Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Welcome to the 4th edition of idronics, Caleffi’s semi-annual design journal for
Dear Hydronic Professional,
hydronic professionals.
Welcome to the 2nd edition of idronics – Caleffi’s semi-annual design journal for
Most hydronic
hydronic professionals are familiar with how the availability of PEX and
professionals.
PEX-Al-PEX tubing rejuvenated the radiant heating market here in North America.
When
The 1combined
st
editionwith the numerous
of idronics energy saving
was released and health
in January 2007benefi
and ts associatedto over
distributed
with radiant
80,000 heating,
people these America.
in North products helped the market
It focused on thegrow
topicover twenty fold
hydraulic separation. From
since 1990.
the feedback received, it’s evident we attained our goal of explaining the benefits
and proper application of this modern design technique for hydronic systems.
A Technical Journal However, many designers and contractors still think of PEX and PEX-Al-PEX tubing
as
If only
you for use inyet
radiant panel aapplications, and are#1,
notyou
familiar
canwith theby
advantages
from haven’t
ofattached
using thisreader
received
tubingresponse
copy of idronics
along with card,
manifolds
or byforregistering
panel radiators,
online
do so
baseboards,
sending in the
fan coils or
at www.caleffi.us. The
other type of hydronic heat emitters.
Caleffi Hydronic Solutions publication will be mailed to you free of charge. You can also download the
complete journal as a PDF file from our Web site.
This edition of idronics addresses state-of-the-art design techniques for applying
manifold technology
This second in aaddresses
edition wide variety
airofand
hydronic heating
dirt in (andsystems.
hydronic cooling) applications.
Though not a new
Ittopic
explains whyindustry,
to our these approaches
the use deliver
of modernboth high-efficiency
superior performance and demands a
equipment
cost effectiveness.
thorough understanding of the harmful effects of air and dirt, as well as knowledge
on how to eliminate them. Doing so helps ensure the systems you design will
CALEFFI NORTH AMERICA, INC We trust you
operate will find
at peak this issueand
efficiency a useful educational
provide tool and a handy
long trouble-free reference for
service.
your future system designs. We encourage you to send us feedback on this issue
3883 W. Milwaukee Rd using the attached
We trust you willreader response
find this issue card or by e-mailing
of idronics a usefuluseducational
at idronics@caleffi .com.
tool and a handy
Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53208 USA reference for your future hydronic system designs. We also encourage you to send
Finally, if you are
us feedback oninterested
this issuein previous editions
of idronics usingofthe
idronics, please
attached go to response
reader www.caleffi.
card or by
e-mailing
us where they uscan
at idronics@caleffi.com.
be freely downloaded. You can also register to receive future
Tel: 414-238-2360 issues either online or by filling out the attached reader response card.
FAX: 414-238-2366
Sincerely,
E-mail: idronics@caleffi.com
Website: www.caleffi.us
Mark Olson
General Manager,
© Copyright 2008 Caleffi North America, Inc.
Caleffi North America, Inc.
