Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 8

USING VIDEOPHONES AS INTERGENERATIONAL CONNECTIONS FOR

QUALITY OF LIFE ISSUES


Saul B. Troen, Ph.D.
Bramson ORT College
69-30 Austin Street
Forest Hills, New York 11375
USA
stroen@bramsonort.edu

ABSTRACT the other hand, is a vehicle for instant auditory


The videophone can be useful in enhancing the quality of communication. While the sound of a voice can be
life of the elderly and providing a learning experience for comforting, it has its limitations. It does not provide a
youth. Feelings of loneliness and isolation often due to the visual stimulus and face-to-face communication. In
lack of social contact are frequently found in elderly addition, social isolation and loneliness is exacerbated
populations. Loneliness has been described as “such a when older people outlive partners and friends; this adds
painful and frightening experience that people will do to their loneliness and decrease in quality of life. This
practically anything to avoid it.”[1] Many elderly do not means that new and convenient ways must be found to
receive regular visits from friends and family because of help maintain and improve a person’s well being. [4]
distance and time.
Modern videophones can bridge time and space by
Many school children do not have living grandparents and providing visual communication between two locations
therefore miss out on learning the wisdom of the elderly. that have regular telephone lines. The question that begs
New communications technologies provide a variety of an answer is why haven’t videophones become standard
solutions that can address this problem. Moreover, it communication devices to enhance the quality of life of
appears that the bi-directional influence of the elderly and the elderly and the disabled?[5]
youth is a neglected area of research. [2]
Over ten years ago, the CEO of the Greater New York
This presentation sheds light on how videophones can Board of Jewish Education (BJE) underwent a spinal
connect the elderly and school children to improve the fusion that prevented him from leaving home.[6] This
quality of life of the elderly in long term facilities and made it difficult for him to supervise his organization.
help students to understand the vicissitudes of life. While it may not have been unusual for
videoconferencing to be used for telehealth purposes to
KEY WORDS take care of patients, videoconferencing was not popular
Aged, Videophones, Adopt-a-grandparent, Caregiver, as a home-based service to connect the disabled with their
Health offices.[7] A videophone was installed in his home and
another videophone was placed in the board room of the
BJE. This video connection enabled him to better run the
1. INTRODUCTION organization from home because he could see the people
and they could show him their work. The BJE built on
Studies indicate that social interaction, even at a this experience and designed a virtual-classroom that
minimum, is critical for helping to maintain and improve connected school children with their class. The virtual-
a person’s well being. Loneliness and isolation can classroom was then transferred to organizations that
contribute to the need for more intensive care. Yet it addressed the needs of the handicapped and terminally ill.
appears that hardly any attention has been given to using [8]
videoconferencing to eliminate loneliness and isolation.
[3] About three years ago, this presenter conducted a
qualitative study on the impact videophones had on the
Writing letters enables communication between people quality of life of residents in long term care facilities who
who live far from each other, but it is limited in time and did not have regular visits from their families because of
space. Letters do not provide visual or auditory contact. distance. This study was originally designed to last but
Television fills the role of immediacy but does not one month; it lasted for three months because it afforded
provide for reciprocal communication. The telephone, on them an opportunity to see their families.
Based on these experiences, this presenter sought a venue This presentation demonstrates how videophones can be
where an ‘adopt-a-grandparent’ program that utilized used to connect the elderly in long term facilities and
available videophone technology could be established. school children. It shows how the intergenerational
The Bnos Malka Academy of Queens, New York, proved ‘Living and Learning Legacy’ program can improve the
to be the perfect venue because the vice principal of this quality of life of the elderly and at the same time help
private school had had first hand experience in using the school children to understand the history and life that
videophone in a virtual-classroom setting. The virtual- seniors have lived.
classroom had provided her with the opportunity to
complete her degree from her home. Her first-hand We hope that this presentation will spur further study in
experience influenced her decision to find a way to use the use of videophone technology as it applies to
videophones in a community service context. She chose intergenerational communication.
to partner with the Atria of Kew Gardens, New York,
because she frequently visited this residence.
3. METHODS
