Group Bernardo, João Machado, João Meira, Inês members Main questions Democracy or Slavocracy? Democracy: a door for multiculturalism of globalization? Basis for improvement or unquestionable dogma? EU: or disguised tyranny? The perfect recipe: men in black. Politics or Propaganda? Strong points Controversial questions with clear rationale Well prepared and very successful presentation Weak points Rhetorical questions? … some questions seem to have a readymade answer/airtight explanatory system!!! Understanding of ‘research’ Collaboration Sorry, no observation at all. skills Presentation evidenced clearly divided tasks. You seem to have managed interdependence and co-responsibility. Were roles divided?
DEMOCRACY IN OUR GLOBAL ERA
Group João Costa, Karina, Nuno, Rita (Tomás) members Main questions Strong points Weak points No presentation; some ideas, no research, no group. Collaboration skills
MULTICULTURALISM & CITIZENSHIP
Group Joana Duarte, Marta, Pedro, Tiago members Main questions Are we human or are we dancers? (BIG question) Do we all have the same rights and opportunities? Are we equal despite our different languages, religions, ethnicity, …? Why can discrimination and multiculturalism be considered opposites? Can we make the difference if we stand for Human Rights? How are immigrants integrated in our society? Do they have full legal rights? How do immigrants and their cultures contribute to enrich society? Do we accept each other as we are or do we seek for perfection? (consumer society) Strong points Excellent BIG question (connection with own experience, interests and reflection skills) Many ‘researchable’ questions Ability to raise debate! Weak points Presentation not well rehearsed Rationale behind questions not very clear (‘the things we know that made these questions possible’) Collaboration Focused observation was not possible but see if you agree: skills Group members easily out of focus Poor listening skills Objectives of work not clear for all. Hard time to get started No one willing to perform coordination role
THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE
Group Frederico, Hugo, Sara, Vranda members Main questions What is the future of English? Will the English language lose its status as a global language? If yes – Which language will replace English? Why? What is the key factor for the survival of English as a global language? Strong points Research was done Presentation was well prepared Weak points Participation was uneven Lack of confidence – be bold! Collaboration Focused observation was not possible but see if you agree: skills Good listening skills Objectives of work not clear for all. Hard time to get started No one willing to perform coordination role
CULTURE, ARTS & SOCIETY
Group Joana Lima, Jorge, Miguel, Raquel members Main questions What is Art? Can just anybody be an ‘artist’ or are there any boundaries? Strong points Creativity Understanding of the topic Questions asked Poster (as it was meant to raise curiosity and reflection, not information) Weak points Not much research done, apparently Pictures chosen but insufficient rationale (or ill-explored) in presentation Presentation not (well) rehearsed Some members too self-conscious during presentation Collaboration Focused observation was not possible but see if you agree: skills - Group members easily out of focus - Poor listening skills; no turn taking - No one to: make objectives clear; summarise and paraphrase; systematize; distribute tasks; organise materials; wrap up … - Some(?) members not aware that if they fail the group will fail - Problems such as ‘finding time extra class to meet’ not overcome - Roles not distributed; need for these roles still not clear for all