0 оценок0% нашли этот документ полезным (0 голосов)
67 просмотров25 страниц
This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction is expressly forbidden. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should be independently verified.
Исходное описание:
Оригинальное название
New Findings on the 1958 Las Melosas Earthquake Sequence
This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction is expressly forbidden. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should be independently verified.
This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction is expressly forbidden. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should be independently verified.
On: 18 May 2010 Access details: Access Details: Free Access Publisher Taylor & Francis Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37- 41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK Journal of Earthquake Engineering Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=t741771161 New Findings on the 1958 Las Melosas Earthquake Sequence, Central Chile: Implications for Seismic Hazard Related to Shallow Crustal Earthquakes in Subduction Zones Sergio A. Sepulveda a ; Maximiliano Astroza b ; Edgar Kausel c ; Jaime Campos c ; Eduardo A. Casas a ; Sofia Rebolledo a ;Ramon Verdugo b a Department of Geology, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile b Department of Civil Engineering, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile c Department of Geophysics, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile To cite this Article Sepulveda, Sergio A. , Astroza, Maximiliano , Kausel, Edgar , Campos, Jaime , Casas, Eduardo A. , Rebolledo, Sofia andVerdugo, Ramon(2008) 'New Findings on the 1958 Las Melosas Earthquake Sequence, Central Chile: Implications for Seismic Hazard Related to Shallow Crustal Earthquakes in Subduction Zones', Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 12: 3, 432 455 To link to this Article: DOI: 10.1080/13632460701512951 URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13632460701512951 Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.informaworld.com/terms-and-conditions-of-access.pdf This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan or sub-licensing, systematic supply or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material. Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 12:432455, 2008 Copyright A.S. Elnashai & N.N. Ambraseys ISSN: 1363-2469 print / 1559-808X online DOI: 10.1080/13632460701512951 432 UEQE 1363-2469 1559-808X Journal of Earthquake Engineering, Vol. 00, No. 0, November 2007: pp. 142 Journal of Earthquake Engineering New Findings on the 1958 Las Melosas Earthquake Sequence, Central Chile: Implications for Seismic Hazard Related to Shallow Crustal Earthquakes in Subduction Zones xxxx S. A. Sepulveda et al. SERGIO A. SEPULVEDA 1 , MAXIMILIANO ASTROZA 2 , EDGAR KAUSEL 3 , JAIME CAMPOS 3 , EDUARDO A. CASAS 1 , SOFIA REBOLLEDO 1 , and RAMON VERDUGO 2 1 Department of Geology, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile 2 Department of Civil Engineering, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile 3 Department of Geophysics, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile On the 4 th of September 1958, a sequence of 3 earthquakes of magnitude 6.76.9 struck the Andean Main Cordillera at the latitude of Santiago, Central Chile. The quakes were preceded by a magni- tude 6.0 foreshock one week earlier. This seismic sequence provided the only documented effects of strong shaking related to shallow earthquakes in a subduction-zone environment in which seismicity is dominated by interplate and intermediate-depth intraplate earthquakes. The 1958 earthquake sequence is reviewed as part of a project of seismic hazard assessment of the densely populated region of Santiago. We reinterpret historical documents and carried out field observations to obtain new intensity estimates, and we estimate ranges of peak acceleration values based on geotechnical back-analyses of earthquake-induced landslides. Estimated peak intensities of 9 and peak accelera- tions close to 1 g illustrate the significant seismic hazard in areas around active faults in the region and the need to adapt the building codes to these rare but potentially highly destructive types of earthquakes. Keywords Earthquakes; Landslides; Seismic Hazard; Strong Ground Motion 1. Introduction 1.1. Shallow Earthquakes in Chile Over the last 100 years, 15 earthquakes have caused significant human and economic losses in Chile. Although the largest events occurred along the coast in an interplate seismogenic zone with a low-angle reverse focal mechanisms, these were not necessarily the most destructive events. Intraplate earthquakes with continental epicenters, with inter- mediate depths and with a lower frequency of occurrence than the interplate events, have caused significant damage (e.g., the 1939 Chilln earthquake, although it was influenced by bad quality of construction). A third group of earthquakes in this region comprises earthquakes with continental epicenters with shallow focal depth (crustal), such as the sequence of events at Las Melosas in 1958. These occur with a lower frequency than the Received 16 January 2007; accepted 14 June 2007. Address correspondence to Sergio A. Sepulveda, Department of Geology, University of Chile, Plaza Ercilla 803, Santiago, Chile; E-mail: sesepulv@ing.uchile.cl D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 433 former two types, but due to their shallow depths, they pose a fairly significant seismic hazard not considered in current seismic building codes [INN, 1996]. Several of the crustal earthquakes associated with active faults in the region of the Andes Mountain Range have drawn the attention of specialists. Previous studies of limited instrumental data have concluded that the 1958 Las Melosas sequence included three prin- cipal mainshocks with magnitudes of 6.9, 6.7, and 6.8 respectively [Lomnitz, 1960; Piderit, 1961]. More recent well-recorded events, such as the 2001 M = 6.3 Chusmiza earthquake (northern Chile), and the 2004 M = 6.4 Curic earthquake (central Chile), have aroused great interest among seismologists and engineers. All of the well-recorded recent events were shallow (< 15 km depth) with epicenters far from important cities. The events caused little damage, possibly because of their remote locations. The Las Melosas, Curic and Chusmiza earthquakes, besides the recent April 2007 (M = 6.2) Aysen earthquake in Southern Chile, are the only Chilean shallow events to-date that have produced strong- motion data. Shallow crustal earthquakes are caused by brittle deformation of the crust under the tectonic load controlled by subduction. The existence of shallow seismic activity within the mountain range has been apparent in field studies carried out by several researchers, among them, Barrientos and Vera [1995] and Barrientos et al. [2004], who studied the central zone of Chile between 32.5S and 35.5S. Crustal seismic activity also occurs on the Argentine side of the Andes in the provinces of Mendoza, San Juan and La Rioja. Crustal seismicity is familiar in these provinces because earthquakes have destroyed the important cities of San Juan and Mendoza on several occasions. The earthquakes of 1782, 1861, and 1927 are well known in the city of Mendoza, as well as the large quakes of 1894, 1944, and 1977, which destroyed the city of San Juan. All of these earthquakes are crustal intraplate events with focal depths between 10 and 30 km [Zamarbide and Castano, 1993; Castano and Castano, 1997]. The southernmost part of Chile, Tierra del Fuego, has also experienced shallow earthquakes, such as the great Punta Arenas quake of 1949. These are interplate events, generated along the contact between the South America and Scotia plates along the Almirantazgo Fjord and Fagnano Lake. Earthquakes in Chile are not exclusive to the fault systems associated with the forma- tion of the Andes Main Range; there is also evidence of geologically active faults in the continental crust near the coastal region [Armijo and Thiele, 1990; Herv, 