The Kurdistan Region is made up of three governorates: Erbil,
Sulaymaniyah and Duhok with a total population of some 5.2 million with population growth estimated at 3% per annum. GDP growth is forecast at 8% for 2013. Erbil (or Hawler in local parlance) is the capital of the Region with an estimated population of 1.3 million.
Since the enactment of the 2006 Investment Law which created the architecture for attracting Foreign Direct Investment, the Kurdistan Region of Iraq (KRI) has established itself as a business friendly environment for foreign companies. As of June 2013 there are now in excess of 2,300 foreign companies registered in the KRI in addition to the 15,000 local companies. Factors encouraging expansion into the KRI include: security, regular power, airport infrastructure, growing social and transport infrastructure, quality of life and investment opportunities.
One of the cornerstones of the economy are the regions huge untapped natural resources: an estimated 45bn barrels of oil reserves, up to 200TCF of natural gas reserves and relatively unexplored mineral deposits. This has attracted estimated investment of nearly US$20bn up to 2013 in the Oil & Gas sector alone.
The KRG is actively encouraging public and private investment in the industrial & logistics, tourism and agriculture sectors. Housing has also been a key investment sector attracting nearly 50% of all investment licenses granted within KRI.
The current and potential economic growth is overshadowed by the KRGs fractious relationship with Baghdad and wider political risk from neighbouring countries however the KRI is capitalising on its lead as the safe and business-friendly region of Iraq that also offers businesses and investors a spring board into the rest of the country.
FIGURE 3 Erbil International Airport Passenger Numbers Key Economic Indicators 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 M i l l i o n
P a s s e n g e r s
FIGURE 1 GDP Growth 2004 to 2012 FIGURE 2 GDP per Capita Growth 2004 to 2012 Source: EIA Source: Kurdistan Regional Statistics Office/IKG Property Research FIGURE 4 KRG Investment figures by sector (excluding Oil & Gas) 2006 to July 2013 (USD m) 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 U S D
m i l l i o n s
Source: Kurdistan Regional Statistics Office/IKG Property Research Market Overview Kurdistan Region of Iraq Erbil Commercial and Residential Property Q3 2013 IKG Property Research 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 Source: Kurdistan Regional Statistics Office/IKG Property Research 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 U S D
U S D
b n
ikgproperty.com 1
Office Market Overview Local businesses tend to cluster within the 60m Road in the historic CBD; International companies are located within gated communities and standalone office buildings/villas on Gulan Street and 100m Road within close proximity to the airport. This area is defined as the emerging CBD. Additionally, international companies are clustered within Ainkawa District, New Azadi, Dream City and American Village. The office sector is undeveloped. Lack of conventional office space has resulted in companies leasing converted residential accommodation, both villas and apartments. With the inherent inefficiencies of converted residential buildings, lack of brand integrity and less commercially minded individual investor Landlords, the international corporates are beginning to move to conventional office space. Completed office buildings are characteristically poor quality: typically low-rise, retail ground and mezzanine floors with office space above. There are some recently developed exceptions in close proximity to Erbil International Airport. Office demand is increasing, in particular from the Oil & Gas sector due to headcount increases as they graduate from exploration to production phase.
