Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 95

-

,
" "
""

-

2012

32.97373
63

:
, . .
, . .
, , . .

:
. . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . ,
. .
: . / . . [ .]. . : - . -,
2012. 93 .
(Computer-Aided
Engineering, CAE) ,
.
,
.
: SimulationBased Design ( )
3
SuperComputer (SmartMat*Mech)*(Multi ) Simulation and Optimization
Based Product Development, Digital Mock-Up & Digital Manufacturing (
). &
& (MultiDisciplinary & MultiScale / MultiStage)
, 3 MultiDisciplinary & MultiScale / MultiStage & MultiTechnology (MultiCAD & MultiCAE)
- 3- ,

, , , ,
.

- - (CompMechLab) - (CAD/FEA/CFD/CAE Centre of Excellence).

.
.
-
.

:
: . .
: . .
: -
: . .
, : . .

ISBN 978-5-7422-3766-2

, 2012
-, 2012
- , 2012
. ., , 2012

Abstract

1. ,

10

1.1. 10
1.2.

11

1.3.

12

2. 18
2.1. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM (EKM/SLM/SPM/PSM/ESM)/PLM- :
, ,

18

2.2. MCAE-

28

2.3. C MCAE-

31

2.4. MCAE-

33

3.

34

3.1. CAE- PLM-

34

3.2. CAE- PLM-

35

3.3. Cyon Research: CAD/CAE- [11]

39

4. CAD-, CAE- PLM-

46

4.1. CAE-

48

4.2. PLM-

48

4.3. PLM- CAE-

49

4.4. op-11 CAE

56

4.4.1. ANSYS

56

4.4.2. Dassault Systmes

61

4.4.3. MathWorks

62

4.4.4. MSC Software

62

4.4.5. LMS International

63

4.4.6. Altair Engineering

63

4.4.7. ESI Group

64

4.4.8. Siemens PLM Software

64

4.4.9. CD-adapco

64

4.4.10. Autodesk

65

4.4.11. PTC

65

4.5.

65

5.

66

5.1.

66

5.2.

67

5.3. ADEM, Model Studio CS

68

5.4.
. 3D-

68

6.

72

7.

74

7.1.

74

82

88

90

92

,
-.
,

.

, , - .
, , ,
/ ,
.
, , .
, , . , 150 .
.
, , , , . , , , ,
. -
, ,
, . - , , .
, -

, (..
): 1)
,
; 2) ; 3) (, , ) .
.
, : -, , , . :
, , ,
.
,

, : ,
, .
- ..
,
, , , , .

. ,
, ,
.
,
, , .



. , , ,
, / .
, , (Computer-Aided Engineering),
M3- MultiDisciplinary & MultiScale /
MultiStage & MultiTechnology (MultiCAD & MultiCAE).
, ,
:
Simulation-Based Design ( ) ( ) SuperComputer (SmartMat*Mech)*(Multi3)
Simulation and Optimization Based Product Development, Digital Mock-Up &
Digital Manufacturing ( ).

PLM- CAE-, CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM/PLM- FEA/CFD/CAE-.

Abstract

The primary aim of modern industry is development of global competitive and


solicited production of a new generation in the shortest time possible. For a successful
solution of this problem one demands permanent generation, application, buildup and transfer of brand-new knowledge, creation and development of highend technologies with their further aggregation into technologic chains of a new
generation, development of science-based innovations and creating of modern
digital/smart manufactures.
The central one, as well as the most science-based out of all technologies which
provide production of a new generation competitive ability, is Computer-Aided
Engineering. For this technology such features are distinctive as multi-physics and
suprasectoral pattern innovative M3-conception MultiDisciplinary & MultiScale
/ MultiStage & MultiTechnology (MultiCAD & MultiCAE).
Stages of key groups of technologies development are represented along with the
depth of their introduction into industry, as well as the evolution of the modern
industry paradigm development: from the acknowledged conception Simulation
Based Design to the conception of the future (competitive advantages
of tomorrow) Super Computer (SmartMat*Mech)*(Multi) Simulation
and Optimization Based Product Development, Digital Mock-Up & Digital
Manufacturing (digital manufacturing as a central part of smart manufacturing
environment).
The trends of development of worldwide leaders and main players of PLMmarket and CAE-market and their main products CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM/PLMtechnologies with an emphasis on multi-physics and suprasectoral FEA/CFD/CAEtechnologies are represented.

,

(The Hyper-Competitive, Global,
Knowledge-Driven Economy of the 21st Century)
, , ,
.


. ,
, : , , ,
, ( / ).

1.1.

1. . , , ,
, , ,
. ,
, , .
2. -
() (), . , ,
,
.
, , - .
3. (-).
, ,
, () . :
I , II III . I -

10

, , III
, II, III, .
,
- / - / -
, ,

- -
, , .
4. , Coopetition
(ooperation) (ompetition).
,
,
-
, - -, ,
, , ,
(, , , -
,
), .

smart-,
- , ,
, , (MultiScale) , , , -, ,
- (, , ..).

1.2.
XX , , , , ,
(Computer-Aided Engineering, CAE) ,
, (Computational Science, Computational
Mechanics / Computational Structural Mechanics / Computational Fluid
Dynamics, Computational Heat Transfer, Computational Material Science ..)
, , (Simulation & Analysis, S&A; SuperComputer Simulation).

1.1.

11

, ,
, :
2004, National Science Foundation. Simulation-Based Engineering Science;
2005, Presidents Information Technology Advisory Committee (PITAC).
Computational Science: Ensuring Americas Competitiveness;
2006, National Science Foundation. Simulation-Based Engineering Science.
Revolutionizing Engineering Science through Simulation;
2006, Aberdeen Group. Simulation-Driven Design Benchmark Report. Getting
It Right the First Time;
2006, Guide for Verification and Validation in Computational Solid Mechanics.
Part 1. National Agency for Finite Element Methods and Standards (NAFEMS)
Benchmark;
2007, The United States National Committee on Theoretical and Applied
Mechanics (USNC/TAM). Research Directions in Computational and Composite
Mechanics;
2007, Guide for Verification and Validation in Computational Solid Mechanics.
Part 2. NAFEMS Benchmark;
2009, . .., .., .. ,
, ;
2010, Aberdeen Group. Cost Saving Strategies for Engineering: Using Simulation
for Make Better Decisions.

1.3.

1. M3- MultiDisciplinary & MultiScale / MultiStage
& MultiTechnology (MultiCAD & MultiCAE)-*.
MultiDisciplinary & MultiScale / MultiStage
, () - / - / , (MultiPhysics),
, , (Computer-Aided Engineering).
M3-, , , , :
, , ,
-, --- ( MultiDisciplinary),
--- ( MultiScale), CAE- , ,
(, /
/ / / .., MultiStage).

12


(MultiStage)

KH

KH

KH

KH

KH

-,
3-

, ,
, ,
, ..

KH
KH

KH

Homo
KH

Hetero
KH

KH

KH

KH

KH

KH

(MultiScale)

...

KH

KH

/
/

(MultiDisciplinary)

KH
KH
KH

KH -

...
KH

KH - (Know-How),
,

.

1. M3- - M3- , , , , .

2. Simulation-Based Design
, CAD- (Computer-Aided Design) - (Finite Element Simulation, FE
Simulation; Simulation & Analysis, S&A) CAE-
-
( , , , -, -, -, - , - / - , , ..), ,
, XXI - .
Simulation-Based Design (; Finite Element Method,
FEM) , :
CAD, Computer-Aided Design (,
); CAD: CAD (MCAD
Mechanical CAD), CAD (ECAD Electronic CAD / EDA
Electronic Design Automation) - CAD (CAD/AEC
Architectural, Engineering and Construction), , -

:
*- M3- ,


, , , . : .. , ..
, .. .

,
-.

1.3.

13

MCAD- ;
FEA, Finite Element Analysis - , , , , ,
, , , , , ..
; , ,
, ,
(, ,
), ,
..;
CFD, Computational Fluid Dynamics ,
;
CAE, Computer-Aided Engineering ,
CAE-, FEA- CFD- ,
. ( ) CAE-
,
- , , ,
, ;
FEA, CFD MBD (Multi Body Dynamics)
(CAE),
, , MCAE (Mechanical CAE),
ECAE (Electrical CAE), AEC (Architecture, Engineering and Construction) ..
:
- ,
, - / - /
- , ; CAE-, -;
- , - (----;
-
- ; .. );
- , ,
, SuperComputer (SmartMat*Mech)*(Multi3) Simulation and
Optimization Based Product Development, ,
, , . .
- - (- ), ( ),
.

14

1-2

1-3

1-2

2-3

1-3

1-2-3*

1-2-3*

2-3

2.

. , ,
.
2. Simulation-Based Design. XXI Simulation-Based Design
- CAE- .
, , Simulation-Based Design
Digital Manufacturing ( )
(.. , 2011), :
Simulation-Based Design;
Simulation-Based Design / Engineering ( ,
);
MultiDisciplinary Simulation-Based Design / Engineering ( ,
);
SuperComputer MultiDisciplinary Simulation-Based Design / Engineering HPC- (High Performance Computing) (,
.., , CPU- GPU) (, , / , / / )
,
, - -

1.3.

15

, , , , . ,

,
,
HP*C- (High Productivity Computing), ,
, , , , ,
, 100%
),
SuperComputer (MultiScale / MultiStage * MultiDisciplinary * MultiTechnology)
Simulation-Based Design / Engineering ( :
/ * *
), MultiTechnology , , MultiCAD & MultiCAE;
SuperComputer (Material Science * Mechanics) * (Multi3) Simulation-Based
Design / Engineering ( );
SuperComputer (SmartMat*Mech)*(Multi3) Simulation and Optimization Based
Design / Engineering ( smart- / , (, , , , ..), ..);
SuperComputer (SmartMat*Mech)*(Multi3) Simulation and Optimization Based
Product Development (, Virtual Product Development
/ );
Digital Mock-Up / Digital Manufacturing ( , 3-D ,
-, / -
).
,
SuperComputer (SmartMat*Mech)*(Multi3) Simulation and Optimization Based
Product Development, Virtual Product Development Digital Manufacturing :
4. D/- (Computer-Aided Design / Manufacturing),
CAD- CAM- , -

16

3-D , ,
, ,
, , (Rapid Prototyping, RP) (Additive
Technologies, AD), , 3-D ;
5. Concurrent Engineering (CE) / /
,
. CE , , , .
6. PDM- (Product Data Management, PDM)
,
(Collaborative PDM, cPDM).
7. Research Knowledge Management , , ,
, .
CAE- (
(data), (results), (methods)
(processes) :
(Engineering Knowledge Management, EKM),
- () () (Simulation Lifecycle Management, SLM);
(Simulation Process
Management, SPM);
- (Product
Simulation Management, PSM), ,
(Enterprise
Simulation Management, ESM).
8. 3D Visualization & Virtual Reality & Global Visual Collaboration ,
;
9. , ,

, , ,
.