1987; Naranjo, 1987]. Recently, Campos et al. [2002] also found clear evidence of crustal seismic activity along the coastal zone of Constitucin Concepcin (3537S). An analysis of historical shallow earthquakes in Chile is generally only possible through geological studies. The seismological network was installed only recently. The intensities generated by shallow crustal earthquakes in Chile also attenuate quickly with distance, so earthquakes in uninhabited zones have gone largely unnoticed. For instance, the Punta Arenas earthquake of December 17, 1949 (magnitude M s = 7.8), occurred in an uninhabited region, and at a time when there were no local or regional seismic instruments. This study is focused on the 1958 Las Melosas earthquake sequence. These events struck close to the capital city of Santiago, in the interior of the Maipo River valley, where hydroelectric, mining, and agricultural and most recently, tourist activity, support increas- ingly large human settlements. The Las Melosas earthquakes can be considered as some of the few shallow earthquakes of great magnitude with reported damage that have occurred in Chile. Their study is of considerable importance for the seismic design of buildings and facilities, despite the few instrumental data available. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 434 S. A. Sepulveda et al. 1.2. Geological and Tectonic Setting Central Chile is located along the convergent margin of the Nazca and South American plates (Fig.1). The Nazca Plate converges presently at a rate of about 8 cm/yr, although the rate has varied during the Palaeogene and Neogene from about 415 cm/yr [e.g., Pardo- Casas and Molnar, 1987; Somoza, 1998; Le Roux et al., 2005]. Due to this tectonic setting, the Andes in the study area are segmented in north-south oriented morphostruc- tural units, which are from west to east (Fig.1): the Coastal Cordillera, Central Depression, Main Cordillera, and Frontal Cordillera [Fock, 2005]. The epicentral area of the 1958 earthquakes is located within the Maipo River drain- age basin in the Andes Main Cordillera (Fig. 2). The geology of the region [Thiele, 1980; Fock, 2005] is complex, characterized by extensive outcrops of the Cenozoic volcano- sedimentary rocks of the Abanico and Farellones Formations, on the western flank of the Main Cordillera, whereas in the eastern part a sequence of Jurassic and Cretaceous continental and marine sedimentary and volcanic rocks are disposed in north-south trend- ing bands, all affected by intense deformation related to the Andes orogeny. Recent volca- nic rocks and deposits are located to the east of this sequence, whereas Miocene granitoids are intruded throughout the area. The heaviest damage produced by the 1958 earthquake was in the valleys of the Maipo, Volcn and Yeso Rivers (Fig. 2). These valleys were affected by the last glaciation [Ormeo, 2006], with characteristic U-shapes and steep slopes. They are filled with fluvial and alluvial sediments of usually coarse granulometry, partially covered by lateral alluvial fans as well as landslide, debris flow, and mudflow deposits formed by mass movements generated on the valley slopes and in lateral ravines [Chiu, 1991]. Some glacial till deposits form small hills with smooth topography on the valleys flanks [Ormeo, 2006]. Important FIGURE 1 Regional morphostructural map of Central Chile, showing the tectonic setting and regional geomorphological units. The black box shows the area of study (Fig. 2) (modified from [Fock, 2005]). D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 435 landslide deposits of several cubic kilometres related to Late Pleistocene Holocene, possi- bly post-glaciation landslide events shape part of the relief in the Yeso and Volcn Valleys [Abele, 1984; Chiu, 1991]. Ignimbritic deposits generated by Pleistocene volcanic activity [Stern et al., 1984; Vargas, G., pers. comm., 2006] occur on some of the topographic highs. The steep rocky slopes are usually covered by colluvium and rock fall deposits [Chiu, 1991]. The region is dominated by a series of folds and faults with an approximately north- south trend [Thiele, 1980; Fock, 2005] (Fig. 2). A few kilometers east of the 4 th of September 1958 earthquake epicentre, a couple of regional west-vergent thrust faults crop out (Chacayes-Yesillo and Diablo Faults), whereas folds interpreted as fault-propagating folds by Fock [2005] deform the rocks around the point identified as the epicenter by Lomnitz [1960]. These deformation patterns indicate the presence of blind faults a few kilometers below the surface. The Las Melosas sequence apparently involved rupture on one or more of these faults. 1.3. Historic Seismicity and the 1958 Las Melosas Earthquake Sequence Little was known about the seismicity of the region until the occurrence of the Las Melosas sequence. According to historical data available at the Geophysical and Seismological Institute at the University of Chile, seismic activity had been observed in the Maipo Valley in 1850, 1870 to 1880, 1905, and 1947 [Flores et al., 1960]. FIGURE 2 Simplified geological map of the Maipo drainage basin [modified from Fock, 2005]. The main geological units are: (1) Mesozoic marine sedimentary and volcanic rocks; (2) Cenozoic volcano-sedimentary rocks; (3) Miocene granitoids; (4) Neogene volcanic rocks; (5) Neogene alluvial and fluvial sediments. Main faults and folds are shown. The location of the 28/08/1958 and 04/09/1958 earthquakes is shown (stars), along with the location of the studied landslides in this article (triangles) and towns and villages mentioned in the text (dots). D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 436 S. A. Sepulveda et al. The Las Melosas sequence started on the 28 th of August, 1958, but the events with greater magnitude occurred on the 4 th of September, 1958, at 5:50 pm local time. Accord- ing to seismological reports, this was a sequence of three events in a span of six minutes. The epicenter was located at the junction of the Maipo and El Volcn Rivers, at a focal depth of about 10 km (Fig. 2). A composite hypocenter and focal mechanism solution, using first motion P waves of the first event, was determined by Lomnitz [1960] and Pardo and Acevedo [1984] as a left lateral strike-slip along a north-south trending fault plane. The inferred composite focal mechanism, obtained for the three principal main- shocks, has a strike of N14E and a dip of 78W [Pardo and Acevedo, 1984]; N12E/ 79W [Lomnitz, 1960]; or N13E/ 77W [Piderit, 1961]. Recently, Alvarado et al. [2007], based on P wave modeling, report a strike-slip fault plane with azimuth of 20, dip of 70 to the south-east, and rake of 30, with a focal depth of about 8 km. The mag- nitudes (M s ) of the three largest events were 6.9, 6.7, and 6.8, respectively [Flores et al., 1960; Piderit, 1961]. The peak acceleration recorded in Santiago, about 65 km from the epicenter, was 0.05 g. The 4 th of September sequence was preceded by several foreshocks of lesser magnitude. The largest of these occurred at 5:30 local time on the 28 th of August, and had a Richter magnitude M s = 6.0 [Flores et al., 1960; Pardo and Acevedo, 1984]. The inferred fault plane for this event had a NS strike and 75W dip [Pardo and Acevedo, 1984]. Table 1 shows the hypocentral data of the previously mentioned earthquakes, as well as of the largest aftershock. The epicentral area is a mountainous region about 70 km from Santiago. According to Flores et al. [1960], the center of this epicentral zone would be at the locality of El Volcn, where a modified Mercalli intensity (MMI) of IX was estimated. Other populated centers located within the epicentral zone are Las Melosas and Los Queltehues (Fig. 2). The 28 th of August earthquake damaged the facilities of the police summer camp in Las Melosas; therefore, it had been evacuated before the 4 th of September. Part of the personnel at the hydroelectric plants of Los Queltehues and El Volcn had also been evacuated. Likewise, the town of El Volcn had already been evacuated due to the landslides that had taken place. This situation, along with the fact that many local people were at polling booths in the town of San Jos de Maipo because September 4 was election day, left the epicentral region partly deserted, and therefore the effects of this triple earthquake were minor in terms of the number of casualties. Reports indicate that the September 4 sequence caused 4 fatalities and 35 serious injuries, and left 175 people homeless. The earthquakes of the 4 th of September were followed by 99 documented aftershocks, which continued until early December, 1958. The magnitudes of these aftershocks varied TABLE 1 Magnitude and hypocentral data of the largest shocks of the 1958 Las Melosas seismic sequence Date and GMT Time Year/month/day hh: mm:ss Latitude Longitude Depth (km) Magnitude 1958/08/28 09:36:04 34.0 70.1 15 6.0 1958/09/04 21:51:08 33.9 70.2 10 6.9 1958/09/04 21:52 33.9 70.2 10 6.7 1958/09/04 21:55 33.9 70.2 10 6.8 1958/09/08 22:24:55 34.0 70.0 n/a 5.3 D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 437 between 3.5 and 5.3, the latter having occurred on the 8 th of September [Piderit, 1961] (Table 1). 