The BJE helped pave the way for the ‘Living and
Learning Legacy’ program by providing the necessary As mentioned above, this program did not begin as a
equipment. study. This program was designed as a community service
quality of life program. While the program is now in its
third year, this presentation is based on the first two years
2. BACKGROUND of the program.
Numerous studies have been done that measure the Two POTS videophones were provided for the program.
independent and interactive relationships of social support One POTS videophone was placed in the school and
networking on mental and physical health of the elderly. another videophone was placed in the Atria. The
Telehealth studies usually focus on videoconferencing as videophone in the Atria was connected to a TV to provide
a solution for augmenting the health of patients living in a larger picture. In addition, the videophone at the
their own homes or for the exchange of information residence was placed in a public location to eliminate
between different sites. issues of privacy.
The telephone has been used in health care for a century, The videoconference was held every Friday morning. The
and more advanced telecommunications technology has school usually initiated the call. However, an individual
been in use for more than three decades. Despite this resident could also initiate a call. Personnel at the school
history and recent rapid developments in the and at the Atria monitored the videoconference.
telecommunications field, the use of telecommunications
technology to deliver health care remains Before beginning the program, the students were prepared
underdeveloped. in class to understand what it means to be an ‘adopted
grandchild’. They were then shown how to use the
The “Living and Learning Legacy” fills this void. It was videophone, taught how to interview the elderly, and
designed to use videophones to address the issues of write reports and newsletters using the information they
loneliness and isolation of the elderly and the need for obtained.
students to learn from grandparents. The “Living and
Learning Legacy Program” is a contemporary version of The process at the Atria was different. Two one-and-a-
an “Adopt a Grandparent” program. half hour sessions were needed to explain the program to
the Director and develop an approach. The Director of the
Most importantly, the “Living and Learning Legacy” did Atria briefed the social workers about the program and
not begin as a study. However, after two years of they then chose the appropriate residents for participation
operation, it became apparent that the program had in the program.
succeeded beyond expectations and should be shared with
others. We had been interested in enhancing the quality of The social workers decided that the elderly residents
life of the elderly. We were surprised to learn that the should meet the students before seeing the videophone in
students involved in the project learned from the elderly operation. On the day the program began the students
in ways we never anticipated. No one anticipated the presented a play to all the residents. After the play the
depth of the feelings the students would have from their Director of Activities, himself, demonstrated the
encounters with the elderly. Some of the feelings the videophone. He created an enthusiasm by showing the
eighth grade students developed and what they learned residents that they could actually see the people with
were presented as a power point presentation at their whom they would speak.
graduation. Their presentation and writing form the core
of this article.
After the demonstration the students, as a group, were They were excited to learn that they would be among the
introduced to the residents. The students circulated among first to use modern videophones.
the residents in order to find a person with whom they 5. STUDENT PRESENTATION
could bond. Since there were more students than
participating residents several students could adopt the The bonding between the students and the elderly was
same “grandparent.” Therefore a grandparent might have stronger than expected. These feelings became the core of
a group of “grandchildren” from a class. A grandparent their graduation power point presentation. Rather than
also might have “grandchildren” in more than one class. present a summary of the findings we will let the students
After the initial ‘bonding session’ everyone was invited and seniors speak for themselves. We feel that it is more
for refreshments. valuable to present the original thoughts of the students as
they expressed them, because several of the girls were a
It was interesting to observe the initial interaction bit afraid of the elderly. One student wrote that only after
between the residents and students because this was an she began to speak with her adopted grandparent did she
uninhibited meeting. The students had never met the realize that her grandparent had interesting stories to tell,
residents before and therefore had no inkling of their and looked forward to the next meeting.
mannerisms, foibles and past history. The elderly, for
their part, were elated that they could relate their life The class began its power point presentation as follows:
stories to a fresh set of ears.