1.3.

17



:
-
/ .. ,
.. , .. , .. //
VI .


.
. 2002,
, .1. . -
.17-24.[76]
..,
..

,
// XI .
-. .

. .. . .
2004. 33 48.[43]
..,
.., .. ,



// IX .

.
-. .:
. , 2005. 9 18.
[44]

18

2.1. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM (EKM/SLM/SPM/PSM/ESM)/PLM: , ,


CAD
Computer-Aided Drafting Computer-Aided Design ( ), Computer-Aided
Computer-Assisted
( ), .
CAD: CAD (MCAD Mechanical CAD), CAD (ECAD Electronic
CAD / EDA Electronic Design Automation) - CAD
(CAD/AEC Architectural, Engineering and Construction).
MCAD- .
1971 MCAD- . Computervision CADDS ( 1998
Parametric Technology Corporation, PTC),
Unitied Computing ( 1976 McDonell-Douglas
Automation, UniGraphics Solutions, UGS), SDRC (Structural
Dynamics Research Corp., 2001 UGS, , , Siemens PLM Software). CAD-
, ( )
2-D CAD- .
1970- Avion Marcel Dassault
Lokheed CADAM (Computer Augmented Drafting
And Manufacturing) CATIA (Computer-Aided
Three-Dimensional Interactive Application),
.
, CAD-
. 1965 (G.
Moore, Chairman Emeritus of Intel Corp.),
, :
, ,
. ,

, .
, 30 ,
Intel 4004 1971 Intel Itanium II 2002

, 100 000 : 2 250 220


; ,
...
1980 MCAD- 1 . ., .. 10
, 40 ( 25 . .)!
1980- , MCAD:
1981 IBM PC ;
(2-D) (3-D) - NURBS (
Non-Uniform Rational Basis Spline),
( , concurrent engineering, CE).
1982 , , MCAD- Autodesk, 1983
CAD- IBM PC AutoCAD
, 80/20 20% 80%
. AutoCAD
2-D , CAD-.
3-D MCAD- , IBM, HP, DEC,
, , Sun
Silicon Graphics.
1987 Parametric Technology Corp. Pro/ENGINEER, , , . Pro/
ENGINEER PTC 3-D MCAD-.
1990-
MCAD-: Dassault Systmes / IBM, Unigraphics, SDRC, PTC
, ,
. ,
CAD- UNIX-.

..
PLM, , . 1.
,

// .
- . ,
2005. 4 7. [37]

..
PLM, , .
2.

PLM-
// -. - . , 2006. 06 13.
[38]
..,
.., .. -.
.
// XI .


. .: - .
2007. 12 - 28. [75]

..
PLM: , , . .
2011-2012. - .:
-. 2011.[40]

1995 80/20 SolidWorks, SolidWorks-95


80% Pro/ENGINEER 20%
3-D ,
. 1997
SolidWorks Corp. Dassault Systmes (DS), 2009
DS SolidWorks Corp.

2.1. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM (EKM/SLM/SPM/PSM/ESM)/PLM- : , ,

19

Autodesk, Dassault
Systmes, PTC UGS ( Siemens PLM Software).
CAD-
, 40
(National Science Foundation, NSF) CAD-
.


1980- . , ,
- (Computer-aided Acquisition and Logistics Support, CALS),
IBM (Computer Integrated Manufacturing, CIM). ,
,
.
:
D/- ( Computer-Aided Design / Manufacturing), . CAD/CAM-,
, :
(3-D high-end), 1980- : CATIA Dassault Systmes ( 2009
600 . PLM- IBM), NX ( Unigraphics
SDRC- I-DEAS Siemens PLM Software, High Definition PLM / HD-PLM,
,
) Creo Elements (- 2010 . Pro/ENGINEER CoCreate );
(3-D middle range)
SolidWorks, Solid Edge, Autodesk Inventor,
1990- 3-D ,
Windows. CAD/CAM , , T-Flex;
(2-D ), ,
, , AutoCAD.

20

CAE- (Computer-Aided Engineering, CAE)


,
CAE-. ( )
CAE- ,
- , ,
;
, , (; Finite Element Analysis, FEA).
FEA (- ; ), , , , , , ,
, , , , ..
, ;
, , , , ( ,
, , , ), , .

, CAE- - ANSYS, SIMULIA/Abaqus
( CAE- Abaqus, Inc. 2005
Dassault Systmes), MSC Software, Altair Engineering, ESI Group, LMS Int., LSDYNA NX CAE (Siemens PLM Software).
(Computational Fluid Dynamics,
CFD), ,
Fluent, STAR-CD ( CD-adapco)
ANSYS CFX. CFD-
ANSYS, Inc., 2003 CFX
AEA Technology, CFD- CFX ( # 3
CFD-), 2006 565 . . Fluent, Inc. CFD- # 1 Fluent. ANSYS
Inc. 2006 CAE- MSC Software , .
, -
105 25*106 , , .

2.1. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM (EKM/SLM/SPM/PSM/ESM)/PLM- : , ,

21

. , CFD-
109 ( - CAE- ANSYS, 2008
), FEA- 5*108 (- CAE- NX Nastran
Siemens PLM Software, 2008 ), FEA 2*108 Siemens PLM Software
2006 .
, FEA, CFD MBD (Multi Body Dynamics) (CAE), , , MCAE
(Mechanical CAE), ECAE (Electrical CAE), AEC ..
PDM- (Product Data Management, PDM)
,
(Collaborative PDM, cPDM).
CAE-

(data), (results), (methods) (processes)
- CAE- PDM-: (Engineering
Knowledge Management, EKM), - () () (Simulation Lifecycle
Management, SLM); (Simulation
Process Management, SPM); - (Product Simulation Management, PSM), , (Enterprise Simulation
Management, ESM).
CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM-, 1990-
ERP- (Enterprise Resources Planning, ERP)
, MES-
(Manufacturing Enterprise Solutions, MES)
, SCM- (Supply Chain Management, SCM)
), CRM- (Customer Relationship Management, CRM)
.
IBM
PLM (Product Lifecycle Management), ,
CALS- CIM-, PLM- , .
PLM- ,
CAD / CAM / CAE / PDM (EKM/
SLM/SPM/PSM/ESM) / PLM ERP, MES, SCM CRM , ,

22

, , , , .
, PLM-
CAD/CAM-, CAE- PDM-,
.

CAD-, CAE ( ) CAM-
, ,
PDM-.
, PLM (,
-, , .) . PLM-
, - ,

, .
CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM/PLM
, : BAE Systems, BMW, Boeing,
Daimler / Mercedes, EADS, Exxon, Ford Motor Company, General Dynamics,
General Electric, General Motors, Hitachi, Honda, Hyundai Group, LG Electronics,
Lockheed Martin, Mitsubishi Group, NASA, Nissan Group, Northrop Grumman,
Samsung Group, Schlumberger, Siemens, Shell, Toyota Group, Volkswagen Group,
Weatherford .
PLM- - ,
Gartner Group :
$1 ;
$10 ;
$100 ;
$1 000 ;
$10 000 ;
$100 000 ;
$1 000 000 .
, CIMdata PLM- :
(Tools, , .);
cPDM (
, , , , , , .).

2.1. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM (EKM/SLM/SPM/PSM/ESM)/PLM- : , ,

23

, Tools, ,
cPDM, .
Tools- PLM- CAE. CAE-
, 2006 Windows 64-
2008 ,
CRAY Research CRAY CX1.
CAE, , , (, MultiScale; , MultiStage;
, MultiStep) 3-D (MultiDisciplinary, MultiPhysics) , .
CAE-:

30 .
-, ,
- ,
.
- (Distributed High Performance Computing, DHPC Distributed High
Productivity Computing, DHP*C) ,
, ,

,

; ,
,
HPC- CAE-;
CAE, / / - ,
- ,

;

24


,
, , .

, , , CAE-.
, CAE-
, ,
, , ..
,
,
,
/ / / - , .

V&V- (Verification & Validation)
CAE-, , . V&V- 1999
(US
Association for Computational Mechanics, USACM), - (American Society of
Mechanical Engineers, ASME), (American National Standards Institute, ANSI) - (National Agency of Finite
Element Methods and Standards, NAFEMS, ),
(FEA, CFD, CAE), (International Association for Computational Mechanics, IACM) NAFEMS.
CAE-
(, ..) ,
CAE- . , , -

2.1. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM (EKM/SLM/SPM/PSM/ESM)/PLM- : , ,

25

, . , ,
CAE- , , ,
(CFD-), (MultiDisciplinary / Multiphysics Problems) , .. ,
, ,
, .
Daratech 2006
DaratechSUMMIT 2006 , PLM- , .. 2007-2016 ., CAE-, ..
CAE- PLM
. ,
, .

PLM-:
1970 ;
1970 2-D ;
1985 3-D ;
1995 3-D ;
2005 CAD- CAE-, (PLM-),
, ;
(
2010 . ):
CAD-, CAE;
CAE , ;
(Open
Innovations), (Reverse Engineering), Simulation-Based
Design ,

, - ;
,
, HP*C-;

26

1
Software /
CAD

2-D CAD-,

2-D CAD-

(AutoCAD, );
3-D CAD-
(Pro/Engineer, );

4
2-D CAD (AutoCAD, );
3-D CAD
(Pro/Engineer, CATIA,
I-deas, Unigrapics /
NX, );

5
: Dassault Systmes (CATIA, SolidWorks, ), Siemens PLM Software (NX, Solid
Edge, ), PTC (Creo, ), Autodesk (AutoCAD, Inventor, ), , (-3D, ),
- (T-FLEX), , SpaceClaim, ;
3D, 4D, 5D, 6D, ;
PLM- =
CAD/CAM/CAE/cPDM/;

PDM is First;
3-D
Cloud Computing, SaaS, SoD, Mobility (Android, ), Sustainability, , ;
CAD-

, , ,
, ;
Windows (SolidWorks, );
CAD- ; , ;
Digital Manufacturing ( ), , , ;
CAD-,
Software /
CAE


(,
FEA),

in-house FEA-software
();

CAE-

(ANSYS, COSMOS,
();
NASTRAN, )

in-house FEA (),
2-D 3-D
software
,
,


,

2-D

()

FEA/CAE-

-:

(ANSYS, Abaqus,

(3-D
, ,
, , , .)
, , , ,
, ,

MSC Software,
HyperWorks, LMS, ESI
Group, LS-DYNA, )
3-D
,


,
(,
,
,
,

MultiScale / MultiStage * MultiDisciplinary * MultiTechnology (MultiCAD, MultiCAE, );

FEA/CAE/CFD-

);

(ANSYS, SIMULIA/Abaqus, MSC Software, HyperWorks, LMS, ESI Group, LSDYNA, ) 3-D , ,
, , .
(, , ,

CFD- (Fluent,
STAR-CD,

, , , ,
..);

CFX, )

();

, , ANSYS (CFX, Autodyne, Fluent, Ansoft, );


HPC- CAE-;
- , , ;
CAE ( ,
, , , );
Research Knowledge Management, ;
Cloud Computing, SaaS, SoD, Mobility (Android, ), Sustainability, , ;
SuperComputer (Smart Mat*Mech)*(Multi3) Simulation and Optimization
Based Product Development;
Digital Mock-Up, Digital Manufacturing ( ), ,
, ;
CAE- ;
CAE-,

Hardware

(IBM; ,

-,
(IBM; , EC ),
EC ),
,
;

(), ,

,

,
(,

Brainware

, , HPC, HP*C-,
;

Windows- ;
Windows-
- (PDP,
;
;
; DEC, );
SuperComputer (Smart Mat*Mech)*(Multi3) Simulation and Optimization
(IBM, HP, Sun,

Based Product Development;
); Windows-
Cloud Computing, SaaS, SoD, Mobility (Android, ), Sustainability, , ;
(, );
;
;

-220, );

-:
;
;
(3-D
,
,
, , ,
, , .) ,

, , ,

, ,


in-house CAE- CAE-;
MultiScale / MultiStage * MultiDisciplinary * MultiTechnology (MultiCAD, MultiCAE, );

, ;


=
;
CAE- ;
, , , , - ,
- -,
: Centre of Excellence ( ), , , , ,

1. : .