2. Damage Characterization and Intensity Assessment Earthquake damage was concentrated in the mining and industrial facilities (electricity generation and water supply plants) and in single and two-storey houses. Many of the structures did not have earthquake-resistant designs and were built with materials avail- able in the immediate area. Damage to the Queltehues, El Volcn and Maitenes hydroelectric plants affected the electricity supply of Santiago; the Queltehues plant service was suspended for 180 days. The water supply of Santiago city was also affected due to the destruction of the Laguna Negra aqueduct near San Gabriel (Fig. 3). Furthermore, the roads suffered significant damage due to landslides and rock falls. Field visits to the damage zone allowed us to study the damage in some ruined and some repaired structures that are still standing. In many cases, the construction and material quality were of poor quality; a situation that had been reported by Lamana [1963]. In this study, we determine intensity values in 15 places located 80 km or less from the earthquake epicenter. According to Flores et al. [1960], the most severely affected area was approximately elliptical with 20 km in length and 10 km wide. This zone was visited soon after the shocks by members of the Department of Civil Engineering of the University of Chile, who collected information that was reported by Rosenberg [1958] and Flores et al. [1960] and left a photographic collection [DIC, 1958]. The intensity values in the cities outside of the damage zone were obtained from information given by the local press [El Mercurio, 1958a]. FIGURE 3 Damage in the Laguna Negra unreinforced concrete aqueduct [DIC, 1958]. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 438 S. A. Sepulveda et al. 2.1. Types of Construction and Damage Single and two-storey buildings in the epicentral region can be classified as unreinforced stone or rubble masonry cemented with mud, adobe houses, quarry masonry cemented with mortar, diagonally braced wooden frame, and partially or totally confined stone masonry. With the exception of the last category, all building types suffered very heavy damage. Our findings for the performance of each type of construction are as follows: (i) Unreinforced rubble or stone masonry cemented with mud had very poor earth- quake resistance and had the worst performance, with partial (Fig. 4) or total collapse of most structures [Flores et al., 1960]. The damage was similar to that observed following the Tarapac earthquake of northern Chile of June 2005 [Astroza et al., 2005a]. (ii) Quarry masonry cemented with mortar also had very poor performance. In this type of construction the walls are reinforced with concrete beams (Fig. 5) that are designed to help support the roof and avoid the out-of-plane wall collapse. Damage to these structures was nearly total and partial collapse of the walls and vertical cracks in walls at intersections (Fig. 5). More severe damage occurred in buildings in which the construction and/or quality of mortar was poor. Another example of this type of construction is the Lo Valds German Mountain Shelter, located to the northeast of the earthquake epicenter, which was well built with a good quality mortar and did not suffer structural damages. (iii) Adobe houses are not common in this area; existing adobe structures suffered heavy damage. According to Flores et al. [1960], the damages correspond to par- tial wall collapse and vertical cracks in walls at intersections with out-of-plumb. (iv) Braced wooden frame structures performed relatively well. In these structures, void spaces between timbers are filled with different materials and covered with mud or mortar stucco. The damage corresponds to the collapse of wooden panels (Fig. 6) and the fill or plaster. Constructions with a concrete fill showed good performance, suffering only cracking at the contact between the concrete blocks and the timber members of the panels. FIGURE 4 Stone masonry house at El Ingenio [DIC, 1958]. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 439 (v) Confined masonry houses performed quite well. In this type of construction the masonry walls are confined either totally or partially by vertical- and horizon- tal-reinforced concrete elements (pilares and cadenas), which restrict the out-of-plane displacements of the masonry walls. The behavior of these struc- tures was quite good, even in the epicentral zone, especially when the verti- cally reinforced concrete elements (pilares) confined the masonry wall completely (Fig. 7). The masonry walls are built with quarried stones cemented with mortar. (vi) Other types of constructions in the area include quincha houses, built with branches and covered with mud plaster (Fig. 8), as well as wooden constructions. The latter showed a good resistance to damage. 2.2. Seismic Intensities Intensity values are determined based on the distribution of damage to different types of structures, which are classified according to their vulnerability (Table 2). An adaptation of the MSK-64 intensity scale [Karnik et al., 1984], considering the characteristics of FIGURE 5 Damage in quarry stone masonry buildings at Las Melosas [DIC, 1958]. Left: Vertical cracks in walls at intersections; right: Collapsed wall. FIGURE 6 Railway station at El Volcn [DIC, 1958]. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 440 S. A. Sepulveda et al. Chilean buildings [Monge and Astroza, 1989] is used. This scale is based on the damage distribution for each vulnerability class as shown in Table 3. Damage grades for different types of buildings are defined in Tables 4 and 5 (both based on Monge and Astroza, 1989). The intensities are equivalent to those of the Modified Mercalli Intensity scale, MMI [Levret and Mohammadiorun, 1984; Barrientos, 1980]. The adapted MSK-64 scale has been used in several works related with the evaluation of the Chilean earthquake effects and in the seismic zonation of Chilean cities [Astroza and Monge, 1991]. FIGURE 7 Confined masonry buildings at El Volcn [DIC, 1958]. FIGURE 8 Quincha house near El Volcn [DIC,1958]. TABLE 2 Definition of vulnerability classes Vulnerability Class Type of Structure A Stone masonry and adobe houses B Stone masonry with cement mortar. Unreinforced masonry houses. Braced wooden frame infill with adobe. C Reinforced and confined masonry houses. D Confined masonry houses built according to NCh2123 Chilean code. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 441 According to the observed damage in unreinforced and confined quarry stone masonry buildings and buildings with braced wooden frame infill with adobe, and applying the Monge and Astroza [1989] methodology, we estimate MSK values as follows: TABLE 3 Intensity degree based on damage distribution according to MSK [Monge and Astroza, 1989] Intensity Degree Class A Class B Class C Class D % Damage % Damage % Damage % Damage 5 5 1 100 0 100 0 100 0 95 0 6 5 2 5 1 100 0 100 0 50 1 95 0 45 0 7 5 4 50 2 50 1 100 0 50 3 35 1 50 0 35 2 15 0 10 1 8 5 5 5 4 5 3 5 2 50 4 50 3 50 2 50 1 35 3 35 2 35 1 45 0 10 2 10 1 10 0 9 50 5 5 5 5 4 5 3 35 4 50 4 50 3 50 2 15 3 35 3 35 2 35 1 10 2 10 1 10 0 10 75 5 50 5 5 5 5 4 25 4 35 4 50 4 50 3 15 3 35 3 35 2 10 2 10 1 11 100 5 75 5 50 5 5 5 25 4 50 4 50 4 35 3 12 100 5 100 5 100 5 TABLE 4 Description of damage in stone, adobe, or masonry buildings [after Monge and Astroza, 1989] Damage Grade Description 0 No damage 1 Fine cracks in stucco 2 Fine cracks in walls. Horizontal cracks in chimneys, tanks, pediment, cornice. Vertical cracks at intersection of walls. 