Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
30 (2013) 69
2013 Hosokawa Powder Technology Foundation
Abstract
Thermal drying is a highly energy-consuming process found in almost all industries accounting for
between 10-20% of national industrial energy consumption in the developed economies of the world.
It is arguably the oldest unit operation and yet R&D in this area is only a few decades old. Over
50% of products consumed by humans are in particulate form so that drying of wet particulates as
well as feedstock such as solutions, suspensions or pasty solids is of great industrial interest. Ef ficient
drying technologies must produce engineered dry particulates of desired quality at minimum cost,
low carbon footprint and little environmental impact. This article attempts to provide a global
overview of recent advances in drying technologies most of which represent evolutionary innovations.
In order to reduce investment costs one needs to enhance drying rates within limits imposed by the
product properties and end product quality requirements. Several novel gas-particle contactors
for example have been evaluated for drying. Combined modes of heating and hybrid dryers can
improve drying performance in some cases. Recent interest in production of nanoparticles by wet
processing also has stimulated interest in drying to produce nanoparticles. Drying of heat sensitive
biotech and pharmaceutical products also pose new challenges. A capsule overview is presented of
recent developments including enhancements in conventional drying technologies as well as more
innovative new technologies.
Keywords: advances in drying, hybrid drying, innovative dryers, particulate matter, selection and classification
Some Recent Advances in Drying Technologies to
Produce Particulate Solids
1
Department of Chemical Engineering, National Taiwan University of Science and Technology
2
Department of Chemical Engineering, National Taiwan University
3
Mechanical Engineering Department, National University of Singapore
4
Institute of Chemical Technology, Mumbai, India
1. Introduction
Drying involves removal of a liquid- most of the
time water- from diverse physical forms of feedstock
at widely varying production rates (1 kg/h to 100t/
h) subject to different quality constraints. In fact hun-
dreds of variants are needed to meet the commercial
requirements. Drying involves transient transport
phenomena subject to rather severe constraints im-
posed by material science. Thus the same physical
dryer will work differently for different materials and
in fact may not work at all for some if there are some
changes in properties such as stickiness or change in
glass transition temperatures during drying
1)
. Minor
changes in product formulations can affect drying ki-
netics such that the capacity of a given dryer may be
altered substantially. Although recent R&D aims at
injecting more science and engineering into the scale-
up, design and operation of most dryers, industrial
dryer design still depends heavily on empiricism and
operating experience. Innovations therefore come
slowly. Another reason for the slow rate of innovation
in industrial drying may be the long shelf life of most
dryers which may range from 25 to 50 years in some
cases which makes it unattractive to change designs
frequently
2, 3)
. Lack of fundamental knowledge makes
scale-ups hard, unreliable and risky.
In this paper we will look at conventional dryers
Corresponding author:
E-mail: mpeasm@nus.edu.sg
TEL:+65-6516-4623FAX:+65-6775-4710
Duu-Jong Lee
1,2
, Sachin Jangam
3
and Arun S. Mujumdar
3,4
KONA Powder and Particle Journal No.30 (2013) 70
which can be enhanced by simple modifications,
combination with known drying technologies and
modifying the way heat is input into the system. We
shall also examine some newer gas-particle contac-
tors which are or can be used as convective dryers
due to their enhanced heat and mass transfer perfor-
mance.
Note that when the feedstock is in liquid or sludge
form some sort of pretreatment is often applied to
speed drying or to reduce the drying duty. In the in-
terest of space this aspect is not covered here. Read-
ers may refer to Handbook of Industrial Drying
1)
for
details. When selecting a dryer for a given application
it is important to examine the whole drying system
which may typically include mechanical dewatering
before drying and some post-dryer operations such
as cooling, coating, agglomeration etc. It is suggested
that LCA should also be carried out before selecting
the drying system as the concerns of global warming
and resulting legislations may place severe limita-
tions in emission of green house gases in not-too-
distant future.
Selection of dryers is a major and most important
task. It is necessary to look at conventional dryers as
well as the newly developed ones although there is
limited field experience with the latter. In the follow-
ing section we will examine the classification and se-
lection of dryers as it is central to further discussion
on recent developments.
2. Some Conventional Dryers - Selection and
Classification
Dryer selection has long been practiced as an art
rather than science depending more on prior expe-
rience and vendorsrecommendations. As drying
technologies have evolved and become more diverse
and complex, this has become an increasingly dif-
ficult and demanding task for the non-expert. For an
optimal selection of process, one must examine the
overall flowsheet as well as the drying system . A
careful evaluation of as many of the possible factors
affecting the selection helps to reduce the number of
options. For a new application (new product or new
process), it is important to follow a careful procedure
leading to the right choice of the dryer.
1)
Character-
istics of different dryer types should be recognized
when selecting dryers. Changes in operating condi-
tions of the same dryer can affect the quality of the
product. So, aside from the dryer type, it is also im-
portant to choose the right operating conditions for
optimal quality and cost of thermal dehydration. Each
type of dryer has specific characteristics, which make
it either suitable or unsuitable for a specific given
application. The details can be found in Mujumdar
(2006).
1)
Baker
5, 6)
has suggested a structural approach for
dryer selection, which is iterative. It includes follow-
ing steps:
List all key process specifications
Carry out preliminary selection
Carry out bench scale test including quality tests
Make economic evaluation of alternatives
Conduct pilot scale trials
Select most appropriate dryer type
Sometimes the selection is based on the past ex-
perience rather than the technical approach. It has
few limitations such as; the new choice will be less-
than-optimal if the original selection is not optimal.
Selection of a proper dryer is a crucial step, but best
design of the wrong dryer is still a poor choice. His-
torically, dryer selection has been made by experts
on the basis of their extensive knowledge. However,
in recent years the computer based techniques have
been developed, which have the potential of at least
partially deskilling this process. Amongst these pos-
sibilities, fuzzy expert systems are the most promis-
ing. Before going for the selection of drying system
proper classification of dryers based on various cri-
teria is very necessary such as the one provided in
Fig. 1 based on mode of operation.
For illustrative purposes let us look at drying of
foods. A wrong choice of a drying system and/or
drying conditions can have adverse effects on both
the physical and nutritional properties of the dried
product. The selection of a dryer for a particular food
product depends on the type of feed, the amount
and type of moisture, drying kinetics, heat sensitiv-
ity, physical structure of the material to be dried,
quality requirements of a dried food and many other
factors
7-10)
. Dryers are commonly classified based on
the mode of heat transfer (e.g. conduction, convec-
tion or radiation) and mode of operation (batch vs
continuous). Long drying times and small through-
puts favour batch drying.
Fig. 2 lists various conventional drying methods
used for food applications. This is a very basic cat-
egorization of dryers based on physical nature of the
wet material to be dried. For liquid feed, spray drying
is still the most common way of drying although ro-
tary drum dryers are also popular. Drying of liquids
by spraying on beds of inert particles using some
variants of the fluidized bed, spouted bed, moving
bed, vibrated bed, agitated bed etc have also been
proposed for drying pastes and slurries to produce
KONA Powder and Particle Journal No.30 (2013) 71
powders. Spray drying is an expensive technique
to use for low value products, mainly because of its
low thermal efficiency due to requirement of moving
large quantity of drying air through a large chamber
and then collecting the particles in a suitable gas
cleaning system. Therefore a method such as inert
bed drying has been proposed and recently much ef-
fort has been devoted to this technique
11-13)
. However,