Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
A Short
Introduction
to Vedant
By:-Abhiram
A Short Introduction to Vedant 2
Declaration
Earlier it was decided that this work will be published and sold at some
reasonable and affordable price to people. The idea of fixing price was that
people should take it seriously for having paid for the same. Later it was
thought that it is poor logic that a thing that is charged gains importance, for
example the air we breathe.. And even if it gets importance then that is a bad
standard of judging the importance of the thing and this needs to be
changed. So this work is to be distributed free as far as possible and if
allowed by the author it may be printed and distributed by any one freely.
This is expected to be done in good faith trusting the goodwill of people,
and is expected that:-
1. This work will not be used for any commercial purpose what-so-ever.
Printing charges should as far as possible be borne by the people who
want to distribute it, unless permitted by the author to the contrary.
2. This work will not be published in name of someone else other than
the author.
The author has written this work for any one who cares to read it. To know
more about him is not important. If one wants to know the authority of any
work he should use his judgment. The standard of authority is not that the
work comes from the mouth of a person who says he is enlightened. The
author does not claim to be an enlightened person and neither expects nor
wants to get enlightened. Meeting the author is not important at all and
difficult also for he keeps roaming all over India or is the on Ghats of
Varanasi most of the time. However since it does not seem proper that a
work written should be left creating confusion in the minds of people, a
probable contact address of the author is given below:-
A Short Introduction to Vedant 3
INDEX OF CONTENTS
Introduction
1. What is Vedanta
2. Adhikari – Fit aspirant
3. Guru-disciple relationship
4. Methods of Vedanta
5. Self: Portal to Brahman
6. Maya – Illusion
7. The illusory creation
8. What is Not Brahman
9. Law of Karma
10. Who is Self-realized
A Short Introduction to Vedant 4
INTRODUCTION
A story in Upanishads goes like this. There is a tree and on that tree
there are two birds sitting. One on the lower branch eats the fruits of that
tree. The fruits are bitter sweet. So when the bird sitting on the lower branch
eats the sweet fruit it becomes happy, but when it eats the bitter fruit it
becomes sad. And once in a while it sees the Upper bird that is so
magnificent yet silent which is neither eating sweet nor bitter fruits of the
tree. It is just sitting there silently, as if free of all care. The lower bird
seeing that, wants to know about the Upper bird but again it starts eating the
fruits of the tree. Sometimes bitter sometimes sweet. One day it moves up
with trepidation and slowly gets near the Upper bird. And as it is slowly
getting near the Upper bird magic takes place. Lo! It finds that there was
only one bird, the Upper one, and the Lower one was just its reflection. That
it was always the same all the time.
And then explaining the story Upanishads say that we are now the
lower birds. The individual selves are the lower bird. The tree is this world
where we are reaping the fruits, sometimes good, sometimes bad. But
actually we are the reflection of that upper bird. And that Upper Bird is
Brahman, our true self. And all our trouble is because we are not knowing
that we are the Upper bird. And once we know this all our troubles and
problems will be resolved. This is the teaching of Vedanta. To go out of this
limited sense of “I” and know ourselves as the Brahman.
One may raise the question as to why one should know the Brahman
at all? What is the purpose of it? The Upanishads say “Bhidyate hridi
granthani chidyte srava smasaya / khiyante chasya karmani tasmin dristi
paravre” which means ‘seeing That (Brahman) one's all the blocks are
cleared, all his doubts vanish and all his karmas are finished'. Also that
“those who know Self (as Brahman) they get out of sorrow also”. And “by
knowing that Brahman one becomes Brahman itself”. Also that “one who
knows Brahman gets the highest knowledge”.
Very few of us are aware of the grand philosophy of Vedanta, the
essence of Vedas which shines forth as ever, declaring human being as the
supreme, professing strength of human being The Non-Dual Vedanta says
two things. First “This world is illusion and actually everything is
Brahman.”. Second “The individual self that is experienced as ‘I’ is
Brahman and nothing else”. This Self is Brahman not in future after some
A Short Introduction to Vedant 5
evolution, not only in past in some Garden Of Paradise, not only in present
Experienced as this moment, now, but in all phases, in all stages, without
exception.
And Brahman is the ground on which all this world is coming and
going. Brahman is the big ocean and all this world is like waves coming and
going. Brahman is the ever present consciousness, it is the silent witness of
all our actions, mental and physical including sleep. It is not that which
resides in our heart, but whole of us are verily that Brahman itself. It is the
thing which is within and without and between everything. It is the seat of
all bliss. It is the seat of all existence. It is not only the base of everything
but rather it is everything that has existence.
This is the grand message of Vedanta and once this is realized in our
life fully we are free from all illusion, all fear, all craving. Life then becomes
a dance of bliss which none can snatch away from That which is not based
upon any condition. Anyway why should there be any fear and why there is
craving for anything? Is it not because of that which we consider ourselves
separate from? But once we do realize that every thing is one then there is
no shoka (suffering), no moha (attachment). Again this is not a theoretical
thing only, not something that which you believe and then everything seems
to be O.K. It is not a philosophy to console and create a comfort zone and
feel safe there. Like a Power of positive assertion it is neither a slow process
of brain-washing. But Vedanta prescribes a very scientific psychological
method and deep logical argument too. There are many processes. All
created at first hand to suit the needs of the individual to raise him to the
essence of that maxim “I AM BRAHMAN”. Before this one does not have
to accept anything blindly, although there is a requirement of shraddha
(basic faith that neither rejects nor accepts the theory but rather experiments
and waits with a rational and open mind). One is free to argue, and
contemplate on teachings. The teaching goes even to such an extent that
“one can know it by means of logic also”. But till the time one does not
realize that everything is Brahman, including this little self, one does not
need to believe it. This is the quintessence of Non-dual Vedanta that “The
Brahman Is This Self”. So let us dive deep into the nature of our own self
and understand all this.
“May I not leave that Brahman and may the Brahman not leave us
either.”
- Upanishads
A Short Introduction to Vedant 6
1. WHAT IS VEDANTA
The word 'Ved' means knowledge. We have this wrong idea that Vedas
are books. Rather, Vedas are the collection of all knowledge that rishis or
seers of yore have experienced and discovered in their deep meditation from
time to time. 'anta' means end as well as essential decision or crux. So
Vedanta means the essential decision of Vedas or in other words, the essence
of all knowledge. Now, what is the essential decision? The teachers and
interpreters of India vary a lot on this point. So there are many schools of
Vedanta thought in India. But what we are talking here is the Advaita School
of Vedanta, that is non-dual Vedanta.
The teachings of Vedanta are very simple. In text there are four small
sentences that are called mahavakyas (the great sentences) and knowing
their meaning and contemplating over them bring one to the conclusion of
their real meaning. These five sentences are :-
1. Aham brahmasmi:- I am Brahman [that I (The Self) am the existence–
knowledge-bliss].
2. Ayam atama Brahma:-That this Self (now in this moment) is Brahman
3. Pragyanam brahma:- That knowledge is Brahman.
4. Tat-tvam Asi –Thou (you, The Self) art That (God).
know the reality. But then how to be silent, how to be calm and all that? We
are bound by some force, so to say, running all the time. To where, we don’t
know. And then if someone says as to why are you running, stop and be
silent and there is no where to go! This creates all the more confusion. For,
before we were running to achieve something. But now the search and
running is still there but with a condemnation, a hatred towards this search
which is very part of us. The search has not been finished but we may start
trying to deny the search causing more conflict within ourselves. There is
really nowhere to go but that happens to be the experience of someone else.
This is useful only when it is your own understanding. Once a person will
understand it, he will automatically stop. One will not have to say him
anything to stop and be silent and enjoy the rising sun and the blooming
flower! Till then his pain, his confusion, his fear, greed, search and all that,
is real for him. So he should not be forced to enjoy rising sun and the
blooming flower. Rather to go out of this all.
So Vedanta says that all our fear, greed, pain and confusion is based
upon this sense of self, this limited “I”. It is like this: first we take this “I” as
being good or bad and then we start to adore or change it. It is this sense of
“I”, based on which ‘mine’ comes. And then we feel that I have or don’t
have something. Then we try to get what we don’t have and get rid of what
we have but don’t like. Vedanta says this is natural and you can not get out
of all this by thinking alone or by psychological adjustment. But we have to
get out of this limited sense of ‘I’ anyhow. It is rather, this limited sense of I
is illusion and so all we have to do is to know that it as illusion.
And in Vedanta, a systematic and practical approach is given, to
overcome all these fears, problems and confusion, for ever by going beyond
the I, saying good bye to them and then never to say hello again.