4. THE PARTICIPANTS

The administration of the Bnos Malka Academy


incorporated this project into its community service
Living Kindness curriculum. The sixth, seventh, and It is noteworthy that the students set the mood for their
eighth grade students were chosen to participate because presentation by expressing their feelings of “happiness,
they are at the age where they began to search for an support, love’ in the opening slides. They wanted
identity. The eight grade girls also decided that their everyone to understand how they viewed their
graduation project would be to present to their parents a relationship with their adopted grandparents.
power point presentation about their experiences as an
“adopted grandchild”. The open expression of these emotions is astounding
because their initial expectations were far removed from
being positive. The following is what they wrote about
their first meeting:

“Many of us expected to be bored at the Atria -


we all were extremely surprised.”

Instead of being bored they had an extraordinary positive


experience that is described in the following slides.

Astonishment THE PAST PATIENCE

We heard tales We heard stories We sat with


of: about: residents and
-War -Wars listened to
-School Days -Foreign countries their stories
-DATES!!!!!! -Different languages even though
-The schools they told the
(guess which -Life lived in the stories many
one we like past times
most)
A senior resident of the Atria videoconferencing with
her “adopted grandchild” at Bnos Malka Academy. The vignettes they related about the stories they heard and
enjoyed are a précis of the life history of the elderly they
The residents, some of whom were afraid of modern adopted. The information the students shared with their
technology, overcame their inhibitions when they realized families and friends shed light on the impact their adopted
that the videophone worked just like a regular telephone. grandparents had on the youth.
The stories that follow are indicative of what the students When it’s a good weather outside she likes to walk. She
considered important enough for them to impart. also has a lot of friends and every body treats her in a
Gunther Ruth Levy very good way. Mrs. R. does not have any children, which
Ruth worked as a secretary is sad, but she is still a nice lady.
WAS IN TWO ARMIES: in a school.
Ruth met her husband My Reflections on our Visit to the Atria
THE HAGANA AND THE through dialing a wrong On the way to the Atria, even though I was a little
BRITISH ARMY number. nervous, I was also a little excited to see my future
Ruth has 1 married son and grandmother. What made this trip special on the way to
WAS A MEDIC 2 grandchildren. the Atria was that I was going with a group of
Ruth is a wonderful person knowledgeable and sweet girls who would show a great,
GREW UP IN GERMANY to be around with. big way to do good deeds.

When we arrived to the Atria, I was looking forward to


seeing my A grandmother, R.L. and there she was sitting
Hellen there like an angel waiting to be pampered by friends. A
Hellen was born in OCCUPATION Hey A., A Hey R., with a big hug.
Ridgewood, NY.
Hellen moved to Then an hour passed by and it was time to go home. I’ll
She is from a family of 7 Manhattan and became a see you, bye with even a bigger hug. But I knew I would
children, 5 girls and 2 boys. secretary for a law firm. see her next week during our weekly phone call.

She herself is the 4th child. Well, what I gained from this R. was that life is a box of
She has no children. cherries, some can be sweet and some can be bitter, you
never know what you’re going to get.
The students ended their presentation with the following
two slides that speak for themselves: A Reflection on our Trip to the Atria
I gained a lot more then I expected on our visit to the
REFLECTIONS Atria. Before I went to the Atria, I was a little impatient
Thank you grandparents for with older people. I gained a lot of knowledge to be more
We think it’s very patient with older people.
important to visit the Atria your stories, love, and care.
residents and learn about I used to hate having to repeat myself twice every time I
their past because it teaches Love, tried to tell an older person something. At the Atria the
us how much they older people were able to understand that it’s hard to keep
accomplished and how Your grandchildren repeating ourselves and they would lean over to hear
much we can accomplish. something.

