9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
Heavy Reading Independent quantitative research and competitive analysis of next-generation hardware and soft- ware solutions for service providers and vendors
KEY FINDINGS A full ecosystem, including more than 50 silicon devices, has developed specifically to support LTE Carrier commitment to LTE continues to grow, now up to 166 operators across 62 countries worldwide 100Mbit/s Cat 3 LTE is now supported by the majority of LTE silicon; 150Mbit/s Cat 4 is in the pipeline The first LTE- Advanced features are now becoming available in silicon Vendor consolidation is driving a highly competitive handset silicon market ARM A9 application processors are used by most vendors; the first A15 cores will arrive by end 2011 Multimode handsets supporting 2G, 3G, and LTE will be the next wave of devices, starting in 2012 VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 LTE Baseband, RF & Appl ication Processors: A Heavy Readi ng Competiti ve Anal ysi s
LTE is the fastest-growing wireless network technology with more than 160 operators across 62 countries committed to LTE. In less than two years, more than 20 operators have commercially launched LTE networks in 16 countries. The number of user devices supporting LTE has grown by more than 60 percent in four months. Mobile carriers have chosen LTE to deliver high- speed data services up to 150Mbit/s initially, then up to 3 Gbit/s within five years, once LTE-Advanced is fully implemented.
The first LTE devices are in production and second generation solutions are almost ready. Established mobile chipset vendors and silicon vendors are pushing to deliver integrated solutions for multimode handset devices and micro, pico, and femto base stations. The established vendors are being challenges by a group of Tier 2 vendors with established credibility in either the HSPA or WiMax markets that have developed LTE silicon solutions with market-leading features.
This report delivers a complete competitive analysis of LTE silicon solutions from 29 vendors, covering more than 70 different products and product families. The report offers detailed competi- tive analysis on LTE baseband, RF and application processors for user devices and base stations, covering key product fea- tures, as well as power, price, and availability.
AUTHOR: SIMON STANLEY, ANALYST AT LARGE, HEAVY READING USE OF THIS PDF FILE IS GOVERNED BY THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS STATED IN THE SUBSCRIBER LICENSE AGREEMENT INCLUDED IN THIS FILE. ANY VIOLATION OF THE TERMS OF THIS AGREEMENT, INCLUDING UNAUTHORIZED DISTRIBUTION OF THIS FILE TO THIRD PARTIES, IS CONSIDERED A BREACH OF COPYRIGHT. HEAVY READING WILL PURSUE SUCH BREACHES TO THE FULL EXTENT OF THE LAW. SUCH ACTS ARE PUNISHABLE IN COURT BY FINE S OF UP TO $100,000 FOR EACH INFRINGEMENT. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
2 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION & KEY FINDINGS .................................................................................. 4 1.1 Key Findings ....................................................................................................................... 5 1.2 Report Scope & Structure ................................................................................................... 6 II. LTE MARKETS & TECHNOLOGY .................................................................................... 7 2.1 Market Overview ................................................................................................................. 7 2.2 LTE Technology Primer ...................................................................................................... 8 2.3 LTE-Advanced .................................................................................................................. 11 2.4 LTE IP Solutions ............................................................................................................... 11 III. BASE STATION DEVICES & SOLUTIONS .................................................................... 13 3.1 LTE Base Station PHY Devices ....................................................................................... 13 3.2 LTE Base Station PHY Devices ....................................................................................... 14 3.3 LTE Base Station MAC & Control Devices ....................................................................... 15 3.4 Integrated LTE Base Station Devices .............................................................................. 16 IV. BASE STATION SILICON VENDORS ............................................................................ 20 4.1 Cavium Inc. ....................................................................................................................... 20 4.2 DesignArt Networks Ltd. ................................................................................................... 21 4.3 Freescale Semiconductor Inc. .......................................................................................... 22 4.4 LSI Corp. ........................................................................................................................... 23 4.5 Mindspeed Technologies Inc. ........................................................................................... 24 4.6 NetLogic Microsystems Inc. .............................................................................................. 24 4.7 Octasic Inc. ....................................................................................................................... 25 4.8 Picochip Ltd. ..................................................................................................................... 26 4.9 PMC-Sierra Inc. ................................................................................................................ 26 4.10 Texas Instruments Inc. ..................................................................................................... 27 V. HANDSET & CPE DEVICES ........................................................................................... 28 5.1 LTE CPE & Handset Baseband Devices .......................................................................... 28 5.2 LTE Ready Application Processors .................................................................................. 30 VI. HANDSET & CPE SILICON VENDORS .......................................................................... 33 6.1 Altair Semiconductor Ltd. ................................................................................................. 33 6.2 Broadcom Corp. ............................................................................................................... 34 6.3 Cavium Inc. ....................................................................................................................... 34 6.4 GCT Semiconductor Inc. .................................................................................................. 34 6.5 Innofidei Inc. ..................................................................................................................... 35 6.6 Intel Corp. ......................................................................................................................... 35 6.7 Marvell Technology Group Ltd. ........................................................................................ 35 6.7 Nvidia Inc. ......................................................................................................................... 35 6.8 Qualcomm Inc................................................................................................................... 36 6.9 Renesas Mobile ................................................................................................................ 36 6.10 Sequans Communications ................................................................................................ 36 6.11 ST-Ericsson ...................................................................................................................... 37 HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
3 6.12 Texas Instruments Inc. ..................................................................................................... 37 VII. RF CHIPS & VENDORS .................................................................................................. 38 7.1 Analog Devices Inc. .......................................................................................................... 41 7.2 Fujitsu Microelectronics America Inc. ............................................................................... 41 7.3 Genasic Design Systems Ltd. .......................................................................................... 41 7.4 Lime Microsystems Ltd. .................................................................................................... 41 7.5 Maxim Integrated Products Inc. ........................................................................................ 42 7.6 Semtech Corp. .................................................................................................................. 42 APPENDIX A: ABOUT THE AUTHOR ......................................................................................... 43 APPENDIX B: LEGAL DISCLAIMER ........................................................................................... 44
HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
4 I. Introduction & Key Findings Long Term Evolution (LTE) deployments are growing quickly, with 166 carriers in 62 countries now committed to using it. LTE provides the reduced latency, increased peak bandwidth and greater network capacity required for the advanced voice, data and video applications made possible by the latest smartphones. HD video is only the latest in a stream of new applications that is stretching 3G networks to the breaking point.
Mobile carriers need LTE to deliver high-quality services to smartphone users. LTE is the leading 4G wireless network and is backward compatible with existing solutions. LTE and LTE-Advanced will meet the long-term needs of carriers and their customers for high-speed data traffic support- ing Internet browsing, voice and video.
Semiconductor components are key to the successful rollout of LTE networks around the world. As LTE develops and LTE-Advanced is introduced, there is pressure on semiconductor vendors to introduce devices supporting additional frequency bands and a complex mix of networks, bandwidths and performance. To meet these challenges, semiconductor vendors must develop flexible and highly integrated devices that meet the performance criteria of carriers and deliver cost-effective, power-efficient solutions.
The LTE semiconductor market is very competitive, with multiple vendors developing application processors, baseband and radio frequency (RF) devices for both base stations and user equip- ment. With LTE, we are seeing components developed by existing application processor, mobile baseband and RF market leaders; startups targeting the LTE market; and well-established companies shifting from WiMax to LTE. There have also been several high-profile acquisitions that have brought application processor and baseband developers into one company, including ST-Ericsson, Renasas, Intel and Nvidia.
LTE Baseband, RF & Application Processors: A Heavy Reading Competitive Anal ysi s identifies and analyzes the full spectrum of vendors developing LTE components for both base stations and user devices. The report includes not only granular information on the components and systems themselves of interest to system OEMs, smartphone developers and service providers but also insights into how the overall market and ecosystem is developing of interest to a wide audience, including investors.
The report evaluates and analyzes the products and strategies of 29 leading vendors in this rapidly growing market, including more than 70 baseband, RF and application processors from these companies. The vendors covered in this report are:
Altair Semiconductor Ltd. Altera Corp. (Nasdaq: ALTR) Analog Devices Inc. (NYSE: ADI) Broadcom Corp. (Nasdaq: BRCM) Cavium Inc. (Nasdaq: CAVM) DesignArt Networks Ltd. Freescale Semiconductor Inc. (NYSE: FSL) Fujitsu Microelectronics America Inc., a subsidiary of Fujitsu Ltd. (TSE: 6702; Pink Sheets: FJ TSY) GCT Semiconductor Inc. Genasic Design Systems Ltd. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
5 Innofidei Inc. Intel Corp. (Nasdaq: INTC) Lime Microsystems Ltd. LSI Corp. (NYSE: LSI) Marvell Technology Group Ltd. (Nasdaq: MRVL) Maxim Integrated Products Inc. (Nasdaq: MXIM) Mindspeed Technologies Inc. (Nasdaq: MSPD) NetLogic Microsystems Inc. (Nasdaq: NETL) Nvidia Inc. (Nasdaq: NVDA) Octasic Inc. Picochip Ltd. PMC-Sierra Inc. (Nasdaq: PMCS) Qualcomm Inc. (Nasdaq: QCOM) Renesas Mobile, a subsidiary of Renesas Electronics Corp. (TSE: 6723) Semtech Corp. (Nasdaq: SMTC) Sequans Communications ST-Ericsson, a joint venture of STMicroelectronics NV (NYSE: STM) and Ericsson AB (Nasdaq: ERIC) Tensilica Inc. Texas Instruments Inc. (NYSE: TXN) Xilinx Inc. (Nasdaq: XLNX) 1.1 Key Findings Key findings of this report include the following:
A full LTE ecosystem, including more than 50 sili con devices, has developed specificall y to support LTE. Of the more than 70 silicon devices covered in this report, more than 50 have been designed specifically for LTE or have had features added to support LTE.
Carrier commitment to LTE continues to grow, now including 166 operators across 62 countries. A total of 24 operators have launched commercial LTE networks in 16 countries, making LTE the fastest-growing wireless technology in the world.
The majority of LTE sili con supports 100Mbit/s Cat 3 LTE. Most of the silicon solutions designed for both user devices and LTE base stations support 100Mbit/s Cat 3 LTE. A small number of older devices are limited to 50MHz Cat 2 LTE, and a few of the latest devices will support 150MHz Cat 4.
The first LTE-Advanced features are becoming available in si licon. The first silicon devices with features such as carrier aggregation and multi-user MIMO (MU-MIMO) to support LTE- Advanced are sampling to system developers.
HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
6 Vendor consolidation is driving a very competitive handset sil icon market. Due to some high-profile acquisitions, ST-Ericsson, Renasas, Intel and Nvidia all now have both application processors and LTE baseband solutions under one roof.
ARM A9 application processors are used by most vendors; the first A15 cores will arrive by the end of 2011. ARM Cortex A9 processor cores are used by Nvidia, Renesas, ST-Ericsson and Texas Instruments. Intel has the Atom processor core, and Qualcomm has developed the Scorpion and Krait processor cores.
Multimode handsets supporting 2G/3G/LTE will be the next wave, starting i n 2012. All LTE- enabled handsets today are dual-band designs supporting LTE and 3G. Using the silicon devices already developed, the next generation of handsets will be multiband, supporting 2G/3G and possibly multiple LTE bands.
Integrated silicon solutions are available for small-cell base stations. Small-cell base stations must be very low-cost and low-power. The latest introductions from several vendors include highly integrated devices for picocells and femtocells that enable very low-power and low-cost solutions. 1.2 Report Scope & Structure This report is based on interviews conducted with a wide range of LTE silicon vendors in the four months leading up to J uly 2011, along with product and volume information supplied by vendors. The tables presented in the report are based on product documentation and supplemental data from our interviews and email conversations. All of the data in product tables has been provided to vendors for confirmation, feedback and updating ahead of publication. In total, the report contains detailed information and analysis on more than 70 products from 29 different vendors.