So according to Vedanta we are all complete but there is a but. That
'but' is that our Self that is Brahman, is as if wrapped by Ignorance (avidya)
and that is why we are not able to be free. This Ignorance is nothing but
Maya. There are many who translate Maya as illusion or as a power or some
others as some sort of Goddess. Maya is the one which blocks Self–
knowledge. It is because of this that we are not able to experience the Self.
And all effort in Vedanta is to gain knowledge and go beyond Maya. But
then this concept of what is Maya really is also very confusing needing
detailed discussion. We will discuss this in detail in the chapter “Illusion”.
Then comes the question as to how can we get away from this Maya.
Here also Vedanta has very a rational attitude, Vedanta says ‘yaya yaya
bhabet pumsam vyutpatti pratyagattamani sa sa eva prakyiya sadhwavi” that
is, by whatever means you get the knowledge of that Self, that very process
A Short Introduction to Vedant 8
is good for you. And then it gives a number of methods that are useful in
knowing the Self. For example, one of the techniques is reading this book.
How it is so will become clear once you go ahead reading it. Similarly self-
inquiry and many other methods can be used about which we will discuss in
detail in chapter “Methods Of Vedanta”
The great teachers of present times like Raman Maharshi, Nisargadatta
Maharaj, etc. all of them had taught Vedanta and they are the part of a great
tradition. Even what teachers like J.Krishnamurthy, Gurdejief, Ouspensky,
U.G.Krishnamurthy and others have taught is also the part of Vedanta itself.
For Vedanta is not a book or teaching of a particular person but a realization
of reality and if we compare the teachings of these teachers with teachings of
Vedanta we will see that what they are saying is part of Vedanta itself. Only
that they do not say so that “I am talking Vedanta”. This does not mean that
they have learnt it from some text somewhere but taht this is their own
realization. And coming to a definite place and same conclusion of reality by
many a person, only goes to prove the validity of these teachings. For
reality and knowledge about reality can be one only, differences occur only
in the way it is expressed.
Again, these teachings of Vedanta are very old. Upanishads which are
pre Buddhist are sometimes recorded as stories of how a person gets
knowledge and sometimes deep philosophy insights. That means teachings
of Vedanta are even older than Upanishads and have survived the test of
time for thousands of years and many an attack both intellectual and
physical. But again teachings are not wine, older they get better they
become. Simply because a thing is old so it must be good is not a valid case.
but a thing that has survived so much test of time therefore it means that
there is some vitality, some power in that to transfer and yet survive in a
long sequence of events. Therefore, due to this also we need to ponder over
the teachings of Vedanta and contemplate over them.
And this has been the discovery of all the teachers, all the masters that
knowing yourself is the cause of end of all suffering. Socrates and even
people before him say the same thing ‘know thyself’. Similarly teaching of
Jesus, ‘I and my father are one’ is the teaching of Vedanta itself. Slowly as
you go through these pages and know what is Vedanta then you will
understand that what all teachers are talking about is accumulated in
Vedanta itself and it provides a systematic study of all that, that has been
said. The contradictions sometimes found in many places causing conflict
among people are also resolved here.
Every individual is in pain, in conflict, in constant fear, in insecurity all
the time. There is so much craziness in the minds of people which is
A Short Introduction to Vedant 9
hopelessly throwing them here and there all the time. Is it not enough to
rethink over entire system and do something about it? All of us are trying to
do and think something about this strife and trying to solve this by many
methods. Some time some of these methods work but more often they do not
work. Many a time solutions with which we come up become problems in
course of time. Isn’t the real problem somewhere else? Because we are in
unrest, so we are creating problem for ourselves and unrest for others as
well. But most of us do want to do something about it. We all, at least most
of us are not ready to live with this all the time and are trying to change
things ourselves. The more intelligent ones emphasize on changing things
inside, while the less intelligent ones on changing outside. But extensive
observations over a fairly long period of time have told us that it is
impossible to change the situation externally all the time to make us feel
better. Even if we are able to do it, the problem will come again because we
cant control the situation, and human minds, all the time in our favour. Even
if we are able to do this the situation which is in our favor will be against
someone else. Every morsel of food that we eat is coming from the mouth of
some one else, a person or protozoa or bacteria or whatever.
So in the first place changing situation
out side all the time is simply impossible and even if someone is able to do it
in his favor he is doing it against some one else’s favor. This can we
understood by a person using his common sense. Yet there may be people
who are so boastful of things that are there all good and nice in physical world
even though their feel good may be only momentary. It is just the absence of
discomfort for the time being, which will surely come, sooner rather than
later. This is not a pessimistic philosophy but rather the reality and therefore
must be dealt with appropriately.
So now we are able to understand that resolving and correcting
outside world only is not going to help us. One may have money, car, house,
or all such gadgets, there is nothing bad in that. They provide good comfort
but yet this is not enough for well being of man. For those without all these
are sometimes seen happier and those with these are more often are seen
unhappy. So happiness as it seems has very little to do with things outside.
So an intelligent person comes to the conclusion that changing situation
inside is the way out. That by changing the mind or attitude or thinking
pattern they may come to a state of fulfillment. And then they are using all
such psychological methods and self-hypnosis to bring a change in the mind.
But most of the time it causes more problem. Still there is a category of people
who are too much tormented by “mind”, or unconsciousness mind who come
up to the conclusion that O.k. I have to “jump out of mind”. That we start
A Short Introduction to Vedant 10
hating ourselves that we are uncomfortable with something called mind that
we simply cant live with any more. So we are trying to achieve a stage, a
place where there will be no “mind” and everything will be O.K., all nice all
good. So we start seeking some stage called nirvana or Samadhi or
enlightenment as panacea for all our problems. We start to look for it
passionately going here and there looking for things here and there. And this
creates all the more unrest because this “mind” is wanders everywhere. This
fear of mind is the worst of fears that can be conceived of. We may dare to
cheat GOD sometimes, so, since this mind is always with us, we think, always
that it is cheating us, manipulating us and making us do things that we don’t
want to do. With this philosophy in mind we go on looking, searching trying
and create for ourselves even worse situation. That is why people who are
pursuing material things in the world or in yoga or doing Hare Krishna chants
do seem to be happier than those trying to go beyond the mind. But the fact is
that, it is in those “jump out of mind” people that have more intelligence, so to
say. But because they donot understand things fully that is the reason why
they have problem. In general teaching of Vedanta is for all but it is more so
for those who understand it more quickly. This however does not mean that it
is not for others. But the acute pain experienced by the “I have to jump out of
Mind" works as a catalyst to understand the Vedanta teachings more easily.
Also they are already aware of the fact that neither an outside situation nor
psychological change is going to help them. Yes, this has to be made very
clear that all the psychotherapy and similar methods are of not much use as
they can not give a restful state at all. We are so much psychotic already and
each change made in the mind will need more changes to fit it. And one may
have experienced it quite often that the change we make in the mind today
which may seem helpful now, becomes troublesome later. So this is no way
out.
But those wanting to “jump out of mind” as if mind was a fence of a jail
which you have to jump, or “break the mind” as if mind was a mud pot, have
to understand the teaching of Vedanta which declares something like this
“Howah!!!! There is no mind, so there is nothing to jump out of. Know that
you are complete Brahman and also that you are free now at this very
moment. Nothing can bind you ever”. But again this assertion of Vedanta is
not merely a “good feel” thought, or a “positive assertion” that you go on
making to yourselves day and night forgetting the time. Rather these words
have deeper meaning to it and many a method to REALIZE THEM, AND
NOT JUST UNDERSTAND THEM INTELLECTUALLY. So teachings
of Vedanta are not merely a philosophy that can be intellectualized by
indologists but a concept to be practiced in day to day life and is an existential
A Short Introduction to Vedant 11
truth which one needs to understand to its very core. The process is not for
arriving at a logical conclusion but to realize by methodical practice, that yes
it is indeed so. Again shallow understanding of words will not serve any
purpose, rather it will create all the more problems. And it has created such
problems to many a spiritual aspirants for a long time. Each of these terms,
MIND and NON-EXISTENCE and GOD and ILLUSION and SELF has a
very deep meaning and needs to be understood slowly.
The Kathopanishad Upanishad says “drusyate twadagraya budhdhya
sukhsmya sukhsma darshibhih meaning that It is attained by a intellect that
is sharp and upfront.
“But Sir, I am such a stupid person, had bad grades in schools and so
Vedanta is not for me”. Don’t raise such doubt. Here intelligent does not mean
a calculative mind, a mind that is good in cheating, good in making good and
incisive jokes and storing a lot of rubbish but rather one which is able to
discriminate between self and non-self and there are a few other simple
psychological rules. Here Self also has another meaning but before learning
about it we need to know who is fit to study Vedanta.
