Walter R. Fillippone is a consultant on seismic velocity interpretation and
exploration projects in Placentia, CA. He holds a BA degree in geology from Marietta (OH) College and an MS degree in geophysics from the California Inst. of Technology. He worked on velocity data for United Geophysical Co. for 11 years in the Pasadena, CA, office. During 1955-84, he worked for Union Oil Co. of California (UNOCAL) as staff geophysicist, exploration manager for the Rocky Mountain area and the Glacier Div., and senior research associate. In this last position, he worked on computer techniques to assist in the interpretation of seismic and magnetic data and was UNOCAL's representative to the GEOSAT Committee (user companies' advisory committee to NASA) and remote sensing study groups. Practical Applications of Remote Sensing Walter R. Fillippone, Geophysical Exploration Consultant Summary. Though remote sensing has been available in many forms for decades, it became much more available and interesting with the advent of the Earth Resources Technology Satellite-I (ERTS-l), later renamed LANDSAT -I, in 1972. Since that time, hundreds of thousands of images detected by satellites have been transmitted to base stations at strategic locations around the world and recorded in digital format for further processing. These data have been made available to the entire free world for agricultural purposes. The large areas covered by each image and the repeatability of the images on subsequent passes have made them useful additionally in navigation, engineering studies of ice floes and harbors, studies of sedimentary deposition near river deltas, and the interpretation of geologic features too large to visualize on conventional aerial photographs. This paper highlights applications of readily available, remotely sensed data without the need for more sophisticated processing. It points out some techniques used to interpret events on the imagery that relate to subsurface features that are important in the exploration and development of oil and gas fields and makes use of analogies to known geologic features. The Appendix lists the current sources of the various remotely sensed data. Introduction Remote sensing of the environment and the earth has been in use for many years. Airborne instrumentation for photography that uses special films, radiation detection, magnetic and electromagnetic measurements, and radar are a few examples. Each has been used successfully in exploration for oil, gas, and minerals. Surveys have been made with infrared (lR) film for thermal radiation detection of the earth's surface to locate geothermal sources and some minerals associated with recent vulcanism. These IR surveys, conducted at night from low-flying aitcraft, were particularly hazardous and not very useful because of turbulence and poor navigation. With the addition of radar instrumentation, the surveys wete much safer and were more accurately assembled into useful, carefully registered strip maps. Copyright 1986 Socie1y of Petroleum Engineers Journal of Petroleum Technology, January 1986 Aeromagnetic surveys were flown over most of the basins of the world to provide reconnaissance maps. Simultaneous aerial photography tied the magnetic data to landmarks to make maps that could be used to locate magnetic minerals or minerals associated with magnetic rocks. These surveys also were used to calculate depth-to-basement maps that provided good framework maps of the basin shape, basement faults, and basement topographic structures related to anticlines and synclines in the overlying sediments. Electromagnetic surveys have been used extensively for the detection of the sulfide minerals, which tend to be more conductive than the host rocks and most sediments. Sidescan radar has been in use for many years to provide imagery of the surface and to find structures related to the topography. These surveys have been indispensible in the tropics, where aerial photography and satellite imagery have been hampered by clouds and fog that are present to some degree all of the 9 CANADA CENTRE FOR REMOTE SENSING DEPARTMENT Of' ENERGV MlNS AHO RESOUACES CENTRE CANADIEN DE TI:LI:DI:TECTION I,IINtSTERE DE L ENEFIGI E DES ....NES T OES AESSOIJRCf S Fig. 1-Map of Canada with tracks of LANDSAT 1 satellite. time. Most of the islands in the South Pacific region and in the Amazon basin region of South America would be unmapped had it not been for the application of radar mapping systems. As useful as airborne instrumentation is in detailed surveys, it has its drawbacks: (1) it covers only a small area in each photograph; (2) continuous surveys are subject to wind and turbulence effects; and (3) the look angle with sidescan radar has much distortion in areas of topographic relief, usuall y the areas of interest. Satellite and Space Imagery In about 1960, the U. S. federal government became interested in space travel to the moon and embarked on a program