LTE Baseband, RF & Application Processors: A Heavy Reading Competitive Anal ysis is structured as follows:
Section II examines the dynamics of the LTE market, provides an overview of LTE technology, introduces the plans for LTE-Advanced and covers three vendors that will provide intellectual property to support the development of LTE devices.
Section III focuses on base station solutions. This section covers 22 devices, including LTE PHY devices, LTE MAC and control devices and integrated LTE base station devices.
Section IV presents detailed product and strategy analysis for 10 vendors that provide LTE PHY devices, LTE MAC and control devices and/or integrated LTE base station devices.
Section V analyzes 31 baseband devices and application processors for LTE user devices, including handsets, tablets and USB dongles.
Section VI presents detailed product and strategy analysis for 13 vendors that supply baseband devices and application processors for LTE user devices.
Section VII analyzes 18 RF devices available for LTE and presents detailed product and strategy analysis for six vendors that provide RF devices and are not covered elsewhere. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
7 II. LTE Markets & Technology 2.1 Market Overview The dramatic increase in the use of smartphones by both businesses and consumers has dramatically increased user expectations and driven exponential mobile data traffic growth. To meet these expectations, carriers are investing in mobile broadband service delivery. However, average revenue per mobile user is growing more slowly than data per user, and this is putting carrier profitability under pressure. LTE is a significant step forward for wireless carriers, reducing the cost per user and delivering peak rates of 100 Mbit/s and above.
LTE was developed within the 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) as a 4G successor to WCDMA/UMTS. WCDMA/UMTS, including High Speed Packet Access (HSPA) and CDMA2000, represent the mainstream 3G mobile technologies supporting voice and increasing data band- width. Since Qualcomm stopped developing Ultra Mobile Broadband (UMB) in November 2008, LTE has also been adopted as the successor to CDMA2000. LTE will meet the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) requirements for 4G networks (IMT-Advanced) with the introduc- tion of LTE-Advanced, currently being developed within 3GPP.
LTE uses similar techniques to WiMax, which has been in development for eight years. This has accelerated the introduction of LTE equipment and handsets. LTE is architecturally backward compatible with conventional mobile solutions, and although we are seeing some WiMax deploy- ments, most wireless carriers are committing to LTE for their long-term mobile network evolution. Beyond that, LTE-Advanced promises data rates up to 3 Gbit/s, and we expect LTE/LTE- Advanced to be the leading 4G wireless technology. Ericsson has demonstrating LTE-Advanced, achieving speeds 10 times faster than current LTE systems.
Carriers' commitment to LTE continues to grow. According to a recent report from the Global mobile Suppliers Association (GSA), there are now 166 operators across 62 countries committed to LTE. LTE is now the world's fastest-growing mobile networking technology, as a total of 24 operators have commercially launched LTE networks in 16 countries, according to the GSA. After early enthusiasm in Asia and Europe, the U.S. is now taking the lead on LTE, with In-Stat forecasting that 25 percent of all LTE base stations deployed from 2011-2014 will be in the U.S.
Figure 2.1: Worldwide LTE Subscribers
Source: AT&T HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
8 As Figure 2.1 shows, LTE subscriber numbers are expected to grow rapidly from 2013 onward. The LTE infrastructure market is expected to reach $11.4 billion by 2014 (Infonetics Research, April 2010). Analysts expect 136 million LTE subscribers (Pyramid Research, May 2009) paying $70 billion in service revenue (J uniper Research) an average of $42 per subscriber per month.
LTE will be available on more frequency bands than any previous wireless service. LTE will be available with frequency-division duplexing (FDD), where transmit and receive are on different bands; and time-division duplexing (TDD), where transmit and receive share the same frequency, but are separated in time. LTE also supports half-duplex FDD (HFDD), where the transmissions to and from a specific terminal are on different bands and separated by time.
Key FDD LTE bands will initially be 700MHz in the U.S. and 2.6GHz in Europe. Some capacity will be available in the 900MHz band as traffic is shifted from GSM, and in the 800MHz band as digital spectrum is released by the shift from analog to digital TV. Other FDD LTE bands available include 850MHz and 950MHz. China Mobile is planning to use the 2.3GHz TDD LTE band, and 2.6GHz may be used as some spectrum originally allocated to WiMax becomes available. LTE- Advanced will support additional bands.
The first fully commercial LTE network was launched by TeliaSonera in Sweden in December 2009. Today TeliaSonera provides coverage for more than 30 cities in Sweden, Norway and Denmark, delivering data rates up to 100 Mbit/s. Other operators deploying commercial mobile broadband networks based on LTE include MetroPCS, Verizon and AT&T in North America, Vodafone and Deutsche Telekom in Europe, and NTT Docomo in J apan. A number of WiMax operators are also moving toward LTE. These include Yota in Russia and Clearwire in North America, which is investigating the introduction of an LTE-Advanced network.
Initial networks are using single-band USB dongles for subscriber terminals and dual-mode LTE handsets. Multiband LTE dongles and multimode handsets are in development covering GSM, WCDMA/UMTS and LTE. General availability of multiprotocol handsets will be from 2012. According to a recent report from the GSA, 45 manufacturers had announced 161 LTE-enabled user devices by J uly 2011 a 64 percent increase since March 2011. 2.2 LTE Technology Primer Key objectives for LTE are higher performance, with 100 Mbit/s peak downlink and 50 Mbit/s uplink initially (Cat 3), and at least 1 Gbit/s downstream for LTE-Advanced. Faster cell edge performance, reduced latency and scalable channel bandwidths of 20 MHz or more will deliver much higher performance and better user experience. LTE is backward compatible and supports handover and roaming to existing mobile networks including 3G and 2G (GSM/EDGE).
LTE provides two to five times greater spectral efficiency than existing advanced 3G networks. With simple network architecture, the reuse of existing cell sites and multivendor sourcing, LTE will deliver significantly lower cost per bit. LTE has a very wide application with support for both TDD and FDD spectrum modes, mobility up to 350 km per hour and connectivity for a large range modem devices, including phones, PCs and cameras.
The LTE downlink transmission scheme is based on orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM), like WiMax. Carrier bandwidths are flexible. The LTE uplink is a single carrier transmis- sion based on discrete Fourier transform (DFT)-spread OFDM (DFTS-OFDM). This is the most significant difference between implementing mobile WiMax and LTE with a programmable baseband solution.
3GPP Release 8, frozen in December 2008, specified all the key parameters for LTE. The user equipment categories for 3GPP Release 8 are shown in Figure 2.2. 3GPP Release 9, completed at the end of 2009, adds enhancements to LTE particularly for home base stations (femtocells). HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
Maximum network capacity is determined by the channel bandwidth and coding. The channel bandwidth can be 1.4, 3, 5, 10, 15 and 20 MHz and is fixed for a particular network. The coding can be QPSK, 16QAM, or 64QAM and may switch dynamically depending on link performance, with 64QAM providing the highest performance.
LTE link performance is significantly enhanced with the use of multiple-input/multiple output (MIMO) antennas. The base implementation for LTE is a 1x2 MIMO configuration, with a single transmitter and two receivers. The two receiver streams are combined, reducing the requirement for error correction and retransmission. Additional transmit antennas are used for transmit diversity and beam-forming. 2x2 MIMO configurations have two receivers and two transmitters. Initial LTE implementations specifying Cat 3 equipment with 2x2 MIMO will reach 100 Mbit/s for the downlink and 50 Mbit/s for the uplink under ideal conditions.
The LTE base station, called the eNodeB, integrates the function of both the 3G base station (NodeB) and the 3G distributed radio network controller (RNC). The eNodeB radio interface architecture shown in Figure 2.3.
Figure 2.3: LTE Radio Interface Architecture
Source: Earlswood Marketing HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
10 The LTE radio interface architecture consists of five main layers. The Radio Resource Control (RRC) handles admission control and hand over. The Packet and Data Convergence Protocol (PDCP) handles header compression, ciphering and integrity protection. The Radio Link Control (RLC) handles segmentation and retransmission, as well as in-sequence delivery. The Media Access Control (MAC) handles link scheduling and hybrid acknowledge request, and the Physical Layer (PHY) handles the coding, APM modulation and multi-antenna mapping.
LTE is the first wireless network technology that does not include circuit-switched voice. Current LTE network deployments use legacy fallback to a circuit-switched 2G/3G connection to support voice calls. This approach interrupts the LTE data session to make or receive voice calls, and call setup times can be as much as six seconds. Voice can also be supported using voice over IP (VoIP) with Skype, or a similar Internet VoIP service. Neither of these approaches is viewed by carriers as a long-term solution, as one requires the circuit-switched infrastructure to remain and the other gives control of voice to a third-party provider.
The GSM Association (GSMA) has adopted Voice over LTE (VoLTE) as the standardized method for delivering voice services over LTE. VoLTE requires carriers to implement IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) infrastructure. IMS has already been deployed by some mobile carriers; however, the benefits of IMS including the GSMA-defined Rich Communications Suite (RCS) services have not been enough to persuade most carriers to deploy it. The combination of LTE, VoLTE and IMS is expected to prove attractive to most carriers over time. Other solutions for delivering voice services over LTE without using IMS, such as the VoLGA (VoLTE via Generic Access) initiative, are no longer seeing much interest.
To meet the requirement for lower capex and opex and to support the high bandwidth require- ments for LTE, 3GPP has developed a new network architecture, System Architecture Evolution (SAE), shown in Figure 2.4. The SAE consists of the radio access network (RAN) and Evolved Packet Core (EPC). The EPC will connect with an IMS network or directly to the Internet. The Mobility Management Entity (MME) is the control plane node for the EPC. The EPC user plane consists of the serving gateway connecting the EPC to the LTE RAN and the packet data network gateway connecting the EPC to the Internet using the SGI interface. User data is stored in the Home Subscriber Server (HSS), which may be shared with the IMS network.
Figure 2.4: System Architecture Evolution (SAE) Source: Earlswood Marketing
The EPC can also support a combined 3G/LTE network with interfaces to the SGSN and RNC for the HSPA network (see Figure 2.5). A combined HLR/HSS is used by the EPC for both LTE and the GSM/WCDMA network.
HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
11 Figure 2.5: 3G/LTE System Architecture Source: Earlswood Marketing 2.3 LTE-Advanced LTE-Advanced, which will deliver up to 3 Gbit/s, is nearing completion. The features of LTE- Advanced include:
Carrier aggregation: The use of multiple carrier bands, either contiguous or non- contiguous, giving carrier bandwidths up to 100MHz. Improved spectral efficiency Higher-order MIMO: Extended utilization of antennas, including multi-user MIMO (MU- MIMO) up to 8x8 downlink and 4x4 uplink Multi-hop transmission (relay) Inter-cell interference management, multi-cell cooperation and self-organizing network (SON) New user equipment categories as shown below: o Cat 6 300 Mbit/s downlink, 50 Mbit/s uplink o Cat 7 300 Mbit/s downlink, 100 Mbit/s uplink o Cat 8 3 Gbit/s downlink, 1.5 Gbit/s uplink
Basic LTE-Advanced functionality is covered by 3GPP Release 10, which was mostly frozen in J une 2011. Further enhancements, including multi-cell cooperation (CoMP), are covered by Release 11, which is expected to be frozen by the end of 2011. In November 2010, LTE- Advanced was ratified as an IMT-Advanced technology by the ITU. 2.4 LTE IP Solutions LTE intellectual property (IP) has been important in the development of semiconductor devices. Much of this IP was initially developed for WiMax and has been adapted to LTE. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
12 There are several companies that provide LTE IP, including:
Al tera Corp.: Altera is a leading FPGA vendor. The company has developed IP blocks for a range of WiMax- and LTE-related functions, including Turbo encoder/decoder and a scalable OFDMA engine. Tensilica Inc.: Tensilica is a semiconductor IP company that provides customizable data plane processors. In February 2010, the company released details of the Atlas LTE ref- erence architecture using Tensilica processor cores that will support Cat 4 LTE handsets. The company claims that eight of the top 15 LTE chipset manufacturers are working with its digital signal processing (DSP) core for their LTE designs. Tensilica processor cores are also used by DesignArt for its base station devices (see Section 4.2). Xilinx Inc.: Xilinx, the leading FPGA vendor, provides IP and reference design for net- working applications. The company has developed IP blocks for a range of LTE-related functions, including MIMO encoder/decoder, downlink channel encoder and uplink channel decoder. Xilinx FPGAs are used in a growing number of LTE base station implementations. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
13 III. Base Station Devices & Solutions 3.1 LTE Base Station PHY Devices LTE networks are being built using a heterogeneous mix of small and large base stations (eNodeBs), as shown in Fi gure 3.1. The first LTE networks are using micro base stations that support up to 600 users. Macro base stations with more than 1,000 users will be needed for some high-density, urban locations, but micro base stations will be the most common. A recent devel- opment is the picocell, supporting up to 128 users, and femtocells for fewer than 32 users. Pico base stations can be located indoors or outdoors on a light pole to provide a local hotspot. Enterprise femtocells and home femtocells provide local connectivity within buildings.