Here this fit or unfit has nothing to do with 'applying for a job' criteria and it is
not correct understanding that anyone not having these qualities is unfit to
study and understand the same. Rather they are the standards and if we don’t
have these standards and these qualities, no need to worry, as we can develop
them.
Now why should I develop any quality in me when I am the supreme
self “aham brahmasmi” myself? Because, to understand that you are Brahman
you need these things. Even if one can say and believe that he is Brahman still
that is not enough. For, then what is Brahman? And also that it is not the
Brahman that can be understood thus. All understanding is in the mind and
freedom that comes is also in the mind. Brahman has nothing to do with
bondage and liberation. It is neither a bond nor freedom. Since all liberation
and bondage is in the mind training of the mind is required. This training has
deep psychological meaning and impact on a person. Without this
understanding Vedanta would be simply impossible since a person may
understand it wrongly and get confused and create more problems for himself.
So in the next chapter ADHIKARI or who is fit for studying Vedanta is
discussed. These are detailed discussions, where methods to develop them
methods and how to develop them as also their effect on the person are
discussed. Even if one practices only these it gives a lot of freedom and
control over oneself. If practiced sincerely these methods will solve almost all
the psychological problems and take the aspirant to a state of deep rest and
also confer some of the siddhis or yogic powers. Although we must not expect
A Short Introduction to Vedant 12
such a things and focus on understanding the real meaning of Vedanta, these
will occur as a bye-product of the efforts.
become aware of them. But there are strong outer actions that we have to
control in order to overcome as we have the choice whether to perform them
or not. It is those actions that we need to choose to withdraw from.
There is nothing morality involved in that. It is just about making
choice of what you want to do with your limited time and mental energy, to
understand the higher truths (Do not say that mind has unlimited energy.
Even if it may have, I am talking here about that limited energy which it is
able to express itself with). For example a man may feel jealous towards his
business competitor, it is but natural and he will continue to feel so till he
understands the real nature of the Self or may go through a mental process,
but he can control himself from killing his competitor. For if he kills him he
will land himself in trouble with the police and jail and will waste his energy
on discussing the nature of law and advocates rather than nature of self. It is
so simple!!!! Similarly a student who wants to do well in his studies, should
refrain from running all the time behind girls. That is the wastage of energy
and time. And if one is able to see that it is wastage of time and all that to
understand the higher truths, and if he wants to do well in his studies,
simply he will quit and focus more on studies. There is nothing here that is
suppression and repression and all that. For sex is a big addiction and he can
see it that he spends a lot of time and energy in that. Or he may create a
balanced between what to do and how. It is more about choosing from a
number of things than suppressing yourself. But there are people who feel
bad because they say that they are still unable to go beyond rules (not to
follow the rules). This “do not following the rules” have become a rule in
them. No be free of all these. If you want to know Vedanta and go really
beyond rules and all limitations you should follow the rules and
limitations.If you don’t want to understand then don’t follow them. It is
more about making right choice, of making right investment. If you are
following these rules which is to be stated later you can be able to save
energy more. If you are not able to follow these you will lack the necessary
focus to understand Vedanta. It has nothing to do with morality or
immorality and I assure that they are not going to built any knots in your
mind. Rather they will open up the knots that one has already.
One more thing here is that these qualities are not like the
things that you either have or one does not have. It rather like having more
or less of these qualities. The more of these qualities one have more he is
benefited from them. This will become more clear when you go through all
these rules or qualities.( they can be called rules when a person is not having
them and is trying to develop them and qualities when a person is having
them to the extent that they become a part of his function of his mind.)
A Short Introduction to Vedant 14
1.Viveka
Discriminating between what is permanent and what is transitory is viveka.
The problem starts here. Entire Non-dual Vedanta is based upon the theory
that everything is Self and that everything is Brahman. But the first thing
that has come technical in this book is that we need to make difference and
discrimination between self and non-self, real and unreal!!!! This is the
tragedy of all the thing. This is the point which we have to understand.
Now Vedanta says that knowing Brahman frees one from all bondage
and also that everything is Brahman. But then knowing cow or pot should
free us from all bondage because cows and pots are Brahman. And so we
are all free because we know many cows and pot. But that is not so. So we
have to understand what is the method of Vedanta. Actually everything is
Brahman but then what is Brahman. This is what neo-Vedantains don’t
understand. Simply knowing that everything is Brahman will not serve any
purposes rather we have to know what Brahman is in experience. And after
one experiences what Brahman, what is the nature of it is he will feel and
know and experience that the same quality is everywhere and then know that
everything is Brahman. So everything is Brahman is to be experienced later.
We must know what is Brahman (a answer that should be different than
‘everything is Brahman’). So here Actually everything is Brahman but one
of its attribute is permanence. Because one which is everywhere in all time
must be permanent. So when we are looking for Brahman we are looking for
something that is permanent, which is the basis of all the chances that are
occurring. But than is there are two things permanent and non-permanent?
No and yes. For everything is Brahman so everything is permanent and what
are these changes are occurring in the things that are not of existence. For
Dog and cats are not Brahman but rather Brahman is, by mistake being seen
as dog and cat and that being seen as cat and dog is illusion. And this cat
and dog is illusion because it is not permanent because in a place we see it as
A Short Introduction to Vedant 15
dog but next time that place is empty. In traditional Vedanta text they give
very beautiful example of this illusion by example of snake-rope. The
analogy goes like this that a rope in darkness is being seen like snake but in
reality it just the rope and not the snake. Similarly everything is Brahman
but it is being seen as cats and dogs. So being seen as cat or dog is
impermanent as snake in rope is impermanent and because it is Brahman
itself and hence permanent. So in Vedanta there is this great emphasis that to
make discrimination between permanent and impermanent. For everything
that is permanent is a Brahman and everything that is experienced as other
than Brahman is impermanent and hence illusion. And once this
discrimination is made we are not motivated to achieve one that is
impermanent and try to know what is permanent. For there is nothing to
achieve. So it is called “praptasya prapti” or getting something one already
has. Hence one is able to direct his energy on understanding that permanent
Brahman.
2. Vairagya
Once making discrimination between permanent and non-permanent one has
this attitude of letting go. For one that is impermanent can neither be
accumulated nor discarded. The rope that was being seen as rope and after
being discovered that it is just rope one does not interests in killing it nor
petting it. Similarly Even if one does not have complete Self-Knowledge,
yet can make difference between permanent and non-permanent is able to let
go that develop a dispassion towards the things happening around. Vairagya
or dispassion is different from renunciation. While renunciation is leaving
the things altogether Vairagya is simply not taking them notice of. It is a
state of big let go. It is when that things start to come up.
time about Vedanta it his highest duty and he should not do anything
and.But not many of us can do that. So Vedanta has a practical approach
here. That is that in rest of time “to do what one’s duty is.” There is story
that a butcher and a prostitute getting realization by doing ones duty.
But here one should be free to decide what ones duty is and
may change it as per his conveniences. For Uparati is meant to help you in
understanding but if the duty imposed on you is causing disturbance simply
quit. There has been a big corporate in Delhi whom I know personally, who
when started getting deeper in meditation left his job and stated driving Taxi
for it took less time in making one or two trip and suit to his basic need. The
concept of Sannayasa in India is meant for this purpose. Similarly a student
of physics if is able to understand the Vedanta and his schooling is causing
trouble to him he should simply quit. Then telling him that following your
own dharma is good is of no use, for his dharma has changed.He is no more
a student but a seeker. But then all those who are thinking to change there
duty must be very sure that they are not doing it with any other motive or
reason other than to know Brahman. Otherwise all this enquiry is just escape
from ones duty and will lead the person to no where.
iv. Titiksha or Forbearance
The forbearance is maintaining equanimity in pain and pleasure, heat and
cold, favorable and unfavorable. For a mind which becomes too much
stirred by all these cant think and understand Vedanta. Every time and every
place we cant have good nice atmosphere to contemplate and all that. So if
we are always seeking a ideal place or condition than we are gone.