2.1. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM (EKM/SLM/SPM/PSM/ESM)/PLM- : , ,

27

:
Cyon Research 2010 Survey
of Engineering Software
Users. A Cyon Research
Report. September 7, 2010.
[11]
., .
MCAE-. I. //
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer,
2009, 1, 64 69. [58]
., .
MCAE-. II. //
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer,
2009, 2, 58 63. [59]
., .
MCAE-. III. //
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer,
2009, 4, 64 75. [60]

(Digital
Manufacturing);
:
(SaaS, Software as a Service)
(SoD, Software on Demand);
(Cloud Computing), , , : ,
?
? ;
,
( , , , Twitter Facebook,
-
,
,
);
, , ,
, -,

2.2. MCAE-
2008 Cyon
Research Corporation
MCAE- (Classes
of MCAE software: clarifying the market).
-, , (CAE-) - / (Mechanical
Computer-Aided Engineering, MCAE) .
-, MCAE .
-, . , MCAE-

mid-range high-end.
Cyon Research MCAE-:
(difficulty) ,
(straightforward) ()
(hairy, , ,
);

28

()
(Big, Large / Difficult / Complex
/Challenges )


(Automatable)


(... / Small / Simple Tasks)

-
(Hairy / SuperLarge /
SuperDifficult / SuperComplex /
Grand Challenges)

3. ,
MCAE-.

(scale) , ; , , , (big) ;
(workflow); , ,
, , (automatable problems).
, MCAE- , ( )
.
, (complexity) ,
.
MCAE-
-
, (Digital Product Simulation
Management, PSM),
SPDM (Simulation and Process Data Management, SPDM
).
, Simulation
. Cyon Research ,
MCAE-

2.2. MCAE-

29

MCAE.
MCAE, , CAE-.
yon Research, MCAE- , .
MCAE-
. ,
() ( , -) .

( ), , (
), .
MCAE- .
,
( ).
-
, ,
(,
, / , , , ; ,
..); ,
MCAE-.
, MCAE-,
. , ,
MCAE-
, Altair Engineering, ANSYS, Inc., Dassault Systmes, MSC Software
Siemens PLM Software ( ).
. , -

. ; , , .
CAD- (Mechanical
Computer-Aided Design, MCAD) Cyon Research , ,
, ,
MCAE-.

30

MCAD- ,
, MCAD-. Mainstream (, mid-range) Specialized (,
high-end). Mainstream
,
-, Specialized , , , -,
. ,
Cyon Research, MCAE-
, MCAD-.

:
., .

MCAE-. III. //
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer,
2009, 4, 64 75.

2.3. C MCAE-
(, ) , , , , yon Research,
. , -
, .
, , ,
, ,
- , .

, yon Research
MCAE-:

Comet
GeomSim Abstract (Simmetrix)
MSC.FluidConnection

ANSYS Workbench
MSC.SimEnterprise
SIMULIA SLM

Altair Process Manager


ANSYS Workbench
MSC.SimXpert

4. .
4. .

2.3. C MCAE-

31

( / ; /
/ / ..);
, ;
, ,
;
;
;
;
;
;
;
;
, ,
.
, MCAE- .

2.4. MCAE-
yon Research,

MCAE- . MCAE-
,
(Physical Prototyping),
, ,
-
(Digital Mock-Up, Digital Prototyping). , ,
,
.
, yon Research, MCAE-
, . , -
, -
. ( ) (mainstream) MCAD-,
MCAE-, , SolidWorks Office Premium, Solid Edge Femap Express, Autodesk
Inventor Professional ( Autodesk Inventor Simulation Suite).

32

CAE

- CATIA Analysis
- Femap Express
- Inventor Professional
- NX CAE
- SolidWorks

- SolidWorks Simulation
(COSMOSWorks Advanced Professional)

- ALGOR Professional Static/LM


- Femap NX Nastran

- ALGOR Professional MES


- ANSYS Workbench
- Femap NX Nastran
- MSC.Nastran, MSC.SimDesigner
- NX CAE

- ALGOR Professional Designer


- COMSOL

- ANSYS Workbench
- COMSOL
- Altair HyperMesh/HyperWorks
- MSC.Nastran/MSC.SimXpert/
SimManager
- NX Nastran
- SIMULIA/Abaqus
- Star-CD

AMPS
ANSYS Workbench
LS-DYNA
MOLDEX-3D
MOLDFLOW
NX CAE
PAM-CRASH
ProCAST
RADIOSS
SIMULIA/Abaqus
SYSWELD

- SolidWorks Flow Simulation


- Star-CAD Series

- ALGOR Professional CFD


- CFdesign
- FloWizard

CAE

5. MCAE- ,
.

- COMSOL

- ANSYS CFD (CFX, FLUENT)


- MSC.FluidConnection
- NX Flow
- Star-CCM+

- ANSYS CFD (CFX, FLUENT)


- Star CCM+

- Altair AcuSolve
- AMPS
- ANSYS CFD (CFX, FLUENT)
- CFD ACE+
- CRADLE CFD
- NUMECA
- Star-CD
- XFlow

6. MCAE- ,
.

2.4. MCAE-

33



3.1. CAE- PLM-
C (Computer-Aided Engineering, CAE) PLM- (Product Lifecycle
Management, PLM) :
- (-) CAE- PLM- ,
CAE- ( CAE-, , ,
XXXXI . .. ), , , -, -, -,
CAE-, , : , , , ;
: , , , , , , ,
.., , , , ,
CAE-; IT-
HPC-, , ,
, (, ..),
, CAE-;
, , Internet- ..
, CAE-
. , , CAE, :
- , ..
,
- (, CAE ANSYS, CAE-, 35
000 -);

, ; , , ,
, ,
, , -
, , .

34

CAE- , Formula 1,
Boeing, .
. , CAE- - CAE- ,
, , .

3.2. CAE- PLM-


(ComputerAided Engineering, CAE) PLM-:
, , , (
-), (
, , ., ), ,
, ,
2020 :
2015 ;
2020 ;

2020 ;

2020 ;
20102020 2030 ;
20072010
2015 ;
2020 ;

2015 ;
2025 ;
:

,
(, () ()),
, ;
;
,
, ,

3.2. CAE- PLM-

35

William Morgan, Morgan


Design Analysis Ltd.,
:
.

CAD FEA.

,
(dumbing down) .

().
,
CAE- CAE- (CAE-),
CAE-
(-, -, -, , , , ) :
, - - ;
40 ,
2 , 29 9 ;
57 , () 20062008 .;
55 - ;
,
9 2010 . 218 (77 ), 219 (56 ), 220
(26 ) 132 ;
- (, National Science Foundation, National Research Funding and
Technology Research Organizations .),
(),
(), (),
( ),
- .);
(The industry):
, : -, , .. ,
Outsourcing/Outstaffing- , , :
47 ( ,
, ), () ,
3 2010 ., 4 ( - 31.12.2011 . 241 ),
;
, 27 ,

36

1 2011 .,
2 ( - 31.12.2011 . 41 );
(),
(, ), (), , - (), , , ;
(The World Industry Top, ., , Fortune Top500 Global List);
Hi-Tech--
Hardware- (IBM, CRAY, HP, Intel, AMD, T- .);
Software, , CAD/FEA/CFD/CAE PLM-,
( ): Altair Engineering, ANSYS, Autodesk, Bentley System, Cimatron, Cadence
Design Systems, CD-adapco, CNC Software, Componeering, CoreTech Systems,
Dassault Systmes, Delcam, e-Xstream Engineering, ESI Group, Intergraph,
KISSsoft, Livermore Software Technology Corporation, LMS International, Mentor
Graphics, MSC Software, National Instruments, NEi Software, PTC, Siemens PLM
Software, ADEM, , , , - .;
, -, :
International Association of Computational Mechanics (IACM), ( );
National Agency of Finite Element Methods and Standards (NAFEMS);
American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME), -;
American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), -;
The Aerospace Industries Association (AIA), ;
American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM), ;
American Welding Society (AWS), ;
Society of Automotive Engineers International (SAE), ;
The Royal Society of London for the Improvement of Natural Knowledge,
;
Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers (IEEE),
;
();
;
;
();
();
;
;
;

3.2. CAE- PLM-

37


()


( ,

(

)
)


( ,

, ..


)

General Dynamics, Raytheon, /


British Petroleum, Shell, Schlumberger,

Statoil, Weatherford, /
() /
Hyundai Heavy Industries,

Samsung Heavy Industries,


LG Electronics,
(,
Boeing , EADS (Airbus),
/ Universities /
Panasonic, Samsung

Lockheed Martin,
, , ,
Electronics, Whirlpool,
) /
BAE Systems / NASA,
, , ,
/
/
Air Force Lab., /
, , ,


National Labs. (Livermore,
, ,
(

Los-Alamos, Sandia, )
, ,
)

/ General Electric ,
, ,
, , /

Siemens, /
, .
,
,
BMW, Daimler, General
.. , . ..
/

Motors, Toyota, ;
, ,

, . ..