Printed:
Milwaukee, Wisconsin USA
INDEX
3 THE EVOLUTION OF HYDRONIC DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS IN Panel Radiator Systems Using Manifolds
NORTH AMERICA Fan-Coil Systems Using Manifolds
Chilled Water Cooling Supplied Using Manifolds
5 TRADITIONAL HYDRONIC DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Combined Heating and Cooling Using Air Handlers and Manifolds
DESIGNED FOR RIGID PIPING
Series Loop Systems 20 6. MANIFOLD CONFIGURATION AND PIPING OPTIONS
One-Pipe (Diverter Tee) Systems Valveless Manifolds
“2-Pipe” Direct Return Systems Extended Manifold Systems
“2-Pipe” Reverse Return Systems Manifolds with Integral Valves
Zone Circulator Systems Zoning Options for Manifold Systems
Zone Valve Systems Multiple Manifold Stations Operating at Different Supply Temperatures
Series Primary / Secondary Systems Selecting A Manifold Size
Parallel Primary / Secondary (P/S) Systems Manifold Mounting Options
Other Manifold Mounting Tips
9 MANIFOLD-BASED DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS
31 7. DIFFERENTIAL PRESSURE CONTROL IN MANIFOLD SYSTEMS
10 ADVANTAGES OF MANIFOLD-BASED DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Differential Pressure Bypass Valves
Same water temperature supplied to each circuit Variable Speed Pressure-Regulated Circulators
Room-By-Room Comfort Control
Ability To Adjust Flow In Each Circuit 36 8. FILLING AND PURGING MANIFOLD DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS
Installation Flexibility Purging A Valved Manifold Station
Adaptability to Variable Speed Pressure-regulated Circulators Purging A Valveless Manifold Station
Lower Operating Cost Purging At The System Level
1. THE EVOLUTION OF HYDRONIC DISTRIBUTION pressure lies in the increased temperature secured before
SYSTEMS IN NORTH AMERICA the boiling point is reached. Water at sea level atmospheric
pressure boils at 212º , but at 10 pounds gauge pressure
Many types of hydronic distribution systems have been it does not boil until it reaches a temperature of 239.4º.
developed and used in North America over the last This greater temperature provides greater heat for each
century. The earliest water-based hydronic systems pound of water.”
date back to the late 1800s. These non-pressurized
*Source: National Heating Corporation Blue Book
systems used coal-fired cast-iron boilers. A tank at the
top of the system was vented to the atmosphere and
Electrically powered circulators were introduced for
served as both the filling point and expansion reservoir.
hydronic heating in the early 1930s. Forced circulation
An example of an open-loop hot water heating system
in combination with closed-loop piping significantly
from the 1930s is shown in figure 1-1. These systems
expanded possible system configurations. The boiler no
did not have circulators. Instead, they relied on density
longer had to be at the low point of the system. Multiple
differences between hot water in the boiler and cooler
circulators allowed different parts of the building to be
water in the return piping to create slow, buoyancy-
independently controlled. Better controls were developed
induced circulation. Most systems of this vintage used
that allowed more automatic operation of the system.
rigid iron piping
Although occasionally used as early as 1915, the first
Figure 1-1
significant market for radiant floor heating in North
America developed during the 1940s. At that time,
wrought iron and copper tubing were installed in concrete
floor slabs, as shown in figure 1-2. During these years
noted American architect Frank Lloyd Wright popularized
the concept of radiant heating.
Figure 1-2
3
The years following World War II brought rapid growth Figure 1-3
in all sectors of the construction market. This fueled the
demand for better heating systems. The concept of central
heating was quickly establishing itself as preferable to the
standard practice of tending multiple coal stoves or other
types of area heaters located throughout a building.
Hydronic distribution systems continued to evolve into systems. As demand for cooling increased, forced-
the 1950s, but the piping configurations were highly air systems quickly claimed market share away from
constrained by the fact they were built of rigid metal hydronic heating. This trend was worsened by eventual
piping. Although there were significant advancements failures of some early generation floor heating systems.
in the design of boilers, circulators, heat emitters and
controls, there were virtually no changes in the piping Rigid plastic piping was introduced for plumbing
materials available to construct hydronic systems. applications during the 1970s. However, it was not used in
Designers were limited to steel, iron and copper piping, hydronic heating, primarily because the hydronic systems
most of which was supplied as rigid straight lengths to of the time were designed for water temperatures much
be joined together using threaded fittings, soldering or higher than the ratings of earlier plastic pipe.
welding as shown in figures 1-3 and 1-4.
Metal pipe continued to be used in virtually all hydronic
Although the craftsmanship used in building these early heating systems until the early 1980s, when crosslinked
hydronic systems was often exceptional, the installation polyethylene tubing (a.k.a. PEX) first appeared in North
labor was significantly greater than what would be America. At that time, PEX tubing had a well-established
economically competitive today. record for performance and reliability in Europe. It was
introduced to North America as a means of reinvigorating
By the 1960s, the American hydronic heating industry the radiant panel heating market. This “revolutionary”
faced a major challenge from the rapidly growing market product offered a new way to deliver the benefits of
for central cooling, which mandated forced-air delivery earlier generation radiant panel heating without the
4
complications of joining metal pipe, or the concern over 2. TRADITIONAL HYDRONIC DISTRIBUTION
potential leaks from hundreds of joints that were literally SYSTEMS DESIGNED FOR RIGID PIPING
cast in concrete.
