Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Number 264
April 1990
$2.50
^^^w^^^^^
V>*a£^*?v]3»^SHiss&:;-aa ^r^Li*L*^ **w*"*,w-'^' .-•' • '.**^- "2e%%
&&%$
The MUFON UFO JOURNAL is The contents of the MUFON UFO JOURNAL are determined by the editor and
published monthly by the Mutual UFO do hot necessarily represent the official position of MUFON. Opinions of contributors
Network, Inc., Seguin, Texas. are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of the editor, the staff or MUFON.
Membership / Subscription rates: Articles may be forwarded directly to MUFON. Responses to published articles
$25.00 per year in the U.S.A.; $30.00 may be in a Letter to the Editor (up to about 400 words) or in a short article (up
foreign in U.S. funds. Copyright 1990 to about 2,000 words). Thereafter, the "50% rule" is applied: the article author
by the Mutual UFO Network. Second may reply but will be allowed half the wordagc used in the response; the responder
class postage paid at Seguin, Texas. may answer the author but will be allowed half the wordage used in the author's
POSTMASTER: Send form 3579 to reply, etc. All submissions are subject to editing for style, clarity, and conciseness.
advise change of address to the Permission is hereby granted to quote from this issue provided not more than 200
MUFON UFO JOURNAL, 103 words are quoted from any one article, the author of the article is given credit,
Oldtowne Rd., Seguin, Texas 78155- and the statement "Copyright 1990 by the Mutual UFO Network, 103 Oldtowne
4099. Rd., Seguin, Texas 78155" is included.
SWIRLED LANDING TRACE?
By Carol & Rex Salisberry
The Gulf Breeze plot continues to UFO phenomena for his employer. report.) Mr. Walters also reported the
thicken. For additional recent During the evening of 15 November, discovery of the swirl to Mr. Charles
sightings in the area, consult this Mr. Curtis passed the information to Flannigan, Pensacola MUFON Direc-
issue's Current Case Log. The Mr. Ed Walters, a resident of Gulf tor, who assigned the case to the in-
following report concerns itself with Breeze whose extensive UFO ex- vestigators. Mr. Cook and Mr. Walters
a circle of swirled grass first found periences have been reported to are the first visitors to the scene who
on November 15th of last year. MUFON. have been identified.
Parallels, as well as differences, During the morning of Thursday, At approximately 9:30 a.m. on
with the English "crop circle" 16 November, Mr. Walters called the Friday, 17 November, Mr. Walters, ac-
phenomenon are obvious. Editor of the Gulf Breeze Sentinel, companied by Mr. Robert Reid, a resi-
Mr. Duane Cook, to report the swirl, dent of Ft. Walton Beach, again
There have been no reports of UFO and to request that Mr. Cook accom- visited the site. Mr. Reid attempted to
sightings in the area of the possible pany him to find the site. Mr. Walters duplicate the swirl in a grassy area
landing site since 2 November 1989. stated to the investigators that he did similar to that of the original area. A
However, it is possible that sightings not want to visit the scene alone video tape was made of this attempt.
have occurred but have not been because of safety considerations, Additional color photos were made at
reported. The Gulf Breeze Sentinel (there is a swampy area just to the the same time.
published a report of the finding of the north of the site which is probably The investigators, in the company
swirl in the Thanksgiving week issue, snake infested) and to avoid undue of Mr. Ray Griffin of Gulf Breeze, first
and it was hoped that this article might criticism of himself, i.e., that he might visited the site about mid-day on
stimulate the reporting of possible somehow be responsible for the swirl. Saturday, 18 November. Photographs
sightings. One sighting was reported Mr. Cook and Mr. Walters took were made and an inspection of the
for the evening of 15 November, cameras and a ladder to the scene to immediate area was accomplished,
which was after the discovery of the inspect the site and to take photos for but it was evident that the initial con-
possible landing site was reported. the newspaper. (Copies of these ditions at the site had been com-
photos were provided to the in- promised by the numerous visitors to
Chronology vestigators and are included with the the scene. The investigators went to
Site Description
By Stanton T. Friedman
I
am frankly astonished at and her boss, Edwin Thompson, had considerable correspondence and
Robert Todd's 35-paragraph Director of the Records Declassifica- phone conversations with them as
"MJ-12 Rebuttal" (Ref. 1) tion Division at the NA, as well as with well as with the NA which quotes the
with its repeated ad hominem at- Ed Reese. Todd doesn't mention that EL. No such claim has been made!
tacks and its massive misrepresenta- there were at least half a dozen I must also give the EL and the NA
tion of both my views and the facts 4-person teams of USAF reservists, credit for changing one of their earlier
concerning MJ-12. It seems strange with the highest possible clearances, claims (Ref. 10) that all of Robert
indeed that the only one of my many spending many months reviewing the Cutler's carbon copies were done on
papers (Ref. 2-9) referenced is a brief USAF HQ Intelligence files, including paper with a certain watermark, after
progress report (Ref. 9) to the Fund Box 189, and in Top Secret Facilities I pointed out several onionskin Cutler
For UFO Research not even intended where they could bring briefcases; memo copies having no watermark.
for publication! that the box was first handled just 2 They do make mistakes.