Figure 3.1: LTE Base Stations BASE STATION TYPE LOCATION COVERAGE USERS Home Femto Home Home 4-8 Enterprise Femto Enterprise Office buildings 8-32 Pico Indoor Hotspot 32-128 Pico Street (Light Pole) Immediate area 32-128 Micro Street, cabinet or light pole Suburban or Rural Area (40km) 400-600 Macro Street cabinet or central office High-Density Urban Areas >1,000 Source: Heavy Reading
LTE components must be very flexible, handling multiple standards, frequency bands and channel bandwidths. Baseband devices should therefore be software-programmable, handling involved specifications and channel allocations, as well as scalable and very low-latency.
Figure 3.2 shows the devices in a typical eNodeB. On the left is the network interface; in the middle is the baseband, including MAC and PHY devices; and on the right is the RF front end.
Figure 3.2: eNodeB Source: Earlswood Marketing
The RF front end has integrated power amplifiers, filtering and control for transmit and receive. To support 2x2 MIMO, the RF front end should integrate at least two transmit and receive and signal paths. The RF front end may have an analog interface to the baseband device or integrate the HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
14 digital to analog converters (analog front end [AFE]) and have a digital interface to the baseband device. The baseband consists of an OFDM-based PHY and MAC function. The network inter- face handles networking functions including address translation, packet processing, traffic management and interfaces to the backhaul network. The control processor provides system, network management, and handles exception and control plane functions.
Many LTE base stations also support 2G and 3G legacy networks, including GSM, CDMA and HSPA+. This multimode requirement significantly increases the work required to qualify new systems and gives existing 2G and 3G wireless baseband component suppliers a significant advantage.
Larger LTE base stations (macro, micro) use separate devices for PHY, MAC and RF front end. Smaller pico base stations can be implemented using integrated devices with DSP, packet processing, network input/output (I/O) and control processor. Future devices may also integrate the RF front end.
The rest of this section is split into three subsections covering LTE base station PHY devices, LTE base station MAC devices and integrated devices for LTE base stations. 3.2 LTE Base Station PHY Devices Figures 3.3 is a summary of the leading PHY devices for LTE. These include devices from DesignArt and Picochip that have been developed for this application, along with general-purpose devices from Freescale and Texas Instruments that have been enhanced to support 4G wireless networks including LTE. Throughput ranges from 100 Mbit/s downstream and 50 Mbit/s upstream (LTE Cat 3) to 300 Mbit/s downstream and 150 Mbit/s upstream (LTE-Advanced Cat 7). The DesignArt DAN3100 and Texas Instruments TCI6618 will also support the 40MHz channel bandwidth required for LTE-Advanced.
Figure 3.3: LTE PHY Devi ce Summary COMPANY/ DEVICE THROUGH- PUT (DOWN/UP) CHANNEL BANDWIDTHS NETWORKS PROCESS POWER AVAIL- ABILITY DesignArt DAN3100 N/A 3.5, 5, 7, 10, 20, 40MHz GSM, [W]CDMA, WiMax, LTE, LTE-Advanced 40nm 5W max Sampling Freescale MSC8156/4 N/D N/D LTE, HSPA+and WiMax 45nm N/D Production Freescale MSC8157 N/D N/D LTE, HSPA+, LTE- Advanced and WiMax 45nm N/D Sampling Picochip PC203 100 Mbit/s/ 50 Mbit/s Up to 10MHz HSDPA, HSUPA, CDMA2000, TD-SCDMA, WiFi, GSM, GPRS, EDGE, LTE, EGPRS 90nm N/D Production Picochip PC500 150 Mbit/s/ 75 Mbit/s Up to 20MHz HSPA/LTE/ LTE- Advanced 90nm N/D Sampling Texas Instruments TCI6616 150 Mbit/s/ 75 Mbit/s Up to 20MHz LTE, WCDMA/HSPA+, GSM/EDGE, TD-SCDMA, WiMax, CDMA2000 40nm N/D Production Texas Instruments TCI6618 300 Mbit/s/ 150 Mbit/s Up to 40MHz LTE, WCDMA/HSPA+, GSM/EDGE, TD-SCDMA, WiMax, CDMA2000 40nm N/D Production Source: Heavy Reading HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
15 Typical power consumption is 7.5W to 10W for a three-sector implementation. These programm- able devices can also be used to support WiMax, WCDMA, CDMA2000, GPRS, EDGE and WiFi, as well as LTE. The DesignArt DAN3100 is designed for use on a remote radio head and maxi- mum power is 5W. Most devices use 40nm or 45nm semiconductor technology. The Picochip devices use 90nm.
Figure 3.4 shows more detail on LTE PHY devices. All these devices implement the LTE PHY in programmable DSP cores. The Freescale and Texas Instruments devices are enhanced versions of general-purpose DSP processors. Picochip use an array of processors optimized for DSP processing (picoArray), and DesignArt has licensed reduced instruction set computing (RISC) and DSP cores from Tensilica.
Most devices will support 2x2 MIMO and both TDD and FDD. The Texas Instruments TCI6618 will support 4x4 MIMO. All the devices integrate a security acceleration engine and significant internal memory. The network interfaces to the MAC are typically Gigabit Ethernet (GE), and host interfaces are PCI Express (PCIe), Serial RapidIO (SRIO) or GE. All the devices provide a digital interface to the RF front end. The most common interface is Common Public Radio Interface (CPRI), but other interfaces are supported, including FRMI, Open Base Station Architecture Initiative (OBSAI) and SRIO.
Figure 3.4: LTE PHY Devi ce Features COMPANY/ DEVICE PHY MIMO SEC- TORS NETWORK & HOST INTERFACE RF INTER- FACE INTER- NAL MEMORY DesignArt DAN3100 6 x Tensilica RISC cores, 6 x Tensilica DSP cores N/A 16 2 x GE; 2 x SRIO 4 x DFE; 8 x PRI; 2 x SRIO 3.5 MB Freescale MSC8156/4 6 x SC3850 StarCore DSP, MAPLE-B accelerator N/D N/D 2 x GE, PCIe x4, 2xSRIOx4 None 4MB Freescale MSC8157 6 x SC3850 StarCore DSP, MAPLE-B2 accelerator N/D N/D 2 x GE, PCIe2.1 x4, 2xSRIOx4@5G 6x CPRI 4.1@6G 6MB Picochip PC203 picoArray 2x2 (extenda- ble to more) Scal- able FE and MII or local bus 3xADI, FRMI N/D Picochip PC500 picoArray 2x2 (extenda- ble to more) Scal- able FE and MII or local bus 3xADI, FRMI N/D Texas Instruments TCI6616 4xC66x DSP cores plus coprocessors 2x2/1x2 (FDD); 2x8/ 8x2 (TDD) 1 SRIO, 2xGE CPRI/ OBSAI 6MB Texas Instruments TCI6618 4xC66x DSP cores plus coprocessors 4x4/2x2 (FDD); 2x8/ 8x2 (TDD) 2 SRIO, 2xGE CPRI/ OBSAI 6MB One or more C66x DSP cores may be shared between PHY and MAC Source: Heavy Reading 3.3 LTE Base Station MAC & Control Devices This section covers devices that can be used as LTE base station MAC and control devices. They all integrate a control processor with hardware acceleration for networking functions. These devices can be used to implement the network interface including service applications and operations, administration and maintenance (OAM), control processing and system management, and the LTE MAC layer. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
16 Figure 3.5 shows a number of devices that are suitable for LTE base station MAC and control functions. All of the companies in this table supply a range of multicore processors that include devices with both higher and lower performance and integration than those shown in this table. For more information on multicore devices, see the vendor-specific information in Section IV, or the report Multicore Processors for Network Systems: A Heavy Reading Competitive Analysis.
All these devices support a wide range of network and host interfaces, including GE, SRIO and PCIe. The hardware acceleration is implemented in either hardcoded blocks or programmable engines, such as the PMC-Sierra SMT engines. The processor core count ranges from two e500v cores in the Freescale QorIQ P2020 to 10 cnMIPS64 v2 cores in the Cavium Octeon II CN6645. The Cavium CN6645 and NetLogic XLP316L devices support IEEE 1588v2 hardware time stamping for Ethernet backhaul timing.
Figure 3.5: LTE MAC & Control Devices COMPANY/ DEVICE CONTROL & MAC ETHERNET INTERFACE OTHER HOST/ NETWORK INTERFACE INTER- NAL MEMORY PRO- CESS POWER AVAIL- ABILITY Cavium Octeon II CN6645 10x cnMIPS64 v2 cores 2x10GE or 8xGE 2x(PCIex4 or SRIOx4 2MB 65nm 7W Produc- tion Freescale QorIQ P2020 2x e500v2 cores 3xGE 3xPCIe 512KB 45nm 8W max Produc- tion LSI ACP3442 4x PowerPC 476 cores 8xGE SRIOx4, 3xPCIex4 4MB 45nm N/D Produc- tion NetLogic XLP316L 4x MIPS64 cores 2x10GE, 8x2.5GE, 16xGE, 72xFE PCIe x1, 2xSRIOx4. 16xTDM, Utopia/SPI-3 6MB 40nm 4.5- 9.5W Produc- tion PMC-Sierra WinPath3 2 x MIPS34KC 650MHz cores, 12 proprietary SMT engines @ 450MHz 2x10GE, 8x2.5GE, 16xGE, 72xFE, PCIe x1, 2xSRIOx4, 16xTDM, Utopia/SPI-3 2MB 65nm 4.5- 9.5W Produc- tion Supports IEEE 1588v2 hardware time stamping for Ethernet backhaul timing synchronization Source: Heavy Reading 3.4 Integrated LTE Base Station Devices Seven vendors have released details of integrated LTE base station devices, ideal for femtocells and the growing picocell market. These are summarized in Figure 3.6.