through the National Aeronautics and Space Admin. (NASA) to develop remote-sensing instrumentation and vehicles . In testing these devices over land test sites that simulated lunar conditions, NASA discovered the response of microwave radiation to vegetation and mineralization. In time, these di scoveries were recognized as a means of surveying the earth for agricultural , geologic, hydrologic, and oceanographic data and NASA set up the Earth Resources Survey Program. On July 23 , 1972, the first satellite designed for this purpose was launched in a near-polar , sun-synchronous orbit and 10 called ERTS-l (LANDSAT-I ). It was designed to last 1 year, but continued to function well for several years. Remote sensing by satellite is not photography, but is more like television recording in that the earth's surface is scanned in small spots , or picture elements , called pixels, that have a specific location and a finitely measured intensity value that is digitally recorded, then transmitted to a base station for storage and processing. The satellite is in a near-circular orbit about 913 km [567 miles] above the surface of the earth and makes one revolution around the earth every 103 minutes. On its downsweep from north to south, it is scanning points on the earth's surface at about 9:30 a.m., local time, as the earth rotates eastward below it. On its upsweep, it is in the shadow of the earth and is not recording. On its next downsweep, the earth has moved over by 17 scan widths. The next day' s tracks will be adj acent to the previous day's tracks with a small overlap at the equator. Every 18 days the orbit will repeat the sequence. In this manner , temporal changes in vegetation, snow pack, surface-water content , and ice conditions can be recognized. In the polar regions , the overlap of the scenes is sufficient to show temporal changes on a daily basis for 3 to 5 consecutive days. This makes it possible to Journal of Petroleum Technology, January 1986 Fig. 2-Point Barrow, AK, area i mage from four LANDSAT 1 scenes. monitor the movement of ice floes and their effect on shipping and drilling platforms. The only obstacles to these observations are cloud cover, ambient light, and of course, the transmission of the data to a base station. The observed bandwidths of the LANDS A T satellites cover two bands in the green and red portions of the visible spectrum and two bands in the near or reflective infrared. Band 4, in the 0.5- to 0.6-J.tm range, can penetrate water to tens of meters depending upon the clarity of the water. Band 5, 0.6- to 0.7-J.tm range, penetrates about half that amount; Band 6, 0.7- to 0.8-J.tm range, less than I m [3.3 ft]; and Band 7,0.8- to 1.1-J.tm range, has no penetration into water. With a suite of different bands for one scene, one can make some estimates of the water- bottom contours. In delta areas, the sediment load and its direction of travel can be determined from an inspection of the data. On land or on ice, the response of Band 7 can detect areas of surface water or saturation of the soil. Bands 6 and 7 are very responsive to the reflection of the longer wavelengths from live vegetation. This makes these bands very useful for forestry and agriculture by identifying live vs. dead trees or vegetation. Trees killed by parasites can be detected readily from these images, and crops can be identified to some degree by their response to several bands. As in most projects in exploration, a great deal of interpretation is made by analogy to known objects, Fig. 3-Gulf of Alaska area from three bands of a LANDSAT-1 image; note penetration of various wave lengths into the water. Courtesy U. of Alaska. Journal of Petroleum Technology, January 1986 II Fig. 4-False-color composite image from Bands 4, 5, and 7, showing Mississippi delta area; note sediment loads in river channels in Gulf of Mexico. geologic structures, lithologies, and conditions. Therefore, training areas of known conditions and crops should be used in identifying similar character- istics in nearby areas. Some mineralization can be de- tected by the effect of the minerals on the vegetation, such as poisoning by certain metals like copper or zinc on certain trees or crops. LANDSAT 2 was identical to LANDSAT 1, while LANDSAT 3 had one additional channel, the thermal infrared band at 10.4 to 12.5 /Lm, whIch measured thermal emissivity rather than reflected infrared. LANDSAT 4, or D, covered the same spectra, plus a band in the shorter wavelengths in the visible spectrum for marine observations and two bands in the infrared that help in snow and cloud differentiation and differentiation of clay types. LANDS A T 4 was called a thematic mapper and had a resolution of 30 m [98 ft] with coverage in spectral bands from 0.45 to 0.52, 0.5 to 0.6, 0.63 to 0.69, 0.76 to 0.90, 1.55 to 1.75, 2.08 to 2.35, and 10.4 to 11.65 /Lm. LANDSATS 4 and 5 were identical, but their tracks were 8 days apart. Their track spacing was 