Surely no reasonable person can weeks after the death of the last • Since Todd has never been to the
consider Todd's tirade as a "rebuttal," reputed surviving MJ-12 member, EL or NA, it is perhaps not surpris-
which would make it a refutation of and last handled less than 2 weeks ing that his tirade about finding other
arguments made by me, not of false before it was reviewed by M/S. onionskin copies on the same water-
ones dreamed up by Todd and put in This is all spelled out in my 30-page mark paper as the CT memo and
my mouth. Let me be specific about 1989 MUFON Conference paper related comments is so foolish.
some of his false charges. (Ref. 4) which Todd never references. I will repeat what I have published
• Todd claims that I want and ex- The insertion, then, of a one page elsewhere: that the EL does not have
pect people to believe that: a) Ele- onionskin memo by a highly cleared all the NSC materials from the Ike era,
ments within MJ-12 had me under USAF person is no big deal. Todd's and that what it does have totals at
surveillance; b) MJ-12 ordered the CT elaborate fictional confabulation is ab- least 250,000 pages, much of which
memo stolen; c) MJ-12 ordered the surd. M/S called me the day the has not yet been reviewed for
CT memo planted; d) that MJ-12 memo was discovered and read it to classification and is totally inaccessible.
then went to Ethiopia to pick up me. The titles of file folders are included
postcards; and e) that MJ-12 flew to • Todd claims that M/S and I had in 11 different "finders aids," totalling,
New Zealand to mail these postcards!! long ago identified the most likely as I recall, over 100 pages. One can
What an imagination, since I have MJ-12 people. Nonsense. Donald order at most 18 archive boxes at a
written none of these. The post office Menzel's name on the list was a shock time. Only one box can be opened at
box 189 was added to the postcard. that made us very wary of the docu- a time, and only one folder can be
I would think that Todd is aware that ment, as demonstrated by the fact taken out of a box at a time.
postcards can be sent from one place that it was not released when received Often an entire box would contain
to another in envelopes. in Dec. 1984, or even after the only withdrawal sheets, each listing,
• Todd further claims that Moore discovery of the CT memo in July of in very brief form, 10 or 12 docu-
and Shandera (M/S) weren't at the 1985, but rather in the Spring of ments still classified. If one wants a
National Archives (NA) to find the CT 1987. specific document classification
memo. They were certainly there • Todd claims that M / S / F seem reviewed, (i.e., Lay-to-Cutler memo,
because the postal cards (read to me to feel that if a document can't be pro- secret, July 16, 1954, 1 page) one
over the phone as we tried to solve ven fake, then it must be real. My ar- lists it on long form. Within a week
the riddles thereon) and my input ticles clearly indicate the opposite, and or two the EL will file a formal request
strongly indicated they should go to suggest that proving the anti- for mandatory classification with the
Washington, DC. They did not realize arguments wrong does not make the appropriate agency (CIA, FBI, or,
that the "Box 189, Addis Ababa" was documents genuine, as I have written worst of all, the NSC). Typically, the
a tipoff to Box 189 in which the over and over. I have not said the average response time for the NSC is
memo was found. MJ-12 documents are genuine. 2.5 years!
Todd neglects to mention that I • Todd amazingly claims that the Finally, on March 6, 1990, I re-
visited the Archives in March of 1985, Eisenhower Library believes the CT ceived my first response dealing with
and had a number of subsequent con- memo is a fake! I have made the one-page Lay-Cutler, July 16,
versations with Jo Ann Williamson numerous visits to the EL, and have 1954, formally secret message I re-
;ED
O
ne of Todd's worst misrepre- obvious great distress concerning the
wary of the document. sentations, however, relates documents. Me thinks he doth pro-
to the security markings on test too much ... "sound and fury
quested in February of 1988. This is the CT memo and on others from the signifying nothing."