Figure 3.6: Integrated LTE Base Stations Device Summary COMPANY/ DEVICE THROUGH- PUT (DOWN/UP) CHANNEL BANDWIDTHS NETWORKS MIMO PRO- CESS POW- ER AVAIL- ABILITY Cavium OCTEON Fusion CNF7280 300Mbit/s Down, 300Mbit/s up Up to 2x20MHz LTE, LTE Adv., WCDMA Not dis- closed 28 nm 7W max Late 2012 Cavium OCTEON Fusion CNF7130 150Mbit/s Down, 150Mbit/s up Up to 20MHz LTE, WCDMA Not dis- closed 40nm 10W max Dec '11/J an '12 HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
17 COMPANY/ DEVICE THROUGH- PUT (DOWN/UP) CHANNEL BANDWIDTHS NETWORKS MIMO PRO- CESS POW- ER AVAIL- ABILITY Cavium OCTEON Fusion CNF7120 100Mbit/s Down, 75Mbit/s up Up to 20MHz LTE, WCDMA Not dis- closed 40nm 6W max Dec '11/J an '12 DesignArt DAN3300 300 Mbit/s total 3.5, 5, 7, 10, 20MHz GSM, [W]CDMA, WiMax, LTE, LTE-Advanced MU- MIMO 40nm 5W max Sam- pling DesignArt DAN3400 600 Mbit/s total 5, 7, 10, 14, 20, 28, 40, 56, 80, 125, 250, 500MHz GSM, [W]CDMA, WiMax, LTE, LTE-Advanced MU- MIMO 40nm 8W max Sam- pling DesignArt DAN3800 1.25 Gbit/s total All [W]CDMA, WiMax, LTE, LTE-Advanced MU- MIMO, CoMP 40nm 8W max Sam- pling Freescale QorIQ Converge PSC9130/31 100 Mbit/s/ 50 Mbit/s N/D LTE-FDD, LTE-TDD, HSPA+ 2x2 45nm N/D 3Q11 Freescale QorIQ Converge PSC9132 150 Mbit/s/ 75 Mbit/s N/D LTE-FDD, LTE-TDD, HSPA+ 2x4 45nm N/D 3Q11 Mindspeed Transcede 3000 N/D 5, 7, 10, 14, 20, 28, 40, 56, 80, 125, 250, 500 HSPA+, LTE- Advanced and WiMax 2x2 40nm 8W typ August 2011 Mindspeed M84xxx Transcede 4000/4020 N/D Up to 10MHz (600MHz Transcede 4000); up to 20MHz (750MHz Transcede 4020) WCDMA, LTE-FDD, LTE-TDD, TD- SCDMA and WiMax 2x2 40nm 15W max (12W max Tran- scede 4000) August 2011 Octasic OCT2224W 300 Mbit/s/ 75 Mbit/s Up to 20MHz GSM, EDGE, eEDGE, CDMA CDMA1x, EVDO, UMTS, HSPA, WiMax and LTE 2x2 (4x4 with two devices) 90nm 3W 3Q11 Picochip PC5x2 150 Mbit/s/ 75 Mbit/s Up to 20MHz HSPA/LTE/ LTE- Advanced 2x2 (extend- able to more) N/D N/D N/D Texas Instruments TCI6612 150 Mbit/s/ 75 Mbit/s Up to 20MHz LTE, WCDMA/ HSPA+, GSM/ EDGE, WiMax, TD- SCDMA, CDMA2000 2x2/1x2 (FDD); 2x2/2x2 (TDD) 40nm N/D 4Q11 Texas Instruments TCI6614 300 Mbit/s/ 150 Mbit/s Up to 20MHz LTE, WCDMA/ HSPA+, GSM/ EDGE, WiMax, TD- SCDMA, CDMA2000 4x4/2x2 (FDD); 2x8/8x2 (TDD) 40nm N/D 3Q11 Source: Heavy Reading HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
18 All these programmable devices will support 2x2 MIMO and TDD/FDD. The Texas Instruments TCI6614 will support 4x4 MIMO, and several other devices will support 4x4 MIMO with multiple devices. DesignArt claims support for MU-MIMO. All the devices will support multimode base stations with a mix of WCDMA, CDMA2000, GPRS, EDGE and WiMax. The Cavium OCTEON Fusion CNF7280, due to sample in late 2012, is the first integrated device to be announced with support the 40MHz channel bandwidth required for LTE-Advanced. Typical power consumption for a three-sector implementation is 5W to 15W. Octasic claims the lowest power consumption, at 3W.
Figure 3.7 shows additional information on the integrated LTE devices. All these devices have a mix of RISC cores, DSP cores and either hardware acceleration or network processor cores (NPU) for networking functions. The DesignArt devices are configured to support pico, micro or larger base stations with 1, 4 or 16 sectors. The other devices are designed to support femto, pico or micro base stations. The Cavium OCTEON Fusion and Freescale QorIQ Converge devices support IEEE1588v2 clock synchronization for Ethernet-based backhaul.
Figure 3.7: Integrated LTE Device Features COMPANY/ DEVICE CONTROL & MAC PHY SECTORS NETWORK & HOST INTERFACE RF INTER- FACE INTERNAL MEMORY Cavium OCTEON Fusion CNF7280 Six cnMIPS64 v2 cores @ 2GHz 8x DSP cores @ 1GHz with hardware accelerators 2 4xGE with 1588v2, optional OFDM Backhaul J ESD 207P/ CPRI Not disclosed Cavium OCTEON Fusion CNF7130 Four cnMIPS64 v2 cores @ 1.5GHz 6x DSP cores @ 500MHz with hardware accelerators 2 (with off- chip PHY) 2xGE with 1588v2 J ESD 207P/ CPRI Not disclosed Cavium OCTEON Fusion CNF7120 Two cnMIPS64 v2 cores @ 1GHz 4x DSP cores @ 500MHz w/ hardware accelerators 1 2xGE with 1588v2 J ESD 207P/ CPRI Not disclosed DesignArt DAN3300 4 x ARM926; 6 x Tensilica NPU cores 6x Tensilica RISC cores; 6 x Tensilica DSP cores 1 2 x GE 4 x PRI 3.5 Mbytes DesignArt DAN3400 4 x ARM926; 6 x Tensilica NPU cores 6x Tensilica RISC cores; 6 x Tensilica DSP cores 4 2 x GE, SRIOx4 4 x DFE; 8 x PRI; 3 x SRIOx4 3.5 Mbytes DesignArt DAN3800 4 x ARM926; 6 x Tensilica NPU cores 6x Tensilica RISC cores; 6 x Tensilica DSP cores 16 2 x GE 4 x SRIOx4 3.5 Mbytes Freescale QorIQ Converge PSC9130/31 e500v2 RISC core SC3850 StarCore DSP, MAPLE-B2F accelerator 1 2xGE with IEEE1588v2 3x J ESD207 0.75 Mbytes Freescale QorIQ Converge PSC9132 2x e500v2 RISC cores 2x SC3850 StarCore DSP, MAPLE-B2P accelerator 1 2xGE with IEEE1588v2, PCIe 5Gx2 4x J ESD207, 2x CPRI v4.1 @ 6G 1.5 Mbytes HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
19 COMPANY/ DEVICE CONTROL & MAC PHY SECTORS NETWORK & HOST INTERFACE RF INTER- FACE INTERNAL MEMORY Mindspeed Transcede 3000 ARM Cortex- A9 Quad MPCore, Security Engine 5 Ceva DSP cores, 5 Mindspeed applica- tion processors, FEC engine Up to 3 2xGE, 4xTDM, 2x SRIOx4, PCIe x4 4x CPRI 4.1 7Mbytes Mindspeed M84xxx Transcede 4000/4020 ARM Cortex- A9 Quad MPCore, Security Engine 10 Ceva DSP cores + ARM Cortex-A9 Dual MPCore,10 Mindspeed application processors, FEC engine Up to 3 2xGE, 2x SRIOx4, PCIe x4 6x CPRI 4.1 7Mbytes Octasic OCT2224W ARM11 500MHz 24 Opus2 DSP cores Up to 3 4xGE, PCIe x1, SRIOx4 3x J ESD207 3.5Mbytes Picochip PC5x2 N/D picoArray Scalable FE FRMI None Texas Instruments TCI6612 Cortex A8 2xC66x DSP cores plus coprocessors 1 SRIO, 2xGE OBSAI, CPRI, SPI 4.25MB Texas Instruments TCI6614 Cortex A8 4xC66x DSP cores plus coprocessors 1 SRIO, 2xGE OBSAI, CPRI, SPI 6.25MB One or more C66x DSP cores may be shared between PHY and MAC Source: Heavy Reading HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
20 IV. Base Station Silicon Vendors This section covers the leading base station silicon vendors. Figure 4.1 shows which type of device is shipping or in development from each of the leading vendors.
Figure 4.1: Base Station Silicon Vendors COMPANY MAC/ CONTROL PHY INTEGRATED MAC/ CONTROL/PHY RF Analog Devices
Source: Heavy Reading 4.1 Cavium Inc. Cavium is one of the leading suppliers of security, network services and content processing semiconductor devices. It has a successful line of multicore processors, security processors, ARM-based communications processors and video and content processors that address 10 Mbit/s to 40 Gbit/s performance for wired and wireless network equipment. In J anuary 2011, the company acquired WiMax and LTE baseband vendor Wavesat. The Wavesat devices are covered in Section 6.3.
Cavium has developed three generations of Octeon processor, and all three generations are software-compatible. The Octeon Plus, introduced in 2006, has an enhanced MIPS64 core with a larger data cache and additional packet processing and quality-of-service accelerators. Octeon II, announced in March 2009, has a further enhanced core, larger data and instruction caches, and additional hardware acceleration engines. The Octeon II devices have 2 to 32 cnMIPS64 v2 cores running up to 1.5GHz.
The Cavium CN6645 covered in this report is one of the latest Octeon II devices (see Figure 4.2). The device is configured for 3G/4G/LTE wireless base stations and integrates 10 cnMIPS64 v2 cores. The device has hardware acceleration for packet processing and security. Other devices in the CN66xx series have two or four cnMIPS64v2 cores. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
21 Figure 4.2: Octeon II CN66XX Block Diagram
Source: Cavium
In October 2011 Cavium announced the first of a new family of devices specifically designed for the LTE/3G base station market. The Cavium OCTEON Fusion devices integrate the MIPS64r4 cores from OCTEON II and a new wireless baseband PHY architecture based on multiple DSP cores and software developed with expertise from baseband vendor Wavesat, which was acquired by Cavium in J anuary 2011.
The company has released details on three OCTEON Fusion devices. The 40nm Cavium OCTEON Fusion CNF7120/30 devices support LTE Release 9 and 3G and will be sampling December 2011 or J anuary 2012. The 28nm Cavium OCTEON Fusion CNF7280 device will add support for LTE Advanced and will be available late in 2012. All the devices can be programmed to support the full functionality for LTE/3G wireless base stations including digital front end and Ethernet backhaul. 4.2 DesignArt Networks Ltd. DesignArt is an Israeli fabless semiconductor company with about 70 employees. The company has developed several system-on-a-chip (SoC) solutions for WiMax and LTE network infrastruc- ture and point-to-point backhaul. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
22 DesignArt's core product is the DAN3xxx family developed for LTE and backhaul applications. The DAN3000 architecture is a second-generation solution based on the DAN240 developed for WiMax and in production since 2008.
The DAN3000 family uses a three-issue VLIW Single Instruction Multiple Data (SIMD) DSP architecture is based on technology licensed from Tensilica. Some of the devices also integrate two ARM926 cores for control and LTE MAC. The first devices started sampling toward the end of 2010 and production is planned for the third quarter of 2011.
A full list of DAN3000 devices is shown in Figure 4.3. The devices are pin-compatible and based on the same design.
