Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
July 2005
EMMY 2005
replacement yet. And Jim Lemon has left KOVR (CBS) in all three areas as well. But
after almost four years at the helm. now Hackney is moving from a
KOVR and KMAX (UPN) are the new CBS duopoly in traditional newscast role to
Sacramento, and the network has promoted from within entertainment co-host on
to lead the news portion of that partnership. Steve KPIX’s Evening Magazine with
Charlier was named Vice President of News for both Malou Nubla. Hackney will
KOVR and KMAX. Charlier comes to Sacramento from also be “an integral part of the
CBS’s O&O in Salt Lake City, KUTV. Joining Charlier as producing staff of Evening
Assistant News Director for both stations is Lori Magazine,” according to Ch. 5.
Waldon. Waldon was Managing Editor of CBS-owned Hackney moved from KGO to KRON back in 1995,
KPIX in San Francisco. and is the first front-line talent to leave KRON since
One survivor in the Sacramento shake-up is Brent station management offered many of them the opportu-
Baader, who is staying on as News Director of KMAX, nity to break their contracts and move to other stations
focusing primarily on the station’s morning newscast. within the market, in the station’s continuing effort to cut
costs. He begins his new role on Evening Magazine in
RTNDA NAMES THE mid-July.
ON THE MOVE
Jack Poorman has joined KGO-TV in San Francisco Producer for Investigations at the same station. And
as a promotions producer/writer. Poorman will produce Karl Norberg moves up from associate producer to
and edit news series and image promos for the station. producer of Evening Magazine.
Poorman has been working as a freelance producer in General Assignment reporter Jonathan Carlson
San Francisco and Los Angeles most recently, after jumps 49 markets to Fox affiliate KTXL in Sacramento
spending 15 years at CNN in Atlanta, where he shared in from the NBC affiliate in Fort Myers, FL. Jonathan who
a national Emmy® and Peabody for the network’s is a graduate of Quinnipiac University in Hamden, CT,
coverage of the Gulf War. has also worked as a general assignment reporter at the
Jeff Harris moves to Executive Producer for Special ABC affiliate in Rochester, New York.
Projects at KPIX-TV in San Francisco, from Executive
Off Camera, July 2005, page 3
EMMY® AUDIT EMMY® 101
The San Francisco/Northern
California Chapter annually
honors outstanding individual,
news and program achieve-
ments in Northern California,
© 2004
statuettes is to provide incentive
for continuing outstanding
individual and production
achievements within the televi-
sion industry.
The Emmy® Awards pro-
continued from page 1 gram is also a means of focusing
The outlying areas didn’t fare quite as well. Of public attention upon the multi-talented individuals who
Fresno’s 73 entries, 19 percent were nominated and 3 comprise this business and to honor them. Since we are
percent received statues. In Hawaii, 24 percent of the awarding excellence, there can be one award, more than
region’s 25 entries were nominated while 4 percent won one award or no award presented in each area.
Emmy® awards. In Reno, 14 percent of the 28 entries The awards judging process begins in July when the
were nominated and none of those were awarded Northern California chapter’s Awards Committee meets
Emmy® statuettes. The Salinas-Monterey, Eureka and to determine what areas will be offered in the following
Chico-Redding regions had a total of six nominations and year’s competition. That list is sent to the National
one Emmy® recipient. Awards Committee for approval, making sure all the
Spanish-language stations had 56 entries with 12 rules conform to National policy and regulations. The
getting nominations and one winning an Emmy® award. approved “call for entries” information is made avail-
Cable outlets, including Fox Sports Bay Area, had 41 able to the chapter by late fall, with a mid-January
entries with 14 nominations and four Emmy® awards. deadline for award submissions.
All entries were judged outside of our chapter by a
panel of at least six peer judges from five other NATAS
chapters
Compton also grouped the judging by region to see if
there was any chapter that was prevalent in the areas
that received complaints. He discovered the four areas
that received no nominations this year were judged by
three different chapters. A similar pattern emerged in
areas with few nominations.
Compton also re-checked the judges on a sampling of
areas to make sure qualified peer judges were on each
panel. He found no discrepancies. The “breaking news”
This year, 722 entries were submitted from the
category, for example, was judged by three reporters, an
calendar year 2004, for Emmy® award consideration.
anchor, a producer and a photographer.
The actual process started when the entry arrived at the
“The Emmy® award stands for excellence and out-
Academy office. We call the day after the January
standing achievement in television. The integrity of the
deadline “sorting day.” A group of volunteers from the
Emmy® process is one the highest priorities in my life.