Depending own our definition of good condition we may not even find
them. but then should we wait for all the time to come a nice condition to
come and than start listening and all that. It is not so. Rather we should we
able to make use of what so ever situation we have in hand and start
practicing the inquiry into nature of self and study Vedanta. Otherwise we
get puffed by a little happiness and squeezed by a little sorrow all the time
then there is no energy left for contemplation. For example one may wait all
his life, for death of a disturbing wife and never practice anything and
eventually die leaving his wife widow!!!!! Similarly one should not expect
much from one who goes to every wedding ceremony of his sister’s
husband’s cousin’s and remains engaged in that for a month before and after
the D-Day. Here I don’t mean that on should not enjoy but rather such a
person can be doubted of having so much deep sorrow deep inside that he
seems to use all such situation as escape from himself and dance in a illusion
of happiness. We should start practicing Vedanta and bear any problem that
A Short Introduction to Vedant 18
comes in the way as well as digest a situation that gives so much joy that we
are overwhelmed.
v. Sradhdha or faith
This question of faith is a big one and can be misinterpreted many a times.
First of all why should we have faith at all? Is faith good or bad? Faith is
neither good nor bad. If we have faith on a thing ‘as it is’ then this faith is
good, and if we have faith on a thing ‘as it is not’ then this faith is bad and
undesirable. For example if one believes that poison kills it is good faith and
should be cherished. But faith that one’s mind is being controlled by a lasers
beam may help one land one in lunatic asylum and hence such a beliefs
should be avoided.
Again this believe that everything is to be questioned
should be questioned. Why is that we have to have question everything?
And even if we have to question everything still we should never say that a
thing is True Or False until full experiment is done. Same with Vedanta also.
All its teachings should be seen as a potentially true. It
is only than that we will be able to inspired to walk on it with full zeal. This
is not that after one will know that everything is Brahman then he will start
believing in that. Before that he will not believe in that. This is like tying
the ox behind the cart. Neither cart not ox can move ahead. Rather one
should have at least necessary faith to walk over the path.
For example, if some one from Europe says that
until he has not seen India he will not believe that there is such a country.
And because he does not believes in such a country as India there is no
question of going there. Then he will reach no where. But a rational attitude
is that once being told that there is a country called India the, person has to
have at least necessary faith to buy a ticket and get visa and come to India.
And after he has seen Varanasi he gets confirmed of his believe. Similarly
one should have at least faith necessary to walk the path. And that faith is
called sraddha
make his way out once he gets the right thing. But those are not committed
will always remain the same and keep talking.
But by this I don’t mean that one should force
himself to believe something and try to become committed to it. But rather
stop association with it for what so ever reasons it may be and find another
way. This will become clear from example. If one has become Hare Krishna,
but does not believe in its philosophy, he should simply quit and not poison
himself up with the idea that “I am such a retched that I don’t believe that
Krishna is my master and Husband. I am really very low because I think that
I am man because I have male organs, but these Masters are saying that you
are really a cowherd-women.” No we should not do that. Faith is not
something to be created but rather it happens. The other way can also be said
that a person who is Hare Krishna and is committed to it is better than those
who talk and preach of no mind, but themselves don’t believe in that
vi.Samadhana or Concentration
This is also very interesting thing. For many a school of thought like yoga
there is very little difference between concentration and mediation. The
concentration is the ultimate thing that they can conceive of. And many a
Buddhist teachers accuse Hindu way of meditation as Shutting oneself up on
one point and loosing sense. But it is not so. In Vedanta concentration is just
a means.
And then there are many a teachers those who
simply focus on knowledge or insights. But all knowledge without
concentration can be of no use for without it they will remain incomplete.
The person will see them in parts and with only one side, without there full
meaning and context. And this incomplete knowledge causes neurosis. That
is why we may come across many a person who have great insight but are
really very confused and restless. It is because that due to lack of
concentration they are not able to co-relate between their thoughts.
For example imagine the situation of a person who has
Heard that “one should go beyond the mind”. Now knowing this he is trying
all the methods to go “beyond” but if has concentration he will understand
that one who is trying to go out is mind itself. Similarly what we expect
from a person whose mind runs like this---‘I have to realize self’, ‘but there
is nothing to realize’, ‘ya there is no self that is what Buddha says’, ‘No
there is self because I feel so’, ‘ I have a appointment with doctor today’, ‘
Yes that doctor has great insights, how nice he talks’, ‘ But this is the body,
impermanent and I should not take care of it so much ’, ‘No it is my duty to
take care of ’, ‘But I am without any duty, The Eternal Self’ ……..
‘but…..’ ‘ …if…..’ ‘ …..anyway’ and so on.
A Short Introduction to Vedant 20
I think this the most important quality one most have in order to
understand Vedanta. Rather without this all enquiry in the nature of
Brahman is impossible. But what is this freedom. Freedom from this
limitation of body, from fixed and crazy patterns of mind that forces to
commit same things over and again, keeping us bound in the twin pair of
sorrow and happiness, pleasure and pain. We are always worrying on the
things which are petty and small and go round in the circle. Here Upanishad
says “ A Brahmin ( a person who wants to know Brahman) after examining
the world and getting out of attachment makes the enquiry”.
Really a real enquiry in to religion comes only when we
are experience the impermanence of world, that we see our limitation and
drawbacks. And then one cant remain satisfied with the mundane world or
even heaven(if there exists any). He would then not seek solace in the things
of world as well as psychological gratification. Then one will try to know
what is real, is truth and then this real enquiry in the nature of self becomes
our guide, a real GURU and takes to the ultimate. So this yearning to know
and get liberated is the most important quality and if a person has this he
will develop all others qualities. If a person does not have this even all other
qualities are useless. He will them make use of all these in pursuit of world.
Like today there are a few Tailor-made Corporate Training Programs for
better management of self to earn more money or manage the industry in
better way, all claiming to take wisdom from Vedanta. And they even find
people to listen them. I don’t say that there is anything bad in that but
Vedanta is called Para-Vidya or the Ultimate Knowledge and then again this
Farm Management…… Both do not seem to go together.
What so ever, such a fit aspirant approaches is able
to approaches to teachings in form of Guru and thus gets realized. So guru is
dealt in next chapter.
A Short Introduction to Vedant 22
3. GURU-DISCIPLE RELATIONSHIP
GURU
THE DISCIPLE
In Upanishads the description of anxiety and trouble
of a seeker of knowledge is given by a beautiful and practical analogy. It
says that “as a person whose head had been caught with fire seeks water
body so one troubled with world and seeks of knowledge.” This is really a
very practical analogy. Ones experience says that how much one remains
troubled and in tension for seeking a way out of all that. The pain
experienced is really cant be described. But we know from now that even in
Upanishads the condition of a seeker is described as “one whose head is on
fire”. So the pain experienced by seekers in initial period is but natural. So
one do not have to be feel really painful because one is in pain. The people
who seem satisfied with the things outside do seem very happy. Similarly
those who are complete do remain in bliss. It is the person who are in middle
that suffer. ‘Klisanti Antreto Janah.”
So such a person is the disciple.
THE RELATIONSHIP
Relationship between Guru and disciple is based upon
compassion and faith. Then Sankara says “Guru instructs disciple (said
above), Of truth with Absolute Compassion.”
The compassion is expected from teacher toward the disciple to utmost. It is
true that there is nothing to understand but a teacher who is compassionate
will teach disciple slowly of this truth. He should be one who deals with his
confusions and even ego based argument with love, for knowing that the
person is in ignorance. And what ever disciple is doing, has no control over
it, as if all his actions and speech dominated by his whole mind, ego, habits
and all that.
Similarly, what is expected from a disciple is the faith.
This faith does not mean that what ever the Guru is saying is to be taken true
and that it should not be questioned and argued upon. Rather this faith
requires that the disciple has this faith in the ability of Guru, that by
whatever means he can impart me self-realization or at least something that
one thinks would be helpful in self-realization.
Without this faith disciple should not approach a teacher just to show off, to
test or examine him, if he does not want to waste his time. All though if one
is thinking him to be a potential teacher than he must be tested. Although
there is no restriction for spiritual-tourists, who want to grab a bit of this and
that from everywhere.
Many people think that guru disciple relationship is
like one time in a life commitment. This is one of the most confused topic of
A Short Introduction to Vedant 25
discussion. That once a Guru is chosen he should be kept as guru for all his
life and one should be completely surrendered to him for ever and ever.
This is not so. This sort of commitment was made a rule sort of thing
because it was more often the restless condition of student, and his
flickering mind that caused him to run from one place to other. But now a
days there are many sort of gurus. So if someone after getting in contact with
a guru or teacher is not happy with his teachings or what so ever, then he
should simply quit. And also that if a person feels that he has learnt
everything from a teacher, then there is no reason to be in the company of
such a teacher.
So one do not have to be committed towards teachers
all the time. But if someone really feels that being in the company of
someone has helped him get out of pain, illusion and all that naturally he
will feel a sense of gratitude towards him. And out of this sense of gratitude
he may choose to do anything. He may bow before him, give all his money
or do what so ever.