Sometimes when I’m excited I talk very fast. Older


people’s minds are not always able to process things as
fast as us. So when I talk fast, older people can’
6. STUDENT STORIES understand. I learned to speak slower and in easy
vocabulary in some cases.
The following is taken from some of the student
compositions in which they recorded their feelings. All in all I gained a lot from going to the Atria. The most
important thing I learned about older people was that they
Interview with R.M. love having children come over to visit. I hope that in the
I enjoyed interviewing Mrs. R. because she is a very future we can go back to the Atria.
sweet lady and she and I have a lot in common. She also
is somebody who you would want as a friend. Mrs. R. Reflection on our Trip to the Atria
also taught me a useful lesson. She told me that if I do I learned that it’s very hard to be in the nursing home.
something good for somebody else the good deed will Some people don’t like it there and people can’t do
come back to me. whatever they want to do. Some people don’t like being
next to other people. The people that live there like it
She told me her favorite color is blue when she is bored when we come to them and they also like a lot of
she likes to call boys. She told me that she does not like company. I learned that you have to be very patient and
eating ice cream because it gives her a cold or it gets her they even might say something twice or so many times. I
sick. realized that when we talk to them they have a smile on
their faces and they really enjoy it. They also say a lot of
stories about their life and they are really sad. Some
people wish that we were their grandchildren. The “Living and Learning Legacy” is not designed as a
7. STORIES OF THE ELDERLY telehealth program, yet it does provide a channel for the
enhancement of the quality of life of people who may not
The Residents also has something to say. The following have regular visits from family and friends. In short, the
are some excerpts from an article in Newsday regarding impact of videophone virtual visits as a supplement to in-
the program. person visits addresses the human need for visual
communication and requires further study.
“I have never been part of such a wonderful program. It is
so nice to see young, smiling faces. I have never had the
opportunity to share my life experiences with an BIBLOGRAPHY
individual so eager to hear what I have to say.”
[1] M. Eure, Loneliness Can Make You Sick,
“These are my adopted grandchildren,” said S. brimming http://seniorhealth.about.com/od/mentalemotionalhealth/
with pride…“They are beautiful…smart…intelligent.” a/lonely.htm, (Downloaded from the Internet 11/24/2002)

DA related: “Having young people …tell us things from


their point of view is important and is refreshing.” [2] E. Aphek, A Study in Reciprocity: Minimizing the
Digital Divide and the Intergeneration Gap-Children
“It’s most refreshing,” added H.T., “just to look at these Tutor Seniors at Computer and Internet Skills and Get a
young lovely faces.” Lesson in History, Learning Technology 3, (4), October
(2001)
http://lttf.ieee.org/learn_tech/issues/october2001/#2
8. CONCLUSION
[3] A. Arnaert, Tele-Nursing for the Elderly; The Case of
From the students’ writings it is obvious that they learned Videotelephony, Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare,
a great deal about life from their adopted grandparents. 7(6), 311-316, 2001
For as one student related: “They appreciate more than us.
They teach us to be thankful for what they have. They [4] T. Tsirakis, Social Interaction Improves Mental and
know, because they’ve been through it.” Physical Well Being. Originally published in: Geriatrics
and Aging 2, (5), September/October 1999,
The comments of the elderly also show that they gained www.geriatricsandaging.ca, 2(5) September/October 1999
'grandchildren' who care for them. So close was the bond (Downloaded from Internet, November 5, 2002)
between the two groups that the 'grandparents' asked to
join their 'grandchildren' in school events and attend their [5] F. Hopp, An Evaluation of Home-based Telemedicine
graduation. Service, VA Ann Arbor Health Care System, Ann Arbor,
MI, http://www1.va.gov/hsrd/research/abstracts/TEL_20-
From the statements and attitudes of the elderly it is clear 015.htm (Downloaded from Internet 7/23/05)
that the videophone virtual visits helped to maintain and
enhance the personal relationships that developed [6] R. Friedman, J. Stollerman, D. Mahoney, and L.
between them and the school children. Rozenblyum, The Virtual Visit: Using
Telecommunications Technology to Take Care of
The virtual visits were conducted both on a personal basis Patients, Journal of American Medical Information
and on a class basis. Sometimes the entire class would Association. November; 4 (6): 413–425, 1997
participate in the videophone call as a group. These
community videophone calls had a special significance to [7] K. Stroetmann, T. Erkert, T, HauseTeleDienst-A
the students as well as the elderly. It appears that these CATV-based Interactive Video Service for Elderly
calls helped to create a special class – grandparent People, The Impact of Telemedicine on Health Care
relationship. The residents knew that when one class Management, Volume 64, M.Nerlich and R. Kretschmer
graduated another class would take its place, that they (eds) (Amsterdam, The Netherlands, IOS Press. 1999)
would not be isolated and they would have another
opportunity to relate their stories to a fresh set of ears. [8] S. Cross, Access to information/communication
technology for people with disabilities – conference,
The use of videophones to promote closer relationships 1999, www.dwp.gov.uk/acdet/aict.doc+%22video
and stronger bonds between the elderly and the students (Downloaded from Internet 5/13/2002)
as well as a learning tool for the young warrants further
study. While nothing can replace a face-to-face visit,
videophones can enhance the relationship between people
who cannot maintain regular in-person visits.
<[YQ GQXQTQMX`T
IUPQ[\T[ZQ_
>@:6 GQXQTQMX`T C^[PaO`
<>73 R\ YUNJ\NM ]X Y[X_RMN UX` KJWM`RM]Q GI/**FC IUPQ[\T[ZQ
?BJ 76A9J=9G< I=9:B G:?:8B@@HA=86G=BAF