The majority of hydronic distribution system designs
PEX tubing, perhaps more than any other product over used in North America over the last several decades were
the last 25 years, enabled the North American hydronic designed around rigid metal pipe. This section describes
heating industry to transition from decline to growth. these traditional designs and discusses their individual
Indeed, since 1990 the use of PEX tubing and similar strengths and limitations. A fundamental understanding
products such as PEX-AL-PEX has driven the North of these system “topologies” helps in understanding the
American radiant panel heating market to grow by more advantages of manifold-type distribution systems.
than 2,000 percent!
SERIES LOOP SYSTEMS:
The majority of North American heating professionals One of the simplest distribution system concepts is as a
were introduced to PEX and PEX-AL-PEX tubing as a single series loop, as shown in figure 2-1.
product for use in radiant panel heating systems. Over
the last 20 years, thousands of North American heating
Figure 2-1
professionals have used PEX and PEX-AL-PEX tubing for
this purpose. Most of these applications involved multiple
circuits connected to one or more compact manifold
stations, as shown in figure 1-5. Copper tubing continued
to be used for connecting the manifold stations back to
the mechanical room in many of these systems.
Figure 1-5
Series loop distribution system
s 7ATER TEMPERATURE DECREASES AS IT PASSES FROM ONE HEAT
emitter to the next. Proper design requires that each heat
emitter be sized for the water temperature at its location
within the circuit. If, instead, each heat emitter is sized
for the average circuit water temperature, those near the
beginning of the circuit will be oversized, and those near
the end of the circuit will be undersized. In such cases,
complaints of underheating from the heat emitters near
the end of the circuit are likely. The longer the series
circuit, the more pronounced this effect becomes.
Given the context in which they were introduced to PEX
and PEX-AL-PEX tubing, it’s not surprising that many s 4HE TOTAL HEAD LOSS OF A SERIES CIRCUIT IS THE SUM OF
North American heating professionals think such tubing the head loss of each component in that circuit. The
and its associated manifold hardware is limited to radiant circulator must supply this total head loss as the design
panel applications. This is absolutely not true. PEX and flow rate. Designers must avoid creating series circuits
PEX-AL-PEX tubing and associated manifold hardware with excessively high head loss. Such a situation can
can be used for a wide variety of hydronic heating and occur if a component with relatively high flow resistance
cooling applications. is included in the circuit along with several heat emitters
that also create significant head loss. If the circuit’s head
This issue of idronics describes how PEX and PEX-AL- loss is high, it may become necessary to use a “high
PEX tubing in combination with manifold stations now head” circulator. Such circulators often draw two to three
represents the state-of-the-art in hydronic system design. times more wattage than standard zone circulators, which
It is a combination that allows current hydronic heating results in significantly higher operating cost. Insufficient
pros to construct systems with capabilities unimaginable flow through a high head loss series circuit can also result
to their predecessors. in reduced heat output.
5
s !LL HEAT EMITTERS IN THE SERIES LOOP PROVIDE SIMULTANEOUS temperature drop depends on which branches are active
heat output. It is not possible to zone on a room-by- at any given time. Designers should size heat emitters
room basis using a series loop. Changing the flow rate assuming all branches are operating simultaneously.
or supply water temperature affects the heat output of
all heat emitters on the loop. For this reason, all rooms s 4HE DIVERTER TEES ADD SIGNIFICANT FLOW RESTRICTION TO THE
served by a series circuit should be considered as a main circuit. It is not uncommon for a diverter tee fitting
single zone. If some rooms experience significant internal to have an equivalent length of 25 feet of tubing. Adding
heat gains and others do not, a series circuit should not several to a circuit adds significant flow resistance.