Supply Current built supply is limited in volume and quality. We estimate that current supply of Grade B/C office buildings is approximately 70,000 m 2 with the majority clustered around the airport. This figure does not include the ungraded commercial buildings. Current supply of completed Grade B/C buildings are at approximately 95%+ occupancy. The majority of current built supply is poor quality and does not adhere to International Building Code standards. Relative good standard developments include Empire Business Complex, UB Plaza, Ster Tower and Erbil Business Centre. All of current supply is single Landlord owned with the exception of Empire World and Justice Tower where floors/individual units within some of the office buildings are being sold off plan. Future supply is difficult to assess due to the large number of office developments that have either not been officially launched or those developments that have been are still under construction but the developer is undecided as to what use class the building will be. We estimate the cumulative supply of Grade C and better office buildings is approximately 430,000 m 2 by end of 2016. A large volume of the future supply is expected from Empire World, Justice Tower, Emaars new Downtown project on Gulan Street and from the office components within other mixed use developments. We are seeing some of the major local Landlord developers aspiring to develop true international Grade A offices and are employing international consultants to help achieve this. Khoshnaw Tower on 100m Road is one such example. Source: IKG Property Research Market Overview | Erbil Commercial and Residential ikgproperty.com 2 Q3 2013 - 50,000 100,000 150,000 200,000 250,000 300,000 350,000 400,000 450,000 500,000 2013 2014 2015 2016 FIGURE 6 Future Office Supply: 2013 to 2016 100m Road 60m Road Erbil International Airport FIGURE 5 Erbils Emerging New Business District Source: Bing Maps/IKG Property Research m 2
Rent USD/m 2 /pm Trending Prime 45 Secondary 15 Villa 20 Source: IKG Property Research Market Overview | Erbil Commercial and Residential ikgproperty.com 3 Q3 2013 Demand International Oil Companies are scaling up operations giving rise to large headcount increases. IOCs are currently the largest international occupier type, according to our research they lease approximately 30,000 m 2 offices within Erbil. A large proportion of these companies have agglomerated in the first phase of Empire Business Complex, currently running at almost 100% occupancy. An increasing number of international companies are setting up small representative offices in Erbil, most notably in the banking, law, oil & gas related services and construction sectors. The majority set up in villas as a cost effective solution, in some instances using the premises as combined residential and office accommodation. Small number of large occupiers (> 1,000 m 2 ). The market is primarily made up of small to medium occupiers of 100 300 m 2 . Rising public sector demand as government related entities relocate to better quality premises or expand out of existing premises.
Rents Average prime rental rates for the prime office buildings are showing flat growth since Q1 2013. The rental rate quoted in Figure 7 is an average figure for shell & core offices that excludes exceptional deals anecdotal evidence suggests that Empire Business Complex has achieved rental rates of in excess of USD55 per m 2 . Commercial villa rents, particularly in Italian City and English Village, are showing strong growth due to supply/demand imbalance. Evidence suggests year-on-year rental growth of up to 20% from Q3 2012. Relative to the global market, Erbils prime office occupancy costs are similar to Munich, Houston and Abu Dhabi.
Outlook Occupier demand will be driven by expanding business in Erbil, especially within the Oil & Gas and related sectors, consolidation and also new market entrants. Strong GDP growth will contribute to increasing office demand. Continued international interest in foreign entities setting up representative offices in KRI. Short term absorption of new office buildings expected to be high given the immediate undersupply. Increasing supply of good quality offices as the market matures and developers start to understand occupier requirements. Occupiers of residential conversions are beginning to consider relocating to conventional offices, although given current cost differential and immediate undersupply we expect this to be a relatively slow process. We expect the consolidation of existing offices spread over multiple villas and apartments into single office premises. Lease terms are set to increase from annually renewable to longer terms as companies solidify local business. In the longer term we see a potential for built-to-suit solutions for larger occupiers. We see rental rates remaining stable as more supply enters the market given a combination of economic growth with slow/delayed delivery of new office buildings. FIGURE 7 Office Rental Rates FIGURE 8 Prime Office Occupancy Costs: Erbil vs selected cities 0 50 100 150 Kuala Lumpur Prague Adelaide Auckland Abu Dhabi Ho Chi Minh City Erbil Munich Houston Vancouver Buenos Aires Aberdeen Istanbul Dubai Seoul London City Moscow USD/m 2 /pm* Source: IKG Property Research * Occupancy costs include service charge (if applicable) Prime rents will remain stable for the short term. In the mid-term, given volume and some superior quality supply we expect rental rates will adjust to more sustainable levels for Grade B/C offices. Source: IKG Property Research Market Overview | Erbil Commercial and Residential ikgproperty.com 4 Q3 2013 Residential Market Overview The residential sector continues to be an attractive investment sector with many new developments under construction. Many of the new residential developments under construction appear stalled with construction being initially commenced possibly for land banking purposes to avoid investment licenses being revoked. Although the city does not enjoy a true CBD, the overseas community favors the West of the City given its attractive location close to Erbil International Airport and within easy reach of many 5 star facilities and services. It is rumored that the KRG is refusing to grant new building permits for residential developments in effort to prevent possible over-supply of low quality product whilst legislation is promulgated to encourage higher construction standards. The serviced apartment market has yet to establish itself, although some supply is currently under construction. Rental yields upwards of seven percent are being typically achieved on prime rental stock suitable for the international community.