!KR]$[J]N" _RMNX ]NUNLXVV^WRLJ]RXW\ Y[XM^L]\


OX[ :XVN ENUNQNJU]Q ^\RWP YUJRW XUM ]NUN$
YQXWN \N[_RLN !A@ED"%
:M_e B\Q^M`U[Z_
EQN FWR]NM D]J]N\ 9X_N[WVNW] NWLX^[JPNM <UST DaMXU`e IUPQ[
FWR_N[\JU AQXWN DN[_RLN X_N[ .' bNJ[\ JPX% =GH'G <(-,. F`MZPM^P_
EQN ^KRZ^R]X^\ ADE? ENUNLXVV^WRLJ]RXW\ FQXR'bUQc " EQY[`Q bUQc

;:6GHE:F
Db\]NV R\ J \][J]NPRL J\\N] ]QJ] R\ Y[N\NW]Ub JUU #" 6PVa_`MNXQ \UO`a^Q ]aMXU`e " R^MYQ _\QQP
K^] OX[PX]]NW RW ]QN \QJMX`\ XO 4[XJMKJWM
BZQ 7a``[Z 9U^QO` 6OOQ__
JWM ;D6? OX[ ENUNQNJU]Q% EQN XWN LXW\]JW]
;aZO`U[Z_ M_ M _`MZPM^P 6ZMX[S CT[ZQ c)[ bUPQ[
JVXWP VJWb _J[RJKUN\ RW :XVN ENUNQNJU]Q R\
]QN J_JRUJKRUR]b XO !A@ED" URWN YQXWN \N[_RLN%
BZ'_O^QQZ @MZaMX 8[Z`^[X
6OOQ__[^e =Z`QS^M`U[Z #:ZTMZOQP [\Q^M`U[Z_$
A@ED =RWN GRMNXYQXWN\ J[N XWUb WX` KNRWP
[NLXPWRcNM J\ J UNPR]RVJ]N ]XXU OX[ C^[JU
:XVN ENUNQNJU]Q% EQN KJ\RL :*)+ !A@ED"
GRMNXYQXWN LJW KN \^LLN\\O^UUb RWLX[YX[J]NM
GI/**FC TM_ NQQZ _T[cZ `[ _aN_`MZ`UMXXe ^QPaOQ `TQ
RW]X ]QN P[X`RWP MNVJWM OX[ :XVN ENUN$
O[_` [R OM^Q& UY\^[bQ `TQ ]aMXU`e MZP QM_Q `TQ Na^PQZ
QNJU]Q >XWR]X[RWP% 6NYUXbRWP :*)+ GRMNX$
[R OM^Q R[^ N[`T \^[bUPQ^ MZP \M`UQZ`
YQXWN\ \QX^UM KN J \][J]NPRL XY]RXW# XWN XO CXMUZ BXP GQXQ\T[ZQ FQ^bUOQ #CBGF$
7:A:;=GF