the date of the "previously scheduled NSC. TOP SECRET RESTRICTED
meeting" noted in the CT memo. The SECURITY INFORMATION is on CT References
CT memo is dated July 14, 1954, the (Todd neglects the SI). On a letter 1. Todd, G. "MJ-12 Rebuttal" MUFON
same date on which Lay (who I from Eisenhower to Cutler dated UFO Journal, No. 261, Jan. 1990, 17-20.
believe prepared the memo) met with March 17, 1953, are typed "Restricted 2. Friedman, ST. "MJ-12: The Evidence So
Eisenhower at 2:30 p.m., and then Security Information" at the top, Far" International UFO Reporter,
Sept. /Oct. 1987, pp. 13-20 (included in Ref.
had a brief telephone conversation "Restricted" at the bottom and, rub- 8).
with him at 4:35 p.m. ber stamped in large letters, "CON- 3. Friedman, ST. "The Secret Life of
The message (transmitted elec- FIDENTIAL' at both top and bottom. Donald H. Menzel" International UFO
tronically by White House Secretary, On a memo to the NSC from Lay, Reporter, Jan./Feb. 1988, pp. 20-24 (in-
cluded in Ref. 8).
General Paul Carroll) reviewed the same date, are rubber stamped 4. Friedman, ST. "UPDATE ON OPERA-
items discussed at the July 15 NSC "RESTRICTED" in big letters and TION MAJESTIC-12" MUFON 1989 Interna-
meeting and concludes with these two "SECURITY INFORMATION" in tional UFO Symposium, Las Vegas, Nevada,
lines: "Hope you will recuperate, rest small letters at the top and "CON- 20 pages, 14 ref., included in item 8 and
and enjoy yourself for few days before FIDENTIAL" top and bottom in big published in MUFON 1989 Symposium Proc.,
returning. Will try to have everything letters. (See previous page.) pp. 82-112. (includes MJ-12 Documents).
5. Friedman, ST. "MJ-12 Debunking
tidy and not too much pressure upon There is no downgrading stamp, Fiasco" International UFO Reporter, May-
you when you arrive." Clearly Cutler only the declassification dated June 1988, pp. 12-17. (included in item 8).
and Lay were in touch and Lay was 2/18/82 on both items. Based on 6. Friedman, ST., Moore, W.L. "MJ-12 and
handling things for Cutler. my own extensive experience with Phil Klass: What are the Facts?" Proceedings
of MUFON 1988 International UFO Sym-
Since the briefing says "one-of- the combination of "SECRET RE- posium, June 1989 pp. 205-235.
one," it hardly seems likely that a copy STRICTED DATA" and "Confidential 7. Friedman, ST. "Debunking a Debunker"
of it or anything else connected with Restricted Data," if the documents 1988, 14p., 17 Ref., $3.00 fr UFORI, POB
MJ-12 would be at the EL. No ar- had been downgraded during their 3584, Sta. B., Fredericton, NB Canada E3A
chivist there has gone though all or working life from Confidential to 5H1.
8. Friedman, ST. 90 page collection re
most of the EL NSC material. Since Restricted SI, there would have to MJ-12 "Update on Operation Majestic 12." In-
much of the material in the NSC files have been a downgrading stamp on cludes Ref. 2, 3, 4, 5 and other documents,
is still classified, and the EL search of them. If Confidential can be used with and much more. $10. from UFORI.
Todd involved only a modest sample Restricted Security Information, then 9. Friedman, ST. "FUFOR Progress
of unclassified materials, it is not very so can SECRET and TOP SECRET. Report" MUFON UFO Journal, No. 257,
likely that the EL would find much for Perhaps I should add that anybody Sept. 1989, p. 16, 17.
10. Williamson, J.A. "Reference Report on
the time in question. reviewing thousands of documents at MJ-12 (revised)," May 9, 1988 National Ar-
Perhaps I should mention that the the EL or NA, or the other 12 Ar- chives, Military Reference Branch.