Figure 4.3: DesignArt DAN3000 Famil y DEVICE APPLICATION THROUGH- PUT SECTORS INTERNAL MEMORY EXTERNAL MEMORY PROCESSOR DesignArt DAN3100 Remote radio head N/A 16 3.5 Mbytes None 2 x ARM,12 x Tensilica cores DesignArt DAN3200 Unified backhaul 1.25 Gbit/s Up to 4 PTP Links 3.5 Mbytes 2xDDR3 4 x ARM,18 x Tensilica cores DesignArt DAN3300 Single-mode picocells 300 Mbit/s total 1 3.5 Mbytes 2xDDR3 4 x ARM,18 x Tensilica cores DesignArt DAN3400 Multi-mode, multi- carrier pico- and micro BTS 600 Mbit/s total 4 3.5 Mbytes 3.5 Mbytes 4 x ARM,18 x Tensilica cores DesignArt DAN3800 High-capacity baseband pooling 1.25 Gbit/s total 16 3.5 Mbytes 3.5 Mbytes 4 x ARM,18 x Tensilica cores Source: Heavy Reading 4.3 Freescale Semiconductor Inc. Freescale is a leading supplier of embedded processors for wireless, networking, automotive, consumer and industrial applications. The company was formed out of Motorola's semiconductor businesses and acquired by a consortium of private equity funds led by the Blackstone Group in December 2006. The company has two processor architectures; the PowerPC-based RISC architecture and the StarCore DSP architecture.
The Freescale QorIQ multicore platform was announced in 2008 and is built around a switch fabric, multiple PowerPC e500mc cores and a shared Layer 3 cache. Multiple network connec- tions are provided with PCIe, RapidIO, Ethernet and an embedded Quicc engine to handle low- level network protocols. Many companies are using Freescale PowerQuicc processors for 2G, 3G and now 4G base stations. The existing QorIQ multicore processor family includes devices with 2, 4, 6 or 8 32-bit cores. The next generation, announced in J une 2011 and due to start sampling in the first quarter of 2012, will have up to 12 64-bit cores.
The MSC8156 DSP device was announced in November 2008. The device integrates six SC3850 StarCore DSP cores, a multi-accelerator platform engine (MAPLE-B) for Turbo and Viterbi decoding and FFT/DFT acceleration, and a dual RISC core Quicc engine for I/O processing. The MSC8157 DSP has an enhanced MAPLE-B2 hardware engine solution, and the company is seeing strong design wins for LTE. A similar device is available for WCDMA and HSAP+3G applications (MSC8158).
Freescale has released an Advanced Mezzanine Card (AMC)-based reference design for LTE, WiMax, WCDMA and TD-SCDMA pico base stations. The reference design includes a QorIQ HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
23 P2020 dual-core processor for packet processing and MSC8156 DSP for LTE PHY. For macro base stations, multiple MSC8156 devices can be used with the larger P4080 8-core multicore processor. The company has developed a full software suite for LTE, HSPA+and WiMax.
In February 2011 Freescale announced the QorIQ Qonverge devices that integrate both StarCore DSP and QorIQ multicore RISC cores. The first products are the PSC9130/PSC9131 devices for femtocells and PSC9132 for picocells. Freescale has been working closely with Alcatel-Lucent on SoC solutions for base stations and Airvana has announced that its multi-mode femtocells will be based on the new QorIQ Qonverge devices.
These first Qonverge multicore devices are built in 45nm process technology and planned for availability in the third quarter of 2011. Freescale plans to introduce further QorIQ Qonverge devices targeting larger cell (metro and macro) base stations built in 28nm process technology later in 2011. 4.4 LSI Corp. LSI provides silicon-based solutions for the storage and networking markets. The company's solutions for networking include PHY devices, custom application-specific integrated circuits (ASICs), content processors, DSPs, network processors and multicore communication proces- sors. Most of the networking products were acquired when LSI bought Agere Systems.
Figure 4.4: LSI ACP34xx Axxia Multicore Processor
Source: LSI Logic HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
24 The LSI ACP3400 Axxia multicore processor (see Figure 4.4 above) was announced in Septem- ber 2009. The architecture is built around a switch fabric and a message passing protocol that implements a virtual pipeline. The initial devices started sampling in February 2010 and have 2 or 4 PowerPC 476 32-bit cores.
The LSI ACP3442 is recommended for 3G and 4G/LTE base stations and has 4 PowerPC 476 32-bit cores. LSI also has a range of DSP products that can be used in wireless base stations, however none of these is currently recommended for LTE base station designs. 4.5 Mindspeed Technologies Inc. Mindspeed provides networking devices for communications applications in enterprise, access, metro, wide-area and wireless networks. The Transcede 4000 wireless broadband processors are a development of the Comcerto VoIP processing devices. The Transcede 4000 devices integrate up to 10 Ceva DSP cores, up to 10 Mindspeed application processing engines, a security engine and two ARM Cortex A9 multicore processors. PHY processing is handled by a dual-core ARM Cortex A9 multicore processor. MAC and packet processing is handled by a quad-core ARM Cortex A9 multicore processor.
The Transcede 4000 family includes the Transcede 4000/4020 for 4G macro and larger pico base stations and the Transcede 3000 for smaller base stations. All these devices will handle PHY, MAC and packet processing for LTE. All the devices integrate GE, SRIO and CPRI interfaces. Mindspeed will supply baseline LTE PHY code and Interphase has developed an AMC module based on the Transcede 4000. 4.6 NetLogic Microsystems Inc. NetLogic Microsystems is a leading supplier of networking silicon devices including multicore processors, content processors, network search engines, embedded processors and high-speed GE PHY devices. The company went public in 2004 and merged with RMI in J une 2009. In March 2011, NetLogic entered an agreement to acquire Optichron, which develops digital front end (DFE) components for wireless base stations. In September 2011 Broadcom announced that it would acquire NetLogic for approximately $3.7 billion.
Figure 4.5: NetLogic XLP Multicore Processor
Source: NetLogic HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
25 Figure 4.5 (above) shows the latest NetLogic multicore processor family. The 40nm XLP proces- sor builds on the 90nm XLR architecture developed by RMI. The NetLogic multicore architecture is built around a shared memory switch that connects up to 8 MIPS64 cores and distributed interconnects to the 8MB Layer 3 cache, memory controllers and networking I/O. Each MIPS64 supports 4 separate hardware threads, giving the devices up to 32 virtual 16 NXCPU cores.
The NetLogic XLP316L processor has four MIPS64 cores, 8 GE interfaces or two XAUI 10GE interfaces, and both SRIO and PCIe interfaces. The device is targeted at 3G and 4G/LTE wireless base stations. 4.7 Octasic Inc. Octasic provides media and wireless baseband processing silicon and software solutions. The company's multi-core DSP solutions are based on a unique asynchronous DSP architecture. Octasic is shipping DSP-based voice processing and media processing solutions. In J une 2010, the company announced the OCT2224W multi-core DSP devices for femto, micro and pico base station PHY and MAC.
Figure 4.6: Octasi c OCT2224W Block Di agram
Source: Octasic HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
26 The OCT2224W has 6x4 Opus2 DSP cores and a single ARM 11 core for control and MAC processing. The device has very low power consumption at 3W and is expected to be available to customers from the third quarter of 2011. 4.8 Picochip Ltd. Picochip, founded in 2000, has developed a range of wireless base station PHY solutions based on the PicoArray multicore DSP architecture. Its many WiMax design wins include Airspan, Intel, Ericsson, Nortel and Redline Communications. The company coined the term "femtocell" and is a key supplier of silicon for 3G femtocells having shipped more than one million chips. Picochip has said it plans to go for an initial public offering (IPO) sometime in 2011.
The PC203 base station PHY processor is optimized for multimode femtocells. It integrates 273 picoArray processors, security acceleration, Ethernet MAC and three analog interfaces. Picochip provides firmware and reference designs for a range of applications including LTE, WiMax, HSPA, WCDMA and TD-SCMA. A larger device (PC202) that integrates an ARM926 processor core is also available. Both devices are in production. The company is shipping an eNodeB development system based on the PC203.
The PC500, shown in Figure 4.7, is an optimized version of the PC203 in the same 90nm technology. The PC500 will support dual-mode LTE/HSPA and channel bandwidths up to 20 MHz. The maximum throughput is 150 Mbit/s downstream and 75 Mbit/s upstream. The PC500 is designed for femtocells, but larger systems can be built using multiple devices. The device is currently sampling to customers.
Figure 4.7: Pi cochip PC500 Block Di agram
Source: Picochip
Picochip is working on a third-generation product family. The PC5x2 devices will be optimized for specific applications and will integrate processors for control and MAC processing. A release date has not been announced, but the first devices are expected to arrive in late 2011 or early 2012. 4.9 PMC-Sierra Inc. PMC-Sierra is a leading network silicon vendor shipping a mix of MIPS-based processors, high- speed mixed signal devices and communication semiconductors including TDM, Sonet/SDH, HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
27 Ethernet and PON. In November 2010, PMC-Sierra completed the acquisition of Wintegra, a fabless semiconductor company founded in J anuary 2000 that develops single-chip communica- tions processors for access networks. Key customers include Cisco, Alcatel-Lucent and Tellabs.
The 65nm WinPath3 is a third-generation device. WinPath3 integrates up to 12 RISC engines and two MIPS 34K cores. PMC-Sierra has developed software for the LTE MAC and backhaul packet processing, It has also introduced a half-size device, the WinPath3-SL. Volume pricing is less than $50 for WinPath3 and less than $25 for WinPath3 SL. AMC modules for LTE base stations using the WinPath3 are available from Accipiter, CommAgility, Interphase and Xalyo. 4.10 Texas Instruments Inc. Texas Instruments is a leading supplier of multicore DSP devices for a wide range of applications, including wireless base stations. The company's DSPs are widely used in 2G and 3G base stations, including those supporting HSPA+. C64x+-based AMC modules for use in base stations are available from CommAgility. The latest C66x+-based multicore DSP devices provide an attractive upgrade path, supporting LTE and LTE-Advanced. Texas Instruments also has a range of RF components that have been used in WiMax systems, but it has not yet announced any integrated WiMax or LTE solutions.
The four TCI66xx Keystone devices included in this report (TCI6612/14/16/18) integrate 2 or 4 1.2GHz 66x+cores and acceleration for security and packet processing. Two devices (TCI6612/ 14) also integrate an ARM Cortex A8 RISC core for control and service applications. The devices are suitable for small cells as well as large macro base stations. The TCI6618 will support the 40MHz minimum channel bandwidth required for LTE-Advanced. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
28 V. Handset & CPE Devices This section covers LTE baseband devices and LTE-ready application processors for handsets and customer premises equipment (CPE). Handsets and CPE cover all types of LTE subscriber units, including smartphones, tablets, PDAs and other mobile devices, USB dongles, PC cards, residential gateways and modems. All these devices require cost-effective and very low-power silicon solutions.
Figure 5.1: LTE Subscriber Unit
Source: Earlswood Marketing
Figure 5.1 shows a typical LTE subscriber unit with network interface, baseband, AFE, RF front- end and application processor. The technology is very similar to that used in the base station devices; however, the throughput is lower and integration much higher. All the leading vendors have chipsets that include application processor, baseband, AFE, RF front end and in many cases a power management chip. Most vendors supply chipsets mounted onto a multi-chip module to reduce cost and real estate. 5.1 LTE CPE & Handset Baseband Devices Figure 5.2 summarizes LTE handset and CPE baseband devices from leading vendors. Inte- grated baseband and application processor devices are covered in Section 5.2. LTE subscriber baseband devices are shipping from Altair, Cavium (Wavesat), GCT Semiconductor, Qualcomm and ST-Ericsson. Broadcom (Beceem), Nvidia (Icera), Renesas and Sequans are sampling devices to customers. Samsung and Motorola have in-house LTE baseband. Fujitsu, NEC and Panasonic Mobile Communications have developed an LTE mobile handset SoC design under a collaborative project with NTT Docomo in J apan.
