Property

Case Outline

PROPERTY
Case Outline 2 SR [SY 2013-2014]
Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez

Title I. Classification of Property

Topic
Immovable
Property

Art.
415

Case Title
Leung Yee v. Strong Machinery
PRC, Inc. v. Jarque
Berkenkotter v. Cu Unjieng
Davao Sawmill v. Castillo,
Machinery and Engineering v. CA
Navarro v. Pineda
Caltex v. CBAA
Benguet Corp. v. CBAA
Serg's Products v. PCI
Soriano v. Galit
JG Summit v. CA

Movable
Property

416

Sibal vs. Valdez

Laurel v. Judge Abrogar

Property in
Relation to
the Person to
whom it
belongs

420

City of Manila v. Garcia

Republic v. Lat Vda. Del Castillo,
Republic vs. Gonzales
Republic v. CA, Morato
Chavez v. PEA
Morandarte & Ferbrera v. CA
Villarico v. Sarmiento
Domalsin v. Valenciano
MIAA v. CA
PFDA v. CA
PFDA v. CBAA
MIAA v. City of Pasay
City of Pasig v. RP
Fernando v. Acuna

421
422

Cebu Oxygen v. Bercilles

Laurel v. Garcia
International Hardwood v. UP
Chavez v. PEA
RP v. Barandiaran
Heirs of Malabanan v. RP

Citation

61 P 663

50 P 512

66 S 481
187 S 797
200 S 554

GR
L-11658
41506
41643
40411
L-7057
L-18456
L-50466
10604
137705
156295
124293

Date
Feb 15, 1918
Mar 25, 1935
Jul 31, 1935
Aug 7, 1935
Oct 29, 1954
Nov 30, 1963
May 31, 1982
Jan 29, 1993
Aug 22, 2000
Sep 23, 2003
Jan 31, 2005

26278
155076

Aug 4, 1927
Jan 13, 2009

L-26053
L-69002
45338
100709
133250
123586
136438
158687
155650
150301
178030
163072
185023
161030

Feb 21, 1967

Jun 30, 1988
Jul 31, 1991
Nov. 14, 1997
Jul 9, 2002
Aug 12, 2004
Nov 11, 2004
Jan 25, 2006
Jul 20, 2006
Oct 2, 2007
Dec 15, 2010
Apr 2, 2009
Aug 24, 2011
Sep 14, 2011

L-40474
92013

Aug 29, 1975

Jul 25, 1990
Aug 30, 1991
Jul 9, 2002
Nov 23, 2007
Apr 29, 2009

133250
173819
179987

Title II. Ownership

Topic

Art.

Limitations
Case Title

Citation

GR

Date

Property
Case Outline

Doctrine of
Self Help

429

People v. Narvaez
Camarines Norte c. Quezon
MWSS v. Act Theater
UCPB v. Basco
Villafuerte v. CA
PB Com v. Trazo