, . .. ,
(, ,
. .. ,
)
, , , ,
, ,


(, , ) /
,
CAE

Boeing , EADS (Airbus, ),

Lockheed Martin,
() /
,

BAE Systems /

NASA, Air Force Lab., /


(,
General Dynamics, Raytheon, /
(LG Electronics,
National Labs. (Livermore,

BP
,
Shell,
Statoil
/
Panasonic,
Samsung
Los-Alamos, Sandia, )
) /
Hyundai Samsung Heavy Industries, Electronics, Whirlpool,
/ General Electric ,
/

) /
Siemens, /



BMW, Daimler, General

-
(
Motors,
Toyota,
;

-
)

-

, , /
,

(, )
/


(, ,


(, , ) /
,
CAE

(, )

(, ,
)

(, , );

(, C, , );

(, )
(, )

(, , )




/
(, , ) /
/

,


CAE ,
,

2. ( ).

38

- (The media, Mediaholders),


, CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, , , , -, ANSYS Advantage, ANSYS Solutions, Benchmark
(NAFEMS), CAD Engineer, Computers & Structures, Concept to Reality (Altair
Engineering), Contact Mag (Dassault Systmes), Engineering Computations, FEA
Information, Finite Elements and Design, PLM News (Siemens PLM Software),
Simulating Reality Magazine (MSC Software), . , PLM .

3.3. Cyon Research: CAD/CAE- [11]


2010 Cyon Research CAD/CAE-. CAD/CAE- 56%
, 18% - - ,
CAD/CAE-, 11% - ,
8% - , 7% - (. 7).
7%
8%

,
-

11%

56%

18%

7. (Respondents by role).
: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

. 8 Cyon Research.
24% ,
(19%),
(17%),
( 16%), (14%), (32% ).

19%

16%

16%

17%

24%
14%

32%

8. . ,
. (Respondents by industry sector. Many respondents firms participate in more than one sector.
: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

3.3. Cyon Research: CAD/CAE- [11]

39

CAD-:
- 47% Autodesk AutoCAD ( 2-D
- CAD- );
- 34% DS SolidWorks;
- 24% PTC Pro/Enginner;
- 20% Autodesk Inventor;
- 13% Siemens PLM Software NX;
- 10% DS CATIA V5;
- 9% Siemens PLMSoftware Solid Edge.
CAE-:
- 57% ANSYS (15% - ANSYS Workbench, 11% - ANSYS Mechanics, 9% ANSYS Multiphysics Fluent, 6% - ANSYS CFX, 3% - ANSYS EKM, 4%
- ANSYS ());
- 47% Dassault Systmes (15% - SolidWorks Premium, 12% - SolidWorks
Simulation Pro, 9% - Abaqus, );
- 26% MSC Software (10% - Nastran, 7% - Patran, 6% - ADAMS, 3% - Marc);
- 17% Siemens PLM Software (6% - NX Nastran, 6% - NX CAE, 5% - FEMAP);
- 16% Autodesk (7% - Algor Simulation, 4% - Moldflow)
- 13% PTC Pro/Mechanica;
- 10% Altair (6% - HyperMesh, 4% - HyperWorks);
- 4% COMSOL Multiphysics;
- 4% NEi Software.
Autodesk: AutoCAD
Dassault Systemes: SolidWorks
PTC: Pro/Engineer ( incl. Wildfire)
Autodesk: Inventor
Autodesk: AutoCAD LT
Siemens PLM: NX
Google: ScetchUp
Autodesk: Revit
Dassault Systemes: CATIA V5
McNeel: Rhino
Siemens PLM: Solid Edge
Bentley Systems: MicroStation
Kubotek: KeyCreator or CADKey
Siemens PLM: pre-NX (incl. SDRC I-DEAS)
Alibre: Alibre
Dassault Systemes: CATIA V4
Nemetschek: VectorWorks
Autodesk: Alias
Dassault Systemes: CATIA V6
SpaceClaim: SpaceClaim
Nemetschek: ArchiCAD

47%
34%
24%
20%
14%
13%
13%
10%
10%
9%
9%
6%
5%
5%
4%
4%
4%
3%
3%
3%
2%

9. , CAD-.
: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

40

Cyon Research CAD-


, ,
( 65%).
CAD- (,
CAD-)
(40%) (46%).
(53,5%), (54,5%), (58%) (60%).

Altair

0%

Ansys

Altair

Co
ms
ol Autodesk

Ansys

Autodesk

Dassault
Systemes

Comsol

Ne
me NEI
tsc Na
Siemens PT he str MSC.Softwar
e
PLM
C k an

Dassault
Systmes

MSC.Software
NEI Nastran
Nemetschek
PTC
Siemens PLM

HyperMesh
HyperWorks
ANSYS CFX
ANSYS EKM
ANSYS Fluent
ANSYS Multiphysics
ANSYS Structural Mechanics
ANSYS Workbench
ANSYS (other)
Algor Simulation
Autodesk (other)
Moldflow
Comsol (any)
CATIA Analysis
SIMULIA Abaqus
SolidWorks Flow Simulation
SolidWorks Premium
SolidWorks Simulation Pro
Adams
Marc
MSC Nastran
Patran
NEI Nastran
SCIA
Pro/Mechanica
FEMAP
NX CAE
NX Nastran

2%

4%

6%

8%

10%

12%

14%

16%

6%
4%
6%
3%
9%
9%
11%
15%
14%
7%
5%
4%
4%
5%
9%
6%
15%
12%
6%
3%
10%
7%
4%
7%
13%
5%
6%
6%

10. , CAE-.
: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

3.3. Cyon Research: CAD/CAE- [11]

41

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%
71,1%
69,8%

,
30,5%
23,3%

CAD

25,4%

( )

CAE

14,3%
11,0%
10,1%

17,7%

12,5%

11. CAD/CAE-?
: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

4,0%

10,4%

Cyon Research , (. 11):


- 71,1% (69,8%) CAD (CAE) - ;
- 30,5% (23,3%) CAD (CAE) -
CAD (CAE) - (, - ..
CAD-(CAE) , CAD (CAE) - ).

9,3%
9,3%

4,0%

,0%

6,3%

14,6%
7,4%
4,2%

22,9%

90%

35,2%

80%

70%

,3%

14,6%

2-

9,3%

18,3%

16,7%

6-10

,8%

3,7%
6,8%
8,5%

5,6%

6,3%

7,4%

CAE

PDM

Consolidation

11,4%
4,7%

15,3%

15,3%

3,5%

10

16,4%

11,6%

7,2%

6,7%
14,1%

13,4%
10,6%

24,6%

23,3%

0%

CAD

6,7%
3,8%

CAE

PDM

6,7%

4,1%
6,0%

14,6%
7,4%

0,0%

4,2%

26,3%

22,9%

6,3%

18,2%

26,1%

10,2%

5,3%

17,6%
7,5%

CAE
Transition

14,6%
9,3%

19,3%

26,1%

22,9%

19,3%
5,8%
11,6%

PDM

35,2%

6,8%

8,0%

12,9%

CAD

17,7%

20,8%

10,4%

5,7%

Transition

9,3%
9,3%

7,3%
29,9%

12,6%
8,3%

14,2%

21,2%

31,0%

9,6%

10,4%

26,1%
14,0%

10,4%

9,0%
4,4%

20%

29,2%

8,7%
10,4%

1,5 . .
14,0%

19,4%

3,0%

12,9%

30%

1,5 . .

11,8%

5,7%
12,2%

40%

10%

4,2%

17,2%

7,1%
12,6%

60%

21,0%

1,5 . .

27,9%

2-6
22,9%

CAD

1,5 . .

50%

9,3%

2,3%

100%

16,7%

8,8%
10,4%

7,3%

6,7%

7,3%

8,0%

CAD

CAE

12,3%

3,4%

PDM

Consolidation

CAD

4,2%

5,6%

6,3%

7,4%

CAE

PDM

Consolidation

12. AD-, CAE-, PDM-,


1.5 . .
: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

. 12 (
, ) :
- CAD/CAE/PDM-
o 10 (9,6% / 5,7% / 4%);
o 6 - 10 (12,6% / 8,3% / 6,7 %);
o 2 - 6 (27,9% / 31,0% / 23,3 %);
o 2 (8,5% / 12,2% / 12,9 %);

42

- CAD/CAE/
PDM- (23,1% / 21,8% / 35,9 %);
- CAD/CAE/PDM- (18,3% / 21,0% / 17,2 %).
:
- PDM- (35,9%
PDM- );
- CAE- (, CAE-, CAE-)
21% CAE-.
,
1,5 . (A1-),
1,5 . (A2-). , A1 , , , 11,8% / 13,4% / 24,6% A1- CAD/CAE/PDM-, 6,8%
/ 5,7% / 14,1% 2- CAD/CAE/
PDM- .
. 12 A1- A2-
( ) CAD/CAE/PDM-. , A1- A2- : CAD/CAE/PDM- 26,3% / 22,9%
/ 35,2% A1-, A2-
CAD/CAE/PDM- : 10,4% / 6,3% / 10,2%.

CAE

36,1%

50,0%

44,2%

38,7%

42,0%

43,1%
0%

10%

20%

27,6%

43,8%

28,6%

30%

Best-in-Class (regardless)

40%

50%

60%

Best-in-Class (qualified)

70%

17,1%

28,6%

35,7%

35,7%

13,9%

27,8%

38,9%

33,3%

18,8%

21,6%

48,9%

29,5%

CAD

37,5%

43,7%

80%

14,9%
90%

100%

Best Integrated

13. : CAD, CAE.


: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

. 13 , - Best-in-Class (, )
CAD/CAE- (85,1% / 83%), Best Integrated ()
CAD/CAE- (14,9% / 17%). , , ( ) CAD/
CAE-, .. , Best-in-Class Best-in-Class.

3.3. Cyon Research: CAD/CAE- [11]

43

0%

20%

40%

60%

CAD

80%

60% 8%

14%

100%

18%


CAE

58% 8%

PDM

48%

14%

17%

20%

20%

15%

14. AD-, CAE-, PDM-.


: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

. 14 , CAD/CAE/PDM
60% / 58% / 49% , 18% / 19% / 15%
CAD/CAE/PDM .
0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

CAD-

Best-in-class (regardless)

CAE-

Best-in-class (qualified)

ERP-

Best Integrated

Office-

15. (Best-in-class versus


Best Integrated).
: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

. 15 , 80% CAD/CAE--
Best-in-Class CAD/CAE-, Office/ERP- 70%, , 30%
(Best Integrated) Office/ERP-, , , .
0%

Altair
Ansys
Autodesk

10%

20%

4%

50%

60%

4%

20%

12%
24%

32%
33%

11%
20%

24%
24%

90%

21%

18%

20%
17%

80%

19%

27%
27%

12%

32%
27%

22%

70%

29%

21%

MSC Software

Siemens PLM

40%

29%

8%

Dassault Systemes

PTC

30%

14%
17%

100%
13%
7%
12%

9%
19%

12%
17%

8%
13%

16. CAE- (Altair, ANSYS, Autodesk Algor, DS


SIMULIA/Abaqus, MSC Software, PTC, Siemens PLM Software).
: Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010.