Board and Awards Committee opened each package
I spend well over a thousand hours each year processing
checking that the information on each tape label
each entry from the day it is received till the statuettes
matched the entry form. The tapes were sorted by area
are handed out,” said Compton. “Our awards’ accountant
number.
and support staff go to great lengths to make sure that
Several hundred hours
each entry is treated equally and fairly.”
were then spent processing
Chapter president David Mills requested this year’s
the paper work. All the
judging review. After the committee’s investigation, Mills
information on the entry
said he is satisfied with the results of the awards audit.
form was entered into a data
“Emmy® judging is always a subjective thing. What
base, including every name
one person thinks is a quality program, another person
and title submitted. We may
may think is mediocre,” Mills said. “I was concerned
have had 722 entries, but
when we received the complaints after the Emmy®
that amounted to 1,518
show; but after the committee’s investigation, I’m
individual entrant names.
convinced there was nothing significantly wrong with this
year’s judging.” Membership status and correct entry fees were checked
Mills also asked the Awards Committee to study ways and the funds deposited. Upon completion, the entry
to increase the nominations of smaller markets as well as database was published on the emmysf.tv website.
Spanish-language stations. The committee will take up About three weeks after the January sorting day, the
those topics as well as next year’s award rules at its July Awards Committee had an all day “certification meeting.”
14th meeting. continued on page 5
Off Camera, July 2005, page 4
EMMY® ENTRY PROCEDURE
are announced. This is referred to as “blind scoring.”
The committee, looking at raw scores, determined a cut-
off in each area and entries above that cut-off were
considered nominees. The committee then selected the
Emmy® recipients by highest scores in each area. Again,
since we are awarding excellence, there was the possibil-
ity of multiple award recipients. In some cases, if the
scores were too low, no nominations or winners were
selected. The Awards Committee members made these
selections without knowing which entries or areas were
being considered.
Emmy® Certification continued from page 4
They went through the entire entry list looking for tapes
that were in the wrong area or for entrants who may
have “double dipped,” having entered the same material
in more than one area. A list of entrants that had not
paid the proper fees was also distributed to the commit-
tee as well as posted on the website.
After the certification meeting the ballots were
prepared. A random sort was made of entries in each
area. The sort determined the order that the judges
would view the entries. This year we went back to the
30 point judging scale for programs (1 to 10 points for
content, creativity, and execution, 30 points being
excellent). Craft areas were judged on creativity and
execution only, possible 20 points. The station call
7
THE BOARD OF GOVERNORS
OFFICERS:
David Mills, KPIX, President
Lynn R Friedman, KGO, VP, SF
Keith Sanders, Perfect Pitch TV, VP, SJ
Dan Adams, KXTV, VP, Sacramento
Nancy Osborne, KFSN, VP, Fresno SAN FRANCSISCO
Terri Russell, KOLO, VP, Reno NORTHERN C ALIF
CALIF ORNIA
ALIFORNIA
Pamela Young, KITV, VP, Hawaii 4317 Camden Avenue
Terry Lowry, LaCosse Productions, Secretary San Mateo, CA 94403
(650) 341-7786 F: (650) 372-0279
NATIONAL TRUSTEES:
Linda Giannecchini, KQED (Museum) Tamar Maghdissian, KHSL
Alison Gibson, Media Cool (Education) Deanne Moenster-Poitras, KTVU
Cynthia Zeiden, Zeiden Media (Activities) John Murray, JM Communications
John Odell, CCSF
GOVERNORS: Sheraz Sadiq, KQED
Terri Amos, Cornerstone Productions Pam Schoen, KTXL
Duncan Armstrong, KHNL Javier Valencia, KRON (Awards)
Dan Ashley, KGO
Brian Avery, Avery Media COMMITTEE CHAIRS: (not listed above)
Samuel Belilty, KFTV John Catchings, Catchings & Assoc.
John Burgess, KFTY (Museum)
Thomas Drayton, KTXL Darryl Cohen, Cohen & Cooper (Legal)
Janice Edwards, KNTV James Spalding, Spalding & Co., (Finance)
Deirdre Fitzpatrick, KCRA
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR:
Albert Garcia, KUVS
Darryl R. Compton, NATAS
Bob Goldberger, KGO
Stewart Heller, York Productions
Valeria Hernandez, KDTV Off Camera
Justin Kanno, KOLO Bob Goldberger, Editor
Ronald Louie, KTVU (Alt. Trustee) Darryl Compton, Publisher
Terry Lowry, LaCosse Productions Robert Mohr, Photographer
Off Camera, July 2005, page 10