Right of the
owner

430

Spouses Custodio v. CA
Aneco v. Landex
Heirs of Limense v. De Ramos

Topic
What owner
owns
With Respect
to what is
Produced

Art.
437
440444

With Respect
to Immovable
Property

253 S 483

Rights of Accession
Case Title
NPC v. Ibrahim

Citation

L-33466
80796
147076
142688
134239
165500

Apr 20,1983
Oct 11, 2011
Jun 17, 2004
Aug 31, 2004
May 26, 2005
Aug 30, 2006

116100
165952
152319

Feb 9, 1996
Jul 28, 2008
Oct. 28, 2009

GR
168732

Date
Jun 29, 2007

Tacas v. Tobon
Bachrach Motor v. Talisay-Silay
Torbela v. Spouses Rosario

30240
35223
140528

Aug 23, 1929

Sep 17, 1931
Dec 7, 2011

445

Bernardo v. Bataclan

44606

Nov 28, 1938

447

Pacific Farms v. Esguerra

Heirs of Orosa v. Migrino

L-21783
99338-40

Mar 25, 1970

Feb 1, 1993

448

Ignacio v. Hilario
Tayag v. Yuseco
Ignao v. IAC
Pecson v. CA
Pleasantville Devt. Corp. v. CA
Parilla v. Pilar
Technogas v. CA
RP v. Judge Ballocanag
Sulo sa Nayon v. Nayong Pilipino
Arangote v. Spouses Maglunob
Cabang v. Basay
Navarez v. Alciso
Tuatis v. Escol
Fuentes v. Roca
Benedicto v. Villaflores
Angeles v. Pascual
Torbela v. Spouses Rosario
Communities v. Nanol

L-175
14043
72876
115814
79688
167680
108894
163794
170923
178906
180587
165907
175399
178902
185020
157150
140528
176791

Apr 30, 1946

Apr 16, 1959
Jan 18, 1991
May 26, 1995
Feb 1, 1996
Nov 30, 2006
Feb 10, 1997
Nov 28, 2008
Jan 20, 2009
Feb 18, 2009
Mar 20, 2009
Jul. 27, 2009
Oct. 27, 2009
Apr 21, 2010
Oct 6, 2010
Sep 21, 2011
Dec 7, 2011
Nov 4, 2012

449451

Congregation RVM v. CA
De Vera vs. CA
Pada-KIlario v. CA
Heirs Durano v. Uy
Ravina v. Villa Abrille

126363
97761
134329
136456
160708

Jun 26, 1998

Apr 14, 1999
Jan 19, 2000
Oct 24, 2000
Oct 16, 2009

452

Martinez v. Baganus

9438

Nov 25, 1914

Property
Case Outline

With Respect
to Movable
Property

Quieting of
Title

454

Enriquez v. De Guzman
Geminiano v. CA
Editha Alviola vs. CA
Pada-Kilaro v. CA

28721
120303
117642
134329

Oct. 5, 1928
Jul 24, 1996
Apr 24, 1998
Jan. 19, 2000

457

Grande v. CA
Zapata v. Director of Lands
Agne v. Director of Lands
Agustin v. IAC
Vda. De Nazareno v. CA
Heirs of Navarro v. IAC
Bagaipo v. CA
Siain Enterprises v. FF Cruz
New Regent v. Tanjuatco
Office of City Mayor v. Ebio

L-17652
L-17645
L-40399
66075-76
98045
68166
116290
146616
168880
178411

Jun 30, 1962

Oct 30, 1962
Feb 6, 1990
Jul 5, 1990
Jun 26, 1996
Feb 12, 1997
Dec 8, 2000
Aug 31, 2006
Apr 16, 2009
Jun. 23, 2010

458
461

Government v. Colegio De San Jose

Baes v. CA

108065

Aug 29, 1929

Jul 6, 1993

472

Santos v. Bernabe

31163

Nov 6, 1929

474

Aguirre v. Pheng

L-20851

Sep 3, 1966

476

Sapto v. Fabiana
Bucton v. Gabar
Coronel v. IAC
Fernandez v. CA
Mamadsual v. Moson
Pingol v. CA
Heirs of Olviga v. CA
Secuya v. Vda. De Selma
Metrobank v. Alejo
Portic v. Cristobal
Calacala v. RP
Bank of Commerce v. San Pablo
Rico v. Rufon
Butuin v. Caoleng
Tandog v. Macapagal
Clado-Reyes v. Spouses Limpe
Guaranteed Homes v. Heirs
Lasquite v. Victory Hills
Acosta v. Salazar
Eland v. Garcia
Philiville v. Bonifacio

L-11285
L-36359
70191
83141
92557
102909
104813
136021
141970
156171
154415
167848
04-1822
157567
144208
163876
171531
175375
161034
173289
167391