VJWb OX[ :XVN ENUNQNJU]Q A[XP[JV\% #" :M_e B\Q^M`U[Z_4 BZQ Na``[Z PU^QO` O[ZZQO`& [bQ^'
_UfQ WQe\MP " Na``[Z_& /h ?89 _O^QQZ
<>73 QJ\ KNNW J Y[RVN _NWMX[ OX[ ]QR\ Y[XM$
#" =Z`QS^M`U[Z " :ZTMZOQYQZ` \^[S^MY \^[bUPQ_ bMXaQ'
^L] JWM [NUJ]NM ENUNQNJU]Q \^YYX[] \N[_RLN\
MPP ^QMX XURQ _[Xa`U[Z_ R[^ CBGF NM_QP GQXQTQMX`T
OX[ ]QN 6NYJ[]VNW] XO GN]N[JW\ 3OOJR[\ \RWLN
\^[S^MY_
)'',% 3\ J \][J]NPRL YJ[]WN[ RW :XVN ENUN$
QNJU]Q# <>73 QJ\ ]QN TWX`UNMPN JWM [N$
#" =Z`Q^[\Q^M`U[Z cU`T M\\^[bQP GQXQTQMX`T YQM_a^Q'
\X^[LN\ ]X J\\R\] `R]Q WN` Y[XP[JV MN_NUXY$
YQZ` " Y[ZU`[^UZS PQbUOQ_(
VNW] X[ eS^VY$\]J[]f NaR\]RWP Y[XP[JV\%

<>73 K[RWP\ J UN_NU XO ]NLQWRLJU & RW]NP[J]RXW


NaYN[]R\N# Y[XP[JV JWM Y[XSNL] VJWJPNVNW]
NaYN[RNWLN `R]Q :*)+ _RMNXLXWON[NWLRWP ]QJ]
>@:6 i :KC:E=:A8: BA LBHE F=9:

VX\] ]NUNQNJU]Q _NWMX[\ JWM [N\NUUN[\ LJWWX]


VJ]LQ%
@^[ VR\\RXW R\ ]X Y[X_RMN \XURM YN[OX[VJWLN#
X^]\]JWMRWP _JU^N JWM OJR[ Y[RLRWP ]QJ] NWJKUN
X^[ YJ[]WN[\ JWM L^\]XVN[\ ]X JLQRN_N ]X]JU
YN[OX[VJWLN XKSNL]R_N\# \^YYX[]RWP ]QNR[ VR\$
\RXW\ ]XMJb JWM RW ]QN O^]^[N%
<>73 \N]\ ]QN \]JWMJ[M OX[ QRPQ Z^JUR]b JWM
KN\] X_N[JUU _JU^N `R]QRW X^[ LX[N LXVYN]NW$
LRN\% 8X^WMNM RW )''*# X^[ OXL^\ QJ\ KNNW ]X
Y[X_RMN TNb K^\RWN\\ Y[XP[JV VJWJPNVNW]#
Y[XSNL] RVYUNVNW]J]RXW JWM RW\]JUUJ]RXW X_N[$
\RPQ]# ]NUNLXVV^WRLJ]RXW\ MN\RPW JWM RW]NP[J$
]RXW%
<>73 QJ\ XOORLN\ RW DJW 6RNPX# 53 JWM 9RU$
VJW]XW# ?: JWM Y[X_RMN\ \XU^]RXW\ JL[X\\
]QN FWR]NM D]J]N\ ]X RWLU^MN :J`JRR JWM
3UJ\TJ%

>@:6 CT[ZQ4 0*-)-0.'*+..


