Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 6

INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT

LESSON 18
THE ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT

Poverty does not destroy virtue, nor does wealth bestow it. subsidiary, made the first contact with Soviet officials. They
- Spanish Provers began lengthy negotiations, which lasted until 1988 when a
formal agreement was signed. In the mean-time, McDonald’s
Learning Objective had opened restaurants in Hungary and Yugoslavia, thus
• To learn the criteria for the dividing countries into different providing the company with valuable experience in operating in
economic categories communist countries. By the mid-1980s, the company was
• To learn the difference among the world’s major economic expanding more rapidly outside the United States than inside,
systems and company executives reasoned that if they were to meet the
• To discuss key economic issues that influence international
company’s rapid growth objectives, that trend must continue.
business Although the Moscow City Council was a partner of
• To assess the transition process certain countries are
McDonald’s in the Russian joint venture, the com-pany
undertaking in changing to market economic-and how this repeatedly ran into negative responses, such as “Sorry, you’re not
transition affects international firms and managers in my five-year plan,” when it attempted to obtain such
materials as sand or gravel to build the restaurant. The company
CASE Study had to negoti-ate to ensure it would be allocated, in the then-
McDonald’s Corporation in Emerging Markets Soviet Union central plan, sufficient sugar and flour, which were
Nearly everyone has an opinion about McDonald’s, including in chronically short supply. Even for some products in sufficient
Jerry Seinfeld. In one of his live standup acts, he relayed the supply, such as mustard, government regulations prevented
following observations. Soviet manufacturers from deviating from standard recipes in
order to comply with McDonald’s needs. In other cases, strict
Why McDonald’s Still counting? How insecure is this company?
allocation regulations dictated that Soviet plants sell all output
40 million, 80 jillion, billion, zillion, killion, tillion. . .. Is
to existing Soviet companies, thus leaving them no opportunity
anyone really impressed anymore? “Oh, 89 billion sold . . ..
to produce products for McDonald’s. Yet another problem was
alright, I’ll have one. I’m satisfied.” . . . Who cares?
that some supplies simply were not produced or consumed in
I would love to meet the chairman of the board of McDonald’s the Soviet Union, including iceberg lettuce, pickling cucumbers,
and just say to him, “Look, We all get it. OK, you’ve sold a lot and the Russet Burbank potatoes that are the secret behind
of hamburgers, whatever the number is. Just put on the sign, McDonald’s French fries.
‘McDonald’s-We’re doing very well: We are tired of hearing
To handle these problems, McDonald’s scoured the country for
about every dang one of them.”
supplies, contracting for such items as milk, cheddar cheese, and
What is their ultimate goal, to have cows just surrendering beef. To help ensure ample supplies of the quality products it
voluntarily or something? Showing up at the door: “We’d like needed, it undertook to educate Soviet farmers and cattle
to turn ourselves in. We see the sign. We realize we have very ranchers on how to grow and raise those products. In addi-
little chance out there. We’d like to be a Happy Meal® if that’s at tion, it built a $40 million food-processing center about 45
all possible.” minutes from its first Moscow restaurant.
With 30,000 outlets in 121 countries, McDonald’s Corporation One problem McDonald’s did not encounter was attracting
is “doing very well” by many measures. It has taken an aggres- employees and customers. The company placed one small help-
sive growth stance by entering into risky emerging markets and wanted ad and received about 27,000 Russian applicants for its
riding on the eco-nomic growth spurt of the 1990s. But as the 605 positions. McDonald’s did no advertising prior to its
world slipped into an economic recession in 2001, McDonald’s Moscow opening. However, Russian television covered the
has felt the blow, showing six consecutive quarters of declining upcoming event extensively. When the restaurant’s doors
results. Although prosperous in some emerging markets, like opened for the first time in January 1990, it was almost
Russia and China, it has done poorly in others, like Turkey, impossible to accommodate the crowd, even though it was the
Malaysia, and the Philippines, where it closed 163 unproductive largest McDonald’s in the world. An estimated 30,000 people
stores at a cost of $91 million in 2001. As the world economy were served the first day, eclipsing the previous daily record of
has taken a downward turn, McDonald’s is facing risks and 9,100 set in Budapest. The crowds continued to arrive, even
challenges that raise questions and doubts about the future of though the price of a Big Mac, French fries, and soft drink
its worldwide operations. equaled a Russian worker’s average pay for four hours of work.
McDonald’s entry into Russia in 1990 exemplifies the process In contrast, lunch at a state-run or private sector cafe cost 15 to
and difficulties it has encountered in most developing countries 25 percent as much as a meal at McDonald’s.
where it has begun operations. During the 1976 Olympics in The entry of McDonald’s into China in 1990 resembled its
Montreal, George A Cohon, president of McDonald’s Canadian experience in Russia. However, the Chinese government moved