EL had also been unable to find a chives I have visited, quickly becomes
copy of one of the other two Cutler- accustomed to a huge variety of
Twining memos found at the Library security markings. The size of the
of Congress Manuscript Division, nor type, whether printed or rubber CHANGE OF ADDRESS
of a memo Dr. Menzel claims went to stamped, the location on the paper,
Eisenhower, nor of a TS memo dated whether Top or Bottom or just one, MEMBERS/SUBSCRIBERS
April 6, 1959, noted in a censored TS all vary. Not being either psychic, as
memo-to-file from Gordon Gray, Todd seems to be, nor a psychiatrist, Advise change of address
same date and relating to an I cannot provide an explanation for (include county and
unspecified 5412/2 (Covert) activity. Todd's (to use his words) "gross
The primary job of EL archivists is deception, gross incompetence, phone no.) to:
to retrieve Archive boxes for re- spurious evaluations and assess-
searchers, not to paw through huge ments" or lack of objectivity. MUFON
files in vaults. Perhaps Todd is Considering Todd has never been 103 Oldtowne Rd.
unaware that all EL file folders are in responsible for classified material, nor
typically 6" wide, covered archive visited any archives, his lack of Seguin, Texas 78155-4099
boxes, not in file drawers, and that familiarity with procedures, document
The following summarizes case in. The site, a clockwise swirl of cident was confirmed by other airline
reports received from December 1989 depressed weeds, was uniformly 7 personnel.
through March 1990 that were well feet 8 inches in diameter. The vegeta-
documented, and which may repre- tion was coiled tightly at the epicenter. • Log #900104: 12/21/89, 12:30
sent significant ufological events. No footprints or other imprints were a.m. event in Pensacola, Florida, in-
Unless noted, no sound, vibration or found under the depression or vestigator Rex Salisberry. A man was
odor was detected. leading up to the site. No debris was driving across the Pensacola Bay
found outside the site which could Bridge on his way home from work
• Log #891204: 11/2/89. 9:40 logically be associated with a when he spotted a dark cylindrical ob-
p.m. event in Gulf Breeze, Florida, in- downdraft. An attempt to manually ject moving very slowly in the near
vestigators Carol and Rex Salisberry. duplicate the effect in a nearby stand distance and opposite direction,
A teenage brother and sister, walking of weeds was unsuccessful. A perhaps 200 feet over the water. A
home from a convenience store, radiological test conducted five days bright beam emanated from its front.
noticed two lighted bell-shaped discs later offered no extraordinary Two or three red blinking lights were
moving swiftly nearby. As they stopped readings. (See the article, "Swirled centered on the underside. Total
to stare, the vehicles likewise halted Landing Trace?" in this issue for ad- length was likened to an airliner. Hav-
and hovered. The teens again started ditional details and photographs.) ing slowed his auto, the witness never-
walking and the objects resumed their theless passed out of view after 5
flight, only to hover once more seem- • Log #891206: 9/28/89. 8p.m. minutes. Collateral contacts with
ingly in response to the witnesses event over Tillamook Bay, Oregon, military and civilian authorities failed
stopping. Momentarily these sped out investigator Skip Schultz. Nine report- to resolve the incident but established
of sight and a third identical disc ap- ing witnesses (and possibly dozens of that the path indicated is off limits to
proached, then dropped below a others) observed a circle of lights, air and ship traffic.
treeline at which point a humming each light consisting of a ring and
sound was detected. Racing home, transparent center, moving slowly • Log #900105: April 1987, late-
they convinced their mother to go northward over the bay. An apparent night event in Pensacola, Florida, in-
outside. She also heard the sound, thin line was observed connecting the vestigator Joe Barron. A woman
which continued for over a minute, lights. No other outline was positive- returned to bed after a bathroom visit
though nothing further was observed. ly identified. Separately, brilliant and momentarily became aware of a
Dogs in the vicinity barked until the flashes of light were seen intermittent- brilliant light in the room. She then
humming ceased. The surface of all ly in the same area. Collateral con- saw a column of white light (a rain-
three was described as blue-gray. tacts with military bases and a com- bow of colors within) protruding down
White light shone on the bottom of mercial airport ruled out conventional through the ceiling, within which
each of the first two, while the under- aircraft as a resolution. The duration floated a 3-3V2 foot humanoid. The
side of the third displayed brighter was 15 minutes for the observations being, suspended near the ceiling
yellowish light. The total duration was of individual scattered witnesses and throughout, was described as having
estimated as five minutes. 45 minutes in total. an oversized head, grey skin, no hair,
black almond-shaped eyes, a slit
• Log #891205: 11/15/89. • Log #900103: 10/24/89, 6:15 mouth, nostrils without a discernible
discovery in Gulf Breeze, Florida, in- a.m. event in northern Indiana, in- nose and long arms. It wore a tight-
vestigators Robert Reid, Carol and vestigator Franklin Reams. A com- fitting jumpsuit of dark olive "fuzzy"
Rex Salisberry. An unidentified caller mercial airline crew in flight en- material which extended over both
to WEAR-TV (Pensacola) gave direc- countered a boomerang-shaped vehi- hands and feet. The woman leapt out
tions to an unusual mark in a weedy cle passing overhead. A vertical beam of bed, turned on a lamp, and en-
area of Shoreline Park. Upon refer- of light shone downward from the gaged the being in a fixed stare
ral from WEAR, the Gulf Breeze Sen- underside of the object. The object without communication for several
tinel editor and a companion located passed from view in 30 seconds. minutes. Finally, she yelled "Get outta
the site. Investigators were then called Radio communication during the in- here!" Immediately, the beam began
By William E. Jones
January 7, 1948 is one of those the object's conelike shape? Did tion. The volume was turned down
landmark dates in the annals of Mantell die as a result of oxygen star- low, so that he would not miss any
ufology that will forever be a part of vation, or was he killed either acciden- calls from inbound aircraft on his air
each new comprehensive history of tally or on purpose by conscious traffic radio. There were no lights on
the subject. On that date Captain design? in the shack except for those on the
Thomas Mantell was leading a flight The answers to these and other radio dial.