.- (57 #%$ ;Md4 200)023'3-10
)12304654 +/! ,* "$'$& YNe^ZQ_5WYQMS^[a\(ZQ`
ccc(WYQMS^[a\(ZQ`
GI/**FC IUPQ[\T[ZQ " B\`U[ZMX 6OOQ__[^UQ_
I6 A6G=BA6? 8BAGE68G !I131C'3+.0
I=9:B 86CGHE: " 86@:E6

IUPQ[\T[ZQ i 8M\`a^Q " 8MYQ^M 9QbUOQ_


8[Z`^MO` 6\\^[bQP
CEB9H8G 96G: @B9:? L:F)AB

% GI/**FC #CBGF$ IUPQ['


/&'(&)'', EG,''DA I& G.0.A$0(+-
\T[ZQ

% HF7)E86 8M\`a^Q 9QbUOQ /&'(&)'', G5 FD4( I& G.0.A$0(+-

% 8MYQ^M @UZUC^[ #FT[cZ$ /&'(&)'', <>73 -*'$>5 I& G.0.A$0(+-

<D8 8MYi@UZU, /&'(&)'', DH :B5 ('' @OO 5XW][JL]

% =A FGB8> ) 8BAGE68G =G:@

8[ZZQO`UbU`e& 6aPU[ " CMW >U`_


CEB9H8G 96G: 8[Z`^MO` 6\\^[bQP ' L)A

% BRRUOQ >[ZZQO`[^, /&'(&)'', I& G.0.A$0(+-

8XUZUOUMZ GI@ >U` /&'(&)'', @OO 5XW][JL]


;=?G:EF " :A<6A8:@:AGF

8XUZUOUMZ GIE >U` /&'(&)'', @OO 5XW][JL]

I6 G^MUZQ^ GQ_` >U` /&'(&)'', I& G.0.A$0(+-

% =A FGB8> ) 8BAGE68G =G:@

;UX`Q^_& ?UZQ :ZTMZOQYQZ`


8[Z`^MO`
CEB9H8G 96G: @B9:? 6\\^[bQP L)A

=ZPUbUPaMX ;UX`Q^_ MZP 6PP'[Zg_ R[^ >U` CMW_

% E; :XUYUZM`[^ .&),&)'', >D3? C8)', @OO 5XW][JL]

% ?[[\ 8a^^QZ` EQSaXM`[^ .&),&)'', >D3? =5 CNP )'( @OO 5XW][JL]

>D3? =5 3]]W
% ?[[\ 8a^^QZ` 6``QZaM`[^ .&*'&)'', @OO 5XW][JL]
)',

% <MZP_Q` ?UZQ 6Y\,, .&),&)'', >DD3? :D 3VY)) @OO 5XW][JL]

6a`[ EUZS 9[cZ-*/ .&*'&)'', G< ),'64= @OO 5XW][JL]

8B ?UZQ :YaXM`[^i?UZQYMZ /&&'(&)'', C9;E =>)( @OO 5XW][JL]

<>73 5FD$
FC:8=6? 8?=A=8=6A <G< 7aZPXQ /&'(&)'', I& G.0.A$0(+-
E@>+F

8HFGB@ GI<G< :Z`Q^\^U_Q >=G :*)+ !A@ED" E@ :*)* !;A" 7?E7CAC;D7 D@=FE;@?

I=FA 633 /'=A'+ 7HA9?: , A3E;7?E EG>d\ 3?6 ( 5=;?;5;3? EG> <;E

>@:6 AQXWN1 -'*&*-+$'(++


A@ 4Xa )-* 8Ja1 /--&-/0$0*.-
9RUVJW]XW ;H# ?: '*/*. VKb[WN\2TVNJP[X^Y%WN]
```%TVNJP[X^Y%WN]
C^[JU ENUNQNJU]Q DXU^]RXW\
© )''. <>73

Вам также может понравиться