31 views

Uploaded by vijayjaghan

Material selection process

You are on page 1of 6

Material selection is a step in the process of designing any physical object. In the context of product

design, the main goal of material selection is to minimize cost while meeting product performance goals.

[1]

Systematic selection of the best material for a given application begins with properties and costs of

candidate materials. For example, a thermal blanket must have poor thermal conductivity in order to

minimize heat transfer for a given temperature difference.

Systematic selection for applications requiring multiple criteria is more complex. For example, a rod

which should be stiff and light requires a material with high Young's modulus and low density. If the rod

will be pulled in tension, the specific modulus, or modulus divided by density , will determine the

best material. But because a plate's bending stiffness scales as its thickness cubed, the best material for a

stiff and light plate is determined by the cube root of stiffness divided by density . For a stiff

beam in bending the material index is .

Contents

1 Ashby plots

2 Cost issues

3 Example

4 References

5 External links

Ashby plots

An Ashby plot, named for Michael Ashby of

Cambridge University, is a scatter plot which

displays two or more properties of many

materials or classes of materials.

[2]

An Ashby

plot useful for the example of the stiff, light

part discussed above would have Young's

modulus on one axis and density on the other

axis, with one data point on the graph for each

candidate material. On such a plot, it is easy to

find not only the material with the highest

stiffness, or that with the lowest density, but

that with the best ratio . Using a log scale

on both axes facilitates selection of the

material with the best plate stiffness .

Page 1 of 6 Material selection - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

24/05/2014 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_selection

Ashby plot of density and Young's modulus.

Plot using Ashby's own CES Selector software.

The first Ashby plot on the right shows density

and Young's modulus, without a log scale.

Metals are represented by blue squares,

ceramics by green, and polymers by red. It was generated by the Material Grapher.

[3]

The second plot shows the same materials

attributes for a database of approx 100

materials. Materials families (polymers, foams,

metals, etc.) are identified by the larger colored

bubbles. The image is created using Prof Mike

Ashby's own CES Selector software and data

from Granta Design.

[4]

Cost issues

Cost of materials plays a very significant role

in their selection. The most straightforward

way to weight cost against properties is to

develop a monetary metric for properties of

parts. For example, life cycle assessment can

show that the net present value of reducing the

weight of a car by 1 kg averages around $5, so material substitution which reduces the weight of a car

can cost up to $5 per kilogram of weight reduction more than the original material. However, the

geography- and time-dependence of energy, maintenance and other operating costs, and variation in

discount rates and usage patterns (distance driven per year in this example) between individuals, means

that there is no single correct number for this. For commercial aircraft, this number is closer to $450/kg,

and for spacecraft, launch costs around $20,000/kg dominate selection decisions.

[5]

Thus as energy prices have increased and technology has improved, automobiles have substituted

increasing amounts of light weight magnesium and aluminium alloys for steel, aircraft are substituting

carbon fiber reinforced plastic and titanium alloys for aluminium, and satellites have long been made out

of exotic composite materials.

Of course, cost per kg is not the only important factor in material selection. An important concept is 'cost

per unit of function'. For example, if the key design objective was the stiffness of a plate of the material,

as described in the introductory paragraph above, then the designer would need a material with the

optimal combination of density, Young's modulus, and price. Optimizing complex combinations of

technical and price properties is a hard process to achieve manually, so rational material selection

software is an important tool.

Page 2 of 6 Material selection - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

24/05/2014 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_selection

Example

A common method for choosing an appropriate material is an Ashby chart. By plotting a performance

index for a specific case of loading on the Ashby chart, a material with maximum performance can be

selected. The performance index takes into consideration the dimensional constraints, material

constraints, and free variable constraints of a specific application. The following example will show the

how to come up with the performance index and how to plot and interpret the Ashby chart.

This example will take into consideration a beam that will undergo two different loads with the goal of

minimizing weight. The first load is a beam in tension. Figure 1 illustrates this loading.

Figure 1 - Beam under Tensile stress loading to minimize weight.

The parameters for the beam can be organized into categories. These categories are material variables,

which include density, modulus, and yield stress, free variables which are variables that can change

during the loading cycle, for example applied force. The final category is design variables which usually

are a limit of how thick the beam can be, how much it can deflect, or any other limiting factor for the

specific application. For this loading cycle, the stress in the beam is measured as =P/A, where P is the

load and A is the cross sectional area. The weight is measure as w=AL, where is the density, and L is

the length. By looking at the equation, we see that for a fixed length of L, the material variables are

and . There is one free variable, A, and a variable that needs to be minimized, w.