of Air National Guard F-51 fighter related questions are unknown, at Suddenly, Pickering saw something
planes near Godman Air Force base least to the general public, and are come down through the overcast near
at Fort Knox, Kentucky. Having been likely to remain so. What we do know, or right over the runway. He was
alerted to the presence of an uniden- however,, at least as far as the news- looking up at a 30-degree angle.
tified object in the sky overhead, the paper reading public is concerned, is Pickering described what he saw as
Godman flight controllers radioed that this was the first time someone follows: "Down through the overcast
Mantell's flight and requested that was killed pursuing a "flying saucer." came this great big round red object."
they investigate the object which History was made. As history, For a second or two he thought it was
could easily be seen from the base. however, there is a related story much an aircraft falling in flames; it was red-
One plane was low on fuel and it less well known. The only other orange in color. Then he realized that
landed, but the others went up to reference to it I have been able to find this was not what he was seeing.
observe from a closer viewpoint. As was in an article by Donald E.
they closed in, the object appeared to Keyhoe, "The Flying Saucers Are Interloper
speed away and climb higher. Since Real," which appeared in the October
the planes had no oxygen on board, 1949 issue of True Magazine. Jack jumped off the cot and grabbed
which would permit high altitude fly- Albert R. "Jack" Pickering was a for the telephone to call the tower. He
ing, they had to break off their pursuit. civilian air controller at Lockbourne didn't have time. The tower called him
Captain Mantell, however, ap- Air Force Base, south of Columbus, first, wanting to know what was over
parently excited by the prospect of Ohio, that January day in 1948. He his station. The telephone had a long
closing in on this stranger in_the sky, was working in the direction-finding cord, so he stepped out the door to
continued to climb. Reports of the station off of the north-south runway get a better look at this strange
event indicate that he described the about one mile from the control interloper.
events as follows: "The thing looks tower. Jack had been an air traffic The object appeared to be a perfect
metallic and it's tremendous in size." controller with the military for four sphere. It made no sound. It didn't
As Mantell flew higher, he was ap- years before taking this civilian job. He change color. It had no windows,
parently overcome by a lack of suf- had a two-year associate degree in wings, fins or an exhaust. (Later, Air
ficient oxygen, lost consciousness, engineering and a pilot's license with Force investigators asked him
and his plane went into a dive and an instrument rating. He was familiar specifically about whether an exhaust
crashed. Mantell was killed. with military and civilian aircraft. tube and/or "a rocket tail" was visi-
It was approximately ten minutes ble.) It appeared to be completely
Conjecture after 7 p.m. when Jack had an ex- smooth. Given the known height of
perience that he would never forget. the cloud ceiling, the object appeared
The details of this event have been It was dark. The sky was completely to Pickering to be "bigger than a one
minutely described in numerous ar- overcast with a ceiling of 1200 feet. car garage, but not as big as my two
ticles and books elsewhere. Conjec- There was a 10 mph southwest wind car garage."
ture on what really happened has and the night was not particularly The object came down through the
been circulating ever since. Did Cap- cold, as Jack remembers. There was overcast and stopped. It stayed in this
tain Mantell, an experienced fighter no snow on the ground. location for approximately four to five
pilot, confuse the planet Venus for a Pickering was inside the station minutes. It moved around slightly,
large metallic object, as the govern- shack, lying on his back on a cot look- never quite holding its position for
ment's Project Sign concluded he did? ing out the window. The air traffic that long. The amount of movement
Was the object really a large Skyhook evening had not been heavy, and he didn't seem to cover more than 100
balloon, something at least implied by was listening to a local AM radio sta- square feet. During this time Jack