Now there is one question that can be much
raised that what to do with fake teachers? This is a big issue now a days. But
my understanding is that there are no fake teachers. Everything in this world
is based on exchanged and some personal exchanges. So Gurus flourishing
today before, also were not without interest neither of today. Without any
interest the body will not survive at all. The important is what is the interest
of teachers. There are teachers who want nothing from you other than you
getting out of your pain, confusion and illusion. So they are endeavoring for
this out of compassion. There are teachers who are charging big fees for
seeing them from distance and bigger fees for touching your head. So it is a
matter of agreement between two people. If you want to be with teacher who
wants nothing but your welfare than you have to give him “by you being out
of illusion”. If you want pay money from someone you should go there, pay
money, and see them. it is you who are entering in the agreement. And if it
helps you there is nothing bad in that. After all those Gurus who are getting
a lot money and making business, do find people to give them money at
first place, that is how they get the money. They are not going on Highway
an………
All we have to do about this that, only if we want to, to protect
naïve people from falling pray to such teachers.
By thus obtaining a teacher in form of person,
place, situation or book, one should enquire into nature of Vedanta is made
A Short Introduction to Vedant 26
4. METHODS OF VEDANTA
ness and all that. For dog is Brahman but its true nature (what is Brahman)
is covered by waving tail and teeth, barking, jumping and dog-ness and all
that. We are not able to see them as they are because until we are knowing
tree as tree we are not seeing it correctly. But it is the Brahman which is
being seen as the tree and it is Brahman which is been seen as leaves too. So
outer world is all covered by something or other and we are seeing it by our
mind. So our only portal to know Brahman is we ourselves. It is by making
enquiry in to nature of self that we can get to know what Brahman is. So we
discuss the methods of knowing Brahman by self.
not tell us to reach a new dimension of mind or purify oneself. All that we
have to is to “know that as we are” and the work is over. Simply saying that
‘I am as I am’ is of no use because then question comes that who you are
Really. All the methods are there fore aiming to create that understanding.
Vedanta says “ that what ever means you get realization that process is good
for you.” So techniques are very individual and even if I personally used to
practice a few methods it seems very clumsy to write them. because there is
no rational how they work and what causes them to work. And sometimes
this also happens that a method or techniques that works for this time does
not work the other time. So then one should give that up.
But before we understand any technique we
should understand the nature of self that has to be arrived. The thing is that
Everything is Brahman so our self is also Brahman. But as dog and cats are
superimposed in Brahman. So to say that what we experience as dog or cat
is really Brahman being wrapped ignorance of dog-ness and cat-ness. But
we have no way to remove this wrappers. So it is this Self of us that is the
portal by which we can arrive to the Brahman Because although this is also
wrapped but we can remove this wrapper. We are all aware of this self(this
feeling of I-ness) but then we are not knowing Brahman. But this self is also
not real. Because had this self been real and hence Brahman then we would
have gone out of all sorrow. Upanisad say “The one who knows self(as it is)
swims out of sorrow.”. but we are not out of sorrow, so we have to know
this self as something other than we know. But question can be raised that is
it that we don’t know ourselves? How can be it that I don’t know myself for
I am always aware that “I am”. The answer is no. No we don’t know
ourselves at all.
All we know about ourselves that are concepts of mind
about ourselves. But all the time our concept about ourselves changes. This
is the biggest illusion here is that we think that we don’t have any illusion
about ourselves. When praised we have a different idea about ourselves and
when poked we are different.(This does mean that being different with
praise or poke is wrong, as many religions teach us. For the mind whose
nature is of change will change itself.So all this effort to maintain
equanimity is non-sense). We go on believing body or mental images as
ourselves and this is what ignorance. For in mind, deep inside, we have idea
about ourselves that ‘I am angry’, ‘I am good’ ‘I am happy’ ‘I am sad’ ‘I
am benevolent I am cruel’ ‘I was tortured in my child hood’ ‘I an negative
or positive’ ‘I am in traps’ ‘I am a big joker’ ‘I am such a great one who
understands this Vedanta’ and so on. And out of this idea comes the several
ideas about getting and protecting, changing and removing. A person who
A Short Introduction to Vedant 31
thinks that “I have been tortured in the childhood” try to ‘heal it’ and come
out by psychology. A person who thinks that “I am fat” does dieting. A
person who thinks that ‘I am positive’ starts doing business and a person
who thinks that ‘I am spiritual’ goes to Himalaya and sits in that icy caves.
But who is this I that we have to know. Because this idea about self is
always changing so reality must be beyond all this. Because where is the
ground where all this change is occurring. Who is this that is changing in all
this different forms?. And based on this search for a real self begins.
So concept of Vedanta is that neither
becoming humble will be of any help, neither Positive thinking and powerful
affirmation will be of help. Vedanta neither says that to Say that “ Oh god! I
am such a retched person and very lowly and protect me and guide me, save
me from hell”.
Neither it says “I am very gifted person, I am the centre of creation, I have
ability to achieve my dreams and I am going to do that.”, as Many advocates
of power of positive thinking do ask us to say. Many people are now
confusing this positive assertion with Vedanta also. And they go on
preaching and practicing idiotic concepts in the offices of Multi-National
Companies That “go on saying to yourselves that I am Brahman, the all
powerful, the creator and all that” and you will make good business. This is
simply non-sense and has nothing to do with Vedanta. If these techniques
helps for making good business, OK, do use it. But teaching of Vedanta is
not there at all, to make good business.
The whole effort of Vedanta is that to go beyond this “I”
notion at all, in its limited sense. Go beyond this idea of I am this or that,
and know oneself as a pure being. And that Pure Being is Brahman. I am
Brahman does not mean that “I”, the Self is Brahman, like rose is flower.
But that There is no “I” at all, as we experience in its daily sense and that it
is all Brahman itself.
So all that we have to is to know “the perceiver of
these changes that is occurring in the mind. And when known, quality of life
and our reaction to situation does not remains the same, it cant remain the
same. For all situations loose their firmness and solidity. They do not
remain demons anymore. So we don’t have to go through all that process of
healing oneself bit-by-it through psychological methods and therapy. It is as
if gates of dams being opened and that everything is as if washed away. For
ever and ever.
So what is the mistake we are making is we call
that even if we know that “This self is Brahman ”, then also we are taking
this body and mind as atman or self. A less intelligent people believes his
A Short Introduction to Vedant 32
body as self and says that “I am fat or I am thin” a more intelligent says that
ok this mind is me with all its past impression, ideas habits and thoughts.
The formers concept that Body is the self’ can be negated very easily by
simple logic. In dreaming stage one is not aware of him body, but he is still
aware of This “I” there. But it is very difficult to understand that one is in
existence also when there is no mind like in deep sleep state. And this
experience of ones existence of “I” without mind is what gives the right
understanding that who one is and eventually what Brahman is. Because till
the mind is active one will have concepts about Brahman but not the
Brahman itself. so it is repeated many times in Upanishads that ‘Brahman is
not one that can be thought by mind but it is the one because of which mind
thinks. Know that as Brahman and not one that you worship.” “Brahman is
not one that can be seen by eye but it is one due to which eyes see, know
that as Brahman and not that which you worship. ” Kathopnisad.
But here one should not make mistake that Brahman
or Self is beyond mind only. Then problem comes that what are we when
we are thinking and are taking mind as Brahman or self? We are then also
Brahman itself, but this out of mind experience gives us understanding that
what we really are. It is like for first time we need to recognizing a person
out of crowd of many people , and once recognized we can know him
anytime, whether he is in the crowd or he is not.
So to sum up, to remove bondage we need to know
Brahman, to know Brahman we have only portal that is self(because
everything is Brahman so self is also Brahman ). But to know self as it is
truly, that is Brahman and not our ideas and concepts about ourselves. So
we have to distinguish real-Self from fake illusory ideas of self as Body or
mind. Now it is easy to know oneself that ‘I am not the body’, but we are
really very tangled in mind. So methods and techniques to go beyond mind
is to sought after. To know the Real Self we really need to make mind calm
or so to say, if you like, go beyond mind, because all ideas are in the mind
itself and then know what is the Self, and that Self is in real the Brahman.
(as per pure form of Vedanta the mind is illusion and void of its existence.
But this is not to be thought for all thoughts are in the mind.)
Now doubt can be raised that is there a Self beyond mind? Or
all that we experience as self is just the sum up of all habits, thought and
behavior pattern. Here I wont answer anything because this cant be proved
by logic, although I can get very strong logic to prove it but it would be of
no use because there are counter logic also and theirs counter logic too !!!!.