3 Large and deep cracks in walls. Inclination or falling of chimneys, ped- iment, cornice. Vertical cracks in walls at intersections and some lean out-of-plumb. Diagonal cracks on walls are larger than 3 mm. 4 Partial collapse or total failure of a wall. 5 Total collapse. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 442 S. A. Sepulveda et al. 1. El Volcn: 9. This value was obtained considering the performance of stone masonry without reinforcements and infill-braced wooden frame constructions vulnerability class B. They suffered very heavy damage [Piderit, 1961]. In addition, confined masonry structures suffered slight damage. In agreement with the damage observed during the Tarapac earthquake of June 2005 [Astroza et al., 2005a] and the central Chile earthquake of Llolleo 1985, the damage at El Volcn railway station (Fig. 6) corresponds to an intensity degree greater than 8. 2. Las Melosas: 8 to 9. This value is a conservative estimate considering that the earthquake of the 28 th of August of 1958 produced heavy damage that forced the evacuation of the place [El Mercurio, 1958b]. The constructions with greatest damage were stone masonry houses without reinforcements. 3. Los Queltehues: 8. Reports and photographs indicate the damage in the village church and houses inhabited by families of the hydroelectric plant employees. The damage of the confined masonry houses built a few years before the earthquake is slight; suggesting that the intensity here was smaller than in El Volcn and Las Melosas. 4. San Alfonso area. According to Piderit [1961], structural damage extended to San Alfonso, with 20% of the constructions showing heavy damage. Considering the type of buildings in the zone, this percentage represents an intensity degree equal to 7. Piderit [1961] reported that in El Romeral, San Gabriel, and El Ingenio 50% of the houses suffered heavy damage, which represents an intensity degree between 7 and 8. 5. Lo Valds. In this area upstream of El Volcn little damage was reported, which corresponds to an intensity degree of 7, considering that the constructions are sin- gle and two-storey unreinforced stone masonry buildings. In agreement with the damage observed in the Tarapac earthquake of June 2005, the behavior observed in Lo Valds corresponds to an intensity degree of 7 [Astroza et al., 2005a]. 6. Considering that the damage studies of Chilean earthquakes [Daz, 2001; Astroza et al., 2005a] indicate that rock falls take place when the intensity is equal to or greater than 6.0 and that rock falls were observed down to the sector of Maitenes hydroelectric plant, the limit of the damage zone (I 6) is inferred to have been in the vicinity of the Colorado River. Intensities at Puente Alto, La Obra and Las Melosas, which are outside of the damage zone, are estimated to have been less than 6. In Santiago the intensity was 5 [Kausel, E., pers. comm., 2006]. Our intensity assignments are summarized in Table 6. All the places are located along El Volcan and Maipo river valleys, because they were the only inhabited areas. Figure 9 shows the isoseismal curves obtained from these intensities, in terms of MSK intensity scale. Given the linearity of the geographical distribution of the investigated localities and TABLE 5 Description of damage for buildings with braced wooden frame infill with adobe [after Monge and Astroza, 1989] Damage Grade Description 0 No damage 1 Fine- vertical and diagonal cracks in plaster 2 Fall-down of plaster 3 Fall-down of the fill 4 Partial or total fall-down of a braced wooden frame 5 Total collapse D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 443 the absence of further data, the isoseismal curves are assumed to be concentric. This is an oversimplification, particularly for places located on hard rock, as the intensities were measured along the valleys, where some amplification is expected, especially in the far- field. However, given the geological characteristics of the soil deposits in the zone [Chiu, 1991], this amplification is not expected to be very significant. Therefore, the extension of the isoseismals to rock locations in Fig. 9 can be taken only as a first and conservative approximation. 3. Earthquake-triggered Landslides and Peak Ground Acceleration Estimates 3.1. Landslides Triggered by the 1958 Earthquakes As mentioned previously, the 1958 earthquakes triggered an important number of land- slides, particularly rock falls, which produced considerable damage to engineering structures. Besides rock falls, some slumps were also triggered by the earthquakes. The largest two of these landslides, which are well preserved until now, were investigated from an engineering geological perspective to estimate the levels of strong shaking required to produce them. So far, there are no instrumental records of strong ground motion (accelerograms) in the epicentral areas of shallow crustal earthquakes in Chile. For this reason an indirect approach, studying earthquake-triggered landslides and TABLE 6 Intensities of the earthquakes Place Latitude Longitude Elevation (m s.n.m.) I Puente Alto 33 36 70 34 650 56 Las Vizcachas 33 36 70 31 780 56 La Obra 33 35 70 27 720 56 El Canelo 33 34 70 26 1300 6 El Manzano 33 35 70 24 1300 6 Guayacn 33 35 70 23 963 67 San Jos de Maipo 33 38 70 22 962 67 El Melocotn 33 42 70 20 1016 7 San Alfonso 33 43 70 17 2500 7 El Ingenio 33 46 70 15 2200 78 San Gabriel 33 47 70 15 1900 78 Los Queltehues 33 47 7013 1365 8 Las Melosas 33 51 70 13 2800 89 El Volcn 33 49 70 10 1416 9 Lo Valds 33 51 70 03 2500 7 Santiago 33 27 70 38 600 5 Valparaso (1) 33 02 71 38 150 3 San Felipe (1) 32 45 70 43 630 3 La Calera (1) 32 45 7112 450 3 Sewell (1) 34 05 70 23 2600 4 Rancagua (1) 34 10 70 45 500 3 Curic (1) 34 59 71 14 200 3 Curepto (1) 35 05 72 01 9 3 Talca (1) 35 25 71 35 90 3 Cauquenes (1) 35 58 72 19 161 2 (1) El Mercurio newspaper, 1958a. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 444 S. A. Sepulveda et al. using world records of shallow earthquakes for their analyses, is used to estimate ranges of ground accelerations in the epicentral area. This is an engineering approach that will provide an idea of the expected levels of ground motion in the areas of greater damage until instrumental data can be taken in future events. The investigated land- slides, which may be classified as soil slumps [Keefer, 1984], are Las Cortaderas land- slide, located in the Yeso Valley, and El Manzanito landslide, located in the Maipo Valley, about 9 km north and 6 km south of the main shock epicenter, respectively (Figs. 2 and 9). 3.1.1. Las Cortaderas Landslide. During the 4 th of September 1958 Las Melosas earth- quake, a landslide of ca. 1520 10 6 m 3 was triggered within the mass of an ancient mega-landslide located on the eastern flank of the Yeso Valley [Flores et al., 1960; Chiu, 1991]. The 1958 landslide blocked the Yeso River, forming a small lake that lasted for a few years, until the natural dam was broken by the river [Borde, 1966]. The extent and morphology of the 1958 landslide can be recognized by an analysis of recent aerial photographs and comparison with photographs taken before the earthquake [Casas et al., 2005]. The 1958 scarp has a concave shape, and is about 800 m long and 100 m high, while the deposits formed an irregular, hummocky morphology (Fig. 10). The surface area covered by the landslide exceeds 4 10 5 m 2 . Since the 1958 slump was triggered in an old landslide mass, the geology of both the old and new landslides is the same, com- posed of volcanic rock blocks up to several meters in diameter within a soil mass of silty and clayey sand, according to granulometric analyses [Casas, 2006]. Some rock blocks form morphological irregularities along the 1958 scarp. Hence, the landslide is not purely rotational and the shear surface is not entirely composed of soil. However, the landslide geomorphology and the volumetric preponderance of soil materials allow it to be modelled as a soil slump for stability analyses. FIGURE 9 Intensity map for the 1958 Las Melosas main shock. The isoseismal are assumed as concentric as a first approximation. As the intensities were estimated along the valleys, on rock formations the isoseismals are in dotted line showing that they are a conservative estimate. Geological symbology is explained in Fig. 2. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 445 3.1.2. El Manzanito Landslide. A second, smaller landslide of ca. 4 10 6 m 3 was induced on the eastern flank of the Maipo Valley south of the town of Las Melosas (Fig. 2). According to Rosenberg [1958] and Piderit [1961], most of the damage in this area includ- ing the landslide was produced by the 28 th of August 1958 earthquake, as it was recognized during a field assessment carried out previous to the 4 th of September main shock [Rosenberg, 1958]. The landslide is a typical slump with a concave scarp, and the presence of back-scarps in the landslide deposit, which covers an area of about 2 10 5 m 2 . It was triggered in the tip of an alluvial fan, and delimited by two gullies that acted as landslide flanks (Fig. 10). The material is sandy with around 10% of silt and clay [Casas, 2006]. The deposits did not reach the river, but partially covered a local fluvial terrace. The landslide destroyed the Maipo hydroelectric channel that carried water to the Quelte- hues power station, and displaced electricity posts [Flores et al., 1960], remains of which can still be seen at the site. 3.2. Peak Ground Acceleration Estimates 3.2.1. Landslide Models. From the information collected during geological and geomor- phological surveys, representative cross-sections of the Las Cortaderas and El Manzanito landslides were prepared for the performance of 2-D stability analyses. The topography prior to the landslides was estimated from the surrounding topography, aerial photographs taken before the earthquake, and balanced reconstruction from the present day topography. The shape of the shear surface was estimated from topographic maps, compass measure- ments of the landslide scarps, survey of aerial photographs, field observations of the landslide deposits, and a DGPS survey in El Manzanito landslide. The water table was assessed from field observations and comparison of meteorological data from 1958 with present day conditions. Different possible alternatives of the shear surface and water table level were tested by Casas [2006]. In this article the models which returned the most realistic results are presented. The maximum estimated depths of the rupture surfaces are about 50 m for Las Cortaderas and 20 m for El Manzanito. Geotechnical parameters of the shear surfaces were estimated from in-situ density tests and direct shear laboratory tests of soil samples collected from the landslide scarps (Table 7). Both soils present a relatively high friction angle. For nonsaturated samples, the soil retrieved from El Manzanito devel- oped a cohesion of 30 KPa, whereas for Las Cortaderas the value was close to 4 KPa. For saturated conditions, the cohesion in both cases drops to around zero. The 1958 FIGURE 10 Left: Las Cortaderas landslide, view from the NW. Right: Front view of El Manzanito landslide. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 446 S. A. Sepulveda et al. earthquake occurred at the end of a rainy winter [Casas, 2006], in areas which are partially covered by snow during the winter. Therefore, it was assumed for the analyses that the soil was nearly saturated at the time of the earthquake. 3.2.2. Stability Back Analyses. The stability of the slopes modeled for both landslides was investigated. As a first step, pseudostatic analyses using commercial software were performed, using the Bishop method. The critical acceleration required to obtain a factor of safety of 1.0 was computed, assuming three possible cases: with a vertical acceleration (A v ) equal to zero; with a horizontal acceleration (A h ) equal to twice the vertical accelera- tion; and with a vertical acceleration equal to the horizontal acceleration. The latter condition was investigated due to reports of high vertical accelerations in the epicentral area. The critical accelerations obtained for each case are shown in Table 8. To estimate the accelerations during the earthquakes the method proposed by Newmark [1965], based on an analogy of a rigid block sliding on an inclined plane, was used. The analysis consists of the calculation of the cumulative permanent displacement of the sliding mass (called Newmark displacement) through double integration of the parts of the acceleration time history that exceed the horizontal critical acceleration. This value can be compared with threshold displacements considered to cause catastrophic failure. These threshold values for coherent soil slides are normally about 10 cm [Wilson and Keefer, 1985]. This value is typically chosen to represent critical ground displacement that causes damaging macroscopic movement [Jibson and Keefer, 1993]. However, the 10 cm value applies better for minor ground adjustment of the landslide mass. For deep-seated landslides with greater accommodation of displacement before catastrophic failure, the threshold values can be significantly higher [Murphy and Mankelow, 2004]. The ground adjustment of the studied landslides can be assumed as low, from field observations and due to the partly translational nature of the Cortaderas landslide and the small size and depth of the Manzanito landslide. TABLE 7 Geotechnical parameters estimated for the shear surfaces of Las Cortaderas and El Manzanito landslides, based on geotechnical tests, used for slope stability analyses [after Casas, 2006] Las Cortaderas El Manzanito In-situ natural unit weight [kN/m 3 ] 18.0 17.9 Cohesion, saturated conditions[kPa] 0.0 0.0 Friction angle [] 40 41 TABLE 8 Critical accelerations for landsliding obtained from pseudostatic analyses for different ratios of A h
versus A v Landslide A h vs. A v Critical A h [g] Las Cortaderas A v = 0 0.29 Las Cortaderas A h = 2A v 0.26 Las Cortaderas A h = A v 0.23 El Manzanito A v = 0 0.34 El Manzanito A h = 2A v 0.27 El Manzanito A h = A v 0.22 D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 447 Neither for the 1958 earthquakes nor for other Chilean shallow earthquakes are there acceleration instrumental records in the epicentral area. Therefore, the analyses were per- formed for a series of world records of strike-slip focal mechanism, and focal distance and magnitude similar to the 1958 earthquakes (Table 9). The records were then scaled until the Newmark displacement exceeded the threshold value of 10 cm. The maximum accel- erations of the scaled records return a range for the peak ground acceleration (PGA) values that would resemble the PGA of the earthquakes at the landslide sites. The analyses were performed with the critical accelerations obtained from the pseudostatic analyses for all three cases of vertical to horizontal acceleration ratios considered. The analyses assume that each landslide was triggered by a single earthquake, which is known for the Manza- nito landslide. There is no way to know which of the three shocks of the 4 th of September earthquake triggered the Las Cortaderas landslide, or whether the displacement occurred in a single shock or it was accumulated. In this case, the results would be conservative. Because of these uncertainties, the results of the analyses return a range of accelerations rather than a single value. The range of peak ground accelerations obtained with this method is summarized in Table 10. A second approach was the use of the Arias Intensity (I A ) [Arias, 1970] of the same records from the world database and its comparison with the Newmark displacement (D N ) TABLE 9 Ground motions used for acceleration estimates with Newmark analyses [from database