Early devices from GCT, Sequans and ST-Ericsson supported just LTE. Devices from Altair and Cavium support LTE and WiMax. Devices from the rest support a mix of LTE, 3G and 2G networks. The Qualcomm MSM9600 and Nvidia ICE8061 will handle 50 Mbit/s (Cat 2). Most devices will handle 100 Mbit/s (Cat 3). The Broadcom BCM21880, Intel ComMAX LT8000, Marvell PXA1801 and Qualcomm MDM9625 devices will support 150 Mbit/s (Cat 4). The Broad- com BCM21880 is believed to be the only device already sampling the supports LTE category 4. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
29 Most devices will support both FDD and TDD LTE. The Innofidei TD-LTE device is a TDD-only solution. The GCT GDM7240, Nvidia ICE8061 and ST-Ericsson M720 platform do not support TDD LTE. Semiconductor technology used for these devices is moving quickly with the earliest devices using 55/65nm, the latest devices using 40nm and devices from Qualcomm planned for the end of 2011 using 28nm technology.
Figure 5.3 shows LTE CPE and handset device features. Most devices support channel band- widths up to 20MHz. The Cavium Odyssey supports up to 18MHz and the 50Mbit/s Nvidia ICE8061 just 10MHz. VoLTE is supported by devices from Altair, Broadcom, GCT, Renesas and ST-Ericsson. None of these devices is ready for production yet.
Interfaces to the RF device are either analog or digital. The GCT GDM7240 is the only device with integrated RF. Power consumption for the Cavium Odyssey OD9010 is 120mW. None of the other vendors has released power consumption information. Packages are typically 8x8mm or HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
30 9x9mm. The GCT GDM7240 is larger at 13x13mm. Qualcomm has released very little informa- tion on planned products.
Figure 5.3: LTE CPE & Handset Device Features COMPANY/ DEVICE CHANNEL BANDWIDTHS VOLTE MIMO RF INTERFACE POWER PACKAGE Altair FourGee-3100 1.4, 3, 5, 10, 15, 20MHz 4x2 Analog N/D 9x9 VFBGA Broadcom BCM21880 Up to 20 MHz 2x2 N/D N/D N/D Cavium Odyssey OD9010 3, 4, 7, 8, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18MHz N/D 2x2 Digital IQ 120 mW 9x9 mm FPBGA-256 GCT GDM7240 1.4MHz, 3MHz, 5MHz, 10MHz, 15MHz, 20MHz Yes Integrated RF N/D 13x13mm BGA Innofidei TD-LTE N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D Intel ComMAX LT8000 N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D Nvidia ICE8061 1.4, 3, 5, 10MHz Yes Analog IQ N/D 8x8mm BGA Marvell PXA1801 N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D Qualcomm MDM9600 N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D Qualcomm MDM9615 N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D Qualcomm MDM9625 N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D Renesas Mobile SP2531 1.4, 3, 5, 10, 15, 20MHz Yes DigRF N/D BGA Sequans SQN3010 10, 20MHz N/D 2x2 N/D N/D N/D ST-Ericsson M700 Platform 1.4, 3, 5, 10, 15, 20 MHz Yes N/D N/D N/D ST-Ericsson M720 Platform 1.4, 3, 5, 10, 15, 20 MHz Yes N/D N/D N/D ST-Ericsson M7400 1.4, 3, 5, 10, 15, 20 MHz Yes N/D N/D N/D Source: Heavy Reading 5.2 LTE Ready Application Processors LTE smartphones use the highest-performance application processors. Figure 5.4 lists the leading application processors that are suitable for LTE smartphones and tablets. The latest solutions from Qualcomm integrate application processor cores and LTE/3G modem. Several smartphone manufacturers including Apple and Samsung have their own application processors. Other vendors with mobile application processors are Marvell and Freescale.
The Intel Atom Z670 launched in April 2011, and slower Z6xx family members are designed for tablets. The device requires a separate SM35 chipset. The Nvidia Tegra 2 application processor with two ARM A9 cores is widely used in smartphones today. Both devices are in 45nm and are currently in production.
HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
31 The Qualcomm Mobile Station Modem (MSM) chipsets integrate modem, Snapdragon application processor with one, two or four cores, and Adreno graphics processor. The MSM8x55 and MSM8x60 have Scorpion application processors and integrate a 3G modem and Adreno 2xx. The MSM8930, MSM8960 and MSM8974 use the new 28nm Krait application processor cores and integrate LTE (Cat 2, Cat 3 or Cat 4) and 3G modem. The Qualcomm APQ8064 device integrates four Krait cores and can be used with the Qualcomm MDM9625 LTE modem devices for 150Mbit/s LTE (Cat 4) applications before the MSM8974 is available in 2013.
Renesas and ST-Ericsson offer application processors as part of their mobile platforms. The Renesas APE5R and ST-Ericsson A95xx application processors have dual ARM A9 cores. The 28nm ST-Ericsson A9600 application processor, planned for the second half of 2011, will have two ARM A15 cores. The Texas Instruments OMAP44x0 application processors also integrate two ARM A9 processor cores.
Figure 5.4: LTE Ready Application Processor Summary COMPANY/ DEVICE INTEGRATED MODEM PROCESSOR CORE NUMBER OF CORES MAX CORE SPEED PROCESS AVAIL- ABILITY Intel Atom Z670 None Atom 1 1.5GHz 45nm Production Nvidia Tegra 2 None ARM A9 2 1.0GHz 45nm Production Qualcomm MSM8x55 HSPA+, CDMA2000 1X, 1xEVDO Rev. 0/A/B Scorpion 1 1.4GHz 45nm Production Qualcomm MSM8x60 HSPA+, CDMA2000 1X, 1xEVDO Rev. 0/A/B Scorpion 2 1.5GHz 45nm Production Qualcomm MSM8960 LTE Cat 2, TD-SCDMA Krait 2 N/D 28nm Sampling Qualcomm MSM8930 LTE Cat 3, TD-SCDMA Krait 1 N/D 28nm 1H12 Qualcomm MSM8974 LTE Cat 4, DC-HSPA+, 1xAdv/DOrA/B, TD-SCDMA Krait 4 N/D 28nm 1H13 Qualcomm APQ8064 None Krait 4 N/D 28nm 1H12 Renesas APE5R None ARM A9 2 N/D N/D Sampling ST-Ericsson A9500 None ARM A9 2 1.2GHz 45nm Production ST-Ericsson A9540 None ARM A9 2 1.85GHz 32nm 2H11 ST-Ericsson A9600 None ARM A15 2 2.5GHz 28nm 2H11 Texas Instruments OMAP4430 None ARM9 2 1GHz 45nm Sampling Texas Instruments OMAP4460 None ARM9 2 1GHz 45nm 1Q11 Source: Heavy Reading
Figure 5.5 shows the key features of the leading LTE-ready application processors. Intel, Nvidia and Qualcomm use internally developed graphics cores. Renesas, ST-Ericsson and Texas Instruments license the Imagination Technologies PowerVR SGX5 or PowerVR SGX6 ("Rogue") HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
32 multi-processor graphics IP. Later devices support HDMI display output and 720p or 1080 HD video playback at 30 frames per second. The Texas Instruments OMAP devices also support 3D video playback. Several devices support both front and back cameras up to 20 megapixels (MP) and 12MP respectively.
33 VI. Handset & CPE Silicon Vendors This section covers the leading handset and CPE silicon vendors. Figure 6.1 shows which type of device is shipping or in development from each of the leading vendors.
Figure 6.1: Handset/CPE Silicon Vendors COMPANY APPLICATION PROCESSOR BASEBAND INTEGRATED APPLICATION PROCESSOR/BASEBAND RF Altair Analog Devices Broadcom Cavium Fujitsu GCT Genasic Innofidei Intel Marvell Maxim Nvidia Qualcomm Renesas Semtech Sequans ST-Ericsson Texas Instruments Source: Heavy Reading 6.1 Altair Semiconductor Ltd. Altair, formed in May 2005 and based in Israel, recently completed a $26 million funding round, led by J erusalem Venture Partners. It has developed low-power baseband and RF devices for mobile devices. The PHY implementation is based on Altair's proprietary Optimized OFDMA Processor (O 2 P) that was developed specifically for OFDM applications, such as WiMax and LTE.
The FourGee-3100 LTE baseband device integrates MAC, PHY and AFE, security acceleration and 32-bit MIPS RISC core. The FourGee-6200 RF transceiver device has analog baseband interface and supports both TDD and FDD LTE across the full 700MHz to 2.7GHz range. The FourGee-6150 RF transceiver device supports just TDD in the 2.3-2.7GHz range. Both devices support 20MHz channel bandwidth. The devices were first sampled to customers in September 2009, and Altair claims 15 customers so far, including IPWireless. Altair is testing the solution with Tier 1 infrastructure vendors including Alcatel-Lucent and carriers including Vodafone.
Altair is focusing on PC-centric applications including USB dongles, routers and SIP modules for tablets. The company is working on a next-generation solution and recently announced it had licensed MIPS Technologies' multi-threaded synthesizable processor IP for next-generation HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
34 chipsets. Altair is working on solutions for LTE-Advanced and will support release 9 using a software upgrade and release 10 in a new product planned for 2014/2015. 6.2 Broadcom Corp. Broadcom is a $6.8 billion company with a market-leading position for silicon solutions, covering broadband communications and networking. Founded in 1991, the company has approximately 9,460 employees worldwide. In November 2010 Broadcom acquired Beceem Communications, a privately-held company that developed silicon solutions for LTE and WiMax, for $316 million. Beceem Communications had developed six generations of WiMax baseband devices and was cash positive.
The BCM21880 (was Beceem BSC500) multimode device announced in February 2010 supports WiMax and LTE and is the first CPE device to support 150 Mbit/s downstream (Cat 4). Broadcom already has several customers for the BCM21880, which is expected to go into production during the second half of 2011. Broadcom is working on future devices that will include integration with multimedia functions. 6.3 Cavium Inc. Cavium is a worldwide leader in security, network services and content processing semiconductor solutions. It has a successful line of multicore processors, security processors, ARM-based communications processors and video and content processors that support 10 Mbit/s to 40 Gbit/s throughputs for wired and wireless network equipment. Cavium multicore processors are used in LTE base stations, covered in Section 4.1.
In J anuary 2011, Cavium acquired WiMax and LTE baseband vendor Wavesat. Wavesat was founded in 2003, and its first fixed WiMax device, developed with Atmel, began shipping in 2004. The NP7256 mobile WiMax device was introduced in February 2007. The first WiMax devices from Wavesat implemented the OFDMA and lower MAC in hardware.
The Odyssey 8500, announced in May 2008, was based on a new proprietary DSP architecture. The DSP architecture is a customized version of a licensed core. In May 2008, Wavesat also released details of the Odyssey 9000 series LTE devices, using the same architecture.
The 55nm Odyssey 9010 device was sampled to customers in March 2010 and is now available in production quantities. The Odyssey 9010 supports LTE, WiMax, WiFi and XG-PHS for the Willcom XGP broadband wireless network. The 120mW device is packaged in a 9mm x 9mm BGA, making this suitable for handsets and USB dongles. The Odyssey 9010 supports 100Mbit/s Cat 3 devices. The next-generation Odyssey 9050 device is expected to support Cat 4 devices with 150 Mbit/s downlink. 6.4 GCT Semiconductor Inc. GCT Semiconductor provides CMOS RF and baseband solutions for CDMA, WiMax and LTE. The company has developed has developed a single chip LTE solution with LG and this began shipping in the second quarter of 2010. The GDM7240 supports 100Mbit/s FDD LTE and channel bandwidths up to 20MHz. The device integrates the RF front end.
The GDM7240 (LG L2000) is used, with the Qualcomm MSM8655 application processor, in the LG Revolution smartphone and is qualified for use on the Verizon LTE network. GCT is working on an LTE TDD solution and multimode solutions for LTE and HSPA, etc. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
35 6.5 Innofidei Inc. Beijing-based Innofidei has developed a TD-LTE modem device for USB dongles that supports 80 Mbit/s downstream and 30 Mbit/s upstream. The 65nm device was first shown October 2010. The company has completed interoperability tests with ZTE. 6.6 Intel Corp. Intel, the leading supplier of processors, is making a strong push into the wireless market. The company is starting to promote the Atom processor for tablets and future smartphones and has made several key investments.