© Copy Right: Rai University


11.154 159
faster and was more accommodating than the Russian govern- countries, this tem-porary slowdown makes good business
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT

ment had been. China’s government wanted to establish its sense.


fast-food market and felt that Western companies like What will be the future of McDonald’s worldwide operations?
McDonald’s could take the risks in proving its success. Will it continue to focus more on the
McDonald’s encountered similar roadblocks in China, such as
United States, Canada, and Europe as stated earlier, or will it
lack of quality supplies and distribution difficulties, and it has
return to the emerging markets where growth is higher,
found analogous benefits, like high volumes of cus-tomers and
although more unstable? Will McDonald’s management be able
employees.
to choose the right countries, commit the right amount of
In 1997, the Asian financial crisis hit, devastating most of the resources, and provide a strategy for sound economic growth
economies in Asia: However, China’s economy, including its for the future?
catering industry, kept growing. In fact, the Chinese government
in 1998 designated the catering industry as a new economic Introduction
growth sector, growing at an annual rate of 20 percent in the Understanding the economic environments of foreign coun-
1990s. Because China avoided most, f the economic turmoil its tries and markets can help man-agers predict how trends and
neighboring countries experienced, McDonald’s prospered. events in those environments might affect their companies’
Much of this growth is attributed to increases in individual’s future performance there. In this lesson, we discuss the
income, changing con-sumer patterns, development of the economic environments of the countries in which an MNE may
tourism sector, and overall growth in the fast-food industry-all want to operate. An MNE such as McDonald’s knows how to
signs of a growing economy. operate in its home-country economic system. However, when
such a company wants to do business in another country for
McDonald’s success in China has continued into the twenty-first
the first time, it needs answers to questions such as these:
century. In the first six months of 2001, McDonald’s opened 96
restaurants in China, totaling 430 restaurants altogether. It plans 1. Under what type of economic system does the country
to open 100 stores each year from 2003 to 2013. McDonald’s operate?
record of success in Russia did a turnaround in 1998 when the 2. What are the size, growth potential, and stability of the
Russian economy collapsed because of the devaluation of the market?
ruble. However, with, sales and growth on the rebound in 3. Is the company’s industry in that country’s public or private
Russia, McDonald’s had 73 stores by the end of 2001. In fact, it sector?
is McDonald’s success in China, Russia, and a couple of 4. If it is in the public sector, does the government also allow
European countries that is one of the few positive notes in private competition in that sector?
McDonald’s 2001 annual report. The 2001 letter to shareholders
written by the chairman and CEO of McDonald’s opens by 5. If the company’s industry is in the private sector, is it
saying, “From many different perspectives, 2001 was one tough moving toward public ownership?
year.” He goes on to say, “Our 2001 performance was hampered 6. Does the government view foreign capital as being in
by the strong U.S. dollar and weak economies in many countries competition with or in partnership with public or local
in which we operate.” The continued economic crisis in Asia private enterprises?
and Latin America and the economic recession in the United 7. In what ways does the government control the nature and
States led to reduced profits. In 2001, McDonald’s was forced to extent of private enterprise?
close down 163 unproductive stores in countries whose 8. How much of a contribution is the private sector expected to
economies are struggling. make in helping the gov-ernment formulate overall economic
When questioned about how world economic situations affect objectives?
the company’s expansion plans, Matt Paull, the chief financial These questions appear simple to answer. However, because of
officer (CFO) of McDonald’s replied, the dynamic nature of political and economic events, the
When planning openings, we consider each market’s current answers are complex-or yet to be seen. For example, foreign
economic conditions, long-term demo-graphic and lifestyle companies have continued to invest in Hong Kong since the
trends, competitive environment and stage of development, as United Kingdom returned Hong
well as the poten-tial effect on existing McDonald’s restaurants
and returns.
Based on these criteria, we reduced the number of restaurant
additions over the past few years and expect to add 1,300 to
1,400 McDonald’s restaurants in 2002. About 60 percent of
these open-ings will be in the U.S., Europe, and Canada, where
economies are relatively stable and returns are strong. We also
are adding restaurants in China, where the near- and long-term
growth potential is enormous.
At the same time, we are reducing openings iii-markets with
weak economic environments until we see signs of improve-
ment. Since we already have a clear competitive lead in these