in Jibson and Jibson, 2003] Earthquake Station Mw PGA [g] Focal Distance [km] Arias Intensity [m/s] Mean Period [s] Morgan Hill, 1984 AND-250 6.2 0.42 18.7 0.68 0.43 Morgan Hill, 1984 HVR-240 6.2 0.31 9.7 0.87 0.62 Imperial Valley 1979 BCR-140 6.5 0.59 12.0 3.90 0.49 Imperial Valley 1979 BCR-230 6.5 0.79 12.0 6.00 0.47 Imperial Valley 1979 SHP-270 6.5 0.51 17.8 2.74 0.34 Superstition Hills 1987 SM8045 6.5 0.73 18.4 3.81 0.33 Superstition Hills 1987 SM8135 6.5 0.90 18.4 6.76 0.40 Superstition Hills 1987 PTS-315 6.5 0.52 21.3 3.04 0.65 Kobe, Japan 1995 NIS-090 6.9 0.50 23.5 2.27 0.53 Kobe, Japan 1995 NIS-000 6.9 0.51 23.5 3.35 0.49 Duzce, Turkey 1999 DZC-270 7.1 0.54 13.8 2.93 0.82 Duzce, Turkey 1999 VO-000 7.1 0.97 25.2 9.98 0.30 TABLE 10 Results of Newmark analyses, showing the range of PGA values obtained from application of Newarks method to the records presented in Table 9 Landslide A h vs. A v Critical A h [g] PGA range from Newmark analyses[g] Las Cortaderas A v = 0 0.29 0.701.15 Las Cortaderas A h = 2A v 0.26 0.661.10 Las Cortaderas A h = A v 0.23 0.601.00 El Manzanito A v = 0 0.34 0.791.30 El Manzanito A h = 2A v 0.27 0.671.12 El Manzanito A h = A v 0.22 0.580.99 D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 448 S. A. Sepulveda et al. given by the formula obtained by Jibson et al. [2000] based on a database of landslides, most of them from California: In this case, the formula allows computing the required Arias intensity (in m/s) so that the value of D N (in cm) is equal to 10 cm, given a critical acceleration (in g) that is obtained from the pseudostatic analysis of each landslide. The Arias intensity is obtained from the integration of the full accelerogram, therefore it takes into account the frequency content of the ground shaking. For each studied case, the record with Arias intensity most similar to the required value was scaled until obtaining the threshold displacement, and the PGA of the scaled record was then computed. The results are shown in Table 11. The results of the peak ground acceleration estimates (Tables 10 and 11) show that, depending on the assumption for the horizontal versus vertical acceleration ratio, the PGA varies between about 0.6 and 1.2 g for Las Cortaderas landslides and from 0.6 to 1.3 g for El Manzanito landslide using the Newmark method. With the application of the Jibson et al. [2000] equation and calculation of the Arias intensity, the peak acceleration values are around 0.91.0 g for both cases, showing much less dispersion due to the pre-selection of one record using the Arias intensity criterion. These are rough estimates due to the uncertainties and assumptions of the applied geotechnical models. The uncertainty of sta- bility analysis of earthquake-triggered landslides is usually high due to a great number of factors that are difficult to constrain [Murphy et al., 2002]. Therefore these results are just an approximation. Despite this, the results are consistent with reports of very high acceler- ations in the epicentral area. After the earthquakes the effects of large accelerations both horizontal and vertical were observed: several railway wagons at the El Volcan railway station jumped out of the tracks from their original position and an unanchored five HP electric motor was overturned [Flores et al., 1960]. The results within the context of shal- low earthquakes in Chile are discussed in the next section. 4. Discussion 4.1. Intensity and Acceleration Attenuation Relationships 4.1.1. Intensity attenuation. To evaluate the impact of shallow earthquakes on regional seismic hazard, we compare the intensity attenuation inferred for this sequence with that inferred for other shallow earthquakes in Chile, in Mendoza, Argentina, at the same lati- tude of Santiago, and in California. log D = 1.521 log I 1.993 log A 1.546 N A c (3.1) TABLE 11 Estimated peak accelerations and scaling factors to obtain the required Arias Intensity (I A *) for a Newmark displacement of 10 cm according to Eq. (3.1) Landslide Ac [g] I A * [m/s] Scaled Record Scaling Factor PGA [g] Las Cortaderas 0.23 6.88 SM8135 1.01 0.91 Las Cortaderas 0.26 8.08 SM8135 1.09 0.98 Las Cortaderas 0.29 9.32 VO000 0.98 0.95 El Manzanito 0.22 6.49 SM8135 0.98 0.88 El Manzanito 0.27 8.49 VO000 0.92 0.89 El Manzanito 0.34 11.48 VO000 1.08 1.05 D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 449 Figure 11 shows that the estimated intensity of Las Melosas 1958 earthquakes is strong in the epicentral area, but the intensity value is reduced quickly from 9 to 6 over a distance of just 40 km. Furthermore, the Barrientos intensity attenuation relationship for Chile [Barrientos, 1980] predicts intensity values greater than those estimated in this study. Barrientos equation does not make a distinction of the type of seismic source, which has been recognized to have a strong effect on the intensity distribution [Chavez and Castro, 1988; Bakun et al., 2002; Astroza et al., 2005b]. Barrientos used available data from 73 Chilean earthquakes with a magnitude equal or greater than 5.4 that occurred from 19061977, a total of 945 intensity values. In Fig. 12 the intensities of Las Melosas 1958, Chusmiza 2001 (Mw = 6.3), Mendoza (Argentina) 1861 (M = 7.0) and Mendoza 1985 (Mw = 5.9) shallow earthquakes are com- pared. The intensity attenuation pattern of the four events is similar, indicating severe dam- age (I = 9) in the epicentral zone. These high intensity values can be associated with a high number of fatalities, for example in the Mendoza 1861 earthquake, which killed approxi- mately 1/3 of the 18,000 inhabitants in the epicentral region [Zamarbide and Castano, 1993]. In Fig. 13, we compare the estimated intensities of Las Melosas 1958 earthquakes with an intensity attenuation relationship inferred for Californian earthquakes [Bakun and Wentworth, 1997]. The Californian relationship overestimates the damage caused by Las Melosas earthquakes, although both trends show a similar shape. When the observed Las Melosas intensity values are compared with the expected values obtained from the intensity attenuation relationship proposed for Californian and Chile earthquakes, it must be considered that these relationships represent the best fit for the central tendency of distance data corresponding to an intensity value. For Las Melosas intensity data, this central value is always under both attenuation curves; in this way, if any scatter of observed intensity value is taken into account the commentaries obtained from Figs. 11 and 13 do not change. 4.1.2. Acceleration Attenuation. Figure 14 shows the results of the peak acceleration estimates from the stability back-analyses of Las Cortaderas and El Manzanito FIGURE 11 Comparison of Las Melosas earthquake intensity data with attenuation relationship for Chile proposed by Barrientos [1980]. l = 1.3844 M 37355 log 10 (D e ) 0.0006 D e + 3.8461 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Epicentral Distance [km] I n t e n s i t y Barrientos [1980] (M = 6.9) El Mercurio [1958a] This study 0 320 300 280 260 240 220 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 450 S. A. Sepulveda et al. landslides. These are compared with other recent shallow crustal earthquakes that occurred in Chile (2001 Chusmiza earthquake and 2004 Curic earthquake) and Colombia (1999 Quindio earthquake), and with attenuation relationships proposed for shallow crustal earthquakes based on Californian strong motion data [Sadigh et al., 1997]. It can be observed that all the Chilean as well as the Colombian records and the estimated PGA for the 1958 Las Melosas seismic sequence, are consistently higher than the expected accelerations using the Californian data, for both rock and deep soil sites (defined as soil FIGURE 12 Comparison of strong shallow Chilean earthquake intensity data with data of Mendoza 1861 and Mendoza 1985 earthquakes. 