44

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

. 16 CAE-
(Altair, ANSYS, Autodesk Algor, DS SIMULIA/Abaqus, MSC Software, PTC,
Siemens PLM Software). . 9 , 67% MSC Software ( , .. MSC Software
), 64%
HyperWorks-CAE- Altair Engineering, HyperWorks-CAE- . ANSYS (37%) PTC
(35%) - . ANSYS CAE, ANSYS
,
CAE-. PTC, ,
CAE- ( , Pro/Mechanica
MathCAD CAE-). , 12% / 8% , PTC /
ANSYS . PTC
- , ANSYS ,
ANSYS , .

3.3. Cyon Research: CAD/CAE- [11]

45


CAD-, CAE- PLM-
:
..

/
PLM 2010 . I. /

// CAD/CAM/
CAE Observer, 2011, 2,
10 20. [77]
..

/
PLM 2010 . II. /

// CAD/CAM/
CAE Observer, 2011, 3,
9 18. [78]
..
/PLM
2011 . I. / //
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer,
2012, 3, 10 25.[79]

2012 North American PLM Market &


Industry Forum CIMdata PLM 2011 PLM 15,2%, 29,98 .
, CIMdata PLM- -
() , :
Comprehensive PLM , PLM, ,
Comprehensive PLM Market ( PLM);
Mainstream PLM , PLM, ,
Mainstream PLM Market ( PLM).
PLM CAD- high-end (MultiDiscipline MCAD, MCAD-MD)
CAD- mid-range (Design Focused MCAD,
MCAD-DF); CAM- ,
CAD-, ;

(CAE- S&A, Simulation & Analysis);
(DM-, Digital Manufacturing); (Comprehensive
cPDM), PLM-,
PLM;
(System Integrator, SI) (Value Added
Resellers, VAR).
PLM , , PLM,
(Electronic Design Automation,
EDA), - (Architecture
Engineering Construction, AEC) .
PLM. PLM 2011 . 14,2%
29,7 18,7 . ., .
- CAD/CAM/
CAE/PDM/PLM- AEC/BIM (Building Information Modeling)- , 2011 . ( . ), ( %).

46

CAD-, CAE- PLM-

; $931,90; 3%

Focused Apps; $1 431,26; 5%

AEC; $2 381,90;
9%

Digital Manufacturing; $505,55; 2%

EDA; $6 296,72; 24%

NC Non-Bundled; $932,96; 3%

MCAD-Design Focused; $2
362,45; 9%

MCAD-Multidiscipline; $3 081,42;
12%

Comprehensive cPDm; $3 932,94;


15%

SI/Reseller/VAR; $4 902,52; 18%

17. PLM 2011 .


: .. /PLM 2011
. I. / // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2012, 3, 10 25.

Digital Manufacturing; $505,60; 3%


NC Non-Bundled; $933,00; 5%

MCAD-Design Focused; $2 362,40;


13%

Simulation & Analysis; $2


941,60; 16%

Comprehensive cPDm; $3 932,90;


21%
MCAD-Multidiscipline; $3 081,40;
16%

SI/Reseller/VAR; $4 902,50; 26%

18. PLM 2011 .


: .. /PLM 2011
. I. / // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2012, 3, 10 25.

47

4.1. CAE-
2011 Top-11 2.655 . , 90.3%
CAE, , CIMdata, 2.942 . . 2010
84.2% 2.324 , 2009 82.9%
2.130 . , 2008 76.6% 2.275 .; ,

( MathWorks).
,
;
, .

4.2. PLM-
, CAE PLM-.
CIMdata Autodesk PLM, 2010
2011 . Dassault Systmes,
Autodesk, Siemens PLM Software PTC. ,
Autodesk , - (AEC).
CIMdata (. 17-18).
, (Product
Lifecycle Management PLM), CIMdata
:
comprehensive PLM , PLM;
mainstream PLM , PLM.
PLM
:
(Mechanical ComputerAided Design, MCAD) high-end (MultiDiscipline) mid-range (Design
Focused);
(Computer-Aided Manufacturing,
CAM); CIMdata CAM-
(non-bundled Numerical Control),
MCAD-;

(Computer-Aided Engineering, CAE Simulation & Analysis, S&A);

(comprehensive cPDm collaborative Product
Definition management);
(Digital Manufacturing DM);
(System Integrators SI)

48

CAD-, CAE- PLM-

(Value Added Resellers VAR), PLM.


, , PLM,
:

(Electronic Design Automation, EDA);

(Architecture Engineering Construction, AEC);
(focused) .
PLM , :
PLM- ; PLM CAD-, CAM-, CAE- PDM-,
SI+VAR ;
PLM- ; PLM- DM-.

4.3. PLM- CAE-


PLM 2010 7.7% ( 14.025 16.3
. ) 2009 , 2011
14.5% ( 16.3 18.659 .) 2010 (. 5-7).
PLM 2010 16.2% ( 23.956 25.8
. ) 2009 , 2011
9.6% ( 25.8 28.270 .) 2010 .
2011
PLM 2008 ,
.

Marc Halpern,

,
Gartner:

.
,
MCAE-
,

.

.
, MCAE

,
,



MCAE-,
MCAE-.

CAE- CIMdata, 2011


2.942 . , 29.3% 2008 . CAE- PDM. ,
CAM-, , 2011
CIMdata .
PLM ,
CAE-. CIMdata, 2011
2009 ,
2008- (. 17-18, . 5, 7).
PLM, CAE- :
PLM 22.2%;
PLM 21.4%;
PLM 15.8%;
PLM 10.4%.

4.2. PLM-

49

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

ANSYS
Dassault Systemes
MSC.Software

2008

LMS International
Altair Engineering
ESI group
Siemens PLM
CD-adapco
Autodesk
PTC
ANSYS
Dassault Systemes
MSC.Software

2009

LMS International
Altair Engineering
ESI group
Siemens PLM
CD-adapco
Autodesk
PTC
ANSYS
Dassault Systemes
MSC.Software
MathWorks
LMS International
Altair Engineering
ESI group
Siemens PLM
CD-adapco
Autodesk

2010

PTC
ANSYS
Dassault Systemes
MSC.Software
MathWorks
LMS International
Altair Engineering

2011

ESI group
Siemens PLM
CD-adapco
Autodesk
PTC

19. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM/PLM AEC/BIM: -, 2008-2011 .


(. .).
: .. /PLM 2011 . I. / // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2012, 3, 10 25.

50

CAD-, CAE- PLM-

800

PLM-

2011 . . . ( ) / CAE- 2011 . . . ( )

CAE- 2011 . . . ( )

Autodesk

2 216 (+14%) / 100 (+18%)

AEC/BIM, MCAD, CAE

Siemens PLM Software

PTC

1 650 (+11%) / 123 (+10%)


1 170 (+16%) / 57

PLM, MCAD, CAM

ANSYS
Bentley Systems

523 (+10%)

AEC/BIM

Math Works

LMS Int.

290 (+9%)
AVEVA
AEC (plant design)

67 (+14%)

Delcam
CAD/CAM

691 (+19%)

CAE

350 (+17%)

MSC Software

255 (+13%)

Altair Engineering

168 (+18%)

CD-adapco

110 (+10%)

244 (+28%)

2480 (+14%) / 395 (+23%)

24 (+17%)

MCAD, AEC/BIM, PLM

Nemetschek Group 228 (+10%)


AEC/BIM

Dassault Systmes
MCAD, CAM, CAE, PLM

131 (+17%)

Cimatron

ESI Group
CAE

36 (+11%)

GRAITEC

41 (+13%)

CAM

AEC/BIM

CAE 20082011 .

20. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM/PLM AEC/BIM:


-, 2011 . (. .), (+%)

. 21 PLM: Autodesk ( NASDAQ: ADSK), Dassault


Systmes (NASDAQ: DASTY), Parametric Technology Corporation (PTC), Siemens
PLM Software (SPLM). PLM- 20102011 . (Total
Revenue) , ,
, , , , .
2011 7,564 . ( 2010
15,9% 1,037 . ),
2008 , .

21. c 20002011 .
: .. /PLM 2011 .
I. / // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2012, 3, 10 25.

4.3. PLM- CAE-

51

ADSK

DASTY

PTC

SPLM

2000 .

936.3

577.7

924.3

525.8

2964.1

2001 .

947.5

667.9

898.3

732.6

3246.3

2002 .

824.9

733.7

725.9

860.5

3145.0

2003 .

951.6

857.6

656.8

897.1

3363.1

2004 .

1233.8

993.4

672.4

978.0

3877.6

2005 .

1523.2

1117.5

744.0

1154.6

4539.3

2006 .

1839.6

1457.9

884.1

1218.7

5400.3

2007 .

2172.0

1730.4

960.9

1352.8

6216.1

2008 .

2315.2

1955.0

1069.5

1512.0

6851.7

2009 .

1714.0

1746.0

956.2

1278.0

5694.2

2010 .

1952.0

2074.0

1018.2

1482.5

6526.7

2011 .

2215.6

2479.7

1218.7

1650.0

7564.0

12

18625.7

16390.8

10729.3

13 642.6

59388.4

3. /PLM (. USD).

2011 Dassault Systmes


(NASDAQ: DASTY) 1 783 . USD, 2 479.7 . . PLM- .
DASTY PLM- .

2011 .

, :

(), maintenance

1783.0
465.0
1151.9
166.1


:
PLM
CATIA
ENOVIA
DELMIA, SIMULIA
Mainstream 3D (SW, COSMOS, 3DVIA)

1616.9
1275.9
762.4
229.9
283.6
341.0

:


-

1783.0
488.8
827.1
467.1

3D- , :
CATIA
SolidWorks

?
47905

SolidWorks

5 386

329.3

682.9

289.2


, .

1154.3
9556

4. Dassault Systmes 2011 . (. EUR).

52

CAD-, CAE- PLM-

14,00
11,53

12,00
10,40
10,00

9,91
8,86

8,82

2005

8,82

2006
8,00
6,45
6,00

6,92

6,70

2007

6,88

5,84

2008

5,84
5,04

2009

4,94

4,45

2010

4,00
2,69
1,66

2,00

1,99

1,47

1,93

2011
2,13

0,00
DASTY

PTC

ADSK

22. 20052011 . (. .).

23. (. ) / (%) CAE 20082011 .


23. (ANSYS, Autodesk, Dassault Systmes) (PTC)
20082011 (ANSYS, Dassault Systmes, PTC) 20092012 (Autodesk) .
: .. CAE- 2009 : // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2010, 4, 77 85.
12,00
Dassault Systemes ( 31.12)

Autodesk ( 31.01)

ANSYS ( 31.12)

10,00

PTC ( 31.12)

9,80

9,19 9,25

8,16
8,00

6,77
5,47

6,00
4,00
2,00

5,30

4,73
3,85
1,93

1,74 1,71
0,52

0,96

2,66

2,08 1,95
0,58

1,02

2,48 2,22

2,13
0,69

1,22

0,00
2009 .