© Copy Right: Rai University


160 11.154
A global concern is the growing gap between rich and poor,

INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT


especially in many developing countries. The photo shows the
stark contrast between urban slums and upper-income housing
in Caracas, Venezuela.
Kong to China in 1997, even though the business world is
wondering whether China will sti-fle some of Hong Kong’s
economic freedoms. Companies like McDonald’s, which invest
in emerging markets, are experiencing enormous difficulties
because the changes taking place in those countries are so rapid
and unpredictable. The question is whether today’s global
compa-nies can keep up with the world’s changing economic Demand conditions, also known as market potential, include
landscape. three dimensions: the composition of home demand (or the
As Figure7.1 notes, economic forces are an important part of nature of buyer needs), the size and pattern of growth of
the physical and societal factors that help comprise the external home demand, and the internationalization of demand. The
influences on company strategy. Economic forces include such composition of demand is mown as the quality of demand,
issues as the general economic framework of a country, and size is known as the quantity of demand. Factor condi-
economic stability, the existence and influence of capital tions are especially crucial for investments made for the
markets, factor endowments, the size of the market, and the production of goods, but demand conditions are crucial for
availability of a good economic infrastructure, such as transpor- market-seeking investments. The combination of factor and
tation and communica-tions. Managers need to understand the demand conditions, along with other qualities, makes up the
nature of the world’s economies if they are going to make wise location-specific advantage that a country has to offer domestic
investment decisions. To provide them with a frame of and foreign investors.
reference, we will first describe countries by income level, Countries Classified by Income
location, and economic system. Then we will look at key Although we can classify countries along any of the dimensions
economic indicators, such as economic growth, inflation, and mentioned earlier, the key dimension we use to distinguish one
surpluses and deficits that affect the decision of management country from another is the size of demand, or gross national
on where to commit MNE resources and efforts. Finally, we will income (GNI), formerly referred to as gross national product
examine the potential of the major geographic regions in the (GNP). In particular, we classify countries according to per capita
world, with special emphasis on countries in economic transi- GNI, or the size of GNI of a nation divided by its total
tion. population. Those countries with high populations and high
An Economic Description of Countries per capita GNI are most desirable in terms of market potential.
There are 207 countries in the world with populations of more Those with low per capita GNI and low popula-tions are least
than 30,000. Which of those countries are the ones where desirable, and the other countries fit somewhere in between.
managers should commit resources? Although the answers vary What is GNI? It is the broadest measure of economic activity.
by company, it is true that companies do business abroad for a It is the market value of final goods and services newly
variety of reasons, such as access to factors of production or produced by domestically owned factors of production. For
demand conditions. Factor conditions, or production fac-tors, example, the value of a Ford car manufactured in the United
include essential inputs to the production process, such as States and the portion of the value of a Ford manufactured in
human resources, physical resources, knowledge resources, Mexico using U.S. capital and management counts in U.S. GNI.
capital resources, and infrastructure. Physical resources include However, the portion of the value of a Japanese Toyota
weather, the existence of waterways to get goods to and from manufactured in the United States using Japanese capital and
market, and the avail-ability of crucial minerals and agricultural management would not be counted in U.S. GNI, but it would
products. Knowledge resources are best represented by research be counted in Japanese GNI. The World Bank and other
and development conducted by companies and governments. institutions now use GNI, but the definition and measure-
For example, the Silicon Valley in the United States is a hotbed ments remain the same as GNP used previously. An alterna-tive
of high-tech research. The U.S. government has also poured to GNI is gross domestic product (GDP), the value of
significant resources into the U.S. aviation industry for the production that takes place within a nation’s borders, without
development of mili-tary aircraft, and this technology has been regard to whether the production is done by domestic or
helpful in developing the civilian aircraft industry as well. Capital foreign factors of production. So both a Ford and a Toyota
resources include the availability of debt and equity capital that manufactured in the United States would be counted in U.S.
firms can use to expand. Infrastructure includes roads, port GDP, but a Ford produced in Mexico would not be.
facilities, energy, and communications. Why do we use GNI to describe countries? The World Bank
Figure 7.1 Physical and Societal Influences on International (www.worldbank.org), a multilateral lending agency, uses per
Business capita GNI as a basis for its lending policies. The World Bank
Group was founded in 1944 by the United Nations. It consists
of five closely associated institutions: the International Bank for
Reconstruction and Development (IBRD), the International