But what ever may be logic and counter logic, one will not get convinced.
But one simple argument that can be put it that all is changing. Ok. But who
A Short Introduction to Vedant 33
become identified with first thought and believe yourself a idiot. Which You
are not For sure!!!.
These practice are sort of deep cleansing.
Even if you are able to do this practice even for 10 min. a day it would we
like taking a inner bath and you and others will feel a change that is
occurring in you. But problem is that once you start doing this for first time,
it will feel like as if someone has thrown you out of your sit. One does not
understands what has caused him to come out of the sitting place and roam
in the park. This is because our inability to be silent. Vedanta says that
“Even yogis fear from that silence and emptiness that is experienced”. But
one need to practice them any way. Also that one starting to do these
practices may see or hear many a things. But always keep in the mind that
they are all illusion. Either like a horn of donkey(donkey’s don’t have horn),
and hence creation of mind. Or like illusion of seeing of seeing a tree as tree
and not as Brahman for Vedanta does not deny the existence of beings or
things that are not seen by our eyes. So don’t give them any importance.
Only Brahman is real and every thing is illusion.
But if one is not able to sit or lie silently, without doing anything or if
there are so much experiences and visions and sounds that it may create
problem then one can practice a no. of cleansing methods (Karma) and
Focusing methods(Upasanas). confusion about this. On one side people who
are against it say that doing Japa is useless and even harmful because it
makes mind dull. They say that you feel-good
One of the most powerful is doing Japa (or repetition of a mantra-
Sanskrit word). But there is lot of after mantra because there is noise in the
mind and by Mantra greater noise is made so mind becomes calm. They are
right to some extent. But observation is incomplete. Similarly there are
people who are in support of mantra doing and they go in labs and make
experiment on people of effect of mantra and display their observation using
words like ‘Vibrations’ ‘Delta-Theta-Gamma Waves’ ‘Better Heart rate’
‘Low tension’ and all that. But they don’t simply understand the difference
between The Brain- that is mass of flesh and neurons and blood and Mind-
That is the sum total of habits patterns, behavior and personality of a person.
(although in Vedanta both physical body and mind are of nature of Jada-
unconsciousness) But there is the difference of brain being material and
mind being subtle.
But the thing is when mantra is done with a purpose cleaning mind it
should be done slowly in a rhythm, and one will see it automatically that all
the craziness of mind is coming out. As if it allows us to be aware of our
thoughts bit by bit in parts, so that we don’t run away with them. and this
A Short Introduction to Vedant 36
really heaps. But the thing is that anything that falls in the hand of a less
intelligent person( I don’t call them fools), they use it in wrong way.
Similarly working in a office is a good practice for clarity of the mind
and developing focus. Similarly social service as well as psychotherapy can
be of great use. But by the cleansing, don’t understand that Some negative
karma will get finished. But it is the our mind that will make change. (But
don’t start making that practice of mindfulness by making slow movement
in the work place with eyes focused on tip of nose and moving limbs in a
strange way, as if practicing Judo. True Awareness cant be practiced. )
But always remember that The Methods are meant only for
Understanding Of Truth. If one is unable to understand the reality directly
and thinks that methods are really important than only he should use
methods and what so ever methods.
So what is the most important method is devise your own way and
techniques with or without help of some one which may range from doing
japa to direct being pushed in enlightenment(If there exist any)!!!!!
6. Maya - ILLUSION
In Vedanta the most confused word is
illusion or Maya(perhaps it is Maya or illusion itself). The Vedanta says that
everything except Brahman is illusion. But people are so much confused
with that illusion. Actually in Vedanta Maya does not mean a illusion like a
rabbit’s horn (for people who don’t know rabbit it is stated that rabbits don’t
have horn) or like the illusion of milk of turtle (turtles don’t have milk) or
like a lotus in the sky or like a barren woman’s son.
Here illusion has a special definition “that knowledge of
which is not Valid in all the three times viz. present, past, and future is
called illusion”. No need to understand them now slowly they will become
clear themselves.
In almost all the systems of philosophy they have
two types of experience. First the experience of the things that are not as
they are like seeing a tree in the night as ghost, or listening the sound of a
bee as the probable attack of terrorist. This is illusion and all such objects of
this knowledge like ghost or attack is illusory object. And then there is the
real experiences of things that is seeing them as they are like seeing tree as
tree, ghost as ghost( if it is really a ghost for sure), experiencing bees sound
as bees sound and attack as the attack. This is generally called real
experience and objects of such a knowledge like tree, ghost, bees’ sound,
and attack is called real objects. So there are existence of two types of
objects Illusory and Real. Here is the specialty of Vedanta. Vedanta says that
A Short Introduction to Vedant 37
even tree that is seen as tree and bees sound that is experienced as bees
sound, are illusory and reality is the Brahman itself. So in Vedanta there are
three types of objects:-
1.Pratibhasik ( or illusory) like the Snake-
rope(snake rope is a not special type of snake rather in Vedanta it is the
experiencing a rope in darkness as rope and is most used example to
describe Maya or illusion )
So taking the two definitions together For a some one who is experiencing a
rope as rope and snake as snake. But after realization he experiences them as
Brahman itself..( To be exact, there is no experience and being experienced,
but to make understanding, words are to be used). So the knowledge that
snake is snake and rope is rope is invalid after realization. So it is not valid
in all the three times. So the definition that “knowledge of which is not
Valid in all the three times viz. present, past, and future is called illusion”.
That is why it is called Illusion.
The difference between First Illusion and
Second Grade illusion is simple. For illusions like seeing rope as snake
becomes clear when we know that it is not snake but rope. But illusion of
seeing rope as rope becomes clear when we experience it as Brahman itself.
So when Vedanta says that all this world say
dog or cat is illusion it does not mean that world is illusion like snake- rope
but rather what we see as dog is in reality Brahman itself. So from view
point of Vedanta everything that is experienced as other than Brahman is
illusion be it what so ever. And when it is said that Cat and dog is Brahman,
it is not meant that cat is Brahman like Rose is flower. Rather is meant that
what is experienced as cat is mistaken and it is Brahman is real. So to say
there is nothing other than Brahman. So this creation is all illusion from
point of view of Brahman but real for those not knowing Brahman
A Short Introduction to Vedant 38
and mind, thought and emotion and all that. All are just different forms or
functions of Mind-Stuff(Anatahkaran) itself.
So when we are dreaming or day dreaming it is with this
Subtle Sheath (Sukhma Sarira ) that we see and experience different things.
There is no awareness of physical body and one is having only Subtle body
and Causal Sheath.
Now explaining death in Vedanta we come to
define answer. We may have heard that Soul is immortal and it never dies.
And while explaining death it is said that the soul has left the body. But
then question comes that “ Sir did you not say that it is the Self or Brahman
is everywhere?” So why does one dies. According to Vedanta It is not that
Self leaves the body for it is every where but is this Subtle Body, consisting
of Vital forces, and Mind-stuff(with memory, habit, behavior and all such)
that leaves the body and due to ignorance as per past fruits of actions takes
the different body to bear those particular fruits. That is why death is illusory
in Vedanta for is just the transfer of a few illusory things from one illusion
to different illusion. And this is what meaning of Self is beyond death and
birth.
God, who is creator of this universe, is bound to give the fruits according to
the Karma of individual self. It is because of clearing this fruit of action that
Creation comes into being again and again and gets annihilated again and
again. When this cycle started and why this cycle started, there is no
explanations, it is just called beginning less. Because The cause of Karma,
The Ignorance is considered Beginning less. So it is important that a short
introduction to Law of Karma is made is an also because a big confusion is
there about it. So Karma is explained in Ch. Law of Karma.
The all effort to explain these Three things viz God, The
Individual self, The World, was this:- To make a direct insight into what is
the Real nature of Brahman. That is these three are not Brahman. What
really Brahman is cant be said. As per Vedanta it is said that to know Self all
we have to do is to Understand what are things that we take them as Self but
they are really non-self.
Similarly Self is not the one in the tree stages of wake,
dream, and sleep. It prevents many a things that we may have imagined to
be our real Self just due to lack of discrimination between self and non-self.
All the concept we have of Self or Brahman is really a product of Mind-
stuff. Now at least we can know that everything that we imagine by mind is
not self.