Supply Apartment Market Only approximately 2,000 units have been successfully delivered to date. If all planned developments are completed, total supply could exceed 15,000 units, a 700% increase on existing stock levels. Typically, units are configured to 2/3 bedroom arrangements with only a small number of developers offering studio and one bedroom style accommodation. The majority of new stock supplied over the next few years will be offered at around USD1,200 / m 2 . In the next few years several new luxury projects are anticipated to be completed establishing new price / quality thresholds. Much of the existing and future supply is typically of local build quality with only a handful of developments being to international standard.
Villa Market Typically villas suitable for the international community are found within gated compounds offering back up power and 24/7 security located in the West of the city. New townships are springing up around the city, typically along major arterial routes and sandwiched between the built 100m Road and the yet to be completed 120m Road. New villa developments are typically part of wider mixed-use developments and can be split broadly into international standard and local standard quality. Total supply by end of 2016 is likely to be nearly 35,000 units. Local grade accommodation is available for purchase within many new townships from around USD150k per unit.
FIGURE 9 Villa Rental Rates FIGURE 8 Residential Sales Rates Source: IKG Property Research Rent USD/m 2 /pm Trending Empire World 22 Italian City 18 English Village 15
Price USD/m 2 Trending Luxury Apartment 1,650 Luxury Villa 1,950 Local Villa 1,200
Source: IKG Property Research 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 16,000 2013 2014 2015 2016 FIGURE 9 Cumulative Apartment Supply U n i t s
Market Overview | Erbil Commercial and Residential ikgproperty.com 5 Q3 2013 FIGURE 10 Incremental Apartment Supply by Grade Source: IKG Property Research Source: IKG Property Research Demand Villa Market Villas within gated compounds are typically being rented between USD 3,500 and USD 6,500 per month depending on quality and handover condition. Despite being an opaque market, villas within gated compound facilities are transacting on the secondary market in the region of USD 700,000 per unit - equivalent to approximately USD 2,000 / m 2 . With little new short term supply and the increasing popularity for corporates to be located in the West of the City close to Erbil International Airport, rental rates and valuations are expected to remain at worst case firm. Increased appetite from the corporate sector for villas as office accommodation, especially for new start ups are likely to underpin prices accordingly. Villas which do not enjoy gated compound facilities and services enjoy healthy discounts and are available for rent at approximately USD2,500 per month and are currently transacting at approximately USD250,000 per unit.
Apartment Market On the back of several top end developments being completed over the next few years, demand for mid-tier stock might suffer as new price/quality thresholds are established. Rental rates for good quality apartments range between USD2,000 and USD4,000 per month depending on location and configuration, with the more expensive units being available within gated communities offering security and management services. Transactions are on a cash basis with bank lending / mortgage derived financing being minimal. Initial yields of around ten percent are being achieved on medium grade stock, encouraging purchase for investment purposes over immediate owner / occupation. Given the political and security landscape of Iraq, Erbil is a favored location for Iraqi nationals living in areas suffering from greater security risks.
Outlook Rental rates and valuations for top end compound villa stock likely to remain firm. Apartment market could suffer from over supply if planned developments go ahead available stock could increase to over 15,000 units compared with just over 2,000 units as of 2013. In tandem with a large supply of new stock, the delivery of several top end developments would establish more transparent price / quality thresholds possibly weakening demand for mid-tier accommodation. Local villa market unlikely to change due to limited supply with continued demand from corporates to be located in the West of the City. Erbil will continue to be an attractive proposition for non-Kurdish nationals seeking a safe haven to invest in property.