© Copy Right: Rai University


11.154 161
Development Association (IDA), the International Finance forward, whereas others, especially some in Africa, are not
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT

Corporation (IFC), the Multilateral Guarantee Agency (MIGA), making much progress.
and the International Center for Settlement of Investment The high-income countries are clustered in just a few geographic
Disputes (ICSID). The World Bank is comprised of 183 areas, whereas the developing countries are found in all areas of
countries, and its major objective is to provide development the world the relative imbalance among the low-, middle-, and
assistance to countries, especially the poorest of the poor. It high-income countries in terms of number of countries, total
uses the measure per capita income to identify those countries GNI, and population. The high-income countries generate
that need the most help. In particular, its programs include nearly 80 percent of the world’s GNI, but they represent a
• Investing in people, particularly through basic health and relatively small number of countries and population. This
education. illustrates the quandary that manager’s face. The high-income
• Focusing on social development, inclusion, governance, and countries are a natural place to do business because of the
institution-building as key elements of poverty reduction. quality and quantity of demand, but the developing countries
exhibit tremendous potential because of the sheer size of the
• Strengthening the ability of the government to deliver
population-74.8 percent of the total number of countries and
quality services, both efficiently and transparently.
85 percent of the total population. It might be safer to focus on
• Protecting the environment. the high-income countries because of their relative political and
• Supporting and encouraging private business development. economic stability, but the future is in the developing countries,
• Promoting reforms to create a stable macroeconomic and managers must establish a strategy for penetrating them in
environment, one that is conducive to investment and long- the short and long-term.
term planning? Another measure of wealth, per capita GNI, is computed by
The activities of the World Bank are important to MNEs, taking the GNI of a country and converting it into dollars at
because they build infrastruc-ture and promote economic market rates and then dividing the total by the population.
growth and stability, thus improving the quality and quantity of However, the World Bank points out that nominal exchange
demand. In particular, the World Bank is most interested in rates (the actual market rates not adjusted for inflation) do not
eliminating poverty and its demand-reducing influences. The always reflect international differences in prices. So the World
World Bank classifies economies into one of the following Bank has come up with GNI per capita in international dollars
categories according to per capita GNI. converted at purchasing power parity (PPP) rates. PPP is the
number of units of a country’s currency required to buy the
Low income $755 or less in 1999
same amounts of goods and services in the domestic market
Middle income $756-$9,265 that $1 would buy in the United States provides some striking
Lower middle income $756-$2,995 comparisons between GNI per capita and PPP GNI per capita
Upper middle income $2,996-$9,265 for a small sample of countries. Note how much higher PPP
income is for China and the Czech Republic than regular per
High income $9,266 or more
capita GNI and how much lower Japan’s PPP income is. In
The World Bank refers to the low- and middle-income coun- China’s case, measuring its per capita income in PPP terms
tries as developing countries, even though it recognizes that not would raise it from a lower-middle-income country to an
all “developing” countries are alike-nor are they all “developing.” upper-middle-income country, which is more consistent with
Developing countries are also known as emerging countries, a people’s perceptions of economic improvements in China.
term also used to distinguish the capital markets (debt and
The United Nations publishes an annual report, the Human
equity markets) in those countries from the cap-ital markets in
Development Report that ranks countries according to the
the more advanced countries. In addition, the World Bank’s
Human Development Index. The index measures a coun-try’s
terminology does not imply that the high-income countries
achievements by looking at life expectancy, education, and
have reached some preferred or final stage of development.
income per person. The index does not include political
High-income countries are also sometimes called developed
freedom or inequality measures. The index for 2002, as shown
countries or industrial countries. Initially, this was because those
in that the United States ranks second in per capita GDP but
countries had a relatively high percentage of their GNP and
only sixth in the Human Development Index; it is outranked
employment from industry rather than from agriculture. Now,
by neighboring country Canada.
however, these countries have a larger percentage of their GNP
and employment tied up in services rather than industry. But Countries Classified by Region
the term industrial country is still popular. The developing Much of the World Bank data for developing countries is
countries; adude different types of countries-some with large provided by geographic region, and this factor will be especially
populations, such as China (1.2 billion people) and India (997 important as we discuss economic growth in a later section of
million people), and others with small populations, such as the lesson.
Guyana (697,181 people). These countries also include counties East Asia and Pacific
in economic transition to a market economy, such as China,
Latin America and the Caribbean
Poland, Russia, and Vietnam. Some developing countries, espe-
cially those in Asia and Latin America, are generally moving The Middle East and North Africa
South Asia