Body is not the Brahman that is very clear. Also mind is
not the Brahman. It is because both of them are changing all the time. And
what ever is changing is not the Brahman. But many today get stuck at a
very crucial stop. That is the psychological consciousness. In Vedanta The
consciousness is Brahman itself and all the rest including mind is
Unconsciousness. So meaning of psychologist’s consciousness is different
from meaning consciousness of Vedanta. When psychologist are talking of
consciousness they are talking about something which is product of mind
and that is why to make it effort is required. But when in Vedanta
consciousness is ever the consciousness and it never changes and becomes
unconsciousness. It is ever witness.
The mental forms or what we imagine as Watcher when
watching the thought, are just a part of mind seeing itself. We don’t
understand this, that is why we “Have to Be aware”. Otherwise awareness
is the natural state, we don’t have to make any effort ‘to Be aware’.
Although this, being aware of mind by mind is sometimes good and changes
many of the deep seated behavior patterns and psychological defilement and
A Short Introduction to Vedant 44
sometimes may give us very fine moods of silence.But many of those who
practice these types of meditation, their happiness depends upon this game
of watching. There is nothing bad in this “Watching Silently” game but
problem comes when we want to make those experiences permanent. We
want this calmness to survive all the time but it is impossible to be so.
Because both Watcher and Watched are one, the mind itself. one part being
expressed as Thought and Other Part as its seer. After all mind is mind and
the moment it will take part in the part being watched, trying to change or
trying to hold, it will be no more in the state of passive witness and start to
associate with it. And then we say that when I am not watching I am in pain.
It is not so. Otherwise there are times when one is not watching and still is
happy. And it is not that “Watcher” will feel sorrow all the time when being
associated with “Watched” but depending upon the nature of “Watched” it
is identifying, if “Watched” is in pleasure or pain, the “watcher” does also
experiences the same.
But we might be experiencing the pain when
we are not able to Watch due to idea “ I am not able to watched”. And this
idea is pain because of many reasons. We have made it a moral obligation
sort of thing that I must always keep watching. It is not so. This obligation
has been infused by psychologists, or those neo-Buddhist those are trying to
make a wedding between Psychoanalysis and Meditation, Freud and
Buddha and create a queer thing out of that. But this is not a happy
marriage and is creating lot of trouble.
The whole aim of psychology is to make
mind good. If one wants that one can do that. But realization is something
different which brings a total transformation in the person. Then the whole
body and mind is transformed automatically and one goes beyond all pain
and pleasure and enjoys the true bliss.
Sometimes people are so addicted to this process of watching that
they cant live with out it. It is because watching sometimes gets them
freedom from mental traps and wrong behavior pattern. Also that watching
makes the mind alert and calm. So we start to expect too much from this
game. When we are not able to watch it feels that if there was a “Watcher”
Me That was watching that rubbish devilish “Mind”. And now that I am
not able to watch this mind it will make me do something Crazy. So
watching becomes a emergency. But is there such a thing as “Watcher” and
“Being watched”? No. Both of them are mind itself. If it was that watcher
and watched were two then why they come together, and if they are one then
creating two out of them will always create problem.
A Short Introduction to Vedant 45
same effect as in sleeping stage but with knowledge. But all these are
product of ignorance and Vedanta aims at cutting the cause itself the
-Ignorance. It is already explained above that Causal Body that is Ignorance
itself is the cause of Physical body and Subtle body. That is why sometimes
Samadhi of yogi is Jokingly called by masters as “Sleeping In Lotus
Posture”. But this is also not that Samadhi is unimportant. It has its value.
But point is that because Yogis are not aiming at getting away of ignorance,
so we hear the story of ascetics after coming out of deep Samadhi
becoming Very angry or going out with heavenly maidens( one may say that
there is nothing bad but off course they regret it later so it comes that they
don’t like it ).This is all because in Samadhi mind has been calmed but once
they come out of it mind is already there with all its nonsense. Similarly
those doing these practices are sometimes more vulnerable and less able to
cope with world than those are not doing it. Here I don’t mean
Yogasana(postures) by Yoga.
Again the Buddhist say that there is nothing as an
entity who is aware of sleeping stage. And it is all Blank, Shunya and that
there is no self. This can be explained in two ways. Now either what they
Shunya is called in Vedanta as Self. The Self that is experienced as
Brahman is not like “Oh it is here My Self That I have been looking for so
long”. What is the experience cant be described completely and actually but
surely it is different than that. And what is called “inter-connection of all
Phenomenon” is “everything as Brahman of Vedanta. So Buddhist are
calling this as Non-self. Different names and way of describing the same
thing.
Or there is other way of explaining this
also. Vedanta agrees with what Buddhists are saying that everything is
changing. But Vedanta adds to it that everything is changing but only
Brahman is permanent. Logically it is put like this that if everything is
changing than who is the knower of all these changes. That knower must be
present when two changes are taking place then only it can know the change.
But in India, although it may hurt someone, it is
sometimes believed that Buddha did not realized completely and was stuck
somewhere in the blank of Mind. But Vedantaic masters say Sankara
perhaps does not believe in that and he has even written a beautiful prayer to
Buddha But others say that he reached the Highest stage of “I am Brahman”
but for some reasons he did not speak that “ It is the self that is everywhere”.
Why he did not speak there are many silly reasons for that but may be he did
so because people may misunderstand it. So he allowed the people to
experience it themselves. I personally agree with later view that he was
A Short Introduction to Vedant 47
9. LAW OF KARMA
Here is a bit of introduction to Law of Karma is
necessary so, that will make us understand what is meant by Bondage in
Vedanta. One thing is to be made clear that the word Karma is used in two
senses, first the action and second, the fruit of action (Karmaphala)
interchangeably. Many think that Vedantains do not believe in Law of
Karma. It is not so. In Vyavahara (or conventions, the second kind of
illusion explained in Ch. Illusion) everything is illusory with relation to
Brahman but are real in their own level of existence. So if one does a action
that is good or bad (the standard of good or bad is not to be put here) it has
some effect or fruit that is also to be bared by the Doer. But both are
illusory this has to be kept in the mind. Because often this happens that in
Vedanta it is taught that “One is unaffected By Karma”. But what is really
meant here that One is neither does nor the bearer of Fruit of Karma
because One is Brahman. It is the Body and Mind that does the Karma and it
is the Body and mind which bears its fruit.
But people knowing that everything is illusion
and that “I am unaffected by Karma” may start doing all sort of non-sense.
Up to this that everything is illusion is correct but then when some trouble
A Short Introduction to Vedant 48
comes people really get messed up. When they are doing something wrong
they say it is the body and mind which is doing it. But when we are doing
something good and appreciation comes we boast up and say that it is me
who has done it. Similarly when trouble comes it is body-mind that suffers,
so why to worry?
This all confusion comes up when we really are
not able to grasp what is meant by illusion and make the illusion of Vedanta
as a comfort zone and feel-good Idea for our action. It does not mean that I
do say that one should condemn himself up, but then protecting our guilt
behind some Ideology is not a good idea. If one is to accept himself up as he
is.he should do it without any false pretences and making it something
religious that is rule that I should accept myself up. Or that such and such
person accepted himself up and hence got realized. There is no need to hide
behind something, because that is not true acceptance. And also that we need
not accept ourselves up. This is not a rule. If we accept our non-acceptance
and even all that, to the end that is what brings transformation and not
acceptance to achieve or get rid of something.
For example a person steals and murders someone
and is caught by police. He is brought before court and judges inflicts on
him punishment of “being hanged till death”. Now he arguments that
everything is illusion and so stealing and killing is also illusion and one
should not be punished for a illusory a action that is illusion. But he has to
understand this nicely that the punishment of being hanged till death is also
illusion!!! So no problem!!!
But this all simply explains that he has not
understood anything. For if everything is illusion then why is he, at first
place, tempted to accumulate illusory wealth at all. And if he has realized
that everything is self than where from does he gets the idea that to
accumulate wealth that is also I. duality is not ‘I’ and you only. Duality is ‘I
’ and ‘mine’ also. Because we are taking things other than ourselves that is
why we are motivated to get them to get away from them so seriously. And
it is from this that all craving and aversion comes. So Vedanta does not says
that come out of craving and aversion but it rather says that uproot the cause
of craving and aversion that is believing in the finite self as true.
Similarly, what ever we do must reap its
results, good or bad. I do not say that there is heaven or hell as they are
being described in Mythology but some law decides that every action must
have its effects.
And there are three types of karma (here
meaning fruit of action):-
A Short Introduction to Vedant 49
1. Sanchit:-one that accumulated over all the past lives over eons and
eons of life. So it is the sum total of all the Karma of Jivas that.(Here also;
there is no way to really convince one that there is really past lives),
2.Prarabdha: Out of that sanchit (accumulated karma) The Creator
takes a part of it and sets our life according to it. So our this life in this very
body will remain till there is this prarabdha and when prarabdha gets
finished life is finished.