0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 A B C In excess of USD1,200/m 2
Launch price between USD850 1,200/m 2 Launch price between USD600 860/m 2 FIGURE 11 Cumulative masterplanned (Int. & Local) Villa Supply If all planned apartment developments are delivered on time, Erbil apartment supply will increase by 700% within the next few years. U n i t s
U n i t s
IKG Property provides high quality residential and commercial property services across Iraq, applying insight, experience, and local market intelligence and resources to help our clients make informed real estate decisions.
Our clients range from global corporations to individuals and our commitment is to serve them, whether occupiers, owners or investors, to the highest possible standards across all service lines and asset classes through a dedicated team of professionals. We take an international best practice approach to our services, adding value and delivering the best possible solutions for our clients.
IKG Property currently has a team of 9 employees and is headquartered in Erbil with plans to expand its operations across Iraq in the near term.
Market Overview | Erbil Commercial and Residential ikgproperty.com 6 Q3 2013 Industrial Market Snapshot Light industrial, logistics and storage uses are mainly clustered to the West on Mosul Road, to the South on 100m/Kirkuk Road and to the North on Gazna Road and in proximity to Bahirka. To the East Predominantly warehouse quality is very poor, typically steel portal frame construction with block work to full eaves height. Connectivity to utilities in some outlying areas is poor. There is currently no professionally masterplanned industrial and logistics hub although we understand there are some under consideration. Stores Land on Mosul Road is the only major industrial focussed development that approaches being properly master planned although development progress has ceased. Limited centralised cold storage facilities but some under construction at Erbil Food Distribution Centre, a high quality facility off the Mosul Road. Increasing demand from major FMCG companies for storage and distribution facilities. Increasing demand for storage from major retail franchisees as international retail operators in KRI increase. Increasing demand from the oil & gas sector for lay-down yards and workshops. Ad-hoc speculative supply from local Landlords, characteristically clusters of c. 600 m 2 low grade warehouse units. Larger occupiers are starting to purchase/lease plots to develop their own long term facilities. We see this trend increasing due to the limited and low quality existing options. IKG Property Research will publish a full industrial report as part of the Q4 2013 Market Report
Retail Market Snapshot Typically street retail clusters within the 60m Road. Retail has generally agglomerated on a street by street basis, for example Computer Street, Stationary Street. Limited supply of destination shopping malls. Majidi Mall, Family Mall and Royal Mall are the only malls in Erbil that offer an international type of shopping experience. Limited international brand penetration within market but growing. Increase in big box retail formats such as the new Ace Hardware store on 100m Road. A French hypermarket is due to open shortly on 100m Road. There is already an existing Carrefour hypermarket in Family Mall. Upcoming supply of low grade community malls, if they are completed. Built supply is invariably poor quality with some malls such as Gallery and Sofy Malls being converted to office premises. Small scale Mall developers have historically sold individual units off-plan to fund construction which has resulted in poor retail mixes. The Kurdish majority tend to shop within the historic shopping areas of Erbil. Footfall within the Malls is predominantly expatriate. IKG Property Research will publish a full retail report as part of the Q4 2013 Market Report
IKG Property Research Team Edward Carnegy Managing Director +964 (0) 750 198 6645 edward.carnegy@ikgproperty.com Neil Thurston MRICS Director +964 (0) 750 207 0399 neil.thurston@ikgproperty.com Omar Moradi Research Analyst +964 (0) 750 202 7294 omar.moradi@ikgproperty.com This report is for general informative purposes only. It may not be published, reproduced or quoted in part or in whole, nor may it be used as a basis for any contract, prospectus, agreement or other document without prior consent. Whilst every effort has been made to ensure its accuracy, IKG Property accepts no liability whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from its use. The content is strictly copyright and reproduction of the whole or part of it in any form is prohibited without written permission from IKG Property Research.
Manual of Administrative Policies and Procedures SECTION: Facilities Number: 09.03.01 Area: Facilities Use and Oversight SUBJECT: Event Reservation and Rental of University Facilities