2009 .

2010 .


2010 .

2011 .


2011 .

24. (ANSYS, Autodesk,Dassault Systmes)


(PTC) 20092011 (ANSYS, Dassault Systmes, PTC) 20102012 (Autodesk) , . .

4.3. PLM- CAE-

53

2008 .
2009 .

(.
(.
(%)
(%)
USD)
USD)
2.940
18.4%
2.575
18.4%

MCAD (high-end)

2010 .

(.
USD)

2011 .

(.
(%)
USD)
3.081
16.5%

MCAD (mid-range)

2.282

14.3%

1.825

13.0%

2.362

12.7%

CAM

0.587

3.7%

0.475

3.4%

0.933

5.0%

CAE

2.275

14.3%

2.130

15.2%

2.942

15.8%

PDM

3.032

19.0%

2.700

19.3%

3.933

21.1%

DM

0.510

3.2%

0.445

3.2%

0.506

2.7%

4.334

27.2%

3.875

27.6%

4.903

26.3%

14.025

100.0%




PLM

15.960 100.0%

16.300

18.659 100.0%

5. PLM 20082011 .
2008 .
2009 .
2010 .
2011 .
2011 .

2007 . (%) 2008 . (%) 2009 . (%) 2009 . (%) 2008 . (%)
MCAD (high-end)

2.4%

-12.4%

19.7%

4.8%

MCAD (mid-range)

11.6%

-20.0%

29.4%

3.5%

CAM

-5.0%

-19.1%

96.4%

58.9%

CAE

4.9%

-6.4%

38.1%

29.3%

PDM

10.9%

-10.9%

45.7%

29.7%

DM

8.5%

-12.7%

13.6%

-0.9%

4.9%

-10.6%

26.5%

13.1%

6.1%

-12.1%

16.2%

33.0%

16.9%




PLM

6. / (%) 20082011 . .

PLM

2008 .

CAE
(.
(%)
USD)
26.500
8.6%

2009 .

CAE
(.
(%)
USD)
23.956
8.9%

2010 .

(.
USD)
25.800

2011 .

CAE
(.
(%)
USD)
28.270
10.4%

PLM

15.960

14.3%

14.025

15.2%

16.300

18.659

15.8%

11.626

19.6%

10.150

21.0%

13.757

21.4%

11.116

20.5%

9.705

21.9%

13.251

22.2%

PLM

PLM

7. PLM CAE 20082011 .


800

700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
ANSYS

Dassault

LMS

Altair

MSC

CD-adapco ESI Group

Siemens
PLM

Autodesk

ISID

25. CAE , . .

54

CAD-, CAE- PLM-

2010 Infinity Research


, CAE 20112015 . 11,4%, .. , 70%.
, ,
. CAE CAE-
S&A-, , .
ANSYS, Inc (CAE- ANSYS), Dassault Systmes (SIMULIA/
Abaqus), MSC Software LMS International, Altair Engineering (Altair
HyperWorks) ESI Group.

Joe Walsh, -
Simmetrix, Inc. :
-
CAE-
.

. ,
.


, CAE- , .
CAE- , Hardware Software. - ,
,
.
, ,
CAE-: ,
(High Performance Computing, HPC),
CAE- CAE- (Simulation Process & Data
Management, SPDM), (Software as a
Service, SaaS, Software on Demand, SoD Cloud Computing),

(omputational
Fluid Dynamics, CFD). (MultiDisciplinary MultiPhysics) (ElectroMagnetics), , , (Mechtronics)
- (MagnetoHydroDynamics) .
op - CAE 2011 .
, Top CAE- 50 . 11 , Top-11.
op-11 CAE
CAE- 50 . .

4.3. PLM- CAE-

55

4.4. op-11 CAE [61-63, 66-71]


4.4.1. ANSYS
ANSYS ( ANSS) 1970 .
2200 , - Canonsburg
(, ).
CAE- ANSYS
2006 , MSC Software. ,
ANSYS CAE,
. 2011
691.5 . , 19.2% (. 2) ,
2010- (580.2 .). 2006 263.6 . 2.5 .
, (double-digit
CEO -)
: 23% 2000 2011 ., 29.4% 2006 2011 .
2000

2001

,
:

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

74.5

84.8

91.0 113.5 134.5 158.0 263.6 385.3 478.3 516.9 580.2 691.5

(software licenses)

43.5

45.3

48.2

58.4

71.3

85.7 156.9 253.3 318.1 315.6 351.0 425.9

(mainte-nance and service)

31.0

39.5

42.8

55.1

63.2

72.3 106.7 132.0 160.2 201.3 229.2 265.6

36.1

40.4

41.4

42.9

50.9

56.9

98.5 138.6 159.7 180.3 198.5 228.0

34.3

38.7

39.6

37.3

46.7

52.5

94.3 131.8 151.7 172.3 188.6 215.9

1.8

1.7

1.8

5.6

4.2

4.4

23.4

25.5

29.9

43.8

54.3

65.0 104.8 160.0 195.6 190.5 198.6 238.9

8.7

8.6

4.8

8.0

8.0

9.9

12.1

15.2

20.2

23.4

34.6

51.0

68.4

55.6

60.4

72.3

10.6

11.9

11.8

19.4

14.8

15.1

21.2

18.0

22.2

29.8

50.8 109.0 127.2 134.9 138.2 166.6

15.0

19.0

19.7

26.8

29.3

36.1

60.3

88.8 123.0 146.0 183.2 224.6

8.8

11.0

10.4

15.9

17.0

19.9

35.4

50.9

67.0

75.2

95.5 112.2

6.2

8.0

9.3

10.9

12.3

16.2

24.9

37.9

56.0

70.8

87.7 112.4

14.5

16.9

19.6

23.8

26.9

30.7

49.4

56.5

71.6

79.9

89.0 108.5

18.0

19.7

20.1

24.8

39.8

43.3

86.9 115.1 134.9 137.3 155.1 180.4

6.3

28.5

46.2

78.0

83.5 176.2 104.3 171.9 233.9 343.8 472.9 471.8

16.3

13.7

19.0

21.3

34.6

10.4

4.2

43.9

14.2

82.4 111.7 116.4 153.1 180.7

8. ANSYS 20002011 . (. USD).


: .. CAE- 2011 : // CAD/CAM/
CAE Observer, 2012, 4, 26 37.

56

CAD-, CAE- PLM-


:
. 15.8%
, ( R&D research & development)
2006 2011 . 454.9 . - CAE-.

26. ANSYS.
: www.ansys.com.


(425.9 ., 61.6%) . 265.6 . , 38.4% (. 8).
CAE- ANSYS
:
(Independence), (Company Strength)
(Vision) CAE-;
(Adaptive Architecture) ,
(Best-in-Class) ( MultiPhysics; Comprehensive MultiPhysics), ,
, ;
(Global Support),
,
(Customization, Industry-Oriented Solutions).

4.4. op-11 CAE

57

27. ANSYS.
: www.ansys.com.

: (Advanced Technologies),
(Virtual Prototyping), (Process Compression) ,
(Dynamic CAE Collaboration).

28. ANSYS: : .
: www.ansys.com.

58

CAD-, CAE- PLM-

ANSYS :
-- (Best-inClass Solvers and Pre-Post), , (Optimization, Automation and Customization),
(Knowledge Management), :
, (Moder Architecture:
Cloud, HPC, Mobile);
(Single Physics), (Coupled MultiPhysics),
(MultiScale: from
Parts to Full Assembly),
(MultiFidelity: from 0-D to 3-D).

29. ANSYS: .
: www.ansys.com.

ANSYS - (
, 40- ANSYS).
, ANSYS, Inc. CFD- CAE- CFX Fluent. , MCAE,
EDA- Ansoft , .
2011 ANSYS EDA-, 310
. Apache Design Solutions,
.

4.4. op-11 CAE

59

30. ANSYS-
.
: www.ansys.com.

, ANSYS
12- , , Jim Cashman
, PLM ( CIMdata).
. 31 ANSYS, Inc.
2008 .
, ANSYS, Inc.

CAE-, ,
.

31. ANSYS, Inc. - CAE-.

60

CAD-, CAE- PLM-

2 000

1 500

2 500

ANSYS
19702012 . ( FLUENT, ANSOFT, APACHE DESIGN SOLYTIONS .)
~ 35000 -

(2011 .) $ 5,2 .
(2011 .) $ 691,5 .

Apache
Design, Inc.

ANSYS + APACHE $ 310 .


ANSYS +ANSOFT (HFSS, Maxwell)$ 800 .
ANSYS + FLUENT $ 565 .

Ansoft Corp.

ANSYS + Century Dynamics (Autodyn)


ANSYS + Harvard Thermal (TAS, TASPCB, PTD)

1 000

ANSYS+CFX AEA Technology (CFX)

Fluent Inc.

ANSYS+CADOE S.A. (Paramesh)


ANSYS+ICEM CFD Engg. (ICEM CFD)

ANSYS, Inc.

20012011 APACHE =
1 375 -

500

65

2 200

19842008 ANSOFT = 2 200 -


19832006 FLUENT = 8 000 -
19702012 ANSYS = 21 250 -

1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1969
1995
1970
1996
1971
1997
1972
1998
1973
1999
1974
2000
1975
2001
1976
2002
1977
2003
1978
2004
1979
2005
1980
2006
1981
2007
1982
2008
1983
2009
1984
2010
1985
2011
1986
2012
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

CompMechLab
- -

32. ANSYS- 1970-2012 . ( ANSYS-).


: - - .

CAE-
, , , , (ANSYS 1969 .),
, ( ANSYS
2200 ), , CAE- ( CFD- CFX Fluent, Ansoft).
ASNSYS,
CompMechLab ( CAE- , ) - - , 35 000 -.

4.4.2. Dassault Systmes


Dassault Systmes ( DASTY), 2009
PLM, Top-11 CAE 2- .
CAE- SIMULIA,
2005 ABAQUS. CATIA SolidWorks.
CAE- :
SIMULIA V5 V6; Abaqus; Isight & SIMULIA Execution Engine;
Simulation Lifecycle Management.
CAE- . 2010 DS CFD-, . DS 2011
Simulayt Ltd. (), National Composites Center, .
SolidWorks SIMPOE
SolidWorks Plastics .

4.4. op-11 CAE

61

K. Boyalakuntla, Simulation Product


Management
SolidWorks:
,


3D-


.

,

(),

,
,
,

,

.
,

-,
-.
,

,


. , ,


, .
,

62

2011
283.6 . 394.9 . (. 1, 2).
2010 (243 . 322.6 .
), ,
16.7% 22.7% . , DS
SIMULIA, , ,
. ,
2005 , 4 (,
ABAQUS, , 90 . ).