3. Kriyamana: Out of that Prarabdha; the fruits of action that we are
bearing in this very moment is Kriyaman karma. The food you are eating
and that book you are reading is all that Kriyaman Karma and slowly
finishes the prarabdha.
Similarly in this life time what we are doing will be added to the stock
of Sanchit Karma(the accumulated) Karma. And then there are a number of
actions that are so strong that they bear there fruit in this very life time. That
is why those familiar with Hindu tradition may have heard the stories that a
person has no son and some sage tell him that there is no son in your fate in
this life time because that is in the prarabdha. But later a Sacrifice is
performed and that that person gets a son. So what is happening that the
performer makes such a strong fruit of action that becomes a part of his
Prarabdha and gives fruit in this life time. Here I don’t say that burning
quintals of Ghee in fire, in a poor country like India, will give you a son.
Better try with test-tube baby. That was a old method.
But this principle has to be understood that we have all
the power to change destiny in our favor.. Similarly a very strong negative
action may result in negative fruit in this very life time. Because You are
Brahman and everything else is Brahman, so the best standard of morality
that I understand that don’t harm someone by any way thought, word and
speech. For that harming someone will create a negative will you in
Universe and helping one will create positive wave for you. Even if there is
nothing of this wave and there can be no logic to explain it still it is my idea
that standard of morality is “Loving” and standard of realization is also
“Love ” itself.
So we should be careful on what we are doing if
we don’t want to Experience anything undesirable. And it follows from
same point that every action that are done gives good result and bad results
also. But if we are not concerned with fruits( those are illusory) of action to
care about our action is not important. But all actions(illusory they might
be) must have their effect(though it is illusory).
But the problem is that this relation between
cause and effect is sometimes not really understood. That is why people may
A Short Introduction to Vedant 50
say that if you don’t believe that such and such is God you will go to hell. It
is true that if you don’t believe in something you will have some effect( for
example if thing is non-sense you will have not to bear trouble ) but then
“going to hell” effect is wrong.
But if someone says that self can be realized by going
to pilgrimage or making offerings it is non-sense. By doing
Pranayam(breathing exercises ) mind becomes calm, and luster of body
improves and by doing yogasana body becomes healthy, that is the true
effect, and if one wants these effects one may do that. There is no problem
in that. So Asana, Pranayam, all Pranic Healing, Kundalini Chakra or Magic
Making sidhdhis(yogic psychic power) and all that is going on the name of
spirituality is not useless. But what is their right use is to be kept in the
mind. They have their own distinct effect.
Money, house, job, friends all have their own value.
With money one have freedom in many physical sense, one can travel, one
can eat good food one can give it to beggar and feel good about it or get a
good body massage. There is nothing bad in having money. But then if we
start to expect that money will give us power to walk on water without any
aid that is craziness. For walking on water one should go and practice some
higher form of yoga and all that and get that sidhdhis. In Vedanta these
sidhdhis are not denied but only said that they are of no use in getting
liberation. So what we are doing is not so important but then we should
understanding it clearly that the action will give what sort of results. But
then expecting something from a thing that cant give it, this is the trouble.
And this is always to be kept in the mind that
Liberation or Self-Knowledge cant be attained by any action but by
knowledge alone. Self-Realization is beyond cause and effect. The Brahman
cant be achieved by any Karma what so ever good it may be, and cant be
lost by karma what so ever bad it may be. Liberation comes by Knowledge
itself and not by any “ Karma or hundreds of Pranayam”. . All action that are
done are for knowledge. Even if God becomes happy with some one he will
come and as Teacher make one understand and give Knowledge about
reality or make situations such that knowledge comes to you by any other
medium.
So prayers and worshipped is not denied by a
Vedantains. After all, God is not a entity beyond ourselves but sum total of
all the Individual Self. So prayers made are really got answered. The prayers
are changed into Will, and universe must fulfill that will. It is because the
very existence of universe is there for use of Individual Selves.. This all
depends upon the amount of trust you are putting while praying. Similarly
A Short Introduction to Vedant 51
all the wills that you are making must get fulfilled. Vedanta says that don’t
make will not because they will get fulfilled in course of time depending
upon their intensity. It is not because unfulfilment of it will bring frustration
but fulfillment of them will keep you in the circle of birth and death for all
the time. And this is one of the bondage.
Now there are many ways and meaning of bondage. This
does not follows that we have to break all the bondage one by one. But Self-
Realization breaks all the bondages. But bondage of Karma is one of them.
Here a focus on FREE WILL, shall also be important.
We are all, as if bound by Prarabdha(see what is it in
beginning of chapter) are doing actions all the time. So one may say that
then are we held responsible for what we are not doing out of our free will
but due to pre-distended Prarabdha. And also that why we should do
anything at all if it is all already decided. This has caused great havoc and lot
of misunderstanding in India, people becoming lazy to highest extent. It is
not true that there is every thing pre-destined but there is free will also to
the. Due to Prarabdha we are facing a few situations but how we are
reacting to it is in our hand. For example due to prarabdha one may get his
leg cut but he is free to react to this situation by either becoming to bitter to
the world leave his job of working on computer( or anything that could be
done without one leg) and fight with everyone and create a hell for himself
and others or by taking is calmly and facing the life and remaining humble
to people. Similarly due to prarabdha one may be born in a poor family but
then he has free will to make his own way out. But one may say that what if
this same person who is born poor gets polio attack? But still is a way out
for him. So this can be extended to all and many situation. This relation of
Free -will and Pre-destination is very vague and not separate. So one should
do his action as if taking it granted that every thing is free will and what
comes next is to be left over to prarabdha that is unknown for we don’t know
what is in our prarabdha.
And even though there are things that are in
reserve for us but our action in this life may counteract them so prarabdha is
a thing that is very flexible and should be known and understood carefully.
But at last it is all illusion that is to be remembered.
Now because there is this free will there fore there
is bondage also. We are reaping the fruits of Karma that we have done in
the past and every moment we are making new Karma all the time because
there is free will. So what is to do. Even if we are not doing anything
physically then mental karma will have their effects. And even if mental
A Short Introduction to Vedant 52
Karma has been stopped then what about karma that has been accumulated a
long time for eons and eons.
The thing is that there is no way out other than realize
our real Nature of self… So what happens to a Jyani that all his sanchit
karma (the big eternal stock) is finished and that he is no more accumulating
new Fruits of action any more. But his prarabdha does remains till his body
is and after prarabdha finishes body dies. So if in his prarabdha it there that
he will have sickness or accident or shot out by bullet, it will happen. But
only that he will no more be remain concerned with these.
This law of karma is not there to frighten one.
Even if one does not believe it there in it there is no need to force oneself to
believe in these but this is all written to motivate one to find the true nature
of Self to make clear of ill-known and wrongly understood conceptions of
Karma. That people who are trying to get rid of effect of Karma bit by bit, or
clean their mind bit by bit of habits and thinking pattern, they must
understand that there is no way out other than know oneself.
city he was coronated as king and his rule is still called the ideal for any
state.
Fifth is the sage and priest Vasistha. All his life he continued to do sacrifice and
oblations to fire. But his instruction to Ram, as he was his guru, forms the most advanced
teaching on Vedantaa, entitled "The Yoga Vaasistha". In it when Ram as a teen aged
prince had to go to the forest and leave royal life he says “O Ram! Where can you go?
For, where-ever you go your mind will also be there along with you.”
This is the attitude of Vedanta. All this is stated here is to make one
understand that whatever one does there is no way of imitation of realized
behaviour. One can not imitate and should not imitate a realized person.
Everywhere else behavior can be imitated but not here. So better try to
understand the simple truth that “Thou Art That” and then what ever you do
will be right. Before that hardly anything works.
But again, do not postpone it, do not remain addicted and attached to
your problems because they are so dear to you. Even loss of a familiar
enemy is uncomfortable. One may simply say that this self is something that
I will realize in future after sitting six months below a tree. This is cheating
oneself. No, one can understand it now, in this current moment and be free
while he is also free not to understand it and say that I have to made an
effort. Don’t make any images and expectations of what it would feel like
when you do not know. Don’t expect a round circle of light and all that
behind your head. But when one realizes it, one will know that the game is
over. And one who knows it becomes free and knows that the whole
universe is also free and realized, in this moment the whole nothing is there
that is not realized. Sarvam khalvidam Brahma. Everything is Brahman.
This is complete, and that is also complete. This complete has come out from that
complete. When you take out complete from complete, only complete is left behind.
---- Upanishads
A Short Introduction to Vedant 55