APPROVED A

Approved without exception

APPROVED WITH COMMENTS AC
Approved Subject to Incorporation of comments
RETURNED FOR CORRECTION RT
Insufficient Information/ Detail
Resubmit for Approval
REJECTED RJ
Complete redesign required
RECEIVED FOR INFORMATION I
Returned without comments
RECEIVED FOR INFORMATION IC
Returned with comments
any obligations covered under contract
Engineer:
Discipline:
Date:
Note: Approval or comments does not relieve the Contractor of
Pyry Energy
TWO(2) X 500MW
MONG DUONG 1 THERMAL POWER PLANT
David Langhorne
Senior Mec Engineer
5-Mar-13
Pyry Comment
Two(2) x 500MW Mong Duong 1 Thermal Power Plant Project

Dwg. / Doc. Title
Outline Drawing for HP-7
Low Pressure FWH
Dwg. / Doc. No. MD1-0-V-114-01-00004
HDEC DT No. MD1-HDH-EVN-X-1036 Submitted Date 2012.11.02 Rev. B
Pyry TR No. 9A000323-002559 Received Date 2012.11.28
New HDEC DT No. MD1-HDH-EVN-X-2233 Re-Submitted Date 2013.02.05 Rev. C
Status Received for Information Returned with Comments

Page1 / 1
No. Pyrys Comments Contractors Reply / Action
1 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Please refer to general comments on MD1-0-V-
114-01-00001.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Reflected.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Closed.

2 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Review the steam inlet nozzle material. The
skirt design temperature is 490 deg C.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Reflected.
Steam inlet material has been revised from
A106-B to A335-P11.
3 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Clause 6.4.3 of the ERQ states that the HP
Heaters shall be designed to withstand the boiler
feed water pump shut-off pressure. Please
confirm this requirement is met in the heater
calculations.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Boiler Feedwater Pump shut-off pressure is 300
barg. BFP shut-off pressure has been reflected
as tube side design pressure of 300 barg.

4 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
At the key plan, please correct location of HP-7
FWH from Mezzanine floor to Operating floor.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Noted the drawing is for Heater No. 7.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.C>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
HP-6 FWH is on the HP heater floor. Please
check the modified key plan.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Reflected.

5 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Correct the nozzle bevel data table. It appears
to be a cut and paste from MD1-0-V-114-01-
00001.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Reflected.