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Epicentral Distance [km] I n t e n s i t y Las Melosas 1958 (M = 6.9) Mendoza 1985 (Mw = 5.9) Mendoza 1861 (M = 7.0) Chusmiza 2001 (Mw = 6.3) 0 340 320 300 280 260 240 220 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 FIGURE 13 Comparison of Las Melosas earthquake intensity data with attenuation relationship proposed by Bakun and Wentworth [1997]. Bakun et al. [1997] (M = 6.9) El Mercurio [1958b] This study L BAKUN = 5.07 + 1.09 M 3.69 log 10 (D e ) 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Epicentral Distance [km] I n t e n s i t y 0 320 300 280 260 240 220 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 451 depths exceeding 20 m). The Chilean soils are generally stiffer than Californian soils, with higher shear wave velocities; therefore accelerations somewhere between the rock and soil curves should be expected, which is only observed for a couple of far-field records. The chart confirms the observations by Ruiz and Saragoni [2004] and Campos et al. [2005] that the peak accelerations from Chilean earthquakes are not well represented by attenua- tion relationships based on data from elsewhere, the Chilean accelerations being generally higher. Campos et al. [2005] also concluded that the Chilean shallow earthquake high frequency content is greater than those observed for the Kobe (1995) and Northridge (1994) acceleration earthquake records. The estimated PGAs from the landslide analyses contribute near-field values, not available from instrumental data of Chilean shallow crustal earthquakes. They confirm the tendency suggested by the instrumental records, although the values obtained from the different slope stability methods described above are somewhat higher than the general tendency. This small difference may be attributed to the inherent uncertainty of the geotechnical methods applied for the acceleration estimates. 5. Conclusions We conclude that strong, shallow Chilean earthquakes generate high seismic intensities that would rise to about 9 (MSK Scale) in the epicentral zone when the earthquake magnitude is FIGURE 14 Comparison of peak ground accelerations estimated from landslide analyses with data of acceleration records of recent shallow earthquakes in Chile and Colombia, and attenuation relationships proposed for rock and deep soil sites for strike-slip shallow crustal earthquakes by Sadigh et al. [1997] based on Californian data. Dots show the aver- age PGA obtained from the application of the Jibson et al. [2000] relationship of Newmark Displacement and Arias intensity (Eq. 3.1), whereas the bars show the range of peak accelerations obtained from direct Newmark analyses of shallow earthquakes world data (Table 10). Rupture distance was approximated to hypocentral distance where the rupture surface is not defined. Modified from Campos et al. [2005]. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 452 S. A. Sepulveda et al. about 7.0, without the presence of particularly unfavorable local conditions that would produce greater damage due to site effects. The estimation of peak accelerations based on back-analysis of two landslides is shown to be an appropriate methodology, where different approaches allow a narrow range of possible values of PGA to be constrained effectively. According to this study and Campos et al. [2005], the maximum ground acceleration registered in the Chilean, Argentine, and Colombian shallow earthquakes is greater than the value obtained with the equation for the shallow earthquakes of California. For the Chilean earthquakes, this does not mean greater damage because the high-frequency contents of the Chilean earthquakes attenuate the effect of the high accelerations [Campos et al., 2005; Saragoni et al., 2005]. This situation was verified with the buildings located in the damage zone of Las Melosas 1958 earthquakes that partially fulfilled the requirements of the Chilean seismic code. Currently, the Chilean seismic building codes only consider the seismic hazard from interplate thrust events with coastal epicenters. To quantify the seismic hazard of shallow Chilean earthquakes, it would be necessary to map active geological faults and to install instruments in the zones where these faults are located. With this information, the seismic zones proposed in the seismic code could be revised. In addition, considering the expected maximum intensities for large shallow earthquakes (M = 7.0), the Chilean seismic code must forbid the construction of adobe and masonry buildings with little reinforcement. It is also necessary to introduce a factor that considers the near source effect. The results presented here will allow a better assessment of the seismic hazard from crustal faults along the Chilean Andes, some of which are located very close to important urban centres located in the Central Depression. One such fault is the San Ramon Fault along the boundary of the Santiago basin, which might potentially trigger earthquakes of magnitudes exceeding 6.0 [Rauld et al., 2006]. The intensity and peak acceleration values and attenuation patterns obtained from this study may be used in microzonation and hazard assessment studies around suspected active faults in the Chilean subduction environment. Acknowledgments This study was funded by the Millenium Initiative P02033-F Nucleus of Seismotectonics and Seismic Hazard. The authors acknowledge the AES Gener Hydroelectrical Company for permitting access to its premises. Many thanks to Dr R. Thiele, C. Valderas, R. Rauld, and A. Ormeo for their collaboration during the fieldwork, Dr. J.P. Le Roux for his revision of the draft article, and three anonymous reviewers for their thoughtful comments. References Abele, G. [1984] Derrumbes de montaas y morrenas en los Andes chilenos, Revista de Geografa de Norte Grande 2 (11), 1730. Alvarado, P., Barrientos, S., Saez, M., Astroza, M., and Beck, S. [2007] Source and damage study of the historic 1958 Las Melosas crustal earthquake, Chile, and its tectonic implications, Phys- ics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors, Special Issue Earthquakes in subduction zones: a mul- tidisciplinary approach submitted. Armijo, R. and Thiele, R. [1990] Active faulting in northern Chile: ramp stacking and lateral decoupling along a subduction plate boundary?, Earth and Planetary Science Letters 98, 4061. Arias, A. [1970] A measure of earthquake intensity, in Seismic Design for Nuclear Power Plants, Hansen, R. J., ed. MIT Press, pp. 438483. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 453 Astroza, A. and Monge, R. [1991] Seismic microzones in the city of Santiago. Relation damage- geological unit, Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on Seismic Zonation, Vol. III, pp 595601, Stanford, California. Astroza, M., Moroni, M. O., Norambuena, A., and Astroza, R. [2005a] Learning from Earthquakes: Intensities and damage distribution in the June 2005 Tarapac, Chile, Earthquake, EERI Special Earthquake Report, November 2005. Astroza, M., Sandoval, M., and Kausel, E. [2005b] Estudio comparativo de los efectos de los sismos chilenos de subduccin del tipo intraplaca de profundidad intermedia, Proc. IX Jornadas Chilenas de Sismologa e Ingeniera Antissmica, Paper A0105, Concepcin, Chile. Bakun, W. H. and Wentworth, C. M. [1997] Estimating earthquake location and magnitude from seismic intensity data, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 87 (6), 15021521. Bakun, W. H., Haugerud, R. A., Hopper, M. G., and Ludwin, R. S. [2002] The December 1872 Washington State Earthquake, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 92 (8), 32393258. Barrientos, S. [1980] Regionalizacin ssmica de Chile MSc. Thesis, Geophysics Department, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile. Barrientos, S., Vera, E. [1995] Shallow seismicity and crustal structure in Central Chile, Proceed- ings of the XXI International Union of Geodesy and Geophysics General Assembly, Boulder, Colorado. Barrientos, S., Vera, E., Alvarado, P. Monfret, T. [2004] Crustal seismicity in central Chile, Journal of South American Earth Sciences 16, 759768. Borde, J. [1966] Las incidencias cataclsmicas en la morfologa de los Andes de Santiago, Informaciones Geogrficas, XX, 725. Campos, J., Hatzfeld, D., Madariaga, R., Lopez, G., Kausel, E., Zollo, A., Iannacone, G., Fromm, R., Barrientos, S. and Lyon-Caen, H. [2002] A Seismological study