172 km [107 miles] at the equator, and their scan or scene width was 185 km [115 miles]. The satellites repeated the same track every 16 days. Perhaps the most useful aspect of the satellite imagery is for photogeologic interpretation. The imagery has an advantage over conventional airborne photography in that each LANDSAT scene covers an 12 area of 34,225 km 2 [l3,214 sq miles], observed under consistent light conditions and free of turbulence. Large geologic features-such as basins, faults, anticlines and synclines, mountain ranges, lineaments, salt domes, volcanoes, and deltas-can be encompassed in one scene rather than a complex mosaic of several hundred photographs. The sweep of the scanner is less than 6 0, which results in a small amount of distortion at the outer east/west edges of the scene. At the equator, there is about 14% of sidelap of the scenes and greater than 50 % in the polar regions. Current practices in the processing of the data can provide very accurate registration and geometric correction that make the resulting scenes and enhanced-color composites extremely accurate and useful for mapping and interpretation. The resolution of the first three LANDSAT's data is about 80 m [260 ft] and includes about 4000 m 2 [1 acre] per pixel, while LANDSAT 4 has resolution of 30 m [100 ft], which represents an area of about 1000 m 2 [1,4 acre]. SPOT IMAGE is a French remote-sensing satellite that will use fixed arrays of detectors and records in three bands of the spectrum. The detectors can acquire data out to 27 from the vertical, and the data can be processed and corrected to produce images similar to the LANDSAT data. The shuttle spacecraft carried an experimental shuttle imaging radar (SIR-A) on the first flight in Journal of Petroleum Technology, January 1986 Fig. 5-U.S. west coast composite built from several hundred images and a geologic map to show lineaments apparent on small-scale images. 1981. It has a 47 angle of incidence and 40-m [I30-ft] ground resolution to acquire images for geologic studies. A surprising result of these images is the ability of the radar to penetrate arid sand dunes to depths of several meters and to detect buried drainage channels under the sand. For a more detailed description of the construction and performance of remote-sensing systems, please see Ref. 1. Some Interpretive Uses of LANDSAT Imagery Fig. 1 shows a map of Canada with an overprint of the tracks of LANDSAT 1. Each scene constructed from the transmitted data covers an area of about 34,200 km 2 [13,200 sq miles] in a trapezoid with sides of about 185 km [115 miles]. At the latitude of 70 north, the tracks overlap each ground point 5 consecutive days as the satellite track advances about 25 miles/D [40 km/d]. If the atmosphere is cIoud- free, any changes on the surface can be observed on a daily basis. Fig. 2 shows an area around Point Barrow, AK, made from four scenes from LANDSAT 1. The scene on the right is the first day of the sequence. Two days later, the second scene was observed, and the ice floes had moved the length of the long arrow, about 34 km [21 miles]. The scene on the left was observed the day following the scene in the middle Journal of Petroleum Technology. January 1986 and shows arrows with lengths of 14 and 16 km [9 and 10 miles], all moving in a southwesterly direction as a result of combined wind and sea current action on the ice. Note also the ice that is firmly attached to the coast and is not involved in the ice movement farther offshore. This is called fast ice. Suites of these scenes can be obtained for most locations in the northern hemisphere for various times of the year to study ephemeral effects for placement of platforms, loading facilities, and the study of ice floe movements. Fig. 3 shows three images in the Gulf of Alaska area from LANDSAT 1 to illustrate the penetration of the various wave lengths into the water. Band 4 has the greatest penetration and can observe fine sediments at greater depths than Band 5, which can define only the shallow sediment load. Bands 6 and 7 have little or no penetration and observe only the surface debris and texture. It is evident that there is a heavy load of sediment carried in the river outflow, and that the shore currents are carrying it toward the west. Fig. 4 is a false-color composite made from Bands 4, 5, and 7 of the Mississippi delta and illustrates the amount of sediment load being carried by the rivers and the direction of transport when it reaches the Gulf of Mexico. From this scene, it is evident that all the sediments and nutrients are being carried by the shore currents to the west, which implies that the 13 . "---l r . ......,...: .. - GEO. r KELLY MAPS