May 16, 1958

Jan 31, 1974
Oct 29, 1987
Sep 21, 1990
Sep 27, 1990
Sep 6, 1993
Oct 21, 1993
Feb 22, 2000
Sep 10, 2001
Apr 22, 2005
Jul 28, 2005
Apr 27, 2007
Jun 25, 2007
Aug 10, 2007
Sep 11, 2007
Jul 9, 2008
Jan 30, 2009
Jun 23, 2009
Jun 30, 2009
Feb 17, 2010
Jun 8, 2011

53 P 423

525 S 477

Property
Case Outline

Title III. Co-ownership

Topic
Definition

Art.
484

Case Title
Spouses Si v. CA
Mercado-Fehr v. Fehr
Ocampo v. Ocampo
Sanchez v. CA
Herrera v. Fangonil
Balus v. Balus
Pascual v. Ballesteros

Shares in
benefits and
charges

485

Jimenez v. Fernandez
De Guia v. CA
Mendoza v. CA

Right to bring
action for
ejection

487

Punsalan v. Boon Liat

De Guia v. CA
Wee v. De Castro
Plasabas v. CA

Right to
reimbursement

488

RA 4726
Condo Act
Alteration
Rights regarding
ideal share

Partition

GR
122047
152716
150707
152766
169356
168970
186269

Date
Oct 12, 2000
Oct 23, 2003
Apr 14, 2004
Jan 20, 2003
Aug 28, 2007
Jan 15, 2010
Feb 15, 2012

L-46364
120864

Apr 6, 1990
Oct 8, 2003

18009
120864
176405

Jan 10, 1923

Oct 8, 2003
Aug 20, 2008
Mar 31, 2009

Adille v. CA
Aguilar v. CA

L-44546
76351

Jan 29, 1988

Oct 29, 1993

490

Sunset View v. Campos

L-52361

Apr 27, 1981

491

Javier v. Javier

2812

Oct 18, 1906

493

Mercado v. Liwanag
Acebedo v. Abesamis
Bailon v. CA
Sps. Cruz v. Leis
Del Campo v. CA
Sanchez v. CA
Heirs of Balite v. Lim
Metrobank v. Pascual
Heirs of Co v. Gervacio

L-14429

Jun 30, 1962

125233
108228
152766
152168
163744
157537

Mar 9, 2000
Feb 1, 2001
Jun 20, 2003
Dec 10, 2004
Feb 29, 2008
Sep 7, 2011

46345
51914
46296
118904
124262
139524
170080
169356
105608
171628
157537
151898

Jan 30, 1990

Jun 6, 1990
Sep 24, 1991
Apr 20, 1998
Oct 12, 1999
Oct 12, 2000
Apr 4, 2007
Aug 28, 2007
Apr 30, 2008
Jun 13, 2011
Sep 7, 2011
Mar 13, 2012

76351

Oct 29, 1993

494

498

Fabian v. Fabian
Ceniza v. CA
Bicarme v. CA
Delima v. CA
Arturio Trinidad v. CA
Tomas Claudio v. CA
Santos v. Santos
Austria v. Lichauco
Herrera v. Fangonil
Monteroso v. CA
Alano v. PDB
Heirs of Co v. Servacio
Rizal v. Naredo
Aguilar v. CA

Citation

199 S 778
44 P 320

217 S 186
160 S 738

22 S 520

Property
Case Outline

Essentially
indivisible
object

Reyes v. Concepcion

190 S 171

56550

Oct 1, 1990

Title IV. Some Special Properties WATERS

Ownership
of Waters

Use of
Public
Waters

Art.
502503

504506

Case Title
Republic v. Lat Vda. De Castillo
Taleon v. Sec. of Public Works and
Communications
RP v. Candymaker
Filinvest v. Flood
Fernando v. Acuna
Honorio Bulao v. CA, et al.,

Citation

GR
L-69002
L-24281

Date
Jan 30, 1988
May 16, 1967

163766
165955
161030

Jun 22, 2006

Aug 10, 2007
Sep 14, 2011

101983

Feb 1, 1993