case against Napoles et al. would be prejudiced by her appearance in the Senate. So on that basis, were deferring to the judgment and the ruling of the Ombudsman he said. Prudence dictates and out of respect for her office, I have decided to defer to her (Morales) judgment, the senator added. Drilon quickly dismissed any speculation that there was an attempt from the Senate or his office to stop Napoles from spilling the beans against other senators. Three senators Juan Ponce-Enrile, Jose Jinggoy Estrada and Ramon Bong Revilla Jr. were among those charged with plunder at the Office of the Ombudsman for allegedly using their PDAF to dummy non-government organizations linked to Napoles. There is none. There is none, Drilon said. Asked if the Senate was reluctant to invite Napoles in the hearing, the Senate leader said: There is no reluctance. We sought the opinion of the Ombudsman and this is the opinion that (she gave us). Meanwhile, Drilon signed a request to subpoena Justice Secretary Leila de Lima and produce principal whistleblower Benhur Luy, and other witnesses in the scam, when the blue ribbon committee resumes its hearing on Thursday.

Letter1

Letter2

Letter3

Related Stories:

2 of 4

9/24/13 10:09 PM

Ombudsman: Inviting Napoles to Senate not advisable | Inquir...

http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/494053/ombudsman-inviting-napole...

Guingona subpoenas Benhur Luy, whistle-blowers in next hearing Janet Napoles and the pork barrel scam

Follow Us

453

21
Google

459
Recommend

From Around The Web

!

Israeli Soldier Is Lured to West Bank and Killed

(The New York Times)

!

Bodies Pile Up in Texas as Immigrants Adopt New Routes Over

Russia Sells Stake in Maker of AK-47s to Investors

(The New York Times)

!

(The New York Times)

!

Pope Says Church Is Obsessed With Gays, Abortion and

How to Become a More Attractive to Women

(The New York Times)

!

(i.Net.How)
!

Teacher tells mayor, governor: try my job for 1 hour!

Seven Foods That Fight Inflammation and Belly Fat

(Philly.com)
!

Airline loses husbands ashes

(Dummies.com)
!

(Philly.com)
!

Modern slavery generates profit of over $32 billion

(WALK FREE)
!

Why Disaster Recovery Is So Important to Your IT Operations

China Lost 14 Million People in World War II. Why Is This

(DSS Blog)
!

(Pacic Standard Magazine)

The Five Dumbest Things You Can Do If You Have Too Much Debt

(i.Net.How)

Recommended by

You May Like

by Taboola

3 of 4

9/24/13 10:09 PM

Ombudsman: Inviting Napoles to Senate not advisable | Inquir...

http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/494053/ombudsman-inviting-napole...

14 Ways To Decrease Your Bad Cholesterol L

Fitnea

The Secret Swing to Hit the Ball Straight

Graves Golf

Pandora Shrugs Off Apple A bevy of celebs in bikinis iTunes Radio; Stock At (42 Photos)
Investors.com Holywoodlollipop

Travel Secret: 1 Euro Monaco-Nice bus ride! |

Travelaureate

Bernanke watch
Financial Times

PGA Pro Talks Golf Myths

Graves Golf

Discover What Few Golfers Know About Hit

Graves Golf

Recent Stories:

Habagat death toll in Zambales, Bataan rises to 30 Olongapo stunned by record floods 43 victims of trafficking rescued from 2 Cebu bars War on rice hoarders urged as harvests seen to meet targets Another suspect in Davantes murder surrenders in Cavite 7.8 quake jolts southwest Pakistan 5 soldiers arrested for looting amid fighting in Zamboanga City Top 10 veterinarian board examinees Pope Francis names future Newark archbishop 242 pass veterinarian board exam

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.
Tags: Janet

Lim Napoles , PDAF , Politics , Pork barrel , pork barrel scam , Priority Development Assistance Fund , Senate Is Jesus God?
Discover the Evidence From Scholars About Jesus' Claims to be God
Ads by Google

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

Australia Hotel Discount

Agoda.com/Australia_Hotels

Check & Compare Rates, Reviews. Up to 75% off. Book today!

Copyright 1997-2013 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved

4 of 4

9/24/13 10:09 PM