© Copy Right: Rai University


162 11.154
Sub-Saharan Africa Figure 7.2 Relationships Between Control of Economic Activity

INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT


These designations are important to MNEs, which tend to and Ownership of Production Factors
organize their operations along geographic lines. Managers can Their 2002 index classifies 156 countries as follows:
use the data compiled and disclosed by the World Bank to spot Categories Number of Countries Examples Of
trends in key markets. Investors can use the data to analyze Countries
where potential growth and risks exist in the regions where their
Free 14 Hong Kong, Singapore, United
companies operate.
States
Countries Classified by Economic System Mostly free 57 Czech Republic, Japan, Canada
A final way of classifying countries is by their economic system.
Mostly unfree 72 Zambia, Russia
Every government struggles with the right mix of ownership
and control of the economy, as illustrated in Figure 7.2. Repressed 13 Iraq, Cuba, North Korea
Ownership means those who own the resources engaged in In most cases, countries at the top of the index also have a high
economic activity-the public sector, the private sector, or both. degree of political freedom; all of the countries at the bottom
Public sector ownership of economic activity refers to the of the index have no political freedom. In addition, there is a
existence of state-owned enterprises. A good example would be high correlation between economic freedom and economic
China prior to the reforms initiated in 1978 by Chinese leader growth: the freer an economy, the bet-ter off the people-at all
Deng Xiaoping. At that time, all enterprises in the coun-try were economic levels. Countries that are high in economic freedom
owned by the state. Private enterprise was neither permitted nor have more control in the private than in the public sector.
encouraged. The same could be said of all the countries under However, there are some advanced countries with significant
the control of the Soviet Union, such as Poland and Czechoslo- government interference in the economy. Two examples are
vakia (now the countries of the Czech Republic and Slovakia), Japan and South Korea. After World War II, the Japanese
where state- owned enterprises generated most of the economic government intervened in the economy in a significant way,
activity of the country. However, state- owned enterprises are even though it was not involved in the ownership of compa-
not just a phenomenon of the communist countries. Countries nies. For example, government agencies such as the Ministry of
like Brazil in South America, India in South Asia, and France in Finance, the Bank of Japan, and the Ministry of International
Europe also have large state -owned enterprises that are an Trade and Industry (MITI) helped establish a broad vision of
important part of the overall economy. Japan’s future that rejected individualism and open mar-kets.
Hong Kong and the United States are examples of the absence The government protected industry from outside competition;
of state ownership in major economic activity. Although there supported funding of preferred industries; told private banks
are extremes, most countries are a mixture of public and private which companies to lend to; and controlled access to technol-
ownership of economic activity. The degree varies, but most ogy, foreign exchange, and raw materials imports. South Korea
countries with sig-nificant state-owned enterprises, such as and much of Asia followed that same model, also known as
those mentioned earlier, are moving toward less, not more, state capitalism, by permitting government inter-vention in the
ownership of enterprises. This is known as the process of operation of the economy. This led to spectacular growth
privatization, which we will discuss later in the lesson. during the decades of the 1970s, 1980s, and early 1990s.
Control of economic activity refers to the fact that resources may Market Economy Now we need to take the concepts of
be allocated and controlled by the public or the private sector. ownership and control and put them into the context of two
Each year, the Heritage Foundation and the Wall Street Journal major economic systems: a market economy and a command
publish an index of economic freedom in which they rate economy. A market economy is one in which resources are
countries according to 50 variables organized into 10 economic primarily owned and controlled by the private sector, not the
factors: trade policy, fiscal burden of government, government public sector. The key factors that make the market economy
intervention in the economy, monetary policy, capital flows and work are consumer sovereignty-that is, the right of consumers
investment, banking and finance, wages and prices, property to decide what to buy-and freedom for companies to operate in
rights, regulation, and black markets. The study is helpful the market. Prices are determined by supply and demand. In a
insofar as it identifies ways that governments control economic market economy, for example, the price of gasoline rises during
activity and the degree to which they do so. holidays because of the excess of demand over supply. Rising
prices bring supply and demand into balance. At higher prices,
consumers will eventually consume less, resulting in a drop in
demand to match existing supply.
Command Economy In a command economy, also known as
a centrally planned econ-omy, all dimensions of economic
activity, including pricing and production decisions, are deter-
mined by a central government plan. The government owns
and controls all resources. The government sets goals for all
business enterprises in the country-how much they pro-duce
and for whom. In this type of economy, the government
considers itself a better judge of resource allocation than its