be used. In general, series circuits are limited to relatively Designers should carefully assess this effect when
open floor plans where all areas are to be maintained at designing the circuit and selecting a circulator.
the same comfort level.
s 4HE ONLY SIGNIFICANT ADVANTAGE A ONE
PIPE DIVERTER TEE
ONE-PIPE (DIVERTER TEE) SYSTEMS: distribution system has over a series loop system is flow
Similar in some respects to series loops, one-pipe control at each heat emitter. This advantage comes at an
distribution systems use a special fitting called a diverter associated higher installation and operating cost.
tee to route a portion of the flow in the main piping circuit
through a branch path containing one or more heat “2-PIPE” DIRECT RETURN SYSTEMS:
emitters. The concept is shown in figure 2-2. Hydronic heat emitters can also be piped in a parallel
rather than series. One approach puts each heat emitter
in its own “crossover” pipe, which connects to a common
Figure 2-2 supply and return main, as shown in figure 2-3.
diverter tee
diverter tee
Figure 2-3
diverter tee
6
s &LOW THROUGH EACH CROSSOVER CAN BE CONTROLLED ON non-electric thermostatic radiator valves. This allows
off or modulated) through the use of zone valves or non- each heat emitter to be independently controlled, and
electric thermostatic radiator valves. This allows each thus room-by-room comfort control is possible when the
heat emitter to be independently controlled, and thus system is properly configured.
room-by- room comfort control is possible when the
system is properly configured. s $IFFERENT TYPES OF HEAT EMITTERS CAN BE USED ON THE
various crossover provided they are all sized for the same
s $IFFERENT TYPES OF HEAT EMITTERS CAN BE USED ON THE supply water temperature.
various crossovers provided they are all sized for the
same supply water temperature. s 4WO
PIPE REVERSE RETURN SYSTEMS ARE OFTEN FAVORED
over 2-pipe direct-return systems for their inherent self-
“2-PIPE” REVERSE RETURN SYSTEMS: balancing characteristics.
If the piping design used for the direct return system of
figure 2-3 is modified as shown in figure 2-4, the result is ZONE CIRCULATOR SYSTEMS:
a 2-pipe reverse return system. A traditional North American approach for creating
multi-zone hydronic systems uses a separate circulator
for each zone circuit as shown in figure 2-5.
Figure 2-4
Figure 2-5
“Two-pipe reverse return systems have the following Notice that each zone circuit contains a flow-check
characteristics: valve. This valve can be a separate component mounted
downstream of the circulator as shown in figure 2-5,
s %ACH HEAT EMITTER RECEIVES WATER AT ESSENTIALLY THE SAME or it can be integral to the circulator. The flow-check
temperature. This simplifies heat emitter sizing because valve prevents reverse flow through inactive zone
the water temperature drop associated with series loops circuits while other zones are operating. It also prevents
and diverter tee systems is eliminated. buoyancy-driven hot water migration through inactive
zone circuits. Each zone circuit should also be equipped
s &LOW THROUGH EACH CROSSOVER CAN BE CONTROLLED ON with its own purging valve to expedite air removal during
off or modulated) through the use of zone valves or start-up and servicing.
7
ZONE CIRCULATOR SYSTEMS HAVE THE ZONE VALVE SYSTEMS HAVE THE FOLLOWING
FOLLOWING CHARACTERISTICS: CHARACTERISTICS:
s %ACH ZONE CIRCUIT RECEIVES THE SAME SUPPLY WATER s %ACH ZONE CIRCUIT RECEIVES THE SAME SUPPLY WATER
temperature as the other zones on the same supply header. temperature as the other zones on the same supply
header.