4.4.3. MathWorks
MathWorks 1984 ( 2400 , - Natick, , ).
, MATLAB Simulink,
. MATLAB - , , . Simulink

(Model-Based Design) (MultiDomain) .
MathWorks . , , , , , , ,
, 5000
.
MathWorks -11, (.. ): 350
. 2011 (. 1); 2010
300 . 16.7%.

4.4.4. MSC Software


MSC Software, 1963 , 2013 50-, 1000. - MSC.
Software Santa Ana (, ).
NASTRAN, 2011 MSC Software MaximumPC - (The 10 Original Software Companies).
, 2006 , MSC Software
CAE . Symphony Technology Group, MSC Software
.
, , MSC Software, , , 2011

CAD-, CAE- PLM-

,
.
, .
, 2011 MSC Software,
Next Limit Technologies,
CFD- XFlow, ( XFlow
, , , . , 2011 MSC Software Free Field Technologies,
.
MSC Software , 2008 2011
255 . Top-11 4- .
. , CIMdata MSC
Software 2011 212 .

4.4.5. LMS International


LMS International 1980 , 2011
1200 . -
Leuven.
2011 LMS SAMTECH.
, LMS
SAMTECH, ,
, .



. ,

,
.
K. Boyalakuntla,
Simulation Product
Management

SolidWorks:



,
(). C,
. ,


3D-,


3D- .

- , 2011
243.7 . 5- Top-11. ,
CIMdata LMS 218.1 . .

4.4.6. Altair Engineering


Altair Engineering 1985 , 2011 1500 . - Troy (, ).
Altair , . , 2011 ACUSIM
Software, CFD. 2011 -
HyperWorks On-Demand,
.
- 2011 200 .
. Altair Engineering 6-
Top-11. CIMdata Altair 213.9 . .

4.4. op-11 CAE

63

Dr. Garret Vanderplaats,




Vanderplaats Research &
Development,


CAE-
:
.


.
,

,

4.4.7. ESI Group


ESI Group ( ESI.PA) 1973 , 750 ; - .
2011 ESI Group :
Comet Technology Corporation, COMET Acoustics
; IC.IDO,
; Efield,
.
2011 ESI Group 94.2 . 131.2
. . 2010 (111.8 . ), 17.3%.
ESI Group 7- .

4.4.8. Siemens PLM Software


Siemens PLM Software (SPLM) PLM.
- SPLM, Siemens, Plano (, ).
2011 SPLM , 8-
NX CAE-.
, NX CAE ,
NX Nastran.
2011 SPLM VISTAGY, .
SPLM 2011 123.1 . ,
SPLM 8- . CIMdata
SPLM CAE- 108 . .

4.4.9. CD-adapco
CD-adapco , 30- CFD-. 550 , -
Melville ( -, ).
CFD- STAR-CD; 2011 7- .
CAD-, CATIA, SolidWorks, NX CAE Pro/E,
CFD-.
CD-adapco 2011 109.6
., 9- Top-11. CIMdata CD-adapco 143.3 . .

64

CAD-, CAE- PLM-

4.4.10. Autodesk
Autodesk ( ADSK)
PLM, CAE . San Rafael, , .
Autodesk
CAE. 2008
Moldflow ( ), 2008
Algor, 2011 Blue Ridge Numerics. ,
Autodesk CAE-
- .
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, CAE 2011 100 . Autodesk 10- . CIMdata,
Autodesk CAE- 72.7 . .

4.4.11. PTC
PTC ( PTMC) PLM .
- Needham, , .

Creo, , CAE, , , CFD (, CD-adapco).

W. Bradley Holtz,

Cyon Research
Corporation Dr. Joel N.
Orr,
-,

, :
,



CAE-.


.
,

(), -,

-,
CAE.

CAE- 2011 57 . 11- Top-11.


CIMdata 50 . .

4.5.
, , ,
CAE-:
CAE;
,
-;
CFD-
;

;
,
,
.

4.5.

65

- CAD/CAE-
: -.

5.1.
( 1989, 550 ,
200 )
. , 23-
.
7000
.
:
, ;

;

.
:
-3D , ; -3D / ,
CAD/CAM/CAE ;
- ;
:PLM ;
: ;

66

5.2.
( 1992) T-FLEX CAD/CAM/CAE/CAPP/PDM.
T-FLEX PLM+ - . T-FLEX CAD/CAM/CAE/CAPP/PDM/CRM

, PLM-
, . T-FLEX PLM+
, .
, - , ERP-,
.
(PLM+) , . T-FLEX

.
T-FLEX PLM+ :
CAD T-FLEX CAD - ,
.

T-FLEX CAD.
PDM T-FLEX DOCs 2010 - PLM - , - .
T-FLEX CAD/CAM/CAE/CAPP/PDM T-FLEX DocsLine PLM- T-FLEX DOCs 2010.
CAE T-FLEX , T-FLEX , T-FLEX / , T-FLEX .
CAPP T-FLEX 2010 - , .
T-FLEX . T-FLEX .
CAM - T-FLEX , T-FLEX
NC Tracer.

5.2.

67

5.3. ADEM, Model Studio CS


-
:
- ADEM (Automated Design Engineering Manufacturing) CAD/CAM/CAPP (Computer-Aided Process Planning,
CAPP ), - ();
- Model Studio CS ;
, , . MechaniCS
AutoCAD Autodesk Inventor,
. Project Studio CS - AutoCAD. TechnologiCS
, . ElectriCS Pro , , .
Energy CS
. GeoniCS , , ,
, .

5.4.
.
3D- .
2010 ( ,
, , ,
) .
, , , ,
, .;
-, -, , .;
, -, .; , , , .;
, , , , .
2011 ( ) ,
2007-2011 .
3D-
-

68

.
3D- 690 . ( 30 . 1
, 23 . ).

.. ().
, 3-D
-. (3D-) ,
(, CAD) . 3D-
,
. , , , , ,

, , .
, ,
, ,
, , . .
( -), / 3-D , 90% , ,
, , .
, , Siemens PLM Software (Parasolid) Dassault
Systmes (ACIS). , 3D-, ,
20 .
, 3-D ,
.

;
, , ;
(
, , ); . ,
3D- ,

5.4. .
3D-

69

, .

-, . , .
,
.
, 3-D (Parasolid
Siemens PLM Software, ACIS Dassault Systmes)
, -,
3-D 23 . .
, ,
3-D . , /
- -,
(
).
-.
( )
( 90% ). , ,
, , , , ..,
..
( , CAD/CAE-) .
, ,
,
() .

70

71



1. ,

.
2. :
- , , , , ,

,
- , ( ),
, .
3.
, ,
,
(), .
4. , , , , .
5. () : ,
CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM/PLM- ,
/ , , , ..,

.
6.
-
,
, , , , -

72

, ,

.
7. , ,

.
8.
, ,

.
9. .
10.
,
.
11. , .
12. , ,
,
.

73

9.1.
(
232- 309-) 01.09.2009 .
()
() (..
). XXI
151600 ,
9 2009 . 540, 541. ()
,
, .
, - ,
(. )
(. ),
,
.
:
- , , , , , , , , , , - ,
,
, :
- ,
,
- , ,
;
,
,
,
, ,
,

74

, / ,
,
,
,
,
,
- ;

: , CAD/CAE-
(PLM, Product Lifecycle Management), -
, ,
, , ( ,
,
), ;
, , , , ,
(,
, , , ,

, ), ,
: , ,
, , ,
,
, , -
, ,
(, -,
, , , ,
-), , , , , -
.
:
, -
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , ;
, , - ,
( -

9.1.

75

, ; CAD-, Computer-Aided Design),


(CAE-, Computer-Aided Engineering), Simulation-Based Design ( ,
- ) Digital MockUp ( ,
,
-
);
, , (,
), ( , , ,
, , , ) , , ;
, ,
, , ,
; , ,
, .

:
, , ,
, ;
, ;
;
- ;
;
, ;
,
;
,
;
,
,
;
-

76

, - ;
, ,
, , ;
, , , ,
;
- , ;

, , ;
, ;
,
, , , ;
, ;
, , ,
, ;
, ,
;
, , ;
, ;
,

9.1.

77

.

:
- -:
- , ,
- ;
- , ,
, ;
-
- , , -, ,
, ;
-

,
,
, ;
-
,
, , , - ;
- ,
, ,
, , ;
, ,
,
, ,
, ,
;
, ,

(CAD/CAE-) ;

78


, - , ; - , ,
(- );


, , , ;

, , , ; , ;
-:

;
, , , ;
- , , ;
(CAD-)
, , , , ,
;

, , ,
;
- , ,
;
-:
-
;
-

9.1.

79

, , , ;

;
-
: , ,
, , , , ,
;
-:
- - ;
, ;
- , - - ;
,
, ;
;
-:
,
,
;

,
, , , ,
;
;
,
;

80


, ;
,
, - ;

, , , , , , ,
;
, ;
, ;
-:
-
, ;
, ,
, -
,
;
-:
-, ,
-
, (CAD/CAE-);
- , .

9.1.

81


1. Aberdeen Group. Boucher M. Cost Saving Strategies for Engineering: Using Simulation
for Make Better Decisions. April 2010 // Aberdeen Group. 24 p.
2. Aberdeen Group. Simulation-Driven Design Benchmark Report. Getting It Right the
First Time. October 2006 // Aberdeen Group. 24 p.
3. ANSYS 2012 Investor Day. Executive Summary. NASDAQ MarketSite. March 2012. 21
p.
4. ANSYS Inc. Ansoft Corporation. 2008, http://www.fea.ru/FEA_
news_1225.html
5. ANSYS, Inc. Fluent, Inc. 2006,
http://www.fea.ru/FEA_news_529.html
6. Behrens A. 35 //
CAD / CAM / CAE Observer. 5. 2006. 15 17.
7. Bozdoc . The History of CAD (http://mbinfo.mbdesign.net/CAD-History.htm).
8. CAD/CAM/CAE Observer. - (http://
www.cadcamcae.lv)
9. Classes of MCAE Software: Clarifying the Market. Cyon Research corp., 2008, 23 p.
10. Computational Science: Ensuring Americas Competitiveness. Presidents Information Technology Advisory Committee (PITAC). 2005. 117 p. (http://vis.cs.brown.edu/
docs/pdf/Pitac-2005-CSE.pdf)
11. Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software Users. A Cyon Research Report.
September 7, 2010
12. Global Simulation and Analysis Software Market 2011-2015. Infinity Research Report.
March 2012. 34 p. Table of Contents http://www.technavio.com/content/GlobalSimulation-and-Analysis-Software-Market-2011-2015
13. Guide for Verification and Validation in Computational Solid Mechanics. Part 1. NAFEMS
Benchmark, October, 2006.
14. Guide for Verification and Validation in Computational Solid Mechanics. Part 2. NAFEMS
Benchmark, January, 2007.
15. History of CAD/CAM. CADAZZ. 2004. (http://www.cadazz.com/cad-software-history.htm).
16. Obama B. Remarks by the President at the National Academy of Sciences Annual
Meeting. The White House. April, 27. 2009. (http://www.whitehouse.gov/the_
press_office/Remarks-by-the-President-at-the-National-Academy-of-Sciences-Annual-Meeting)
17. Research Directions in Computational and Composite Mechanics. A Report of the
United States National Committee on Theoretical and Applied Mechanics (USNC/
TAM), June 2007. 12 p.
18. Simulation-Based Engineering Science. April 2004. Report of the National Science
Foundation. 26 p.
19. Simulation-Based Engineering Science. Revolutionizing Engineering Science through
Simulation. May 2006. Report of the National Science Foundation. 88 p.
20. 01consulting (http://www.01consulting.net/)

82

21. Aberdeen Group (http://www.aberdeen.com/)


22. AMR Research (http://www.amrresearch.com/)
23. Cambashi (http://www.cambashi.com/)
24. CIMdata (http://www.cimdata.com/)
25. Cyon Research Corporation (http://cyonresearch.com/)
26. Daratech (http://www.daratech.com/)
27. Gartner (http://www.gartner.com/)
28. IDC (http://www.idc.com/)
29. Infinity Research (http://www.infiniti-research.com/)
30. Research and Markets (http://www.researchandmarkets.com/)
31. ..