© Copy Right: Rai University


11.154 163
businesses or citizens. To use the gasoline example described
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT

Notes -
earlier in the market context, the price of gasoline always stays
the same in a command econ-omy, because the government
determines its price. When supply becomes tight, people line up
and buy gasoline until the supply is exhausted, so supply is
allocated by the queue rather than by price. Before prices were
freed in Russia, people used to say that if they ever saw a line,
they just stood in it. When they got to the front of the line,
they bought whatever was being sold. Even if they didn’t need
the item, they figured that someone in their extended family
did, so they just bought it. When the supply ran out, there
wouldn’t be any more left, no matter what price you were
willing to pay.
Mixed Economy In actuality, no economies are purely market
or completely command. Most market economies have some
degree of government ownership and control, whereas most
command economies are moving toward a market economy
and away from command concepts. If you think of economic
systems as a spectrum with market on one end and com-mand
on the other, Hong Kong and the United States would
represent two of the countries at the market end of the
spectrum, and Vietnam and North Korea would represent two
countries at the command end of the spectrum. In Hong Kong
and the United States, the government plays a very small role in
economic activity, desiring instead to provide a stable environ-
ment in which economic activity can take place. In communist
countries such as Vietnam arid North Korea, the government
still owns and controls most aspects of economic activity. China
is an example of a communist country that is trying to move
from command to market.
Another example of a mixed economy is market socialism, in
which the state owns sig-nificant resources, but in which
allocation of the resources comes from the market-price
mechanism. France, as mentioned earlier, is a good case in
point. Although the government owns significant economic
resources, it allows supply and demand-rather than government
fiat-to set prices. Sweden is a country that owns few economic
resources, but it levies heavy taxes to fund an aggressive social
program. Although the market determines prices, a lot of
economic activity is controlled by government fiscal policies.
As mentioned in the eight questions raised at the beginning of
the lesson, managers need to be aware of both the type of
economic system in which they are doing business and what the
role of their companies is and is likely to become. Many
Western managers com-plain about the government bureaucracy
in China and the degree of influence of the Chinese govern-
ment in economic decision-making. However, China is going
through a transition, so it is important for managers to
understand the direction and speed of change and how their
own industries will be affected by these changes. The same is
true of any country, especially those going brough transition, so
managers need to understand the context of the owner-ship
and control of resources of the countries where they wish to
operate. In addition, the degree of interference by the govern-
ment may vary by state within a country, especially those that are
quite decentralized.

© Copy Right: Rai University


164 11.154

Вам также может понравиться