s 4HE COMBINED FLOW RATE OF ALL OPERATING ZONES MUST PASS
through whatever the headers connect to. To minimize s 4HE COMBINED FLOW OF ALL OPERATING ZONES MUST PASS
interaction between zone circuits, headers, as well as the through whatever the headers connect to. To minimize
piping components connected to the headers, should interaction between zone circuits, headers, as well
provide low head loss. This is generally not a problem when as the piping components connected to the headers,
cast-iron boilers or other low head loss heat sources are should provide low head loss. This is generally not a
used. However, heat sources with higher flow resistance problem when cast-iron boilers or other low head loss
need to be hydraulically isolated from the headers using heat sources are used. However, heat sources with
either closely spaced tees or hydraulic separators. higher flow resistance need to be hydraulically isolated
from the headers using either closely spaced tees or
s 4HE TOTAL ELECTRICAL ENERGY DEMAND OF A ZONE CIRCULATOR hydraulic separators.
system at design load tends to be higher that with other
methods of zoning. Designers should carefully scrutinize s 4HE TOTAL ELECTRICAL ENERGY DEMAND OF A ZONE VALVE
circulator selection and speed settings to minimize “over- system at design load tends to be lower than an
pumping,” and excessive power consumption. equivalent system using zone circulators.
Figure 2-7
8
Series P/S systems consist of a single primary loop that s 4HE PRIMARY CIRCULATOR MUST OPERATE WHENEVER ANY ONE
usually connects to the heat source. The primary loop or more of the secondary circulators is operating. This
delivers heated water to one or more secondary circuits. increases the electrical energy consumption relative to
The latter are connected to the primary loop using pairs systems that do not require a primary circulator.
of closely spaced tees, as shown in figure 2-7.
PARALLEL PRIMARY/SECONDARY (P/S) SYSTEMS:
As flow moves through the primary loop there is almost In a parallel P/S system, the primary loop is divided
zero pressure drop between any set of closely spaced into multiple parallel crossovers as shown in figure 2-8.
tees. Hence, there is very little tendency for flow to Water from the heat source splits up through all these
develop in a secondary circuit until the circulator in crossovers whenever the primary circulator is operating.
that circuit operates. The closely spaced tees provide A pair of closely spaced tees within each crossover
hydraulic separation between the primary circuit and provides hydraulic separation of each secondary circuit.
each of the secondary circuits. The word "series"
describes how multiple secondary circuits are arranged THE FOLLOWING POINTS SUMMARIZE
around the primary loop. PARALLEL PRIMARY/SECONDARY SYSTEMS:
s 4HE PARALLEL ARRANGEMENT OF CROSSOVERS PROVIDES THE
THE FOLLOWING POINTS SUMMARIZE SERIES same water temperature to each secondary circuit. This
PRIMARY/SECONDARY SYSTEMS: simplifies heat emitter sizing.
s 4HE PROGRESSION OF SECONDARY CIRCUITS AROUND THE
primary loop creates a temperature drop wherever s ! BALANCING VALVE SHOULD BE PLACED IN EACH CROSSOVER
primary loop flow passes a pair of tees connected to so flow can be adjusted in proportion to the percentage
an operating secondary circuit. As in series loops and of total load handled by the secondary circuit connected
diverter tee systems, this reduction in water temperature to each crossover. This adds to the installed cost and
must be accounted for when sizing heat emitters. commissioning cost of the system.
s %ACH CIRCUIT IN A PRIMARYSECONDARY SYSTEM IS s %ACH CIRCUIT IN A PARALLEL PRIMARYSECONDARY SYSTEM
hydraulically isolated from the other circuits. This prevents is hydraulically isolated from the other circuits. This
interference between circulators. Each circuit can be prevents interference between circulators.
designed as if itís a ìstand-aloneî circuit unaffected by
other circuits in the system. s ! FLOW
CHECK VALVE OR SPRING
LOADED CHECK VALVE MUST
be installed on the supply side of each secondary circuit
s ! FLOW
CHECK VALVE OR SPRING
LOADED CHECK VALVE MUST to prevent buoyancy-driven heat migration.
be installed on the supply side of each secondary circuit
to prevent buoyancy-driven heat migration. s 4HE PRIMARY CIRCULATOR MUST OPERATE WHENEVER ANY ONE
or more of the secondary circulators is operating. This
increases the electrical energy consumption of the system
Figure 2-8 relative to systems that do not require a primary circulator.
9
s 0%8 !34- & &