of the 1835 Seismic gap in South Central Chile, Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interior 132, 177195. Campos, J., Ruiz, S., Perez, A., Ruiz, J., Kausel, E., Thiele, R., Saragoni, R., and Seplveda, S. A. [2005] Terremotos corticales de Las Melosas 1958, Chusmiza 2001 y Curic 2004: Un anlisis comparativo de los terremotos de Northridge 1994 y Kobe 1995. Nuevos antecedentes para el peligro ssmico de Chile, Proc. IX Jornadas Chilenas de Sismologa e Ingeniera Antissmica, Paper A0128, Concepcin, Chile, Casas, E. A., Seplveda, S. A., Campos, J., and Rebolledo, S. [2005] Estudio del terremoto de Las Melosas de 1958 mediante caracterizacin de deslizamientos cossmicos, Proc. IX Jornadas Chilenas de Sismologa e Ingeniera Antissmica, Paper A0106, Concepcin, Chile. Casas, E. A. [2006] Anlisis de deslizamientos cossmicos asociados al terremoto de Las Melosas, 1958, Thesis, Geology Department, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile. Castano, J. C. and Castano, M. V. [1997] Anlisis comparativo de los terremotos ocurridos en la provincia de Mendoza, Argentina, y su relacin con la distribucin del peligro ssmico. Proc. VII Jornadas Chilenas de Sismologa e Ingeniera Antissmica, vol.1, pp. 4756, La Serena, Chile. Chavez M. and Castro, R. [1988] Attenuation of modified Mercalli intensity with distance in Mexico, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America 78 (6), 18751884. Chiu, D. [1991] Geologa del relleno cuaternario de las hoyas de los ros Yeso, Volcn y Maipo, este ltimo entre las localidades de Guayacn y Los Queltehues, Regin Metropolitana. Thesis, Geology Dept., University of Chile, Santiago, Chile. Daz, O. [2001] Estudio de los efectos de las condiciones locales en el terremoto de Punitaqui de 1997, Thesis, Civil Engineering Department, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile. DIC [1958] Archivo Fotogrfico, Divisin Estructura-Construccin-Geotecnia, Departamento de Ing- eniera Civil, Facultad de Ciencias Fsicas y Matemticas, Universidad de Chile, Santiago, Chile. El Mercurio [1958a] Diario El Mercurio, Santiago, Chile, 5 th of September. El Mercurio [1958b] Diario El Mercurio, Santiago, Chile, 29 th of August. Flores, R., Arias, S., Jenshke, V., and Rosemberg, L. A. [1960]. Engineering aspect of the earth- quakes in the Maipo Valley, Chile, in 1958. Proceedings of 2 nd World Conference in Earth- quake Engineering, Japan, 1, pp. 409431. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 454 S. A. Sepulveda et al. Fock, A. [2005]. Cronologa y tectnica de la exhumacin en el Negeno de los Andes en Chile Central entre los 33y 34S. MSc. Thesis, Geology Department, University of Chile. Herv, M. [1987] Movimiento sinistral en el Cretcico Inferior de la Zona de Falla Atacama al norte de Paposo (24S), Chile, Revista Geolgica de Chile (31), 3742. INN [1996] NCh433.Of96 Diseo ssmico de edificios, Norma Chilena Oficial. Instituto Nacional de Normalizacin, Santiago, Chile. Jibson, R. W., Harp, E. L., and Michael, J. A. [2000] A method for producing digital probabilistic seismic landslide hazard maps, Engineering Geology 58, 271289. Jibson, R. W. and Jibson, M. W. [2003]. Java programs for using Newmarks method and simpli- fied decoupled analysis to model slope performance during earthquakes. U.S. Geological Service, Open-File Report 03005,Version 1.1, CD-Rom. Jibson, R. W. and Keefer, D. K. [1993] Analysis of the seismic origin of landslides: examples from the New Madrid seismic zone, Geological Society of America Bulletin 105, 521536. Karnik, V., Schenkova, Z., and Schenk, V. [1984] Vulnerability and the MSK Scale, Engineering Geology 20, 161168. Keefer, D. K. [1984] Landslides caused by earthquakes, Geological Society of America Bulletin, 95, 406421. Lamana, A. [1963] Fallas de juntas de hormigonado y de anclajes y empalmes de armaduras en los terremotos de Chile de 1958 y 1960, Proc. I Jornadas Chilenas de Sismologa e Ingeniera Antissmica, vol. 1, Paper B22, Santiago, Chile. Le Roux, J. P., Gmez, C. A., Olivares, D. M., Middleton, H. [2005] Determining the Neogene behavior of the Nazca plate by geohistory analysis, Geology 33 (3), 165168. Levret, A. and Mohammadioun, B. [1984] Determination of seismic reference motion for nuclear sites in France, Engineering Geology 20, 2538. Lomnitz, C. [1960] A study of the Maipo Valley earthquakes of September 4, 1958. Instituto de Geofsica y Sismologa, Universidad de Chile, Publication N 10. Monge, J. and Astroza, M. [1989] Metodologa para determinar el grado de intensidad a partir de los daos, Proc. V Jornadas Chilenas de Sismologa e Ingeniera Antissmica, vol. 1, Santiago, Chile, pp. 483491. Murphy, W. and Mankelow, J. M. [2004] Obtaining probabilistic estimates of displacement on a landslide during future earthquakes, Journal of Earthquake Engineering 8 (1), 133157. Murphy, W., Petley, D. N., Bommer, J., and Mankelow, J. M. [2002] Uncertainty in ground motion estimates for the evaluatioin of slope stability during earthquakes, Quarterly Journal of Engi- neering Geology and Hydrogeology 35, 7178. Naranjo, J. A. [1987] Interpretacin de la actividad cenozoica superior a lo largo de la Zona de Falla Atacama, norte de Chile, Revista Geolgica de Chile (31), 43 56. Newmark, N. [1965] Effects of earthquakes on dams and embankments, Geotechnique 15 (2), 139160. Ormeo, A. [2006]. Geodinmica de la hoya hidrogrfica del ro Maipo en la zona cordillerana de la Regin Metropolitana, MSc. Thesis, Department of Geology, University of Chile. Pardo-Casas, F. and Molnar, P. [1987] Relative motion of the Nazca (Faralln) and South American Plates since late cretaceous time, Tectonics 6(3), 233284. Pardo, M. and Acevedo, P. [1984] Mecanismos de foco en la zona de Chile Central, Tralka 2 (3), 279293. Piderit, E. [1961] Estudios de los sismos del Cajn del Maipo en el ao 1958, Thesis, Civil Engineering Dept., University of Chile, Santiago, Chile. Rauld, R., Vargas, G., Armijo, R., Ormeo, A., Valderas, C., and Campos, J. [2006] Cuantificacin de escarpes de falla y deformacin reciente en el frente cordillerano de Santiago, Proc. XI Chilean Geological Congress, vol. 2, Antofagasta, Chile, pp. 447450. Rosenberg, L. [1958] Informe visita a la zona daada por los terremotos del Cajn del Maipo, Unpublished Report, Civil Engineering Dept., University of Chile, Santiago, Chile. Ruiz, S. and Saragoni, R. [2004] Caractersticas de los acelerogramas y terremotos sudameri- canos, Proc. XXXI Jornadas Sudamericanas de Ingeniera Estructural, Mendoza, Argentina. D o w n l o a d e d
A t :
1 7 : 2 4
1 8
M a y
2 0 1 0 Las Melosas Earthquake: Shallow Seismicity Hazard in Chile 455 Sadigh, K., Chang, C. Y., Egan, J. A., Makdisi, F., and Youngs, R. R. [1997] Attenuation relation- ships for shallow crustal earthquake based on California strong motion data, Seismological Research Letters 68 (1), 180189. Saragoni, G. R., Astroza, M., and Ruiz, S. [2005] Relaciones entre la alta frecuencia caracterstica o cruces por cero de los terremotos chilenos y el dao observado, Proc. IX Jornadas Chilenas de Sismologa e Ingeniera Antissmica, Paper A0113, Concepcin, Chile. Somoza, R. [1998] Updated Nazca (Faralln) South America relative motions during the last 40 My: implications for mountain building in the central Andean region, Journal of South American Earth Sciences 11 (3), 211215. Stern, C., Amini, H., Charrier, R., Godoy, E., Herv, F. and Varela, J. [1984] Petrochemistry and age of rhyolitic pyroclastic flows which occur along the drainage valleys of the Ro Cachapoal (Chile) and the Ro Yaucha and Ro Papagayos (Argentina) Revista Geolgica de Chile (23), 3952. Thiele, R. [1980] Carta Geolgica de Chile 1:250.000. Hoja Santiago, Regin Metropolitana N 39. Instituto de Investigaciones Geolgicas, Santiago, Chile. Wilson, R. C. and Keefer, D. K. [1985]. Predicting areal limits of earthquake-induced landsliding, in Evaluating Earthquake Hazards in Los Angeles, Ziony, J. I., ed., Zamarbide, J. and Castano, J. C. [1993] Analysis of the January 26th, 1985, Mendoza (Argentina) earthquake effects and of their possible correlation with the recorded accelerograms and soil conditions, Tectonophysics 218, 221235. D o w n l o a d e d