In May 2010, Intel acquired ComSys, which was formed in 1998 and was a leading supplier of 2G and 3G software, with more than 20 million handsets using its technology. The first ComSys WiMax device was introduced in 2006. The ComMAX LT8000 LTE baseband device was devel- oped to support multimode handsets and dongles with 2G, 3G and Cat 4 LTE up to 150 Mbit/s downstream. The device was being designed for availability in late 2011 or early 2012. The current status of this development is unclear.
In August 2010, Intel announced that it was acquiring the Wireless Solutions business from Infineon Technologies, in a deal reported to be worth more than $1.2 billion. Before the acquisi- tion completed in J anuary 2011, Infineon wireless acquired Blue Wonder a Dresden, Germany- based company that had developed TDD and FDD multimode baseband IP that would support Cat 4 LTE.
Intel continues to market the SMARTi RF transceiver devices developed by Infineon. The 65nm SMARTi LTE RF transceiver supports LTE bands I through IX. The SMARTi LU supports LTE, HSPA+, HSPA, WCDMA and GSM/GPRS/EDGE. 6.7 Marvell Technology Group Ltd. Marvell supplies silicon devices for the storage, communications and consumer markets. In September 2011 the company announced the PXA1801, a single-chip LTE modem. The device supports 150Mbit/s category 4 FDD/TDD LTE, HSPA+, TD-SCDMA and EDGE. Marvell also supplies the PXA range of application processors. 6.7 Nvidia Inc. Nvidia, one of the leading graphics chipset vendors, is making a strong push into the mobile processor market. The Tegra 2 application processor is developed from Nvidia's GeForce graphics processing unit (GPU) architecture. The Tegra 2 integrates two ARM A9 processors, ultra-low power (ULP) GeForce GPU and 1080p video playback processor. The device is used in several leading smartphone devices. Nvidia is working on a third-generation, quad-core device with enhanced video processing that is expected to be available during the second half of 2011.
In May 2011, Nvidia acquired Icera for $367 million. Icera, founded in 2002, had raised $260 million to develop market-leading wireless handset solutions. The Livano wireless soft modem is at the core of Nvidia's solution. Nvidia has won important HSPA designs with leading handset makers and is driving significant revenue growth. Icera demonstrated a dual-mode LTE/HSPA modem running on Livano-based commercial HSPA USB data sticks in February 2010.
The ICE8061 is part of the Espresso 410 chipset. The device supports Cat 2 FDD LTE with 10MHz channel bandwidth. The company is working on an Espresso 500 chipset that will support 20MHz channel bandwidth and TDD LTE that should be available in 2012. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
36 6.8 Qualcomm Inc. Qualcomm is the leading supplier of CDMA2000 baseband devices and a leading supplier of application processors for handsets. In 2008, the company announced the MDM9xxx-series multimode chipsets for LTE. The Qualcomm MDM9600 was first sampled to customers during 2009. The HTC Thunderbolt LTE smartphone, now available for the Verizon LTE network, uses the MDM9600 and Qualcomm MSM8655 1GHz Snapdragon application processor.
There are four generations of Snapdragon application processors (S1-S4). The 45nm Snapdra- gon S2 MSM8655 integrates a single Scorpion RISC core, Qualcomm Adreno 205 graphics core and 3G modem. The Snapdragon S3 MSM8660 integrates dual Scorpion RISC cores, enhanced Adreno 220 graphics core, with support for HDMI out and 3G modem. Qualcomm claim the Scorpion application processor cores are slightly higher performance than the equivalent ARM 9 processor core.
In February 2011, Qualcomm announced the 28nm Snapdragon S4 family of devices integrating an enhanced processor core, code-named "Krait." The first Snapdragon S4 chipset to sample is the MSM8960. This device integrates two 1.5GHz "Krait" cores, Adreno 225 graphics core and Cat 3 (100Mbit/s) LTE modem. Production is planned for late 2011.
The MSM8960 will be followed by the MSM8930, a cut-down version with a lower-speed core and Cat 2 (50Mbit/s) LTE modem, and the APQ8064 device with four "Krait" cores and no modem. These 2012 devices will integrate new Adreno 3xx graphics cores. In 2013 Qualcomm plans to introduce the MSM8974 with the four "Krait" cores and Adreno 320 graphics blocks from the APQ8064 and a dual-mode 3G/LTE Cat 4 (150Mbit/s) modem. 6.9 Renesas Mobile Renesas Mobile is a subsidiary of Renesas Electronics Corp. Renesas Mobile was formed in December 2010 by combining the Renesas application processor group and Nokia's wireless modem business that Renesas had just acquired. The company has 1,800 employees, including a wireless modem team that has been in the market for more than 20 years. The company supplies application processors and wireless modem devices for smartphones, tablets and USB cards, as well as chipsets for car infotainment systems.
Renesas Mobile announced the MP5225 High-End Smartphone Platform with support for LTE in February 2011. The 45nm chipset is sampling to customers and includes the APE5R application processor, SP2531 baseband processor and a radio front end device. The APE5R integrates two ARM9 processor cores and Imagination Technologies PowerVR SGX multiprocessor graphics. The SP2531 supports Cat 3 LTE (100 Mbit/s), DC-HSPA+EDGE and GSM. 6.10 Sequans Communications Sequans was formed in 2003 and announced its first-generation products for fixed WiMax in October 2005. The company has a complete WiMax chipset solution, including a WiMax base station baseband device, RF transceiver device and subscriber unit baseband. The Sequans baseband devices implement MAC and PHY in hardware with an ARM processor for control. The company has had a strong market position for mobile WiMax devices, with customers including Alcatel, Airspan, Huawei, Redline, Telsima and ZyXEL.
In March 2010, Sequans announced the SQN3010 LTE baseband device, which is optimized for TD-LTE. The device will support Cat 3 LTE and is sampling to customers. China Mobile selected Sequans to provide LTE chips and USB dongles for its TD-LTE demonstration network. The company is working an LTE RF solution, higher integration and multi-mode support. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
37 6.11 ST-Ericsson ST-Ericsson is a joint venture between STMicroelectronics and Ericsson, formed in 2008 to offer semiconductors and platforms to the wireless handset industry. Its key customers are Nokia, Samsung, Sony Ericsson, LG and Sharp. The J V integrates the Ericsson Mobile platforms group and ST-NXP Wireless, a J V with NXP Semiconductor, then fully owned by STMicroelectronics.
ST-Ericsson's first-generation LTE platforms have been sampling to customers since September 2009. The M700 platform consists of three devices: DB7000 baseband, AB5000 AFE device and RF7000 RF transceiver. The M700 supports LTE only and is designed for use in fixed broadband applications. The M710 adds support for HSPA and EDGE, and the M720 also supports HSPA+. The M700 platform is usually matched with "Nova" application processors, such as the 45nm A9500 that integrates two 1.2GHz A9 processor cores. An enhanced 32nm A9540, planned for the second half of 2011, will integrate two 1.85GHz A9 processor cores. Announced customers for the first-generation LTE platforms include Quanta Computer, which is using the M700 and A9500 in a 10.1-inch tablet reference design.
ST-Ericsson's second-generation LTE platforms ("Thor") were announced in February 2011. The 40nm M7400 LTE modem consists of a baseband and RF device. The modem supports LTE Cat 3, HSPA+, EDGE and TD-SCDMA. The M7400 is sampling to customers and will support VoLTE. ST-Ericsson has also released details on the A9600, an enhanced "Nova" application processor with two 2.5GHz A15 processor cores and Imagination Technologies PowerVR Series6 "Rogue" GPU. The A9600 will be available during the second half of 2011. ST-Ericsson is also developing "NovaThor" integrated LTE modem and application processor devices. 6.12 Texas Instruments Inc. The Texas Instruments OMAP application processors are used by a number of leading handset manufacturers. The 45nm OMAP4 application processors (OMAP4430/4460) have two 1GHz ARM9 processor cores and Imagination Technologies PowerVR SGX540 graphics. Texas Instruments are working on 28nm OMAP5 application processors with ARM A15 cores. These are expected to be available during 2012. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
38 VII. RF Chips & Vendors Both CPE/handset and base station baseband devices are designed to work with RF transceiver devices. Figure 14 shows RF transceiver devices from nine vendors. Some of these were originally developed for WiMax. This section includes profiles for RF devices vendors that do not supply other LTE devices.
There are 12 vendors with announced RF devices for LTE. The full list is shown in Figure 7.1, with supported networks and target applications. All the devices will support TDD LTE; most of them will also support FDD LTE. Most of the devices designed for smartphones and tablets also support 3G and 2G networks for backward compatibility. This is less important for USB dongles and PC cards. Devices from Analog Devices, Lime Microsystems, Maxim and Semtech will also support WiMax.
Figure 7.1: LTE RF Device Applications COMPANY/DEVICE FDD LTE WIMAX 3G 2G SMART- PHONES, TABLETS USB DONGLES & PC CARDS BASE STATIONS Altair FourGee-6150 Altair FourGee-6200 Analog Devices AD9354 Analog Devices AD9355 Analog Devices AD9356 Analog Devices AD9357 Fujitsu MB86L10A Fujitsu MB86L12A Genasic GEN4100 Nvidia ICE8261 Intel SMARTi LU Intel SMARTi LTE Lime Microsystems LMS6002D Maxim MAX2839 Qualcomm WTR1605 Renesas RFIC Semtech SMI7336 ST-Ericsson Wireless RF7000 Two AD935x devices are needed to support FDD LTE Source: Heavy Reading
Figure 7.2 shows further information on the RF devices, including the number of transmit and receive channels, the frequencies covered, maximum channel bandwidth and current availability. Most devices support two transmit and two receive channels. Several of the older devices, developed from WiMax solutions, support a very limited range of LTE frequencies. Most of the devices support a range of LTE frequency bands. Analog Devices and Semtech supply different devices for each frequency band. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
40 Real estate, power and temperature range are all important for both smartphone handset usage and base stations. Figure 7.3 shows key parameters for each device. Older devices are in 0.18 CMOS or SiGe. Newer devices are believed to be 65nm or 40nm. Most devices are in a 7x7mm, 8x8mm or 9x9mm package. The interface to baseband from the RF devices can be either analog or digital. The Lime Microsystems LMS6002D is the only device to support both.