- XXI // . .
" , ",
100- .-. . .. .
, 2011, 6 .
32. .., .., ..
XXI
// , 2007, 2, 3 10.
33. .. (Computer-Aided Engineering, CAE)
. //
(Workshop) -
. , - 11 2012 .
34. .. (Computer-Aided Engineering, CAE). //
(Workshop) -
.
-, - 10 2012 .
35. .. CompMechLab-REVIEW - CAE-: ANSYS Inc. vs MSC.
Software 1995-2008 . // http://www.fea.ru/FEA_news_1417.html
36. .. CompMechLab-REVIEW. CAE- ANSYS, Inc. 40 //
http://www.compmechlab.ru/FEA_news_1779.html
37. .. PLM-, ,
. 1. ,
// -. -
. , 2005. 4 7.
38. .. PLM-, ,
. 2.
PLM- // -.
- . , 2006. 06 13.
39. .. PLM-: , , . .
2008-2009. - .: -. 2008. 24 - 29.
40. .. PLM-: , , . .
2011-2012. - .: -. 2011.
41. .. - .
,
// . .

. . . . 2003. 24 33.

83

42. .. (Computer-Aided Engineering, CAE).


- CAD/FEA/CFD/CAE Centre of Excellence) // .
.
, , 21 2012 .
43. .., ..
,
// XI . -. .
. .-. . . 2004.
33 48.
44. .., .., .. ,


// IX .
. . .: . , 2005. 9 18.
45. .., .., ..
,
// ,
. .
. .
.. "" .. .
, 28 2007 , ,
.
46. .., .. -
//
, - . 2007, . 149, . 4, 6 35.
47. . ., . ., . . ,
, ,
. .: , 2007. 100 .
48. .., .. , ,
/ , 2008, . 78, 6, 500 512.
49. .., .., .. , ,
. ., , 2009, 140 .
50. . // PC Week Review, , 2011.
51. . (Jenkins B.)
// CAD/CAM/
CAE Observer, 2010, 1, 44 48.
52. PCWeek (http://www.pcweek.ru)
53. ANSYS - Mechanical
Design Engineer . 1.10.2006. (http://www.fea.ru/FEA_news_686.html)
54. MCAE: . Cyon Research,
2008 (http://isicad.ru/ru/articles.php?article_num=12593)
55. . // CAD / CAM /
CAE Observer. 1. 2011. 29 33.
56. www.FEA.ru 2003-2012 .
57. - M3- ,

, ,
, . 465/1
21.06.2011 .

84

58. ., . MCAE-. I. // CAD/


CAM/CAE Observer, 2009, 1, 64 69.
59. ., . MCAE-. II. //
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2009, 2, 58 63.
60. ., . MCAE-. III. //
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2009, 4, 64 75.
61. .. CAE- 2009 : //
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2010, 4, 77 85.
62. .. CAE- 2010 : // CAD/
CAM/CAE Observer, 2011, 4, 20 30.
63. .. CAE- 2011 : // CAD/
CAM/CAE Observer, 2012, 4, 26 37.
64. .. 20102011
: . I. // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer,
2011, 5, 74 84.
65. .. 20102011 :
. II. // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2011,
5, 79 90.
66. .. CAE- 2007 . I. /
PLM CAE // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2008,
5, 18 21.
67. .. CAE- 2007 . II. /
CAE // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2008, 6, 18 21.
68. .. CAE- 2007 . III.
/ MCAE- ECAE. EDA // CAD/CAM/
CAE Observer, 2008, 7, 70 72.
69. .. CAE- 2008 . I.
. PLM
CAE // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2009, 4, 77 81.
70. .. CAE- 2008 . II.
/ PLM. CAE // CAD/CAM/CAE
Observer, 2009, 6, 22 28.
71. .. CAE- 2008 . III.
/ CAE/ CAE-
// CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2009, 7, 22 29.
72. ..
. PLM, MCAE, EDA, CPU&GPU HPC
// CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2011, 3, 92 95.
73. : . www.soyuzmash.ru/
mol/docs/sukhoi.ppt
74. . 27
2009 ., , a 26 2009 .
http://www.scientific.ru/trv/2009/029/obama.html
75. .., .., .. -.
. // XI
.
. .: - . 2007. 12 - 28.
76. - /
.. , .. , .. , .. // VI
.
. -. 2002,
, .1. . - .17-24.

85

77. .. /PLM
2010 . I. / //
CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2011, 2, 10 20.
78. .. /PLM
2010 . II. /
// CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2011, 3, 9 18.
79. .. /PLM
2011 . I. / // CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2012,
3, 10 25.
80. .. . , 1987.
81. .., .. :
//
. 2007. 52. . 11-18.
82. . CAD
. 26.03.2012 (http://isicad.ru/ru/articles.php?article_num=15158).
83.
151600
( () "").
9
2009 . 541, 18 2009 .
15741.
84.
151600
( () "").
9
2009 . 540, 8 2010 .
16298.
85. .. . // STRF.ru.
86. .., .., . . -
// XIV . -. .
. .: . . 2007.
87. .., .., .., .., .. // . 10. .:
- . 2007. 5 22.
88. . (Evans M.) ,
// CAD/CAM/CAE Observer, 2011, 6, 18 20.
89. PLM // : . , . , . .
: . 2008. 445 .

86

87

1. M3- - M3-
, , , ,
13
2. 15
3. , MCAE-
29
4.
31
4.
31
5. MCAE- ,
33
6. MCAE- ,
33
7. (Respondents by role)
39
8.
39
9. , CAD-
40
10. , CAE-
41
11. CAD/
CAE-?
42
12. AD-, CAE-, PDM-,
1.5
.
42
13. : CAD, CAE
43
14. AD-, CAE-, PDM- 44
15.
(Best-in-class versus Best Integrated)
44
16. CAE- (Altair, ANSYS,
Autodesk Algor, DS SIMULIA/Abaqus, MSC Software, PTC, Siemens PLM Software) 44
17. PLM 2011 .
47
18. PLM 2011 .
47
19. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM/PLM AEC/BIM:
-, 2008-2011 . (. .)
50

88

20. CAD/CAM/CAE/PDM/PLM AEC/BIM: -, 2011 . (. .), (+%) 51


21. c 20002011 .
51
22.
20052011 . (. .)
53
23. (. ) / (%)
CAE 20082011 .
53
23. (ANSYS,
Autodesk, Dassault Systmes) (PTC) 20082011
(ANSYS, Dassault Systmes, PTC) 20092012 (Autodesk)
53
24.
(ANSYS, Autodesk,Dassault Systmes) (PTC) 20092011
(ANSYS,Dassault Systmes,PTC)20102012(Autodesk),. 53
25. CAE,
54
26. ANSYS
57
27. ANSYS
58
28. ANSYS: :
58
29. ANSYS:
59
30. ANSYS-
60
31. ANSYS, Inc.
60
32. ANSYS- 19702012 . ( ANSYS-)

61

1. : 27
2.
( )
38
3. /PLM (. USD)
52
4. Dassault Systmes 2011 . (. EUR) 52
5. PLM 20082011 .
54
6. / (%) 20082011 .

54
7. PLM
CAE 20082011 .
54
8. ANSYS 20002011 . (. USD) 56

89

1. ABET
2. AD
3. AEC
4. CAD
5. CAE
6. CALS
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.

CDIO
CE
CFD
CIM
CRM
ECAE
EIT
EKM
FEA
FANI

17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.

MBD
MCAE
MES
MIT
PDM
PLM
RP
SCM
SLM
STEM

27. TAP
28. WA
29.
30.
31.

90

Accreditation Board for Engineering and


Technology
Additive Technologies
Architecture, Engineering and Construction
Computer-Aided Design
Computer-Aided Engineering
Computer-aided Acquisition and Logistics
Support
Conceive-Design-Implement-Operate
Concurrent Engineering
Computational Fluid Dynamics
Computer Integrated Manufacturing
Customer Relationship Management
Electrical CAE
European Institute of Technology
Engineering Knowledge Management
Finite Element Analysis
European Federation of National Engineering
Associations
Multi Body Dynamics
Mechanical CAE
Manufacturing Enterprise Solutions
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Product Data Management
Product Lifecycle Management
Rapid Prototyping
Supply Chain Management
Simulation Lifecycle Management
Science, Technology, Engineering and
Mathematics
Tapping Americas Potential
Washington Accord

32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.

43.
44.
45.
46.

-




-
-, -
-


-

91


-
- 2000
.
: (),
, , - .
-
.
.

. , ,
.
, ,
- .
, , , -.

, 199106, -, 26- .., . 15, . 2, . .


./: +7 (812) 380 0320, 380 0321
E-mail: mail@csr-nw.ru
http://www.csr-nw.ru

92

-


- ,
.
30 000 .
3 000 , 27
- , 500 , .
2007
2008 . -
. 2010 .
, .
20102019 . ,
.
218, 219, 220.
20 , 7 ;
; ,
. ,
- 250 , , ,
- .
, 195251, -, ., . 29.
./: +7 (812) 552 7395
E-mail: iafc@spbstu.ru
http://www.spbstu.ru

93

. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .




005-9, . 2; 95 3005

27.12.2012. 6084 1/8. .


. . . 11,75. 100. 2827.

-, ,
.
195251, -, ., 29.
.: (812) 550-40-14.
./: (812) 297-57-76.