In order to find the performance index, an equation for w in terms of fixed and material variables needs

to be found. This means that the variable A has to somehow be replaced. By rearranging the axial stress

equation, A can be represented as A=P/. Substituting this into the weight equation,w= P/ L, gives an

equation for weight that has only fixed and material variables.

The next step is to separate the material variables from all other variables and constants. The equation

becomes w=(/)LP. Since the goal is to minimize weight, the material variables have to be minimized.

This means that (/) has to be minimized, or the inverse equation, (/) has to be maximized. We call

the equation that needs to be maximized our performance index. P_cr=(/). It is important to note that

the performance index is always an equation that needs to be maximized, so inverting an equation that

needs to be minimized is necessary.

The performance index can then be plotted on the Ashby chart by converting the equation to a log scale.

This is done by taking the log of both sides, and plotting it similar to a line with P_cr being the y-axis

intercept. This means that the higher the intercept, the higher the performance of the material. By

moving the line up the Ashby chart, the performance index gets higher. Each materials the line passes

through, has the performance index listed on the y-axis. So, moving to the top of the chart while still

touching a region of material is where the highest performance will be.

Page 3 of 6 Material selection - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

24/05/2014 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_selection

The next loading cycle will have a different performance index with a different equation. For example, if

you also want to maximize this beam for bending, using the max tensile stress equation of bending =(-

My)/I, where M is the bending moment, y is the distance from the neutral axis, and I is the moment of

inertia. This is shown in Figure 2. Using the weight equation above and solving for the free variables,

you arrive at w=((6MbL^2 ))*(/), where L is the length and b is the height of the beam. This turns

the material performance index into P_CR=/

Figure 2 - beam under bending stress. Trying to minimize weight

By plotting the two performance indices on the same Ashby chart, the maximum performance index of

both loading types together will be at the intercept of the two lines. This is shown in figure 3

Page 4 of 6 Material selection - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

24/05/2014 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_selection

Figure 3 - Ashby chart with performance indices plotted for maximum result

[2]

As seen from figure 3 the two lines intercept near the top of the graph at engineering ceramics. This will

give a performance index of 120 for tensile loading and 15 for bending. When taking into consideration

the cost of the engineering ceramics, especially because the intercept is around the diamond area, this

would not be the optimal case. A better case with lower performance index but more cost effective

solutions is around the Engineering Composites near CRFP.

Page 5 of 6 Material selection - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

24/05/2014 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_selection

References

^ George E. Dieter (1997). "Overview of the Materials Selection Process", ASM Handbook Volume 20:

Materials Selection and Design.

1.

^

a

b

Ashby, Michael (1999). Materials Selection in Mechanical Design (3rd edition ed.). Burlington,

Massachusetts: Butterworth-Heinemann. ISBN 0-7506-4357-9.

2.

^ "Material Grapher" (http://orbis.kent.edu/matdl/matml/select.php). Materials Digital Library Pathway

MatDL.org.

3.

^ "Granta Design" (http://www.grantadesign.com). Granta Design. 4.

^ Ashby, Michael F. (2005). Materials Selection in Mechanical Design. USA: Elsevier Ltd. p. 251.

ISBN 978-0-7506-6168-3.

5.

External links

Cambridge University - Profile of Prof. Michael Ashby (http://www-

edc.eng.cam.ac.uk/people/mfa2.html)

Cambridge Engineering Selector software - embodies Ashby charts and his performance indices

as part of its selection functionality - from Granta Design - chaired by Prof. M. Ashby

(http://www.grantadesign.com/products/ces/)

Categories: Materials science Product development Design

This page was last modified on 12 March 2014 at 18:56.

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms

may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia is a

registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization.

24/05/2014 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_selection

- Ashby chartUploaded byArjul Akram
- CasingSelectionUploaded byDaniel Bolaños
- Titanium ApplicationsUploaded byamabz
- Materials SelectionUploaded byManjunatha Eikila
- E1013161Uploaded byMilton Almeida
- Drilling Casing DesignUploaded byboxer995
- Casing DesignUploaded byLeopard Eyes
- Casing DesignUploaded byRisTy FrogGiesaa AmaNee
- Introduction to Materials Selection ChartsUploaded byKishore Bhat
- TitaniumUploaded byrifaldy
- Fishing Jars Brochure.pdfUploaded byLincoln ZhaoXi
- Casing DesignUploaded byNaser Khan
- haynesUploaded byJeff Haynes
- Job InterviewUploaded byERICATHENA
- 4 Casing DesignUploaded byZhong Ying
- TitaniumUploaded bynb262
- TitaniumUploaded byDjoe6897
- TitaniumUploaded bypotterhead1D
- TitaniumUploaded byRyan Mac
- titaniumUploaded bynveman
- TitaniumUploaded byIsidoro López
- TitaniumUploaded bytxk1789
- Heat Transfer in a Bubbling Fluidized BedUploaded byBilal Khan
- TitaniumUploaded byRicardo Rovira Chaler
- TitaniumUploaded byBinyam Bekele
- Material SelectionUploaded byIwan Surachwanto
- Drill Pipe manualUploaded bybrunoribeirovasconce
- Attachment I - Table 9 -Steel Composition Limits_ WehnerUploaded byRh Bobba
- TitaniumUploaded byAshish Dass
- TitaniumUploaded byFidel Medina Lopez