Figure 7.3: LTE RF Device Detail s COMPANY/ DEVICE BASEBAND INTERFACE TEMP. RANGE PROCESS PACKAGE POWER Altair FourGee-6150 Analog IQ N/D N/D 8x8mm QFN N/D Altair FourGee-6200 Analog IQ N/D N/D 8x8mm QFN N/D Analog Devices AD9354 J ESD207 -40C to +85C 0.18 CMOS 88mm 56LFCSP N/D Analog Devices AD9355 J ESD207 -40C to +85C 0.18 CMOS 88mm 56LFCSP N/D Analog Devices AD9356 J ESD207 -40C to +85C 0.18 CMOS 10x10mm 144-BGA N/D Analog Devices AD9357 J ESD207 -40C to +85C 0.18 CMOS 10x10mm 144-BGA N/D Fujitsu MB86L10A 2x DigRF N/D 90nm 6.5x9mm 230LGA N/D Fujitsu MB86L12A 2x DigRF N/D 90nm 6.5x9mm 230LGA N/D Genasic GEN4100 J ESD207 -40C to +85C 65nm CMOS N/D <300mW typ Nvidia ICE8261 Analog IQ N/D N/D 7x7mm BGA N/D Intel SMARTi LU Analog IQ N/D 65nm CMOS N/D N/D Intel SMARTi LTE Analog IQ N/D 65nm CMOS N/D N/D Lime Microsystems LMS6002(D) Analog IQ, J ESD207 (D only) -40C to +85C SiGe 0.18 108-pin DQFN 600mW Maxim MAX2839 Analog IQ -40 C to +85 C N/D 8x68mm 56TQFN N/D Qualcomm WTR1605 N/D N/D N/D Wafer-level package N/D Renesas RFIC DigRF N/D N/D N/D N/D Semtech SMI7336 Analog IQ -40C to +85C SiGe 8x8mm 64QFN N/D ST-Ericsson Wireless RF7000 N/D N/D N/D N/D N/D Source: Heavy Reading
Several devices have analog interfaces and are designed to work with baseband devices with integrated digital-to-analog and analog-to-digital converters (DAC/ADC). The RF devices from Analog Devices and Genasic integrate the DAC/ADCs and can be used with any baseband device supporting the standardized J ESD207 digital interface. Lime Microsystems has a device with the analog interface and one with the digital interface. The Fujitsu MB86L01A, announced in J une 2010, supports the serial DigRF interface. All of these devices support TDD LTE. Most integrate the two frequency synthesizers needed to support FDD. The Analog Devices compo- nents support HFDD, and FDD can be supported using two devices. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
41 Power consumption and package size are key parameters for RF front-end devices. Genasic and Lime Microsystems were the only companies to release typical power numbers. The 600mW Lime Microsystems LMS6001 is good for base stations and femtocells. Lime Microsystems has also been working on a lower-power CMOS device. The <300mW Genasic GEN4100 device is optimized for USB dongles.
Most WiMax/LTE RF devices are implemented using 0.18 SiGe or CMOS processes. This is in significant contrast to most baseband chips that are 45nm or 65nm CMOS. Most devices support industrial temperature range (-40C to +85C); however, a few devices developed for handsets, such as the Sequans SQN1140/5, only support a reduced temperature range. Packages vary from 7mm x 7mm for handset devices to 10mm x 10mm for base station devices. 7.1 Analog Devices Inc. Analog Devices is a leading supplier of analog, mixed-signal and DSP devices. The company has a wide range of components for wireless base stations, including high-performance RF devices. The AD935x RF devices support 2.5GHz and 3.4GHz frequency bands for WiMax and LTE. All the devices support the standardized J ESD207 digital baseband interface. The 1x2 MIMO AD9354/5 devices are suitable for CPE applications, and the 2x2 MIMO AD9356/7 devices are suitable for base stations. Two AD9356 devices are needed to support FDD LTE.
Analog Devices has been working closely with several baseband device vendors, including Wavesat, Runcom, DesignArt and Sequans. The device is being used in several LTE trials, and the company is working on new developments for LTE. 7.2 Fujitsu Microelectronics America Inc. Fujitsu Microelectronics, a subsidiary of Fujitsu Ltd., was one of the first companies to introduce a WiMax chipset solution, working with Wi-LAN from 2002, before acquiring rights to the IP in 2006. The company has won WiMax designs with several leading vendors, including Fujitsu Network Communications. In 2009, the company acquired an RF team from Freescale Semiconductor.
In J une 2010, Fujitsu introduced its first LTE transceiver device. The MB86L10A transceiver integrates the surface acoustic wave (SAW) filter and low noise amplifiers, significantly reducing the number of external components required. The device has nine inputs that support LTE, WCDMA and GSM/EDGE. The MB86L10A device supports FDD and TDD LTE and integrates two 3G and 4G DigRF baseband interfaces. The device is in full production. An enhanced version (MB86L12A) is currently sampling to customers. 7.3 Genasic Design Systems Ltd. Genasic, a privately held company formed in 2009, has pulled together a team of design engi- neers with significant RF chip design, including GSM and WiMax transceivers. The company's first product is an LTE RF transceiver supporting 2x2 MIMO and FDD/TDD. The GEN4100 with power consumption below 300mW is sampling to lead customers. The company is working with a baseband chip partner and is already seeing traction with customers developing LTE dongles. Genasic is working on a solution for LTE-Advanced that is expected to be available mid 2012. 7.4 Lime Microsystems Ltd. Lime Microsystems was formed in 2005, and three years later the company announced its first product, the LMS6001. The LM6001 transceiver was a single-chip, multi-band, multi-standard broadband RFIC supporting frequency bands from 375MHz to 4GHz and channel bandwidths from 1.5MHz to 28MHz. Lime Microsystems' core IP enables very flexible digital filtering, which is key to supporting such a wide range of frequencies. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
42 The LMS6001 has been replaced by the LMS6002D. The LMS6002D transceiver device supports various networks, including WiMax, 3G, and LTE for FDD, HFDD and TDD duplex modes. The LMS6002D has a digital baseband interface. All the devices are implemented in 0.18 SiGe, but a CMOS version has been in development that should significantly reduce power consumption. 7.5 Maxim Integrated Products Inc. Maxim is a leading analog and mixed-signal semiconductor company that acquired Dallas Semiconductor in 2001. The company has a range of RF components for LTE and WiMax, including the MAX2839 RF transceiver. The MAX2839 supports 1x2 MIMO for TDD 2.3-2.7GHz and has an analog IQ baseband interface. 7.6 Semtech Corp. Semtech is a leading analog and mixed-signal semiconductor supplier. In December 2009, the company acquired Sierra Monolithics and its range of high-performance optical ICs, RFICs and modules, including the $20 WiMax SMI7030 dual-band wireless transceiver.
Semtech is sampling two SiGe RF transceivers for 4G applications. The SMI7335 device is better for WiMax, supporting four bands. The SMI7336 is better for LTE, supporting six bands including 700MHz. The devices support 2x2 MIMO, TDD, HFDD and channel bandwidths up to 20MHz. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
43 Appendix A: About the Author SIMON STANLEY ANALYST AT LARGE, HEAVY READING
Simon Stanley is Founder and Principal Consultant at Earlswood Marketing Ltd., an independent market analyst and consulting company based in the U.K. Stanley's recent work has included investment due diligence, market analysis for investors and business/product strategy for semi- conductor companies.
Over the last nine years, Stanley has written extensively for Heavy Reading and Light Reading. His reports and Webinars cover a variety of communications-related subjects, including LTE, IMS, WiMax, ATCA, MicroTCA, 40/100Gbit/s networking, 10Gbit/s Ethernet components, multi- core processors, switch fabric chipsets, network processors and next-gen Sonet/SDH silicon. He has also run several Light Reading Live! and virtual events covering ATCA, MicroTCA, 10Gbit/s Ethernet components and broadband devices.
Stanley's previous reports for Heavy Reading include:
ATCA, AMC & MicroTCA Market Update & Five-Year Forecasts (March 2011) Multicore Processors for Network Systems: A Heavy Reading Competitive Analysis (October 2010) ATCA, AMC & MicroTCA Market Update & Forecast (October 2009) 10-Gbit/s Ethernet Components: The Market Takes Shape (May 2009) ATCA, AMC & MicroTCA Market Forecast: Revenue Surge Ahead (J une 2008) ATCA, AMC & MicroTCA: The Next Generation (August 2006) AdvancedTCA: Who's Doing What (J une 2005) Network Processors: A Heavy Reading Competitive Analysis (J anuary 2005) 10-Gbit/s Ethernet Components: A Heavy Reading Competitive Analysis (April 2004)
Prior to founding Earlswood Marketing, Stanley spent more than 15 years in product marketing and business management. He has held senior positions with Fujitsu, National Semiconductor and U.K. startup ClearSpeed, covering networking, personal systems and graphics in Europe, North America and J apan.
Stanley has spent more than 30 years in the electronics industry, including several years design- ing systems for leading aerospace and mass-transit manufacturers, before moving into semicon- ductor marketing. In 1983, Stanley earned a Bachelor's in Electronic and Electrical Engineering from Brunel University, London. He can be contacted at simon@earlswoodmarketing.com. HEAVY READING | VOL. 9, NO. 9, OCTOBER 2011 | LTE BASEBAND, RF & APPLICATION PROCESSORS
44 Appendix B: Legal Disclaimer SUBSCRIBER LICENSE AGREEMENT between HEAVY READING and SUBSCRIBER
Any Heavy Reading report ("Report") and the information therein are the property of or licensed to Heavy Reading, and permission to use the same is granted to annual or single-report Subscribers ("Subscribers") under the terms of this Subscriber License Agreement ("Agreement"), which may be amended from time to time without notice. When requesting a Report, you acknowledge that you are bound by the terms and conditions of this Agreement and any amendments thereto. Heavy Reading therefore recommends that you review this page for amendments to this Agreement prior to requesting any additional Reports.
SUBSCRIPTION RENEWAL For convenience, annual subscriptions purchased by credit card will be auto-renewed at the end of the subscription term. Prior to that auto-renewal you will receive a notice that will include instructions for updating your subscription or payment information and for opting out of the auto-renewal process.
OWNERSHIP RIGHTS All Reports are owned by Heavy Reading and protected by federal, state, and international copyright, trademark, and intellectual property laws, under and by applicable treaties and/or conventions. Subscriber agrees not to export any Report into any country that does not have copyright, trademark, and intellectual property laws that will protect Heavy Reading's rights therein.
GRANT OF LICENSE RIGHTS Heavy Reading hereby grants Subscriber a non-exclusive, non-refundable, non-transferable license to use the Report for research purposes only pursuant to the terms and conditions of this Agreement. Heavy Reading retains exclusive and sole ownership of each Report disseminated under this Agreement. Subscriber agrees not to permit any unauthorized use, reproduction, distribution, publication or electronic transmission of any Report or the information/forecasts therein without the express written permission of Heavy Reading.
Heavy Reading Licensing Options: Single Report purchasers may distribute Reports only to other employees within their entire organization. Enterprise License Subscribers may distribute Reports only to other employees within their entire organization. Site License Subscribers may distribute Reports only to employees within their organization at the location specified in their purchase agreement. If an organization has multiple locations, Reports may not be shared between locations.
For the purposes of this Agreement, an "Organization" is defined as a private or public sector entity that conducts business under a single corporate, organizational, or brand name. It does not include ancillary direct or indirect partner- ships, partial or wholly owned subsidiaries, or other entities that conduct business under a corporate, organizational, or brand name that differs from the name of the Organization owning the license in question.
In case of any distribution of Reports under this Agreement, Subscriber agrees to retain all copyright, trademark, and other proprietary notices on the Reports.
DISCLAIMER OF WARRANTY AND LIABILITY Heavy Reading has used its best efforts in collecting and preparing each Report. Heavy Reading, its employees, affiliates, agents, and licensors do not warrant the accuracy, completeness, currentness, noninfringement, merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose of any Reports covered by this Agreement. Heavy Reading, its employees, affiliates, agents, and licensors shall not be liable to Subscriber or any third party for loss or injury caused in whole or part by Heavy Reading's negligence or by contingencies beyond Heavy Reading's control in compiling, preparing, or disseminating any Report, or for any decision made or action taken by Subscriber or any third party in reliance on such information, or for any consequential, special, indirect, or similar damages (including lost profits), even if Heavy Reading was advised of the possibility of the same. Subscriber agrees that the liability of Heavy Reading, its employees, affiliates, agents, and licensors, if any, arising out of any kind of legal claim (whether in contract, tort, or otherwise) in connection with its goods/services under this Agreement shall not exceed the amount Subscriber paid to Heavy Reading for use of the Report in question.
DISPUTE RESOLUTION This License will be governed by the laws of the State of New York. In case of a dispute arising under or related to this License, the parties agree to binding arbitration before a single arbitrator in the New York City office of the American Arbitration Association. The prevailing party will be entitled to recover its reasonable attorney fees and costs.
Heavy Reading 240 West 35th Street, 8th Floor New York, NY 10001 United States of America Phone: +1 212-600-3000 www.heavyreading.com