P.O BOX 50129 PHON[ 9111-_-2838 TULSA. OKLA 74150 Fig. 6-0klahoma and Texas panhandles (including the Hugoton field) showing several lineaments. better source and reservoir rocks should be west of the delta. This is not an enhanced image. Much better resolution can now be obtained from more recent computer-enhanced images. Bands 6 and 7 are quite useful for making base maps because of the smaller amount of absorption of the energy by moisture in the atmosphere. Bands 4 and 5, with their much shorter wavelengths, suffer from scattering of the light from particles of dust and moisture in the atmosphere and often appear hazy or indistinct. Be sure to ask for computer-enhanced imagery with improved registration for base-map construction. Fig. 5 is a composite of several hundred images of the U.S. west coast and a geologic map at about the same scale for identification purposes. This illustration points out the lineaments that are evident on small-scale images. There is much controversy over lineaments and their significance. I believe that the long lineaments observed on these images are related to deep-seated basement faulting, and that the longer they are, the more involved are the basement rocks and the continental granitic layer. I have marked several lineaments with arrows and letters for identification, but you may see many more and may derive some correlation of those lineaments to known geologic structures, oil and gas fields, minerals, faults, or volcanic activity. Lineament A-A is one that can be traced across most of the continent and will also be referred to in Fig. 6. It is implied by several surface phenomena, such as the offset in the south end of San Francisco Bay, a visible tonal change across the San Joaquin Valley, coincidence with the Kings River Canyon, offsets in the mountain ranges between Owens Lake and Las Vegas, and correlation with the Las Vegas 14 shear zone. Note that in the San Joaquin Valley, most of the hydrocarbon production south of this lineament is oil while most of the production north of it is gas. I relate this to the lineament's presence throughout sedimentary deposition in the valley and believe it represents rejuvenated faulting along this lineament with the south part a deep marine embayment and the north part, including the Sacramento Valley, a shallow marine to nonmarine shelf. Lineament S-S is the south portion of the San Andreas fault zone and can be traced by the offsets in mountain ranges and sediments and surface-color changes. The San Andreas fault zone is composed of several branches, all with right-lateral movement. It is bifurcated at San Jose and one segment goes up through the middle of the San Francisco peninsula while the other becomes the Hayward fault that goes through Berkeley. This bifurcation occurs near Lineament A-A. Lineament M-M is related to the Mendocino Escarpment and can be traced across California and Nevada by offsets in mountain ranges and volcanic activity. The arrows south of Lineament M-M are along a lineament that connects the geothermal area at Clear Lake, the intrusive of the Sutter Buttes, the South Yuba River canyon, the Truckee River between Reno and Fernley in Nevada, and offsets in several mountain ranges east of Fernley. Fig. 6 shows a map of the Oklahoma and Texas panhandles with the traces of several lineaments drawn across it. Lineaments A, B, C, and Dare parallel lineaments projected from the west coast imagery. Note that they are coincident with the gas production of the Hugoton field, where gas production is north of the lineament and oil produc- tion is south of it, but not exclusively. Also, changes in strike of the fields occur along these lineament projections. I relate this to the presence of a Journal of Petroleum Technology, January 1986 5 07-30 1 o 5 10 1.-1--:-7"' mil e s Fig. 7- Band 5 i mage of Casper, WY, area. lineament-related fault system during deposition of the sedimentary rocks . Fig. 7 is a Band 5 image of a portion of a scene of the Casper area, Wyoming. Several lineaments are designated by connecting the coincident arrows and noting the occurrence of apparent fault traces and changes in tone along these lines . The intersection of these lines with the structure in the lower right center of the scene may be related to production cells in the producing zones. One might expect that faults that have great extent on the surface would penetrate to at least half their length into the subsurface. These lineaments can be traced for at least 80 km [50 miles], which would imply that they penetrate the granitic layer. If such is the case, then the sediments should be interrupted by fault planes, and an associated fault gouge would provide a seal to horizontal migration of hydrocarbons . The implied production cells are shown in the insert in the lower right corner of the figure. The insert can be traced and overlain on the structure to see its relationship to the structure. Lineaments have also been used to predict fracture porosity in Journal of Petroleum Technology, January 1986 Fig. 8-0utline map of the U.S. showing a few earthquake epicenters and a few lineaments. areas where the reservoir rocks are brittle and underlain and overlain by massive shale units. In these cases, the brittle rocks fracture along the fault planes, but the shales remain as impervious layers to provide the source and trap for accumulating hydrocarbons. 