- Sheet Metal GuidelinesUploaded bypaulenew
- Principles of Mathematical ModellingUploaded byhgopalkrishnan
- Malleable IronUploaded byvijayjaghan
- Design, Fabrication and Inspection of Welded JointsUploaded bybaca88
- SOLUTION OF ST.-VENANT’S ANDUploaded byvijayjaghan
- Basics of Gray Iron Casting DesignUploaded byvijayjaghan
- unit-3Uploaded byvijayjaghan
- Welding GuidelinesUploaded byarunraj002
- Design Guide for ForgingsUploaded byamol_piaggio
- Design Guide for ForgingsUploaded byamol_piaggio
- Design Guide for ForgingsUploaded byamol_piaggio
- Mfg Tooling -00 IntroUploaded bysivasankarangs1979
- ansys_overview_v81_601Uploaded byjyotikamthe
- Residual StressUploaded byvijayjaghan
- 10 Math Tricks detailsUploaded byvijayjaghan
- 2 - ANSYS Command File Programming FeaturesUploaded byfelleibalazs
- Metric FastenersUploaded byvijayjaghan
- 1 - ANSYS Command File Creation and ExecutionUploaded byBaljinder Singh
- Ansys 11 WorkbenchUploaded byamir53
- 3 - Data Plotting Using Tables to Post Process ResultsUploaded bykanishkmechengg
- The Lost EggUploaded byDick Rink
- shortstories_foxandstorkUploaded byvijayjaghan
- Steelsformoulds EnglishUploaded byvijayjaghan
- FEA Formula HandbookUploaded byvijayjaghan

- MAN-Fuel_Pump.pdfUploaded byAndreea Vanghele
- UNDERSTANDING THE PERFORMANCE OF A PROGRESSIVE CAVITY PUMP WITH A METALLIC STATOR, Jose Gamboa, PDVSA.pdfUploaded byAnonymous Xy309m9Sm9
- The Effects of Consumerism on the EnvironmentUploaded byMenezes Chilongo
- 1281-2011 Te Unep Global Cc Fsp SweraUploaded byAmexTesfayeKora
- Membranes UllmannUploaded byT Josua Nababan
- Geothermal Energy and Geothermal Power PlantsUploaded bySantanu Manna
- National Association of Corrosion Engineers C-28-2015Uploaded bySen Hu
- Thesis Wind Energy Potential of IndiaUploaded bybidyadhar
- EPR_2009Uploaded byRiga Edwards
- 06-16E_BuildingPowerDistributionUploaded byNestor S. ReEyes
- L0807441Uploaded bykraenee
- 20 de Luyen Thi Anh Van Vao 10Uploaded bythangpenta
- Electrical-EngineeringUploaded byvijaydev75
- Principles of DynamicsUploaded byNhezlee Alegre
- article1379674376_RenqingUploaded byHamed Gerami
- Infinite Grid of ResistorsUploaded byUtkarsh Verma
- TRI How It Works OverviewUploaded bysanooksanan
- Remidi English Punya Sin SyinUploaded byAnnisa Retno Arimdayu
- Safety Instrumented SystemUploaded byMustafa Essam
- DOK-TD-IRI1-ERE_NEWUploaded byirfanWPK
- Principals of Electrical GroundingUploaded byAnonymous 2BE2FawD
- Properties of WavesUploaded byBilal
- book listUploaded byCool Shary
- 1 Safety Guide for Sliding Gates GB Ottobre05Uploaded bySourav Robin
- Lampiran Modul Tembak 32 Ver 4Uploaded byThanabalan Munuswamy
- Features of PLC based AMFUploaded bycyrilbabyk
- smartflowerpop-en-8735aa9c879acc510f78f92a16d489e7.pdfUploaded byely_ely3395
- JEE Main Physics SyllabusUploaded byRanjit Kumar
- Valve Recession PlusUploaded byAngel Zanotti
- Republic Act No. 8749Uploaded byVanjared Ocampo