15 Fig. 8 is a map of a few earthquake epicenters and a few lineaments that can be observed on the composite LANDSAT imagery of the conterminous U.S. The profusion of epicenters on the west coast requires a detailed map to show the correlation, but note that other significant earthquakes have occurred along observable lineations, attesting to the deep- seated source of the lineaments. The cluster of epicenters at the intersection of several lineaments near New Madrid, MO is also interesting. A significant earthquake occurred there more than 100 years ago and changed the course of the Mississippi River. Source of Materials There are many products available from remote- sensing surveys, some of which are too esoteric to be included in this review. Many universities are conducting research into the uses of enhanced, filtered, transformed, and statistically analyzed data in gray tones and false color to discover ways to derive more definitive information from remotely sensed data. Considerable progress has been made and greater benefits are promised. The principal limit to these data from a geological standpoint is that they are surface-derived and are useful for oil, gas, and mineral exploration only where subsurface correlation can be inferred. They are, however, certainly indispensible in some applications. During 1985, the distribution of these products was transferred to a private enterprise in a gradual takeover that will have continued government support for a period of 3 years. The Earth Resources Observation System (EROS) Data Center remains the source for these materials and information. Acknowledgments I thank the U.S. federal government for its support of space research and for giving generously of its time, money, and discoveries to aid underdeveloped countries with these materials. Reference 1. Manual of Remote Sensing. second edition, R.N. Colwell (ed.), American Soc. of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Falls Church, V A (1983). Appendix-Remote Sensing Data Sources Distributors of Remotely Sensed Data. Earth Observation Satellite Co. (EOSAT), c/o EROS Data Center, Sioux Falls, SD 57198, TWX No. 910-668-0310, Telephone 1-800-367-2801 (Ask for user services.) Canadian Centre for Remote Sensing (CCRS), User Assistance and Marketing Unit, 717 Belfast Road, Ottawa, Ont., Canada KIA OY7, Telephone 613-995-1210 ESA-ESRIN, Earthnet User Services, Via Galileo Galilei, 000 44 Frascati, Italy, Telephone 39-6-9401360, Telex 611295 Australia LANDSAT Station, 14-16 Ostley Court, P.O. Box 28, Belconnen, A.C.T. 2616, Australia, Telephone 062-515411, Telex 61510 16 SPOT IMAGE Corp., 1150 17th St. N.W., Suite 307, Washington, DC 20036, Telephone 202-293-1656, Telex-4993073 Processing and Image Analysis Companies. General Electric Co., Earth Resources Applications, 4701 Forbes Blvd., Lanham, MD 20706, Telephone 301-459-2900 Earth Satellite Corp. (EARTHSAT), 7222 47th St., Chevy Chase, MD 20815, Telephone 301-652-7130, Telex 248618 Aero Service, 8100 Westpark, P.O. Box 1939, Houston, TX 77001, Telephone 713-784-5800, Telex 775909 Universities With Remote Sensing Laboratories. Jet Propulsion Laboratory 4800 Oak Grove Dr. Pasadena, CA 91109 U. of California Geography Remote Sensing Unit Santa Barbara, CA 93106 U. of Kansas Remote Sensing Laboratory 2291 Irving Hill Dr. Lawrence, KS 66045 U. of Michigan Environmental Research Inst. of Michigan (ERIM) P.O. Box 8618 Ann Arbor, MI 48107 U. of Nevada MacKay School of Mines Reno, NV 89557-0047 U. of North Carolina Chapel Hill, NC Purdue U. Laboratory for Applications of Remote Sensing (LARS) 1220 Potter Dr. West Lafayette, IN 47906 Stanford U. Dept. of Applied Earth Sciences Stanford, CA 94305 Interpretation and Training. Floyd F. Sabins J r., Remote Sensing Enterprises, P.O. Box 2893, La Habra, CA 90631, Telephone 714-879-4367 User Organization. The GEOSAT Committee Inc., 153 Kearney St., Suite 209, San Francisco, CA 94108, Telephone 415-981-6265, Telex 910-371-2043 SI Metric Conversion Factor mile x l.609344* E+OO km "Conversion factor is exact. JPT SPE 15192. Distinguished Author Series articles arc general. descriptive presentations that summarize the state of the art in an area of technology by describing recent developments for readers who are not specialists in the topics discussed. Written by individuals recognized as experts in the areas, these articles provide key references to more definitive work and present specific details only to illustrate the technology. Purpose: To inform the general readership of recent advances in various areas of petroleum engineering. A softbound anthology, SPE Distil1Kuished Author Snies: Dec. 1981-Dec. 1983, is available from SPE's Book Order Dept. Journal of Petroleum Technology, January 1986